Breadwinner Readers Guide
Breadwinner Readers Guide
The Breadwinner
By: Deborah Ellis
A Readers Guide
Created by Ms. Cheryl Passavanti and Dr. Marshall George Albert Leonard Middle School
New Rochelle
READS 2005
Literature Festival
1
c 2005 Jeffrey L. Ward. Used with the permission of FARRAR STRAUS GIROUX
Readers Guide Copyright 2005 Ms. Cheryl Passavanti and Dr. Marshall George Albert Leonard Middle School
The Breadwinner
By: Deborah Ellis
A Readers Guide
What an exciting life we live. The magic of television, computers, and films can bring pictures, ideas, and information to us almost instantaneously. Sophisticated transportation like cars, ocean liners, speed boats, and jets can take us to parts of the world that once took months or even years to traverse. Yet, we do not need fancy and expensive machines to enter a new world and learn about life in a foreign place or at a different time. Reading a book is the safest, least expensive travel ticket we can have. When we open a book and start to read the words, we open a window to a new world, the authors world, and get a chance to travel to dangerous times and places without fear of harm. At the same time, reading a book can be like looking into a mirror. Though the setting of the story and experiences of the character may at first seem very different from those of our own, as the story unfolds we can discover things about ourselves and may gain insight into the way that we think, behave, and respond to other people.
Pre-reading Activities: *Before you walk through the window of The Breadwinner by Deborah Ellis, get your mind working. First, do you know what a breadwinner is? Usually a family has at least one breadwinner. Take a guess first and then check your answer by looking it up in the dictionary. Next, read the back cover and learn little about the story. Look at the book cover and guess what you think the story may be about and who the characters may be. It is not important to be right, but guessing focuses your reading and you will better comprehend the story. Get your bearings. Learn about the setting, the time and place of the story. Turn to the two maps in the front of the book or the one in this study guide and answer these questions: o On what continent is Afghanistan? o What countries surround it? o What are the 4 largest cities? Turn to page 167 and read the Authors Note, which ends on page 168. What is the geography of the area? What people have fought against the Afghans for the past 20 or so years? What changes happened in Kabul when the Taliban militia took over in 1996? In the fall of 2001, the Taliban were driven from most of Afghanistan. Have womens rights changed from 2001?
As an enrichment activity, find current information on the internet. Here are some websites you may want to look at with your parents. http://www.rawa.org/women.html http://www.womenforafghanwomen.org/ http://www.afghanwomensmission.org http://www.public.asu.edu/~apnilsen/afghanistan4kids/index2.html
To whom is the book dedicated? What might this dedication have to do with the main idea of the story? Turn to pages 169-170, a glossary of important Afghani words/terms. Make sure you understand the difference between a burqa and a chador. Which is more restrictive?
During Reading Activities Now turn to chapter one, page 7 and start reading. Use a note card or post-it as a book marker and write down questions and vocabulary which seem confusing. Always ask questions as you read. This will help to focus your reading. The questions listed below for each chapter are meant to guide you through your reading. Some are intended to check your understanding of the story. Others are meant to give you and your reading partner something to think about and to discuss together.
Chapter One Vocabulary: These words are important in chapter one. Be sure that you can define them before you read the chapter. The number following the word is the page on which the word is found. Kabul, p.7 chador, p. 7 decreed, p.16. burqas, p. 17.
In most books, the first chapter introduces important facts and information needed for the story to turn out the way it does. The background facts and information is called the EXPOSITION. 1. Identify and briefly describe Parvana, her father, Nooria, Maryam, Ali and the Taliban. 2. Why does Parvana accompany her father to his job? What is his job? Why is she allowed to go with him? 3. What are Dari and Pashtu? What are some supporting facts that show that Parvanas parents were well-educated? 4. What changes did Parvana, Nooria, Maryam, and Parvanas mother, and Parvanas father undergo after the Taliban came to power? 5. Why does Parvanas father sell his artificial leg? Do you agree or disagree with his explanation? Explain your viewpoint.
6. Afghans cover the earth like stars cover the sky. What does this quote on page 9 imply about conditions in Afghanistan? Why are people scattered? 7. War can affect a persons style of living. How did warfare change Parvana's family? 8. The dangerous trip up Parvanas stairwell into her apartment reflects the dangerous existence that her family encounters each day. Try to explain this imagery.
Chapter Two Vocabulary: toshak, 19 chador, 19. looters, 22 intricate patterns, 22 shalwar kameez, 24.
1. Why cant Nooria and Parvana's mother go out into the street? 2. Nooria and Parvana always bicker. Why dont they get along? How do they talk to each other? 3. What job does Parvana do reluctantly because it has to be done? 4. Who was Hossain and what happened to him? 5. What is meant by eating Afghan style? 6. How does a hospitable Afghani behave? 7. Why is the story of Malali important for the women of Afghanistan? What lesson does her story teach? 8. Why is Parvana's father arrested? How does the family react to his arrest?
Chapter Three 1. Do you think Parvanas father will return? Why or why not? 2. Why is the only window painted black? What do you think about this? Explain your reaction to this decree. 3. What dangerous mission does Parvanas mother undertake? What laws does she break? What is her motivation? Why does Parvana go with her? 4. What does Parvana carry in her sleeve and why? 5. How does Parvanas mother act like Malali? What happens to her? 6. The mothers attacker...shook her off as if she were a fly. By comparing her to a fly, what does this quote reflect about the Talibans regard for women? Chapter Four 1. Who is Fatana and what is her special talent?
2. Why are Parvana and Fatana tired? Why does Parvana complain about her feet? 3. If you were an Afghani, would you stay in your country to try to change the laws you disagreed with or would you leave? Why or why not? Chapter Five 1. Many chapters deal with oppression, not allowing freedom. What groups of people were being oppressed by the Taliban? What were some of the oppressive laws? 2. When the Taliban chases Parvana, who does Parvana run into? Why was this meeting good for Parvana and her family? 3. What does Mrs. Weer have in common with Fatana? How does she help Parvanas family?
1. What must Parvana do to help her family survive? Why is this extreme measure necessary? Why doesn't she wear Hossains clothing, and what is Fatanas reaction to this? 2. Why isnt Nooria chosen to be the breadwinner? 3. Why was it unusual for Parvana to have a shalwar kameez with a pocket? 4. In what way is the relationship between Parvana and Nooria changing? Why?
Chapter Seven 1. Who is Kaseem? How does he earn money? 2. Parvana encounters a Taliban who wants her to read a letter in Pashtu. What does the Talibans reaction to the letter reveal about human nature? Why is this an important scene for the author to include? (p. 80) 3. Why was going to the bathroom a problem for Parvana/Kaseem? 4. At the end of the chapter, Parvana thinks she sees a flicker of movement from the blacked out window. What might this foreshadow? Can you make a prediction?
1. What project are Mrs. Weera and Parvanas mother working on? Why is it dangerous? 2. What does Parvana do for Maryam that could not be done before Parvana became Kaseem? 3. Why does Maryam need her feet wrapped? 4. How does Parvana earn money as the breadwinner? 5. Parvana mistakes a man for her father. What does this tell about her feelings for her father? 6. What gifts are on the blanket and from where do they seem to come from?
1. Who is Shafiq and what does he have in common with Parvana? 2. Explain Shauzias predicament. How is it worse than Parvanas. 3. What is Nooria , Fatana, and Mrs. Weera's new project? 4. What is the newest gift from the Window Woman?
Chapter Ten Vocabulary intact building, 105. rubble, 105. rotting stench, 105. bone broker, 105.
1. What are Parvana and Shauzia going to do to make more money? Could you do a job like this? Why or why not? 2. Kabul has more land mines than flowers...Landmines are as common as rocks an can blow you up without warning. What are land mines and what type of damage can they do? 3. What dangerous solution to the bathroom problem do the girls devise? 4. Why dont the girls want to tell their families about their well paying job?
Chapter 11 1. How does Parvana explain her lateness to her terrified mother? Why was her mother upset? Why does Parvana cry? 2. On page 116, a different Parvana emerges. In what way does she show her maturity and sense of responsibility? In what way does the wise Mrs. Weera support here? 3. Explain Parvanas new plan for making money. Do you think it will work? Why or why not? 4. How are thieves punished under the Taliban regime? Chapter 12 1. What does Parvana fear will happen to her father? 2. Why does Parvana miss work for a few days? 3. What does Shauzia plan to do in the future? Why? Do you think this is a good plan? 4. On page 128, Parvana reveals her two greatest wishes. What are they? What do these two wishes reflect about her being the breadwinner? 5. In spite of the horrors of everyday life, flowers still managed to bloom. What might these flowers symbolize for the future? 6. What were other signs of life blooming during summer? 7. What does Parvana fear is happening to the Window Woman? 8. What goes on in a mans house is his own business. This was said to Parvana as she heard thuds coming from the window womans house. Do you agree or disagree with this quote? 9. What do you think is going to happen to 15 year old Nooria? Chapter 13 1. What seems to be the advantages of Nooria moving to Mazar-e-Sharif? Why is Nooria looking forward to going there? 2. Why is Parvana left in Kabul? 3. What is upsetting Parvana and Shauzia? 4. In what way does Mrs. Weera treat Parvana more like an adult than hr mother does? Has Parvana earned Mrs. Weeras respect?
Chapter 14
Vocabulary
rummaged, 144.
1. What does Parvana risk to save the crying woman? 2. What actions of Parvanas demonstrate her cleverness and bravery? 3. Why is Homa story so frightening to Parvana and Mrs. Weera? What does Parvana fear?
1. When he returns home, how has her father changed? 2. How does Parvana's father react to Kaseem? 3. What future event motivates Shauzia to leave Afghanistan as soon as possible? 4. Where are Parvana and her father going? 5. What great feat did Fatana and Mrs. Weera accomplish? 6. How is the country of Afghanistan like the flowers Parvana planted for the window woman? 7. ...the roots are good. When the time is right, these roots will support plants that are healthy and strong. What does this statement mean? 8. What does the final image of Mount Parvana with the snow on its peak sparkling in the sun seem to indicate to Parvana? Explain your answer.
After Reading Discussions and Activities 1. Though many look upon the burqa as a form of oppression, encasing women in a dark, moveable prison through which only part of the world can be seen, others feel differently. To them the burqa is a protection and helps keep women safe from dangerous outsiders. They see the Taliban laws as protective of women. Go on the internet and find an article support each position. Read the article and summarize it. What position do you take? Burqa: prison or protection? Discuss your thoughts with your reading partner. 2. The Breadwinner is the first in a trilogy of novels written by Deborah Ellis. The next book, Parvanas Journey, picks up where this one leaves off. What do you think is going to happen to Parvana? Will she reunite with her family? What challenges will she face on her journey? After you make predictions, consider reading Parvans Journey. 3. Some readers have suggested that The Breadwinner would make a good movie. Do you agree? Who would you cast to play the various roles on the movie version of the novel? Would you make changes to the story in the movie version? 4. Afghanistan is in the US news almost daily. How does The Breadwinner relate to current events in America? Scan the New York Times or some other newspaper for articles about Afghanistan. Does reading The Breadwinner help you to better understand the news articles you find? Have things changes in Afghanistan since the events described in this book? 5. Parvana faces huge challenges. Even though she is a child, she takes a huge amount of responsibility for her family. What responsibilities do you take in your family? Do you think you could do the kinds of things that Parvana does? Do you admire Parvana? 6. How did you respond to other characters in the book? Do any of them remind you of members of your own family or of your friends? 7. Afghanistan has a fascinating history. Do more reading about Afghanistan, its history, its people, and its culture. How does its history compare to that of the United States? What similarities and differences can you identify between the history, people, and cultures of Afghanistan and the United States? You might want to create a Venn Diagram to demonstrate the relationship between the two countries.
Thanks go to Ms. Cheryl Passavanti and Dr. Marshall George from Albert Leonard Middle School for creating this study guide.
10
Appendix
11
3. 4.
5.
The Five Pillars of Faith are observances in Islam which are duties each Muslim must perform. These are five duties that every Muslim is obliged to perform. 1. Creed (Shahada)- One must state, "There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is the Prophet of Allah." publicly to become a Muslim. Muslims say this when they wake up in the morning, and just before they go to sleep at night. 2. Prayer (Salat)- Prayer must be done by all Muslims over the age of 10 five times a day (upon rising, at noon, in mid-afternoon, after sunset, and before going to sleep) towards the direction of Mecca. The call to prayer is sounded by the muezzin (Muslim crier) from a tower (minaret) within the mosque. Salat is very different from praying on the inspiration of the moment. While an individual can pray on his own, Muslims prefer to perform Salat with others, as this demonstrates the unity of all Muslims. Having specific times each day to be close to Allah helps Muslims remain aware of the importance of their faith, and the role it plays in every part of life. 3. Almsgiving (Zakat)- Muslims are legally required to give one-fortieth (2.5%) of their income to the needy. Since those who receive alms are helping the giver achieve salvation, there is no sense of shame in receiving charity. Giving in this way is intended to free Muslims from the love of money. It reminds them that everything they have really belongs to God. 4. Fasting (Sawm)- During the holy month of Ramadan (the 9th Muslim month), faithful Muslims fast from sunup to sundown each day. Sawm is usually described as fasting, but it actually involves abstaining from all bodily pleasures between dawn and sunset. Not only is food
12
forbidden, but also things like smoking, chewing gum, and any sexual activity. Sawm helps Muslims develop self-control, gain a better understanding of God's gifts and greater compassion towards the deprived. Eid Al Fitr: This religious festival of marks the breaking of the fast and the end of Ramadan. Congregational prayers are held, gifts exchanged, delicious food prepared and new clothes are worn. 5. Pilgrimage (Hajj)- Muslims are expected to make the pilgrimage to Mecca at least once in their lifetime if they have the means to do it and are physically capable of the trip. It is an essential part of gaining salvation, so the old or infirm may send someone in their place. It involves a set of rituals and ceremonies. Additional Facts 1. Another religious duty associated with the five pillars is Jihad, or Holy War. This duty requires that if the situation warrants, men are required to go to war to defend or spread Islam. If they are killed, they are guaranteed eternal life in Paradise. 2. Worldwide, there are 1.2 billion Muslims. There are 7 million Muslims in the United States. Islam is the dominant religion throughout large portions of Asia and Africa, with the largest Muslim populations living in Indonesia (170 million), Pakistan (136 million), Bangladesh (106 million), and India (103 million). Most Arabs are Muslims, but most Muslims are not Arabs. 3. There are two main sects of Islam: Sunni and Shiite. One of their main differences is in their beliefs about who were the leaders following the death of Muhammad. Sunni, from the Arabic word for "tradition," accepted the succession of Muhammad's elected successors. The majority of Muslims in the world today are Sunnis. Shiite, from the Arabic word for "faction," believe that leaders must be descendants of Muhammad through his daughter Fatima and her husband Ali. Sunnis and Shiites share most basic religious tenets. However, their differences sometimes have served as the basis for religious intolerance, political infighting, and violent confrontations. Sunni comprise about 85 percent of all Muslims. Nations with Sunni majority include Egypt, Saudi Arabia and most other Arab nations, as well as non-Arab Turkey and Afghanistan. Most Palestinian Muslims are Sunni. Shiite are the second-largest sect (approximately 10-15% of all Muslims). Shiite populations live in a number of countries, but they constitute a majority in Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, Bahrain, and Azerbaijan.
References McDowell, Josh and Don Stewart, Handbook of Today's Religions. Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 1983. Twelfth printing, June 1992. Shelley, Fred M. and Audrey E. Clarke, eds. Human and Cultural Geography. Dubuque, Iowa: Wm. C. Brown Publishers, 1994. http://www.mnsu.edu/emuseum/cultural/religion/islam/beliefs.html http://hnn.us/articles/934.html
13
14
15
Taraki signs friendship treaty with the Soviet Union. In June, the U.S.-supported guerrilla movement Mujahadeen (Persian for "warriors") is created. 1979: February 14: American ambassador Adolph Dubs is killed. The U.S. cuts off assistance to Afghanistan. Power struggle between Taraki and deputy prime minister Hafizullah Amin ensues. Taraki is killed on September 14 in a confrontation with Amin supporters. USSR invades Afghanistan on December 24 to bolster the faltering communist regime. On December 27, Amin and many of his followers are killed. Deputy Prime Minister Babrak Karmal becomes Prime Minister. Widespread opposition to Karmal and the Soviets spawns violent public demonstrations. By early 1980, the Mujahadeen rebels have united against Soviet invaders and the USSR-backed Afghan Army. 1982: Some 2.8 million Afghans have fled from the war to Pakistan; another 1.5 million have fled to Iran. Afghan guerrillas gain control of rural areas, and Soviet troops hold urban areas. 1984: United Nations investigates reported human rights violations in Afghanistan. 1986: The Mujahadeen are receiving arms from the United States, Britain, and China, via Pakistan. 1987: Mujahideen make great gains, defeat of Soviets eminent. 1988 - 1989: The U.S., Pakistan, Afghanistan, and the Soviet Union sign peace accords in Geneva guaranteeing Afghan independence and the withdrawal of 100,000 Soviet troops. Following Soviet withdrawal (February 15, 1989), the American and Pakistani trained Mujahadeen continue their resistance against the Soviet-backed regime of communist president Najibullah. Afghan guerrillas name Sibhatullah Mojadidi as head of their exiled government. 1992: The Mujahadeen and other rebel groups, with the aid of turncoat government troops, storm the capital, Kabul, and oust Najibullah from power. The U.N. offers protection to Najibullah. The Mujahadeen form an Islamic state: the Islamic Jihad Council. Professor Burhannudin Rabbani is elected president. 1994: Fighting subsequently continued among the various mujahidin factions. This eventually gave rise to a state of warlordism. The chaos and corruption involved in warlordism. The most serious of this fighting occurred in 1994, when 10,000 people were killed from factions fighting in the Kabul area. 1995: Newly-formed Islamic militia, the Taliban, rises to power on promises of peace. Most Afghans, exhausted by years of drought, famine and war, approve of the Taliban for upholding traditional Islamic values. Backed by Pakistan and her strategic allies, the Taliban develops as a political/religious force and eventually is able to capture 90% of the country, aside from Afghan Northern Alliance strongholds primarily in the northeast. The Taliban imposes a strict interpretation of Islamic Sharia law.The Taliban outlaws cultivation of poppies for the opium trade, cracks down on crime, and severely curtails the education and employment of women. Women must be fully veiled, no longer allowed to work, go out alone or even wear white socks. Men are forced to grow beards. Buzkashi, the Afghan national sport is outlawed. Islamic law is enforced via public executions and amputations. The U.S. refuses to recognize the authority of the Taliban. 1995-1999:Continuing drought devastates farmers and makes many rural areas uninhabitable. More than one million Afghans flee to neighboring Pakistan, where they languish in squalid refugee camps. Massive human rights violations by the Taliban. 1997:Taliban publicly executes Najibullah. 1998: February--Earthquake strikes in northeastern Afghanistan, killing over 4,000 people, destroying villages and leaving thousands of people homeless. August--Taliban finally capture Mazar-i-Sharif, and massacre thousands of innocent civilians afterwards, mostly Hazaras. September--Tensions rise between Iran and the Taliban. Iranians are angry about the killing of their diplomats and a journalist by the Taliban
16
when they captured Mazar-i-Sharif. Soon they deploy 70,000 troops to carry out military exercises near the Afghan border. In the end, no fighting occurs between the Taliban and the Iranian army. 1999: February--Earthquake hits eastern Afghanistan, affecting over 30,000 people, and killing at least 60 to 70 people. September--The ex-king of Afghanistan, Mohammad Zahir Shah, calls for a grand assembly, or Loya Jirga to discuss ways of bringing peace to the country. The United Front soon welcomes the idea, but the Taliban ridicule Mohammad Zahir Shah's attempts at establishing peace. October-- UN Security Council Resolution 1267 is adopted; sanctions against the Taliban on grounds that they offered sanctuary to Osama bin Ladin. 2000: International terrorist Osama Bin Laden is widely believed to be hiding in Afghanistan, where he is cultivating thousands of followers in terrorist training camps. The U.S. demands that Bin Laden be extradited to stand trial for the bombing of two U.S. embassies in Africa. The Taliban declines to extradite him. December-- the United Nations punishes Afghanistan with sanctions restricting trade and economic development (Security Council Resolution 1333) 2001: The Taliban controls 95 percent of Afghanistan. March--Despite pleas and requests from various international diplomats, Islamic scholars, the Taliban destroy ancient historical statues in the Kabul Museum, historical sites in Ghazni, and blow up the giant Bamiyan Buddhas from the 5th century. The world expresses outrage and disgust against the Taliban action. April--UN accuses Pakistan of not allowing adequate supply of food and medicines to displaced Afghans, at the Jalozai camp, near Peshawar. May-Taliban order religious minorities to wear tags identifying themselves as non-Muslims. September 11 -suicide attacks on the U.S. kill more than 3,000 people and destroy the two towers of the World Trade Center and part of the Pentagon. October-- Abdul Haq is killed by the Taliban. The United States and UK working with the forces of the United Front (UNIFSA) launch air strikes against the Taliban. ( The Americans hold Osama bin Laden directly responsible for the attacks on the World Trade Center, and the Taliban were targeted for protecting him.) November: Taliban lose control of Mazar-i Sharif. December 5- Bonn Agreement. Major leaders from the Afghan opposition groups and diaspora meet in Bonn, Germany and agree on a plan for the formulation of an interim government that results in the inauguration of Hamid Karzai as Chairman of the Afghan Interim Authority (AIA) 2002: ) In addition to occasionally violent political jockeying and ongoing military action to root out remaining al-Qaida and Taliban elements, the country suffers from enormous poverty, rampant warlordism, a crumbling infrastructure, and widespread land mines. April-- Former King Mohammad Zahir returns to Afghanistan (April) -- does not claim throne. War continues against Al Qaeda and the Taliban. June-- Loya Jirga elects Hamid Karzai as President of a Transitional Government. Karzai picks members of his administration to serve until elections are held in 2004. 2003: War against Al Qaeda and the Taliban continue -- further weakened. August - NATO takes control of security in Kabul. 2004: January-- Afghanistan adopts a new constitution. The country is now a republic with three branches of government (Executive, Legislative, and Judiciary). October/November - Presidential elections are finally held after being delayed twice. Hamid Karzai is declared the winner, with 55.4% of the votes.. The elections were not without controversy; allegations of fraud and ballot stuffing were brought up by many of the presidential candidates. After decades of war, Afghanistan is rebuilding its economy and government. On December 7, 2004 Hamid Karzai became the first democratically elected president in Afghanistans history. Source: http://www.afghan-web.com/history/
17
18
United Nations Security Council passed two resolutions, UNSCR 1267 (1999) and 1333 (2000), demanding that the Taliban cease their support for terrorism and hand over bin Laden for trial.
Afghan men wear a variety of turbans, and even within the Taliban, the strict Islamic government that controls much of the country, there are differences in the way men cover their heads. This Taliban member, for example, is wearing a very long turban ( perhaps two twined together ) with one end hanging loose over his shoulder. The Taliban ambassador to Afghanistan, on the other hand, favors a solid black turban tied above his forehead. And some men in Afghanistan do not wear turbans at all, but rather a distinctive Afghan hat. Source: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/news/nation-world/infocus/mideast/islam/turbans.htmlT
19