Science of Weight Control
Science of Weight Control
Energy Balance
The science of weight control is rooted in energy balance according to the laws of thermodynamics.1 Body weight remains stable when there is a state of balance the energy entering the body equals the energy being expended. Likewise, excess or insufficient energy causes an imbalance and the body restores equilibrium by either gaining or losing weight. Because the law of conservation of energy dictates that energy cannot be created or destroyed, energy entering the human body has essentially two fates 1) conversion to either mechanical energy to fuel movement or metabolism or 2) conversion to adipose tissue, lean body mass or glycogen stores. For the purpose of weight control, energy is commonly expressed in calories and throughout this text, energy and calories are used interchangeably. Simply put, calorie balance indicates the same calories are being burned as expended; a calorie surplus indicates more calories are being consumed than expended, thus resulting in weight gain and a calorie deficit indicates more calories are being burned than consumed, resulting in weight loss. As previously discussed, there are several contributing factors to overweight and obesity; however the underlying cause is a chronic energy imbalance - consuming more calories relative to the calories being expended.2 Therefore, successful weight control requires managing calorie intake and expenditure, and some experts estimate that weight gain can be prevented in over 90 percent of the population by modifying daily energy balance either expending an additional 100 calories or reducing intake by 100 calories 3 or doing a combination of the two on a daily basis. To put this into context, reducing 100 calories can be accomplished by skipping mayonnaise or cheese on a sandwich or replacing a cup of juice or regular soda with water or calorie-free versions. Taking a 20minute walk would also modify energy balance by 100 calories. Likewise, to avoid the average yearly adult weight gain of one to three pounds that often leads to overweight or obesity, a mere adjustment of 10 to 30 calories per day is all that is required. This equates to taking 200 to 300 additional steps per day, standing for 15 minutes instead of sitting or giving up one bite of dinner. These seemingly insignificant yet simple changes in daily behaviors will not make a difference that day or the next, which is likely the reason they are avoided, but over time they mean the difference between staying slim or becoming an obesity statistic. This concept of self-regulation of behaviors to control body weight is cornerstone to providing viable solutions and will be discussed in further detail in the following section.
In addition, practical and effective nutrition weight control strategies include food logging, portion control, modifying restaurant dining and using meal replacements. Food Logging Those who consistently track what they eat lose more weight and are more successful at keeping the weight off. 10,11 The act of writing down the items and quantities that are habitually consumed increases the awareness of ones eating habits, which is important for modifying and self-regulating behaviors that lead to excess calorie intake. Portion Control As previously noted, larger portions and serving sizes often lead to higher calorie intakes and greater underestimating which can then contribute to unwanted weight gain. People generally attempt to consume entire meals,12,13 therefore portion size significantly impacts a persons total calorie intake.12,14 Overwhelming evidence validates that the smaller the portions, the fewer daily calories consumed.15 The following strategies can help control portions and reduce over-eating: Avoid eating from a package or container. Instead, take out a certain amount and put the container away Use smaller plates and bowls Avoid all-you-can eat meals and buffets Keep tempting items away Split a meal with a friend or take half of the entre home Start your meal with a low-calorie dinner salad and/or broth-based soup Pay attention to choices at social occasions the tendency is to eat and drink more
Restaurant Dining Americans are eating away from home on more frequent basis, yet restaurant meals are often oversized and contain hidden fat and calories. Minimizing excess calories from restaurant meals can be accomplished by using the tips listed here:
Always ask how the food is prepared. To cut calories, request that items be grilled, baked or broiled. Ask for sauces, cheese and salad dressing on the side to help control the amount consumed.
Replace French fries, onion rings, casserole side dishes and creamy or cheese soups with steamed rice, a small baked potato (with little to no sour cream or butter), a broth-based soup, corn, beans, fresh fruit or a side salad with light dressing.
Order bread, toast, sandwiches or rolls dry and if needed add condiments (butter, mayonnaise, etc.) to control the quantity. Order extra vegetables with your entre. Choose skinless chicken, turkey or fish instead of fatty cuts of beef, hamburgers, pork or lamb. Minimize or avoid alcohol. Lower calorie choices include light beer and wine spritzers rather than frozen fruit drinks, liquors and creamy after-dinner drinks. Select restaurants that provide nutritional information to help guide decisions. Several restaurants provide nutritional information online.
Meal Replacements Studies have shown that meal replacements are an extremely effective weight loss aid,16 and additional research has demonstrated that meal replacements are more effective than conventional dieting. 17,18,19,20 Meal replacements have also been shown to be as effective as dietary restriction combined with drug therapy.8 Most notably, continuous use of meal replacements may be the most effective means for maintaining weight loss of all treatments 21,22,23,24 (see Figure 1). Meal replacements generally substitute one or two meals a day and allow freedom of choice for the remaining allotted calories. This practice supports weight loss and maintenance by providing portion control and accurate calorie counts and thus reduces under-estimating of daily calorie intake.
20
Weight loss in pounds
15 10 5 0
Study1 Study2 Study3 Study4
RCD PMR
Figure 1: In a one-year follow-up in the groups that were tracked, the subjects still using partial meal replacements (PMR) maintained significantly more weight loss than the reduced calorie diet only (RCD) group. Adapted from Heymsfield SB (2003).
Typical Food Choices 16 oz. Caf mocha 4 oz. Blueberry scone In-n-Out DoubleDouble burger French fries 16 oz Soda Jumbo slice of Pepperoni pizza 16 oz. Blended Coffee Bagel with cream cheese and bacon Chick fil-A Chicken Sandwich Small waffle fries 16 oz soda Turkey Reuben French fries 1000 island dressing (1.5 oz) 20 oz Soda
Calories 708
1,268
890 1070
Healthier Alternative 1 cup Special K cereal 10 raspberries 1 banana 6 oz skim milk Subway 6 inch turkey sandwich Apple Water 5 oz of grilled chicken 1 cup of brown rice Steamed veggies 16 oz brewed coffee 2 scrambled eggs cup oatmeal Chick fil-A Char-grilled chicken sandwich Fruit cup 16 oz unsweetened iced tea Greek Gyro sandwich Water or calorie free drink
933 saved
887
569 saved
1237
760 saved
Although all of the aforementioned dietary strategies have proven to be effective, the means used to maintain a healthy body weight will vary according to individual preference and readiness. Lifelong weight control does not require the complete avoidance of any particular food or food group nor does it require severe and prolonged calorie restriction. In terms of weight control, it is vital to recognize that the amount one consumes is more important than the foods chosen as even an optimal diet will result in weight gain if daily needs are exceeded. Clients are often inclined to adopt more healthful eating habits once they experience success during their initial weight loss efforts, which can be achieved by simply
Other research has confirmed the findings of the National Weight Control Registry and identified additional behaviors common to sustained weight loss, which include planning meals on most days of the week, tracking fat and calories, measuring food, adding physical activity into daily routines and setting goals.28,29 Although weight loss can be achieved without adopting these behaviors, it is important to note that they have been shown to be effective. A more simplified approach is to eat less, move more and make adjustments based on whether changes in body weight occur. For most people, it is safe to say that in an era of convenience, automation and a rich supply of energy-dense food, becoming knowledgeable about calories and portions, consciously controlling food choices while deliberately resisting the natural tendency to be sedentary are essential for successful weight control.
Numerous studies have demonstrated that the inclusion of immediate pre and post-training, fast-acting carbohydrate/sugar and protein feedings can stimulate muscle protein synthesis (MPS)38,39 and reduce muscle damage to a far greater extent than normal eating patterns. 40,41 In other words, no matter how well you eat throughout the day, you recover faster and build more muscle and strength by including these quickly absorbed pre- and post-exercise formulas (see Figure 2). 42,43
7 6 5 4
lbs
3 2 1 0 1 BodyMassLBMFM
PRE/POST MOR/EVE
Figure 2: Training results from 23 experienced recreational bodybuilders resistance training for 10 weeks with all things (diet, supplements, training, etc.) equal except the addition of pre/post feedings yielded significantly greater gains in body mass, LBM, strength and reduction in fat mass for the pre/post feeding subjects.43 Adapted from Rolls et al, 2006.
Diet composition
As stated above, carbohydrates will play an important role in performance, recovery and insulin levels. Carbohydrates should make up 45 to 65 percent of total calorie intake while trying to increase muscle size. Without adequate carbohydrates, ideal insulin activation will not occur, recovery from intense workouts will not be ideal, and muscular stores of energy for the next workout may be suboptimal. None of this contributes to maximum muscular gains. Protein, which mistakenly receives the greatest focus by many exercisers, needs to be high enough to allow for tissue growth. For even the hardest training bodybuilder when calories are not severely restricted, a protein intake of up to 1 gram per pound of bodyweight is more than enough to allow for increased needs due to intense workouts and adding muscle. Higher protein intakes are not necessary and may even impede progress if it takes the place of dietary carbohydrate. The exception to this is during severe calorie restriction during the final weeks of contest preparation of physique athletes. (Nutritional strategies for this population are beyond the scope of this course and are published elsewhere.) Healthy fats will complete the picture, making up the remaining calories and generally supplying 15 to 35 percent of total calorie intake.
10
Dietary Supplements
The final component to maximizing size and performance gains is the integration of dietary supplements. The primary goal of incorporating dietary supplements into food planning is to supply specific compounds that are used during energy, force production (muscle exertion and subsequent damage) and are needed for recovery and building. This helps keep calories within an appropriate range so unwanted weight gain is avoided. Additionally, these specific compounds must be supplied in greater amounts than are used so that a portion of their intake will be deposited into the damaged or depleted structural tissues. This will lead to the desired increase in muscle size. By isolating these nutrients and compounds from the food form, they can be ingested without calories in order to control body composition. Dietary supplements that are manufactured in proper forms and dosages allow users to deliver the needed nutrients into the body at the exact times necessary to take full advantage of periods when muscle cells are most nutrient-sensitive. This is established by training, sleep and meal times. Proper dietary supplement use including the science behind individual products is presented in a separate section of this course.
Summary The science of weight control is rooted in energy balance and the laws of nature. Therefore, managing calories consumed and expended allows for long-term weight management. Critical components in achieving and sustaining weight control goals include becoming aware of influencing factors such as appetite and environmental forces and establishing methods to self-regulate behaviors to properly modify energy balance. Knowing daily calorie requirements, food logging, learning nutritional information, controlling portions and using meal replacements are effective weight control strategies; however, these should be recommended to clients based on lifestyle and readiness. Optimal muscle gain requires extra calories and nutrients, ideal diet composition, pre- and post-workout feedings, proper dietary supplementation and progressive resistance training. Muscle gain will vary based on individual differences including training experience and frequency. By understanding the science of weight control and applying the information provided in this course, fitness professionals can provide an invaluable service by guiding their clients daily activity and food choices and helping them achieve a healthy body weight and a higher quality of life.
11
References
1FairesVM.Thermodynamics.NewYork:MacMillanCompany;1967.P3840.
2PaddonJonesD,WestmanE,MattesRD,WolfeRR,AstrupA,WesterterpPlantengaM.Protein,weightmanagement,
andsatiety.AmJClinNutr.2008May;87(5):1558S1561S. 3 HillJO,WyattHR,ReedGW,PetersJC.Obesityandtheenvironment:wheredowegofromhere?Science.2003Feb 7;299(5608):8535. 4U.S.DepartmentofHealth&HumanServicesandtheU.SDepartmentofAgriculture,DietaryGuidelinesforAmericans, 2005.Availableathttp://www.health.gov/dietaryguidelines/default.htm.AccessedMay2008. 5AmericanDieteticAssociation.PositionoftheAmericanDieteticAssociation:WeightManagement.JAmDietAssoc. 2002;102(8):114545. 6 Nordmann AJ, Nordmann A, Briel M, Keller U, Yancy WS, Brehm BJ, Bucher HC. Effects of Low-carbohydrate vs. Low-fat Diets on Weight Loss and Cardiovascular Risk Factors, A Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Ann Intern Med. 2006;166:285-93. 7WingR,PhelanS.Longtermweightlossmaintenance.AmJClinNutr.2005.82(suppl):222S5S 8WaddenTA,PhelanS.Behavioralassessementoftheobestpatient.In:WaddenTA,StunkardAJ,eds.Handbookof obesitytreatment.NewYork:GuilfordPress,2002;186226. 9DansingerML,TatsioniA,WongJB,ChungM,BalkEM.Metaanalysis:theeffectofdietarycounselingforweightloss. AnnInternMed.2007Jul3;147(1):4150.Review. 10HollisJF,GullionCM,StevensVJ,BrantleyPJ,AppelLJ,ArdJD,ChampagneCM,DalcinA,ErlingerTP,FunkK,Laferriere D,LinPH,LoriaCM,SamuelHodgeC,VollmerWM,SvetkeyLP,WeightLossMaintenanceTrialResearchGroup.Weight lossduringtheintensiveinterventionphaseoftheweightlossmaintenancetrial.AmJPrevMed.2008Aug;35(2):118 26. 11KrugerJ,BlanckHM,GillespieC.Dietaryandphysicalactivitybehaviorsamongadultssuccessfulatweightloss maintenance.IntJBehavNutrPhysAct.2006;3:17. 12LevitskyDA,YounT.Themorefoodyoungadultsareserved,themoretheyovereat.JNutr.2004Oct;134(10):25469. 13WansinkB,PainterJE,NorthJ.Bottomlessbowls:whyvisualcuesofportionsizemayinfluenceintake.ObesRes.2005 Jan;13(1):93100. 14RollsBJ,RoeLS,MeengsJS.Reductionsinportionsizeandenergydensityoffoodsareadditiveandleadtosustained decreasesinenergyintake.AmJClinNutr.2006Jan;83(1):117. 15RollsBJ,RoeLS,MeengsJS.Reductionsinportionsizeandenergydensityoffoodsareadditiveandleadtosustained decreasesinenergyintake.AmJClinNutr.2006Jan;83(1):117. 16HeymsfieldSB,vanMierloCA,vanderKnaapHC,HeoM,FrierHI.Weightmanagementusingamealreplacement strategy:metaandpoolinganalysisfromsixstudies.IntJObesRelatMetabDisord.2003May;27(5):53749. 17AshleyJM,StJeorST,PerumeanChaneyS,SchrageJ,BoveeV.Mealreplacementsinweightintervention.ObesRes. 2001Nov;9Suppl4:312S320S. 18DitschuneitHH.Domealreplacementdrinkshavearoleindiabetesmanagement?NestleNutrWorkshopSerClin PerformProgramme.2006;11:1719;discussion17981.Review. 19LiZ,HongK,SaltsmanP,DeShieldsS,BellmanM,ThamesG,LiuY,WangHJ,ElashoffR,HeberD.Longtermefficacyof soybasedmealreplacementsvsanindividualizeddietplaninobesetypeIIDMpatients:relativeeffectsonweightloss, metabolicparameters,andCreactiveprotein.EurJClinNutr.2005Mar;59(3):4118. 20PostonWS,HaddockCK,PinkstonMM,PaceP,KarakocND,ReevesRS,ForeytJP.Weightlosswithmealreplacement andmealreplacementplussnacks:arandomizedtrial.IntJObes(Lond).2005Sep;29(9):110714. 21HeymsfieldSB,vanMierloCA,vanderKnaapHC,HeoM,FrierHI.Weightmanagementusingamealreplacement strategy:metaandpoolinganalysisfromsixstudies.IntJObesRelatMetabDisord.2003May;27(5):53749. 22DitschuneitHH,FlechtnerMorsM.Valueofstructuredmealsforweightmanagement:riskfactorsandlongterm weightmaintenance.ObesRes.2001Nov;9Suppl4:284S289S. 23RothackerDQ.Fiveyearselfmanagementofweightusingmealreplacements:comparisonwithmatchedcontrolsin ruralWisconsin.Nutrition2000;16:3448. 24FlechtnerMorsM,DitschuneitHH,JohnsonTD,SuchardMA,AdlerG.Metabolicandweightlosseffectsoflongterm dietaryinterventioninobesepatients:fouryearresults.ObesRes.2000Aug;8(5):399402.
12
25WingRandHillJ.Successfulweightlossmaintenance.AnnRevNutr.2001.21:23241. 26McGuire,M.T.,Wing,R.R.,Klem,M.L.,Seagle,H.M.,&Hill,J.O.Longtermmaintenanceofweightloss:Dopeoplewho
loseweightthroughvariousweightlossmethodsusedifferentbehaviorstomaintaintheirweight?InternationalJournal ofObesity,1998,22,572577. 27Shick,S.M.,Wing,R.R.,Klem,M.L.,McGuire,M.T.,Hill,J.O.,&Seagle,H.Personssuccessfulatlongtermweightlossand maintenancecontinuetoconsumealowcalorie,lowfatdiet.JAmDietAssoc.1998,98,40813. 28KrugerK,BlanckHM,GillespieC.Dietaryandphysicalactivitybehaviorsamongadultssuccessfulatweightloss maintenance.IntoJBehavNutrPhysAct.2006.3:17. 29ElfhagK,RossnerS.Whosucceedsinmaintainingweightloss?Aconceptualreviewoffactorsassociatedwithweight lossmaintenanceandregain.ObesRev.2005.6:6785. 30 AagaardP.Makingmuscles"stronger":exercise,nutrition,drugs.JMusculoskeletNeuronalInteract.2004 Jun;4(2):16574.Review. 31 CullinenK,CaldwellM.Weighttrainingincreasesfatfreemassandstrengthinuntrainedyoungwomen.JAmDiet Assoc.1998Apr;98(4):4148. 32McArdleWD,KathFIandKatchVL.Exercisephysiology:Energy,nutritionandhumanperformance,Thirdedition. Malvern,PA.Lea&Febiger,1991. 33StaronRS,KarapondoDL,KraemerWJ,etal.Skeletalmuscleadaptationsduringearlyphaseofheavyresistance traininginmenandwomen.JApplPhysiol1994;76:1247 34GreenH,GorehamC,OuyangJ,BallBurnettM,RanneyD.Regulationoffibersize,oxidativepotential,and capillarizationinhumanmusclebyresistanceexercise.AmJPhysiol1999;276:R591 35McCallGE,ByrnesWC,DickinsonA,PattanyPM,FleckSJ.Musclefiberhypertrophy,hyperplasia,andcapillarydensity incollegemenafterresistancetraining.JApplPhysiol1996;81:2004 36KimballSR,FarrellPA,JeffersonLS.InvitedReview:Roleofinsulinintranslationalcontrolofproteinsynthesisin skeletalmusclebyaminoacidsorexercise.JApplPhysiol.2002Sep;93(3):116880.Review. 37TiptonKD,RasmussenBB,MillerSL,WolfSE,OwensStovallSK,PetriniBE,WolfeRR.Timingofaminoacid carbohydrateingestionaltersanabolicresponseofmuscletoresistanceexercise.AmJPhysiolEndocrinolMetab.2001 Aug;281(2):E197206. 38KoopmanR,WagenmakersAJ,MandersRJ,ZorencAH,SendenJM,GorselinkM,KeizerHA,vanLoonLJ.Combined ingestionofproteinandfreeleucinewithcarbohydrateincreasespostexercisemuscleproteinsynthesisinvivoinmale subjects.AmJPhysiolEndocrinolMetab.2005Apr;288(4):E64553.Epub2004Nov23. 39EsmarckB,AndersenJL,OlsenS,RichterEA,MizunoM,KjaerM.Timingofpostexerciseproteinintakeisimportantfor musclehypertrophywithresistancetraininginelderlyhumans.JPhysiol.2001Aug15;535(Pt1):30111. 40BirdSP,TarpenningKM,MarinoFE.Liquidcarbohydrate/essentialaminoacidingestionduringashorttermboutof resistanceexercisesuppressesmyofibrillarproteindegradation.Metabolism.2006May;55(5):5707. 41BatyJJ,HwangH,DingZ,BernardJR,WangB,KwonB,IvyJL.Theeffectofacarbohydrateandproteinsupplementon resistanceexerciseperformance,hormonalresponse,andmuscledamage.JStrengthCondRes.2007May;21(2):3219. 42PaddonJonesD,SheffieldMooreM,AarslandA,WolfeRR,FerrandoAA.Exogenousaminoacidsstimulatehuman muscleanabolismwithoutinterferingwiththeresponsetomixedmealingestion.AmJPhysiolEndocrinolMetab.2005 Apr;288(4):E7617.Epub2004Nov30. 43CribbPJ,HayesA.Effectsofsupplementtimingandresistanceexerciseonskeletalmusclehypertrophy.MedSciSports Exerc.2006Nov;38(11):191825.
13
The National Academy of sports Medicines OPT system has cutting edge training protocols that are backed by sound science and research! That has made all the difference! Go for gold, get NASM certified! Roger J. Yasin NASM PES, CES
The 100 Best Personal Trainers in America, Top Personal Trainers in Washington, DC
Board of Certification
CERTIFIED
www.nasm.org
To purchase, call 800.460.NASM ext. 5501. For Corporate Accounts, call 800.460.NASM ext. 5504.