Thanks to visit codestin.com
Credit goes to www.scribd.com

Scribd
Upload
3K views2 pages

Debate-Judging Notes Sheet

Notes sheet for the judges in a Mace debate. This is part of a series of files which includes a pptx presentation of debate in the classroom, example of how a debate should be conducted, chairperson's flowchart, guidelines for judges, and timekeeper's flowchart.

Uploaded by

Chiew N Pang
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
3K views2 pages

Debate-Judging Notes Sheet

Notes sheet for the judges in a Mace debate. This is part of a series of files which includes a pptx presentation of debate in the classroom, example of how a debate should be conducted, chairperson's flowchart, guidelines for judges, and timekeeper's flowchart.

Uploaded by

Chiew N Pang
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

Judging notes sheet - Proposition

MOTION:

1st Proposition NAME:


Notes on arguments made: Notes on use of voice, language,
body, face, etc.:

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /40
& Evidence /20 & Prioritisation /10 & Response N/A & Delivery /10

2nd Proposition NAME:


Notes on arguments made: Rebuttal: Notes on use of voice, language, body,
face, etc.:

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /40
& Evidence /10 & Prioritisation /10 & Response /10 & Delivery /10

Prop Summary NAME:


Notes on summary of debate, which should include (a) reference to
proposition arguments, (b) reference to team’s rebuttal of opposition’s Notes on use of voice, language, body, face, etc.:
arguments, (c) some reference to the floor debate

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /20
& Evidence /5 & Prioritisation /5 & Response /5 & Delivery /5

Team Total /100

Acknowledgments: English-Speaking Union, Chiew N Pang


Judging notes sheet - Opposition

MOTION:

1st Opposition NAME:


Notes on arguments made: Rebuttal: Notes on use of voice, language, body,
face, etc.:

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /40
& Evidence /10 & Prioritisation /10 & Response /10 & Delivery /10

2nd Opposition NAME:


Notes on arguments made: Rebuttal: Notes on use of voice, language, body,
face, etc.:

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /40
& Evidence /10 & Prioritisation /10 & Response /10 & Delivery /10

Opp Summary NAME:


Notes on summary of debate, which should include (a) reference to
opposition arguments, (b) reference to team’s rebuttal of proposition’s Notes on use of voice, language, body, face, etc.:
arguments, (c) some reference to the floor debate

Reasoning Organisation Listening Expression


Total /20
& Evidence /5 & Prioritisation /5 & Response /5 & Delivery /5

Team Total /100

Acknowledgments: English-Speaking Union, Chiew N Pang

You might also like