Thanks to visit codestin.com
Credit goes to www.scribd.com

0% found this document useful (0 votes)
76 views8 pages

Submitted By, Aseena.S.A Physical Science

This document discusses the declining use of field trips in K-12 public education. It notes that budget pressures and an increased focus on standardized test scores have led many schools to eliminate planned field trips or replace culturally enriching trips to museums and historic sites with trips focused on entertainment or rewards. Field trips were once seen as central to providing students access to cultural heritage, but are now often viewed as unnecessary frills. While field trips broaden students' educational experiences and make subjects more relevant, many schools no longer see them as a priority amid other pressures.

Uploaded by

asaseena
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
76 views8 pages

Submitted By, Aseena.S.A Physical Science

This document discusses the declining use of field trips in K-12 public education. It notes that budget pressures and an increased focus on standardized test scores have led many schools to eliminate planned field trips or replace culturally enriching trips to museums and historic sites with trips focused on entertainment or rewards. Field trips were once seen as central to providing students access to cultural heritage, but are now often viewed as unnecessary frills. While field trips broaden students' educational experiences and make subjects more relevant, many schools no longer see them as a priority amid other pressures.

Uploaded by

asaseena
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 8

Submitted by,

ASEENA.S.A
PHYSICAL SCIENCE
INDEX

SL NO CONTENT
1 Introduction
2 Obecti!e" o# e$cur"ion
% T&e educ'tion'( !'(ue o# #ie(d tri)"
* De"i+n o# t&e "tudy 'nd "c&oo( tri)"
, Conc(u"ion
- .e#erence




INTRODUCTION
Acro"" t&e n'tion, #ie(d tri)" 're bein+ e(imin'ted #rom "c&oo( di"trict/" bud+et". Te'c&er" 're
re"tricted by t&e )re""ure" #rom di"trict" to "&o0 curricu('r re"u(t" 'nd to co!er content in
c('""room" (e'!in+ (itt(e time #or out1o#1"c&oo( e$cur"ion".
T&e (o+i"tic" o# te"t "c&edu(e", #indin+ ' "ub"titute te'c&er, bu" 'nd #ue( co"t", 'nd b'('ncin+
curricu(um need" 0it& &'nd"1on 'cti!itie" o#ten (e'!e" te'c&er" o!er0&e(med. 2ie(d tri)" 're o#ten
!ie0ed '" 3#(u##4 or e$tr'1curricu('r 'cti!itie" 'nd, t&ere#ore, 're e'"y (ine item" to cut.
Ho0e!er, te'c&er" 'nd "tudent" 'd!oc'te 5 'nd "tudie" indic'te 5 t&'t #ie(d tri)" 're ' 6ey
com)onent o# "c&oo( in"truction7 t&ey bro'den t&e educ'tion'( e$)erience 'nd m'6e ' "ubect more
re(e!'nt.
Student" mi+&t be +ood 't recitin+ 'nd rememberin+ t&in+" but t&ey o#ten don/t m'6e t&e
connection un(e"" t&ey e$)erience it #ir"t &'nd. 2ie(d tri)" connect t&e dot" #or "tudent" by
)ro!idin+ re'( e$)erience" re('ted to '(( content 're'".
2ie(d tri)" enric& 'nd e$)'nd t&e curricu(um, "tren+t&en ob"er!'tion "6i((" by immer"in+ c&i(dren
into "en"ory 'cti!itie", incre'"e c&i(dren/" 6no0(ed+e in ' )'rticu('r "ubect 're' 'nd e$)'nd
c&i(dren/" '0'rene"" o# t&eir o0n community. And e!eryone you ")e'6 0it& &'" ' #ie(d tri)
memory.
8&'t m'6e" ' #ie(d tri) +ood9
T&in6 o# t&e e$cur"ion '" ' #ie(d "tudy, not ' #ie(d tri). It i" ' (e'rnin+ e$)erience or e$)erienti'(
(e'rnin+.
A #ocu" on 'rt" inte+r'tion 'nd )roect1b'"ed (e'rnin+ te'c&e" "tudent" to e$)(ore re'(10or(d
)rob(em" 'nd c&'((en+e". Acti!e 'nd en+'+ed (e'rnin+ in")ire" "tudent" to obt'in ' dee)er
6no0(ed+e o# t&e "ubect" t&ey 're "tudyin+ 'nd '((o0" t&em to "ee &o0 ide'" 're connected.
Te'c&in+ in "uc& ' conte$tu'( m'nner )romote" co(('bor'tion, critic'( t&in6in+ 'nd 6no0(ed+e
retention.
O#ten te'c&er" (oo6 to t&e 'rt" 'nd cu(tur'( or+'ni:'tion" o# t&eir community #or #ie(d tri) ide'";
mu"eum", :oo", "cience center", 'nd n'tur'( 're'". Per#ormin+ 'rt" brin+ t&e )'+e to t&e "t'+e 'nd
c'n '("o o##er ' (e""on in t&e'ter eti<uette.
In 'ddition to t&e tr'dition'( !enue", te'c&er" m'y c&oo"e "ite" #or re'( 0or(d e$)erience" to
encour'+e "tudent" to '))(y 0&'t t&ey/!e (e'rned to "omet&in+ re(e!'nt in t&eir (i#e. 2or e$'m)(e,
c&i(dren !i"itin+ ' con"truction "ite c'n return to t&e c('""room 'nd de"i+n t&eir o0n &ome",
bu"ine""e", 'nd ot&er 'rc&itectur'( "tructure".
=i"itin+ ' co((e+e or uni!er"ity c'm)u" introduce" t&e dre'm o# &i+&er educ'tion7 co((e+e "tudent"
c'n 'ct '" t&e tour +uide", "&o0 dorm room", c'#eteri'", 'nd "tudy &'((", 0&i(e )ro!idin+
mentor"&i) to t&e youn+er "tudent.
T&e be"t #ie(d tri)" c'n brin+ t0o "eemin+(y unre('ted 0or(d" to+et&er.
C&i(dren #rom ('r+e citie" m'y not under"t'nd ' m't& e<u'tion 'bout (i!e"toc6, cro)", 'nd t&e ot&er
"t')(e" o# t&e rur'( e$)erience bec'u"e t&e "tudent" #ocu" on t&e !oc'bu('ry, +et con#u"ed, 'nd "6i)
t&e <ue"tion.
Student" in ' rur'( community 're o#ten i+nor'nt o# urb'n 'nd "uburb'n termino(o+y. Sub0'y "to)",
#'re", e"c'('tor", HO= ('ne">t&e"e o#t1u"ed term" )('ced in ' m't& te"t <ue"tion c'n b(oc6 t&e
m'in ide' 'nd )re!ent ' "tudent #rom 'n"0erin+.
Sometime" "t'te e$'m" inc(ude <ue"tion" t&'t do not brid+e t&e +') bet0een rur'( 'nd urb'n
"tudent".
A 0e((1de"i+ned #ie(d tri) c'n brin+ it '(( to+et&er; combine t0o or more "ubect" 0&i(e o##erin+ '
!'riety o# (e'rnin+ "ty(e" 'nd inte((i+ence", inte+r'te t&e 'rt", encour'+e (o01income 'nd En+(i"&
('n+u'+e (e'rner "tudent" to m'6e connection" bet0een community re"ource" 'nd o))ortunitie" 'nd
t&eir #'mi(y 'nd cu(ture.
T&e"e e$)erience" '((o0 '(( )'rtici)'tin+ "tudent" to 'c&ie!e ' &i+&er 'c'demic )er#orm'nce in '((
"ubect 're'" 5 not u"t t&e 'rt".
?id" need t&i" !it'( com)onent o# "c&oo( in"truction, i# not on(y to im)ro!e te"t "core", but to #ee(,
"ee, touc&, 'nd e!en t'"te t&e re'( 0or(d 'round t&em. And t&'t/" "omet&in+ you c'n on(y +et #rom '
#ie(d tri).
O@AECTI=ES O2 EXCB.SION
1C To c')it'(i:e educ'tion'(y t&e mi+r'tory in"tinct o# t&e c&i(d
2C To 'c<u'int t&e )u)i( 0it& &i" en!ironment
%C To inter)ret "u))(ement 'nd enric& curricu('r e$)erience"
The Educational Value of Field Trips
T&e "c&oo( #ie(d tri) &'" ' (on+ &i"tory in Americ'n )ub(ic educ'tion. 2or dec'de", "tudent" &'!e
)i(ed into ye((o0 bu"e" to !i"it ' !'riety o# cu(tur'( in"titution", inc(udin+ 'rt, n'tur'( &i"tory, 'nd
"cience mu"eum", '" 0e(( '" t&e'ter", :oo", 'nd &i"toric'( "ite". Sc&oo(" +('d(y endured t&e e$)en"e
'nd di"ru)tion o# )ro!idin+ #ie(d tri)" bec'u"e t&ey "'0 t&e"e e$)erience" '" centr'( to t&eir
educ'tion'( mi""ion; "c&oo(" e$i"t not on(y to )ro!ide economic'((y u"e#u( "6i((" in numer'cy 'nd
(iter'cy, but '("o to )roduce ci!i(i:ed youn+ men 'nd 0omen 0&o 0ou(d '))reci'te t&e 'rt" 'nd
cu(ture. Dore1'd!'nt'+ed #'mi(ie" m'y t'6e t&eir c&i(dren to t&e"e cu(tur'( in"titution" out"ide o#
"c&oo( &our", but (e""1'd!'nt'+ed "tudent" 're (e"" (i6e(y to &'!e t&e"e e$)erience" i# "c&oo(" do not
)ro!ide t&em. 8it& #ie(d tri)", )ub(ic "c&oo(" !ie0ed t&em"e(!e" '" t&e +re't e<u'(i:er in term" o#
'cce"" to our cu(tur'( &erit'+e.
Tod'y, cu(tur'((y enric&in+ #ie(d tri)" 're in dec(ine. Du"eum" 'cro"" t&e country re)ort ' "tee) dro)
in "c&oo( tour". 2or e$'m)(e, t&e 2ie(d Du"eum in C&ic'+o 't one time 0e(comed more t&'n
%EE,EEE "tudent" e!ery ye'r. .ecent(y t&e number i" be(o0 2EE,EEE. @et0een 2EE2 'nd 2EEF,
Cincinn'ti 'rt" or+'ni:'tion" "'0 ' %E )ercent decre'"e in "tudent 'ttend'nce. A "ur!ey by t&e
Americ'n A""oci'tion o# Sc&oo( Admini"tr'tor" #ound t&'t more t&'n &'(# o# "c&oo(" e(imin'ted
)('nned #ie(d tri)" in 2E1E511.
T&e deci"ion to reduce cu(tur'((y enric&in+ #ie(d tri)" re#(ect" ' !'riety o# #'ctor". 2in'nci'(
)re""ure" #orce "c&oo(" to m'6e di##icu(t deci"ion" 'bout &o0 to '((oc'te "c'rce re"ource", 'nd #ie(d
tri)" 're incre'"in+(y "een '" 'n unnece""'ry #ri((. Gre'ter #ocu" on r'i"in+ "tudent )er#orm'nce on
m't& 'nd re'din+ "t'nd'rdi:ed te"t" m'y '("o (e'd "c&oo(" to cut #ie(d tri)". Some "c&oo(" be(ie!e
t&'t "tudent time 0ou(d be better ")ent in t&e c('""room )re)'rin+ #or t&e e$'m". 8&en "c&oo(" do
or+'ni:e #ie(d tri)", t&ey 're incre'"in+(y c&oo"in+ to t'6e "tudent" on tri)" to re0'rd t&em #or
0or6in+ &'rd to im)ro!e t&eir te"t "core" r't&er t&'n to )ro!ide cu(tur'( enric&ment. Sc&oo(" t'6e
"tudent" to 'mu"ement )'r6", ")ortin+ e!ent", 'nd mo!ie t&e'ter" in"te'd o# to mu"eum" 'nd
&i"toric'( "ite". T&i" "&i#t #rom 3enric&ment4 to 3re0'rd4 #ie(d tri)" i" re#(ected in ' +ener'tion'(
c&'n+e 'mon+ te'c&er" 'bout t&e )ur)o"e" o# t&e"e outin+". In ' 2E12 1% "ur!ey 0e conducted o#
ne'r(y ,EE Ar6'n"'" te'c&er", t&o"e 0&o &'d been te'c&in+ #or 't (e'"t 1, ye'r" 0ere "i+ni#ic'nt(y
more (i6e(y to be(ie!e t&'t t&e )rim'ry )ur)o"e o# ' #ie(d tri) i" to )ro!ide ' (e'rnin+ o))ortunity,
0&i(e more unior te'c&er" 0ere more (i6e(y to "ee t&e )rim'ry )ur)o"e '" 3enoyment.4
I# "c&oo(" 're de1em)&'"i:in+ cu(tur'((y enric&in+ #ie(d tri)", &'" 'nyt&in+ been (o"t '" ' re"u(t9
Sur)ri"in+(y, 0e &'!e re('ti!e(y (itt(e ri+orou" e!idence 'bout &o0 #ie(d tri)" '##ect "tudent". T&e
re"e'rc& )re"ented &ere i" t&e #ir"t ('r+e1"c'(e r'ndomi:ed1contro( tri'( de"i+ned to me'"ure 0&'t
"tudent" (e'rn #rom "c&oo( tour" o# 'n 'rt mu"eum.
8e #ind t&'t "tudent" (e'rn <uite ' (ot. In )'rticu('r, enric&in+ #ie(d tri)" contribute to t&e
de!e(o)ment o# "tudent" into ci!i(i:ed youn+ men 'nd 0omen 0&o )o""e"" more 6no0(ed+e 'bout
'rt, &'!e "tron+er critic'(1t&in6in+ "6i((", e$&ibit incre'"ed &i"toric'( em)'t&y, di")('y &i+&er (e!e("
o# to(er'nce, 'nd &'!e ' +re'ter t'"te #or con"umin+ 'rt 'nd cu(ture.
Design of the Study and School Tours
T&e 2E11 o)enin+ o# t&e Cry"t'( @rid+e" Du"eum o# Americ'n Art in Nort&0e"t Ar6'n"'" cre'ted
t&e o))ortunity #or t&i" "tudy. Cry"t'( @rid+e" i" t&e #ir"t m'or 'rt mu"eum to be bui(t in t&e Bnited
St'te" in t&e ('"t #our dec'de", 0it& more t&'n ,E,EEE "<u're #eet o# +'((ery ")'ce 'nd 'n
endo0ment in e$ce"" o# HIEE mi((ion. Portion" o# t&e mu"eum/" endo0ment 're de!oted to
co!erin+ '(( o# t&e e$)en"e" '""oci'ted 0it& "c&oo( tour". Cry"t'( @rid+e" reimbur"e" "c&oo(" #or
t&e co"t o# bu"e", )ro!ide" #ree 'dmi""ion 'nd (unc&, 'nd e!en )'y" #or t&e co"t o# "ub"titute
te'c&er" to co!er #or te'c&er" 0&o 'ccom)'ny "tudent" on t&e tour.
@ec'u"e t&e tour i" com)(ete(y #ree to "c&oo(", 'nd bec'u"e Cry"t'( @rid+e" 0'" bui(t in 'n 're' t&'t
ne!er )re!iou"(y &'d 'n 'rt mu"eum, t&ere 0'" &i+& dem'nd #or "c&oo( tour". Not '(( "c&oo( +rou)"
cou(d be 'ccommod'ted ri+&t '0'y. So our re"e'rc& te'm 0or6ed 0it& t&e "t'## 't Cry"t'( @rid+e"
to '""i+n ")ot" #or "c&oo( tour" by (ottery. Durin+ t&e #ir"t t0o "eme"ter" o# t&e "c&oo( tour )ro+r'm,
t&e mu"eum recei!ed ,2, '))(ic'tion" #rom "c&oo( +rou)" re)re"entin+ %I,%*F "tudent" in
6inder+'rten t&rou+& +r'de 12. 8e cre'ted m'tc&ed )'ir" 'mon+ t&e '))(ic'nt +rou)" b'"ed on
"imi('rity in +r'de (e!e( 'nd ot&er demo+r')&ic #'ctor". An ide'( 'nd common m'tc&ed )'ir 0ou(d
be 'd'cent +r'de" in t&e "'me "c&oo(. 8e t&en r'ndom(y ordered t&e m'tc&ed )'ir" to determine
"c&edu(in+ )rioriti:'tion. 8it&in e'c& )'ir, 0e r'ndom(y '""i+ned 0&ic& '))(ic'nt 0ou(d be in t&e
tre'tment +rou) 'nd recei!e ' tour t&'t "eme"ter 'nd 0&ic& 0ou(d be in t&e contro( +rou) 'nd &'!e
it" tour de#erred.
8e 'dmini"tered "ur!ey" to 1E,J12 "tudent" 'nd *IJ te'c&er" 't 12% di##erent "c&oo(" t&ree 0ee6",
on '!er'+e, '#ter t&e tre'tment +rou) recei!ed it" tour. T&e "tudent "ur!ey" inc(uded mu(ti)(e item"
'""e""in+ 6no0(ed+e 'bout 'rt '" 0e(( '" me'"ure" o# critic'( t&in6in+, &i"toric'( em)'t&y,
to(er'nce, 'nd "u"t'ined intere"t in !i"itin+ 'rt mu"eum". Some +rou)" 0ere "ur!eyed '" ('te '"
ei+&t 0ee6" '#ter t&e tour, but it 0'" not )o""ib(e to co((ect d't' '#ter (on+er )eriod" bec'u"e e'c&
contro( +rou) 0'" +u'r'nteed ' tour durin+ t&e #o((o0in+ "eme"ter '" ' re0'rd #or it" coo)er'tion.
T&ere i" no indic'tion t&'t t&e re"u(t" re)orted be(o0 #'ded #or +rou)" "ur!eyed '#ter (on+er )eriod".
8e '("o '""e""ed "tudent"/ critic'(1t&in6in+ "6i((" by '"6in+ t&em to 0rite ' "&ort e""'y in re")on"e
to ' )'intin+ t&'t t&ey &'d not )re!iou"(y "een. 2in'((y, 0e co((ected ' be&'!ior'( me'"ure o#
intere"t in 'rt con"um)tion by )ro!idin+ '(( "tudent" 0it& ' coded cou)on +ood #or #ree #'mi(y
'dmi""ion to ' ")eci'( e$&ibit 't t&e mu"eum to "ee 0&et&er t&e #ie(d tri) incre'"ed t&e (i6e(i&ood o#
"tudent" m'6in+ #uture !i"it".
A(( re"u(t" re)orted be(o0 're deri!ed #rom re+re""ion mode(" t&'t contro( #or "tudent +r'de (e!e(
'nd +ender 'nd m'6e com)'ri"on" 0it&in e'c& m'tc&ed )'ir, 0&i(e t'6in+ into 'ccount t&e #'ct t&'t
"tudent" in t&e m'tc&ed )'ir o# '))(ic'nt +rou)" 're (i6e(y to be "imi('r in 0'y" t&'t 0e 're un'b(e
to ob"er!e. St'nd'rd !'(idity te"t" con#irmed t&'t t&e "ur!ey item" em)(oyed to +ener'te t&e !'riou"
"c'(e" u"ed '" outcome" me'"ured t&e "'me under(yin+ con"truct".
T&e inter!ention 0e "tudied i" ' mode"t one. Student" recei!ed ' one1&our tour o# t&e mu"eum in
0&ic& t&ey ty)ic'((y !ie0ed 'nd di"cu""ed #i!e )'intin+". Some "tudent" 0ere #ree to ro'm t&e
mu"eum #o((o0in+ t&eir #orm'( tour, but t&e entire e$)erience u"u'((y in!o(!ed (e"" t&'n &'(# ' d'y.
In"truction'( m'teri'(" 0ere "ent to te'c&er" 0&o 0ent on ' tour, but our "ur!ey o# te'c&er" "u++e"t"
t&'t t&e"e m'teri'(" recei!ed re('ti!e(y (itt(e 'ttention, on '!er'+e no more t&'n 'n &our o# tot'(
c('"" time. T&e di"cu""ion o# e'c& )'intin+ durin+ t&e tour 0'" ('r+e(y "tudent1directed, 0it& t&e
mu"eum educ'tor" #'ci(it'tin+ t&e di"cour"e 'nd )ro!idin+ comment'ry beyond t&e n'me" o# t&e
0or6 'nd t&e 'rti"t 'nd ' brie# de"cri)tion on(y 0&en "tudent" re<ue"ted it. T&i" #orm't i" no0 t&e
norm in "c&oo( tour" o# 'rt mu"eum". T&e '!er"ion to &'!in+ mu"eum educ'tor" )ro!ide
in#orm'tion 'bout 0or6" o# 'rt i" moti!'ted in )'rt by )ro+re""i!e educ'tion t&eorie" 'nd by '
con!iction 'mon+ m'ny in mu"eum educ'tion t&'t "tudent" ret'in !ery (itt(e #'ctu'( in#orm'tion
#rom t&eir tour".
CONCLUSION
. Our re"e'rc& "u++e"t" t&'t "tudent" 'ctu'((y ret'in ' +re't de'( o# #'ctu'( in#orm'tion #rom t&eir
tour". Student" 0&o recei!ed ' tour o# t&e mu"eum 0ere 'b(e to rec'(( det'i(" 'bout t&e )'intin+"
t&ey &'d "een 't !ery &i+& r'te". 2or e$'m)(e, II )ercent o# t&e "tudent" 0&o "'0 t&e E'"tm'n
Ao&n"on )'intin+ At the CampSpinning Yarns and Whittling 6ne0 0&en "ur!eyed 0ee6" ('ter t&'t
t&e )'intin+ de)ict" 'bo(itioni"t" m'6in+ m')(e "yru) to undermine t&e "u+'r indu"try, 0&ic& re(ied
on "('!e ('bor. Simi('r(y, I2 )ercent o# t&o"e 0&o "'0 Norm'n .oc60e((/" Rosie the Riveter cou(d
rec'(( t&'t t&e )'intin+ em)&'"i:e" t&e im)ort'nce o# 0omen enterin+ t&e 0or6#orce durin+ 8or(d
8'r II. Amon+ "tudent" 0&o "'0 T&om'" H'rt @enton/" Ploughing It Under, FJ )ercent reco((ected
t&'t it i" ' de)iction o# ' #'rmer de"troyin+ &i" cro)" '" )'rt o# ' De)re""ion1er' )rice "u))ort
)ro+r'm. And FE )ercent o# t&e "tudent" 0&o "'0 .om're @e'rden/" Sacrifice cou(d remember t&'t
it i" )'rt o# t&e H'r(em .en'i""'nce 'rt mo!ement. Since t&ere 0'" no +u'r'ntee t&'t t&e"e #'ct"
0ou(d be r'i"ed in "tudent1directed di"cu""ion", 'nd bec'u"e "tudent" &'d no )'rticu('r re'"on #or
rememberin+ t&e"e det'i(" Kt&ere 0'" no te"t or +r'de '""oci'ted 0it& t&e tour"C, it i" im)re""i!e t&'t
t&ey cou(d rec'(( &i"toric'( 'nd "ocio(o+ic'( in#orm'tion 't "uc& &i+& r'te".
T&e"e re"u(t" "u++e"t t&'t 'rt cou(d be 'n im)ort'nt too( #or e##ecti!e(y con!eyin+ tr'dition'(
'c'demic content, but t&i" 'n'(y"i" c'nnot )ro!e it. T&e contro(1+rou) )er#orm'nce 0'" &'rd(y
better t&'n c&'nce in identi#yin+ #'ctu'( in#orm'tion 'bout t&e"e )'intin+", but t&ey ne!er &'d t&e
o))ortunity to (e'rn t&e m'teri'(. T&e &i+& r'te o# rec'(( o# #'ctu'( in#orm'tion by "tudent" 0&o
toured t&e mu"eum demon"tr'te" t&'t t&e tour" m'de 'n im)re""ion. T&e "tudent" cou(d remember
im)ort'nt det'i(" 'bout 0&'t t&ey "'0 'nd di"cu""ed.
. @eyond rec'((in+ t&e det'i(" o# t&eir tour, did ' !i"it to 'n 'rt mu"eum &'!e '
"i+ni#ic'nt e##ect on "tudent"9 Our "tudy demon"tr'te" t&'t it did. 2or e$'m)(e, "tudent"
r'ndom(y '""i+ned to recei!e ' "c&oo( tour o# Cry"t'( @rid+e" ('ter di")('yed demon"tr'b(y
"tron+er 'bi(ity to t&in6 critic'((y 'bout 'rt t&'n t&e contro( +rou).
Durin+ t&e #ir"t "eme"ter o# t&e "tudy, 0e "&o0ed '(( %rd1 t&rou+& 12t&1+r'de "tudent" ' )'intin+
t&ey &'d not )re!iou"(y "een, @o @'rt(ett/" The o!. 8e t&en '"6ed "tudent" to 0rite "&ort e""'y" in
re")on"e to t0o <ue"tion"; 8&'t do you t&in6 i" +oin+ on in t&i" )'intin+9 And, 0&'t do you "ee
t&'t m'6e" you t&in6 t&'t9 T&e"e 're "t'nd'rd )rom)t" u"ed by mu"eum educ'tor" to ")'r6
di"cu""ion durin+ "c&oo( tour".
8e "tri))ed t&e e""'y" o# '(( identi#yin+ in#orm'tion 'nd &'d t0o coder" r'te t&e com)o"ition"
u"in+ ' "e!en1item rubric #or me'"urin+ critic'( t&in6in+ t&'t 0'" de!e(o)ed by re"e'rc&er" 't t&e
I"'be((' Ste0'rt G'rdner Du"eum in @o"ton. T&e me'"ure i" b'"ed on t&e number o# in"t'nce" t&'t
"tudent" en+'+ed in t&e #o((o0in+ in t&eir e""'y"; ob"er!in+, inter)retin+, e!'(u'tin+, '""oci'tin+,
)rob(em #indin+, com)'rin+, 'nd #(e$ib(e t&in6in+. Our me'"ure o# critic'( t&in6in+ i" t&e "um o#
t&e count" o# t&e"e "e!en item". In tot'(, our re"e'rc& te'm b(ind(y "cored %,I11 e""'y". 2or F,E o#
t&o"e e""'y", t0o re"e'rc&er" "cored t&em inde)endent(y. T&e "core" t&ey '""i+ned to t&e "'me
e""'y 0ere !ery "imi('r, demon"tr'tin+ t&'t 0e 0ere 'b(e to me'"ure critic'( t&in6in+ 'bout 'rt 0it&
' &i+& de+ree o# inter1coder re(i'bi(ity.
8e e$)re"" t&e im)'ct o# ' "c&oo( tour o# Cry"t'( @rid+e" on critic'(1t&in6in+ "6i((" in term" o#
"t'nd'rd1de!i'tion e##ect "i:e". O!er'((, 0e #ind t&'t "tudent" '""i+ned by (ottery to ' tour o# t&e
mu"eum im)ro!e t&eir 'bi(ity to t&in6 critic'((y 'bout 'rt by J )ercent o# ' "t'nd'rd de!i'tion
re('ti!e to t&e contro( +rou). T&e bene#it #or di"'d!'nt'+ed +rou)" i" con"ider'b(y ('r+er K"ee 2i+ure
1C. .ur'( "tudent", 0&o (i!e in to0n" 0it& #e0er t&'n 1E,EEE )eo)(e, e$)erience 'n incre'"e in
critic'(1t&in6in+ "6i((" o# ne'r(y one1t&ird o# ' "t'nd'rd de!i'tion. Student" #rom &i+&1)o!erty
"c&oo(" Kt&o"e 0&ere more t&'n ,E )ercent o# "tudent" recei!e #ree or reduced1)rice (unc&e"C
e$)erience 'n 1I )ercent e##ect1"i:e im)ro!ement in critic'( t&in6in+ 'bout 'rt, '" do minority
"tudent".
.E2E.ENCE
1C Te'c&in+ o# "cience 1 Anu "oni
2C Te'c&in+ o# "cience 1 ..C.D'"
%C Te'c&in+ o# "cience 1S.. .Ao"&i
*C Te'c&in+ o# "cience 1 S.P.?u("&re"&t&'

You might also like