Diversity in School
Diversity in School
Chairs
Maria Luiza Heilborn & Srgio Carrara
Editorial Committee
Anna Paula Uziel
Jane Russo
Maria Luiza Heilborn
Srgio Carrara
Editor
Horacio Svori
Co-Editor
Bruno Zilli
This volume
Original in Portuguese
Gnero e Diversidade na Escola. Click here for full credits.
Translation
Alex Formam
Ana Catarina Lopes
Erica Lorraine Williams
Technical Supervision
Horacio Svori & Bruno Zilli | CLAM
Design
Nitadesign | Anna Amendola
5. Training.
Support:
Diversity in School
Diversity in School offers training on gender, sexuality, and ethnic (race) relations for
teaching professionals. The resource, originally delivered in Brazil, was the result of a
partnership between the Brazilian Governments Special Secretariat for Policies on
Women, the Special Secretariat for the Promotion of Policies on Racial Equality (SEPPIR/
PR), the Brazilian Ministry of Education, the British Council and the Latin American Centre
on Sexuality and Human Rights.
Diversity in School was successfully piloted in six cities in Brazil in 2006, involving
1,200 teachers. Since 2008, its contents have revised and expanded so as to make
the programme available in a distance learning format throughout the country and more
widely.
Reducing discrimination by improving understanding of gender, sexual, ethnic and racial
diversity is of central importance to the creation of a positive school learning environment.
Because of successful experience in Brazil, we feel that this translated resource has
potential value to teachers and teacher trainers/educators in many parts of the Englishspeaking world.
The course contents are offered here as an open-access online resource designed for
educators, teacher trainers and all those interested in addressing issues of Diversity in
School.
Introduction
Education, Difference,
Diversity, and Inequality
Across the globe, many people experience forms of discrimination and inequality as a
result of physical or social characteristics, or identities that are deemed to differ from
dominant societal norms. Very often, such prejudice is related to a persons gender, their
race, ethnicity and/or their sexuality. However, it is increasingly recognized that markers
of gender, race and sexuality are social constructions around which certain societal
values and expectations are organised. As such, there can be no universal agreement
or truth regarding what it means to be normal or to be different rather, such notions
result from norms and behaviours that differ from place to place.
In many countries, academic debate, policy-making and rights-focused activism have
tended to treat gender, sexuality, ethnicity and race as separate and distinct issues.
Diversity in School seeks to recognize not only the ways that these issues have evolved
over time, but also the ways in which they can intersect. One well recognized historical
illustration this relates to is Nazi Germany: while official discriminatory discourse related
largely to Jewish people, gypsies, homosexuals and others deemed racially or socially
inferior, it also had indirect implications for other social groups. The promotion of the
Aryan race for example, resulted in many women being excluded from public life as they
were expected to stay at home to raise racially pure children.
This synergy between racist, sexist, and homophobic attitudes and discourses is not
confined to such extremes but continues operating in our everyday lives. One, perhaps
banal, example is as follows: if in school a male student manifests signs of being gay,
it is likely that someone will call him girly or sissy. However, few people ask why
being called a woman should be offensive, or in what sense femininity is a negative
attribute. Such an example demonstrates how misogyny and homophobia reinforce one
another as discrimination towards women or femininity is fostered via discrimination
toward those who are attracted to people of the same sex. Similarly, racist discourse
frequently uses characteristics attributed to women to describe minority ethnic groups.
In such descriptions, individuals and indeed whole communities are seen as more
impressionable, short-sighted, out of control and impulsive and, being deemed closer
to nature, more in need of tutelage. Such discourse can result in people being treated
as dependents requiring protection and in people being unable to fully exercise their
political and human rights.
Diversity in School aims to increase understanding, recognition, respect and value of
peoples differences, enabling them to realise their full potential through the promotion
of a culture of inclussion for staff and students within schools and in the wider society.
If this programme contributes, even a little, to the education of a generation (or even a
small part of a generation) that understands the vital character of social difference, it will
have accomplished a significant amount of its objectives.
6
Introduction
Contents
This English language abridged version includes four modules. Topics addressed include
cultural diversity and ethnocentrism; gender diversity; sexuality and sexual orientation;
and ethnic inequality. The first introductory module familiarizes the reader with diversity
as a core concept. Each of the following modules is divided into three sections. The
first section introduces a general concept; the second one addresses that concept in
the school environment, and the third section provides classroom activities to share
Diversity in School with students.
Table of contents
Diversity in School 05
Education, Difference, Diversity, and Inequality
Module
06
References 16
Activities to encourage an understanding of diversity
17
30
References 36
Activities to encourage a better understanding of gender
37
Table of contents
Module
References
53
54
References 65
Activities to encourage a
better understanding of race and ethnicity 66
Ourselves and others 66
Racism is it history? 67
Role-reversal 67
Ethnic and racial stereotyping 68
Glossary 69
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
Understanding diversity
Different - but equal
In recent decades, many countries have promoted themselves as nations of diversity.
However, while diversity within nations is often celebrated, it is not always viewed as
beneficial by all within a given society. In many cases, differences amongst people
become synonymous with perceived defects in relation to the dominant standards, or
parameters of normalcy which underpin culture and society. Thus, seemingly positive
discussions or statements relating to difference are very often counterbalanced or offset
by more negative statements.
Understanding culture
Throughout history, people across the world have formed communities in which dominant
ideas emerge to shape the social values, norms and expectations which underpin their
lives. However, culture is neither static nor homogenous, but manifests itself and evolves
in different ways over time and space. For example, the status of young people and
in particular, women, has significantly changed and in many areas has improved over
time. Similarly, the values and processes underpinning marriage have in many places
altered. Although once based primarily upon reciprocal obligations and ties between
families, individual choice and the desires of the couple have, in many places, now taken
precedence over more traditional values.
10
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
In all societies there exists a nucleus of conservative resistance against any kind of
change. However, the idea of tradition, like that of progress, should be interpreted within
the context in which it is produced: it is a value of a particular culture. Across the world,
processes of globalization have meant that traditions, values and norms are constantly
reinvented and redefined as they interact and blend with other cultures. Globalization is,
11
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
for some people, seen as synonymous with Westernisation. However, many examples
demonstrate that as societies become more deeply inter-linked, the situation is more
complex than a simple, unidirectional flow of ideas, products and cultures from the
Global North to the Global South.
This complexity is evident in the capacity for resistance demonstrated by indigenous
groups. Rather than passively accept the elements and values imposed upon them,
people adapt and appropriate those elements of Western society that they consider to
have meaning and value whilst at the same time, rejecting others.
Ethnocentrism, stereotypes,
stigma and discrimination
Ethnocentrism involves judging another culture relative to the values and standards of
ones own expectations and norms. In so doing, ones own culture is normalized and
considered superior over others. Ethnocentrism is therefore closely intertwined with
stereotyping and prejudice. One example of ethnocentrism relates to the appearance
that is deemed normal and acceptable within society. Many indigenous people adorn
themselves with body painting, piercing and ornamentation. Yet because they do not
wear garments and clothing that are considered conventional, representations of these
people - particularly within the Western media - tend to portray them as naked, and in
turn, to either romanticize them as being at one with nature, or portray them as lacking
in moral decency.
Ethnocentrism depends on judgment. What is right and what is wrong, ugly or pretty,
normal or abnormal, is based in ones own cultural standards and behaviour. Generalizing
and attributing (usually negative) values to the characteristics of other groups of people
can also lead to stereotyping and, in turn, can play a role in defining power relations and
influencing prejudice and discrimination.
Stereotyping can relate to a wide range of physical and behavioural characteristics
and can have significant and far reaching influences on peoples everyday lives. Such
influences were particularly evident during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries,
where the process of naturalizing and biologizing differences of ethnicity, race, gender,
or sexual orientation, proved a central influence over the rights accorded to, and the
restrictions placed upon, women, non-whites and non-heterosexuals. Anthropometric
techniques for example, were developed during European colonial expansion, with the
aim of categorizing non-white people as socially and physically inferior. Similarly, in many
countries, one justification used for delaying the right to vote to women was the idea
that their brains were smaller and less developed than those of men. Homosexuality,
12
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
in turn, was seen as an anomaly of nature that in many places required punishment and
correction.
The concept of stigma was defined by the North-American sociologist Erving Goffman
(1990) as a negative social attribute associated with deviance from the norm. This
social attribute is incorporated by people and groups who are discriminated against, for
different reasons, including sexual ones. Besides homosexuality, other forms of stigma
are associated with poverty, dark skin colour, certain medical conditions (mental illness,
for example), old age and so-called physical disability. The production of stigma can
only be understood within wider relations of power and dominance (Parker & Aggleton,
2003). Stigmatized identities lead to differences being transformed into inequalities
based on class, age, race or ethnicity, gender or sexual orientation and physical capacity.
Many countries have laws and regulations to promote social equality and to punish
discriminatory practices. While such measures constitute a positive step towards
respecting diversity and upholding human rights, implementing such legislation is often
complicated. It is crucial therefore that society itself undergoes a process of transformation
to embody diversity. Communities across the world must move beyond dealing with
different people and cultures as a gesture of goodness, patience, acceptance and
tolerance of the others purported inferiority. It is of extreme importance that the right to
ones beliefs, the right to ones physical differences, behaviours, and values be respected,
without threat to human dignity.
Diversity in schools:
facing discrimination and promoting equality
In all societies, a range of institutions play a role in establishing and upholding societal
norms. Schools are one type of institution in which societal norms are reproduced,
with staff and students often encouraged to adapt to dominant notions of normalcy
regardless of their backgrounds and identities. Thus, for example, boys and men may
be encouraged to be macho, while girls and women may be praised for their femininity.
Within the classroom, the repetition of images, languages, stories, and antipathy towards
abnormal behaviours or identities (such as being left-handed or, in the case of boys,
being effeminate, for instance) have in many cases, been used to uphold and reinforce
societal norms, whilst antagonizing and punishing difference (often considered as
defects).
Although many teachers recognize the existence of discrimination within and beyond
the school walls, some believe that it is better to remain silent, fearing that to speak
out may result in reprisal and ultimately, further increase prejudice and discrimination.
13
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
Until schools offer concrete possibilities for legitimizing diversity - in speech, in text
books, in the images distributed in classroom activities, etc. - students are often left with
little choice but to repress important aspects of their selves in an attempt to adapt to
norms and expectations, or to rebel against them, and in turn, risk being categorized as
disruptive and deviant, with likely adverse consequences for their educational success.
Importantly, however, schools are also uniquely positioned to challenge the status quo,
and, in so doing, seek to confront and even overturn various forms of prejudice and
discrimination. In fulfilling their responsibility to educate citizens, schools are ideally
placed to offer mechanisms that enable students and staff to recognize, understand,
respect, value and promote cultural diversity. According to Mary Garcia Castro, a
UNESCO researcher,
teachers must be motivated to be alert, to teach citizenship and diversity
in every encounter, whether inside or outside the classroom, in a vigilant
anti-racist, anti-sexist, [anti-homophobic] manner and to respect childrens
and adolescents rights as they are and as they are becoming; not allowing
stigmatizing jokes or pejorative treatment to take place (). The racism, sexism,
[homophobia] and adultism in us operates in subtle ways; not necessarily
intentional or noticed. But it hurts nevertheless, and the recipients suffer these
violent acts, which mark their victims in an indelible way. The victims are all of
us in some ways, but always some more than others, women, black people,
the youngest and the poorest (Castro, 2005)
Education is a key determinant of chances and opportunities. And creating an inclusive
learning environment, which values and respects diversity and equality, is central to an
individuals progression and success. That is why the Diversity in School programme
promotes mainstreaming diversity within the school environment. Rather than considering
it an individual issue requiring sporadic attention, this means the promotion of diversity as
a central feature of all educational activities, including curriculum design, development
and delivery.
Mainstreaming diversity is, therefore, an interdisciplinary task, for which all educators
are responsible - every area of knowledge can and should contribute to unveiling the
realities of discrimination, whether through the re-reading of history, through statistical
analysis, or through the critical review of literature and the inclusion of authors often
excluded because of their identity or point of view. A central part of mainstreaming
involves developing pedagogic approaches that enable staff and students to: a) learn to
listen and to respect other people; b) learn to evaluate arguments and situations; c) learn
to communicate different perspectives; d) learn to work in a team.
The modules which comprise the Diversity in School programme are intended to
encourage teachers to reflect upon the forms of gender, sexual, ethnic and racial
14
Section 1 Module 1
Understanding diversity
prejudice and discrimination present within their school environment. Module 2 examines
gender stereotyping and critically reflects on the ways that social constructions of
gender can influence and be influenced by the school learning environment. Focusing
on concepts of sexuality, sexual orientation, and homophobia, Module 3 examines
the ways in which hetero-normative understandings and ideas can be challenged and
the implications of these issues for teachers and students. Module 4 focuses on the
concept of ethnocentrism and, using Brazilian examples, demonstrates how ethnic and
racial discrimination can be challenged within and beyond the school environment.
All modules aim to help teachers to identify how the school itself may contribute to
upholding and reproducing inequality through, for example, the teaching materials used,
the images displayed, as well as the kinds of attitudes and norms promoted by teachers
and school authorities. Importantly, the programme also provides suggestions not only
on how teachers can challenge discrimination, but also on how they can be actively
involved in the promotion of diversity and inclusion within their school.
15
Module 1
References
References
CASTRO, M.G. (2005). Gnero e Raa: desafios escola. [Gender and Race:
Challenges to the School System] In: Santana, M.O. (Ed.) Lei 10.639/03 - Educao
das relaes tnico-raciais e para o ensino da histria e cultura afro-brasileira e
africana na educao fundamental. Pasta de Texto da Professora e do Professor.
[Teaching ethno-racial relations for the study of African and Afro-Brazilian history
and culture in basic education. Teacher Guides]. Salvador: Prefeitura Municipal de
Salvador.
GOFFMAN, E. (1990 [1963]). Stigma: notes on the management of spoiled identity.
Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.
PARKER, R. & AGGLETON, P. (2003). HIV and AIDS-related stigma and discrimination:
a conceptual framework and implications for action. Social Science & Medicine,
Volume 57, Issue 1, Pages 1324.
16
Activities Module 1
to encourage an understanding of diversity
Activities to encourage an
understanding of diversity
Acknowledging
1 discrimination in school
Activity
17
Activities Module 1
to encourage an understanding of diversity
Discrimination:
2 If you dont speak out, who will?
Activity
they felt or witnessed prejudice and discrimination. Talk about the feelings and
reactions that these situations triggered (students do not have to describe
the situation itself).
Ask students to work in groups to choose one non-governmental organisation
or campaigning group that provides support to victims of gender, ethnic or
sexual discrimination. Encourage students to collect as much information on
the organisation as possible. The research can be done using the internet
but, where possible, you can also suggest that students visit some of the
organisations or projects.
Encourage groups to design a poster detailing the
work of their chosen organisation or network. This information can then be
displayed for the whole school to see and could become part of a schoolwide campaign against discrimination.
FOLLOW-UP ACTIVITY:
18
Activities Module 1
to encourage an understanding of diversity
Stories
3 of resistance
Activity
Building
4 networks
Activity
FOLLOW-UP ACTIVITIES: At the end of the term or school year, students should
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
social behaviour is relatively weak. Instead, they argue, it is culture rather than biology
that makes our species human.
In her book, The Second Sex, the philosopher and feminist Simone de Beauvoir argues
that women have long been defined as other in relation to the male norm, and that this
assertion of difference has led to, and helped to fuel, patriarchal gender relations. Stating
that one is not born a woman, one becomes a woman, de Beauvoir challenged any
natural determination of feminine behaviour. Instead she argued, the way in which men
and women behave in society is the result of socio-cultural conditioning that teaches us
to act according to gender specific prescriptions. There are strong social expectations
regarding how men and women
should behave when walking,
speaking, dancing, making love
and caring for others, as well as
how they should think and interact.
merican anthropologist MarDespite this work, it is still often
believed that there is a type of
personality or behaviour pattern
that is inherently associated with
each sex. In Western culture, for
example, it is generally supposed
that the men are more aggressive
than women.
The latter are
assumed to be more caring and
compassionate. Commonly, the
reproductive role played by women
has led to them being considered
closer to nature than men, and has
linked them with the private sphere
of the home. Men on the other
hand, are usually thought to be
more closely associated with the
outside public world.
Cultures therefore create norms
and expectations that are strongly
associated with male and female
bodies. However, it is important
to recognise that not everyone is
the same. Having a female body,
for example, does not in itself
mean that a woman wishes to be
21
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
a mother. Similarly, bodies designated as male may express gestures seen as feminine
in certain social contexts. They can also have sexual relations with other male bodies
signalling a type of sexuality that goes against expectations that relations between men
and women should be the norm.
Sexuality and gender are different dimensions that contribute to the personal identity
of each individual. Both originate, are affected by, and change according to the social
values in force at a certain point in time. Thus, they are part of culture, helping to organise
peoples individual and collective lives. In short, it is culture that constructs gender,
branding some activities as masculine and others as feminine.
Cultural arbitrariness, that is, the fact that gender can only be
understood in relation to a specific culture, because it can have a
different meaning according to the socio-cultural context in which it
manifests itself.
Individuals are not defined by gender alone, but by a range of other factors including
race, ethnicity, sexuality, age and social class. Together, these interact to influence the
mode and degree of inequality and discrimination that an individual may experience.
In many places, for example, a black working-class man will be judged differently (possibly
disadvantageously) in relation to a white middle class woman. At the same time, a white
middle class woman may be treated differently to a white middle class man. Thus the
relative disadvantage of gender is likely to be influenced by co-existing factors such as
race and class, and to worsen when gender is combined with ethnic, racial or sexual
discrimination.
As work within the social sciences has highlighted in recent decades, social constructions
of sexual or gendered behaviour considered normal, correct or superior over others
exist in all societies. Prejudice, inequality and discrimination may be experienced by
22
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
those who do not adhere to such norms. Understanding gender therefore helps us look
deeper at the processes underpinning the value differences that generate inequalities
between men and women.
Throughout the rest of the module, try to reflect on the norms and expectations that are
placed upon men and upon women in your own society. Think about how these norms
may lead to unequal power relations and gender inequalities. Then think about how these
inequalities are reinforced through our daily activities, our attitudes and our actions.
TOTAL
MEN
WOMEN
TOTAL
MEN
WOMEN
4 years or less
67.9
47
89
21.8
10.6
27.8
5-8 years
72.1
51.3
92.3
20.1
9.7
25.8
9-11 years
73.3
52.5
92.8
19.8
9.9
25.1
12 years +
73
54
88.7
18.1
9.2
22.6
23
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
The same research found that the allocation of domestic chores is not restricted to a
particular class or group, but takes place across people from all social and educational
backgrounds. For a great many women across the world, housework is an extra duty that
is rarely given much recognition, only noted in its absence when chores are not done.
Such an example demonstrates how cultural and social norms and expectations can fuel,
and be fuelled by, relations of power. While men and boys can and do face disadvantage,
experiences from across the world demonstrate that inequalities are more predominantly
experienced amongst women and girls. Even within households, it is often reported that
it is men who are accorded the highest status, whilst women are considered lower in the
social hierarchy.
It is important to ask ourselves why this situation has arisen, and to examine the social
constructions of gender that continue to uphold such power relations.
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
in many parts of the world now face a double day of labour as they struggle to combine
paid and domestic duties.
Changes in attitudes and processes of globalisation have meant that the presence of
women in the global labour market is now significant. However, women continue to
suffer many forms of discrimination compared to men. The historical exclusion of women
from the public sphere has in many places left a legacy in which sharp divisions of labour
and associated inequalities persist.
Reports that compare the position of men and women in the labour
market often point to the following inequalities:
A large portion of top management is occupied by men (including
within the education sector).
Men tend to earn significantly more than women.
Greater concentrations of men in areas such as engineering and IT,
while women tend to work in lower paid activities such as education
and care.
While it may seem that choices or modes of access to the labour market mirror what are
perceived as natural preferences and variations in aptitudes and skills between men and
women, their distribution in the labour market and the resulting inequalities associated
with this can in large part be attributed to socially constructed expectations and norms
regarding what it means to be a man or a woman.
In many societies, for example, it is expected that boys with low levels of educational
attainment will work in construction, transport, or agriculture, or follow a career in the
military. In general, girls in the same educational situation are expected to work as
secretaries, caterers, receptionists or telemarketing operators, or to undertake domestic
or caring roles. Even among young people who manage to get a university degree,
it is very often the case that women enter careers linked to the social sciences and
humanities (education, language and literature, history and the arts), as well as caring
professions (nursing, occupational therapy, speech therapy, nutrition).
While in most countries an increasing number of women can nowadays be found
studying courses such as law, engineering and architecture, such subjects still tend to be
dominated by, and generally perceived as the realm of men. Even in contexts where there
is a strong presence of both men and women, gendered norms often continue to dictate
the roles that each will play. In a bank or supermarket for example, male employees can
25
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
often be found in managerial and security roles, whilst women are usually more likely to
work in catering and routine administrative roles.
Education
Education is another important area in which gender inequalities are evident. Prioritising
the education of boys over girls was and in cases remains, a commonly accepted norm
within many cultures. In countries such as the UK and Brazil, for example, it was only
at the end of the nineteenth century that the government opened up higher education
to women. In other cultures, the education of boys continues to be prioritised as men
are considered to have the greatest future potential as household breadwinners. In
some contexts, changing attitudes and attempts to meet universal targets such as the
Millennium Development Goals1 have led to a recent surge in the educational enrolment
of girls.
26
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
It was only from the 1960s that feminism began to analyze the construction of womens
place in society and to challenge the notion that womens primary role was to reproduce.
Translated in the motto our bodies, our business, the feminist movement has since
attempted to ensure that women are able to access contraception and abortion, and
thus assert some level of control over their sexual and reproductive lives.
Political participation
Although women represent over half of the global population, in all countries of the
world they are under-represented in positions of government and policy making. A 2006
report by the Inter-parliamentary Union found that Rwanda had the highest level of female
participation in government with 48% of parliament members being women. The Nordic
countries, known for their gender equality are also positioned near the top of the ranking:
Sweden (45.3%) in second place; Norway (37.9%) in third place; Finland (37.5%) in
fourth; and Denmark (36.9%) in fifth. Other countries that have relatively high female
participation in government include Holland (36.7%). Cuba (36%), Spain (36%), Costa
Rica (35.1%), Argentina (35%) and Mozambique (34.8%).
Elsewhere however, the picture is not so positive. The USA is below the world average
of 16.6% at 15.2%, while in Brazil the figure is only 8.8%, and in some countries in
the Middle East the figure is less than 7%. The Inter-parliamentary Union reports some
improvement in countries minimum quotas for female candidates have been introduced,
as has been the case in Argentina, Bolivia and Venezuela (Abdela & Boman, 2010).
Credit has also been given to countries such as Afghanistan, Burundi, Iraq and Liberia
where progress in female participation has been made despite recent and large scale
conflict. There has also been an overall increase in female participation in government,
and in 20 parliaments around the world, women already occupy 30% of the seats.
However, the same report emphasises that the aim of achieving a minimum of 30% of
women legislators worldwide a target originally set at the UN Womens Conference in
1995 still remains distant.
Gender-based violence
Gender-based violence is caused by prejudice and inequality between and amongst
men and women. Research has found that boys and men tend to be most exposed to
violence in the public sphere, while girls and women tend to suffer more violence within
the household.
27
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
Section 1 Module 2
Gender and diversity
situations where women have little independence and have to rely on men for finances
and key resources such as land. In cases, women e.g. mothers-in-law, are themselves
implicated in this violence either through their participation in it, or through their tacit
acceptance of the ongoing violence that is perpetrated.
Many countries have policies to protect women from violence and to persecute offenders.
However, in practice, a range of factors make these policies difficult to enforce. For many
women, reporting such violence means not only risking the loss of their family, their
husband, their home and/or their assets but also the public shame and humiliation that
they may have to endure where health, legal and police services question their claims or
provide ineffective support.
Challenging forms of gender-based violence has long formed a central axis in progressive
politics. Understanding the social mores which uphold domestic and familial violence
against women is an important starting point for tackling such discrimination and
inequality.
29
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
men [ ]
30
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
men [ ]
men [ ]
11. Do the men and women featured in the text contribute significantly? How?
12. What role models are presented for girls, boys, women and men?
14. Are there specific sections that deal solely with women or particular ethnicities?
If so, how are social minorities approached?
15. How can this text influence the aspirations of girls and boys in relation to
education and profession?
16. Write a one page summary of the book or material under analysis. Discuss
whether or not it should be adopted and why.
31
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
Gendered assumptions may also be made by teachers with respect to the behaviour and
aspirations of students. Such assumptions can in turn influence the way that girls and
boys are treated, and the opportunities that are made available to them. The following
table illustrates some of the characteristics commonly associated with girls and boys in
the classroom.
Girls
Self-assured
One example which demonstrates such gendered assumptions can be seen in the way
that teachers particularly in junior schools may organise students in their classroom.
Where teachers assume that boys are rowdier than girls, for example, they may alternate
the seating of boys and girls to encourage good behaviour. Alternatively, they may
divide students into groups based on gender. These kinds of assumptions influence
student performance, with girls feeling that they are expected to remain quiet and not
ask questions and boys feeling pressured to be rowdy and disruptive. Girls may also be
asked to carry out organisational and care-based tasks within the classroom, and this
again can reinforce gender stereotypes.
Language can be a shrewd and effective way of creating and upholding differences and
unequal power relations. Because of this, it is important that teachers pay attention to
language use within the classroom between themselves and students, within learning
materials used, and amongst students themselves. That way, it may be possible to
challenge the sexism, racism and ethnocentrism with which language is often imbued.
It is also important to consider whose voices are dominant within the classroom and
how this may also influence relationships between students. In classrooms where boys
voices dominate, some girls may feel too intimidated to contribute to learning activities.
32
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
At the same time, teachers may find that they interact and give disproportionate attention
to the more outspoken students, whilst giving less attention to those who are quiet and
do not speak out.
Gender inequalities in schools are evident not only in the pedagogical approaches
employed within the classroom, but also in more informal play and leisure activities. At
first sight, it may seem that the playground offers a gender neutral environment since
boys and girls are usually able to mix more freely and independently than when being
taught inside the classroom. However, a closer look will often reveal that spaces of play
and leisure are also gendered in line with dominant notions of masculinity and femininity.
In most school playgrounds, some activities are undertaken by both boys and girls. In
games such as hide and seek, the activity may not be particularly gendered. But in other
activities such as those based on gender-divided team games, gender differences may
be reinforced. Other activities are very strongly inclined towards either boys or girls. For
example, while girls may spend time walking around chatting in pairs or groups, boys
may be more likely to be involved in activities like football or sport. When girls and boys
want to play in ways typical of the opposite sex, such behaviours may be considered
as unnatural by teachers and other students, and may in turn lead to name-calling,
exclusion and other forms of discrimination.
Sexual relationships
While masculine and feminine norms and expectations are embedded during childhood,
their influence is particularly evident when young people initiate sexual relationships.
Such experiences are mediated by gendered expectations regarding the way that young
women and young men should behave. Common expectations in this respect are:
Girls and young women
These models of sexual behaviour can have adverse effects when boys and girls do
not fit the gender stereotypes. Any deviation in conduct risks being severely criticized,
33
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
with girls being labelled as whores and wanton if they are perceived to have an active
sexual life. At the same time, however, girls who do attempt to meet gendered norms may
be labelled as frigid, butch or nuns, particularly by their male peers.
Despite these gendered expectations, research in many places has found that girls tend
to engage in sexual activity at an earlier age than boys. Where teachers consider that this
goes against societal norms of acceptability, girls may be considered as reckless and
immoral. In such cases, they are likely to be blamed for risking detrimental consequences
to their studies by pregnancy or sexually transmitted infections. As well as verbal abuse
from fellow students and teachers, in some countries young women may be forced out
of school once their pregnancy is known about, with few options made available to
continue their education. Such attitudes not only discriminate against girls and young
women, they also fail to recognise the value that pregnancy may hold for them. Research
has found, for example, that for many young women, particularly those from relatively
poor socio-economic backgrounds, pregnancy and motherhood hold deep symbolic
value, and can provide young women with status, respect and the possibility of marriage
and security that they would not otherwise have. (Heilborn et al., 2006)
Section 2 Module 2
Gender and diversity within schools
poorly in school. Alternatively, children may copy the violent gestures they have seen at
home within their peer groups. By being aware of these issues, teachers are well placed
to provide pastoral and academic support, and to act to prevent forms of bullying and
violence which may result from them.
35
Module 2
References
References
ABDELA, L. AND BOMAN, A. (2010). Review of Inter Parliamentary Unions gender
programme Gender Equality in Politics InDevelop IMP.
AUAD, D. (2006) Educar meninas e meninos. Relaes de gnero na escola. [Educating
Boys and Girls: gender relations in school]. So Paulo: Editora Contexto.
BEAUVOIR, S. (2011) The Second Sex. New York: Random House, Vintage Series.
BELOTTI, E.G. (1985). Educar para a submisso. [Educating for submission]. Petrpolis:
Vozes.
FERRARI, A. (2003). Esses alunos desumanos: a construo das identidades
homossexuais na escola. [Inhuman students: the construction of homosexual
identities in school]. Educao e Realidade, Porto Alegre, v.1, n.28, p.87-111, jan./
jul..
HEILBORN et al. (ed.) (2006). O aprendizado da sexualidade: reproduo e trajetrias
sociais de jovens brasileiros. [Bringing up sexuality: reproduction and social
trajectories among young Brazilians]. Rio de Janeiro: Garamond e Fiocurz.
MEAD, M. (1935). Sex and temperament in three primitive societies. New York: W.
Morrow & Co.
SOARES, C. & SABOIA A.L. (2007). Tempo, trabalho e afazeres domsticos: um
estudo com base na Pesquisa Nacional por Amostra de Domiclios de 2001 a
2005. [Time, work and domestic tasks: a study based on the National Research
by Household Sample from 2001 to 2005]. Coordenao de Populao e
Indicadores Sociais, Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatstica (IBGE). Rio de
Janeiro: IBGE.
36
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Activity
37
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Challenging
2 gender norms
Activity
show the students the film, or selected clips from it. Ask them to
consider the following:
ACTIVITY:
38
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Gender
3 and relationships
Activity
The aim of this activity is to encourage students to reflect on the ways gender
can influence social expectations and norms regarding sexual relationships.
ACTIVITY:
A female student went out with three different classmates during one term
and was heavily criticised by fellow students. One day, as she walked to
school, she saw her name together with an insult graffitied on the wall. At
around the same time, other girls started avoiding her, laughing at her and
whispering when she was around.
A male student of the same school also dated three classmates in one term,
but he was not criticised. Instead, his classmates considered him a hero, and
nicknamed him Tiger as a compliment. He also noticed that girls started to
look at him in admiration.
Ask students to discuss the following:
What do you think about these two situations?
Why do you think that the boy and the girl were treated in different
ways?
How do you think that each person felt about this treatment? How do
you think this might influence their attitudes towards future relationships
and their self respect?
39
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Pandoras
4 box
Activity
PREPARATION :
40
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Gender
5 and the media
Activity
PREPARATION : Ask the class to select adverts from television and magazines
that sell products using the body and sexuality. Get them to bring examples
to the class.
ACTIVITY: Get students to work in groups or pairs. Distribute the adverts and
ask groups to identify the ways that women and men are portrayed in them.
Ask them to discuss the following:
Why did you choose this advert?
What products are being sold and who is the target audience?
How are women and men portrayed in the advert? What kinds of
images and language are being used?
Is there a sexual/erotic element? If so, why do you think this element
was chosen?
What links are established between the product and the target
gender? Can you identify discrimination or gender stereotyping?
Reflect on the ways that advertising sells ideas, and can reinforce gender
stereotypes.
41
Activities Module 2
to encourage a better understanding of gender
Teenage
6 pregnancy
Activity
ACTIVITY:
42
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
43
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
Despite this holistic approach, there remains a common belief that the body and by
extension, sexuality is the most natural and primal expression of our being, as gendered
people. Nowadays, it is also recognized that desire and the search for pleasure, as well
as the need to share intimacy and affection, are intrinsic to all human beings. However,
while these needs relate to the privacy and wellbeing of each individual, their expression
is constantly subjected to public scrutiny, as social norms influence the kinds of sexuality
that are perceived as normal and those that are not.
In most societies, the union of a man and a woman is considered the sexual norm. Yet
while heterosexual relationships are often considered to be right and normal, bodies,
desires, feelings and behaviours are not convergent and do not necessarily correspond
to these expectations. For example, a man may be masculine and still feel sexual desire
for another man. A woman may feel feminine and yet be attracted to other woman.
Someone who is born with masculine bodily attributes and is raised to act as a man may
feel feminine (or vice-versa), to the extent that he wants to change his body to become
as womanly (or as manly) as those who had that gender attributed to them at birth.
Sexuality, contrary to what many people think, is not a question of instincts dominated
by nature, impulses, genes or hormones. Neither is it limited to the bodily possibilities
of experiencing pleasure and affection. Whilst the importance of the bodys physiology
has some influence on what is possible in terms of sexuality, biological preconditions
do not in themselves produce sexual behaviours, gender identity or sexual orientation.
They make up a set of potentialities that only acquire meaning through socialization and
learning of cultural rules.
Sexuality, like gender, is therefore, above all, a social construct. Understanding our
sexuality involves a continuous and non-linear process of learning and reflecting, through
which we develop a perception of who we are. This is a process that unfolds in specific
historical, social and cultural conditions, and is influenced by factors such as class,
ethnicity/race, gender, and age. Peoples experiences of, and attitudes regarding
sexuality are also moulded alongside other experiences, including the social groups
that they identify with, where they live and the kind of community that they are a part of.
That is why expressions of human sexuality are so diverse and manifest themselves in
different ways throughout ones life.
There are also opportunities and challenges that are specific to each era. As we saw
earlier, the discovery of the contraceptive pill, for example, had a great impact on the
society of the day. In recent decades, the repercussions of HIV and AIDS and the
emergence of assisted reproductive technologies (artificial insemination, etc.) have
influenced the affective and sexual behaviour and attitudes of todays young people. These
events have changed sexual and romantic relationships, with values and experiences
differing between men and women and between people of different sexual orientations.
44
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
some
termi
nology
Sexual
orientation
Sexual orientation refers to the sex of the persons who we view as objects of desire and
affection. Three major types of sexual orientation are generally recognized: heterosexuality
(emotional, sexual and erotic attraction by persons of the opposite sex); homosexuality
(emotional, sexual and erotic attraction by persons of the same sex) and bisexuality
(emotional, sexual and erotic attraction both to persons of the same and the opposite sex).
In many cases, a persons sexual orientation becomes fixed at a certain point in their
life. However, for others sexual orientation may be more fluid and may change over time
and space. Many people for example, come to realize they are gay/lesbian only as
mature or elderly persons. Often, social pressures suffered at the start of their emotional
life lead them to establish heterosexual relations during their youth. After achieving a
certain degree of stability and independence, they recognise their gay/lesbian identity.
Today, there is a consensus among scientists that sexual orientation is made up of
at least three dimensions: desire, behaviour and identity. When we talk about sexual
identity, we refer to two different things:
1. The way a person perceives themselves in terms of sexual orientation; and
2. The way a person makes public (or does not) that perception of themselves in
certain environments and situations.
Importantly, sexual desire, behaviour and identity do not necessarily take the same
form or follow the same direction. Thus, there is no direct connection between the
desire a person feels, their sexual behaviour and the way they perceive themselves. For
example, it is possible for someone to have sex with someone of the same sex without
that person perceiving themselves to be gay/lesbian or bisexual. It is also possible to
have same-sex desires without participating in same-sex sexual relations.5
For example, there are men who have sex with other men, sometimes for money or
other kinds of rewards who, independently of the sexual role they play, see themselves
as simply men, not as homosexuals or gays. In certain environments, to go out with a
person of the same sex does not necessarily imply the commitment to a fixed sexual
identity (such as gay, lesbian or bisexual). Even between men and women who experience
homosexuality as a crucial and distinctive aspect of their lives, there is a great diversity of
denominations, representations and identities regarding lifestyles, aesthetic preferences,
body image, age and generation, class, religion, ethnicity/race and gender.
5. The US biologist Alfred Kinsey argued that there was a continuous gradation of human sexuality, from exclusive
heterosexuality to exclusive homosexuality, with a wide range of variations. To learn more about this, follow the link.
Film suggestion: Kinsey, about the life of Alfred Kinsey and the impact of his research on sexual behaviour of NorthAmerican men and women.
45
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
1.
2.
3.
4.
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
Section 1 Module 3
Sexuality and sexual orientation
48
Section 2 Module 3
Sexuality in school
Sexuality in school
HIV and teenage pregnancy have put sexuality on the agenda of educational policy and
curriculum reform in many countries. Recognition of the importance of sexuality has also
given rise to discussion of a number of more personal matters such as self-esteem and
respect, solidarity, and respect for diversity and difference. At the same time, however,
the models of behaviour promoted and transmitted through schools also embody many
of the prejudices and inequalities prevalent within society, and confer legitimacy on them
through institutional weight and collective sanction.
Even where education about sexuality and relationships is not part of the school
curriculum, sexuality is present in a variety of forms in school life: in presuppositions
about family constitution and the roles of men and women; in school books and in
pedagogic practices; in toilet and desk graffiti; in insinuating looks; in love notes and
malicious messages; in games, jokes and nicknames that stigmatize delicate boys and
the forward girls, etc. This section therefore encourages teachers to adopt a critical
view of the ways in which sexuality is approached in their school. In so doing, teachers
are encouraged to consider the prejudices and the inequalities that may exist and to
develop initiatives to challenge such discrimination.
Discrimination at school
For many young people, adolescence is a time to establish romantic and sexual
relationships. In most schools, however, messages which promote a heterosexual norm
are upheld, whilst other forms of sexuality are given little attention, or are represented
as being abnormal and problematic. Such attitudes can have adverse impacts upon the
wellbeing and freedom of expression of students who do not fit in with the heterosexual
norm. For example, while young people who identify as heterosexual may feel able to
express their sexual orientation at ease, same sex attracted young people may feel
that they have to keep their sexual orientation hidden so that they are not discriminated
against.
Homophobia is widespread in many school environments. As indicated earlier, many
young people report being marginalized by teachers and other students because of their
sexuality. Teachers may also be the victims of this type of discrimination. It is important
to recognize that homophobia does not impact only on those whose gender expression
is different from the expected norm but on all children and young people who fear the
consequences of being labeled lesbian or gay.
49
Section 2 Module 3
Sexuality in school
Expulsion from school due to sexual orientation has also been reported. In such cases,
the individual concerned may be viewed as a risk that might contaminate other people.
Such cases demonstrate how those who are discriminated against are often seen
as being responsible for their own circumstances, and are expected to change their
behaviour in order to solve the problem.
Homophobia is not only reported amongst students but also amongst some teachers.
It may also constitute the prevailing ethos of a school. Sometimes schools are anxious
that sexuality education may lead young people into behaviours that are condemned and
contrary to healthy development. Teachers and parents may feel that children and young
people should not be taught about sexual diversity and sexual and reproductive rights.
However, denying students education about sexuality and refusing to engage with these
issues can contribute significantly to the perpetuation of prejudice, discrimination and
inequality.
50
Section 2 Module 3
Sexuality in school
Tackling sexuality-related
discrimination in schools
In order to understand how homophobia may be reinforced at school,
more of the following activities :
try one or
heteronormativity.
How is heteronormativity upheld within your school? Which sexualities
may be legitimately talked about and practiced? Which ones may not,
and why this is?
4. Research
people believe that young people are not old enough to identify
Why might this be? What kind of power relations are at play in such
assumptions?
6. Think
51
Section 2 Module 3
Sexuality in school
However, for many young people, school may be the only place where they feel able to
openly discuss sexuality-related concerns. Because of this, it is important that teachers
seek to establish a dialogue with students that goes beyond restrictive and moralizing
approaches to reproductive health issues. Key areas for discussion include sexual
diversity, pleasure, emotional involvement, expectations, fears, entertainment, questions,
and respect for sexual diversity. In order to be effective, this dialogue should be nonjudgmental and should promote reflexivity in order to empower young people as individuals
capable of making their own decisions, and who are aware of their possibilities in life,
their rights and responsibilities, and social change.
For maximum effectiveness, it is also important that sexual education is not confined
to biology and science lessons, but is introduced or mainstreamed across a variety of
subject areas. History teachers, for example, can encourage students to examine sexual
behaviour as influenced by political, cultural and economic factors in different eras. Art
teachers could stimulate enquiry into the ways in which sexuality and sexual diversity
have been, and are, represented through different forms of artistic expression.
There are also more subtle ways in which a school may seek to encourage students to
engage with issues of sexuality. The type of teaching and learning materials used for
example, can send messages to students which may uphold or challenge dominant
norms. In most schools, text books reinforce conventional images of sexuality, while not
even acknowledging other forms of sexual orientation or gender identity. Teachers may
therefore seek to find or develop alternative materials which engage positively with sexual
diversity. While such materials may prove controversial amongst parents and students, the
possibility of some negative reactions should not justify inertia or omission. If teachers do
not use their skills and experience to engage creatively and constructively with sexuality,
they will contribute to the continuing legitimization of prejudice, discrimination, gender
hierarchy and homophobic violence in school.
It is important for teachers to feel supported in their work and for relevant training and
ongoing encouragement to be provided. Good quality education about sexuality will
have repercussions not only for young people but also for colleagues, parents and
community and religious leaders. Because of this, it is recommended that schools seek
to build a local support network for this type of work, which includes representatives
from civil society, government bodies and religious institutions who can help add weight
and legitimacy to the task.
52
Module 3
References
References
BRIZTMAN, D. (1996). O que essa coisa chamada amor: identidade homossexual,
educao e currculo. Educao e Realidade. [What is this thing called love:
homosexual identity, education and curriculum. Education and Reality]. Porto
Alegre, v. 21, n. 1, Jan./July.
CARRARA, S. & VIANNA, A. (2006). T l o corpo estendido no cho...: a violncia
letal contra travestis no municpio do Rio de Janeiro. [There is the body lying on
the ground: lethal violence against travestis in the Rio de Janeiro municipality]. In:
PHYSIS: Rev. Sade Coletiva, Rio de Janeiro, v.16, n. 2, 2006. p.233-249.).
CARRARA,S., RAMOS, S. & CAETANO, M. (2003) Pesquisa Poltica, Direito, Violncia
e Homossexualidade. Pesquisa realizada nas Paradas do Orgulho LGBT de Rio
de Janeiro, So Paulo, Porto Alegre e Recife. Rio de Janeiro: Pallas. [Research
on Politics, Rights, Violence and Homosexuality. Survey conducted at LGBT Pride
Parades in Rio de Janeiro, So Paulo, Porto Alegre and Recife]. Available at: http://
www.ucamcesec.com.br/arquivos/publicacoes/publirelatorio.pdf (Accessed on:
13 jun. 2012).
HEREK, G.M. (2004). Beyond Homophobia: Thinking About Sexual Prejudice and
Stigma in the Twenty-First Century. In: Sexuality Research and Social Policy,
Volume 1, Number 2, Pages 6-24.
LOURO, G.L. (1999). Pedagogia da Sexualidade [Pedagogies of Sexuality]. In: Louro,
G.L. (ed.). O corpo educado: pedagogias da sexualidade. [The educated body:
pedagogies of sexuality]. Belo Horizonte; Autntica.
VENTURA, M. (2002). Direitos reprodutivos no Brasil. [Reproductive Rights in Brazil]
So Paulo: Fundao MacArthur. Availabe at: http://www.unfpa.org.br/Arquivos/
direitos_reprodutivos.pdf (Accessed on: 13 jun. 2012).
53
Activities Module 3
to encourage a better understanding of sexuality
Activity
Hand out paper to the students. Ask boys to write the letter M
(male/masculine) and girls to write the letter F (female/feminine) at the top
of the page. Then ask them to write down the first word or feeling that they
have when they hear the word sexuality. Ask students to fold their paper and
collect this in.
Request the help of one or more students to write on the board the key words
emerging from the activity, separating them by male and female responses.
Highlight any differences or similarities between the genders.
In order to make the discussion livelier, you could raise the following questions:
Who do you feel comfortable talking about sex and sexuality with?
Why?
Do you think your friends know everything about sex and sexuality?
Why do you think this?
Who knows more about sex and sexuality boys or girls? Why do you
think this?
If you think your students felt comfortable in the discussion, ask them to share
some of their initial reactions. You can also suggest that students make a
collective poster with the words and phrases identified during the exercise.
Give the poster a title and exhibit it in the classroom.
54
Activities Module 3
to encourage a better understanding of sexuality
HIV
2 and AIDS
Activity
PREPARATION :
55
Activities Module 3
to encourage a better understanding of sexuality
Sexuality-related
3 discrimination
Activity
PREPARATION :
56
Section 1 Module 4
Ethnic inequality
Ethnic inequality
Introduction
This module begins by examining the concept of ethnocentrism, and explores how it
has influenced ideas about race and ethnicity. Taking Brazil as a case study, the module
then examines how racial and ethnic prejudice and discrimination can result in a range of
social and economic inequalities. The second part of the module focuses on the role that
schools can play in combating racial and ethnic discrimination, and promoting diversity.
Throughout the module, try to consider the following questions:
Section 1 Module 4
Ethnic inequality
Despite this increase in circulation of people and ideas, the tendency to naturalize
differences across societies has not disappeared; on the contrary, it has assumed other
forms. Furthermore it has served to control not only the relationship with those who are
distant, but also relations inside the same society. One of these forms, perhaps the most
perverse of them, is racism.
Racism is a doctrine which claims that inherent differences amongst various races
determine individual or collective achievement. Racism usually involves a belief that
ones own race is superior and dominant over others. This, in turn, can lead to forms of
discrimination against those deemed to be inferior. At times throughout history, attempts
have been made to use scientific explanations to prove the existence of racial disparities.
While these assertions have thrived off claims of scientific objectivity, ideas about race
are maintained largely through repetition, ignorance and prejudice.
One example which illustrates the way that racism has had profound impacts upon
different cultures and societies can be seen in the programme of European colonial
expansion which took place between the 19th and 20th Centuries. Until the beginning of
the 19th Century, the term race was rarely used. Instead, the concept of lineage was
used to describe the way that European nations were derived from ancient tribes, such
as the Saxons, the Bretons, the Latvians
etc.. At the same time, forms of colonialism
were predominantly mercantile, with other
cultures often considered as equal trading
partners, or as noble savages to be
harles Darwin (1809
respected.
Throughout the 19th Century, however,
ideas about race and, in particular, racial
difference, came to the forefront. In
large part, these ideas were influenced
by emerging biological and evolutionary
theories, created to explain the differences
between animals and humans. Importantly,
however, dividing and categorising people
into racial types also helped to legitimise
increasing colonial ambitions for territorial
and resource acquisition. By claiming that
human beings in other places were of a
different, less evolved racial type than their
own, the colonisers were able to justify
their actions in seeking to assert control
58
Section 1 Module 4
Ethnic inequality
over them. In the same way that biological differences were believed to render women
inferior to men and to deny them rights to suffrage, for example, colonised populations
were deemed incapable of self-governance.
By creating such categories, and promoting them through popular imagery and
discourse, many Europeans came to believe that their lineages were racially distinct
from, and superior to, those of African, Asian, and American peoples. Such ideas in
turn, influenced the development of other discriminatory theories, one of which was
eugenics. Emerging in the late 19th Century, eugenics used evolutionary theory to
justify the ultimate goal of improving the human species. At the heart of this process was
the aim of controlling human reproduction through prohibiting inter-racial marriage, and
eliminating groups of people supposedly responsible for the transmission of undesirable
characteristics. The implementation of a eugenics policy was seen in the 1930s, when
the Nazi run German state set out to purify the Aryan race. This involved separating
out and eliminating people seen to have characteristics deemed to be deviant, such as
minority ethnic groups, people with mental and physical disabilities, and homosexuals.
While scientific arguments which distinguish between different races are generally
no longer given credence, it is vital to recognize the continuing existence of racism as
an attitude. It is also important to acknowledge that while historically, many forms of
racism were directed by the West, racism exists within and between all societies, with
implications for discrimination against many groups of people deemed to be racially and
ethnically inferior.
59
Section 1 Module 4
Ethnic inequality
expanded upon in the International Convention for the Elimination of all Forms of Racial
Discrimination8 which dealt with protection against discrimination based on colour, on
descent and on ethnic or national origin.
Despite such positive developments, evidence suggests that discrimination on
the grounds of race and ethnicity still exists and, in turn, influences the inequalities
experienced by many people throughout the world. Using Brazil as a case study, it is
possible to see how these ongoing inequalities affect peoples daily lives.
60
Section 1 Module 4
Ethnic inequality
While racial inequalities in rates of literacy and educational attainment in Brazil have
decreased in recent years, significant differences still remain. Black and mixed-colour
students, for example, receive an average of five years of schooling compared to seven
years for white students. Between the ages of 15-17 years, 60% of young people who
are white are studying at secondary level compared to only 32% of young people who
are black or mixed. Similarly, while 21.5% of white people aged 18-19 go on to higher
education, the figures are only 4.4% for black people, and 3.2% for mixed-colour people.
For those aged between 20-24 years, 53.6% of white people are in higher education
compared to only 15.8% of non-whites.
These inequalities are also influenced by the educational attainment of parents,
suggesting that disadvantages are reproduced across the generations. In addition,
regional disparities in educational provision and attainment exist along racial lines.
In Brazil, the white population is concentrated in the most economically advantaged
regions of the country (South and Southeast), while the presence of black and mixedcolour groups is much greater in the Northeast.
The type of employment that is available to people in Brazil is also influenced by ethnicity.
Women categorised as black or mixed-coloured for example, are much more likely than
white women to be found working in domestic service. While this may be due in part
to levels of educational attainment, it is also important to consider the role of prejudice
and stereotyping in perpetuating racial inequalities. Stereotyping involves simplifying
conceptions of people based on a set of prior assumptions made about them. This in
turn, can influence the way that people and their abilities are perceived, as well as the
opportunities that are then made available. The expression, to put someone in their
place thus not only presumes that there are places, but also that each person knows
which place is his or hers. In Brazil, stereotypes which place black people in subservient
positions are common, with acceptable paths for upward social mobility generally limited
to success in music or sport.
61
Section 2 Module 4
Ethnic inequality in schools
62
Section 2 Module 4
Ethnic inequality in schools
Unless teachers critique such materials and stereotypes, they may find themselves
implicit in upholding racism. Racism may also be reinforced when teachers do not act to
tackle discriminatory remarks or behaviours. Racist jokes and nicknames, for example,
may be treated as funny or disregarded as problems that need to be dealt with outside
of the school environment.
63
Section 2 Module 4
Ethnic inequality in schools
Recognise the right of all students to learn about their own culture and
background.
Recognise the ethnic and racial voices that are missing, distorted or
stereotyped in teaching and learning materials. Address these missing
perspectives, particularly in work on history and culture.
Include ethnic and racial issues in all aspects of teaching and learning,
and initiate actions to combat racism and discrimination.
Examine the impact of racism in the school curriculum, and the ways in
which it frequently coexists alongside other forms of discrimination
Combat prejudiced and discriminatory attitudes within and beyond the
school environment.
Discuss race and ethnic inequality with other educators, and with civil
society and minority ethnic organizations.
Take affirmative action to guarantee access to and the involvement of groups
that are under-represented in higher education and university settings.
64
Module 4
References
References
HENRIQUE, R. (2003) Raa e gnero no sistema de ensino. Os limites das polticas
universalistas na educao. [Race and gender in the education system. The limits of
universalist education policies.] Brasilia: UNESCO Brasilia/UNDP.
NASCIMENTO, E.L. (2007) The Sorcery of Color: Identity, Race, and Gender in Brazil.
Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
PAUL, D. B. (2003). Darwin, Social Darwinism and Eugenics. In: Hodge, J. & Radick,
G. (eds.) The Cambridge Companion to Darwin. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
65
Activities Module 4
to encourage a better understanding of race and ethnicity
Activity
ACTIVITY:
66
Activities Module 4
to encourage a better understanding of race and ethnicity
Racism
2 is it history?
Activity
ACTIVITY:
Activity
Role-reversal
PREPARATION :
Watch the film (or extracts from it) with your students and ask
them to consider the following:
What kinds of discriminatory attitudes are evident?
What language is used to describe black and white people?
What stereotypes are evident, and how does this influence the way
that people are treated?
67
Activities Module 4
to encourage a better understanding of race and ethnicity
Ethnic and
4 racial stereotyping
Activity
PREPARATION :
68
Glossary
Glossary
Bisexuality: Feelings or behaviours of romantic and/or sexual attraction towards persons
of the same and the opposite sex.
Culture: A uniquely human phenomenon that reflects the capacity of human beings to
give meaning to their actions and to the world that surrounds them. A culture is shared
by members of a social group, and does not refer to exclusively individual phenomena.
Every human grouping, from different eras and diverse geographical areas, attributes
unique significance to apparently similar objects and passages in life. Culture, therefore,
is more than just a system of customs, it is an object of human intervention, which makes
life an inventive enterprise a readable, assessable, and interpretable experience.
Ethnic/ethnicity: Refers to a group of people whose members identify with each other,
through a common heritage, often consisting of a common language, a common culture
and/or an ideology that stresses common ancestry.
Ethnocentrism: A term used to describe the generic feeling of people who prefer the
lifestyle and norms of their own social or cultural group over that of others. The term,
in principle, does not necessarily prescribe a negative attitude towards others, but a
worldview centering on the core values of the group to which the individual belongs.
However, evaluating all other group or cultural attitudes from this perspective can
generate positions or actions of intolerance.
Eugenics: A science that gained particular attention during the late 19th and early
20th centuries and intended to regulate the transmission of hereditary characteristics
within different social strata. This was to be achieved through the control of human
reproduction, the prohibition of inter-racial marriage and the elimination of groups that
were supposedly responsible for the transmission of undesirable characteristics.
Feminist movement: A social and political movement that fights for equal rights for
women and men, both in terms of legislation and public policy. Feminist organizations
often offer support services and social programmes for women.
Gender: The term gender refers to the socially constructed roles, behaviours, activities
and attributes that a particular society considers appropriate for men and for women. In
recent decades, the concept of gender has had a profound influence on thinking about
equality.
Gender inequality: The unequal value and treatment accorded to women and to men.
69
Glossary
Glossary
Sexual rights: Rights that grant individuals freedom and autonomy in sexual choices,
such as the right to practise a sexual orientation without suffering discrimination or
violence, and a womans right to determine if and when to have children.
Transgender: Person who has a gender identity that is different from the sex designated
at birth. Transgender men and women may manifest the will to undergo hormonal therapies
and/or surgical interventions in order to adapt their physical attributes (including genitals)
to their own gender identity.
Transsexual: Person who identifies with a gender that is inconsistent with their assigned
sex.
71