An Examination of The Physical Properties of Pure Magnesium Stearate
An Examination of The Physical Properties of Pure Magnesium Stearate
Elsevier
IJP 01423
Summary
The effect of various preparation conditions on the form of magnesium stearate prepared by aqueous precipitation was examined.
None of the preparation variables had any apparent effect on the crystal habit of magnesium stearate; however, the preparation
conditions did affect the amount of moisture associated with the crystals. Heating the magnesium stearate at 105 o C not only resulted
in a loss of water of hydration from the crystals, but also a disruption of the crystals’ 3-dimensional lattice structure. Both of these
effects could be reversed by storing the dried crystals under appropriate relative humidity conditions.
metric analyzer (TGA). DSC examinations were in these factors had any effect on the crystal habit of
most cases carried out over a temperature range of the magnesium stearates produced in the present
40 o C-150 o C at a heating rate of 2’ C/mm, al- work, as all of the samples consisted of plate-
though in some cases samples were heated to shaped crystals, i.e. the needle-shaped crystals de-
temperatures as high as 200 ’ C at a heating rate of scribed in the literature could not be isolated. The
lO’C/min. TGA examinations were carried out medium pH did have an effect on the amount of
over a temperature range from 50°C to 130” C at water associated with the crystals, however.
a heating rate of 5 o C/mm. Batches precipitated at pH 9 were shown by ther-
The appearance of the magnesium stearate dur- mal analysis to contain an amount of bound water
ing heating was observed under magnification corresponding to a dihydrate (form A), while
using a polarizing microscope (Optikot-Pal, Nikon, batches precipitated at the pH extremes (i.e. 7 and
Japan) equipped with a hot-stage (Model FP 82, 11) contained considerably less bound water (Ta-
Mettler Instrument Corp., Hightstown, NJ). A ble I). The decreased amount of moisture associ-
heating rate of 2” C/mm was maintained by a ated with the latter batches may be due to irregu-
central processor (Model FP 80, Mettler). lar incorporation of water into the magnesium
stearate crystal lattice during precipitation (Miller,
Infrared spectroscopy 1982) or to the formation of a mixture of mag-
The infrared absorption spectra of stearic acid nesium stearate dihydrate and a lower hydration
and of hydrous and anhydrous magnesium stearate state (Miller, 1985).
samples were obtained using an infrared spectro- Earlier workers have reported that it is possible
photometer (Model 599B, Perkin-Elmer Corp., to prepare magnesium stearate trihydrate by aque-
Norwalk, CT). Ca. 1 mg of the powder to be ous precipitation. Despite the wide variety of
examined was ground with 100 mg of dry potas- precipitation conditions employed in the present
sium bromide, compressed into a pellet, and study, the trihydrate could not be isolated, al-
scanned from 200-4000 cm-‘. though several batches of magnesium stearate
precipitated at pH 9 did contain slightly more
X-ray analysis
water than the amount expected for a dihydrate
Diffraction patterns for magnesium stearate
(e.g. 2.4-hydrate). Storage of these powders over
were obtained using a powder diffractometer
phosphorous pentoxide, however, decreased their
(Phillips Electronics Inc., Mount Vernon, NY).
moisture content to that of a dihydrate (Fig. l),
Samples were irradiated with X-rays from a copper
indicating that the excess water was present as
target (Cu kar radiation, h = 0.15418 nm). Two
adsorbed surface moisture.
types of samples mounts were used: random
An anhydrous form of magnesium stearate
powder mounts, prepared using the sample holder
(form B) was prepared by drying the dihydrate to
provided with the instrument, and ordered powder
mounts, prepared by dropping an ethanolic sus-
pension of magnesium stearate crystals onto a TABLE 1
clean glass microscope slide and allowing the Effect of precipitation pH on the moisture contents of various
solvent to evaporate. Diffraction patterns from Iaboratoty-prepared magnesium stearates
both types of mounts were measured from 20 = 5 o
to 25 O, where 0 is the Bragg angle. Precipitation pH Loss on drying (weight W)
9 5.5650.17 (n = 4)
9 5.71fO.O8(n=8)
Results and Discussion 9 5.22*0.11 (n = 3)
9 5.54k0.21 (n = 4)
As noted in the introduction, medium pH and 7 2.06 + 0.01 (n = 3)
11 3.42+0.31 (n = 8)
cooling rate are thought to be the primary factors
which determine the form of magnesium stearate Values are mean + S.E.M., n denotes the number of determina-
prepared by aqueous precipitation. Neither of tions. The theoretical weight loss for a dihydrate is 5.74%
174
Fig. 1. Weight loss of magnesium stearate form A (2.4-hydrate) Fig. 2. Moisture uptake of magnesium stearate anhydrate
when stored over phosphorous pentoxide. Error bars represent (form B) when stored under 11.3% relative humidity condi-
95% confidence limits. tions Error bars represent 95% confidence limits.
constant weight at 105 o C. This treatment resulted relative humidity was less than 50%, as evidenced
in a loss of moisture only; the plate-shaped ap- by the rapid and continuous weight loss observed
pearance of the original dihydrate was retained. during thermogravimetric analysis (Fig. 4). This
The loss of moisture was, however, accompanied type of moisture sorption has previously been
by the development of striations in the crystals described for anhydrous magnesium stearate
and a darkening of the crystals’ appearance when (Miiller, 1982). When the relative humidity ex-
viewed under crossed polars, indicating a loss of ceeded 50%, however, the anhydrate rehydrated to
their anisotropic property, as has been described form a trihydrate (form C). This phenomenon has
previously (Miller, 1985). These changes were most not been previously described for anhydrous mag-
likely due to desolvation rather than to a polymor- nesium stearate, although other anhydrous metal
phic change in the crystals. soaps are known to rehydrate under appropriate
Magnesium stearate dihydrate exhibited no conditions. The rehydration process was accompa-
tendency to sorb moisture when stored over the
various saturated salt solutions described earlier.
52.8% RELATIVE HUMIDITY (DRIED)
This is not surprising, since magnesium stearate is
classified as being non-hygroscopic (Callahan,
1982), although the compound apparently will sorb
moisture when stored under relative humidities
greater than approximately 85% (Callahan, 1982;
Hiilzer, 1985; Handbook of Pharmaceutical Ex-
cipients). Furthermore, except for the specific cases
mentioned above, the dihydrate exhibited no tend-
ency to lose moisture when stored over phosphor-
ous pentoxide.
Unlike the dihydrate, the anhydrous form of
magnesium stearate did exhibit a tendency to sorb
moisture when stored over the various saturated Fig. 3. Moisture uptake of magnesium stearate anhydrate
salt solutions (Figs. 2 and 3). This moisture was (form B) when stored under 52.8% relative humidity condi-
present as adsorbed surface moisture when the tions. Error bars represent 95% confidence limits.
175
Fig. 4. Typical % weight vs temperature curve (TGA) for Fig. 5. Typical % weight vs temperature curve (TGA) for
magnesium stearate anhydrate (form B) stored under relative magnesium stearate dihydrate (form A).
humidities less than 50%. The example shown is from a sample
stored under 11.3% relative humidity.
characterized by DSC. Thermograms of both the
dihydrate (Fig. 7) and trihydrate (Fig. 8) forms of
nied by a significant increase in the crystal long magnesium stearate exhibited two thermal events,
spacing of the magnesium stearate (Table 2), indi- although the peak temperatures associated with
cating that a change in the packing of the hydro- these events were shifted to lower values for the
carbon chains had occurred. Once formed, the latter form (Table 3). No thermal events were
trihydrate was stable at 25’ C when stored under observed at temperatures greater than 130°C for
relative humidity conditions less than those any of the samples. Previous workers have as-
required for its formation, i.e. less than 50%. The signed the low temperature endotherm to the loss
anhydrate could be regenerated, however, by dry- of bound water from the crystals and the high
ing the trihydrate at 105 o C. temperature endotherm to a melting phenomenon
Thermogravimetric analysis of the dihydrate (Mtiller, 1977a, c; Miller, 1985). These assign-
and trihydrate forms of magnesium stearate ments were confirmed in the present work by
showed that the waters of hydration within a given TGA and hot-stage microscopy. As shown in Table
hydration state were bound equivalently, as evi- 3, the enthalpic change associated with the loss of
denced by the lack of shoulders in their weight bound water from the dihydrate was significantly
loss curves (Figs. 5 and 6). The thermal behavior greater than that associated with the loss of bound
of all 3 forms of magnesium stearate was further
TABLE 2
Crystal long spacing (do,,) of magnesium stearate anhydrate
(form B) as a function of relative humidity
Values are mean f S.E.M., n denotes the number of determina- Fig. 6. Typical & weight vs temperature curve (TGA) for
tions. magnesium stearate trihydrate (form C).
176
TABLE 3
Thermalpropertresof the various forms of magnesium stearate as
determined by DSC
form A
25
4
t5
2e
I i
nX=2d sin@ 0)
TABLE 4
to interpret. A typical diffraction pattern obtained Values are mean f S.E.M., n denotes the number of determina-
from an ordered powder mount is shown in Fig. tions.
11. Diffraction angles corresponding to peak max- * Values reported by Miiller (1977a).
178
TABLE 5
Summary of infrared absorption data for stearic acid and the various forms of magnesium stearate.
from the crystal structures of corresponding correspond to monoclinic packing as well (Mtiller,
hydration states isolated in earlier studies. 1977b). Based on the appearance of this absorp-
The difference between the anhydrate and tri- tion band, the hydrocarbon chains in the stearic
hydrate forms isolated in this work and in earlier acid crystals possessed either a monoclinic or an
studies was further demonstrated by examining orthorhombic packing, which is consistent with
the infrared (IR) absorption spectra of the com- the packing determined for stearic acid by X-ray
pounds. The pertinent absorption data for stearic diffraction (von Sydow, 1956). The hydrocarbon
acid and the 3 hydrates of magnesium stearate chains in the dihydrate form of magnesium stearate
isolated in this work are summarized in Table 5. also existed in either a monoclinic or an ortho-
Because formation of the magnesium salt of stearic rhombic packing, which is again consistent with
acid occurred at the carbonyl end of the molecule, the packing previously described for this species
the observed differences between the absorption (Mtiller, 1977~). The triclinic or hexagonal packing
spectra of stearic acid and magnesium stearate are determined for the trihydrate, however, is not
mainly due to changes in the absorption bands consistent with the orthorhombic packing previ-
associated with the carbonyl group. For example, ously ascribed to this hydrate. The anhydrate has
spectra of all forms of magnesium stearate ex- previously been reported to possess hexagonal
hibited a shift from 1700 cm-’ to 1615-1540 packing (Vold, 1949; Mtiller, 1977c, 1982) which
cm-’ in the absorption band due to the carbonyl at first appeared to be consistent with the hexago-
stretch, indicating that the carbonyl group had nal or triclinic packing determined for the
gone from an unionized to an ionized state in anhydrate in this work. The angle of inclination of
forming the magnesium salt of stearic acid the hydrocarbon chains calculated from the X-ray
(Lecomte, 1950; Mehrotra, 1983). There were, data, however, was not consistent with hexagonal
however, several changes in the spectra associated packing, indicating that the hydrocarbon chains
with the aliphatic portion of the molecule. Of existed in a triclinic packing.
these, the absorption band appearing at approxi-
mately 720 cm-’ was of special interest. This
particular band is due to the CH, rocking mode, Conclusion
and its appearance (i.e. as a singlet or a doublet) is
related to the packing of the hydrocarbon chains Based on what has been discussed above, the
within the crystal (Chapman, 1957). Bands ap- following conclusions were drawn:
pearing as singlets correspond to either &clinic or 1. The crystal habit of magnesium stearate was
hexagonal packing, while bands appearing as not sensitive to either the pH of the precipitation
doublets correspond to orthorhombic packing, al- medium or the cooling rate, as all samples pre-
though it has been argued that a doublet may pared consisted of plate-shaped crystals. The
179
tersuchungen an reinen Magnesium- und Calciumstearaten. Shah, A.C. and Mlodozeniec, A.R., Mechanism of surface
Pharm. Ind., 39 (1977a) 161-165. lubrication: influence of lubricant-excipient mixing on
Miiller, B.W., The pseudo-polymorphism of magnesium processing characteristics of powders and properties of
stearate. Zbl. Pharm., 116 (1977b) 1261-1266. compressed tablets. J. Pharm. Sci., 66 (1977) 1377-1382.
Miiller, B.W., Die Pseudopolymorphie von Magnesiumsalzen Steffens, K.-J., Mliller, B.W. and List, P.H., Tribologische
hljherer Fettsauren. Arch. Pharm., 310 (1977~) 693-704. Gesetzmassigkeiten und Erkentnisse in der Tabletten-
Miiller, B.W., Steffens, K.-J., and List, P.H., Tribologische technologie. 7. Mitteilung: Untersuchungen an Mag-
Gesetzmlssigkeiten und Erkentnisse in der Tabletten- nesiumstearat-Handelspraparaten. Pharm. Ind., 44 (1982)
technologie. 6. Mitteilung; Einfllisse physikalischer Eigen- 826-830.
schaften chemisch reiner Magnesiumstearate auf die Strickland Jr., W.A., Nelson, E., Busse, L.W. and Higuchi, T.,
Schmeiereigenschaften bei der Tablettierung. Pharm. Ind., Physics of tablet compression IX. Fundamental aspects of
44 (1982) 729-734. tablet lubrication. J. Am. Pharm. Assoc. Sci. Ed., 45 (1956)
Nyqvist, H., Saturated salt solutions for maintaining specified 51-55.
relative humidities. Inf. J. Pharm. Tech&. Prod. Manuf, 4 Vold R.D. and Hattiangdi, G.S., Characterization of heavy
(1983) 47-48. metal soaps by X-ray diffraction. Ind. Eng. Chem., 41
Ragnarsson, G., HSlzer, A.W. and Sjiigren, J., The influence of (1949) 2311-2320.
mixing time and colloidal silica on the lubricating proper- Von Sydow, E., The normal fatty acids in solid state - a
ties of magnesium stearate. Int. J. Pharm., 3 (1979) 127-131. crystal structure investigation. Ark. Kern., 9 (1956) 231-254.
Rubinstein, M.H. and Moody, G., “Migration of Magnesium Weast, R.C. (Ed), Handbook of Chemistty and Physics, 58th
Stearate During Tablet Production”, 3rd International Con- edn., CRC, Cleveland, OH, 1977, p. E-46.
ference on Pharmaceutical Technology, Paris, 1983.