Co-Working Space in Vietnam 2017 en
Co-Working Space in Vietnam 2017 en
CO-WORKING SPACE
IN VIETNAM
2017 | CBRE Research
CONTENTS
Executive Summary 5
Co-Working Space
7 12
In Vietnam: How
What Is They Operate And
Co-Working Space ? Compete
CO -WORKING
emphasis on space that creates a community traditional serviced office operators have recently
and an experience for consumers.1 tapped into the co-working space industry by
acquiring co-working space operators.
SPACE?
Creativity Workstations
Main users Open Space
• Start-ups
• Freelancers Networking Reception
Community
Amenities
• Entrepreneurs
CO-WORKING
• Corporate employees SPACE
Wifi Innovation
Number of venues (2016)
Flexibitity
• Worldwide: 11,3002
• Asia: ~3,0003
Contacts Pantry
• Vietnam: 17
Meeting room
1
CBRE, U.S. Shared Workplaces,
Part 3: A Landlord Perspective: Opportunity or Threat?, 2016
2
Deskmag Survey Result, 2016
3
Estimation only, CBRE Vietnam Research, 2017
15,000 1,400,000
Figure 2: Total supply (sq. m.) of Figure 3: Number of co-working venues
Number of coworking space worldwide
Number of members
1,000,000
10,000 15,000 25 350%
800,000
1
Schuermann, M. (2014). Coworking Space - A Potent Business Model for Plug’n Play and Indie Workers. Rocket Publishing, 1
Deal Street Asia, Toong join hands with Capitaland Vietnam to open new co-working space, retrieved May 2017
Lucerne & epubli GmbH. 2
Deal Street Asia, Vietnam: naked Hub plans foray; Uber gets nod under government transport scheme, retrieved May 2017
2
Goenka, A. (2016, December 27). How is the Co-Working Sharing Industry Growing and What Will be the Future in India?.
Retrieved from BW Business World: http://bwdisrupt.businessworld.in/
3
Deskmag Survey Result, 2016
HCMC
co-working space still so new to the market, and space operators in 22 venues. All but one of the
major regional and international operators yet to operators are local. However, this situation is set
enter, growth is set to accelerate further in the coming to change as co-working spaces run by regional
years. operators are set to open later this year and in 2018.
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 H1
2017
HANOI
space worldwide and in Vietnam by year co-working operators – Global vs Asia
450%
400%
Spaces (Regus)
350%
Figure 6: Market share – Number of venues by operators (H1 2017 and 2017 Forecast)
300%
Impact Hub
250%
Growth rate
200% 25 25
%
% %
30
35
150% Naked Hub
100% H1 YE
2017 2017
(forecast)
50% Wework
14%
0% 16% 18 12%
%
24
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017F 0 50 100 150 200 %
Number of Venues
As of H1 2017 the three largest operators controlled 63% of co-working spaces. This is expected to decline to around 51% by the
end of 2017 due to the entrance of new operators.
Source: Deskmag, 2017 & CBRE Vietnam, 2017 Source: CBRE Vietnam, 2017 Source: CBRE Vietnam, 2017
• Co-working spaces usually charge on a per person, • On a sq.m. basis, the rental rates for co-working • Co-working spaces in Vietnam are generally not Co-working space in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City
per seat, or per desk basis rather than on a per sq. spaces are typically higher than traditional offices due located in prime buildings or areas as operators need tends to be concentrated in CBD-fringe districts.
m. basis. The main options include flexible desks, to their provision of added services and amenities. For to keep rental costs at a manageable level. They In Hanoi, a few co-working spaces have located
fixed desks and private offices. For flexible desks, corporate users of co-working space, this means they are more usually found in underutilised buildings in themselves in Cau Giay district, an emerging office
rent is charged on a daily or monthly basis, while do not need to invest CAPEX upfront. It also provides decentralised locations. Both Toong and Up, major cluster.
for the other two options, a monthly rate is applied. them with greater flexibility in terms of size and lease co-working space operators in Vietnam, operate their
• Co-working space operators often seek branding
Some co-working spaces offer hourly rates for non- terms compared to leasing a traditional office. centres from Grade B or lower buildings.
opportunities when leasing space. Toong marked
members.
• The cost of renting co-working space varies across • The typical age of a co-working space user is quite its entrance to Ho Chi Minh City by partnering
• A fixed desk is usually charged at a higher price than different cities. Co-working spaces in Hanoi and Ho young, meaning that co-working spaces should with CapitaLand, a major international developer,
a flexible desk. The cost can be as much as 55% Chi Minh City are currently priced lower than most ideally be located in emerging or developing to promote its co-working space brand and the
higher as the seat is guaranteed for the user. Private other cities in Asia Pacific, which reflects the cheaper locations, or areas popular among students. shopping mall it is located in.
offices are priced the highest compared to the other office rental costs available in Vietnam.
options due to them being able to provide greater
privacy in an environment similar to the serviced office
model.
Map of existing co-working spaces in Hanoi Map of existing co-working spaces in Ho Chi Minh City
Figure 7: Type and cost of co-working space in Vietnam and Asia Pacific 20171
TAY HO
DISTRICT 3 DISTRICT 2
DISTRICT 7
Daily pass
Co-working space venue
1
CBRE Vietnam. Asking rents in Q1 2017; estimates only and should be viewed as indicative.
• Typical features of a co-working space include a games room, beds and auditoriums as a point of • Events, networking and community are the backbone • Other activities target a broad cross section of groups
shared workspace with a shared reception, meeting difference. These communal spaces enhance the of co-working space and are the key characteristics and include social events such as breakfast, happy
rooms, access to high-speed Internet, printing and concept of flexibility, collaboration and diversity. that differentiate co-working space from other hours, movie & games nights and sporting events.
copy machines and cafeterias. Most of these facilities workplace models such as serviced offices and They encourage members to share their experiences
• Most of the facilities listed in this section are
(such as Wi-Fi, a receptionist with a phone answering traditional offices. The aim of these features is to and interact with each other, thereby creating a sense
commonly found in co-working spaces worldwide.
service and a pantry with complimentary beverages foster collaboration, encourage knowledge sharing of community. There are also meet-ups or organised
Some co-working spaces have targeted specific
such as coffee, tea, and water) are usually included and facilitate business opportunities to support the classes aimed at attracting prospective members to
groups of members by providing facilities such as
in the rental rate. Members are given a monthly growth of users. co-working spaces.
food courts which can provide meals for members
allowance for meeting rooms and printing machines
and opportunities for food entrepreneurs, in-house • Activities in co-working spaces usually centre around • These events are usually sponsored by interested
and are charged extra if they exceed this amount.
recording or shooting studios for members belonging start-ups and aim to connect them with each other parties such as companies, venture capital firms and
Extra amenities include F&B, which can also be
to the fashion or new media sectors, and virtual and and with venture capitalists. Examples include service providers but can also be arranged by co-
an extra source of revenue for co-working space
augmented reality platforms for IT members. Other hackathons; events that gather a large number of working operators themselves. They are usually free of
operators. Some choose to operate F&B themselves
operators are seeking to provide an extra layer of participants in software development and related charge or offer large discounts for members.
or outsource these components to other providers.
convenience for members through the provision of fields for work, educational or social purposes; panel
• Selected co-working space operators provide other services such as child care and shower rooms. discussions with experienced entrepreneurs; and lunch
amenities and special services such as art galleries, & learns. The quality and frequency of these activities
can influence the growth and success of start-ups in a
local market.
Table 1. Selected events held at co-working spaces in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City
BAR
Citihub July 2016 How to raise fund for early state – start ups
SPACE LIBRARY December 2015 Tech talk with Google CEO Sundar Pichai
ENTERTAINMENT
POOL ROOM
2% 10%
6%
%
13
54%
58%
34%
%
23
Source: CBRE Vietnam survey of 110 co-working space users in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City
1
Deskmag GCUC Global Survey 2016
Monthly cost includes Rents: US$22 - $28 per sq. m. per month Rents: Average fee for a
Specifications Specifications
utilities, serviced charge (including taxes and service charge). private office in a
and taxes. This is the average rent of Grade B office buildings in co-working space in
Rents are those recorded Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City. Rents can vary across Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh
in major completed different locations in the city. CIty (including taxes)
projects in Ho Chi Minh Fit-out cost year 1: US$150 per sq. m.
City in Q1 2017
Note: The leasing cost in Hanoi was used as a basis for Grade A offices and co-working space (index = 1).
The indexes should be used to compare rental costs across the studied markets and should not be used to Figure 12. Number of hours per week spent at a co-working space
compare leasing costs between co-working spaces and Grade A offices within the same city.
Source:
40%
1
2016 CBRE Asia Pacific Fit-out Cost Guide and CBRE Research. The index was calculated based on the
leasing cost per sq. ft.
2
CBRE surveyed major operators in selected cities in April 2017 on a per seat basis. Figures may not 30%
represent the whole market.
Hong Kong is one of the world’s most expensive office The range in the cost of co-working space across 20%
markets and bears the highest leasing costs for both different markets reflects the overall rental cost in
Grade A office and co-working space. The leasing individual markets and also the type of clientele they
cost of Grade A buildings in Hong Kong is two and attract and whether they lean more towards start-ups, 10%
a half to three times higher than that in Hanoi (3.1x), freelancers or multinationals. As co-working space is
Ho Chi Minh City (2.5x) and Bangkok (3.3x) still a relatively new business model, supply–demand
(Figure 10), while the leasing cost of co-working dynamics and pricing is subject to adjustment across
space is around nine times higher. Grade A office different markets. 0%
< 5hrs 5-10hrs 11-20hrs 21-30hrs 31-40hrs > 40hrs
rents in Shanghai and Singapore are relatively similar
but the cost of co-working space in Singapore is
higher.
Source: CBRE Research, 2017, survey of co-working space users in Vietnam
CREATIVE
WORKING
ENVIRONMENT
46% of surveyed users identified a creative
working environment as important. The
modern, dynamic and vibrant design and
layout of co-working spaces, together
with their broad mix of companies and
individuals, can foster creativity and
productivity.
Figure 13: Co-working space features by
level of importance to users
Note: This question asked respondents to rank the importance level of each factor in the scale of 1 to 5. The above chart shows
the percentage of respondents who ranked each factor as 1. Most important and 2. Second most important.
30%
of respondents indicated their
space could reshape landlords’ thinking around
6.5% intention to move to a traditional
workplace strategy and shared offices as larger occupiers’
office within the next five years.
YES, YES, requirements further evolve.
WITHIN YES,
35% of respondents said they were
WITHIN
NEXT UNSURE uncertain. The corresponding figures
NEXT
NOT 12 NO OF FIVE
in the U.S. are 22.2% and 32%2
SURE MONTHS PLAN TIME YEARS respectively.
1
CBRE Research survey of selected co-working spaces in in Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City.
2
CBRE, U.S, Shared Workplaces, 2016
RESEARCH
2. CBRE, U.S. Shared Workplaces, Part 3: A Landlord 8. Deal Street Asia, Toong join hands with Capitaland
Perspective: Opportunity or Threat?, 2016 Vietnam to open new cowroking space, retrieved May With support from
2017
3. CBRE, Asia Pacific, Fit-out cost Guide, 2016 Toong DreamPlex
9. Deal Street Asia, Vietnam: naked Hub plans foray;
Operations Team Operations Team
4. Deskmag, The 3rd Global Coworking Survey, 2012 Uber gets nod under government transport scheme,
retrieved May 2017
5. Deskmag, Global Coworking Survey 2016
10. Deskmag, Global Coworking Survey 2017 For more information regarding global research and activity, please contact:
6. Schuermann, M. Coworking Space - A Potent
Business Model for Plug’n Play and Indie Workers. 11. Deskmag, GCUC Global Survey 2016 Nick Axford, Ph.D. Richard Barkham, Ph.D., MRICS Spencer Levy
Rocket Publishing, Lucerne & epubli GmbH, 2014 Global Head of Research Global Chief Economist Head of Research, Americas
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Follow CBRE
CBRE RESEARCH
This report was prepared by the CBRE Vietnam Research Team, which forms part of CBRE Research—a network of preeminent researchers who collaborate to
provide real estate market research and econometric forecasting to real estate investors and occupiers around the globe.
All materials presented in this report, unless specifically indicated otherwise, is under copyright and proprietary to CBRE. Information contained herein,
including projections, has been obtained from materials and sources believed to be reliable at the date of publication. While we do not doubt its accuracy,
we have not verified it and make no guarantee, warranty or representation about it. Readers are responsible for independently assessing the relevance,
accuracy, completeness and currency of the information of this publication. This report is presented for information purposes only exclusively for CBRE clients
and professionals, and is not to be used or considered as an offer or the solicitation of an offer to sell or buy or subscribe for securities or other financial
instruments. All rights to the material are reserved and none of the material, nor its content, nor any copy of it, may be altered in any way, transmitted to, copied
or distributed to any other party without prior express written permission of CBRE. Any unauthorized publication or redistribution of CBRE research reports is
prohibited. CBRE will not be liable for any loss, damage, cost or expense incurred or arising by reason of any person using or relying on information in this
publication.
To learn more about CBRE Research, or to access additional research reports, please visit the Global Research Gateway at reports www.cbre.com/research-
and-reports