Assam Gas Co. HAZOP Study Report
Assam Gas Co. HAZOP Study Report
:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
HAZOP STUDY
REPORT
PREPARED FOR
P.O. DULIAJAN
DIST DIBRUGARH
ASSAM 786 602
INDIA
REGD. OFFICE: 204, Chanakya, 2nd Floor, Opp. Vimalnath Complex, High Tension Road
Crossing, Vadodara-390023 (Gujarat), India
ALSO AT
NEW DELHI MUMBAI PUNE BANGALORE HYDERABAD
OVERSEAS: AUSTRALIA OMAN AFRICA
ASSAM GAS COMPANY LTD
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
KP : Kavita Patwardhan
DD : Dipali Desai
YD : Yogendra Dave
Signature
Signature
Signature
Signature
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
ABBREVIATIONS
IS Indian Standard
EPA Environment Protection Act
MoEF Ministry of Environment & Forest
OS&H Occupational Safety & Health
PPE Personal Protective Equipment
MSIHC Manufacturing, Storage & Import of Hazardous Chemicals
FA Factories Act
SMPV Static Mobile & Pressure Vessel
LFB Laminar Flow Booth
USA United States of America
OHC Occupational Health Center
SHE Safety Health & Environment
MSDS Material Safety Data Sheet
SOP Standard Operating Procedure
MOM Minutes of Meeting
MPCB Maharashtra Pollution Control Board.
IE Indian Electricity
GW Guide Word
P& IDs Piping and instrumentation diagram
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
INDEX
1. CREDITS 3
2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4
3. INTRODUCTION OF HAZOP 5
4. HAZOP STUDY SCOPE 6
5. HAZOP PROCESS 7
6. HAZOP RECORDING 11
7. HAZOP WORKSHEETS 13
8. RECOMMENDATIONS 21
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
CREDITS
M/s. Assam Gas Company Ltd, Assam, appointed M/S. GREEN CIRCLE CONSULTANTS (I) PVT. LTD.,
VADODARA to conduct HAZOP Study. Hazop team to plant site comprising Mr. Pradeep Joshi –
Managing director from M/S GREEN CIRCLE CONSULTANTS (I) PVT. LTD. In presence of committee of
M/s. Assam Gas Company Ltd, Assam
The auditors from M/S. Green Circle Consultants (I) Pvt. Ltd. Conducted the audit from 29th JUNE 2010
at Khopoli site with standard (Reference Std. IS 14489:1998 – Code of Practice for Occupational
Safety & Health Audit) procedures & methodology including close interactions & interviews of the
Employees of the plant.
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
INTRODUCTION OF HAZOP
An important addition to the methods of hazard identification is the family of techniques known as
Hazard & Operability (HAZOP) studies.
The following description is based on those given by Lawley (1974b) & by the CISHC HAZOP Study
Guide.
A multidisciplinary team, who reviews the process to discover potential hazards & operability
problems using a checklist approach, carries out the studies. They are essentially an application of
the technique of critical examination & their origins in method study are extended by an early
account by Elliott & Owen (1968).
The basis of such a study may be a word model, a process flow sheet, a plant layout or a flow
diagram. There are different types of study which have different objectives & which are done at
different stages of the project. The level of detail & the team composition are accordingly.
Principles of examination
The basic concept of the hazard & operability study is to take a full description of the process & to
question every part of it to discover what deviations from the intention of the design can occur &
what their cause & consequences may be. This is done systematically by applying suitable
guidewords.
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
HAZOP (Hazard & Operability) study was developed to identify hazards in plant & to identify
operability problems, which though not hazardous, could compromise the plants ability to achieve
design productivity.
Hazard Evaluation is carried out to identify the hazard that exists, the consequences that might
occur as a result of hazards, the likelihood that events might take place that would cause an
accident with such a consequence, and the likelihood that safety system, mitigating systems and
emergency alarms and evaluation plan would functioning property and eliminate or reduce the
consequences.
HazOp Pre-requisite:
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
HAZOP PROCESS
A. BACKGROUND
HAZOP is a well recognized method of identifying hazards & problem which may prevent an efficient
operation & lead to a hazard .HAZOP is a technique to critically examine a system, part by part ,in a
very systematic manner ,to find out the cause and consequence of every conceivable deviations
in the normal operation of the system .the method enables prediction of all possible ways in which a
hazard or an operating problem could arise ,whether the design takes preventive care of them and
if not , recommend changes may be necessary.
The HAZOP study is carried out for all major equipment and/or each pipeline joining the equipment
in a process through series of guide words around which a number of question are formulated to
arrive at the possible deviations . In doing so, valve, instrumentation, nature of chemical process and
unit operation involved are closely examined .The probable cause and the consequences of the
deviation are listed and necessary corrective actions are suggested.
The main purpose of HAZOP is therefore to identify all possible deviations from the way the design is
expected to work and probable causes and consequence of the hazard associated with these
deviations together with recommended changes.
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
B. Methodology
A HAZOP study is a formal systematic procedure used to review the design and operation of a
potentially hazardous process facility. It is used to identify deviations from normal safe operation,
which could lead, to hazards or operability problems, and to define any actions necessary to deal
with these.
The study is performed by a team of people who are familiar with the plant design and operation,
working under the guidance of a leader who is experienced in use of the HAZOP method.
The method involves several repetitive steps (Reference is invited to Figure 3.1 on next page):
Step 3 to 6 is repeated until all the guidewords have been exhausted and the team is satisfied that
all meaningful deviations have been considered. The team then goes back to step 1 and repeats
the procedure for the next section of the plant.
In the HAZOP method, the guidewords are systematically applied to a segment of process
equipment in order to promote discussion on possible deviations from the design intention. The
guidewords represent deviations to the design intent and their use leads to systematic highlighting of
hazards and operability problems.
HAZOP Worksheet
The HAZOP worksheet that was discussed during the HAZOP sessions included the following details:
Guideword
Parameter
Deviation
Causes
Approved By: Doc. No.: AGCL/HAZOP/03 Issue No.: 01
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Consequences
Safeguards
Recommendations
Remarks
Guideword
A guideword provides the team with a starting point to identify issues. Using a comprehensive list of
guideword is important to achieve maximum benefit from the HAZOP study. A HAZOP checklist shall
be used to act as an ad-memoir to identify any hazards that may have been over-looked during the
brainstorming session. For each hazard, the root cause, the consequence, any safeguards already
implemented in the design will be identified.
Parameter
Parameter is an aspect of the process that describes it physically, chemically or in terms of what is
happening.
Deviation
Deviation is defined as unreasonable / undesired change in the parameter. Deviation is formed by a
combination of the parameter and guideword.
Cause
For each hazard, the root cause is determined, such that the appropriate safeguards for the causal
events are determined.
Consequence
In assigning a level of consequence to the hazards, the HAZOP team took into consideration the
following factors:
• The present design status of the safeguards and controls
• Physical and working environment conditions
• Levels of training, experience, skills, education etc of the facilities personnel
Safeguards
The study identified the existing design safeguards for each hazard. The types of safeguards
commonly include:
• Preventive safeguards, which aim to prevent the event cause from occurring
Approved By: Doc. No.: AGCL/HAZOP/03 Issue No.: 01
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Actions / Recommendations
The HAZOP study was based on a set of P&I diagrams for the sections to be covered by study. (A
copy of the P&I diagrams used for the study are compiled in Appendix I). The following back-up
documents were also used during the HAZOP sessions:
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
HAZOP RECORDING
Recording of this study is 'complete recording' wherein all discussions of significance were recorded.
The discussion from the study is recorded on log sheets. Information is recorded in columns on the log
sheets as follows:
Guide Words
Parameters
Deviations
Causes
Consequences
Safeguards
Recommendations
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
The application of these guide words may be illustrated by the example already described:
TRANSFER A, The guide words may be applicable to either the word TRANSFER or the word A. Thus for
this case, the meaning might include the following:
NO or NOT No Flow of A.
After having listed all the deviation under each guide word, possible causes for the deviation are
identified & consequences are assessed.
Finally, the study of each pipeline or equipment carried out is document in the form of a worksheet.
Worksheets indicate particular deviation leading to potential hazards and/or operating difficulties
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
which may not have been anticipated during design stage & incorporates recommendations to
prevent or ameliorate the consequences of a deviation.
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
HAZOP WORKSHEETS
Parameter: Pressure
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Parameter : Pressure
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Parameter : Temperature
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Parameter : Pressure
Parameter : Flow
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Less/No Same as
Low
pressure
Reverse -Human -Business loss -Orifice -NRV
error & -Training -Training
valve is -Signage -Display of WI
closed
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Parameter : Pressure
Parameter : Flow
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Parameter : Pressure
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
RECOMMENDATIONS
Pipeline Area
General Recommendation
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
The consulting services conducted by Green Circle Consultants (I) Pvt Ltd (the
“Company”) were performed using generally accepted guidelines, standards, and/or
practices, which the Company considers reliable. Although the Company performed its
consulting services pursuant to reliable and generally accepted practices in the industry,
the Company does not guarantee or provide any representations or warranties with
respect to Client’s use, interpretation or application of the findings, conclusions, and/or
suggestions of the consulting services provided by the Company. Moreover, the findings,
conclusions, and the suggestions resulting from the consulting service are based upon
certain assumptions, information, documents, and procedures provided by the
Customer. AS SUCH, IN NO EVENT AND UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCE SHALL THE COMPANY
BE LIABLE FOR SPECIAL, INDIRECT, PUNITIVE OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMGES OF ANY NATURE
WHATSOEVER, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY LOST REVENUE OR PROFITS OF THE
CUSTOMER OR ITS CUSTOMERS, AGENTS AND DISTRIBUTORS, RESULTING FROM, ARISING
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH, THE SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE COMPANY. The
Customer agrees that the Company shall have no liability for damages, which may result
from Client’s use, interpretation or application of the consulting services provided by the
Company.
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
IMPORTANT
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
Signature
Sl. Section Page Effective
Amendment Particulars (Amendment
No. No. No. Date
incorporated)
REPORT NO.:-GCCIPL/V/AGCL/HAZOP/2010-11/SEP/RMS-075/R01
This Document is
Signature
Signature