Corrosion Fundamentals
Corrosion Fundamentals
Control
Corrosion
Water Chemistry
Bacteria
TSA’s (Field System Survey’s)
Chemistry for Mitigation
Field Performance Testing
Lab Performance Testing
Modeling
Applications
KPI’s
Monitoring
2
See any Corrosion TODAY - ??
3
Usage of “IRON” – Oil & Gas Industry
Use of IRON, other Metals & Alloys:
For STRENGTH & RESISITIVITY to:
- HIGH TEMPERATURES & HIGH PRESSURES
4
Why is corrosion a concern?
Lost Production
Repair/Replacement
Leaks Reduced
Corrosion
Safety/Accidents
Profit
Environmental Fines
It’s the “PIT’S - !!
Increased Regulations
5
What is Corrosion? - Definition
6
The Electromotive Force (emf) Series
Active End
Potassium (K) -2.925 V
Magnesium (Mg) -2.370 V
Aluminum (Al) -1.660 V
Zinc (Zn) -0.763 V
Iron (Fe) -0.440 V
Nickel (Ni) -0.250 V
Hydrogen (H) 0.000 V
Copper (Cu) +0.337 V
Silver (Ag) +0.799 V
Gold (Au) +1.680 V
Inactive End
7
What is Required for Corrosion to Occur?
8
Basic Corrosion Cell
9
Corrosion Cell
10
Parameters Influencing Corrosion
pH Dissolved
Gases
Metallurgy
Water
Chemistry
Organic
Acids
Corrosion
Press.
Bacteria
Temp.
Sulfur
Velocity Solids
11
Water Chemistry
12
Water Analyses – WHY?
13
What’s in Produced Water?
14
Dissolved Gases
Carbon Dioxide, CO2
Lowers the pH, which affects both the waters’ corrosivity and
calcium carbonate scaling tendency
Oxygen, O2
Has a greater affect on corrosivity of water than others
Facilitates growth of aerobic bacteria
15
Dissolved Solids
16
Solubility
140
120
NaNO3
gases
100
KNO3
80
50
KCl
-In our case , water 40
NaCl
30
KClO3
it can hold 0 10 20 30 40 50
Temperature/Celsuis
60 70 80 90 100
17
Solubility - What affects it?
Temperature
↑Temp… more solute can be dissolved
Pressure
↑ Pressure…more gas can be dissolved
18
Solubility - Continued
19
Ionization of Water & pH
H2O = H-O-H → H+ + OH-
The pH of the water is a measure of the balance
between the Hydrogen (H+) and Hydroxide (OH-) ions in
the water.
1
pH = log +
[H ]
Importance of pH
21
NO – “WATER” - ?
NO CORROSION – destroying metal tubing, pipelines,
vessels etc.
NO SCALE – plug, block and/or restrict flow
NO EMULSIONS - plug, block or restrict flow
NO BACTERIA PROBLEMS - plug, block or restrict flow;
increase corrosion rates
Foaming, Hydrate, Paraffin, Asphaltene, Defoamer, Water
Quality – problems would also be minimized
THEREFORE: NO WATER = MINIMAL OIL & GAS
PRODUCTION ISSUES
“It’s the Water -- and a lot more.”
22
How quickly will metal corrode?
23
Factors Affecting Corrosion - pH
The lower the pH of the water, the
greater the rate of corrosion.
In wells with a small amount of
produced water (such as condensate
wells) the pH of the water can get as
low as two or three, due to the
exposure of high pressure and carbon
dioxide.
Therefore, it stands to reason that the
corrosion rate will increase as the pH
decreases because there will be more
hydrogen ions to drive the process.
24
Factors Affecting Corrosion – Acid Gases
Acid Gases
Carbon Dioxide (CO2)
Oxygen (O2)
- Although not an acid gas…O2 accelerates the
corrosion rate many more times than CO2 & H2S
25
Relative Reactivity
While the
presence of
oxygen increases
the rate of
general metal
loss and pitting
attack, the
presence of either
CO2 and/or H2S
augments the rate
of attack.
26
Factors Affecting Corrosion – CO2
The presence of carbon dioxide(CO2) in water
has an impact on the speed of the corrosion
process, and tends to be the primary cause of
corrosion itself.
Some factors influencing the solubility of carbon dioxide in
water are:
Pressure → the higher the pressure, the more soluble carbon
dioxide is in the water.
Temperature → the higher the temperature, the lower the
solubility of carbon dioxide in water, however generally a 10
ºC (17 ºF) increase will double the rate of corrosion reaction.
Composition Of Water → Dissolved materials in water may
buffer it, preventing a reduction in pH.
27
Factors Affecting Corrosion – H2S
H2S corrosion is very common in all parts of North
America
H2S can be generated by bacteria underground and in
surface equipment used.
When H2S is dissolved in water,
it creates a weak acid that is a
significant cause of corrosion.
Hydrogen sulfide is the most
corrosive when combined with
carbon dioxide. H2S corrosion has its own
characteristic pits as well
28
Factors Affecting Corrosion – O2
Common in established (old) oil fields,
oxygen is the worst of the dissolved
gases that can contribute to corrosion.
O2 causes severe corrosion at very low
concentrations. It combines slowly with
many metals, even at temperatures
below 38°C, and rapidly oxidizes (rusts)
iron and steel.
O2 is not normally present in the
produced water, but comes into contact
with it, as it is brought to the surface.
If O2 entry is overlooked severe
corrosion, corrosion products in injection
wells and equipment failures may occur!
29
Factors Affecting Corrosion - Bacteria
Sulfate Reducing Bacteria (SRB)
Sulfate Reducing Bacteria are very corrosive in an
anaerobic (No O2 present) environment.
The sulphate reducing bacteria are able to reduce
sulphate in water to sulfides, resulting in the
production of hydrogen sulphide, which can cause
four different corrosion problems:
– Pitting directly under a colony of bacteria.
– The generation of H2S can make the water more acidic, raising the
level of general corrosion.
– Sulphide cracking, (a form of stress corrosion cracking) and sulphide
blistering.
– "Sour corrosion" which forms insoluble iron sulphide which itself forms
more sites for further pitting.
30
Factors Affecting Corrosion – Dissolved
Solids
Typically, chlorides (Cl-) give water the conductivity
required for corrosion to occur.
Electrolytic conductivity of water is increased as dissolved
inorganic salts increase.
Corrosion reactions almost always increase with an increase of
salt concentration.
The type of salt or ions influence the degree and form of corrosion
attack.
Electrochemical reactions promote chloride and hydrogen ions in
pits which form hydrochloric acid and accelerate corrosion.
32
Factors Affecting Corrosion – Temperature
A temperature increase can affect the rate of corrosion in
many different ways:
The rate of the chemical reaction will speed up.
33
Factors Affecting Corrosion – Pressure
As pressure increases
High Pressure → Higher Solubility → Higher Corrosion Rate
the solubility of gases (CO2, H2S & O2) will increase in
the brine
As pressure decreases
the solubility of gases (CO2, H2S & O2) will decrease in
the brine, raising the pH.
34
Factors affecting Corrosion - Summary
Water Chemistry
Dissolved Gases -- Carbon Dioxide, Hydrogen Sulfide, Oxygen
pH
Pressure
Temperature
Metallurgy
Velocity
Stagnant/low flow: Liquid holdup can impact slugging; chemical transport efficiency
Slug Flow: Can be intermittent; very corrosive; Similar to cavitation
Multiphase flow: Stratified effects most pronounced; 3 Phases can result in three velocities
Condensing water: Un-buffered-low pH; Top of Line Corrosion possible
Solids: Suspended or Dissolved -- Increases erosional; Consumes corrosion inhibitors; Ideal surfaces for
bacterial growth
Sulfur: Can cause accelerated corrosion rates
Bacteria: Grows/reproduces
Galvanic: Dissimilar Metals
Mechanical/ Abrasion
Flow enhanced
Electrolysis
35
Common Forms of Corrosion
General Corrosion
Pitting Corrosion – “It’s the Pits”
Galvanic Corrosion
Velocity Influenced Corrosion
Environmental Cracking
Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion
36
General Corrosion
Corrosion that proceeds without appreciable localization of
attack. Also known as “Uniform Corrosion” & “General
Thinning”
High chlorides and acidic environments
UNIFORM surface roughening and in some cases the presence
of corrosion products
Anodic and cathodic areas SHIFTS – uniform corrosion
Starts at fast rates then slows down due to formation of
protective scale
Predictable
37
Pitting Corrosion
38
Carbon Dioxide
CO 2 + H 2 O → H 2 CO 3
Carbon + Water →Carbonic
Dioxide Acid
39
Carbon Dioxide
• Sweet Corrosion
• CO2 is ~36 times more soluble in H2O than O2 at 25 0C (77 0F)
• Solubility is a function of CO2 partial pressure in gas
Partial Pressure = Total System Pressure x % CO2 / 100
• ‘Rule of Thumb’ - low salinity conditions
PCO2 < 7 psi non-corrosive
PCO2 7 - 30 psi corrosion likely
PCO2 > 30 psi corrosion almost certain
• Forms carbonic acid in water
40
H2S Pitting Attack
Shallow ROUND
PITS with etched
bottoms
41
Crevice Corrosion
Stainless steel
screw, cadmium
plated washer
44
Velocity Influenced Corrosion
Erosion Corrosion
Mechanical Erosion/Impingement
Cavitation
45
Erosion Corrosion
46
Mechanical Erosion/ Impingement
47
Cavitation
48
Environmental Cracking
The combined action of tensile stress and a corrosion
reaction is the principal characteristic of all
environmental cracking phenomena
SCC – Stress Corrosion Cracking
HIC – Hydrogen Induced Cracking
SSC – Sulfide Stress Cracking
Hydrogen Bistering
Corrosion Fatigue
49
Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC)
50
Stress Corrosion Cracking (SCC) - Initiation
Application of
mechanical stress
Accumulation of
Initiation of a crack stress at pit face
51
Corrosion Fatigue
Results from the combined action of a CYCLIC
(alternating) tensile stress and a CORROSIVE
environment
A form of SCC
At the point of high stresses, the corrosion product
film is damaged allowing localized corrosion to take
place
This lead to crack initiation and growth by a
combination of mechanical and corrosive action
H2S attack on
sucker rods
followed by
corrosion
fatigue break,
caused by
alternating
stresses 52
Hydrogen Induced Cracking (HIC)
53
Sulfide Stress Cracking (SSC)
54
Microbiological Influenced Corrosion (MIC)
Types of Bacteria
Aerobic (OXYGEN)
Acid Producing Bacteria (APB)
General Aerobic Bacteria (GAB)
55
Problems caused by Bacteria - MIC
Corrosion due to generation of H2S by SRB’s, Sessile bacteria forms
“Slime” that promotes Crevice/Under Deposit corrosion - MIC
Plugging, filter problems, System fouling, high injectivity pressures
H2S produced by bacteria causes Reservoir Souring of Production
H2S produced by bacteria causes Health Hazards
Sales Gas – unable to met Gas Pipeline Spec’s for sale – 4 ppm or less
H 2S
Increasing presence of H2S Gas – throughout Production System
Physical evidence of slime (Biomasses) found in Production Equipment
Corrosion failures on the rise
Degradation of expensive metal coatings and polymers
Microbiologically Influenced Corrosion (MIC) destroys production
equipment
Emulsion Stabilization
56
What are some signs that a system may
have a corrosion problem?
There are many signs that could suggest that corrosion is
occurring in the system. They include:
Reduced Production
Reduced Casing Pressure
High Iron and/or Manganese Counts
High debris in water
Reddish/blackish water at Production Vessels
Pigging or Caliper Operations show that tubing is
thinning
The age of the system
OTHERS - !!!!! [What’s your Sign - ?]
57
Corrosion Control with Corrosion
Inhibitor
58
Preventive Actions
Engineering solutions – careful selection of material
Control of environment which contacts the metal during
fabrication, shipping and construction
Applied barrier lining: protective coating, paint
Hydrotesting & commissioning – impact on future system
integrity
Electrochemical cathodic protection, “sacrificial anode.”
Modification of the environment - removing acid gases
from the water or de-ionize the water to eliminate its
electrical conductivity, dehydrate the system and remove
the water altogether, addition of chemical corrosion inhibitor
59
Corrective Actions
60
Why are Corrosion Inhibitors needed?
Unprotected Metals =
↑ Corrosion Risks & Failures =
Lost Production ($$) Where did
it all go??
61
Corrosion Inhibitor
62
How do chemical inhibitors work?
63
How do chemical inhibitors work?
Oilfield corrosion inhibitors have usually been derivatives of
nitrogen called amines and organic acids. There are also
molecules containing phosphorous and sulfur that are
corrosion inhibitors.
Corrosion inhibitors form a protective layer between the
metal surface and the water. Without the metal-to-water
contact, corrosion cannot take place
64
Corrosion Inhibitor
Water
Corrosion Inhibitor
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
Corrosion Inhibitors
Fluid Dispersibilities Types of Inhibitors
Oil Soluble - non-water Inorganic
dispersible
Organic
Oil Soluble - water
dispersible Anionic
74
Chemistry of Inhibitors
75
Corrosion Inhibition
Select
the proper application technique to
accomplish these goals
76
How Inhibitors Mix
Oil
Interfacer
Water
77
“Residual” Inhibitor in Water
Inhibitor Adsorbed
onto Surface
78
Corrosion Inhibitor Applications
Continuous
Batch
79
Application of Corrosion Inhibitors
capillary
b) Continuous injection by
capillary tubing stream
Corrosion
Inhibitor
80
Application of Corrosion Inhibitors
81
Application of Corrosion Inhibitors
82
Application of Corrosion Inhibitors
83
Application of Corrosion Inhibitors - Options
84
Batch Application with Pig
Trailing pig
Inhibitor + diluent
Lead pig
Slug is sized for 3 mil film
thickness and at least 10 second contact time
85
Corrosion Inhibition
Batch Application
Regular “batch” application of inhibitor into annulus with
flush of 1 to 10 bbls
86
Monitoring and Inspection
87
Monitoring
• Acquiring data on the rate of material degradation (corrosion rate
measurement)
• Part of control measure activities:
Process Parameters
Chemical Treatment
Chemical Analysis
Pigging
• Corrosion monitoring is not a simple activity:
There are number of different types of corrosion
Corrosion may be uniform or concentrated in a small area
Corrosion rates may vary over some distances
There is no single measurement technique that will detect all
various conditions
88
Monitoring Considerations
Location of monitoring system – based on “worst-case” condition or at a
point where corrosion is expected to be most severe
Chose proper device - long-term coupon exposure vs real-time probe
sensing, simple measurement vs fully integrated surveillance units,
multiple techniques vs increased numbers of single technique
Identify parameters to be monitored – understand what is being
monitored
What part of system is being monitored – monitoring point should be
closed to system being monitored
Avoid contamination of the monitoring system – important information
may be lost due to contamination
89
Monitoring Considerations (cont.)
Use multiple techniques instead of single one – in general,
no individual technique alone is suitable for monitoring
corrosion under complex industrial conditions, very
common long-term coupon exposure is used to correlate
data from probe/instrumented sensor
Repeatability of results – monitoring device provides
consistent results
Interpretation of results – to have a clear view of corrosion
process inside the system being monitored
90
91
Pipeline Monitoring: Where do we put the
probe/spool?
Pressure = 30 bar, Shear stress = 1 Pa, CO2 = 6 mole%
7
Corrosion rate / (mm/year)
pH=5
6
pH=5.4
5 pH=6
4
3
2
1
0
0 50 100 150
Temperature / (°C)
92
Monitoring the Effectiveness of the Inhibition
93
New Technologies
‘Real-Time’ Corrosion Rate Measurement
Electrochemical Noise
High Sensitivity ER
- Ceion
- Microcorr
Field Signature Method
Erosion Monitoring
- Clampon Acoustic Sensors
- Intrusive Metal-Loss Probes
94
Corrosion Inhibition Monitoring the Program
Coupon ladder
From
well
95
Corrosion Inhibition Monitoring the Program
bottom top
middle
96
Corrosion Monitoring Probe Types
97
Flush Mounted LPR Probe
98
Electrical Resistance Probe
99
100
Subsea CEION Probe
101
CEION ™ SPOOL IN SERVICE
102
Electrochemical Noise
Monitoring of Pigging Operations
Trace describes ECN Corrosion Rate. Bars give time of receipt of spheres
0.5
0.4
mm year .
-1
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0
07/12/95 12/12/95 17/12/95 22/12/95 27/12/95 01/01/96 06/01/96 11/01/96 16/01/96
00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00 00:00
Date and Time
103
Instrumented Spool Pieces
Metal loss techniques
Applicable to different metallurgies
Differentiate between general and localised attack
Circumferential measurement Corrocean’s FSM
Technology
Monitors pipe wall
• Cormon’s RPCM Technology
> 10 years field experience
– Dedicated spool piece
Metal loss technique
104
Other Monitoring Activities
Liquids and Gas Analysis
Water content
Fe & Mn Counts
Inhibitor residual
CO2 and H2S content
Associated Analyses
Pig Water/Trash Analysis
Water corrosivity
Solids/Wax Analysis
Microbial enumeration
105
Inspection
Evaluation of the quality of material to a standard or a
specification
Also, an attempt to gain a deeper understanding on
corrosion mechanism and rate of material degradation –
more accurate than monitoring
Mostly used to identify failures “hot spots”
Often a “once-off” measurement, it compliments monitoring
activities
Choice of inspection techniques will depend on the
accuracy and cost
106
Non-Destructive Evaluation (NDE)
107
Visual – Pit Gage
108
Radiography
109
UT Measurement
110
Inspection - Intelligent Pigs
111
Smart Pigs - MFL
112
Magnetic particle indications on pipeline exterior
113