Overview of Holistic-Dynamic Theory: Third Force in Psychology
Overview of Holistic-Dynamic Theory: Third Force in Psychology
Abraham Harold (Abe) Maslow was born in Manhattan, New York, on April 1, 1908,
Maslow spent his unhappy childhood in Brooklyn. As a child, Maslow’s life was filled
with intense feelings of shyness, inferiority, and depression.
Maslow learned to hate and mistrust religion and to become a committed atheist.
After Maslow graduated from Boys High School, his cousin and friend Will encouraged
him to apply to Cornell University, but lacking self-confidence, Maslow selected the less
prestigious City College of New York.
Maslow’s father had wanted his oldest son to be a lawyer, and while attending City
College, Maslow enrolled in law school. However, he quitted, for he felt that law dealt
too much with evil people and was not sufficiently concerned with the good.
He transferred to Cornell University in upstate New York partly to be closer to his cousin
Will. After one semester at Cornell, Maslow returned to the City College of New York, to
draw nearer to Bertha Goodman, his first cousin whom he was falling in love with. The
two were soon married.
One semester before his marriage, Maslow had enrolled at the University of Wisconsin,
from which he received a BA degree in philosophy.
In 1934, Maslow received his doctorate. He enrolled in medical school but quit.
Maslow, a mediocre student during his days at City College and Cornell, scored 195 on
E.L. Thorndike’s intelligence test while working as his assistant.
During the mid-1940s, Maslow’s health began to deteriorate, he suffered from a strange
illness that left him weak, faint, and exhausted.
In 1951, Maslow took a position as chairman of the psychology department at the
recently established Brandeis University in Waltham, Massachusetts.
Maslow suffered a severe but nonfatal heart attack in December of 1967 along with
work-related problems.
He accepted an offer to join the Saga Administrative Corporation in Menlo Park,
California. He had no particular job there and was free to think and write as he wished.
He enjoyed that freedom, but on June 8, 1970, he suddenly collapsed and died of a
massive heart attack. He was 62.
Hierarchy of Needs
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs concept assumes that lower level needs must be satisfied or
at least relatively satisfied before higher level needs become motivators.
The five needs composing this hierarchy are conative needs, meaning that they have a
striving or motivational character. The needs can be arranged on a hierarchy or staircase,
with each ascending step representing a higher need but one less basic to survival.
Maslow (1970) listed the following needs in order of their prepotency: physiological,
safety, love and belongingness, esteem, and self-actualization.
1. Physiological Needs
The most basic needs of any person are physiological needs, including food,
water, oxygen, maintenance of body temperature, and so on.
People do not see beyond food, and as long as these need remains unsatisfied,
their primary motivation is to obtain something to eat.
They are the only needs that can be completely satisfied or even overly satisfied.
A second characteristic peculiar to physiological needs is their recurring nature.
2. Safety Needs
When people have partially satisfied their physiological needs, they become
motivated by safety needs, including physical security, stability, dependency,
protection, and freedom from threatening forces such as war, terrorism, illness,
fear, anxiety, danger, chaos, and natural disasters.
Safety needs cannot be overly satiated.
Children are more often motivated by safety needs because they live with such
threats as darkness, animals, strangers, and punishments from parents.
Some adults also feel relatively unsafe because they retain irrational fears from
childhood. They spend far more energy than do healthy people trying to satisfy
safety needs, and when they are not successful in their attempts, they suffer from
what Maslow (1970) called basic anxiety.
3. Love and Belongingness Needs
After people partially satisfy their physiological and safety needs, they become
motivated by love and belongingness needs, such as the desire for friendship; the
wish for a mate and children; the need to belong to a family, a club, a
neighborhood, or a nation.
It also includes some aspects of sex and human contact as well as the need to both
give and receive love.
People who have had their love and belongingness needs adequately satisfied
from early years do not panic when denied love.
People who have never experienced love and belongingness, therefore, are
incapable of giving love.
People who have received only a little amount of love have stronger needs for
affection and acceptance.
Children need love in order to grow psychologically, and their attempts to satisfy
this need are usually straightforward and direct. Adults, too, need love, but their
attempts to attain it are sometimes cleverly disguised.
4. Esteem Needs
This includes self-respect, confidence, competence, and the knowledge that others
hold them in high esteem.
Maslow (1970) identified two levels of esteem needs—reputation and self-
esteem
a. Reputation is the perception of the prestige, recognition, or fame a person has
achieved in the eyes of others.
b. Self-esteem is a person’s own feelings of worth and confidence. It is based on
real competence and not merely on others’ opinions.
5. Self-Actualization Needs
Once esteem needs are met, people do not always move to the level of self-
actualization.
Self-actualization needs include self-fulfillment, the realization of all one’s
potential, and a desire to become creative in the full sense of the word.
Self-actualizers are not dependent on the satisfaction of either love or esteem
needs; they become independent from the lower level needs that gave them birth.
Maslow identified three other categories of needs—aesthetic, cognitive, and
neurotic.
Aesthetic Needs
Aesthetic needs are not universal, but at least some people in every
culture seem to be motivated by the need for beauty and
aesthetically pleasing experiences.
People with strong aesthetic needs desire beautiful and orderly
surroundings, and when these needs are not met, they become sick
in the same way that they become sick when their conative needs
are frustrated.
Cognitive Needs
This is the desire to know, to solve mysteries, to understand, and to
be curious.
When cognitive needs are blocked, all needs on Maslow’s
hierarchy are threatened; that is, knowledge is necessary to satisfy
each of the five conative needs.
Maslow (1968b, 1970) believed that healthy people desire to know
more, to theorize, to test hypotheses, to uncover mysteries, or to
find out how something works just for the satisfaction of knowing.
People who have not satisfied their cognitive needs, who have been
consistently lied to, have had their curiosity stifled, or have been
denied information, become pathological, a pathology that takes
the form of skepticism, disillusionment, and cynicism.
Neurotic Needs
Neurotic needs lead only to stagnation and pathology.
Neurotic needs are non-productive. They perpetuate an unhealthy
style of life and have no value in the striving for self-actualization.
Neurotic needs are usually reactive; that is, they serve as
compensation for unsatisfied basic needs.
It makes little difference for ultimate health whether a neurotic
need be gratified or frustrated.
Maslow (1970) estimated that the hypothetical average person has his or her needs
satisfied to approximately these levels: physiological, 85%; safety, 70%; love and
belongingness, 50%; esteem, 40%; and self-actualization, 10%.
The more a lower level need is satisfied, the greater the emergence of the next level need.
Needs, therefore, emerge gradually, and a person may be simultaneously motivated by
needs from two or more levels.
Unmotivated Behavior
Some behaviors are not motivated. In other words, not all determinants are motives.
Some behavior is not caused by needs but by other factors such as conditioned reflexes,
maturation, or drugs.
Much of what Maslow (1970) called “expressive behavior” is unmotivated.
Deprivation of Needs
Lack of satisfaction of any of the basic needs leads to some kind of pathology.
Deprivation of physiological needs results in malnutrition, fatigue, loss of energy,
obsession with sex, and so on.
Threats to one’s safety lead to fear, insecurity, and dread.
When love needs go unfulfilled, a person becomes defensive, overly aggressive, or
socially timid.
Lack of esteem results in the illnesses of self-doubt, self-depreciation, and lack of
confidence.
Deprivation of self-actualization needs also leads to pathology, or more accurately,
metapathology, Maslow (1967) defined as the absence of values, the lack of fulfillment,
and the loss of meaning in life.
Self-Actualization
Maslow’s ideas on self-actualization began soon after he received his PhD, when he
became puzzled about why two of his teachers in New York City—anthropologist
Ruth Benedict and psychologist Max Wertheimer—were so different from average
people. To Maslow, these two people represented the highest level of human
development, and he called this level “self-actualization.”
Values of Self-Actualizers
Maslow (1971) held that self-actualizing people are motivated by the “eternal verities,”
what he called B-values.
These “Being” values are indicators of psychological health and are opposed to
deficiency needs, which motivate non-self-actualizers. He distinguished between ordinary
need motivation and the motives of self-actualizing people, which he called
metamotivation.
Maslow (1964, 1970) identified 14 B-values, but the exact number is not important
because ultimately all become one, or at least all are highly correlated. These values
distinguish self-actualizing people from those whose psychological growth is stunted
after they reach esteem needs.
The values of self-actualizing people include truth, goodness, beauty, wholeness or the
transcendence of dichotomies, aliveness or spontaneity, uniqueness, perfection,
completion, justice and order, simplicity, richness or totality, effortlessness, playfulness
or humor, and self-sufficiency or autonomy.
Maslow (1970) hypothesized that when people’s metaneeds are not met or deprivation of
any of the B-values results in metapathology, or the lack of a meaningful philosophy of
life.
Before people can become self-actualizing, they must satisfy their love and
belongingness needs.
Self-actualizing people do not love because they expect something in return. They simply
love and are loved. Their love is never harmful. It is the kind of love that allows lovers to
be relaxed, open, and non-secretive (Maslow, 1970).
Philosophy of Science
Maslow (1966) believed that value-free science does not lead to the proper study of
human personality.
Maslow argued for a different philosophy of science, a humanistic, holistic approach that
is not value free and that has scientists who care about the people and topics they
investigate.
Maslow agreed with Allport (see Chapter 13) that psychological science should place
more emphasis on the study of the individual and less on the study of large groups.
Subjective reports should be favored over rigidly objective ones, and people should be
allowed to tell about themselves in a holistic fashion instead of the more orthodox
approach that studies people in bits and pieces.
His observation of a cold and calloused procedure done by surgeons in medical school
led Maslow to originate the concept of desacralization: that is, the type of science that
lacks emotion, joy, wonder, awe, and rapture.
Maslow believed that orthodox science has no ritual or ceremony; and he called for
scientists to put values, creativity, emotion, and ritual back into their work. Scientists
must be willing to resacralize science or to instill it with human values, emotion, and
ritual.
Maslow (1966) argued for a Taoistic attitude for psychology, one that would be
noninterfering, passive, and receptive.
Maslow insisted that psychologists must themselves be healthy people, able to tolerate
ambiguity and uncertainty. They must be intuitive, nonrational, insightful, and
courageous enough to ask the right questions. They must also be willing to flounder, to be
imprecise, to question their own procedures, and to take on the important problems of
psychology.
Measuring Self-Actualization
According to Maslow (1970), everyone is born with a will toward health, a tendency to
grow toward self-actualization, but few people reach it. Growth toward normal, healthy
personality can be blocked at each of the steps in the hierarchy of needs.
Another obstacle that often blocks people’s growth toward self-actualization is the Jonah
complex, or the fear of being one’s best.
The Jonah complex is characterized by attempts to run away from one’s destiny just as
the biblical Jonah tried to escape from his fate
The Jonah complex, which is found in nearly everyone, represents a fear of success, a
fear of being one’s best, and a feeling of awesomeness in the presence of beauty and
perfection.
First, the human body is simply not strong enough to endure the ecstasy of fulfillment for
any length of time.
Second, most people, he reasoned, have private ambition to be great. however, when they
compare themselves with those who have accomplished greatness, they are appalled by
their own arrogance: “Who am I to think I could do as well as this great person?”
Although the Jonah complex stands out most sharply in neurotic people, nearly everyone
has some timidity toward seeking perfection and greatness. People allow false humility to
stifle creativity, and thus they prevent themselves from becoming self-actualizing.
REFERENCE:
Feist G. & Feist J. 2008. Theories of Personality 7th Edition. United States of
America: The McGraw−Hill Companies, Inc.
REFLECTION
Just like what Abraham Maslow stated in his Holistic Dynamic Theory, as a human being, I do
have physiological or biological needs, the need to be safe and secured, need for affection and
belonginess, to be appreciated, and if possible, has needs for realization of one’s potential. I
agree with Maslow that it is not necessarily mean that those needs identified by him is of fixed
sequence.
In fact, in this time of pandemic, the world as it is faced with a life-threatening COVID-19 virus,
many people are prioritizing their safety needs even over physiological needs. Some are forced
to stay home even to the expense of giving up their jobs just to satisfy their safety needs. One of
which is me with my family. During the Enhanced Community Quarantine, my older siblings
who used to be working as a janitress and as a mechanic in order to sustain the needs of our
family were forced to leave their jobs behind with fear to be infected by the said deadly virus. As
our parents told us once, “We can earn money anytime we want to, but we cannot anymore
restore life once it’s gone.” We did endure a life with uncertainty of whether we will have some
food to eat the next day or clean water to drink. We made sure every family member will be safe.
Even my siblings who were stranded in Luzon, do the same thing as well. Their scenario is
worse than we had because of the same reason, our need for safety.
As we are currently threatened by this infectious and deadly virus and its disease, some of our
needs are deprived. This causes many individuals mild to severe depression. I, myself suffer
from a mild depression these past months of lockdown because of tomorrow’s uncertainty and
feeling useless and doing nothing productive, the situation of my siblings in Luzon, our situation
in our house with scarce resources, and our safety needs are compromised. Hence, with our
needs, it motivates us to do some things in order to satisfy whatever our needs are, may it be
physiological, security, belongingness, esteem, or self-actualization.
Another thing that I can relate about Maslow’s theory is that of what he believes in: “People who
have never experienced love and belongingness, therefore, are incapable of giving love.” I am
often being asked why I can forgive and not be mad even to those who have done evil things
unto me. I always told them that I myself do not know the reason. I was even told that I may be
is pretentious because I show no rage against those people. With that, there are times especially
when I am alone, I would shed tears being judged and talked that way. Good thing, I was able to
read the theory of Maslow and that my long-time question was then answered. On the contrary,
earlier this year, a friend of mine show some signs of depression and to the point where she even
desperately asked her boyfriend for them to live together under a roof and settle a family. She
came from a broken family and an institution took care of her since her parents got separated and
had to live with a drunkard father. It became known to me that my behavior is because I was able
to feel sufficient love and affection from my very own family and that the behavior of my friend
who have stronger needs for affection or acceptance is because he received only a little amount
of love and that it is not from her biological family. It actually remains a big question in our
OIKOS community the reason why she opted to choose to leave the life behind where her needs
are secured and provided for her in exchange of strong need for love and belongingness. Having
read the theory, my puzzled mind became even more oriented of a possible reason of her
decision.
APPLICATION
The theory of personality proposed by Abraham Maslow is very much of use in the social work
profession. Not just that it can be used to analyze the clients’ behavior but can be also a reference
to identify the necessary interventions needed by the clients to solve their problems and enhance
their social functioning.
The hierarchy of needs is the widely used reference in identifying and categorizing the needs of
individual/s, family, groups, and community almost in all areas of profession especially to social
work. The needs identified by Maslow applies to everyone and with its help, it will then be easy
for the social workers to analyze and collect the information they need about their clients. It can
also be a source of information in identifying whether the client’s behavior is pathological or not.
In return, the social workers will be also having the necessary knowledge how they can help
those clients suffering from such state.
This theory is also a good source of nourishment for the soul for the social workers, not just for
the clients since it contains information that are helpful for one to become an effective extender
of help and service, particularly the “Fifteen (15) Tentative Qualities of Self-actualized People”
listed by Abraham. The fact that as social workers, we have to acquire necessary qualities, so we
can share it to our clients better. As they say, “We cannot give what we do not have.” And that,
we have to have such good qualities for us to effectively partake it to the clients.