Ishares Market Perspectives: 2011 Outlook Four Scenarios To Watch in The Coming Year
Ishares Market Perspectives: 2011 Outlook Four Scenarios To Watch in The Coming Year
2
to climb courtesy of federal deficit spending. The dirty little secret Investment strategy
is that despite the financial crisis, overall US non-financial debt has First, investors should look at raising their equity allocation and
climbed by nearly $4 trillion, or over 10%, since the end of 2007 (See lowering their fixed-income exposure. While the recovery will be
Chart 1). Finally, the extension of the Bush tax cuts and long-term weak it will be a recovery. Today, particularly in the United States,
unemployment benefits is unambiguously pro-cyclical. While adding fixed-income yields remain near record lows and real yields are also
to the country’s long term imbalances, i.e. the deficit, both measures close to their bottom. While equities are not as cheap as the 2009
will add to disposable income and by extension economic activity. bottom, they appear reasonably valued and should have room for
CHART 1 further multiple expansion.
Total US Non-Financial Debt Overall, US equity markets look well positioned for a good year.
Stocks in the United States will likely benefit from the low inflation/
40000
rate environment. Typically, US large caps trade with a multiple in the
35000 high teens when inflation and interest rates are this low. With the S&P
500 trading at 15x trailing earnings, there is room for modest multiple
Debt in $ Billions
The other crucial indicator of inflation will be commodity prices, Why this is not likely
particularly food. Unlike developed countries, food constitutes The global double dip is arguably the biggest threat to risky assets
a significant portion of a consumption basket in most emerging in 2011. While possible it still remains less likely than the grudging,
markets. For example, in China food prices constitute one-third grinding recovery we’ve been experiencing the last 6 to 12 months.
of the CPI basket. Any supply disruptions will complicate the inflation
Absent a policy error or exogenous shock the global recovery, while
picture in emerging markets, and raise the likelihood that emerging
fragile, appears self-sustaining. While it is true that significant risks
market central banks will need to tighten more aggressively.
remain – most notably unsustainable sovereign debt in most of the
developed world including the United States – the debt issue is unlikely
3
to erupt in 2011. Instead, a weak economy is likely to give the United CHART 3
States another year of breathing space. As long as private demand Chinese Purchasing Managers Index 2008 to Present
for credit remains anemic and the Fed is engaged in asset purchases,
we are unlikely to see a large-scale sell-off in the Treasury market. 70
As the accompanying chart demonstrates, over the last few decades, If the risks of a double dip rise, investors may want to reduce their
government payments to individuals have constituted an ever larger exposure to equities, lower their beta, and – despite record low
share of income. The extension of unemployment benefits is obviously yields – reembrace US Treasuries and the dollar. Unlike the baseline
supportive, but investors should remain focused on other policy allocation, under this scenario investors may want to dramatically
issues, such as Social Security, that impact disposable income. raise their allocation to bonds, lower their allocation to stocks, and
In short, while contributing to the long-term fiscal imbalance, in the keep their remaining funds in cash.
near term equity markets are dependent on continuing government As inflation is likely to drop, investors may want to overweight sectors
generosity. A sudden embrace of fiscal austerity would, at least that have traditionally done well with little pricing power. Historically,
in the near term, endanger the recovery and equity markets. consumer staples and healthcare have done best in this environment.
CHART 2
More aggressive investors may also want to consider going long
less traditional assets, such as volatility. Equity market volatility is
Transfer Payments as a % of Disposable Income
currently pricing in an economic recovery and stable credit markets.
23 A recession, particularly if it was accompanied by widening credit
Transfer Pymts/Disposable Income (%)
17
15
Scenario 3: Global Inflation
13
Probability 10%
11
9
What it would look like
4
While unconventional monetary policy has raised the long-term risk of Factors to watch
inflation, there are several factors conspiring to prevent a meaningful The key factors to watch that would indicate an accelerating risk
acceleration in inflation in 2011. First, the global economy still suffers of inflation are bank lending and money supply growth, capacity
from too much capacity. In the United States, capacity utilization utilization and labor market growth.
is stuck at around 75%, versus a long-term average of above 80%.
Inflation has rarely accelerated until capacity utilization climbs above As discussed above, the inflation of the 1970’s was preceded by an
its long-term average, and even then it takes a year or so to get going. explosion in bank lending. Between 1972 and the end of 1973, US
commercial and industrial loan demand grew by approximately 15%
Not only is there too much spare capacity in the manufacturing year-over-year on average. As of October 2010, US loan growth was
sector, but obviously the same problem exists in the labor markets. down more than 8% year-over-year. Until loan growth recovers the
While slowly recovering, job creation in most developed countries near-term risk of a surge in the money supply, and a corresponding
is a long way away from the levels that have typically been associated rise in inflation, is limited (see Chart 5).
with wage inflation. In the United States, inflation has been rare until
the growth in jobs starts to exceed the growth in the population. CHART 5
Practically, this means inflation is less of a risk until non-farm payrolls US Commercial & Industrial Loan Demand
start to grow by 1.0% to 1.5% a year. Currently, non-farm payrolls 0.04
in the United States are up only 0.35% from a year ago.
balance sheet over the past 2 years and plans to add another $600
0.00
billion in asset purchases during the first half of 2011. Given the
expansion in the monetary base, how can you not get inflation? -0.01
-0.02
CHART 4
8 Quarters
7 Quarters While loan growth is significantly stronger in emerging markets, recent
6 Quarters
policy changes appear to be effective in dampening growth. In China,
5 Quarters
4 Quarters
loan growth is down by nearly 50% from a year ago (see Chart 6).
3 Quarters
CHART 6
2 Quarters
1 Quarters China Total Loans Financial Institutions YOY
0 Lag
40
-0.05 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40
Quarterly Lag 35
Source: Bloomberg
YOY Change in %
30
The key is bank lending. While the Fed has aggressively created new 25
base, the money supply includes checking account deposits but not
Source: Bloomberg
bank reserves). Until banks resume lending, the mechanism by which
the Fed’s monetary policy gets transmitted to the broader economy Investment strategy
is temporarily broken. This dramatically lowers the risk of inflation
next year, as even when the money supply eventually starts to In the unlikely event that the leading indicators of inflation – spare
accelerate; it typically takes two to three years to see the impact capacity, loan and money supply growth, labor market conditions –
in inflation (see Chart 4). start to flash yellow, investors may want to lower their allocation
5
to stocks (while stocks actually provide a decent inflation hedge be repeated, but some of them are likely to reverse in a way that will
over the long term, they generally suffer during the initial stages create an ongoing headwind for markets. First, both interest rates
of a pickup in inflation), bonds (TIPS and other inflation-linked and inflation are more likely to rise than fall over the long term. And
bonds being the exception), and raise their allocation to commodities. should that not prove the case, lower rates and lower inflation would
The asset allocation under an unexpected spike in inflation could imply Japanese-style deflation, not a particularly good environment
be more heavily weighted toward commodities, with the bond for any asset class other than bonds. At the same time, the peace
allocation dramatically reduced and the equity portion moderately dividend that was enjoyed has long since been eaten up in the form
reduced from the baseline. of two regional wars and an ongoing extension of the global security
apparatus. Finally, and most significantly, aging populations will put
Commodities have historically been the best performing asset class
increasing fiscal pressure on most developed economies. Rather
during the early stages of inflation, with gold in particular generally
than the rare budget surpluses that were present in the late 1990s,
providing an inflation hedge. Within investors’ stock portfolios, energy
most developed countries face daunting fiscal challenges that are
has historically been the most resilient sector under inflation (it has
secular rather than cyclical in nature – in other words the deficits
also performed well under a weak dollar regime) while investors may
do not go away even when the economy recovers.
want to underweight consumer discretionary and financial stocks,
the sectors that have historically had the highest negative correlation One other factor makes a return to the nirvana of the late 1990s unlikely.
with inflation. The 20-year bull market in equities and the 30-year bull market
in bonds were both preceded by secular bear markets in both asset
Finally, while many investors also consider REITs a good inflation
classes. As a result, both bonds and stocks started the early 1980s
hedge, the historical evidence is that REITs behave more like stocks
at historically cheap valuations. Equities, in particular, reached trough
than physical real estate. When inflation accelerates, REITs tend
valuations that had not been seen since the 1930s (see Chart 7).
to suffer the same multiple contraction as traditional equities.
CHART 7
45 18
Low inflation, strong growth, buoyant equity markets 40
1981
16
Probability 10% 35 1929 14
30 1901 12
What it would look like 25
1966
10
6
in March 2011. This could arguably provide a catalyst for a more Conclusion
serious discussion of the long-term deficit. Second, in the United
Kingdom does the coalition government stick to its planned spending “Give me chastity and continence, but not yet” - Augustine of Hippo
cuts? Finally, watch Spain. Spain is important as it is the largest, After the drama of the last four years, our baseline scenario for 2011
by far, of the sovereign debt risks in Europe. Loosening restrictions is for a temporary lull, and probably a good year for equities. Bonds
in the Spanish labor market coupled with further consolidation of the are likely to hold up, at least through the first half of the year, but given
smaller Spanish banks (cajas) would represent important structural valuations and supply issues they don’t appear to offer the best value.
reform and help lower the risk of an eventual EU debt crisis.
That said, it is important to note that our relatively sanguine
We are skeptical, particularly in the United States, that we will outlook for next year does not imply that the global economy has
see any real fiscal reform in 2011. Countries rarely enact painful put its troubles behind it. On the contrary, many of the structural
fiscal restructurings without a catalyst and an election. In the past, imbalances that pushed us into the global crisis are still with us,
fiscal reform – for example, Canada and Sweden – only occurred albeit in an altered form. Ironically, many of the policies that are likely
following an election and change in government. While the United to promote a decent year for economies and markets, i.e. extension
Kingdom obviously satisfied that criteria, it suggests that real of the Bush tax cuts and maintaining transfer payments to individuals,
reform in the United States is unlikely until after the 2012 election. will exacerbate the longer-term imbalances. At some point, the strain
Investment strategy is likely to begin to show even on the largest and richest nations, the
United States, but that is probably not an issue for 2011.
In the unlikely event that the United States, European Union, and
Japan summon up the political coverage for meaningful fiscal reform,
investors could consider going long risky assets, specifically equities
and high yield. Again, commodities are likely to perform respectably,
but the absence of any inflationary pressure implies that equities,
not commodities, will be the best performing asset class. Under
the Goldilocks scenario, equities could have a significant overweight,
bonds a modest allocation, and the remaining part of the portfolio
in cyclical (i.e., not precious metals) commodities.
7
Regulatory Information
BlackRock Advisors (UK) Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority (‘FSA’), has issued this document for access
by Professional Clients in Austria, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Iceland, Israel, Italy, Luxembourg, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, the Dubai
International Financial Centre (DIFC), the Netherlands and the UK only and no other person should rely upon the information contained within it.
For investors in Iceland
The funds mentioned in this document are not registered for public distribution in Iceland. The investment described in this memorandum is not a public
offering of securities. It is not registered for public distribution in Iceland with the Financial Supervisory Authority pursuant to the Icelandic Act on Undertakings
for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities (UCITS) and investment Funds No. 30/2003 and supplementary regulations. The investment may not be
offered or sold by means of this memorandum or anyway later resold otherwise than in accordance with Article 13 of the Regulation on UCITS and Investment
Funds No. 792/2003. This document is intended for information purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to sell or a solicitation
of an offer to buy the funds described within and no steps may be taken which would constitute or result in a public offering of the funds in Iceland. This
document is strictly confidential and may not be distributed without authorisation from BlackRock Advisors (UK) Limited.
Please read the prospectus and ensure that you are eligible to invest under the local regulatory and financial rules, and comply with restrictions on foreign
currency investments, that exist for Icelandic investors. We recommend that you seek independent financial advice before making any investment decision.
This document is for your information only. Accordingly, this document and relevant information may not be used for any other purpose or passed on to any
other person in Iceland. The funds described in this document are not registered for public distribution in Iceland and may not be offered, sold or resold to
the public in Iceland.
Restricted Investors
This document is not, and under no circumstances is to be construed as, an advertisement, or any other step in furtherance of a public offering of shares in
the United States or Canada. This document is not aimed at persons who are resident in the United States, Canada or any province or territory thereof, where
the Companies are not authorised or registered for distribution and where no prospectus for the Companies has been filed with any securities commission
iSMP-SNUGIFLADIs_DeFi NoSwIc_I_1210
or regulatory authority. The Companies may not be acquired or owned by, or acquired with the assets of, an ERISA Plan.
Risk Warnings
iShares may not be suitable for all investors. BlackRock Advisors (UK) Limited does not guarantee the performance of the shares or funds. The price of the
investments (which may trade in limited markets) may go up or down and the investor may not get back the amount invested. Your income is not fixed and
may fluctuate. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. The value of the investment involving exposure to foreign currencies can be
affected by exchange rate movements. We remind you that the levels and bases of, and reliefs from, taxation can change. Affiliated companies of BlackRock
Advisors (UK) Limited may make markets in the securities mentioned in this document. Further, BlackRock Advisors (UK) Limited and/or its affiliated
companies and/or their employees from time to time may hold shares or holdings in the underlying shares of, or options on, any security included in this
document and may as principal or agent buy or sell securities. In addition, investing in emerging markets involves certain risks and special considerations
not typically associated with investing in other markets.
'iShares' is a registered trademark of BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, N.A. All other trademarks, servicemarks or registered trademarks are the
property of their respective owners. © 2010 BlackRock Advisors (UK) Limited. Registered Company No. 00796793. All rights reserved. Calls may be
monitored or recorded.