BTS - Volume I Main Report PDF
BTS - Volume I Main Report PDF
Final Report
Volume I: Main Report
Intercontinental Consultants
and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd.
A-8, Green Park, New Delhi - 110 016, India
in association with
DATACONSULT LIMITED
PPF House, 5th Floor, Samora Avenue,
P. O. Box 75439, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
September, 2009
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
GLOSSARY OF ABBREVIATIONS
1.0 STUDY Background
1.1 TANZANIA IN BRIEF 1.1
1.1.1 ECONOMIC SETTING 1.1
1.2 ROAD NETWORK & TRANSPORTATION IN TANZANIA 1.3
1.3 ESTIMATION OF TRAFFIC IN TANZANIA–AN OVERVIEW 1.3
1.4 STUDY OBJECTIVES 1.4
1.5 SCOPE OF THE STUDY 1.4
1.6 IMPORTANCE & USEFULNESS OF THE STUDY 1.5
1.7 REPORTS SUBMITTED 1.5
1.7.1 DRAFT FINAL REPORT 1.5
1.8 TRAINING FOR TANROADS STAFF 1.5
1.9 FINAL REPORT (PRESENT REPORT) 1.6
1.9.1 THE REPORT STRUCTURE & COVERAGE 1.6
1.10 IMPORTANT MILESTONES OF THE STUDY 1.7
2.0 GENERAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY
2.1 GENERAL 2.1
2.2 APPROACH & METHODOLOGY 2.1
2.2.1 TASK GROUP 101: REVIEW OF THE EARLIER TRAFFIC CENSUS 2.1
RELATED STUDIES
2.2.2 TASK GROUP 102: ESTABLISHING TRAFFIC COUNTING LOCATIONS 2.1
2.2.3 TASK GROUP 103: COLLECTION & REVIEW OF SECONDARY DATA 2.2
2.2.4 TASK GROUP 104: COMPREHENSIVE TRAFFIC CENSUS 2.3
2.2.5 TASK GROUP 105: PROCESSING & ANALYZING TRAFFIC COUNT DATA 2.4
2.2.6 TASK GROUP 106: DESIGN OF COMPUTERIZED TRAFFIC 2.5
CENSUS DATABASE
2.2.7 TASK GROUP 107: TRAINING TO THE TANROADS COUNTERPART STAFF 2.6
2.2.8 DATABASE 2.7
2.3 LESSONS LEARNT 2.8
2.4 ESTABLISHMENT OF COUNTING POINTS 2.8
2.5 COMMENCEMENT OF TRAFFIC SURVEYS 2.8
2.6 BASE YEAR TRAFFIC & TRAFFIC FORECAST 2.9
2.7 OVERSEAS TRAINING OF THE TANROADS COUNTERPARTS 2.9
2.8 SUM UP 2.9
3.0 CONCEPTUAL DESIGN OF TRAFFIC CENSUS
3.1 GENERAL 3.1
3.2 ESTABLISHING THE BASELINE TRAFFIC 3.1
3.2.1 DURATION OF COUNTS 3.2
3.3 ROAD NETWORK & CATEGORY OF ROADS IN TANZANIA 3.2
i
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
ii
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
iii
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
iv
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
v
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
MAPS
MAP 4.1/1 – 4.1/10 CATCHMENT AREA OF THE SPECIFIC TRAFFIC SECTION IN THE REGIONS
ANNEXURES
1.1 PRESENTATION ON DRAFT FINAL REPORT - LIST OF PARTICIPANTS A-1
1.2 A REPORT ON THE TRAINING FOR TANROADS STAFF A-3
1.2-1 TRAINING FOR TANROADS STAFF – LIST OF PARTICIPANTS A-6
1.2-2 TRAINING PROGRAM SCHEDULE AND COVERAGE A-7
1.2-3 QUESTIONNAIRE ON TRAINING FEEDBACK AND EVALUATION A-8
1.2-4 TO 1.2-7 ANALYSIS OF TRAINING FEEDBACK AND EVALUATION FORMS A-9
1.3 COMMENTS ON THE DRAFT FINAL REPORT A-13
2.1 CHECKLIST FOR COLLECTING INFORMATION DURING THE A-16
FIELD VISIT OF THE PROJECT TRAFFIC ENGINEERS
2.2 OVERSEAS TRAINING PROGRAM OF TANROADS OFFICIALS A-18
AT ICT NEW DELHI, INDIA
3.1 CATCHMENT’S AREA OF SPECIFIC TRAFFIC COUNT POINTS FOR A-20
APPLYING TAFS
3.2 PAVEMENT CONDITION CRITERIA IN TANZANIA A-25
4.1 PLAN FOR TRAFFIC COUNTING ON THE PRIMARY ROAD NETWORK A-26
IN TANZANIA (1988-1996)
4.2 PROPOSED TRAFFIC SECTIONS AND COUNT STATIONS ON THE A-38
TRUNK AND REGIONAL ROADS
4.3 PHYSICAL FEATURES OF TRAFFIC SECTIONS OBSERVED DURING A-46
THE RECONNAISSANCE SURVEY
vi
Glossary of Abbreviations
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
GLOSSARY OF ABBREVIATIONS
AADT ANNUAL AVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC
ADT AVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC
ANPR AUTOMATIC NUMBER PLATE READER
ASCII AMERICAN STANDARD CODE FOR INFORMATION INTERCHANGE
ATC AIR TANZANIA CORPORATION
ATTCs AUTOMATIC TRAFFIC COUNTERS & CLASSIFIERS
CD COMPACT DISK
CPs COUNT POINTS
DANIDA DANISH INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
DCL DATACONSULT LTD.
DFR DRAFT FINAL REPORT
DTV DAILY TRAFFIC VOLUME
FHWA FEDERAL HIGHWAY ADMINISTRATION
FPR FIRST PROGRESS REPORT
GDP GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT
GR GROWTH RATE
GUI GRAPHICAL USER INTERFACE
HDM-4 HIGHWAY DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT
HTV HOURLY TRAFFIC VOLUME
ICT INTERCONTINENTAL CONSULTANTS AND TECHNOCRATS PVT. LTD.
IRP INTEGRATED ROADS PROJECT
MCW MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATION AND WORKS
MDGs MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS
MoCW MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATION AND WORKS
MoW MINISTRY OF WORKS
MPR MONTHLY PROGRESS REPORT
MTAFs MONTHLY TRAFFIC ADJUSTMENT FACTORS
NMT NON-MOTORIZED TRAFFIC
NPV NET PRESENT VALUE
NTCP NATIONAL TRAFFIC COUNTING PLAN
ODBC OPEN DATA BASE CONNECTIVITY
pa PER ANNUM
PMO-RALG PRIME MINISTER’S OFFICE, REGIONAL ADMINISTRATION & LOCAL GOVERNMENT
PRU PLANNING AND RESEARCH UNIT
RDBMS RELATIONAL DATABASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
RED ROAD ECONOMIC DECISION
RFP REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL
RMI ROAD MANAGEMENT INITIATIVE
RMMS ROAD MAINTENANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
RSDP ROAD SECTOR DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM
RSDSP ROAD SECTOR DEVELOPMENT SUPPORT PROGRAM
TA TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
TAFs TRAFFIC ADJUSTMENT FACTORS
TANROADS TANZANIA NATIONAL ROADS AGENCY
TAZARA TANZANIA- ZAMBIA RAILWAY AUTHORITY
TIDB TRAFFIC INFORMATION DATABASE
ToR TERMS OF REFERENCE
TPA TANZANIA PORTS AUTHORITY
TRL TRANSPORT RESEARCH LABORATORY
UTM UNIVERSAL TRANSVERSE MERCATOR
VCHV VEHICLE CLASS HOURLY VOLUME
VOC VEHICLE OPERATING COST
WAN WIDE AREA NETWORK
vii
1.
Executive Summary
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.0 STUDY BACKGROUND (29,847 km) is reported to be in “good” category.
TANROADS is, however, committed for “Good
Roads for National Development”.
1.1 General
Tanzania, located in East Africa, is surrounded 1.3 Estimation of Traffic in Tanzania
by Kenya and Uganda in the north, Rwanda,
Burundi and Democratic Republic of Congo in Road management and planning for socio-
the west, Zambia and Malawi in southwest, economic development requires reliable and
Mozambique in south, and the Indian Ocean in latest data on traffic movement and road
the east. The port of Dar es Salaam (Tanzania) condition, particularly when fast development in
serves many land-locked neighboring countries different sectors of the economy is taking place.
linked by the Trunk Roads, the Tanzania Zambia There have been considerable changes in
Railways (TAZARA), and the Tanzania Railways transport sectors, modal choices and movement
Corporation (TRC)1. pattern. It was reported that currently,
TANROADS3 did not have a comprehensive and
Tanzania Mainland2 measures about 885,000 reliable method of collecting and updating traffic
km2 of area accommodating more than 41.8 data on its primary road network of the Trunk
million of population (2008 estimates), forming a Roads (10,601 km), and Regional Roads (19,247
density of more than 42 persons/km2. The km).
population growth at 2.9% pa, the literacy rate as
71%, and life expectancy at birth as 51 years Moreover, the traffic data presently collected or
have been recorded in the country. For updated for certain roads in the country for short
administrative and planning purposes, Tanzania duration of time for determining the annual
is divided into 26 regions (mikoa), twenty-one on average daily traffic (AADT), the traffic adjustment
the mainland and five on Zanzibar (three on factors (TAFs) being used were old, as they were
Unguja, two on Pemba). There are 130 districts based on the results of the traffic surveys in 1985,
(wilaya) in Tanzania, 120 in the mainland and 10 and the analysis carried out in 1987. It was highly
in Zanzibar and Pemba. realized that the TAFs (1987) currently used in
Tanzania for determining the AADT might not
yield reliable traffic figures using any short
1.2 Road Network & Transportation duration traffic counts for any specific traffic
in Tanzania sections of the road network under TANROADS.
The contribution of transport and So, there was an urgent need for getting the TAFs
communications in process of socio-economic revised and also the traffic figures on all the Trunk
development in any developing countries, and and Regional Road Network updated.
also in Tanzania, does not require any special With this background, establishing a reliable
emphasis. The importance of road sector in database for proper road sector planning,
Tanzania has been growing within the country, particularly the road-network under TANROADS,
and also for the nearby landlocked countries. In and traffic estimates in future with workable
order to cater to the growing transport demand, methods and techniques, the present Study
the total number of motorized vehicles in aimed at carrying out traffic counts on the Trunk
Tanzania has increased to more than 382,150 and Regional Roads as well as estimating the
(2007 estimates) with a growth rate of 9.1% pa traffic adjustment factors (TAFs).
since 1995. The contribution of transport and
communications sub-sector to the country’s GDP The Study was entrusted to Intercontinental
has also been growing, which recorded at 7.6% Consultants and Technocrats Pvt. Ltd., India in
pa since 1998. The total road network in association with Dataconsult Ltd., Tanzania by
Tanzania measures 86,472 km (July 2009) with TANROADS to “Carrying out Baseline Traffic
only 7.5% of the paved roads (mainly Trunk Counts in Tanzania Mainland and Establishment
Roads), and only 58% (2009) of the road of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology
network under Tanzania National Roads Agency for TANROADS”. The Study was commenced in
1
Now known as Tanzania Railways Limited.
2
The islands of Zanzibar are situated some 30 km 3
Based on the Background given in the ToR.
from the Mainland in the Indian Ocean.
E.1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
the fourth week of August 2007 with the commencement of the traffic census; and (iii)
following major objectives. information on the establishment of database,
completion of the system design and trial run. The
2.0 STUDY OBJECTIVES three progress Reports, therefore, submitted are
as follows:
The objective of the study as referred to in the
Terms of Reference (ToR), was to establish a (i) Conceptual Design and Traffic Counts
reliable traffic census methodology, plan and Methodology, i.e. First Progress Report
implement the collection of baseline classified (December 2007);
traffic data during a one-year period, and update
or revise all appropriate traffic adjustment factors (ii) Establishment of Counting Stations and
for Tanzania. This would include the preparation Commencement of the Traffic Census, i.e.
of an overall conceptual design and a generic Second Progress Report (March 2008); and
methodology for a network-wide traffic census. (iii) Establishment of Database: Completion
of the System Design & Trial Run, i.e.
3.0 IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY Third Progress Report: (June 2008).
The present Study on Carrying out Baseline
Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland and 4.1 Draft Final Report
Establishing a Comprehensive Traffic Census
The Draft Final Report was submitted in July
Methodology for TANROADS, aimed at
2009. The Draft Final Report consisted of three
organizing traffic count surveys on the primary
volumes: (i) the Main Report in Volume I; (ii)
road network, i.e. the Trunk and Regional Roads
Traffic Survey Results in Volume II; and (iii) User
in Tanzania at suitable locations to capture the
Manual: Traffic Surveys & Traffic Information
major traffic flow pattern and other important
Database (TIDB) System in Volume III.
traffic flow characteristics of respective traffic
sections. These surveys were carried out for one The Consultants made a power point presentation
year on weekly basis in each month. On the of the Draft Final Report on 29 July 2009 at
basis of traffic data thus obtained, showing TANROADS Headquarters, Dar es Salaam,
hourly variation/distribution in a day, week and Tanzania. The Presentation was attended by
month, relevant traffic adjustment factors (TAFs) senior officials of TANROADS, and representative
were arrived for each traffic section of the of the World Bank.
country.
5.0 OVERSEAS TRAINING
These factors would be useful in determining the
average daily traffic (ADT) and the annual Under the Study, an overseas training for three
average daily traffic (AADT) for the traffic data TANROADS Staff was organized in the month of
obtained for short duration, e.g. 12-hr only for November 2008 in New Delhi, India. Mr. Jason M.
one day or so, due to resource and time Rwiza, Director of Planning, Mr. Bencolias
constraints, on any roads (Trunk/Regional) Tinkaligaile, Head of Planning and Mr. Arnold
falling under the vicinity or influence of the Masaki, Traffic Engineer participated in the
respective traffic sections. The Study also brings training program.
out the detailed traffic survey methodology The training covered various functional areas of
including the manual survey (through traffic surveys including equipment based,
enumerators) and equipment based survey associated data processing and analysis, and
(through automatic traffic counters and forecasting techniques; and also highway
classifiers, i.e. ATCCs) suitable for future use in engineering and planning in view of technical
Tanzania. capacity building. The training program consisted
of classroom as well as field training and site
4.0 REPORTS SUBMITTED visits, discussions, and case studies.
An Inception Report on the Study was submitted Demonstration of the Traffic Information Database
in the month of October 2007 followed by a (TIDB) System was also organized during the
Presentation on the Inception Report at above training.
TANROADS Headquarters, Dar es Salaam. As
per the ToR, Three Progress Reports covering 5.1 Training for TANROADS Staff
different areas of the assignments were
prepared during the Consultancy Services. The As per the requirement of the ToR, a “Two-day
three Progress Reports covered: (i) information Training for TANROADS Staff” was organized on
related to conceptual design and traffic counts the Traffic Census Methodology, and the
methodology; (ii) information on the Application of the Traffic Adjustment Factors
establishment of counting stations and (TAFs) on 20-21 August in Dar es Salaam. The
E.2
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
E.3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
as well as other traffic sections on the road TG-101: Review of Earlier Traffic Census
network. Related Studies;
Chapter VIII illustrates the general approach and TG-102: Establishing Traffic Counting
methodology for undertaking traffic forecast Locations;
modeling exercise, in general and the Tanzanian
conditions in particular. The chapter provides TG-103: Collection & Review of Secondary
details on the components of the traffic forecast Data;
and growth rates, passenger and freight carrying
TG104: Comprehensive Traffic Census;
vehicles, so that any users could work out traffic
level for future. TG-105: Processing & Analyzing Traffic
Chapter IX illustrates mainly approach and Count Data;
system design for data processing, algorithm TG-106: Design of Computerized Traffic
used for data analysis, application of traffic Census Database; and
adjustment factors at different stages for
determining the base year traffic, generation of TG-107: Training to the TANROADS
several reports and tables, interface to the system Counterpart Staff.
developed, etc.
The tasks listed above have been addressed in
Chapter X presents the results of the entire various chapters and sections of the Final Report,
baseline traffic surveys conducted at 45 count which are briefly discussed in the following
points throughout the year. The chapter also
sections and sub-sections.
discusses in brief the usefulness and the
applications of the results. Though all the 7.1.1 Review of the Earlier Studies
tabulated traffic data, ADT, AADT, TAFs, etc. are
presented in Volume II on Traffic Survey Results Review of the earlier studies was one of the
of the Final Report, the chapter, among others, requirements of the ToR, so the Study reviewed
also presents a complete set of the results all the relevant studies carried out in past in
relating to Count Point No. 1 (CP-1), i.e. Chikundi Tanzania on the subject. Towards the same, after
(Masasi) in Mtwara Region, for illustration and having reviewed the outcomes and
immediate reference.
recommendations of the Final Report on ‘Traffic
Chapter XI highlights the summary and major Data Acquisition’ prepared by DHV Consultants in
issues identified in different chapters. 2004, were used in preparing an effective strategy
The Final Report has also been made available to adopt a system of identifying the count points
in a compact disc in MS Office Software and to achieve the most representative traffic
database back up on CD in the MS Access database.
Software. The Study also reviewed the exercise undertaken
by the Ministry of Communications and Works
7.0 SUMMARY OF THE FINAL REPORT (MoCW) regarding manual or enumerator based
classified traffic counts on 266 traffic sections and
7.1 General Approach & count points on the Trunk and Regional Roads in
Methodology the country during 1972-85. Among others, the
review was mainly concentrated to the MoCW
In conformity of the Terms of Reference (ToR) of (1988) traffic adjustment factors derived on 40
the consultancy services, the main functional traffic sections in the country through a one-year
areas of the Study are classified into: conceptual traffic counting activities on 40 count points.
design of traffic counts; establishment of
counting stations; traffic count methodology; The ‘Traffic Survey Strategy’ prepared by the
traffic census in Tanzania; procurement of Ministry of Works (MoW) in 1992 was also
equipment for traffic census in Tanzania; reviewed, which aimed at developing a set of
establishment of traffic database; data updated Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs) for the
processing; traffic forecasting modeling; and entire network locations, which MoW used for
establishment of baseline traffic census in data collection and adjustment to make it
Tanzania. These areas of the Study have been representative until 1993. For obvious reasons,
duly addressed and presented in separate the TAFs developed in 1992, and that too based
chapters of the Final Report. on 1987 level information were no longer valid for
current analyses.
For undertaking the Consultancy Services, the
scope of work has been grouped into the
following “Task Groups (TG)” in a logical
sequence.
E.4
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
7.2 Conceptual Design of Traffic establish the traffic adjustment factors to be used
Census in future traffic census.
The Study developed the conceptual design for For finalizing the above task, the Consultants
conducting traffic surveys and establishing reviewed the latest road network of the country, in
baseline traffic on primary road network in view of changes taken place since 1985 and also
Tanzania. For this purpose, the traffic surveys up-grading of the road categories, e.g. Regional
were planned to be carried out on the selected Road to Trunk Road and so on; supported with
traffic sections through the identified count points field visits to identify the specific traffic sections
on the Trunk and Regional Roads continuously on the network; and to establish traffic survey
for twelve months in the country. One of the count points in the traffic sections.
major outputs of the above survey was to derive The features influencing the traffic sections on the
the traffic adjustment factors (TAFs) valid for the road network are: junctions, inhabitation pattern
catchment’s area of each traffic section. and major economic activity centers, such as,
The TAFs will be used in future for converting mining, factories, markets, institutions, etc.
any short duration traffic count of other trunk and While selecting the traffic survey count points on
regional road sections to determine the average the traffic sections, any influence of local traffic in
daily traffic (ADT), and the annual average daily case of roads connecting major population
traffic (AADT), which could be considered as a centers was avoided.
baseline traffic for any specific planning
purposes. For an effective use of the TAFs on 7.4 Traffic Adjustment Factors
different Trunk and Regional Roads of Tanzania,
a comprehensive list of roads falling under
(TAFs)
specific catchment areas of respective traffic It has been highly realized that conducting traffic
sections has been prepared. surveys throughout the year on a regular basis is
usually not possible or advisable, mainly because
The Conceptual Design of Traffic Census
brought out in the present Study cover in detail: of resource constraints. Therefore, the traffic
approach and methodology of traffic survey data surveys are usually carried out for short durations,
e.g. for 12 hour, 24 hours, a few days in a week
collection, selecting the proper survey
instruments (enumerator or equipment based), or full weeks. The traffic surveys carried out for
proper data processing, determination of several short durations require appropriate traffic
adjustment factors, usually known as TAFs to
traffic adjustment factors, report and
documenting system for the data retrieval make them representative of the annual average.
system for more micro and macro level analyses The Study has developed various TAFs for
will be readily available with TANROADS; so that determining the traffic level on the road network of
any short duration traffic surveys on any traffic TANROADS, which will be used for the short
sections on the road network of TANROADS can duration traffic count data to expand into the ADT
be easily converted into the ADT and the AADT, and the AADT. To meet the above said
which, in turn, establish the traffic census in requirement, algorithms have been developed for
Tanzania in short time consuming much lesser arriving at various traffic adjustment factors
resources. TANROADS will have a mechanism (TAFs) for carrying out the following traffic
on their Wide Area Network (WAN) system, that analysis, which included in the database design:
users can access, retrieve and update the data, (i) estimation of the ADT; (ii) calculation of hourly,
whenever required. daily and monthly TAFs; (iii) determination of the
AADT.
7.3 Selection of Traffic Sections & The TAFs developed in the Study will be used for
Traffic Survey Count Points converting the short duration traffic data into the
During the Study, a comprehensive list of the ADT and the AADT in future for roads falling in
selected traffic sections and the traffic count the catchment areas of the selected traffic
points was prepared. This exercise was based sections of the roads under TANROADS.
on the road network and movement pattern in
the country, for future traffic census. The 7.5 Traffic Count Methodology for
selected traffic sections and their corresponding Tanzania
count locations countrywide are nearly 500.
Conducting traffic survey in the Study was a huge
Out of the above traffic sections countrywide, the task. The traffic count methodology for Tanzania
Study identified 45 traffic sections for was developed based on the comprehensive
undertaking a one-year traffic survey in order to efforts with a logical planning and several
E.5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
E.6
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
retrieved. This would be made compatible with can be broken down into three layers, namely,
TANROADS WAN, as and when commissioned. Data Layer (Backend), Logical
Layer (Middleware) and Presentation Layer (Front
The one-year traffic survey data collected at 45
end). The data layer is a separate component,
count points have been stored in the TIDB
whose sole purpose is to serve up the data from
System, which can be accessed through a user
the database and return it to the user/caller.
friendly Graphical User Interface (GUI), so that
access, updating, and analysis could be easily The Logical Layer is the brain of the System
undertaken. The traffic data from all the survey where all the logical/business calculations, like,
count points have a reference to the calculation of TAF, ADT, AADT, etc. will be done.
geographical coordinates so that visualization Placing all the logics separately in a layer
through maps is possible. increases the reusability of an application. The
presentation layer is the most important layer
7.8.2 Scope simply because it’s the one that everyone
The Scope of the system is to design and observes and uses. With a well structured logical
establish a computerized Traffic Census and data layer, if the presentation layer is
Database, whereby traffic data can be stored, designed properly, this gives the users a better
accessed and updated, so that the same can be view and appreciations of the System. The main
used as a decision support system for Traffic advantages of using tiered approach are the
and Transportation Planning. It includes defining reusability of the programming code and ease to
interfaces to the system, methodology to migrate maintain and enhance/modify the System in the
manual traffic census data into database and future.
assumptions to the system including the
7.8.6 Trial Run & Demonstration
deliverables.
To check the accuracy and integrity of the TIDB
7.8.3 Functional Requirements System, a trial run was conducted in early June
The functionality of the system includes the user 2008. At that point of the time, the traffic data for
interface features, techniques to migrate the the month of January 2008 to April 2008 was
data from Excel Sheets to the Microsoft Access available for the traffic count points in the Study.
Database, error handling, master details, sub- A test data suite, depicting the data for 12 months
systems, backup and recovery mechanism and was created from the available data and the
the database structure including entity System was thoroughly tested to check its
relationship. functional efficiency.
7.8.4 Algorithm of Data Analysis The functionality and working of the TIDB System
was demonstrated to various TANROADS
Algorithms have been developed for arriving at officials during last one year, including,
various traffic adjustment factors (TAFs) for demonstration to the officers concerned, in
carrying out the following traffic analysis, which November 2008 at New Delhi, India, and to
included in the database design: RMMS Officials at TANROADS Headquarters,
Estimation of Average Daily Traffic (ADT); Dar es Salaam, specifically to demonstrate the
information stored in TIDB System, like, Start
Calculation of hourly, daily and monthly
Node Number, End Node Number, etc. which
Traffic Adjustment Factors; and
may be utilized by, and can be transferred to
Calculation of Annual Average Daily Traffic existing software of RMMS, through interface
(AADT). files.
The TAFs will be used for converting the short 7.8.7 User Manual
duration traffic count/data into the ADT and the
AADT in future for roads in the catchment areas A “User Manual: Traffic Surveys and TIDB
of the traffic sections of the Trunk and Regional System”, has been prepared for carrying out the
roads under TANROADS considered in the traffic survey and providing guidance to operate
present Study. the TIDB System. TANROADS Staff has also
been trained during the Training, so that the
7.8.5 Technology system could be effectively used in years to
The TIDB System has been developed using MS come. The above arrangement would augment
Access as database, Visual Basic (.Net) as the in-house capacity and workability, even after
development tool and Crystal Report as report completion of the Consultancy Services. The User
writer tool for generation of reports/tables. The Manual is comprehensive and user-friendly
System is built around a three-tier client server document, which could be used by any new users
architecture. Using this architecture, the System of the TIDB System as well.
E.7
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Executive Summary
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
E.8
Study Background 1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
1
Now known as Tanzania Railways Limited.
2
The islands of Zanzibar are situated some 30 km from the Mainland in the Indian Ocean.
1.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The value of merchandize exports in Tanzania increased to US$ 2.0 billion (2007) from US$
1.7 billion (2006) registering about 16% growth. In fact, Tanzania has started increasing non-
traditional exports, viz. minerals (gold, diamond, etc.), manufacturing products, fish and fish
1.2
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
products, horticulture, etc. The traditional exports of the country are coffee, cotton, sisal, tea,
tobacco, cashew nuts and cloves. Whereas, the value of goods imported (f.o.b.) increased
from US$ 3.9 billion (2006) to US$ 4.8 billion (2007), showing an increase of about 25% over
previous year. This increase has been observed mainly due to the considerable growth in
importation of consumer goods.
3
Based on the Background given in the ToR.
1.3
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
1.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
1.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
(SDR). The Training Program also had adequate “Question-Answer Sessions” after every
topic of the Training. During the Program, all the participants were given “User Manual” on
Traffic Census Methodology, Application of the Traffic Adjustment Factors, and Traffic
Information (TIDB) System, and relevant hand-outs for future reference and use.
“A Report on the Training for TANROADS Staff” has been prepared and presented in
Annexure 1.2. Besides details on the Training Program coverage, list of participants, etc.,
the Report also presents the analysis of the feedback and evaluation of the participants
which were collected through a pre-structured questionnaire.
1.6
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
instruments, selection of the appropriate automatic traffic counters and classifiers, organizing
traffic surveys and logistics, monitoring and quality control mechanism of the traffic counts,
traffic data processing and analysis, and related issues.
Chapter VI aims at establishing the traffic census by organizing and analyzing the traffic
survey data, selection and use of the appropriate traffic adjustment factors for working out the
base year traffic.
Chapter VII investigates the equipment based traffic census in Tanzania, the chapter also
identifies the most suitable automatic traffic counters and classifiers (ATCCs), so that regular
traffic surveys could be undertaken on the selected as well as other traffic sections on the
road network.
Chapter VIII illustrates the general approach and methodology for undertaking traffic forecast
modeling exercise, in general and the Tanzanian conditions in particular. The chapter
provides details on the components of the traffic forecast and growth rates for passenger and
freight carrying vehicles, so that any users could work out traffic level for future.
Chapter IX illustrates mainly approach and system design for data processing, algorithm used
for data processing, application of traffic adjustment factors at different stages for determining
the base year traffic, generation of several reports and tables, interface to the system
developed, etc.
Chapter X presents the results of the entire baseline traffic surveys conducted at 45 count
points throughout the year. The chapter also discusses in brief the usefulness and the
applications of the results. Though all the tabulated traffic data, ADT, AADT, TAFs, etc. are
presented in Volume II on Traffic Survey Results of the Final Report, the chapter, among
others, also presents a complete set of the results relating to Count Point No. 1 (CP-1), i.e.
Chikundi (Masasi) in Mtwara Region, for illustration and immediate reference.
Chapter XI highlights the summary and major issues identified in different chapters.
The Final Report has also been made available in a compact disc in MS Office Software and
database back up on CD in the MS Access Software.
1.7
1.
General Approach & Methodology 2
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
2.1 General
This chapter describes in brief the general approach and methodology adopted for carrying
out the Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland and Establishing a Comprehensive
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS. In conformity with the Terms of Reference
(ToR) of the study, the main functional areas of the study are classified into: conceptual
design of traffic counts; establishment of counting stations; traffic count methodology; traffic
census in Tanzania; procurement of ATCCs for traffic census in Tanzania; establishment of
traffic database; data processing; traffic forecast modeling; and establishment of baseline
traffic census in Tanzania. These areas of the study have been duly addressed and
presented in separate chapters of the present report. While formulating the coverage of the
Final Report, the specific approach, methodology, data base, coverage, etc. are adequately
covered in the respective chapters. However, an overall general approach and methodology
with data base and other required activities are presented in brief in the following sections.
2.2.1 Task Group 101: Review of the Earlier Traffic Census Related Studies
The Consultants reviewed the outcomes and recommendations of the Final Report on
‘Traffic Data Acquisition’ prepared by DHV Consultants in 2004, which have been used in
preparing an effective strategy to adopt a system of identifying the count points to achieve
the most representative traffic database. This review culminated into a set of
recommendations to TANROADS, which eventually became parts of the activities under the
present study, within the scope of work.
The Consultants also reviewed the ‘Traffic Survey Strategy’ prepared by the Ministry of
Works (MoW) in 1992. The Strategy had developed a set of Traffic Adjustment Factors
(TAFs) for the entire network locations, which were used by MoW for data collection and
adjustment to make it representative until 1993. For obvious reasons, the TAFs developed in
1992, and that too based on 1987 level information were no longer valid for current
analyses. Nevertheless, the Traffic Survey Strategy establishes a historical base for the
TAFs to appreciate the changing scenario in Tanzania. The Consultants examined the
sufficiency of those TAFs in the present context through the review work, and made
appropriate changes for updating the Traffic Adjustment Factors as well as other extensions,
as required. A detailed note on the review of earlier studies relating to the traffic census and
the inferences drawn are described in Chapter 4.
2.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
measures 56,625 km. The focus of the Project is on 29,847 km of the Trunk Roads and
Regional Roads of the country.
The conceptual design for traffic counting is a comprehensive document highlighting the
above issues, so that such exercises could be effectively and efficiently planned and
undertaken, and results be analyzed for its purposes.
(i) measurement/sensing: volume, vehicle classification, direction, speed, axle spacing, etc.;
(ii) other features: permanent installation or mobile, covert, work on poor road surface,
weather resistant, and accuracy grade; and (iii) cost: capital, and operation and
maintenance. The Consultants have thoroughly scrutinized the functional merits of the
equipment in view of effectiveness, efficiency and economy, so that the most suitable
equipment could be procured.
For the purpose, the Consultants identified the range of products available and operational,
particularly in developing countries including African countries. The contacts with major
suppliers world-wide were established, so that the equipment could be procured timely
during the Consultancy Services. Accordingly, the Consultants investigated the suitability
and type of equipment in view of Tanzanian conditions in consultations with the TANROADS
Officials including Regional Offices. The discussions also included the operational, safety
and maintenance aspects of the equipment, so that the option could be sustainable for a
long time.
2.2.5 Task Group 105: Processing & Analyzing Traffic Count Data
(i) Traffic Data Processing & Analysis: The direction-wise classified traffic volume
data need to be analyzed to determine: (i) Average Daily Traffic (ADT) of motorized and
non-motorized vehicles in numbers; (ii) traffic data to be compiled and analyzed to determine
vehicle-wise variations in the traffic, in terms of hourly variation in a day, specific day
variation in a week, and month variation in a year, for the selected count points; and (iii)
changing pattern of the traffic composition at the count points.
(ii) Traffic Trend: In order to compare the traffic levels, the Study has also analyzed the
available historical data relating to the same count points under the present study. The
observations made are also part of the traffic forecast model (Chapter 8), particularly for
specific regions / geographical areas.
(iii) Estimation of Traffic Adjustment Factors: Following the ToR, the Study should
carry out all the data processing and analysis, and estimation of the “Traffic Adjustment
Factors” including hourly and daily adjustment factors, and seasonal or monthly factors.
Establishing the Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs) for different Trunk and Regional roads of
the country based on the data collected through the weekly surveys for one year in every
month at all the selected traffic survey count points was one of the crucial assignments
under the present Consultancy Services.
2.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
These traffic adjustment factors will be suitably utilized in future by the TANROADS and
other stakeholders. The TAFs will be used by the TANROADS (Headquarters or Regional
Offices) for any traffic surveys carried out on any Trunk or Regional Roads for limited time
due to the resource constraints or any other reasons, to derive the Annual Average Daily
Traffic (AADT).
This exercise will be largely based on the outcomes of data processing and analysis, as
described in Task 105 (i), and the wider coverage of the representation of the specific count
points for the traffic surveys.
Coverage under the TAFs, the following factors are considered in view of different uses:
peak to daily factor; day to week factor; Average Daily Traffic (ADT) to Annual Average Daily
Traffic (AADT) factor; seasonal or monthly adjustment factor; hourly adjustment factor;
regional factors; local factors, etc.
(iv) Development of a Generalized Traffic Forecast Model: As per the ToR, the
Consultants need to prepare a “Generalized Traffic Forecast Model” for application in
Tanzania, and make recommendations for specific adjustments to the national model based
on regional and other local conditions, as per the requirements. The generalized traffic
forecast model has been developed involving multi-criteria parameters including a number of
explanatory variables affecting the traffic growth in varied socio-economic conditions. The
historical data on the socio-economic performance indicators and traffic data available the
national and regional levels have been used to appreciate the passenger and freight traffic.
For undertaking the exercise, the Consultants have utilized data available through different
sources. The exercise also incorporated the parameters suitably at macro level as well as at
regional level.
The traffic forecast modeling exercise has been undertaken separately for passenger and
freight traffic. The indicators affecting the passenger traffic mainly are: growth in population,
per capita income, changes in sectoral contribution to the national economy, etc., whereas
the freight traffic depends on the growth of agriculture, mining, industrial, trade and
commerce activities, transiting traffic, e.g. port traffic for the neighboring land-locked
countries, Based on the developed generalized traffic forecast model, the appropriate traffic
projection growth rates have been determined for passenger and freight traffic (Chapter 8).
2.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Flow Chart 2.1: Process of Traffic Census Database Development
Study Project
Requirements
Develop System
Requirement
Specifications
Develop Test Develop Reporting
Data Sets Formats
Develop Prototype
and Demonstrate
Populate Database Impart Training on
from Field Survey Data Preparation
Traffic Information Impart Training
Database on Database use
(ii) Development of User Manual: A “User Manual”, i.e. a guide has been prepared for
the Database, and the TANROADS staff has been trained, so that the system could be
widely used in years to come. The menu driven Database will be used by the TANROADS
staff. This arrangement will be able to augment the in-house capacity and workability, even
after completion of the Consultancy Services. The User Manual is a comprehensive
document, which could be used by any new users of the database.
The project envisages developing skills in the TANROADS staff for continual development of
the traffic count data and its analysis even after the Consultants leave after completion of the
Project. The Consultants have prepared a User Manual for Traffic Survey and Traffic
Information and Data Base (TIDB) System (Volume III of the Final Report). The User Manual
will be the guide for the TANROADS staff to administer traffic surveys on different types of
roads of the country as well as computer based data analysis.
2.6
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
the relevant data and information from the Government Departments of various Ministries,
they continuously observed the actions of the Consultants to gain experience in developing
and executing different activities of the Project. To this effect, TANROADS identified three
Counter Staff for attachment with the Consultants right from the beginning, i.e. during the
project inception stage.
(ii) Additional Trainings to TANROADS Counterpart Staff: The Counterpart Staff had
another set of trainings for the actual details of (i) the planning and execution of traffic
counting system, and (ii) use of the MS Access software for processing, analysis and
retrieval of the data. For these two aspects, the User Manual has been prepared in the study
to assist the trainees. The TANROADS Counterpart Staff who were directly related to the
Project and attached to the Consultants, had training on these two aspects for the purpose
of technology transfer as well as capacity building in TANROADS.
(iii) Training on Traffic Census & Application of TAFs: The Consultants, as per the
ToR, organized a two-day Training for TANROADS Staff on the Traffic Census
Methodology; and the Application of the Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs) on 20-21 August
2009 in Dar es Salaam. The participants were from the TANROADS Headquarters, Road
Maintenance Management System (RMMS) and the Regional Offices of TANROADS.
Besides a presentation on the salient feature and findings of the Draft Final Report, and the
User Manual brought out during the Services, the Training focused on the methodology for
carrying out the traffic surveys, including the manual counting (enumerator based),
equipment based automatic counting, use of the traffic adjustment factors on the traffic
survey data (ADT) on specific roads to determine the annual average daily traffic (AADT) for
the highway planning purposes, and traffic forecast model.
The Training also covered the use of computer based data analysis and compatibility of the
data collection through traffic surveys, and the highway planning software. Purpose of the
Training was also to make familiar the participants in different functional areas of the traffic
surveys, traffic projection and other related analyses, so that they could undertake such
exercises independently.
2.7
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Under the primary data collection efforts, the Consultants undertook the Reconnaissance
Survey of the entire traffic sections on the Trunk and Regional Roads of the country, and
inspected physically the locations of all the 45 selected count points (CPs), and organized
meetings with all the Regional Managers of TANROADS, knowledgeable people and
residents living in the catchment’s areas of the selected traffic sections.
For the purpose of extensive level of data collection and maintaining uniformity while making
any comparative analysis for different purposes, a Check List was prepared, and used
during the Reconnaissance Survey (Annexure 2.1). The inferences drawn and knowledge
gained through the Reconnaissance Survey, several meetings and the observations made
by the Project Traffic Engineers, have been extensively used in developing the conceptual
design and traffic counts methodology for Tanzania.
2.8
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
There are several activities need to be carried before, during and after the traffic surveys,
which have been described in detail in Chapter 5.
2.8 Sum Up
General approach and methodology described in the present chapter give an overall and
brief note on carrying out the traffic surveys, data collection and analysis, determining the
TAFs, establishing the base year and future traffic. Detailed note on each of the activity is
presented in designated chapters in the present report.
2.9
1.
Conceptual Design of Traffic Census 3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
3.1 General
The assessment of traffic volume is one of the most basic requirements of highway planning
and management. Traffic volume is also termed as flow and is expressed as the number and
type of vehicles crossing a section of road per unit of time. Traffic volume count is generally
accepted as a true measure of the relative importance of the roads, and in deciding the
priority for any improvement and expansion plans. This is used in planning of traffic
operation and control of existing facilities, and also for planning and designing the new
facilities. Level of traffic volume is particularly useful in geometric and structural design of
pavement, and in computing roadway capacity.
Long-term need for the traffic data covers a wide range of traffic engineering issues. The
traffic data are not only important for highway planning software1, viz. HDM-4, RED, Road
Mentor, etc., but also there are many other activities where the inputs of classified traffic
count data are extremely useful, such as, lane design, maintenance planning, estimation of
total vehicle operation costs (VOCs), environmental appraisal, etc. The Federal Highway
Administration (FHWA) lists out the applications of traffic data types versus different highway
activities (Table 3.1).
Table 3.1: Traffic Data Versus Highway Activities
Highway Activity Purpose for Traffic Counts Specific Use
Engineering Highway Geometry Pavement Design
Engineering Economy Benefit of Highway Improvement Vehicle Operation Cost
Finance Estimates of Road Revenue Highway Cost Allocation
Speed Limits and Oversize
Legislation Selection of Highway Routes
Vehicle Policy
Selecting the Timing of Selection of Maintenance
Maintenance
Maintenance Activities
Development of Control
Operations Signal Timing
Activities
Location and Design of Highway Forecast of Travel by Vehicle
Planning
Systems Type
Forecast of Emissions by Type
Environmental Analysis Air Quality Analysis
of Vehicle
Design of Traffic Control Systems Safety Conflicts due to Vehicle
Safety
and Accident Rates Mix and Accident Rates
Statistics Average Daily Traffic Travel by Vehicle Types
Marketing Keyed to Particular
Private Sector Location of Service Areas
Vehicle Types
Source: FHWA (2001), also reproduced in Data Collection Technologies for Road Management, East
Asia Pacific Transport Unit, The World Bank (2005).
1
These software are used by TANROADS for highway planning and maintenance activities.
3.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
in the catchment’s area to determine the annual average daily traffic (AADT), which could be
considered as baseline traffic for any specific planning purposes. For an effective use of the
TAFs on different Trunk and Regional Roads of Tanzania, the Consultants have prepared a
comprehensive list of roads falling under specific catchment’s areas of respective traffic
sections (Annexure 3.1).
3.2.1 Duration of Counts
It would be ideal to conduct the traffic survey on a continuous basis, i.e. throughout the year
to observe the traffic level on selected locations. But in developing countries like Tanzania, it
is generally not possible to carry out the survey on a continuous basis mainly due to lack of
resources and financial constraints. So, the duration of the traffic count is depending mainly
upon the purpose for which the data are needed, and also on the available financial
resources. Sometimes, it is only desired to measure the flow for a short term, e.g. for an
hour only; at other time may be for a full day; and in some situation, the count may extend
for duration of a full week; and lastly the count may also be a continuous as a regular affair.
The examples of different situations where the above types of counts carried out are given in
Figure 3.1.
- To determine the traffic in - To determine hourly - To determine hourly and daily - To determine the fluctuation of
peak hour fluctuation of flow fluctuation of flow flow daily, weekly, seasonally and
- Used generally in developing
- Used in measuring the
countries as the only means of - To determine the annual rate of
saturation flow at signalised - Used in Intersection Counts
traffic census on non urban growth of traffic
intersections
highways
- Used generally in developed
- Used in the intersection - Used in Cordon Line and - Used in Cordon Line and countries at selected number of
counts during the morning and Screen Line Counts as part of Screen Line Counts as part of stations for a continuous
evening peaks Transportation Surveys Urban Transportation Surveys monitoring of traffic flow in urban or
non-urban locations
Source: Traffic Engineering and Transport Planning by L. R. Kadiyali, Khanna Publishers, Delhi (1997).
3.2
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
unpaved. It may be noted that the paved roads are mostly the Trunk Roads and the Urban
Roads. Only about 48% of the Trunk Roads are paved. The classification of the roads in the
country has been made on its hierarchical functions, given as follows:
The primary national and international through routes that link several
Trunk Roads
regions and provide access to important border posts and ports
The secondary routes connecting district centers in a region or
Regional Roads
connecting another important center to a trunk road
The tertiary route linking:
District Roads (i) district headquarters with ward centers; (ii) important centers within
the district; and (iii) important centers to a higher class road
The village access roads linking important centers within a ward to the
Feeder Roads
rest of the network
Within the urban centers: (i) Arterial Roads; (ii) Collector Roads; (iii)
Urban Roads
Local Collector Roads; and (iv) Access Roads.
3.3
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The total road network in Tanzania has been estimated at 86,472 km. The road length, as
per the classification as well as pavement condition (paved/unpaved) is illustrated in the
Table 3.2. The figures show that percentage of paved roads in the country has increased to
7.5%, and the share of the paved Trunk Roads has become 48% (or 78% of the paved
roads are the Trunk Roads). However, more than 80,650 km of the classified roads are still
unpaved in Tanzania, which require more efforts to improve the situation.
Table 3.2: Classification of Roads as per Pavement Category
Road Class Paved Percent Unpaved Percent Total Percent
Trunk Roads 5,063 78% 5,538 7% 10,601 12%
Regional Roads 646 10% 18,600 23% 19,246 22%
District, Urban,
790 12% 55,835 70% 56,625 66%
Feeder, Roads
Total 6,499 100% 79,972 100% 86,472 100%
Paved / Unpaved 7.5% -- 92.5% -- 100.0% --
Source: TANROADS (July, 2009).
The figures relating to the condition of the Trunk and Regional Roads, in terms of “good”,
“fair”, and “poor”, show that in the last few years, there has been considerable achievement
in improvement of the roads under the jurisdiction of TANROADS. Pavement condition
criteria in Tanzania are presented in Annexure 3.2. The share of good roads in 2002 was
estimated as merely 14%, which got increased up to about 48% in 2008 or i.e. the decrease
in the length of poor roads has been noticed as 16% (2007) from 50% (2002). Somehow, the
status of fair roads remains around 36%. This situation shows two things: (i) there might be
considerable improvement in pavement condition on account of capital investment2, which
enhanced the level of good roads from the poor condition; and (ii) good maintenance
strategy being adopted, so the level of fair roads remain fair or slightly increased.
It may be noted that the medium and long term objective, outlined in the Tanzania National
Transport Policy (2003) is to bituminize all the trunk roads while at the same time ensuring
that all regional as well as key district and urban roads are sufficiently rehabilitated and
maintained to ensure smooth flow of traffic. The Policy brings out main challenges in the
technological development of transportation system: (a) choosing appropriate technology by
setting standards and enforcement mechanism through regulation; e.g., look into possibility
of using motor cycles as taxis to reduce fuel consumption and adverse impacts to
environment; (b) promoting creativity and innovativeness to adopt or develop new
technologies by providing an enabling environment; and (c) in rural areas, deliberate efforts
to promote use of cheap non-motorized traffic technology, sensitize the use of NMTs among
woman in rural areas and also improvement of transport infrastructure in the rural areas to
cater for all transport means including NMT.
2
As per the TANROADS Report (June, 2007), the emergency works, which has been on-going since
December 2006 have enabled repairs of most of the damaged sections, and this has contributed in
the turning around of the condition of roads. More improvement in condition is expected as
emergency works are still in progress in the regions.
3.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
been observed as high as 36% of the total traffic fleet; similar phenomenon could be
apparently observed in most of the developing countries. Cars account for only 4% and
normal trucks, which are used for transportation of intercity goods, for 36%, while trucks with
full trailer are probably used for handling international cargo account for 4% of total fleet on
the Trunk Roads in Tanzania.
Table 3.3: Vehicle Composition on the
Trunk Roads in Tanzania
Vehicle Type (%)
Cars 4
Pickups (including, 4WD) 36
Trucks (<5 tons) 3
Trucks (>5 tons) 33
Truck with Full Trailer 4
Truck with Semi Trailer 2
Small Buses (<25 Passengers) 5
Large Buses 13
Total 100
Source: Ministry of Infrastructure Development (2007).
3.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
conditions on account of vehicles per hour is illustrated in Table 3.4. These figures are
indicative for a quick estimate of the number of enumerators required, and also the survey
cost estimates.
Table 3.4: Number of Trained Enumerators Needed for Manual Traffic Counts
No. of vehicles/hr can be
Road Features and Counting Requirements
counted by one enumerator
2-lane two way road, with separate enumerators for
each direction; vehicles to be counted and 500 vehicles/hr in one direction
classified
2-lane two way road, with one enumerator for both
the directions; vehicles to be counted and classified 200 vehicles/hr in both directions
for each direction separately
2-lane two way road, with one enumerator for both
the directions; vehicles to be simply counted with
800 vehicles/hr in both directions
no requirement for classification and posting into
separate direction
It is, however, more desirable to record traffic in each direction of movement separately and
depute enumerators for both the directions. Enumerators should be literate persons with
preferably higher secondary level qualification, and can be trained suitably for the purpose.
The enumerators record each vehicle passing through the count points using the five-dash
system (tally bars) on a pre-designed traffic count format. Whereby, vertical strokes are
entered for the first four vehicles, followed by an oblique stroke for the fifth vehicle, so as to
depict a total of five to avoid any duplications and confusions. This method eases the
counting while compiling the data. At the end of survey, the total hourly volumes are
transferred to a summary sheet.
3.6.2 Equipment Based Traffic Count
Automatic traffic counter and classifier (ATCC), an electronic equipment, which detects and
records the passing vehicles on the road, where installed for the purpose. The ATCCs are
fixed with a sensor that transmits some form of electric impulse, which activates the
accumulating register or recording chart. The type of ATCCs with its functional features is
presented in Section 3.8. As stated earlier, the equipment based traffic counting is popular in
developed countries, particularly for continuous data collection and higher level of accuracy.
However, with growing awareness and need for traffic data in highway planning and
decision-making, the equipment based traffic counting is now being adopted by many
developing counties as well, including Tanzania.
3.6.3 Manual Vs Equipment Based Counting – A Comparative Analysis
A comparison between the manual and equipment based counting has been illustrated
separately: (i) favoring manual traffic count; and (ii) favoring equipment based traffic count,
which is presented as follows:
(i) Manual Traffic Count:
Details, such as, vehicle classification can be easily obtained. With the equipment, this
information may not be captured accurately;
Manual method enables any unusual conditions obtaining at the time of count to be recorded.
This will help in understanding and analyzing the traffic characteristics. Unusual conditions
may be adverse weather conditions, traffic jam, temporary closure of the road for
maintenance operations, etc., whereas ATCCs do not have the flexibility;
In developing countries, sophisticated automatic devices are not indigenously produced so
may be a costly proposition, and also repair and maintenance may be a problem. On the
other hand manpower for counting is available economically in developing countries;
3.6
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Even if automatic devices are used, it is often necessary to check the accuracy of the devices
periodically, whereas manual method does not require such corrections;
Pilferage and vandalism often prevent the use of costly equipment in remote rural areas, and
in such cases manual counting method has an edge; and
Manual counting method is suitable and economical for short term and non-continuous counts
and also for low volume traffic sections.
(ii) Equipment Based Traffic Count:
Where a continuous and regular record of traffic flow is needed, the only alternative is to
install automatic counters;
There has been wide spread usage of the equipment in the developed countries, where traffic
engineering and transportation planning have attained a high degree of perfection. However,
use of the equipment is getting popular in developing countries as well; and
Automatic devices usually yield data, which are amenable to easy analysis by computers.
3
Vehicle Counter/Classifier, GR 03041, 6 loops, 2 tubes, 44 k memory equipped with a solar energy
charger, GR 03064.
3.7
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
the selection and recommendation for such equipment for traffic counting, and also back up
support to avoid for such eventualities.
3.6.5 Traffic Data Acquisition Study (2004)
The Traffic Data Acquisition Study (2004), in Tanzania underlines, “the use of the traffic
counting machines could save TANROADS a considerable amount of money. However,
since the machines are not yet widely used in tropical environments the consultant cannot
predict their durability”. There is need to establish certain facts about the selection and
recommendation of the deployment of traffic count equipment in Tanzania, particularly in a
frame of social cost-benefit analysis, and support operation and maintenance mechanism.
Of course, there would be a trade-off between scale of traffic count activities and the cost
implications either through manual counting or equipment based counting.
This exercise needs to be supported by a fairly detailed viability exercise, in view of the
traffic count requirements and the Tanzanian conditions. The exercise must incorporate the
total cost implications of procuring and running the survey equipment, i.e. capital cost; and
operation and maintenance (O & M) costs. It is also advisable to carry out the life cycle cost
analysis of installing equipment for the traffic count, which requires to be duly compared with
the enumerator based traffic counting.
The underlying concept of the analysis would be the utilization of maximum domestic
available resources for the purpose. While recommending the employment of equipment,
one must keep in mind the availability of repair and maintenance support, when required,
optimum utilization of the equipment, cost implications, funds available, trained manpower,
and clearly defined ownership of the equipment to protect from theft and vandalism. In fact,
the question, why the equipment for traffic count is required for Tanzania, needs to be
justified? This exercise requires the technology scanning, so that the most suitable
equipment could be procured. A detailed exercise showing the cost comparison of
enumerator and equipment based traffic count using the method of life cycle cost analysis
incorporating the capital cost and operation and maintenance cost has been presented in
Chapter 7 of the report.
3.8
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Road Mentor. A detailed note on the preparation of the Traffic Survey Format for the present
study is given in Section 5.2 (Chapter 5).
3.9
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
without any overtaking within the sensor’s field. Care should be taken to ensure that the
sensors are correctly installed and the equipment is adequately secured against vandalism
and theft. The equipment should be tested and its sensitivity adjusted to detect all types of
required vehicles. Accurate tuning of inductive loops is also a particularly skilled task.
Periodic site visits may be necessary to check that sensors are in good condition or
pneumatic tubes have been cut or suffered from moisture ingression. Periodic maintenance
and upkeep of the electronic devices is a necessity for accurate and reliable results.
3.10
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Hence, it is necessary to carry out the traffic count exercise based on sample methods, i.e.
any traffic count carried out for short duration, e.g. 12 hours on a specific day of the week
could be converted into the AADT. This sample based traffic survey exercise would cut down
the man-hours involved in continuous traffic counting.
Keeping the above in view, TANROADS has embarked on the present study to establish the
traffic adjustment factors in Tanzania mainland, so that any traffic counts carried out by
TANROADS on the Trunk and Regional Roads with the help of various TAFs derived in the
Study, can be converted into the ADT and the AADT level with a fair level of accuracy, which
could be used for any highway planning purposes. For any highway planning, the highway
agency needs, the following statistics relating to the traffic:
Average Daily Traffic (ADT);
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT); and
Time and flow during Peak Hour.
For deriving the above levels of traffic, the following TAFs would be required on the data
obtained through short duration traffic counts:
Hourly Traffic Adjustment Factors in a day;
Daily Traffic Adjustment Factors in a week; and
Monthly or Seasonal Traffic Adjustment Factors in a year;
Besides the above TAFs, traffic growth factors for future traffic estimates would be required
for traffic level of future.
3.11
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
3.12
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
For converting any ADTs to the AADTs, two adjustment factors: (i) representing the daily
variations (i.e. the day of week on which the survey was carried out); and (ii) the monthly
variations (i.e. the month of the year in which the survey was undertaken) are required.
Methodology of converting short duration traffic counts to the AADT / baseline traffic count
has been also illustrated in Figure 3.2.
It may be mentioned that if the traffic count has been conducted for 24 hours, there is no
need for applying any hourly traffic adjustment factors for deriving an ADT, as any 24-hour
traffic count has already incorporated the hourly variations in the traffic count. Similarly, if
traffic count has been taken for seven consecutive days, the data, thus, obtained for seven
days traffic volume need to be averaged, which is nothing, but the ADT for the traffic section,
so in such case there is no need to apply traffic adjustment factor for daily variations in the
week.
It is often seen that while taking any decisions on the investments in infrastructure projects
get delayed due to several reasons, where difficult to use the even immediate past years’
traffic data, and at the same time, organizing a fresh traffic survey would be a costly
proposition or may not be possible for several reasons. In such cases, the then AADT
derived (i.e. old available data) needs to be projected for arriving at new baseline traffic as
well as any short or long term traffic projections by using the appropriate traffic projection
growth factors. These growth factors are derived using the traffic forecast model established
for specific purposes and regions. A brief note on deriving the traffic growth factors is
presented in Section 3.11.7.
3.11.7 Growth Factors
It is very difficult to estimate traffic in future for any traffic sections of road network, as there
are many socio-economic and political factors, which are likely to take place in future, would
also affect the traffic levels. Moreover, there might be several changes in those factors due
to a number of known or unknown factors, and not necessarily predictable. However, for any
traffic projection exercise, the growth factors are generally dependent on the observed past
trend of traffic on the same or nearby traffic sections, planned changes in the major socio-
economic parameters, viz. population, overall growth in the GDP, and growth in the major
sectors of the economy, viz. agriculture and mining, manufacturing and construction, trade,
transport and communications.
The growth factors are usually derived for any particular traffic sections or geographical
regions by establishing causal relations with the transport and traffic related parameters and
the above-mentioned socio-economic performance indicators. During the present
Consultancy Services, a generalized traffic forecast modeling exercise has been carried out,
which is relevant to use for the Trunk and Regional Roads of Tanzania mainland for
undertaking traffic projection exercises (Chapter 8). So, after having arrived at the respective
growth rates, the appropriate traffic projection factors need to be applied on the AADT (base
year) to derive the level of traffic for future years.
3.11.8 Limitations & Constraints
The above sections describe the derivation and application of the TAFs for determining
ADTs and AADTs for the data collected through short duration traffic counts. Short duration
traffic counts are undertaken, mainly due to resource constraints, and with the help of
suitable TAFs, the ADTs and AADTs are established for highway planning and investments,
where reliability and accuracy of the traffic estimates are highly desirable. Since the short
duration traffic counts are highly dependent on the applications of TAFs, it is important to list
out the limitations and constraints of the technique, so that any users should be cautious,
and may further apply required remedial measures. The likely limitations and constraints in
the derivation and application of the TAFs in determining the ADTs or AADTs for any specific
traffic sections are illustrated as follows:
3.13
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Short duration traffic count should be carried out on a normal day, otherwise
significant distortion in the traffic can be expected, as any changes in traffic flow even
for a couple of hours or so, e.g. on account of bad weather, would affect the
ADT/AADT estimates considerably;
The present traffic trend may not continue in future, due to several changes in
external socio-economic parameters as well as neighboring land locked countries, in
case of Tanzania;
Introduction of any alternate route or mode of transport in any specific areas, would
affect level of traffic;
Special projects or heavy investments along the specific traffic sections or on the
network;
Due to severe changes in road pavement conditions either “good to bad” or “bad to
good” effecting considerable changes in traffic level over a period of time;
Where the traffic level is too low, the incremental effect of using TAFs might be
insignificant;
If short duration traffic count carried out either in lean or peak season, the use of the
TAFs may not yield the true picture;
Any effect taking place due to the vehicle fleet modernization on level of traffic;
Growing fuel prices in the world market may have considerable effects of modal
choice;
In case the duration of traffic count is too low, e.g. much below 12 hours in a day, the
accuracy and reliability of data would lower in proportion;
Unusual weather related distortions in traffic, such as, duration and extent of rainy
season, mark changes in start and end of specific season in a year, etc.
Validity of TAFs should not be considered for very long time, as in long term, the
parameters affecting traffic would also change with varied degrees; and
At some places, there may be considerable difference in the traffic pattern on the
traffic section selected the TAFs and other regional roads located in its catchment’s
area.
The limitations and constraints listed above are not comprehensive enough to capture many
unforeseen events. However, these limitations may not be termed as severe ones. It is
advised that to mitigate such problems, the use of the TAFs should be used carefully with
the above notes and considerations.
study: (i) traffic volume analysis; and (ii) determination of traffic adjustment factors,
described as follows:
3.12.1 Traffic Volume Analysis
Under the traffic volume analysis, the following tables and diagrams (Pie Chart, Line
Diagram, etc., as per the requirements) need to be prepared, for every traffic sections:
Hourly Variation of Traffic;
Daily Variation of Traffic;
Monthly Variation of Traffic;
Traffic Structure, i.e. Composition of Traffic by vehicles (Motorized/Non-Motorized;
Average Daily Traffic (ADT); and
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT).
3.15
1.
Establishment of Traffic Count Points 4
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
1
Entry/way out.
4.1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Following the number of traffic sections and count points, as per the ToR, other criteria and
considerations for identification of the traffic sections considered for conducting traffic
census in Tanzania under the present Consultancy Services have been given, as follows:
• A traffic section should have sufficient length representing a sizeable network of trunk
road length and /or regional roads network;
• The traffic section should have an importance for economic activities in the area of
influence, which may include agricultural activities, such as, cash crop production, mining
activities, animal husbandry, fishing, timber products; large and small industries and
business, and trade activities;
• The traffic section should be in a fair condition, i.e. passable in most part of the year, so
that traffic cannot be diverted to other road or mode of transport, and hence, setting with
the traffic trend; and
• The traffic section should have a fair level of traffic so that slight changes in traffic
volume recorded may have minimum influence in the determined traffic adjustment
factors.
4.2.2 Traffic Sections on the Primary Road Network of Tanzania
For identifying the specific traffic sections on the network, and also to establish traffic survey
count points in the traffic sections, available maps of the Trunk and Regional Road Network
of Tanzania were reviewed. The exercise was also supported with the facts and figures
obtained during the field visits of the Project Traffic Engineers on different features affecting
traffic volume on the network. The features influencing the road network are: junctions,
inhabitation pattern and major economic activity centers, such as, mining, factories, markets,
etc. Influence of local traffic in case of roads connecting major population centers is avoided,
while selecting the traffic survey count points on any traffic sections. Following the method
and steps mentioned above, the Consultants identified the traffic sections on the National
and Regional Road network in Tanzania, as illustrated in Maps 4.1/1 to 4.1/10.
4.3 Establishment of Traffic Count Locations Countrywide
4.3.1 General
As per the ToR, the Study, inter alia, had to establish traffic count locations countrywide, and
was supposed to select and justify the locations of traffic count ponts. The conceptual and
methodological part of the establishment of traffic count locations has been elaborated under
the traffic count methodology for Tanzania along with relevant historical facts on the traffic
counting in the country.
4.3.2 Details of Traffic Sections in 1985
The Ministry of Communications and Works (MoCW) organized manual or enumerator
based classified traffic counts on 266 traffic sections and count points on the Trunk and
Regional Roads in the country during 1972-85. The counts undertaken were, however, not
regular. In 1985, the MoCW conducted a one-year traffic counting activities on 40 count
points (CPs) on their respective traffic sections. These traffic sections and CPs were
distributed throughout the primary road network in Tanzania. Of these CPs, 39 traffic
sections and CPs were on the Trunk Roads network, and only one traffic section/CP on a
Regional Road. The data obtained were used later in 1987 to calculate the Traffic
Adjustment Factors (TAFs).
The MoCW prepared the National Traffic Counting Plan (NTCP) in 1987 (Annexure 4.1),
which was to be implemented between 1988 and 1995 on 322 traffic sections and CPs, of
which 204 CPs were on the Trunk Roads and 118 CPs on the Regional Roads. In the
NTCP, the 40 CPs in their respective traffic sections were also included. Somehow, the
4.2
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
NTCP was well implemented in the early years, i.e. up to 1991, but the counting was
stopped by 1994 due to various reasons including lack of resources.
The Plan was to be implemented in 9 years from 1988 to 1996 on 322 traffic sections and
CPs. The Planning and Research Unit (PRU), MoCW, was to implement the NTCP using
own resources. A total of 711 traffic counts were planned over the Plan period on an
average of 79 CPs per year. The implementation of NTCP was modest, i.e. over 60% in
1988 and 1989, but climaxed in 1990 at which implementation was over 130% as shown in
Table 4.1. The implementation, however, dropped below 50% in 1992, and in the
subsequent years after 1992, the counts were stopped mainly due to financial constraints.
Table 4.1: Implementation of NTCP (1988-96)
Particular 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992-96 Total Average
Planned CPs 81 81 74 81 394 711 79*
Counted CPs 54 52 98 27 -- 231 58*
Implementation (%) 67 64 132 33 -- 33 74**
* Average for the first four years of NTCP implementation; ** Average percentage of 1988-1991.
Source: Strategy for Traffic Surveys, Assessment of Existing Data, Traffic Survey Manual for MoW, 1992, and
the Consultants’ Evaluations.
4.3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
A comprehensive list illustrating: Count Point No.; Location; Road Name; Traffic Section;
Comments; and Road No. is presented in Annexure 4.2. The selected traffic sections and
the identified count point locations are classified into the 21 Regions of Tanzania for proper
planning and administrative purposes. A summary of the region-wise distribution of the traffic
sections and count points is presented in Table 4.2.
4.4
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
there will be modification in the basic requirements and considerations. However, the
location of the counting stations on the traffic sections will be more or less the same.
4.4.1 Public Shelter
It is desirable that the traffic counting should be done at a proper place. The presence of
public shelter for enumerators to be protected from the weather is important, so that they
could perform their duties effectively. Such places include local hotels or Migahawa, kiosk,
bus stand, dispensary compound, police posts, etc. If public places are not available, private
houses could be proposed for the traffic survey count points with the consent of the owners.
Experience has shown that, in view of transport development concerns, people in general
cooperate to allow enumerators to perform the traffic counts from their premises.
4.4.2 Secure Place
The places identified for carrying out the traffic counts need to be safe for the enumerators
to perform their activities with minimum security risks, particularly during nights. The count
points (CPs) should be generally located in the outskirts of villages or towns where some
activities also take place during the night time, so that sense of security could be realized.
4.4.3 Public Accommodation
It is normal practice that enumerators based traffic counts are carried out round the clock
requiring work in shift and rest in between shifts at proper and convenient place. Hence,
while fixing the counting points, identification of proper staying place for enumerators and
supervisors and ideally located in view of the proposed count points is highly desirable.
Need for public accommodation also depend on the survey duration, i.e. short or long
period. If traffic counts are being conducted for short or long duration at the same location, it
would be desirable to train and employ local traffic enumerators, i.e. from the same town or
village where the surveys are planned.
But, if the enumerators need to be moved from one CP to another CP, the enumerators
need public accommodation to stay for the entire duration of the survey. The
accommodation needs to be safe and affordable, so the places like guesthouses and hostels
are desirable. Under the present study, the traffic surveys were planned for 7 days, i.e. one
week in each of the month of the year of 2008, at 45 CPs spread all over the country, the
team of enumerators kept on moving weekly from one CP to another. So, any traffic count, if
planned in future, should also consider the survey duration and coverage of CPs requiring
movement from one place to another.
With the above considerations, the availability of public accommodation located nearby the
survey places were given due regard, while planning the traffic surveys. During the field
visits of the Consultants, it was realized that in some cases, it would be difficult to get proper
places for staying near the CPs, and they need to stay a bit away from their designated CPs.
In such cases, they need to rely mainly on public transport system while starting the survey
activities in morning or finishing in evening, depending on their duties in the survey shifts.
4.4.4 Minimum Local Traffic Effects
The location of the traffic survey count points should be away from the urban areas to
minimize the local traffic, i.e. somewhere at the middle of the identified traffic sections, so
that true representative traffic information could be collected. The traffic sections identified
for conducting the surveys are usually connecting two towns or major junctions, i.e.
represented by two nodes. If the locations of CPs are closer to the nodes representing either
side of the traffic section, the probability of counting local traffic would be higher due to
proximity of higher socio-economic activities at both the nodes.
Though a place somewhat at the middle of the traffic section would theoretically be desirable
for undertaking the traffic counting, practically a point at the middle of the traffic section may
be located in a remote place with hardly any facilities. Hence, it is desirable that the location
4.5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
of the CPs should be selected near to the towns/villages, and at the same time also
adequately away from the influence of the town or local traffic movement, so that the effect
of that kind of traffic would be minimum.
4.5 Reconnaissance Survey of the Proposed Traffic Survey Areas
After the Desk Work of identification and selection of the 45 traffic sections and count points
for the Study, a Reconnaissance Survey was carried out by the Project Traffic Engineers
and TANROADS Counterpart personnel to the Project for covering the entire primary road
network of Tanzania Mainland. During the Reconnaissance Survey, the aspects considered
were physical feature of the specific traffic sections, which included specification of the
nodes containing the traffic section, length, surface type (paved, unpaved or combination of
both), traffic mix, motorized (cars, pick up/vans, buses and trucks) and non-motorized, and
movement pattern (local/long distance and international transit traffic). These issues and
observations are discussed in the following sections and also summarized in Annexure 4.3.
4.5.1 Traffic Section Nodes
Most of the traffic section nodes specified at the Desk Work were confirmed during the
Reconnaissance Survey and meetings with the Regional Officials of TANROADS, except for
a few cases whereby the Regional Authorities proposed other traffic sections for determining
the traffic adjustment factors (TAFs).
4.5.2 Length of the Traffic Sections
The project vehicle used in the Reconnaissance Survey was fitted with an odometer, which
facilitated taking the chainage from one point to the other. In doing so, it was possible to
determine the lengths of proposed traffic sections. The traffic sections have been evaluated,
ranging between 9 km (Kanyani-Kasulu) and 191 km (Itigi-Rungwa) traffic sections.
4.5.3 Surface Type
The surface type of the primary road network in Tanzania was observed during the
Reconnaissance Survey as earth, gravel or bituminous paved. A few short problematic
stretches were found paved with concrete as well. During the Reconnaissance Survey, for
reference, the surface types of the traffic sections were specified as (P) for paved (bitumen
or concrete) sections or (U) for unpaved earth or gravel surfaced roads. Traffic sections with
unpaved surfaces ranged from 9 km (Kanyani-Kasulu) to 191 km (Itigi-Rungwa), whereas for
the paved road traffic sections from 16 km (Kanazi-Muhutwe) to 115 km (Songea-Madaba).
4.5.4 Surface Condition
Condition of the identified traffic sections were observed by recording the surface condition
and irregularities, such as, rutting and cracking in case of paved roads and potholes,
depressions, corrugations, gravel loss in case of unpaved roads. In each case, the average
speed over which the driver was comfortably driving was recorded. It was possible to
classify the condition of the roads as Good, Fair or Poor. “Good” was specified for recently
constructed, graveled or graded road with running speeds of over 80 km/hr; and “Fair” for
older pavements with some potholes, cracking for bitumen roads and with some
corrugations, some gravel loss in each case with running speeds over 40-60 km/hr. For
roads in “poor” condition, the surface got deteriorated badly requiring major repairs with
running speeds of 30 km/hr and below. Majority of the traffic sections identified for the traffic
counts were generally in good to fair condition.
4.5.5 Traffic Mix & Movement Pattern
During the Reconnaissance Survey, the Project Traffic Engineers also collected information
through moving traffic counts for vehicles crossing, overtaken and those, which overtook the
survey vehicle. The vehicles were put into four classes, cars, pick-ups/vans, buses and
trucks.
4.6
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The Survey Team observed that the traffic mix on the selected traffic sections varied
considerably, and it was very difficult to set any patterns. For example, trucks presence
varied from 8 to 80% followed by pick-up and vans 9 to 48%, buses 8 to 43% and cars nil to
14%. Local traffic (within the districts’ headquarters) have been estimated varying between
15 and 80%, long distance traffic (between districts and regions) 20 and 75% and
international transit nil and 50%. Since these observations were visual with so much
variation, it was difficult to set any general trends in the traffic compositions on the selected
traffic sections.
4.5.6 Socio-economic Characteristics of the Catchments’ Areas
During the Reconnaissance Survey, data on the socio-economic characteristics in the area
of influence of the traffic sections were also collected. The information collected, inter alia,
included mainly on agricultural and industrial activities, such as, food crops, cash crops,
livestock raising, mineral exploitation/potential, major and minor industries, fishing and trade.
A brief note on the same is presented as follows and also summarized in Annexure 4.4.
(i) Food Crops: Food crops cultivated in most of the influence areas are starch foods
represented by maize, rice, sorghum, millet, sweet potatoes, Irish potatoes, etc., and pulses
including beans, green peas, etc. Different types food crops are grown in varied agro-
climatic regions of the country.
(ii) Cash Crops: Cash crops popular in the areas of influence consist of cashew nuts,
coconuts, tobacco, coffee, cotton, sisal tea, pyrethrum, cocoa, sunflower, etc. Growing cash
crops are usually concentrated in some suitable geographical locations, e.g. cashew nuts
and coconuts are mostly grown in the coastal regions of Pwani, Lindi, and Mtwara, whereas
tobacco is grown in Ruvuma, Tabora, Singida and Kagera Regions. Coffee is grown in
Kilimanjaro, Arusha, Kagera, Mbeya and Ruvuma Regions. Cotton is mostly grown in
Shinyanga, Mwanza and Mara regions and to some extent Tabora Region.
(iii) Livestock Raising: Livestock raising practices in the areas of influence include
cattle, goats, pig and chicken, of these only cattle has been considered for the raising. Cattle
(indigenous) raising is popular in the central and northern regions of Tanzania, viz. Dodoma,
Singida, Tabora, Shinyanga, Mwanza, Mara, Arusha and Kilimanjaro (improved dairy). The
coastal regions including Pwani, Lindi and Mtwara have little population of cattle.
(iv) Mineral Potential: Mineral potential/exploitation in the influence areas of the primary
road network include mineral oil and gas in the coastal regions of Lindi and Mtwara,. Gold
mining is found in Mwanza, Shinyanga, Mara and Tabora Regions. It is reported that other
regions also have potential for gold. Tanzanite and other gemstones are mined in Arusha
Region. Coal is mined in Mbeya and Rukwa. Considerable potential for coal and iron ore
exist at Mchuchuma and Liganga areas respectively in Iringa Region. Potential for
gemstones are abound in many areas in the country. Salt farming is mainly practiced in the
coastal areas of Tanga, Lindi, Mtwara, and Uvinza in Kigoma Region.
(v) Industries: Limited Industrial activities were found in the influence areas of the
primary road network. A few industrial activities reported are processing plants of coffee
curing, maize and wheat flour, ginneries, etc. Other activities are timber, cashew nut
processing, etc.
(vi) Fishing: Fishing is one of the important activities on the coastal areas of Tanzania,
viz. regions of Tanga, Pwani, Lindi, and Mtwara. Fishing is also practiced around Lake
Victoria, Lake Tanganyika, Lake Rukwa and Lake Nyasa, and at Mtera dam (Iringa Region)
and Nyumba ya Mungu dams (Kilimanjaro Region). To some extent, fishing is practiced in
rivers like Rufiji, Ruvu. Ruaha, Malagarasi, Ugalla, and Kilombero.
(vii) Trade: Trading activities in the influence areas of the primary road network cover
general merchandize goods in small shops and kiosks. These shops are stocked with
essential items, such as, salt, sugar, paraffin, cooking oil, matchboxes, sandals, kerosene
lamps, shoes, etc. Food crops, fruits and vegetables are also traded within and between
villages and towns in the area of influence.
4.7
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
4.8
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
4.7 Sum Up
The selection and establishment of the count points countrywide were carried out following
comprehensive efforts and information available through the secondary sources and several
consultations at different levels, which include Regional Offices, TANROADS, other
stakeholders and local knowledgeable people. Since the establishment of the count points
would be used in future as well, particularly in a regularly changing situation of the primary
road network of the country, the task became more important. The process of improving as
well as incorporating new changes in the primary road network in Tanzania was duly
considered during the Consultancy Services.
4.9
Traffic Count Methodology for Tanzania 5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5.1 Fixing the Traffic Survey Count Points on the Traffic Sections
The methodology for identifying the traffic sections is adequately discussed in Chapter 4.
After having determined the traffic sections on a specific Trunk or Regional Roads, it is
necessary to locate and fix the CPs, so that the traffic survey activities could be undertaken
effectively and purposefully. Ideally, any points along the traffic section can be a candidate
location for the survey count. Within the framework of the Desk Study, it is only possible to
use available maps and sketches of the survey area and name of the places for traffic
survey count points, such as, at Mtakuja Village, south of town “A”, east of junction to the
factory “B” or so.
Names of the places for the traffic count points refer to any specific and permanent physical
structures, so that it could be easily identified. This effort would require inspections for
setting the physical coordinates on the road including residential places, location of villages,
road junctions, etc. Any suitable location for the count point should be referenced to some
permanent structures, with GPS Southing and Easting, if possible. This should be done for
all possible locations fixed for the CPs on the traffic sections, including those CPs specified
during the Desk Work. Each point should be evaluated for its suitability against the criteria
for availability of shelter, it being secure and presence of public accommodation and
minimum local traffic effects (again depending on the modality of sourcing the enumerators).
The alternative proposed locations of the CP on the same traffic section should be evaluated
as per the merit, and accordingly it should be recommended.
For the location of the 45 CPs on the selected traffic sections, the Consultants conducted
the field survey trips covering the southern, northern, central and western regions of
Tanzania. The first trip covered 20 CPs in Coast, Lindi, Mtwara, Ruvuma, Mbeya, Rukwa,
Iringa and Morogoro Regions during Oct-Nov 2007, the second field trip covered 25 CPs in
Tanga, Kilimanjaro, Arusha, Manyara, Dodoma, Singida, Tabora Mara, Mtwara, Kagera,
Shinyanga and Kigoma Regions during Nov-Dec 2007.
For all the CPs identified on the selected traffic sections, consensus with respective
Regional Managers of TANROADS was solicited during the above field trips. The list of 45
CPs’ locations approved by the Regional Managers is as shown in Annexure 5.1.
5.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5.2
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5.3
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
appreciate the then conclusions of the entire efforts in view of its main objectives. However,
it can be easily inferred that while conducting any traffic count surveys, the incidence of
degree of loadability in terms of full load, half load and empty is not possible.
(ii) National Traffic Counting Plan (1988-1996): The traffic survey activities in
Tanzania were intensified in 1988, when MoCW prepared a nine-year Traffic Counting Plan
for 1988-1996. A total of 322 Traffic Count Points (CPs) were planned to cover during the
Plan Period, of which, 204 CPs were on the Trunk Road network, and 118 on the Regional
Road network.
As per the Plan, for the purpose of designating the permanent CPs, only 19 places were
selected for yearly counting on the Trunk Road Network. For covering the remaining CPs on
the Trunk Road, it was also planned that during subsequent three years, the traffic surveys
would be conducted at 60-62 CPs every year, whereas, for the 118 CPs on the Regional
Roads, it was decided that on the basis of random selection, the traffic surveys would be
organized on 19-20 CPs every year.
It may be noted that due to the resource constraints, this effort was not sustained in
subsequent years, and continued on a reducing scale until 1991. With the result, in 1991,
roads only in the northern part of the country were surveyed. The traffic counts from 1988 to
1991 are shown in Table 5.2.
Table 5.2: Traffic Count in Tanzania (1988-1991)
Number and Duration (Days) of counts Total for
Year
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 the Year
1988 6 3 76 1 - 3 97 186
1989 1 - 59 - - - 8 68
1990 - - 99 - - - 1 100
1991 - - 27 - - - - 27
Total 7 3 261 1 - 3 106 381
(iii) Traffic Survey Manual (1992): The Ministry of Works prepared a Trunk Road Traffic
Survey Strategy for conducting traffic surveys at 60 count points spread over the Trunk
Road network in Tanzania. The traffic survey was to last for a year, and the data were
presumably be used for validating and updating the traffic adjustment factors (TAFs)
obtained through the Traffic Surveys conducted during 1985. In 1992, a Traffic Survey
Manual was prepared for Traffic Count on The Road Network of Tanzania. That Manual
suggested to take into consideration the following motorized vehicles for traffic count, viz.
Cars, Land Rover (Public), Land Rover (Non-Public), Small bus, Large Bus, Small Truck,
Medium Truck, Heavy Truck and Tractor-Trailer combination. There was no provision of
non-motorized vehicle counting in the Manual. The traffic survey strategy could, however,
not materialize due to various reasons.
5.2.5 Development of Traffic Survey Format
While developing the Traffic Survey Format, the Consultants made full use of prevailing
practices of the TANROADS for their routine traffic surveys carried out by different Regional
Offices, requirements of different highway investment and planning software, viz. HDM-4,
RED, RMMS and Road Mentor, and also supported with the information perceived by the
Project team of the Traffic Engineers, particularly during the Reconnaissance Survey. The
Traffic Survey Format, presented in Annexure 5.2-A, is also compatible with developing the
database, determining the Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs), using the Generalized Traffic
Forecast Model, and several other queries, which might be required from time to time in
further analyses and highway sector planning in the country.
Besides the “General Information” on the survey location, date, day, direction, weather
condition, GPS referencing, etc., the Traffic Survey Format has been classified into two
major groups: (i) time of the survey (hourly classification); and (ii) classified vehicles
5.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
(motorized and non-motorized), in terms of passenger and goods vehicles. The traffic count
needed to follow the tally bar system while counting each vehicle type.
(i) Motorized Traffic: The motorized vehicles under the passenger category consist of
cars, utility vehicles, two wheeler, bus (<=25 seats), bus (>25 seats), and others; whereas
under the goods category; light truck, medium truck (2-axle), heavy truck (3-axle), and very
heavy/articulated trucks. It may be noted that three-wheeler vehicles (popularly known as
“Bajaj”) are occasionally seen on roads of the country, particularly within the cities and urban
areas or serving short-distances places located nearby. The number of such vehicles is not
more at present, and it is also reported that these vehicles would not use the Trunk and
Regional Road network in near future due to its operational limitations for long distance
haulage, light load carrying capacity causing high unit transport cost, and safety concerns.
With the above consideration as well as not representing the Tanzanian vehicle fleet
composition, the Study has not incorporated the three-wheelers in the Traffic Survey Format.
(ii) Non-Motorized Traffic: Discussions with the TANROADS Officials at the
Headquarters and the Regional Offices revealed that the non-motorized vehicles were not
incorporated in current traffic count surveys being undertaken by the Regional Offices. It is
also learnt that while undertaking any investment planning and decision making using the
standard highway software, viz. HDM-4, RED, RMMS, and Road Mentor, the non-motorized
traffic (NMT) was not incorporated.
However, it has been observed that the NMT is widely used in the rural areas of Tanzania
using bicycles, tricycles, animal drawn carts and wheelbarrow to transport agriculture inputs
and outputs1. It may be noted that about 25% of the total rural transport services are catered
by the NMT. This situation reduces efficiency in economic activities and marketing,
accelerating poverty in rural areas. Thus, the National Transport Policy underlines the
importance of the NMT, particularly with gender consideration2. The Plan further endorses
that in such areas where there is inadequate transport facilities and low level of affordability,
the NMT are to be used to ferry passengers and goods.
Keeping the acceptance of the NMT in Tanzania, as an important mode of transport,
presently as well as in near future, the Consultants have included bicycle, and animal drawn
vehicle/hand cart representing the NMT in the traffic survey format. The main purpose of the
inclusion of the NMT in the Format is to collect the data during the on-going survey efforts,
which would otherwise be a costly affair, if organized exclusively. The data collected on the
NMT would be very useful in several analyses, particularly estimating the VOCs of the
motorized vehicles with its influencing factors, such as, roadside friction, speed deterioration
model, congestion, etc.; and also evaluating safety concerns.
1
National Transport Policy (2003), the Ministry of Communications and Transport, p 28.
2
.Ibid, as women spend about 75% of their time walking for long distances to and from farms and
other production centers.
5.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The appropriate traffic data collection technology depends upon the objectives of the survey,
level of accuracy and the resources available. The traffic classifiers are generally preferred
to simple counters, which merely count the traffic volume in unclassified manner. It may be
noted that though the traffic classifiers are much costlier than the simple counters, the
classifiers are preferred, as it provides full details on vehicle composition in the traffic
volume, which are useful in highway engineering planning, etc. It is important that the
vehicle classification system be appropriate for the vehicle fleet in the country.
In view of the above background, the Automatic Traffic Counters and Classifiers (ATCCs)
equipment for conducting the traffic counts on the primary road network in Tanzania should
meet the requirements as described in Section 5.4.2.
5.4.2 Requirements for the Selection of ATCCs
Based on the condition of road network, type of motorized and non-motorized traffic moving
on the road network, and the study’s requirement, the following essential and desirable
prerequisites for the procurement of Automatic Traffic Counters and Classifiers equipment in
Tanzania, have been identified:
(i) Essential Requirements
The equipment must be capable of recording traffic continuously under the varied conditions of
weather, such as, heavy rains, humid and fluctuating temperature, etc. in Tanzania;
The equipment must collect data regarding traffic volume, direction, speed, vehicle
classification and headway for each vehicle passes;
It should preferably be capable of counting motorized as well as non-motorized vehicles. It
should have provision of counting multi-axle trucks (varying from 3 axles to 6 axles);
Vehicle count and classification errors must be within the range of +/-2% of the actual volume
and class;
It should work on different types of roads, viz. paved, gravel and earthen roads;
The equipment should record traffic data on minimum of 15 minutes time interval option;
It should be easy to operate with least maintenance requirements. The equipment will be
essentially used in rural area, so it should have good power back up provision. Spare parts
and maintenance back up should be easily available.
The equipment and its related software should be user friendly, and capable of generating the
required outputs;
The supplier of the equipment must provide operating software compatible with Microsoft
Windows 2000, XP or Microsoft Windows Vista for Pocket PC, which will interface with the
equipment in the field;
The analysis software must be capable of adjusting the classification algorithms or providing
for user defined classification schemes;
The analysis software must be able to provide reports for individual vehicles, listing the speed,
direction, class, wheelbase, headway gap, number of axles and wheel picture of every vehicle;
The equipment and related software must be able to generate reports using either English or
Metric units with the choice being made after the data are collected;
In view of equipment costs, higher utilization and safety, the equipment with mobile character
would be preferred. It should be robust and temper proof with a minimum 12 months warranty
period;
The user must be able to view the estimated number of days of battery life remaining and
provide warning when battery is low to avoid any eventualities;
The analysis software must be capable of excluding data from specified time periods during a
day of the data set to be analyzed, and must be able to exclude entire day (any abnormality)
from the data set analysis.
The analysis software must be capable of eliminating undesired vehicles from the data set to
be analyzed; and
As Tanzania experiences fair amount of rain throughout the year, so traffic counters and
classifiers should be workable during rainy season with same accuracy.
5.7
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5.8
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
3
For the present study, the Consultants have proposed 45 traffic sections and count points on the
Trunk and Regional Roads in Tanzania mainland.
5.9
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
accessories for the survey. It may be noted that the exact location of the traffic survey
counts on all the traffic sections were duly endorsed by the TANROADS Officials.
The arrangements were made in such a manner that the enumerators should reach the
designated survey locations well in advance, preferably, two days prior to the
commencement of the surveys at specific locations, so that the survey enumerators could
take care of the pre-requisites, such as, accommodation, preparation of the survey posts,
light, furniture, etc.
At initial phase of the traffic surveys, the Traffic Supervisors and the Project Traffic
Engineers visited all the 45 count points soon after the commencement of the traffic surveys.
Besides undertaking the routine monitoring and quality control of the data collection efforts,
the experts sorted out any local problems occurring during the conduction of the survey. This
exercise was considered as important one, particularly at the initial stages of the survey
activities.
As detailed in Section 5.6, each group of the enumerators were responsible for conducting
traffic surveys at three nearby count points in every month. After completing the survey
activities at one count point, enumerators moved to the other count points, and conducted
the survey in similar way.
5.10
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Otherwise, the Consultants might use some correction factors or redo the survey for that
specific counting point(s).
Besides the above, the monitoring and quality control mechanism also got evolved with
more knowledge of ground realities and further experience gained throughout the
Consultancy Services. Any development in this regard was duly discussed with the officials
of TANROADS at Headquarters in Dar es Salaam as well as at the Regional Offices.
Towards monitoring and quality control mechanism, during the Reconnaissance Survey, the
Consultants also discussed the above approach and arrangements with the TANROADS’
Regional Officials, and it was mentioned that the Regional Officials also actively participated
and monitored the survey activities in the areas of their jurisdiction.
5.11
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5.12
1.
Figure 5.1: Approach & Methodology for the Traffic Surveys for Establishing Baseline Traffic & Traffic Adjustment Factors
Locations Months
MoW, Trunk Road Traffic Stations & Reconnaissance Training of month
Survey Strategy (1992) Update Survey Traffic
Additional Enumerators
TANROADS, Traffic Data Proposed
Acquisition Study by DHV Traffic CPs
Pilot Surveys
Consultants (2004) Quality Control
Establishment of Baseline
Traffic & Traffic Adjustment
CPs: Count Points
Factors
MCW: Ministry of Communications & Works
***Equipment based traffic count at the selected locations on the approval of the TANROADS.
Table-5.1: Vehicles Compatibility of Different Software in Tanzania
Vehicle Software
Selected Vehicles
Category HDM-4 RED Road Mentor RMMS
Motorized Vehicles
Two-Wheelers Motor Cycle Motor Cycle Motor Cycles
Small Car Small Car Car Cars Cars
Cars Medium Car Medium Car
Large Car Large Car
Light Delivery Vehicle Light Delivery Vehicle Pickup or Van Pickups and Vans Pickups and Vans
Utilities Light Goods Vehicle Light Goods Vehicle
Four Wheel Drive Four Wheel Drive
Light Truck Light Truck Light Lorries Light Lorries Light Truck
Medium Truck Medium Truck Medium Lorries Medium Lorries Medium Truck
Trucks
5.14
Heavy Truck Heavy Truck Heavy Lorries Heavy Lorries Heavy Truck
Articulated Truck Articulated Truck Very Heavy Lorries Very Heavy Lorries Articulated Truck
Mini Bus Mini Bus Buses <=25 Seats Buses under 25 Seats Buses <=25 Seats
Light Bus Light Bus Large Buses >25 Seats Buses over 25 Seats Large Buses >25 Seats
Buses Medium Bus Medium Bus
Heavy Bus Heavy Bus
Coach Coach
*** - - - - Others if any (Please Specify)
Non-Motorized Vehicles
Animal Cart Animal Cart Pedestrians Other Vehicles Bicycle
Bicycle Bicycle Bicycle Animal Drawn
Rickshaw Rickshaw Animal Cart Hand Cart
Pedestrians Pedestrians Pack Animals
*** - - - - Others if any (Please Specify)
6.1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
also based on their suitability for Tanzanian environment, within the available budget, and
test runs, etc. A detailed note on the procurement of the ATCCs is given in Chapter 7.
It may be noted that even after having procured the traffic counting equipment by
TANROADS, the decision on whether the survey method would follow deploying
enumerators or by ATCCs, needs to be made for specific traffic sections, based on the level
of traffic volume, level of accuracy of data, frequency of the surveys, etc. In other words,
both the survey methods, viz. enumerator and ATCCs based, can be suitably used for
undertaking the traffic count exercise on the road network of the country. For the manual
count, a pre-structured traffic survey format is required (Chapter 5, Section 5.2), whereas the
ATCCs count and classify the vehicles passing through, into different types based on the
length of the vehicle / axle spacing.
6.1.3 Short Duration Traffic Surveys
The concept and need for short duration traffic count has been adequately discussed in
Chapter 3, illustrating the need and justification of short duration surveys under resource
constraints. For conducting the traffic census in Tanzania, the short duration counts (SDCs)
are advised for 12 to 24 hours on any week days, or 12 to 24 hours for three continuous or
two on normal week days, and one on Saturday/Sunday (i.e. week end). The traffic count
data, thus, obtained through the above SDCs need to be adjusted to the average daily
traffic, and the annual average daily traffic by using appropriate TAFs. While undertaking the
SDCs, the exact timing of the survey is important, e.g. traffic count on abnormal traffic
conditions, extreme traffic conditions (lean or heavy), etc. are advised to be avoided, as
under these conditions, it would be difficult to use any appropriate TAFs.
6.2
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
illustration, Count Point No. 16 on the traffic section located at Kasamwa between Usagara
and Biharamulo in Mwanza Region on Trunk Road No. T4, is selected for developing the
TAFs required to be used for any short duration traffic counts on the roads of the
catchment’s area. List of the roads falling in the catchment’s area of CP-16 is presented in
Table 6.1.
Table 6.1: Roads under the Catchment’s Area of Usanga-Biharamulo Road (CP No. 16)
16
21
6.3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Place of the traffic count carried illustrates the specific traffic section representing
roads of its catchment’s area for the purpose of traffic estimates;
Duration of survey in terms of number of hours in a day in specific day of the
week in a specified calendar month;
Vehicle-wise classified traffic counts on the selected count points on the specific
traffic section; and
Reference of any other unusual situation, e.g. heavy rain or foggy weather.
Using the relevant information as mentioned above, suitable TAFs should be applied for
estimating the ADT and AADT. The traffic data collected through CPs should be used for the
exercise for representative ADT for a normal day, and AADT for all the months/seasons.
Details on the applications of TAFs are given in the following paragraphs.
derive TAFs relevant for each month (Chapter 5, Section 5.11). So the user must collect the
specific TAF to use on the derived ADT (Section 6.4.1) to arrive at the AADT for several
traffic related analysis. In brief, all the relevant TAFs should be applied on the ADT to
determine the AADT.
1
For illustration, the Manyoni-Tabora-Kigoma Road including the Malagarasi River Bridge and
approach road, which are planned for construction in the near future. After the construction,
considerable traffic to/from the Democratic Republic of Congo, Burundi, Rwanda, etc. (currently
using the other routes in Tanzania) will be diverted to the above road. Other potential diverted traffic
routes will include the Mombasa-Nairobi-Sirari-Mwanza-Bujumbura; Dar es Salaam-Mbeya-Zambia-
the Democratic Republic of Congo; and the Mombasa-Nairobi-Kampala onwards routes on the
Northern Transport Corridor. Similarly, construction of Mtwara Corridor, i.e. Mtwara-Masasi-Songea-
Mbambabay will have diverted traffic from the alternative TANZAM Highway, and TAZARA for
Malawi and Zambia bound traffic.
6.6
Figure 6.1: Flow Chart Showing Derivation & Application of TAFs for Estimation of AADT
TAFs Derivation
Identification & Selection of Traffic Data Collection - one week in a month for
Traffic Sections one year at each CP
Traffic Forecast
Derivation of Daily Traffic Adjustment Factors Model
ADTs for all 12 months Average Daily Traffic (ADT) for the Traffic
Section
Derivation of Monthly Traffic Adjustment Factors
& other Exogenous Adjustment Factors (e.g.,
weather, any accident or some local factors) Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) for
the Traffic Section (Base Year Traffic)
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) Traffic Growth Rates
1
The results of traffic count on these CPs have been used for establishing different traffic adjustment
factors (TAFs) for the entire primary road network in Tanzania.
2
Depending on the factors, whether the equipment is mobile/temporary installed or required to be
fixed permanently on different counting stations. This would be mainly based on the extent and
magnitude of traffic counts required at different stations as well as the optimum usage of the
equipment.
3
Traffic equipment required to be capable of recording information as described in the Traffic Survey
Format designed for the present Study.
7.1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The advantage of traffic count equipment is to record information over a long period of time
with relatively much lower operational cost. Data collection based on any long duration will
minimize the errors caused by fluctuations in traffic flow depending on different pattern of
traffic on varied time period. For the purpose of classification of vehicles, traffic count
equipment normally detects the type of a vehicle taking into account the time taken between
the passage of individual axles or on the basis of overall length of the vehicle passed at the
count point.
The most appropriate traffic data collection methods, with equipment, depend upon the
objectives of the survey planned. For example, equipment with the traffic classifier facilities
is preferable to any simple counters, as the additional data, thus, obtained are usually worth
comparing its additional cost. However, in context of Tanzania, it is important that the vehicle
classification system would be appropriate for the prevailing vehicle fleet in the country. The
selection of technology is based mainly on the following factors and guidelines.
unemployment are beyond the scope of the Study to evaluate the resource cost implications.
However, it is important to keep these issues in mind while choosing any technology for
developing countries, including the traffic count equipment. For the purpose, a diagnostic
analysis revealing certain facts on the cost advantage of an equipment based traffic counting
has been worked out and presented in the following paragraphs.
4
Life Cycle Cost Analysis incorporates the capital as well as operation and maintenance costs over a
period of time, so that the total cost implications could be accounted for.
7.3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
5
The Traffic Data Acquisition (Final Report), 2004.
7.4
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
7.5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
length and the same axle spacing, probably for any ATCC equipment available. Therefore,
the worldwide practice adopted for getting more accurate vehicle classification is to measure
actual split of such vehicle modes (e.g. bus and truck) with manual counts over a short
duration of time and apply the split to the total count obtained by an ATCC.
For the purpose, the Study explored the following ATCC technologies, which were observed
to be widely used for the purpose of traffic counting, classification, and measurement of
speed, etc.: (i) Pneumatic Tube System; (ii) Inductive Loop Detector; (iii) Piezo-electric
Sensor; (iv) Digital Video Detection and Image Analysis; (v) Radar Counters & Classifiers;
and (vi) Automatic Number Plate Recognition.
The ATCC technologies listed above are briefly discussed with their merits and demerits as
follows:
(i) Pneumatic Tube System (PTS)
Pneumatic tubes are hollow rubber tubes stretched across the portion of the roadway where
vehicle counts and/or speeds are needed. One end of the tube is attached to a traffic
counter/classifier and the other end is plugged to prevent air leakage as a vehicle crosses
the transducer on the classifier. The tubes are typically 13 mm (0.5”) in diameter and are
relatively accurate for light traffic flows. Two tubes are placed around 1 m apart to measure
the axle spacing, speed, vehicle class, etc. The advance belt technology eliminates placing
of the two tubes at an exact distance apart. The belt is made up of two tubes placed exactly
6” apart.
Disadvantages:
The tubes or belts can easily get damaged due to poor road surface and heavy traffic and
vulnerable to vandalism; and
This system is not suitable for measuring traffic on unpaved or dirt roads.
7.6
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The system is unable to directly measure speed. If speed is required, then a two-loop speed
trap is employed or an algorithm involving loop length, average vehicle length, time over the
detector, and number of vehicles counted is used with a single loop detector.
Piezo-Electric Sensor
Advantages:
If properly installed and maintained, the Piezo-electric Sensor continues to be the best in all
weather condition;
If properly installed, can accurately provide vehicle count, classification and speed;
The system remains completely covert after installation and it remains protected from
vandalism; and
If Class–I Piezo-electric Sensors are used, the system can provide axle weight also.
Disadvantages:
This system requires extra skill for installation and the traffic operations are to be stopped
while installation;
For installation, several grooves are to be made in the road surface;
Installation of Piezo-electric Sensor is permanent in nature; and
Not suitable for unpaved roads.
7.7
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Disadvantage:
The RCC unit setup is vulnerable to vandalism.
Disadvantages:
For measuring vehicle speeds, additional camera is required; and
Vehicle classification is not possible at all, unless the Vehicle Registration Database of entire
country is available (the registration numbers obtained from the system can be compared
with the database, and vehicle type can be retrieved).
The Consultants made the comparisons the ATCC technologies described above based on
the following criteria:
The equipment should be able to classify different modes of vehicles;
The equipment should be suitable for use on unpaved or dirt roads;
Installation of the equipment should be mobile so that it can be used at different
count stations as per requirements;
Installation of equipment should be easy so that it can be installed with handy tools
and no great skill is required;
The equipment should be able to work under all weather conditions; and
The equipment should not be vulnerable to vandalism.
7.8
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Table 7.2: ATCC Suppliers with the Product Names for ATCC Equipment
Name of Firm Product Name Technology
Digital Video Detection and Image
ACISA, Brazil Visioway Opencounter
Analysis
Automatic Number Plate
Adaptive Recognition Hungary CARMEN ANPR
Recognition
Digital Video Detection and Image
Austrian Research Centers* SmartEye TDS
Analysis
Digital Video Detection and Image
Autoscope, Minnesota, USA Autoscope Solo Terra
Analysis
DataCollect Traffic Systems, Germany* SDR Radar Counters & Classifiers
Diamond Traffic Products, Oregon Unicorn-4 LP Inductive Loop Detector
Diamond Traffic Products, Oregon Unicorn-F 4PZ Piezo-electric Sensor
Apollo Counter with
Diamond Traffic Products, Oregon Pneumatic Tube System
Road Tubes
EIS Traffic Solutions, Canada RTMS - G4 Radar Counters & Classifiers
TREX Flex HS Counter
JAMAR Technologies, Inc., USA Pneumatic Tube System
Classifier
MetroCount, Australia MC 5710 Piezo-electric Sensor
MetroCount, Australia* MC 5600 Pneumatic Tube System
Sierzega Electronics, Austria SR4 Radar Counters & Classifiers
Sierzega Electronics, Austria SR3 Radar Counters & Classifiers
6
The Consultants proposed that all the TANROADS regional offices should be equipped with the
ATCC for understanding the traffic count activities on the road network in its jurisdiction.
7.9
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Officials concerned were kind enough to discuss the above-mentioned agenda
in the meeting proposed. During the meeting, it was also realized and agreed for the need to
evaluate the functional performance of the proposed ATCCs, particularly in view of the
Tanzanian environment, and also the training of the TANROADS Counterpart Staff should
be properly conducted for the use of these before placing any order for the whole lot of the
equipment, as per the budget. It was, therefore, decided that initially two sets of Pneumatic
Tube System and Radar Counters and Classifiers should be procured at the earliest
possible for the purpose.
7.10
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
While evaluating the functional advantages of the ATCCs, the Radar Counters and
Classifiers “SDR” appeared to be more preferred. It may be noted that the cost of SDR per
set is nearly double of the cost of MC56007. Main reasons for the preference of SDR could
be attributed to its easier installation for traffic count, and simplicity in the analysis of the
data for classifying various vehicles moving on Tanzanian primary road network. Thus,
considering the operational advantage of the ATCCs, and consultations with the Clients, the
Consultants procured 18 sets of Radar Counter and Classifier “SDR” and 2 sets of Tube
type equipment (MC5600) within the budget.
The ATCCs (18 sets) procured were duly handed over to TANROADS. A comparison in the
operational characteristics of ATCCs Pneumatic Tube “MC5600” and Radar “SDR” is
presented in Table 7.3.
7
Cost of one set of MC5600 is nearly US$ 2,100, whereas it is US$ 5,000 per set in case of SDR.
7.11
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
7.12
Generalized Traffic Forecast Model 8
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
(i) Trend Analysis: The generalized forecast model for Tanzania is based on several
historical data on traffic on different traffic sections on the primary road network, registration
of different types of vehicles, consumption of fuel (diesel/petrol), particularly by transport
sector, etc.;
(ii) Econometric Models: This exercise is mainly based on a various causal
interdependent relations, viz. (i) growing population and transport needs, (ii) growth in
different economic activities (primary: agriculture, mining, etc.; secondary: manufacturing,
construction, etc.; and tertiary: transport and communications, trade and business, etc.) and
transport demand; and (iii) growth in the national gross domestic production (GDP) and per
capita income, and contribution of the transport sector or related sector(s). These analyses
required to be carried out as per the available historical data for Tanzania; and
(iii) End User Approach: In fact, effects of transport requirements of new or forthcoming
projects in nth year are not reflected while undertaking either in trend analysis or in the
econometric models. So, there would be requirement to estimate the transport needs for
passenger and freight movement (duly converted into specific vehicles) of any such new
projects coming up or planned in specific year in the catchment’s areas. These projects
usually come up in phases spread over a few years or on intervals; and their demand for
transportation would also be accordingly changing, so due care is required to capture the
8.1
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
reality while estimating the transport needs. For the application in the vehicle-wise
projections, the estimates are referred to in Section 8.3.1 on Step-in Traffic.
Besides the above-mentioned standard traffic forecast modeling, the movement pattern of
the port traffic at Dar es Salaam for the neighboring land-locked countries, and intra-country
freight movement following supply-demand structure of selected bulk cargo in the country
needs to be analyzed and incorporated in view of the generalized traffic forecast model.
(iv) Divertible Traffic: Due to improvement of any roads, there would be a high
probability of traffic moving from alternative routes/roads may get shifted on the improved
roads, if beneficial to the road users mainly on account of time, distance and comfort
advantages. This exercise requires to be done for specific road, hence cannot be a part of
any generalized traffic forecast modeling. However, while undertaking the forecasting
exercise, the probability of the divertible traffic from the existing alternate route/roads must
be incorporated.
(v) Generated Traffic: The concept of generated traffic is governed by the general
demand theory, i.e. demand is a function of price, as transport demand will increase if
transport cost decreases. With this functional relation, any improvement option in the
transport infrastructure, e.g. improved road would reduce the vehicle operating costs
considerably, and in turn, reduction in overall transport cost, and eventually, increase in
traffic demand. This type of traffic is referred to as generated traffic. The extent of increase in
traffic demand on account of generated traffic would depend on the prevailing transport
market of the project area. The extent of generated traffic needs to be incorporated while
formulating the traffic forecast on any road improvement option. Since the entire exercise is
road specific and the extent of road improvement, any generalized forecast modeling will not
work.
In line with the approach and methodology mentioned above, the Consultants have worked
out the vehicle-wise projection factors, as per the available data, which could be used
appropriately on the AADT for the base-year traffic, considering the commencement of
project benefits, for determining future traffic. While applying these factors, there are other
important issues need to be considered, as discussed in the following sections. For
additional traffic, which might take place in future in specific year on account of new projects
or port traffic for specific international transit routes or intra-country traffic movement for
specific bulk cargo, etc. would be considered exogenously, which is illustrated as “step-in
traffic” in Section 8.3.1.
There is a simple illustration of using growth factors for making any projection for future
traffic for different vehicles as given as follows:
Tn = Tp[1+(r/100)]^n
[Where: Tn= Projected Traffic in the year n for any specific vehicle; Tp= Base Year Traffic (e.g. AADT
th
of the year of analysis); r=vehicle-wise annual growth rate; n= number of years for the projection (n
th
year; e.g. 5 year, n=5)]
8.3
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
forecasts”1. With the above empirical evidence, the growth in gross domestic products for
traffic projection exercise has been considered in the present analysis.
For the purpose, the GDP of Tanzania with its components including transport sector’s
contribution since 1998 has been analyzed. The analysis shows that the GDP has grown by
6.6% pa on an average since 1998, and the transport sub-sector by 5.8% pa and
communications sub-sector by 13.5% pa; and combined growth rate for transport and
communications sub-sector at 7.6% pa. In recent years, these growth rates were recorded at
slightly higher levels. Estimation of the growth rates are based on the semi log method using
GDP data at Constant Price (2001). Since the above analysis is based on a historical data of
more than 10 years, it may be easily presumed that the trend observed in past would, more
or less, also continue in future, particularly in view of several ongoing and planned socio-
economic development projects.
Table 8.1: Sector-wise Growth Tanzania
Analysis of the sectoral changes of the Tanzanian economy reveals that there have been
gradual changes in the contributions of different sectors to the national GDP. Contribution of
the primary sector activities has been reducing for last 10 years, e.g. it reduced to 27% in
2008 from about 33% in 1998; during the same period, the secondary sector and the tertiary
sector observed growing contribution to the GDP. The contribution of transport and
communications reduced in the category of tertiary sector. Tertiary sector is an important
sector, which now accounts for more than 50% in the country’s GDP. This analysis indirectly
or directly shows the growing demand for transport services in Tanzania, and the trend
would continue in future as well.
For the purpose of traffic forecast modeling, the changes in economic performance, viz.
growth in GDP, and growth in transport and communication sub-sector contributions have
been analyzed, and the results in terms of elasticity value (e) has been worked out. The
value of “e” for the transport and communication sub-sector w.r.t. GDP is estimated at 1.11
on an average using last 10 year figures, whereas the value of “e” goes higher as 1.32 using
recent five year figures. The above values of “e” are important components for any traffic
forecast exercise in Tanzania. The exercise has been further elaborated in Section 8.5.1.
1
Africa Transport Technical Note, Sub-Saharan Africa Transport Policy Program, UNECA and the
World Bank (November 2000).
8.4
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
With this kind of heterogeneity in data on regional GDP, it is difficult to set a trend for
forecast modeling. So, it would be rather more advisable to rely on the national GDP,
presenting on an average figures, which would be more likely at regional levels as well.
8.4.5 Population
Growth in population directly influences the demand for transport services in general, but
also guided by the income level of the transport users for selecting mode of transport, type of
vehicles, frequency, distance of travel, etc. So, the analysis of population growth coupled
with the national economic performance is one of the key parameters for forecast modeling.
For the purpose, trend in population growth at national and regional levels has been
analyzed. The population of Tanzania (mainland) has been growing by more than 2.9% pa
since last decade, and regional analysis of population growth shows growth rate of 3.0% pa
for most of the regions, excepting Arusha Region.
Table 8.4: Annual Growth in Regional Population (Tanzania Mainland)
Population Annual Growth Population Annual Growth
Region in 2008-09 Rate (%) Region in 2008-09 Rate (%)
(‘000) 1999-2006 (‘000) 1999-2006
Dodoma 2,166 3.04 Mbeya 2,758 3.04
Arusha 2,290 2.72 Singida 1,401 3.04
Kilimanjaro 2,594 3.04 Tabora 1,818 3.04
Tanga 2,238 3.04 Rukwa 1,434 3.04
Morogoro 2,245 3.04 Kigoma 1,550 3.04
Pwani (Coast) 1,089 3.04 Shiyanga 3,253 3.04
Dar es Salaam 2,936 3.04 Kagera 2,455 3.04
Lindi 1,094 3.04 Mwanza 3,356 3.04
Mtwara 1,426 3.04 Mara 1,782 3.04
Ruvuma 1,490 3.04 Manyara 1,040* --
Iringa 2,179 3.04 Tanzania M’land 41,554 2.95
Source: Regional Social Economic Profiles (2003-2005); and Economic Watch & Investment Reports (2008).
8.5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
In view of the uniformity in population growth rates at regional level and compared closely
with the national average, the population growth rates observed at national level, can be
considered for the traffic forecast modeling for present and coming years.
In order to appreciate the functional relation between transport sector growth and the
population, and the per capita income, an exercise has been carried out to determine the
transport elasticity w.r.t. the growth in population and the per capita income for the country.
The values of elasticity (e), thus, obtained on an average are: (i) for population as 2.9; and
(ii) for per capita income as 2.1. For general understanding, the values of “e” can be
considered as a multiplier to arrive at the traffic growth rate on the basis of growth in per
capita income.
8.6
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Table 8.5 presents the vehicle population in Tanzania for three years. The incremental
change in motorized vehicles has been noticed at about 29% on an average during 2005-07,
and the quantum jump can be observed in cases of motorcycles, tricycles, light passenger
vehicles, trailers including agricultural trailers. The changes in vehicle composition have
been observed that may be due to several reasons, such as, introduction of economic mode
of transport for short distance and small loads, might be substituting non-motorized traffic
with economical and time saving proposition.
It may be important to note that while undertaking the traffic projection exercise, the
phenomenon of changes in vehicle composition should also be considered, particularly for
long-term planning, because there would be a rational shift in modal choice in transport
system for passenger and freight movement. Visualizing the above incidence with fair level
of confidence is rather a difficult task requiring incorporation of several influencing factors
including type of commodities, extent of load, magnitude and frequency of transport service
requirements, availability of quality roads, etc. So while establishing forecast model with shift
in vehicular composition should be more desirable on trunk and important roads, and
international transit routes, not necessarily on regional and secondary roads, particularly in
short to medium term forecasts.
2
“Previous method of registering vehicles did not remove from the system vehicles that are no longer
road worth and hence not (plying on) the road. TRA (Tanzania Revenue Authority) has now come
up with a new system that requires owners of vehicles to register their vehicles on annual basis.
8.7
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
This system takes on board only vehicles that are roadworthy”. Table 8.5 of the present report is
based on new system.
8.8
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
8.9
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
8.6 Sum Up
Traffic forecast exercise is mainly based on the trend observed in the past, and also
changing socio-economic scenarios at macro level, regional level and/or in the project
influence areas. The growth rates or projection factors accordingly need to be modified from
time to time in view of the changes in the parameters influencing the traffic level. So, it is
suggested that, in long-term, the users should review the changes observed in major growth
parameters, viz. GDP, population, per capita income, vehicle population, fuel consumption,
etc. The performance in these stated parameters would illustrate the picture on the range of
growth in the transport sector providing lower and higher bound in traffic projection figures.
For simple traffic forecast model, the traffic growth rates could be determined on the
expected or proposed GDP of the country incorporating assumed value of “e”. In view of
reliability in the forecasting exercise, it may also be suggested that users should also follow
scenario approach, e.g. optimistic growth rates or conservative growth rates, supported with
sensitivity analysis by changes in parameters.
8.10
Data Processing
- Approach & System Design 9
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Client 1
Client 2
Client n
Intranet
Intranet Intranet
Presentation Layer
(ASP.NET)
Business Layer
(ASP.NET / C#)
Logical
Layer Data Access Layer
ADO.NET
9.2
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.3
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Internet Browser
Internet Browser Menu Bar Internet Browser Shortcut Icons
Address Bar
TIDB Logout
Link
TIDB Login
Name
Title Bar
TIDB Menu
Bar
Internet Browser
Status Bar
The Title Bar of the TIDB system will display the Login Name and also provide a link for log
out, and the Menu Bar, which is below the TIDB Title Bar, contains the menus of the
developed system, as shown in Figure 9.3.
9.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Further details of each component of the TIDB System have been detailed in Volume III of
this report.
9.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Figure 9.4: Flow Chart Showing Data Migration & Data Processing
Start
Reporting
Migration of Migration
Traffic Census
Data to MS-
Access/
Reporting
Select Excel Sheet Excel Sheet
Process Excel
No Yes
Error in Excel
Error Rectify Error
Sheet Data
Repor in Excel
No
Yes
Data
Another End
Processing
Symbols:
Proces Documen
Legend: Data
TAF : Traffic Adjustment Factor Manual Operation
ADT : Average Daily Traffic Terminator
AADT : Annual Average Daily Traffic
*Parameter : CP Name, Month, Direction, Decision
9.6
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
As per the requirements of the Study, traffic count survey was conducted at 45 locations
countrywide continuously for the duration of one year on the Trunk and Regional Road
Network under jurisdiction of TANROADS, Tanzania.
After having physically checked the filled in survey formats obtained through the traffic
surveys, the entire information collected in the survey format was stored electronically on
computer, through a pre-designed format in the Excel Spread Sheet. Besides the vehicle
counts in terms of directions, by vehicle classifications (13 in number), hourly blocks (e.g.
06:00–07:00 hr, 06:00–07:00 hr, etc.), etc. the data entry activities also cover the general
introductory information, weather conditions, special features, and any remarks in hourly
blocks. These fields had been numerically coded for the purpose of assigning different
numeric codes for different happenings and set of information, so as to make use of this
information as causal variables or parameters affecting the extent of traffic behavior at
different count points, duration, day, months, etc. The data entry format has been designed
to make the transfer of data between MS Excel and MS Access data interoperable for
populating the database for the TIDB. In case of any error in the Excel Sheet data, like,
missing CP number, non numeric data in place of numeric data, etc, there is a provision to
generate an exception report, hence enabling the data to be rectified and reloaded into the
database.
There are three aspects of computerized processing for traffic count data:
(i) First Aspect: To determine the Hourly, Daily and Monthly (Seasonal) Traffic
Adjustment Factors;
(ii) Second Aspect: To estimate the Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) for 45 CPs
for the current year; and
(iii) Third Aspect: To automate the process for calculation of Annual Average Daily
Traffic by multiplying the hourly, daily and monthly adjustment factors to any short
duration traffic count to be carried out in future for any specific use.
After uploading the traffic data into TIDB System, the TAFs, ADT and AADT of 45 CPs have
been derived at. The algorithm to arrive at TAFs, ADT and AADT has been detailed in
Section 9.11.
9.7
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.8
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.9
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.10
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
t =13
Average HTV= ∑ AverageVCH V
t =1
Where, Average HTV is the average Hour Traffic Volume and VCHV is the Average
Vehicle/Traffic Class Hourly Volume.
AverageHTV i * 100 100 * AverageHTVi
Hourly Percentage (P i ) = = i = 24
∑ AverageHTV
AverageDTV
i =1
∑ DTV
i =1
i
Average Week Day Traffic Volume (AWDTV)= ,
7
AverageWeekDayTrafficVolume
Day Factor (DF i )=
DayTrafficVolume
9.11
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
i =7
∑ DTV
i =1
= 7
DTVi
Once the traffic data for 24 hours for 7 consecutive days have been estimated; the average
of 7 days in a specific month will provide the user Average Daily Traffic (ADT); and
Traffic Adjustment Factor for the day=Average Daily Traffic (ADT) / Traffic Volume of a
specific day in the week.
Procedure for calculation of traffic adjustment factors for the day in a specific month is
detailed by an example as given in Table 9.6.
Table 9.6: Calculation of Traffic Adjustment Factors for Daily Variation
in a Specific Month (e.g. January)
Day Traffic Volume Average Daily Traffic Daily TAFs
Monday 80 87.4 /80 = 1.09
Tuesday 100 87.4 /100 = 0.87
Wednesday 110 87.4 /110 = 0.79
ADT = 612/7
Thursday 90 87.4 /90= 0.97
= 87.4
Friday 95 87.4 /95 = 0.92
Saturday 87 87.4 /88 = 1.00
Sunday 50 87.4 /50 = 1.74
Total 612 - -
Similarly, daily TAFs for all the 12 months of the year will be obtained. Details showing the
TAFs covering all the 7 days in a month extending all the 12 months are shown in Table 9.7.
Table 9.7: Details of Traffic Adjustment Factors for Daily Variation in Different Months
Month
Monday Tuesday Wednesday -------- Sunday
Day
January A1 A2 A3 -------- A7
February B1 B2 B3 -------- B7
March C1 C2 C3 -------- C7
-
-
-
December - - - - -
∑ ADT
i =1
Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT)=
12
Monthly Traffic Adjustment Factor = AADT / ADT
The procedure for calculation of Monthly Traffic Adjustment Factors in the year is simplified
by an example as shown in Table 9.8:
9.12
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
After derivation of monthly adjustment factors as explained above, daily TAFs as given in
Table 9.7 can be adjusted to AADT level by multiplying the monthly TAFs to the days of
specific months; e.g., TAF of January will be will be multiplied to the daily TAFs of the days
in that month. So Table 9.9 will be generated in the following format.
Table 9.9: Details of Daily and Monthly Traffic Adjustment Factors on a Specific CP
Month
Monday Tuesday Wednesday -------- Sunday
Day
January A1*0.86 A2*0.86 A3*0.86 -------- A7*0.86
February B1*0.79 B2*0.79 B3*0.79 -------- B7*0.79
March C1*0.95 C2*0.95 C3*0.95 -------- C7*0.95
-
-
-
December - - - - -
9.13
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
II. For Calculation of AADT, if Traffic Count Data available >24 hours:
For example: Traffic count carried out in July, from 06:00 hr to 06:00 hr (i.e. round the clock) for 3
days (say, Tuesday to Thursday):
(i) Daily TAF will be average of TAFs of Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday; and
(ii) Monthly TAF will be applicable as of July.
It may be mentioned that if the traffic count has been conducted for 24 hours, there is no
need for applying hourly traffic adjustment factors for deriving an ADT, as 24-hour traffic
count has already incorporated the hourly variations in the traffic count. Similarly, if traffic
count has been taken for seven consecutive days, the data, thus, obtained for seven days
traffic volume need to be averaged for deriving the ADT for the traffic section, so in such
case there is no need to apply traffic adjustment factor for daily variations in the week.
The traffic surveys were carried out at all the 45 CPs during Jan 2008–Dec 2008, and it was observed
that on most of the CPs traffic volume ranged between 200 and 2,000 vpd; and share of few types of
vehicles found to be insignificant, so deriving separate TAFs for all the vehicles may not give proper
results as a little variation in traffic could influence the results by the application of TAFs to a great
extent.
Whereas, TAFs based on total traffic (i.e. only one category) may not give the realistic results, as
share of some of the vehicles is quite high (e.g. share of cycles in the total traffic at some of the CPs)
as compared to other vehicles; and applying the same TAF could distort the estimated figure,
because of different traffic adjustment factors applicable for different vehicles.
Therefore, the vehicles have been grouped into four categories: (i) Light Passenger Vehicles
(Car/Jeep/Van/2-Wheelers etc.); (ii) Heavy Passenger Vehicles (Buses of all types); (iii) Motorized
Goods Vehicles (All Trucks); and (iv) Non-Motorized Traffic.
Therefore, Traffic Adjustment Factors have been worked out for the above four categories.
9.14
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.15
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.16
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
tegory
9.17
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
9.13 Sum Up
The system architecture, development environment and design details of the TIDB System
have been dealt with in this chapter; and also the algorithm used to arrive at TAFs, ADT and
AADT have been explained. To successfully run the TIDB System and generate various
reports out of it, further instructions and guidance are required. The “User Manual” (Volume
III) gives guidance to operate the TIDB System, which has been developed for estimating
the Average Daily Traffic (ADT) and Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) for specific traffic
section(s).
9.18
1.
Baseline Traffic Census
in Tanzania: Results 10
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Weekdays Weekends
Hour of Passenger Vehicles Non- Passenger Vehicles Non-
Goods Goods
the Day Motorized Motorized
Light Heavy Vehicle Light Heavy Vehicles
Traffic Traffic
19-20 0.040 0.025 0.118 0.034 0.082 0.032 0.051 0.040
20-21 0.041 0.033 0.082 0.004 0.076 0.040 0.035 0.008
21-22 0.028 - 0.029 - - - - 0.001
22-23 0.003 - 0.019 0.001 0.016 - - 0.002
23-24 0.003 - 0.006 - 0.006 - - -
24-01 0.004 - - - 0.015 - - -
01-02 - - - - - - - -
02-03 - 0.004 - - - - - -
03-04 - - - - - - - -
04-05 - - - 0.003 0.006 - - 0.003
05-06 0.017 0.008 0.013 0.008 0.006 - 0.011 0.003
10.5
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Table 10.8: AADT on the Traffic Sections of the Trunk & Regional Roads of Tanzania
Road Section-
Section-1 Section-2 Section-3 Section-4 Section-5 Section-7
No. 6
CP No. CP-24 CP-27 CP-28 CP-31 C9-32 CP-36 CP-37
Makamba Ubenazo
T-1 Location Mlowo Mahenge Chimala Doma Vigwaza
ko mozi
AADT 2,135 811 2,122 1,561 994 2,235 3,239
CP No. CP-22 CP-25 CP-33 CP-38 CP-44 - -
T-2 Location Hedaru Longido Manga Kikatiti Homo Jn. - -
AADT 1,372 650 1,146 3,468 3,129 - -
CP No. CP-7 CP-14 CP-23 CP-39 CP-42 - -
Nyakahur East of
T-3 Location
a Igunga
Dumila Ikungi Ushirombo - -
AADT 525 685 1,208 572 1,243 - -
CP No. CP-9 CP-19 CP-30 - - - -
T-5 Location Bicha Nduli Minjingu - - - -
AADT 96 421 296 - - - -
CP No. CP-1 CP-2 CP-15 CP-18 - - -
T-6 Location Ckikundi Litola Gumbiro Mingoyo - - -
AADT 1,420 335 242 918 - - -
CP No. CP-4 CP-26 - - - - -
Nanguruk
T-7 Location Kibiti - - - - -
uru
AADT 511 983 - - - - -
CP No. CP-17 CP-21 CP-41 CP-43 - - -
North of
T-8 Location Mabuki Chunya Sikonge - - -
Nzega
AADT 1,345 605 486 553 - - -
CP No. CP-3 CP-6 CP-8 - - - -
South of
T-9 Location Laela Chala - - - -
Kasulu
AADT 1,384 727 328 - - - -
10.10 Sum Up
The need and applications of the “Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs)” have been discussed
in the present report at several places, and the results of the one-year traffic surveys carried
out at 45 count points are given in different tables in Volume II of the present report. The
compilation and tabulation of the results have been done in such a manner so that the users
could apply them conveniently and effectively.
10.6
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
10.7
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
10.8
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
Table 10.7: Annual Average Daily Traffic (AADT) at Various Count Points
Passenger Vehicles Goods Vehicles Non-Motorized Traffic AADT
Motoriz
CP ADV/ Non- (Mot+
Location 2- Bus Bus Light Medium Heavy Art. ed
No. Car UV Total Others Total Cycle Hand Others Mot Non-
Wh (<=25) (>25) Truck Truck Truck Truck AADT AADT
Cart Mot)
1 Chikundi 16 78 82 56 55 287 9 34 17 7 4 71 358 1,060 2 - 1,062 1,420
2 Litola 6 50 37 28 11 132 13 17 7 3 - 40 172 162 - - 162 334
3 South of Kasulu 90 142 68 48 22 370 14 54 11 11 - 90 460 891 33 - 924 1,384
4 Nangurukuru 15 56 8 35 36 150 10 59 22 13 - 104 254 257 2 - 259 513
5 Muhutwe 117 111 65 118 16 427 20 42 14 20 - 96 523 301 - - 301 824
6 Laela 3 28 14 - 7 52 5 25 10 14 - 54 106 614 7 - 621 727
7 Nyakahura 36 47 22 18 6 129 4 60 16 93 - 173 302 223 - - 223 525
8 Chala 2 28 10 - 6 46 5 19 6 3 - 33 79 245 2 - 247 326
9 Bicha 7 24 4 - 13 48 2 15 8 1 - 26 74 23 - - 23 97
10 Katoma 79 104 34 107 17 341 31 48 16 31 - 126 467 121 - - 121 588
11 Likuyufusi 14 60 32 11 34 151 25 16 9 5 - 55 206 139 1 - 140 346
12 Urambo 15 40 78 1 10 144 3 12 4 6 1 26 170 1,081 13 - 1,094 1,264
13 Kiberege 9 57 42 9 33 150 8 43 8 8 8 75 225 779 1 - 780 1,005
14 East of Igunga 29 71 8 7 39 154 7 73 41 208 1 330 484 196 4 - 200 684
15 Gumbiro 8 42 11 9 32 102 11 9 13 19 - 52 154 88 - - 88 242
16 Kasamwa 22 85 16 20 35 178 15 42 28 26 2 113 291 535 14 - 549 840
17 North of Nzega 38 123 15 27 105 308 8 88 39 206 - 341 649 694 2 - 696 1,345
18 Mingoyo 16 98 39 17 46 216 11 36 21 7 1 76 292 623 2 - 625 917
19 Nduli 17 56 26 10 9 118 12 22 5 5 2 46 164 255 1 - 256 420
20 Sulubu(Komasu) 61 91 15 85 45 297 13 57 25 60 1 156 453 56 1 - 57 510
21 Mabuki 43 115 8 24 84 274 6 55 29 87 2 179 453 150 3 - 153 606
22 Hedaru 115 207 50 86 167 625 34 100 31 129 1 295 920 436 15 - 451 1,371
23 Dumila 77 168 12 33 138 428 18 102 44 208 2 374 802 402 3 - 405 1,207
24 Mlowo 132 211 56 255 130 784 54 111 32 193 1 391 1,175 934 26 - 960 2,135
25 Longido 143 191 20 52 37 443 21 82 15 53 1 172 615 27 6 - 33 648
26 Kibiti 17 98 55 26 81 277 20 66 23 16 1 126 403 576 3 - 579 982
27 Mahenge 75 154 9 31 97 366 26 94 62 257 - 439 805 6 - - 6 811
28 Chimala 103 215 214 163 105 800 56 92 41 216 15 420 1,220 888 12 - 900 2,120
29 Balili 101 136 99 9 122 467 10 64 31 65 2 172 639 734 7 - 741 1,380
30 Minjingu 11 106 4 4 40 165 9 48 31 29 1 118 283 14 - - 14 297
31 Makambako 161 173 28 39 124 525 60 128 67 218 1 474 999 554 7 - 561 1,560
32 Doma 91 205 7 27 131 461 18 101 56 242 1 418 879 115 - - 115 994
10.9
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Final Report
Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Volume I: Main Report
Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
10.10
Summary & Major Issues
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
11.1
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
sections and count points on the Trunk and Regional Roads in the country during 1972-85.
Among others, the review was mainly concentrated to the MoCW (1988) traffic adjustment
factors derived on 40 traffic sections in the country through a one-year traffic counting
activities on 40 count points (CPs).
The ‘Traffic Survey Strategy’ prepared by the Ministry of Works (MoW) in 1992 was also
reviewed. The Strategy had to develop a set of updated TAFs for the entire network
locations, which MoW used for data collection and adjustment to make it representative until
1993. For obvious reasons, the TAFs developed in 1992, which were based on 1987 traffic
level information, were no longer valid for current requirements.
11.2
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
out for short duration in future due to resource constraints or any reasons, would required to
be modified using an appropriate TAF to arrive at the ADT and AADT.
Based on the availability of financial and other resources, duration of the survey can be
adopted for minimum 12 hours in day, but preferably 24 hours (one day) to 72 hours (three
days), as short duration. The traffic data obtained for the short duration count can be
expanded to the ADT and the AADT by applying suitable TAFs. To meet the above said
requirement, algorithms have been developed for arriving at various traffic adjustment
factors (TAFs) for carrying out the following traffic analysis, which included in the database
design: (i) estimation of the ADT; (ii) calculation of hourly, daily and monthly TAFs; (iii)
determination of the AADT.
The TAFs developed in the Study will be used for converting the short duration traffic data
into the ADT and the AADT in future for roads falling in the catchments areas of the selected
traffic sections of the roads under TANROADS.
11.3
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
sensing the passing vehicles, etc. The extent of traffic count duration and frequency of the
traffic surveys should also be planned in view of data accuracy and other requirements.
While organizing equipment based traffic count activities, it is important to refer to the User
Manual of ATCCs carefully.
While using the traffic growth rates in future, it is desirable that the user should consider
changes in GDP and income level including the sectoral changes i.e. agricultural, mining
and manufacturing sub-sectors, if any, and also on new projects and their phase-wise
requirements for transport.
11.4
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
important layer simply because it’s the one that everyone observes and uses. With a well
structured logical and data layer, if the presentation layer is designed properly, this gives the
users a better view and appreciations of the system. The main advantages of using tiered
approach are the reusability of the programming code and ease to maintain and
enhance/modify the system in the future.
The functionality and working of the TIDB System was demonstrated to various TANROADS
officials during last one year, including, demonstration to the officers concerned, in
November 2008 at New Delhi, India, and to the RMMS Officials, specifically to demonstrate
the information stored in TIDB System, like, Start Node Number, End Node Number, etc.
which may be utilized by, and can be transferred to existing software of RMMS, through
interface files.
A “User Manual: Traffic Surveys and TIDB System”, has been prepared for carrying out the
traffic survey and providing guidance to operate the TIDB System. TANROADS Staff has
been trained during the Training, so that the system could be effectively used in years to
come. The above arrangement would augment the in-house capacity and workability, even
after completion of the Consultancy Services. The User Manual is comprehensive and user-
friendly document, which could be used by any new users of the TIDB System as well.
11.5
1.
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts Final Report
in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Volume I: Main Report
Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
The Program, inter alia, also covered on-hand practice of the TIDB System and on-road
functional demonstration of the procured ATCCs, viz. (i) Pneumatic Tube Type (MC5600);
and Radar Type Equipment (SDR). The Training Program was made very interactive with
the “Question-Answer Sessions” after every topic of the Training. During the Program, all the
participants were given “User Manual” on Traffic Census Methodology, Application of the
Traffic Adjustment Factors, and Traffic Information (TIDB) System, and relevant hand-outs
for future reference and use.
“A Report on the Training for TANROADS Staff” has been prepared and submitted. Based
on feedback given by the participants, an evaluation exercise has been carried out, which
reveals that the training program organized by the Consultants highly appreciated by almost
all the participants on different criteria as mentioned in the Feedback Evaluation Form.
11.6
1.
Maps
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/1
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/2
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/3
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/4
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/5
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/6
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/7
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/8
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/9
Final Report
Consultancy Services to Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Volume I: Main Report
Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS September 2009
TANROADS Trunk and Regional Roads Maps
Catchment Area of the Specific Traffic Section in the Regions
Map 4.1/10
Annexures
Annexure 1.1
A-1
Annexure 1.1
A-2
Annexure 1.1
A-3
Annexure 1.2
1.0 Introduction
Following the requirements of the ToR, the Consultants organized a “Two-day Training for
TANROADS Staff” on the Traffic Census Methodology, and the Application of the Traffic
Adjustment Factors (TAFs) on 20-21 August in Dar es Salaam. Main objective of the training
was to develop the departmental capability in carrying out the traffic census on the Trunk
and Regional Roads of the country, and also to equip with the modern tools and techniques
of undertaking the traffic surveys including deployment of the automatic traffic counters and
classifiers (ATCCs), and analyzing the data by using the Traffic Information Database (TIDB)
System.
In order to achieve the above objectives, the training program was divided into several
functional areas focusing on: (i) traffic census methodology (enumerator based and
equipment, i.e. ATCCs based); (ii) concept and application of the traffic adjustment factors
(TAFs); (iii) application of the TIDB System for traffic survey data analysis and estimation of
the ADT and the AADT; (iv) practical training for the use of ATCCs; and (v) method and
application of traffic forecast model.
The Training for TANROADS Staff was for two days covering eight sessions, which also
included a comprehensive question-answer sessions and on-hand training on the TIDB
System and installation, and use of the ATCCs.
The Training was conducted by Mr. Satyakam, Team Leader/Senior Transport Economist,
Mr. Rajeev Makhija, Senior Traffic Engineer, Mr. Arun Gakhar, System Analyst, and Mr.
Aidan Ndaona, Deputy Traffic Engineer. A brief notes on the participants, training contents
and training materials, practical training, participants feedback and evaluation, and results
are given in following paragraphs.
2.0 Participants
The Training for TANROADS Staff was participated by the Senior Officials of TANROADS
Headquarters, Road Maintenance Management System (RMMS) of TANROADS, and
Regional Offices, TANROADS. List of the Participants with their names and positions are
presented in Annexure 1.2-1.
A-4
Annexure 1.2
The Training Program Schedule and Coverage are presented in Annexure 1.2-2
During the Program, all the participants were given “User Manual” on Traffic Census
Methodology, Application of the Traffic Adjustment Factors, and Traffic Information
Database (TIDB) System, and relevant hand-outs for future reference and use. Arrangement
of loading the TIDB System on personal computers of the participants was also made.
Photos……
A-5
Annexure 1.2
A-6
Annexure 1.2-1
A-7
Annexure 1.2-2
A-8
Annexure 1.2-3
Project: Consultancy Services for Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland and
Establishing a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS
Name : ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Designation : ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Title of Training Program : Training for TANROADS Staff on Traffic Census Methodology &
Application of the Traffic Adjustment Factors (TAFs)
Training Organization : Intercontinental Consultants and Technocrats Pvt Ltd. (INDIA) &
DATACONSULT LIMITED (Tanzania)
Dates : 20–21 August, 2009.
Rating
Excellent Very Good Average Poor
Parameter Good
Course Structure
Course Contents
Training Material
Training Tools
Effectiveness of Trainers
A-9
Annexure 1.2-4
Numeric Grade 1-Poor 2-Average 3-Good 4-Very Good 5-Excellent
A-10
Annexure 1.2-5
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
-
Course Course Training Training Tools Effectiveness Practical Case studies Overall
Structure Contents Material of trainers Usage in illustrations Benefits
Future etc. Drawn
A-11
Annexure 1.2-6
1. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Course Structure" 2. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Course Contents"
3. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Training Material" 4. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Training Tools"
5. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Effectiveness of trainers" 6. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Practical Usage in Future"
7. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Case studies illustration etc." 8. Graphical Representation of Responses on "Overall Benefits Drawn"
A-12
Annexure 1.2-7
Application of Training
Response
Received
Immediate 17
Future 8
Total 25
Total 25
A-13
Annexure 1.3
A-14
Annexure 1.3
A-15
Annexure 2.1
I. GENERAL (DATE……/……../2007)
Traffic Section
Nearby Village………………………………………
Check Point Reference Land Mark………………………..…………………
GPS Reference (if available)………………………
A-16
Annexure 2.1
Note: Kindly attach separate sheets for writing the descriptive responses.
A-17
Annexure 2.2
Consultancy Services for Carrying out Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland and
Establishing a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADS
A-18
Date / Day Period (hr) Venue Activity Responsibility / Expert
Procurement & Claims Mr. JS Yadav / Mr. Kaistha
(Contd.) / Discretion of
1430:1700 CR, ICT Participants (DoP) &
Visit to National Highways Mr. Rajeev Makhija & Col.
Authority of India (NHAI) SK Kapur
A-19
Annexure 3.1
A-20
Annexure 3.1
Trunk Roads Regional Roads
Location of Total Legth
CP No. Region Length Length
Count Point Section Status Section Status (km)
(km) (km)
A-21
Annexure 3.1
Trunk Roads Regional Roads
Location of Total Legth
CP No. Region Length Length
Count Point Section Status Section Status (km)
(km) (km)
A-22
Annexure 3.1
Trunk Roads Regional Roads
Location of Total Legth
CP No. Region Length Length
Count Point Section Status Section Status (km)
(km) (km)
A-23
Annexure 3.1
Trunk Roads Regional Roads
Location of Total Legth
CP No. Region Length Length
Count Point Section Status Section Status (km)
(km) (km)
A-24
Annexure 3.2
A-25
Annexure 4.1/1
Plan for Traffic Counting on the Primary Road Network in Tanzania (1988-1996)
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
A-26
Annexure 4.1/2
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
A-27
Annexure 4.1/3
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Mutukula-Bunazi W6 N. of Bunazi S85-10 x x x
Bunazi-Kyaka W25 S. of Bunazi S85-10 x x x
A3-1 Mutukula-Bukoba
Kyaka-Katoma W3 W. of Katoma S85-10 x x x
Katoma-Bukoba Jct. S85-10 x x x New
Bukoba Jct-Kanazi W1 N. of Kanazi S85-5 x x x x x
Kanazi-Muhutwe W2 S. of Kanazi S85-5 x x x
A3-2 Bukoba-Biharamulo
Muhutwe-Muleba W4 N. of Mulemba S85-5 x x x x x x x x x
Muleba-Biharamulo W5 S. of Rubungo S85-5 x x x
Biharamulo-Lusahunga W12 S.of Biharamulo S85-7 x x x
A3-3 Biharamulo Jct-Nyantwiga Lusahunga-Nyakanazi W26 S. of Lusahunga S85-7 x x x
Nyakanazi-Nyantiwiga W16 S. of Nyakanazi S85-7 x x x
Nyantiwiga-Kibondo K8 N.of Kibondo S85-7 x x x
A3-4 Nyantwiga-Kigoma Jct. Kibondo-Kasulu K7 N. of Kasulu S85-3 x x x
Kasulu-Kigoma Jct. S85-3 x x x New
A3-5 Kigoma Jct.-Uvinza Kigoma Jct.-Uvinza K5 N. of Uvinza S85-3 x x x
Uvinza-Msobwe K6 S. of Uvinza S85-3 x x x
A3-6 Uvinza-Mpanda Msobwe-Kabungo RK7 S85-3 x x x
Kabungo-Mpanda S85-3 x x x New
Mpanda-Kisi RK6 S. of Mpanda S85-8 x x x
A3-7 Mpanda-Sumbawanga Kisi-Chala RK5 N. of Chala S85-8 x x x New
Chala-Sumbawanga RK1 N. of Sumbawanga S85-8 x x x
Sumbawanga-Laela RK2 S. of Sumbawanga S85-6 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Rukwa
A3-8 Sumbawanga-Tunduma
Laela-Tunduma MB9 N. of Tunduma S85-6 x x x
A-28
Annexure 4.1/4
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Segera-Korogwe TA13 N. of Segera S85-22 x x x
A4-1 Segera-Mkomazi Korogwe-Mombo TA15 S. of Mombo S85-22 x x x
Mombo-Mkomazi TA17 N. of Mombo S85-22 x x x
Mkomazi-Same S. of Same S85-22 x x x New
A4-2 Mkomazi-Taveta Jct. Same-Mwanza K19 N. of Same S85-22 x x x
Mwanza-Taveta Jct. KL5 S. of Himo S85-22 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Kilimanjaro
Taveta Jct.-Kirua Jct. S85-38 x x x New
A4-3 Taveta Jct.-Moshi
Kirua Jct.-Moshi KL1 E. of Moshi S85-38 x x x
Moshi-Kwa Sadala KL2 E. of Machame Jct. S85-38 x x x
Kwa Sadala-Airport Rd. S85-38 x x x
A4-4 Moshi-Arusha
Airport Rd.-Usa River A4 E. of Usa River S85-38 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Arusha
Usa River-Arusha S85-38 x x x
A-29
Annexure 4.1/5
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Morogoro-Dakawa MR2 At Kihonda S85-23 x x x
Dakawa-Mvomero S85-23 x x x New
Mvomero-Magole MR20 E. of Magole S85-23 x x x
A5-1 Morogoro-Dodoma Magole-Gairo MR19 W. of Magole S85-23 x x x
Gairo-Kongwa Jct. D5 E. of Kongwa Jct. S85-23 x x x
Kongwa Jct.-Mgunga S85-23 x x x New
Mgunga-Dodoma D2 E. of Dodoma S85-23 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Dodoma
Dodoma-Bahi D3 At Kizota S85-39 x x x
Bahi-Manyoni SI8 E. of Manyoni S85-39 x x x
A5-2 Dodoma-Singida Manyoni-Itiqi SI7 W. of Manyoni S85-39 x x x
Itiqi-Issuna Jct. SI5 N. of Itiqi S85-39 x x x
Issuna Jct.-Singida SI1 S. of Singida S85-39 x x x
Singida-Kiamboi Jct. SI2 N. of Singida S85-14 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Singida
Kiamboi Jct.-Sekenke SI4 At Shelui S85-14 x x x
A5-3 Singida-Nzega
Sekenke-Ziba T7 E. of Ziba S85-14 x x x
Ziba-Nzega T10 E. of Nzega S85-17 x x x
Nzega-Itobo T14 W. of Nzega S85-17 x x x
Itobo-Ugisha T9 W. of Itobo S85-17 x x x
A5-4 Nzega-Nyankanazi Ugisha-Kahama S85-17 x x x New
Kahama-Bukome S13 W. of Kahama S85-17 x x x
Bukome-Nyankanazi W15 E. of Nyankanazi S85-17 x x x
A-30
Annexure 4.1/6
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Dar es Salaam-Mlandizi C12 At Ruvu S85-37 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Pwani
A6-1 Dar es Salaam-Chalinze
Mlandizi-Chalinze C17 At Ruvu S85-37 x x x New
Chalinze-Ubenazomozi C9 W. of Ubenazomozi S85-36 x x x
A6-2 Chalinze-Morogoro
Ubenazomozi-Morogoro MR3 E. of Morogoro S85-36 x x x
Morogoro-Kimamba Jct. MR1 W. of Morogoro S85-32 x x x
A6-3 Morogoro-Mikumi
Kimamba Jct.-Mikumi MR7 W. of Mkata Jct. S85-32 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Morogoro
Mikumi-Ruaha River MR8 At Ruaha Bridge S85-27 x x x
A6-4 Mikumi-Iringa
Ruaha River-Iringa IR3 E. of Iringa S85-27 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Iringa
A-31
Annexure 4.1/7
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Mingoyo-Mtama L3 W. of Mingoyo S85-18 x x x
A7-1 Mingoyo-Masasi Mtama-Nanganga L4 W. of Mtama S85-18 x x x
Nanganga-Masasi MT9 E. of Masasi S85-18 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Mtwara
Masasi-Akwungwazi S85-18 x x x New
Akwungwazi-Nangomba S85-18 x x x New
A7-2 Masasi-Tunduru
Nangomba-Lumesule MT10 W. of Nangomba S85-1 x x x
Lumesule-Tunduru R5 E. of Tunduru S85-1 x x x
Tunduru-Matemanga R4 W. of Tunduru S85-2 x x x
A7-3 Tunduru-Songea Matemanga-Namtumbo S85-2 x x x New
Namtumbo-Songea R1 E. of Songea S85-11 x x x
Songea-Mbinga R2 W. of Songea S85-11 x x x
A7-4 Songea-Mbamba Bay
Mbinga-Mbamba Bay R6 S. of Mbinga S85-11 x x x
A-32
Annexure 4.1/8
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Sirari-Tarime M9 N. of Tarime S85-20 x x x
Tarime-Utegi M7 E. of Utegi S85-20 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Mara
Utegi-Kinesi Jct. M6 W. of Utegi S85-20 x x x
A8-1 Sirari-Bunda
Kinesi Jct.-Makuntano M5 N. of Bukokowa S85-20 x x x
Makuntano-Kukirango M3 S. of Makuntano S85-29 x x x
Kukirango-Bunda M10 N. of Bunda S85-29 x x x
Bunda-Ndabaka Gate M12 S. of Bunda S85-29 x x x
Ndabaka Gate-Nyahanga MW4 At Kalemera S85-29 x x x
A8-2 Bunda-Mwanza
Nyahanga-Magu S85-29 x x x New
Nyalikungu-Mwanza MW1 At Kisessa S85-29 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Mwanza
A8-3 Mwanza-Usagara Jct. Mwanza-Usagara Jct MW15 N. of Usagara S85-21 x x x
Usagara Jct-Kikongo(Ferry) S85-16 x x x New
A8-4 Usagara Jct.-Geita Busisi(Ferry)-Sengerema MW5 E. of Sengerema S85-16 x x x
Sengerema-Geita MW8 E. of Geita S85-16 x x x
Geita-Bwanga MW9 W. of Geita S85-16 x x x
A8-5 Geita-Biharamulo Jct.
Bwanga-Biharamulo Jct. W14 E. of Chato Jct. S85-16 x x x
Lusahunga Jct.-Nyakahura W27 W. of Lusahunga S85-7 x x x
A8-6 Lusahunga Jct.-Rusumo Nyakahura-Nyakitama S85-7 x x x New
Nyakitama-Rusumo S85-7 x x x New
A-33
Annexure 4.1/9
Adjustment Year
P Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Usagara Jct.-Mabuki MW2 S. of Usagara S85-21 x x x
Mabuki-Runere S85-21 x x x New
B1-1 Usagara Jct.-Shinyanga Runere-Bubiki MW13 S. of Runere S85-21 x x x
Bubiki-Kolandoto S4 N. of Mwadui Jct. S85-21 x x x
Kolandoto-Shinyanga S85-21 x x x New
Shinyanga-Tinde S2 S. of Shinyanga S85-17 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Shinyanga
B1-2 Shinyanga-Nzega
Tinde-Nzega T8 N. of Nzega S85-17 x x x
Nzega-Puge T5 N. of Puge S85-17 x x x
B1-3 Nzega-Tabora
Puge-Tabora T1 At Kazima S85-12 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Tabora
B1-4 Tabora-Ipole Tabora-Ipole T2 S. of Kipalapala S85-12 x x x
B1-5 Ipole-Rungwa Ipole-Rungwa T13 S85-12 x x x
Rungwa-Makongolosi MB11 N. of Makongolosi S85-12 x x x
B1-6 Rungwa-Mbeya Makongolosi-Chunya S85-34 x x x New
Chunya-Mbeya MB7 N. of Mbeya S85-34 x x x
Makambako-Kibena IR9 S. of Makambako S85-31 x x x
B2-1 Makambako-Njombe
Kibena-Njombe S85-31 x x x New
Njombe-Litoni S85-15 x x x New
B2-2 Njombe-Songea Litoni-Ruhuhu River IR13 S. of Litoni Jct. S85-15 x x x
Ruhuhu River-Songea R3 N. of Songea S85-15 x x x x x x x x x Permanent C/P for Ruvuma
A-34
Annexure 4.1/10
Adjustment Year
Road No. Description Section C/P No. Location Remarks
C/P No. 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
Makuyuni-Manyara Jct. A6 W. of Makuyuni S85-30 x x x
B3-1 Makuyuni-Ngorongoro Manyara Jct.-Karatu E. of Karatu S85-30 x x x New
Karatu-Ngorongoro A8 S85-30 x x x
Ngorongoro-Seronera S85-30 x x x New
B3-2 Ngorongoro-Ikoma Gate
Seronera-Ikoma Gate S85-30 x x x New
Ikoma Gate-Nyamuswa S85-30 x x x New
B3-3 Ikoma Gate-Musoma Nyamuswa-Makutano M4 S. of Makutano S85-29 x x x
Makutano-Musoma M1 E. of Musoma S85-29 x x x
Babati-Dareda A10 W. of Babati S85-9 x x x
B4-2 Babati-Singida Dareda-Mgori Jct. A11 S. of Dareda S85-9 x x x
Mgori Jct.-Singida S13 E. of Singida S85-14 x x x
B5-1 Rungwa-Itigi Rungwa-Itigi S19 S. of Itigi S85-12 x x x
Mpanda-Inyonga E. of Mapanda S85-8 x x x
B6-1 Mpanda-Iplole
Inyonga-Iplole S85-8 x x x
A-35
Annexure 4.1/11
A-36
Annexure 4.1/12
A-37
Annexure 4.2/1
Proposed Traffic Sections and Count Stations on the Trunk and Regional Roads
Arusha Region
Manyara region
Coast region
A-38
Annexure 4.2/2
Dodoma region
Iringa region
Shinyanga region
A-39
Annexure 4.2/3
Kigoma region
Kilimanjaro region
Lindi region
A-40
Annexure 4.2/4
Mara region
Mbeya Region
Morogoro Region
A-41
Annexure 4.2/5
Mtwara Region
Mwanza region
Rukwa Region
A-42
Annexure 4.2/6
Ruvuma region
Tanga region
A-43
Annexure 4.2/7
Singida region
Tabora Region
Kagera region
A-44
Annexure 4.2/8
Dar es Salaam Region
A-45
Annexure 4.3
A-46
Annexure 4.4
Socio Economic Characteristics Along Traffic Sections Observed during Reconnaissance Survey
Crops Trade
CP Length Mineral
Road Road Section Traffic Nodes Between Livestock Industries Fishing Tourism Attractions
No (km) Food Cash Deposits General Food Vegetables/
No (Yes/No)
Fruits
1 T6 Mingoyo-Masasi Nanganga Masasi 56 Sorghum, Cassava, Maize Cashew nuts, Simsim No No Yes Yes No
Uranium,
Sorghum, Sweet Potatoes, Cashew nuts, Game hunting in Selous
2 T6 Masasi-Songea Namtumbo Songea 69 No Gemstones, No Yes Yes No
Maize Tobacco Game reserve
Diamond
Sweet potatoes, groundnuts,
3 T4 Kigoma-Nyakanazi Kanyani Kasulu 9 Cotton, Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sorghum, Maize, Banana
Cashew nuts,
4 T7 Dar es Salaam-Lindi Nyamwage Nangurukuru 103 Sorghum, Cassava No Salt Timber mill Yes Yes Yes Yes Kilwa ruins
Coconut, Simsim
Sweet potatoes, Sorghum, Coffee, Cotton,
5 T4 Biharamulo-Bukoba Kanazi Muhutwe 16 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Maize, Banana Flowers, Groundnuts
6 T9 Tunduma-Sumbawanga Tunduma Laela 127 Maize, Sweet Potatoes Simsim Yes Yes Yes Yes No
8 T9 Sumbawanga-Mpanda Sumbawanga Chala 62 Maize, Sweet Potatoes Simsim Yes Gold Yes Yes Yes Yes Katavi National Park
9 T5 Babati-Dodoma Kolo Kondoa 23 Maize Yes No Yes Yes Yes Kondoa Irangi Caves
10 T4 Bukoba-Mutukula Kyaka Katoma 45 Sorghum, Maize, Banana Coffee, Flowers Yes Kagera Sugar Company Yes Yes Yes Yes
11 T12 Songea-Mbambabay Peramiho Jn Kitai 34 Rice, Maize Coffee, Tobacco No Coal, Gemstones Coffee curing Yes Yes Yes No
15 T5 Songea-Makambako Songea Madaba 115 I. Potatoes, Maize Tea No Coal, Iron No Yes Yes No
Cashew nuts,
18 T7 Lindi-Mtwara Mingoyo Ndumbwe 48 Sorghum, Cassava No Oil, Gas Yes Yes No No Mikindani ruins
Coconut
Mtera Hydro electic
19 T5 Iringa-Mtera Nduli Mtera 108 Maize Yes Yes Yes Yes No
power generation
20 T4 Musoma-Sirari Mika Kuruya 36 Maize, Sorghum Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Serengeti National Park
Pamba Engineering
21 T8 Mwanza-Shinyanga Mabuki Ng'wamhaya 22 Maize Yes Limited, Fish Yes Yes Yes Yes
processing industries
A-47
Annexure 4.4
Crops Trade
CP Length Mineral
Road Road Section Traffic Nodes Between Livestock Industries Fishing Tourism Attractions
No (km) Food Cash Deposits General Food Vegetables/
No (Yes/No)
Fruits
Mkumbara Chipboard
22 T2 Segera-Moshi Mkomazi Same 89 Maize, Rice Sisal No Yes Yes Yes Mkomazi Game Reserve
Factory
Maize, Sweet Potatoes,
23 T3 Morogoro-Dodoma Magole Gairo 70 Sugar Cane No Mtibwa Sugar Factory No Yes Yes Yes
Rice, Tomato
26 T7 Dar es Salaam-Lindi Mkuranga kibiti 92 Cassava, Sorgum Cashew nuts, Coconut No No Yes Yes No
Udzungwa mountains
27 T1 Iringa-Morogoro Ipogolo Ruaha river 107 Maize, Onion, Tomato Yes No Yes Yes Yes
National Park
30 T5 Arusha-Babati Minjingu Babati 60 Maize Yes Minjingu Phosphate Plant No Yes Yes Yes
31 T1 Makambako-Iringa Makambako Mafinga 84 Maize, I.Potatoes Tea No Paper mill, Tea Factory No Yes Yes No
33 T2 Chalinze-Segera Msata Mkata 73 Cassava, Maize, Sorghum No No Yes Yes Yes Saadan Game Reserve
Electric Power
34 T10 Uyole-Kasumulu Uyole Tukuyu 60 Rice, I.Potatoes, Banana Tea, Coffee, Cocoa Yes Oxygen, Coal Yes Yes Yes Yes Lake Nyasa
Generation
Tanga Cement & Lime
35 T13 Segera-Tanga Muheza Tanga 43 Maize, Cassava No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Factories
Kilimanjaro Machine
38 T2 Moshi-Arusha KIA Junction Arusha 42 Maize, Banana Coffee, Flowers Yes Tanzanite No Yes Yes Yes Arusha National Park
Tools
Sweet Potatoes, Maize,
39 T3 Singida-Mkiwa Issuna Jct Singida 56 Cotton, Ground nut Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Sorghum
40 T18 Itigi-Mbeya Rungwa Itigi 191 Maize Yes No Yes Yes Yes
44 T2 Himo Jct-Moshi Himo Jct Moshi 22 Maize, Banana Coffee, Flowers Yes No Yes Yes Yes Kilimanjaro National Park
A-48
Annexure 5.1
2 T6 Mtwara-Mingoyo-Tunduru-Songea-Makambako Tunduru - Songea Litola Litola Bus Stand Namtumbo 10°33.556´ 035°55.922´
3 T9 Tunduma-Sumbawanga-Mpanda-Kasulu-Nyakanazi Kasulu-Kigoma South of Kasulu Lightness Guest House Kasulu 04°34.715´ 030°06.624´
4 T7 Dar es Salaam-Kibiti-Lindi-Mingoyo Nyamwage-Nangurukuru Nangurukuru 50 m North of Police gate Kilwa 08°47.912ô´ 039°20.889´
5 T4 Mutukula-Bukoba-Biharamulo-Geita-Usagara-Mwanza-Bunda-Sirari Kanazi-Muhutwe Muhutwe Bayango shop (Near Kamachumu junction) Bukoba 01°34.072´ 031°42.154´
11 T12 Songea-Mbambabay Songea-Mbinga Likuyufusi 100m West of Peramiho Junction Songea 10°40.727´ 035.28.432´
12 T18 Manyoni-Itigi-Tabora-Kanyani Urambo-Tabora Urambo Placard for Union of Disabled Persons Urambo 05°04.264´ 032°04.740´
13 T16 Mikumi-Ifakara-Mahenge Kidatu-Ifakara Kiberege At Kiberege one storey building Kilombero 07°57.358´ 036°51.292´
14 T3 Rusumo-nyakanazi-Isaka-Nzega-Singida-Dodoma-Morogoro Sekenke-Ziba East of Igunga Silver "C"Lodge and bar Igunga 04°17.252´ 033°53.107´
15 T6 Mtwara-Mingoyo-Tunduru-Songea-Makambako Songea-Madaba Junction Gumbiro Gumbiro Bus Stand Songea 10°15.903´ 035°39.160´
16 T4 Mutukula-Bukoba-Biharamulo-Geita-Usagara-Mwanza-Bunda-Sirari Geita-Sengerema Kasamwa Kasamwa bus stand(big tree) Geita 02°50.352´ 032°25.415´
17 T8 Usagara-Shinyanga-Tabora-Ipole-Rungwa-Chunya-Mbeya Tinde-Nzega North of Nzega Uchama (St Justin) Secondary School Nzega 04°11.265´ 033°10.911´
18 T6 Mtwara-Mingoyo-Tunduru-Songea-Makambako Mingoyo - Mpapura Mingoyo South of Weigh Bridge Lindi 10°06.808´ 039°37.100´
19 T5 Makuyuni-Babati-Dodoma-Iringa Nduli-Mtera Nduli 100 m North of Nduli Primary School Sign Post Iringa 07°40.961´ 035°44.883´
20 T4 Mutukula-Bukoba-Biharamulo-Geita-Usagara-Mwanza-Bunda-Sirari Utegi-Kinesi Junction Sulubu(Komasu) Gwessosons Group shops Tarime 01°25.720´ 034°11.235´
25 T2 Namanga-Arusha-Himo junction-Segera-Chalinze Oldonyo Sambu-Namanga Longido Longido Saccos Longido 02°43.956´ 036°41.739´
26 T7 Dar es Salaam-Kibiti-Lindi-Mingoyo Mkuranga-Kibiti Kibiti Mariam Consolata Dispensary Rufiji 07°37.5.115´ 038°56.521´
27 T1 Dar es Salaam-Morogoro-Iringa-Mbeya-Tunduma Ruaha river-Iringa Mahenge Majichano Bar Kilolo 07°38.018´ 036°15.980´
28 T1 Dar es Salaam-Morogoro-Iringa-Mbeya-Tunduma Chimala-Uyole Junction Chimala New Bus Stand Mbarali 08°51.412´ 034°00.914´
31 T1 Dar es Salaam-Morogoro-Iringa-Mbeya-Tunduma Mafinga-Makambako Makambako Green View Pub Njombe 08°50.181´ 034°50.208´
A-49
Annexure 5.1
33 T2 Namanga-Arusha-Himo junction-Segera-Chalinze Msata-Mkata Manga 100m South of Mr FRESH BAR Handeni 05°54.493´ 038°14.191´
34 T10 Uyole-Kasumulu Uyole-Tukuyu Mtokera Mwazola Bar and Guest House Rungwe 09°05.059´ 033°33.726´
35 T13 Segera-Tanga Muheza-Tanga Muheza Lusanga Bus Stand Tanga 05°10.792´ 033°49.412´
36 T1 Dar es Salaam-Morogoro-Iringa-Mbeya-Tunduma Mdaula-Morogoro Ubenazomozi Ubena Ward Saccos T. Ltd Bagamoyo 06°38.174´ 038°10.123´
37 T1 Dar es Salaam-Morogoro-Iringa-Mbeya-Tunduma Mlandizi-Chalinze Vigwaza Centre for Inspection of Forestry Products at Vigwaza Bagamoyo 06°40.489´ 033°37.339´
38 T2 Namanga-Arusha-Himo junction-Segera-Chalinze KIA junction-Ussa River Kikatiti Kikatiti Bus Stand Arumeru 03°28.331´ 036°56.612´
40 T22 Mkiwa-Itigi-Rungwa Rungwa-Itigi Mitundu Meatu Guest House Manyoni 06°00.852´ 034°03.539´
42 T3 Rusumo-nyakanazi-Isaka-Nzega-Singida-Dodoma-Morogoro Bukombe-Kahama Ushirombo Primary Court -Bukombe Polster Bukombe 03°28.393´ 031°54.323´
43 T8 Usagara-Shinyanga-Tabora-Ipole-Rungwa-Chunya-Mbeya Tabora-Sikonge Sikonge District Agricultural and Livestock Office (Sikonge) Sikonge 05°36.552´ 032°44.674´
44 T2 Namanga-Arusha-Himo junction-Segera-Chalinze Himo Junction-Moshi Himo Junction Mabungo Petrol Station Moshi 03°24.383´ 037°30.364´
45 T17 Makuyuni-Ngorongoro Makuyuni-Mto wa Mbu Makuyuni 300 m NW of Jn to Mto wa Mbu Monduli 03°32.949´ 036°06.057´
A-50
Annexure 5.2-A
Baseline Traffic Counts in Tanzania Mainland & Establishment of a Comprehensive Traffic Census Methodology for TANROADs
CP No .
MANUAL CLASSIFIED TRAFFIC COUNTS
Direction of Traffic From: To: Date Day Passability of the Road GPS Reference
Name of the Road Traffic Section: dd / mm / yy Upstream S
Survey Location District: Downstream E
Nearest Town Region: Special Feature:
Any other Remarks:
Motorized Traffic
Non‐Motorized Traffic
Passenger Vehicle Goods Vehicle
Time Two
Weather
Remarks
Bus Medium Heavy Very Heavy / Animal
Utility Wheeler Bus Others Others
Car (<=25 Light Truck Truck Truck Articulated Bicycle Drawn /
Vehicle (Motor ( >25 Seats ) (Specify) (Specify)
Seats) ( 2‐Axle ) ( 3‐Axle ) Truck Hand Cart
Cycles)
From………….hr
To………………hr
From………….hr
To………………hr
From………….hr
To………………hr
From………….hr
To………………hr
Signature of the Enumerator:
Consultants: Signature of the Monitor/ Supervisor:
Intercontinental Consultants and
Technocrats Pvt. Ltd., India
Name & Position of the Monitor/ Supervisor :
Name of the Enumerator: in association with
DATACONSULT Limited, Tanzania
Note: Refer to the attached explanatory note before filling in the format.
A-51
Annexure 5.2-B
A-52
Annexure 8.1
A-53
Annexure 9.1
Motorized Traffic
Non-Motorized Traffic
Time Passenger Vehicle Goods Vehicles Re-
Total
(hr-hr) Bus Bus Light Med. Heavy Art. ADV / marks
Car UV 2-Wh Others Cycle Others
(<=25) (>25) Truck Truck Truck Truck Cart
Day: Monday Weather Hr Special Feature
06:00-07:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - -
07:00-08:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
08:00-09:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
09:00-10:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
10:00-11:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
11:00-12:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
12:00-13:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
13:00-14:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
14:00-15:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
15:00-16:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
16:00-17:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
17:00-18:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
18:00 19:00
18:00-19:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
19:00-20:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
20:00-21:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
21:00-22:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
22:00-23:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
23:00-24:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
24:00-01.00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
01:00-02:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
02:00-03:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
03:00-04:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
04:00-05:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
05:00-06:00 - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Total Day - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
A-54
BTS CPS IN COMPATIBILITY WITH RMMS CODING
Annexure 9.2
Location of the Study Count Points w.r.t. RMMS Links & Nodes
Distance from
Start Node
CP No Road No. Place District Link No End Node No. Start Node
No.
(metres)
1 10006 Chikundi Masasi 1323 0035 0005 04077
2 10006 Litora Namtumbo 1390 0810 0811 10360
3 10009 South of Kasulu Kasulu 1880 7102 7103 07121
4 10007 Nangurukuru Kilwa 1560 0406 0426 00100
5 10004 Muhutwe Bukoba 0945 8415 8416 06854
6 10009 Laela Sumbawanga 1796 4932 4902 11210
7 10003 Nyakahura Biharamulo 0805 8402 8403 27290
8 10009 Chala Namanyere 1815 4909 4910 34090
9 10005 Bicha Kondoa 1210 2713 2714 00011
10 10004 Katoma Bukoba 0920 8410 8411 10810
11 10012 Likuyufusi Songea 2075 0819 0820 00100
12 20381 Urambo Urambo 5505 4515 4535 00920
13 10016 Kiberege Kilombero 2249 2313 2319 12850
14 10003 East of Igunga Igunga 0730 4501 4502 03140
15 10006 Gumbiro Songea 1415 0815 0816 00100
16 10004 Kasamwa Geita 1005 7903 7991 00040
17 10003 North of Nzega Nzega 1672 4505 4506 03073
18 10007 Mingoyo Lindi 1305 0003 0401 33320
19 10005 Nduli Iringa 1175 3514 3515 00200
20 10004 Sulubu(Komasu) Tarime 1100 7506 7533 22960
21 10008 Mabuki Missungwi 1710 7922 7923 00229
22 10002 Hedaru Same 0420 5306 5801 11720
23 10003 Dumila Kilosa 0612 2308 2309 02019
24 10001 Mlowo Mbozi 0240 4009 4110 00173
25 10002 Longido Longido 0535 6305 6306 00309
26 10007 Kibiti Rufiji 1535 1912 1913 -
27 10001 Mahenge Kilolo 0135 2306 3501 33240
28 10001 Chimala Mbarali 0205 4002 4003 01747
29 10004 Balili Bunda 1070 7500 7501 17990
30 10005 Minjingu Babati 1226 6502 6503 24540
31 10006 Makambako Njombe 0180 3509 3510 07930
32 10001 Doma Mvomero 0127 2328 2305 00200
33 10002 Manga Handeni 0390 1908 5301 01800
34 10010 Mtokera Rungwe 1970 4022 4023 10200
35 10013 Muheza Muheza 2140 5308 5309 03444
36 10001 Ubena Somozi morogoro 0097 1934 1936 20110
37 10001 Vigwaza Bagamoyo 0095 1902 1903 13690
38 10002 Kikatiti Arumeru 0510 5818 6325 17530
39 10003 Ikungi Singida 0690 3106 3107 01089
40 10022 Mgandu Manyoni 2465 3120 3121 14840
41 10008 Chunya Chunya 1607 4099 4013 40980
42 10003 Ushirombo Bukombe 0790 6706 6739 00757
43 10008 Sikonge Sikonge 1650 4510 4511 02106
44 10002 Himo Junction Moshi 0460 5808 5809 01679
45 10017 Makuyuni Monduli 2315 6314 6307 30780
A‐55