Final Analysis
Final Analysis
University of Florida
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
2
Abstract
may feel pressures from outside forces to succeed in college, and when accompanied by new
feelings of isolation and loneliness that comes with this unfamiliarity, students can face
deterioration in their mental health. There are many social and economic factors that play a role
in why a student may resort to self-harm or suicide, and the effect that it has on the community
can be detrimental. At the University of Florida, the Counseling and Wellness Center is a
resource that students can access for mental health care, counseling, and for check-ins on their
overall well-being. Programs like the Counseling and Wellness Center seek to reduce the
number of students suffering from mental health issues and/or suicidal ideation by implementing
the structural functionalist theoretical perspective into their programs. This paper will discuss the
issue of suicide as a whole, the population it affects and how the community-level factors
influence the population and problem, while also discussing the ways the CWC is endorsing their
Organizational Overview
The University of Florida’s Counseling and Wellness Center (CWC) is a short term
counseling center for university students. The facility is located on the university campus,
making it easily accessible to students. Their mission statement, to foster human development in
all of its diversity through compassion, empowerment, advocacy, hope, and heart, i llustrates
their goal in taking care of the Gator Nation (UF CWC). They offer a broad array of student
services, including individual counseling, group therapy and workshops, psychiatry, and crisis
services. In order to determine which services will best fit the needs of the individual, students
attend an initial triage appointment to discuss the details of their problem and to provide
additional background. Students are seen for an average of one to six appointments, but the
organization also provides assistance to individuals looking for a more long term therapy. The
CWC acknowledges the changes that students experience upon entering college and aim to
In order to learn more about this organization, a student manager, Bianca Cegatte, was
interviewed. Bianca works as a liaison between the Counseling and Wellness Center and U
Matter We Care. She is well versed in recommending the services offered by the CWC to
students and ensuring that students do not encounter additional stress when pursuing these
services. Bianca provided information on the organization’s outreach and advocacy programs
that reduce students’ feelings of isolation and the stigma associated with seeking help.
Problem
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
4
In recent years, suicide rates have been on a steep incline, especially among teenagers
and young adults. In addition to this, self harm is on the rise. These two issues mentioned are of
extreme urgency in today’s society, which is why this group has chosen to discuss them and the
effects they can have on a community. While suicide and self harm begin as individual-level
problems, they can have a heavy impact on both the household and community in which they
occur.
When an individual commits suicide, this can have a tremendous impact on his or her
microsystem; the people they interacted with on a regular basis feel the effects of it the most.
According to Elana Premack Sandler, this can include the individual’s parents, siblings, friends,
classmates, coworkers, teachers, and anyone else who is close to the victim (Sandler, 2018).
Sandler explains that not only do these people miss the physical presence of the person, but the
loss can also have an immense effect on their mental health as possible feelings of guilt, anger,
and shame can arise due to the stigma surrounding the topic, as well as the lasting question of
“why?”. Furthermore, this tragedy can strongly affect this person’s wider community, their
mesosystem, such as: students in their school, acquaintances, religious group members, and
According to Jackie Burrell, some primary risk factors for suicide among adolescents are
“major depression, traumatic or stressful life events, a prior suicide attempt, a sense of isolation
and lack of support, and poor coping skills” (Burrell, 2019). The main reasons mentioned in the
interview for students engaging in self-harm or feeling suicidal are academic stress, roommate
problems, and the isolation of being away from home and family. In addition to this, Bianca
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
5
stated that students also suffer as they feel overwhelmed by the size of the university and its
student body, thus causing them to feel lonely and often self-destructive.
In the United States, suicide is the tenth leading cause of death as of 2019 (Nichols,
2019). According to the Florida Department of Health, in the year 2018, 42 people took their
own lives here in Alachua county (Florida Department of Health, 2018). The Florida Department
of Health also highlighted that in 2018, 3,552 persons committed suicide in the state of Florida.
It should also be noted that the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention reported that a total
of 47,173 persons died of suicide in the United States in 2017. Lastly, every year, one in five
females as well as one in seven males engage in self harm in the United States (Gluck, 2019).
Suicide and self harm often go hand in hand as “deliberate self-harm is the strongest risk
factor for future suicide” (Hawton, Zahl & Weatherall, 2018). According to the Centre for
Suicide Prevention, self harm can lead to suicide when it is “no longer an effective coping
method” and it “ceases to offset the feelings caused by stress or trauma” (Centre for Suicide
Prevention, 2018, para. 6). Often times when persons engage in self harm or commit suicide,
their environment is one of the primary aspects under investigation. Questions about the state of
their households, neighbourhoods, and schools are asked to determine the causes. In other words,
the community in which the individual resides is analyzed. This is how a community plays such
a crucial role in the health of its members and why suicide and self harm have lasting effects on
the community.
Population
Every year 800,000 people around the world attempt to take their own life (Suicide
Statistics, 2019). According to the American Foundation for Suicide Prevention, suicide is the
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
6
tenth leading cause of death in the United States (Suicide Statistics, 2019). Suicide affects
families and communities alike. Bianca described the Counseling and Wellness Center’s
involvement in the community as they work one-on-one with the student, as well as with their
family members and friends. She stated that the CWC is aware of the impact that suicide and
self-harm has on the people in the individual’s life and ensure that they are taken care of as well.
Suicide is common in both high income communities and vulnerable communities. These
Gender seems to be a factor in societal rates of self-harm and suicide. When comparing
rates of suicide over generations, the number of male suicides outnumber that of females. In
2017, the rate of suicide in men was 3.54 times higher than females (Suicide Statistics,2019).
This increased rate of suicide could be linked to the more violent suicide methods that men tend
to choose (Siversten et al., 2019). While women were four times more likely than men to use
overdosing as a means to committing suicide, men more often resorted to firearms, hanging, and
Individuals that suffer from mental illnesses are more vulnerable to suicide and self-
harm. Depression and schizophrenia are the two most common mental illnesses linked to high
rates of suicide (Bird, L., & Faulkner, A., 2000). Individuals with depression struggle with a
chemical imbalance of serotonin and norepinephrine that prohibits the brain from passing
information through neurotransmitters (Bird, L., & Faulkner, A., 2000). While an individual
equipped with a regular balance of serotonin and norepinephrine can regulate their emotions and
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
7
readily consider their options when confronting a hardship, someone with depression has more
difficulty relying on their neurotransmitters to receive those important messages (Bird, L., &
Faulkner, A., 2000). Similarly, someone with schizophrenia may lose touch with reality as their
brain also struggles with receiving the necessary neurotransmitters. The symptoms of both of
these disorders can be very isolating for an individual, especially in cases where they are not able
According to Dr. Qureshi, immigrants and other ethnic minorities may be at a higher risk
of suicide when compared to the average population of the country (Forte et al, 2018). Migrants
are often exposed to traumatic circumstances, as many of them fled their countries of origin due
to violent and economic instability. Starting a life in a new country can bring many challenges
such as separation from family, language barriers, loss of social networking, job loss, and a lack
of healthcare information (Forte et al, 2018). All of these components combined with
psychological problems such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), mood and anxiety
disorders make this specific group inclined to experience suicidal thoughts and puts them at a
The stigma surrounding suicide and self-harm is a major contributor to the low
percentage of individuals that actively seek help when dealing with adverse effects. As
individuals continue to avoid seeking help in these situations, they will be unable to receive
necessary assistance. The general public also lacks knowledge and awareness about suicide as a
self-harm in individuals and communities; this section will focus mainly on the community-level
factors that play a role in this process. Suicide is the second leading cause of death among
college students in the United States (National Institute of Mental Health, 2017), which means
that universities have a responsibility for providing access to resources to help students suffering
from suicidal ideation and self-harm. Suicide prevention programs are an example of a
community factor that attempts to mitigate the issue of suicide, as they were created to reduce
factors that increase suicidal thoughts and actions while increasing the factors that protect people
from suicide and self-harm. Suicide prevention programs on college campuses seek to mitigate
training mental health staff to address risk factors, and have crisis management plans (Suicide
Prevention Resource Center, 2013). The CWC has programs in place for mitigating these issues;
as learned in the interview, friends, family, and professors of students can call UMatter or the
CWC on behalf of a student they think is in need of mental health support services. Another
multiple levels of care for patients with suicide risk tend to be effective when they include
treatment for mental and/or substance use disorders, non-restrictive settings, and
follow-up/referral services that happen in a timely manner (Suicide Prevention Resource Center,
2013). Based on the interview with Bianca, we learned that the CWC has no time-limit on when
they stop checking in on a student after the student seeks counseling. The counselor uses their
professional judgement to determine if the student is in need of further counseling, and of course,
if the student feels they need more help, they will receive it.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
9
Overall connectedness in the community and school is an important protective factor
since social isolation can contribute to anxiety and depression, which can increase the risk of
suicide and self-harm. A 2017 survey of nearly 48,000 college students showed that 64% felt
“very lonely” in the previous 12 months, with 12% saying they contemplated suicide (Art and
Healing, 2017). Minority, first-generation, and international students are most likely to
experience these feelings of loneliness, and this could be considered a community problem
because of the lack of resources available to these groups. Research has shown that feelings of
loneliness and, more specifically, feeling like “a burden on others” are signs that an individual
may have suicidal ideations (Hollingsworth et al., 2016) Community-based efforts in schools can
combat these feelings of loneliness to vulnerable groups by raising awareness and encouraging
openness about feelings of loneliness and hopelessness. Combined with access to behavioral
healthcare and mental health services mentioned above, these initiatives can be great resources
for helping students suffering from suicidal ideation due to isolation and loneliness (Nobel,
2018).
Having access to basic physical needs and overall psychological safety is another
protective factor, and this can be achieved by living in an area that is not exposed to school and
community violence. Poverty and community-level traumatic events would contribute to the
problem of suicide; globally, suicide rates have fallen as living conditions improve, and the
reverse is also true (American Psychological Association, 2019). Access to firearms is a key risk
factor for suicide since firearms were the leading mechanism for suicide death in 2016
(American Public Health Association, 2018). Restricted access to firearms, especially on college
campuses, is a protective factor that the community has a direct influence on.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
10
Especially in adolescents attending a college or university, a sense of isolation and lack
of support is a major risk factor for suicide. Stigma surrounding seeking help for mental health
issues and suicidal ideations can easily be considered a community-level issue, especially in a
college environment that promotes professionalism and perfectionism. This stigma has
manifested into a lack of campus mental health services across the country. Only 7% of two-year
institutions and 58% of four-year colleges have on-campus psychiatric consultation (Gallagher,
2015). Many of these resources may have wait times that are inefficient for patients who may
urgently need psychiatric help, which only increases the likelihood of a suicide attempt or
self-harm. Referrals to off-campus psychiatric clinics are also an inefficient solution because of
financial issues/minimal mental health insurance, transportation issues, and lack of availability of
these types of psychiatric clinics in the community as a whole. Students with the highest risk of
suicide ideation and attempts are those who already have some pre-existing mental health
problems and those who develop mental health problems when enrolled, which is why it is so
important that college campuses have the adequate counseling centers and suicide prevention
Our interview with Bianca gave us insight on what the CWC identifies as being important
community-level factors that were relevant to the topic of suicide and self-harm on campus. We
learned from her that people who had a pre-existing mental health issue were more likely to seek
out counseling than others, which was something we also initially found in our research.
Isolation and feelings of loneliness were also cited as the biggest contributors to suicidal ideation
among college students, especially if they are farther from home, like an out of state or
international student. Bianca told us that the end of the semester corresponds with the highest
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
11
influx of students seeking support services, and this can be for a variety of reasons including
stress from final exams, feelings of sadness from students who cannot go home for the holidays,
and students who are graduating who have fears about the future. Students being unsure about
their plans after graduating is something we did not account for in our research, but this is
alarming rate (Remington, 2019). While there is a stigma around mental health, some students
who might seek help are unaware of the resources free to students on campus, such as the
Counseling and Wellness Center and U Matter We Care. Instead, students tend to struggle
silently until someone notices that they are struggling, or until a mental break occurs
(Remington, 2019).
The adjustment to college life transitioning from public high school to a top 10 university
is a significant difference. Students go from having classes from seven in the morning, Monday
through Friday, to having the ability to create their own schedule, the way they like it. While it
sounds nice, there are already stressors that are taking place due to full classes and overlapping
lectures. After the initial excitement of college wears off, loneliness, depression, and
homesickness usually arrive. In our interview, Bianca reiterated the fact that having a large
campus like the University of Florida makes individuals feel alone. According to College Stats,
50% of students rated their mental health below average or poor (Mental Health Guide, 2019).
In order to still be able to achieve both academically and mentally, students need to understand
the importance of taking a mental health day in order to avoid pent up stress.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
12
College students typically put a lot of pressure on themselves. According to American
Psychological Association, anxiety is the top concern for 41.6% of students (College Students’
Mental Health is a Growing Concern, Survey Finds). They sign up for twelve to seventeen credit
hours a semester, going in with the expectation of receiving an A in every class and make sure
students reported they had problems with schoolwork due to a mental health issue (Mental
Health Guide, 2019). Parents also tend to put pressure on the students as well. Parents understand
that students are going to be stressed and do not expect their children to be perfect but projecting
their thoughts and disapproval upon certain ideas and activities affects the student. It is reported
that 80% of students feel overwhelmed by their responsibilities as a student (Mental Health
Guide, 2019). The student is already aware that they are spending thousands of dollars to attend a
university and do not need the additional reminders that there is a lot of weight hanging on their
shoulders to succeed.
It is not surprising that there is a stigma about mental health services around the
University of Florida campus when it is reported that 40% of students fail to seek help (Mental
Health Guide, 2019). In the interview, Bianca mentioned the stigma saying that students are
scared to go because it is attached to the school (Cegatte). While it is attached to the school and
the CWC is aware of the stigma, Bianca also stated that they pride themselves on the
confidentiality and anonymity, and that reaching out to seek help is a low pressure process, and
that they are there to be a resource. She also mentioned that in addition to the CWC, U Matter
We Care is another great resource for students as they also provide additional assistance, as well
as have ambassadors on campus. While GatorWell is a prominent and trusted resource, it also
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
13
has its flaws. A very distinctive flaw is that during times where students are typically most
stressed and suicidal, like exam season or the end of the semester, there are no available
appointments. GatorWell is known for turning students away in a time of crisis in the end of the
semester, saying that they are booked, and instead offer to make an appointment for the
following semester. This is lamentable as students may experience additional distress after being
turned away from GatorWell, and do not know where to go. These students are typically
unaware of the remarkable resources that the Counseling and Wellness Center provides,
including crisis services that are offered both in person and via telephone (“Crisis Services- UF
A community level factor that mitigates the problem of suicide and self-harm is campus
involvement and having a vital support system in Gainesville that is available when presenting
signs of distress. Additionally, spending time with peers in a setting not involving academia that
allows for a relaxed, enjoyable environment is also likely to reduce thoughts of self-harm and
suicide. As previously mentioned, the Counseling and Wellness Center and You Matter We Care
are essential resources for students that may be struggling with mental health issues on the
Theoretical Perspective
problem of suicide and self harm among college students is structural functionalism. The basic
premise of structural functionalism is that every part of society serves a purpose to help that
society function properly (Moore, 2019). The CWC is a structure whose function is to provide an
array of services to students suffering from mental health illnesses or suicidal thoughts.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
14
Structural functionalism aims to maintain the status quo within society, which in this case would
look like students having equal access to resources on campus that would prevent them from
engaging in self-harm and/or having suicidal thoughts. As stated in the interview, the CWC
attempts to maintain the status quo through outreach to students, confidential counseling sessions
with certified professionals, advocating for students with mental health issues, as well as
Social pathology is a theory that comes from the structural functionalist perspective
which can provide a clearer understanding of the issue of suicide and self-harm. Social pathology
is a result of institutions or elements of the structure or culture not functioning properly. This can
happen when individuals are not socialized to adopt the norms and values of society. In this case,
this would mean that individuals are not adequately educated about the prevalence of mental
health on college campuses or they are unaware of how to obtain access to resources on campus
that specialize in mental health. The CWC aims to fix this part of society with their outreach
program; this involves getting in touch with students whose family and/or friends have expressed
concerns about their mental health status, as well as ensuring that students remain on track with
among college students can be due to a number of reasons: social isolation, being away from
family/home, academic stress and/or relationship issues. The outreach program at the CWC is a
form of intervention for when students appear to be suffering in silence. Additionally, the CWC
has a variety of suicide prevention resources including access to a 24-hour messaging platform
with a trained professional for those who do not wish to meet in person.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
15
Structural functionalism assumes that society is a set of interdependent parts that each
serve a function, which is why the CWC not only caters to those who engage in self-harm and/or
have thoughts of suicide, but also those who have been indirectly affected. It was stated in the
interview that the CWC also aims to provide counseling and comfort to individuals who have
been affected by losing someone to suicide. Losing someone to suicide can have adverse effects
on one’s mental health and can affect their academic, personal, and professional life. In the case
of an organization losing a student to suicide, the CWC along with U Matter We Care work
together to provide a representative whose main purpose is to help others make sense of and
process the hardship of losing a loved one. This is another example of how the structural
functionalist perspective is implemented by this organization; the effects of suicide are seen as a
societal issue that can be solved through the services that the CWC provides.
Concluding Remarks
located on campus which allows for easy access for those seeking help at the university, there
can be limited availability for appointments at times. The CWC provides their services mainly
through appointments. As mentioned in the interview, there are certain times of the semester
(example: around finals or closer to graduation) where there is an influx of students seeking help
and they are not always able to accommodate everybody. A possible solution to limited
availability is more funding provided to the CWC by the university which will allow for
By including community-level factors in this program, the CWC is able to reach more
students in need. University students are away from home and their primary caregivers, but the
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
16
CWC is an organization that has the ability to ease this process for students. By promoting
counseling and psychiatry services, among others, the university is seen as a source of support.
Rather than being afraid to admit that they are struggling, students will be able to tackle this
seeking mental health help, lack of available mental health services and access to help into their
programs in two different ways. The first idea is attempting to reduce the stigma of mental health
issues by creating a class similar to “First-Year Florida”. This class would be created by the
CWC with the purpose of teaching ways to prevent and overcome stressors that occur during the
college experience in a way that helps prevent suicide and depression before issues begin to
occur, while additionally discussing positive self-care and creating an individualized stress
management plan to use over the course of their college experience. The second
recommendation is to create a satellite location in both Marston and Library West similar to
Peabody Hall as a location student can go in an environment, they are comfortable to relax and
decompress in a place where the feeling of stress and overwhelmingness typically occurs.
While structural functionalism is the theoretical perspective the CWC is most likely to
endorse, symbolic interactionism can also be used to interpret the problem of suicide and
self-harm and the effect it has on the community. The basic premise of symbolic interactionism
is that meaning is created through interactions, and we act in response to the meaning we assign.
Some people may percieve suicide and self-harm as a community-level issue, where as others
may percieve it as a sign of weakness. There is a lot of stigma associated with those who suffer
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
17
from mental illness; they can be seen as weak for not being able to handle the problem in a
different way.
interactionism changes how the organization approaches problems. Using this approach, the best
course of action for the problem would aim towards reducing stigma related to mental health and
topics of suicide, along with acting as advocates for those suffering from mental illness and
suicidal ideations. In our interview with Bianca, she discussed how they advocate and raise
awareness for these individuals. The organization sends representatives to classrooms to talk
about mental health, stigma, and programs for those who want to seek help without a high
amount of pressure. Talking about the subject can be hard to navigate, but doing so is important
in the effort to reduce any lingering stigma. With this approach, it’s important to also consider
the affects that an individual’s cultural, economic, and ethnic background will have on their
perception of mental health and suicide. Some groups may be more understanding of the issue,
whereas other groups may not be as educated about it, and these are the people who often create
American Psychological Association (2019). Worrying trends in U.S. suicide rates. Retrieved
from https://www.apa.org/monitor/2019/03/trends-suicide
American Public Health Association (2018). Reducing Suicides by Firearms. Retrieved from
https://www.apha.org/policies-and-advocacy/public-health-policy-statements/policy-data
base/2019/01/28/reducing-suicides-by-firearms
Art and Healing (2017). Fact Sheet: Loneliness on Campus. Retrieved from
https://www.apa.org/monitor/2013/06/college-students.
from https://mentalhealth.org.uk/publications/suicide-and-self-harm
Burrell, J. (2019, November 5). The Grim Numbers Behind Adolescent Suicides and Attempts.
Retrieved from
https://www.verywellmind.com/college-and-teen-suicide-statistics-3570768.
Crisis Services- UF Counseling and Wellness Center (CWC). (n.d.). Retrieved from
http://counseling.ufl.edu/services/crisis/
Forte et al. (2018). Suicide risk among immigrants and ethnic minorities: a literature overview.
International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 1 5(7): 1438, doi:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6068754/.
SUICIDE AND SELF-HARM
19
Gallagher, Robert P. (2015) National Survey of College Counseling Centers 2014. Project
Hawton, K., Zahl, D., & Weatherall, R. (2003). Suicide following deliberate self-harm:
Hollingsworth D.W., Slish, M.L., Wingate, L.R., Davidson, C.L., Rasmussen, K.A., O’Keefe,
V.M., … Grant, D.M. (2016). The indirect effect of perceived burdensomeness on the
relationship between indices of social support and suicide ideation in college students.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07448481.2017.1363764?scroll=top&need
Access=true
Illinois Department of Public Health (2014). Suicide and College Students. Retrieved from
http://www.dph.illinois.gov/sites/default/files/publications/suicide-ncollege-students-050
216.pdf
https://collegestats.org/resources/mental-health-guide/.
Moore, K. (2019). FYC3401: Social and Economic Perspectives on the Community, Unit 14:
etrieved from
NAMI. (n.d.). The Ripple Effect of Suicide. R
https://www.nami.org/Blogs/NAMI-Blog/September-2018/The-Ripple-Effect-of-Suicide.
National Institute of Mental Health (2017). Mental Health Information: Statistics in Suicide.
Nobel, Jeremy (2018). Forging Connection Against Loneliness. American Foundation for
https://afsp.org/forging-connection-against-loneliness/
Remington, C. (2019, September 25). New UF Study Finds Suicide Is Higher Among Young
https://wusfnews.wusf.usf.edu/post/new-uf-study-finds-suicide-higher-among-young-peo
ple-previously-reported.
Schimelpfening, N. (2019). Are there gender differences in suicide and suicidal behaviors?
Retrieved from
https://www.verywellmind.com/gender-differences-in-suicide-methods-1067508.
https://www.suicideinfo.ca/resource/self-harm-and-suicide/
Self Injury, Self Harm Statistics and Facts. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.healthyplace.com/abuse/self-injury/self-injury-self-harm-statistics-and-facts
Siversten, B., Hysing, M., Knapstad, M., A.G., Reneflot, A., Lonning, K. J., & O’Connor, R. C.
prevalence study.
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/suicide.