Motor Performance
Motor Performance
ELECTRIC
MACHINES
HANDS-ON SKILLS FOR LEARNING ACTIVITY PACKET 4:
MOTOR PERFORMANCE
School Supplied
1 3/16-inch Allen Wrench
1 Roll Electrical Tape
1 Graph Paper
1 Calculator
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will calculate the power output of various motors based on given information. This is the first
step necessary to size an electric motor.
4. Calculate the power of a motor given the following information. Show all calculations.
Force = 3.75 N-m
Radius distance = 1.2 m
Speed = 1200 rpm
5. Calculate the maximum torque that can be generated by a motor given the following information. Show all calculations.
Round off to the nearest 0.1 N-m.
Speed = 1140 rpm
Pout = 0.25 kW
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will convert motor power values from U.S. Customary to S.I. units, and from S.I. to U.S.
Customary units. This is a common task you will do if you work with products made throughout the world.
1. Convert the S.I. power value from step 2 of skill 1 to PHp. The conversion formula is as follows:
PkW = PHp × 0.746
PHp = ________________________________________________________________________________________
(Hp)
It should be approximately 0.239 Hp.
2. Convert the PHp value from step 3 of skill 1 to kW.
PkW = _______________________________________________________________________________________
(kW)
The output power in kW is 124.28 kW.
3. Convert the PkW value from step 4 of skill 1 to PHp.
PHp = ________________________________________________________________________________________
(Hp)
4. Convert the PkW values in the table below to PHp.
TO LOAD
SPEED =
MOTOR 1750 rpm
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will calculate the efficiencies of a number of motors based on the given information about
each motor.
1. Perform the following substeps to calculate the efficiency of the motor in figure 3-1 given the following information.
Applied Voltage = 120 VDC
Armature Current (I) = 10.7 A
Horsepower = 0.5 Hp
IA = 10.7A
120V MOTOR
OUTPUT
POWER
Ein I in
Pin
1000
Pout
Eff . 100
Pin
Eff. = ___________________________________________________________________________________ %
The efficiency should be 29.05%.
As you can see, this motor is not very efficient. In fact, most DC motors are not very efficient. You will learn more
about this later in this LAP.
2. Calculate the efficiency of the motor in figure 3-2. Show all calculations.
NOTE
If you already know the horsepower rating of a motor, the formula for calculating the output power in kilowatts is
PkW = PHp × 0.746.
Efficiency = ________________________________________________________________________________ %
IA = 8.9A
240V MOTOR
1/4 Hp
The input power should be 2.136 kW. The output power should be 0.187 kW. The efficiency of the motor should be
approximately 8.73%.
3. Calculate the efficiency of a motor given the following information. Show all calculations.
Motor Configuration - DC Shunt
Applied Voltage = 120 VDC
Armature Current = 7.2 A
Power Rating = 3/4 Hp
Efficiency = ________________________________________________________________________________ %
4. Determine the power of a motor given the following information about the motor. Calculate both the U.S. Customary
and S.I. power rating. Show all calculations.
Motor Efficiency = 25%
Applied Voltage = 240 VDC
Armature Current = 5.2 A
HINT
What percentage of the input power is not used? This will help you determine what power was lost.
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will measure the speed, input current, and voltage at different load levels for the three DC
motor configurations and record each motor’s performance data. You will then use the measurements to calculate
the output power and efficiency.
1. Perform a tagout.
2. Perform the following substeps to perform a motor safety check.
NOTE
If you are unsure about any of these questions, tell your instructor and review the safety rules. Do not proceed any
further.
6. Perform the following substeps to prepare to measure the voltage and current.
A. Locate a multimeter.
B. Attach the multimeter red (V) lead to the (+) jack of the 120 VDC power supply on the workstation front panel.
C. Attach the black (COM) lead to the (-) jack of the 120 VDC power supply on the workstation front panel.
D. Set the multimeter function switch to measure 120VDC or higher.
E. Locate an AC/DC clamp meter.
F. Set the range/function switch to the appropriate setting (DC Amps).
G. Press the meter’s Zero button to calibrate the meter.
H. Open the ammeter jaws.
I. Fully enclose the (+) Lead Wire running from the variable 120 VDC power supply jack on the workstation front
panel to the motor connection post S1.
7. Connect the motor in the series configuration, as shown in figure 4-1.
You are now ready to operate the DC series motor.
PICTORIAL DIAGRAM
50
40 AXI MUM OU 60
OF M
S2 A2 F2 C2 CE
NT
AGE
TPU
T
VO
LT
R
PE
AG
30
EMERGENCY
70
E
STOP
50
40 60
80
20
30 70
20 80
90
10
10 90
0 100
0 100
FIELD
ADJUST
S1 A1 F1 C1 V L1 L2 L3
GND
N N
45033
VDC
Hz
~V V
200A 40A
~ ~
200A
40A
MA
ZERO
HOLD
X/M
IN
ON
OFF
EXTE
0
AC/
DC
INSTR
Min
10
CH UMEN
i Cla
TS
mp
20
Met
er
30
3809
40
41
Hz
V
MAX
COM
600
V
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM
SERIES
WINDING C1 C2
S1 S2 INTERPOLE A1 A2
AC/DC MULTIMETER
A AMMETER COMMUTATOR
CLAMP METER V
Figure 4-1. Pictorial and Schematic Diagram for DC Series Motor Connections
8. Perform the following substeps to prepare the motor shaft for the use of the photo tachometer.
A. Cut a strip of reflective tape 1/16-inch wide and approximately one inch long.
B. Wrap electrical tap around the exposed portion of the motor shaft (between the brake drum and the motor housing).
C. Peel off the backing material from the reflective tape strip and place it on the motor shaft where the black tape is
located.
9. Notify your instructor that you are ready to operate the motor.
The instructor must check your setup and reset the emergency stop pushbutton before you can proceed.
10. Perform the following substeps to operate the DC series motor.
A. Make sure the voltage control knob is turned fully counterclockwise (0%).
B. Remove the tagout.
C. Turn on the Main Power circuit breaker.
D. Slowly turn the voltage control knob clockwise to 50%.
E. Set the prony brake load to 4 ounces using the wingnut.
11. Perform the following substeps to measure and record the performance characteristics of the motor.
A. Measure the speed of the motor with a four-ounce load using the photo tachometer. Record the reading in the
appropriate space in the following Measured Motor Characteristics table.
CAUTION
Remember to check the water in the brake drum frequently and add water as needed. Do not let the brake drum
run dry.
DC SERIES MOTOR
MEASURED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
INPUT VOLTAGE
(volts)
INPUT CURRENT
(amps)
SHAFT SPEED
(rpm)
B. Record the DC voltage reading from the multimeter in the appropriate space in the table.
C. Record the DC amp reading from the AC/DC clamp meter in the appropriate space in the table.
D. Repeat substeps A-C for each load setting in the table.
Remember, to increase the load, turn the wingnut on top of the prony brake clockwise. Watch the scale to determine
the correct load setting.
NOTE
When the load is near 24 ounces, the brake drum may start to squeal. Don’t panic, this is okay.
CAUTION
Remember to periodically check the brake drum and add water when needed.
NOTE
1 oz. = 0.28 N
1 in. = 0.025 m
DC SERIES MOTOR
CALCULATED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
TORQUE / / / / / / / / / /
(in-oz/N-m)
INPUT POWER
(kW)
MOTOR POWER / / / / / / / / / /
(Hp/kW)
EFFICIENCY
(%)
16. Perform the following substeps to calculate the input power for each load setting.
This is necessary in order to calculate efficiency.
A. Locate the Input Voltage and Input Current readings for a 4 ounce load in the measured motor performance
characteristics table from step 11.
B. Use these two values to calculate the input power for that load value and enter your calculated answer into the
appropriate column in the Input Power row of the Calculated Motor Characteristics table.
C. Repeat substeps A and B for each of the other load settings.
17. Use the motor output power formula to calculate the power output of the motor for each load setting. Use either U.S.
Customary units or S.I. units. Enter each answer in the appropriate column in the Motor Power row of the Calculated
Motor Characteristics table.
(T S ) (T S )
Pout Pout
5252 9549
You will need to use the speed readings from the measured motor performance characteristics table you filled out
earlier and the calculated torque values from the Calculated Motor Characteristics table.
18. Use the efficiency formula to calculate the efficiency of the motor for each load setting. Enter each answer in the
appropriate column in the Efficiency row of the calculated motor performance characteristics table.
EFFICIENCY FORMULA
P
Eff . out 100
Pin
19. Connect the motor in the self-excited shunt configuration, as shown in figure 4-2.
PICTORIAL DIAGRAM
50
40 AXI MUM OU 60
OF M
S2 A2 F2 C2 CE
NT
AGE
TPU
T
VO
LT
R
PE
AG
30
EMERGENCY
70
E
STOP
50
40 60
80
20
30 70
20 80
90
10
10 90
0 100
0 100
FIELD
ADJUST
S1 A1 F1 C1 V L1 L2 L3
GND
45033
VDC
Hz
~V V
200A 40A
~ ~
200A
40A
MA
ZERO
HOLD
X/M
IN
ON
OFF
EXTE
0
AC/
DC
INSTR
Min
10
CH UMEN
i Cla
TS
mp
20
Met
er
30
3809
40
Hz
41
V
MAX
COM
600
V
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM
C1 C2
INTERPOLE A1 A2
COMMUTATOR
SHUNT WINDING
F1 F2
A
+ -
V
Figure 4-2. Pictorial and Schematic Diagram for a Self-Excited DC Shunt Motor
20. Repeat steps 9-18 to collect and calculate performance data for the shunt configured DC motor.
Enter your data in the following two tables.
DC SHUNT MOTOR
MEASURED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
INPUT VOLTAGE
(volts)
INPUT CURRENT
(amps)
SHAFT SPEED
(rpm)
DC SHUNT MOTOR
CALCULATED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
TORQUE / / / / / / / / / /
(in-oz/N-m)
INPUT POWER
(kW)
MOTOR POWER / / / / / / / / / /
(Hp/kW)
EFFICIENCY
(%)
21. Connect the motor in the cumulative compound configuration, as shown in figure 4-3.
PICTORIAL DIAGRAM
50
40 AXI MUM OU 60
OF M
S2 A2 F2 C2 CE
NT
AGE
TPU
T
VO
LT
R
PE
AG
30
EMERGENCY
70
E
STOP
50
40 60
80
20
30 70
20 80
90
10
10 90
0 100
0 100
FIELD
ADJUST
S1 A1 F1 C1 V L1 L2 L3
GND
45033
VDC
Hz
~V V
200A 40A
~ ~
200A
40A
MA
ZERO
HOLD
X/M
IN
ON
OFF
EXTE
0
AC/
DC
INSTR
Min
10
CH UMEN
i Cla
TS
mp
20
Met
er
30
3809
40
Hz
41
V
MAX
COM
600
V
SCHEMATIC DIAGRAM
SERIES
WINDING C1 C2
S1 S2 INTERPOLE A1 A2
COMMUTATOR
SHUNT WINDING
F1 F2
A
+ -
V
Figure 4-3. Pictorial and Schematic Diagram for a Cumulative Compound DC Motor
22. Repeat steps 9-18 to collect performance data for the compound configured DC motor.
Enter your data in the following two tables.
DC COMPOUND MOTOR
MEASURED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
INPUT VOLTAGE
(volts)
INPUT CURRENT
(amps)
SHAFT SPEED
(rpm)
DC COMPOUND MOTOR
CALCULATED MOTOR CHARACTERISTICS TABLE
LOAD (oz.) 4 8 12 16 20 24 28 32 36 40
TORQUE / / / / / / / / / /
(in-oz/N-m)
INPUT POWER
(kW)
MOTOR POWER / / / / / / / / / /
(Hp/kW)
EFFICIENCY
(%)
CAUTION
If the motor is too heavy for you, get someone to help you move it.
In the next segment you will analyze the data that you have created. Proceed to the Self Review.
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will use the data you collected earlier to plot the torque vs. speed curves for the three DC
motor configurations. You will then analyze and compare the curves.
1. Perform the following substeps to plot the torque vs. speed curves for the three DC motor configurations.
A. Plot the torque vs. speed for the DC series motor using either U.S. Customary and S.I. units.
Use the graph provided on the data sheet. You should have 10 points on the graphs, each corresponding to a
torque and speed value for a given load setting.
B. Repeat substep A to plot the torque vs. speed curves for the DC shunt and compound configurations.
Use the same graph.
2. Compare the curves and determine which of the configurations offers the best speed regulation.
TORQUE VS SPEED
240/1.695
220/1.550
200/1.412
TORQUE (in-oz / N-m)
180/1.271
160/1.130
140/.989
120/.847
100/.706
80/.565
60/.424
40/.282
20/.141
0
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900
SPEED (rpm)
NOTE
Speed regulation refers to the motor’s ability to maintain speed as the load increases.
3. Compare the three curves that you just plotted with the three theoretical curves of figure 5-1 and determine which of
the theoretical curves most closely matches the shape of the one you plotted.
Curves that match ________________________________________________________ (Series/Shunt/Compound)
The series curves should match fairly closely in shape. The curves in figure 5-1 are for a wide range of torque and
speed measurements. For this particular motor, the rated full-load speed is 1750 rpm. For the series configuration,
you were actually close to the range of the curve in figure 5-1.
500
450
400
% RATED FULL LOAD TORQUE
350
300
COMPOUND
250
200
SERIES
150
100 SHUNT
Figure 5-1. Typical Torque vs. Speed Curves for the DC Motor Configurations
The shunt and compound configuration curves, however, do not resemble the theoretical curves of figure 5-1. This is
because you did not plot enough points to create the entire curves for these configurations. This means that you are
only looking at a small segment of the overall curves. Figure 5-2 shows the section of the overall curve that you have
plotted for the shunt configured motor.
500
400
% RATED FULL LOAD TORQUE
200
100
Figure 5-2. Narrow Range Plotted for the Shunt Configured Motor
Figure 5-3 shows the section of the overall curve for the compound configured motor that you have plotted.
500
400
% RATED FULL LOAD TORQUE
RANGE PLOTTED
FOR COMPOUND
CONFIGURATION
300
200
100
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will use the data that you collected earlier to plot the efficiency vs. power curves for the DC
motor configurations. You will then analyze and compare the curves.
1. Perform the following substeps to plot the efficiency vs. power curves for the three motor configurations.
A. Plot the efficiency vs. power of the DC series motor.
Use either U.S. Customary or S.I. units on the graphs provided on the data sheet. You should have 10 points on the
graphs, each corresponding to a torque and speed value for a given load setting.
100
90
80
70
EFFICIENCY (%)
60
50
40
30
20
10
0 0.033 0.066 0.099 0.132 0.165 0.198 0.231 0.264 0.297 0.330
0.025 0.049 0.074 0.098 0.123 0.148 0.172 0.197 0.222 0.250
POWER (Hp/KW)
B. Repeat substep A to plot the efficiency vs. power curves for the DC shunt and compound configurations on the
same graph.
C. Compare the curves of the three configurations and determine which motor appears to be able to maintain its
efficiency as the output power increases.
100
90
80
70
EFFICIENCY (%)
60
50
BREAKDOWN
TORQUE
40 POINT
30
20
10
0 0.033 0.066 0.099 0.132 0.165 0.198 0.231 0.264 0.297 0.330
0.025 0.049 0.074 0.098 0.123 0.148 0.172 0.197 0.222 0.250
POWER (Hp/KW)
As you can see, the series configured motor will reach breakdown torque much earlier than the other configurations.
This adds yet another limitation to the applications of a DC series motor.
For example, you would not want to use a series motor to drive an elevator, when the speed must be constant even
if the load is increased.
PROCEDURE OVERVIEW
In this procedure, you will analyze the characteristics you charted in the previous activities to help you select a DC
motor for an application.
1. Determine which type of DC motor would best satisfy this application for a wood lathe, like the one in figure 7-1. Use
the graphs you created in the previous skills and the following information.
NOTE
You may have to refer to several different graphs in order to make your selection.
____________________________________________________________________________________________
2. Select the best DC motor for the following crane application using the graphs you created earlier.
Device the motor is to drive: Crane
Device drive requirements: 120 VDC
1/3 Hp
High starting torque
Speed control not important
Full-load current - 2.5 A
____________________________________________________________________________________________
CABLE
REEL
AND
MOTOR ARM
LIFT
CYLINDER HOOK
SUPPORT
COLUMN
CONTROLS
BASE
BASE MOTOR
3. Select the best DC motor for the following conveyor application using the graphs you created earlier.
Device the motor is to drive: Conveyor
Device Drive requirements: 120 VDC
1/3 Hp
Moderate starting torque
Fair speed control
Full-load current - 2.75 A
____________________________________________________________________________________________
CONVEYOR
MOTOR
NOTE
Most motor manufacturers have already tested their motors as you did in the previous activities. The manufacturers
usually include their findings in the specifications for the motor.