Chapter 4
Chapter 4
Chapter 4
Learning Objectives
▪ By the end of this chapter, you will be able to do the
following:
▪ .
Chapter 4. Recruitment and Selection
4.1 Recruitment
4.1.1 Recruitment Defined
4.1.2 Recruiting Sources/ Methods
4.1.3 The Recruitment Process
4.1.4 Flexible Staffing as Recruiting
4.1.5 Recruiting Evaluation
4.2 Staff Selection
4.2.1 Selection Defined
4.2.2 Selection Process
4.2.3 Placement and Orientation
Recruitment
▪ the process of generating a pool of qualified candidates for a
particular position.
▪ the process of searching for prospective employees and
stimulating and encouraging them to apply for jobs in an
organization
▪ the art of attracting a pool of applicants from among whom the
most suitable ones may be selected
Recruitment
▪ involves seeking and attracting a pool of people from which
qualified candidates for job vacancies can be chosen
▪ It also involves:
▪ Identifying the sources where the required number and kind of
candidate employees are /will be available.
▪ Using suitable techniques to attract the desirable candidates.
▪ Stimulating as many candidates as possible and be able to attract
large number of candidates.
▪ The higher the number of applicants, the better chance of being getting
qualified employees.
Recruitment
▪ Therefore, recruitment is the process of attracting
individuals
▪ just in time,
▪ in sufficient number and
▪ with appropriate qualifications,
▪ and encouraging them to apply for the jobs
Factors Affecting Recruitment
▪ Internal Factors
▪ Working conditions of the organization
▪ Promotional Opportunities
▪ Salary level, and type and extent of benefits
▪ Other Personnel policies and practices
▪ Image of the organization
▪ Ability and skill of the management to stimulate the
candidates
▪ Quality of the recruitment process.
Effective Recruiting
▪ Internal factors affecting recruiting:
▪ The consistency of the firm’s recruitment efforts with
its strategic goals
▪ The available resources, types of jobs to be recruited
and choice of recruiting methods
▪ Non-recruitment HR issues and policies
▪ Line and staff coordination and cooperation
Factors Affecting Recruitment
▪ External Factors
▪ Personnel policies and practices of other organizations
regarding working conditions, salary scale, benefits,
promotional opportunities, employee relations etc.
▪ Career opportunities in other organization.
▪ Government regulations
▪ Labor market conditions
Effective Recruiting
▪ External factors affecting recruiting:
▪ Looming undersupply of workers
▪ Lessening of the trend in outsourcing of jobs
▪ Increasingly fewer “qualified” candidates
Reasons for Recruitment
▪ Company expansion
▪ When the operation of the organization is
expanding, new jobs are created and additional
employees are required.
▪ Turnover
▪ because of employees leaving the organization,
such as natural attrition, voluntary and
involuntary turnover
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Internal Sources
▪ seeks applicants for positions currently employed workers of
an organization
▪ include present permanent and temporary /causal
employees
▪ Vacant positions in organizations could be filled by those
existing employees through transfers and promotions.
▪ With the exception of entry-level positions, most
organizations try to fill positions with current employees
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Internal Sources
▪ Most large organizations attempt to develop their own
employees for positions beyond the lowest level.
▪ The internal source is one of the best sources of recruitment
if an organization has been effective in recruiting and
selecting employees in the past and has a strong employee
development program.
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Internal Sources
▪ Promotion
▪ is moving an employee from a lower position or job status to a
higher position or job status.
▪ This is done when individuals have the potential and capacity to
carryout the requirement of the higher position and job status.
▪ Transfer
▪ is moving one person from the existing position to another position
with equal status.
Finding Internal Candidates
▪ Job posting
▪ Publicizing an open job to employees (often by literally posting it on
bulletin boards) and listing its attributes.
▪ Rehiring former employees
▪ Advantages:
▪ They are known quantities.
▪ They know the firm and its culture.
▪ Disadvantages:
▪ They may have less-than positive attitudes.
▪ Rehiring may sent the wrong message to current employees about how to get
ahead.
Finding Internal Candidates (cont’d)
▪ Succession planning
▪ The process of ensuring a suitable supply of
successors for current and future senior or key jobs.
▪ Succession planning steps:
▪ Identifying and analyzing key jobs.
▪ Creating and assessing candidates.
▪ Selecting those who will fill the key positions.
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Advantages of internal recruitment
▪ It is a relatively cheap way of recruiting, vacancies can be
advertised at little cost and it can also save time.
▪ Organizations typically have a better knowledge of internal
applicants’ skills, knowledge and abilities.
▪ Inside job candidates have better knowledge of the
organization’s policies, procedures and other special
characteristics and its operation. -orientation and training
▪ have a significant positive effect on employee motivation and
morale when it creates promotion opportunities.
▪ enhances employee commitment and job satisfaction
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Advantages of internal recruitment
▪ The return on investment that an organization has on
its present workforce is increased.
▪ Most organizations have a sizeable investment on their
employees in the form of training and development,
frienge benefits, etc. being able to use this workforce to its
maximum capability improves the organization’s return on
its investment.
Internal Sources of Candidates: Hiring from Within
▪ Advantages
▪ Foreknowledge of candidates’ strengths and
weaknesses
▪ More accurate view of candidate’s skills
▪ Candidates have a stronger commitment to the
company
▪ Increases employee morale
▪ Less training and orientation required
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Disadvantages of internal recruitment
▪ Internal recruiting simply promulgates the old ways
of doing things;
▪ that creative problem solving may be hindered by lack of
new blood or a sort of “managerial inbreeding.”
▪ Inbreeding of ideas can stifle new ideas and innovations.
▪ When an entire management team has been brought up
through the ranks, there may be a tendency to make
decisions “by the book” and to maintain the status quo.
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Disadvantages of internal recruitment
▪ Infighting for promotions can become overly intense and
have a negative effect on the morale and performance of
employees who are not promoted.
▪ An organization can suffer if it uses inferior internal
sources just for the reason of boosting the morale of
current employees (promotion based on seniority)
▪ Failed applicants become discontented
▪ Time wasted interviewing inside candidates who will not
be considered
▪ Inbreeding of the status quo
Sources of Recruitment
▪ External Sources
▪ lie outside the organization.
▪ External recruiting is attracting applicants from various
outside organizations.
▪ It is needed in organizations that are growing rapidly or have
a large demand for technical, skilled, or managerial
employees.
▪ External sources provide large pool of candidates.
Sources of Recruitment
▪ External Sources
▪ Employers require external sources:
▪To fill entry-level jobs (jobs for the beginners).
▪To acquire skills not possessed by current
employees.
▪To obtain employees with different background, to
provide new ideas.
Sources of Recruitment
▪ External Sources
▪ Sources of external recruitment include:
▪Schools, colleges and Universities
▪The unemployed
▪Competitors and other organizations
▪Private and public employment agencies
▪Professional Associations
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Advantage of external recruitment
▪ Large number of applicants (a pool of talent is much larger
than the internal sources).
▪ It is often cheaper and easier (low training cost) to hire
technical, skilled, or managerial people from the outside
rather than training and developing them internally.
▪ Can bring new ideas (insights and perspectives) to
organization
▪ Expand external relation of an organization.
▪ Avoid internal promotion polities
Sources of Recruitment
▪ Disadvantage of external recruitment
▪ Attracting, contacting and evaluating potential employees
can be more difficult and can be very costly.
▪ This is especially true for higher-level jobs.
▪ Employees hired from the outside need a longer adjustment
or orientation period.
▪ As a result, it might take a significant time before they can perform
with their full potential.
▪ It can be one reason for the reduction of morale of internal
employees who feel qualified to do the job.
Recruitment Methods
▪ Internal Methods
▪ Job Posting and Bidding
▪Job posting and bidding is an internal method of
recruitment in which notices of vacant positions are
posted in central locations throughout the
organization and existing employees are given a
specified length of time to apply for the available
positions.
Recruitment Methods
▪ Internal Methods
▪ Job Posting
▪ mean posting notices of job openings on organization bulletin
boards for recruiting possible internal candidates.
▪ is a process where announcements of positions are made available
to all current employees through organization newsletters, bulletin
boards, and so on.
▪ The job notice specifies the job title, pay scale, and minimum
qualifications.
▪ It is a procedure for informing the employees that a job opening
exists.
Recruitment Methods
▪ Internal Methods
▪ Job Posting
▪Accordingly, interested employees could apply for
the vacant job.
▪Some organizations develop policies for job posting
to be successful
Recruitment Methods
▪ Internal Methods
▪ Job Posting
▪ They may include:
▪ Both promotions and transfers should be posted.
▪ Job vacancies should be posted for a specific period of time
before going to external sources.
▪ Eligibility rules for the job posting system need to be developed
and communicated to the employees.
▪ Specific standards for selection should be included in the
notice.
Recruitment Methods
▪ Internal Methods
▪ Job bidders
▪ should be required to list their qualifications and reasons
for requesting a transfer or promotion.
▪ Unsuccessful bidders should be notified by the human
resource department and advised as to why they were not
accepted.
▪ In unionized organizations, job posting and bidding
procedures are usually spelled out in the collective
agreement.
Recruitment Methods
▪ External Method
▪ Job Advertisement
▪ It is a widely used recruitment method in order to reach relatively large
number of potential applicants.
▪ Advertisements are commonly placed in daily newspapers, trade and
professional newspapers, and occasionally on radio, TV and billboards.
▪ However, the choice of appropriate media for a specific advertisement
should depend on the type of job and the required degree of coverage.
▪ In addition to the media used, the construction of the advertisement is
also important.
Outside Sources of Candidates
▪ Advertising
▪ The Media: selection of the best medium depends on the positions
for which the firm is recruiting.
▪ Newspapers (local and specific labor markets)
▪ Trade and professional journals
▪ Internet job sites
▪ Marketing programs
▪ Constructing an effective ad
▪ Wording related to job interest factors should evoke the applicant’s
attention, interest, desire, and action (AIDA) and create a positive
impression of the firm.
Recruitment Methods
▪ External Method
▪ Job Advertisement
▪ Attract attention:
▪ Using wider boarders or a lot of empty space around it, might help the
advertisement to standout by itself.
▪ Develop or create interest in the job
▪ Create desire:
▪ amplifying on the interest factors and other factors that may be part of the
job (job satisfaction, career development, etc…)
▪ Instigate action:
▪ adding phrases such as “Call today”, Write today for more information”,
etc could make potential applicants take action towards applying.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Newspapers
▪ Advantages
▪ Short deadlines
▪ Ad size flexibility
▪ Circulation concentrated in specific geographic area
▪ Classified sections are well organized for easy access by
active job seekers.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Newspapers
▪ Disadvantage
▪ Easy for prospects to ignore.
▪ Considerable competitive clutter.
▪ Circulation not specialized.
▪ Poor printing quality
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Newspapers
▪When to use
▪When sufficient number of prospects are clustered
in a specific area.
▪When a recruiter want to limit recruiting to a
specific area.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Magazines
▪ Advantage
▪ Specialized magazines reach pinpointed occupation
categories.
▪ Ad size flexibility
▪ High quality printing.
▪ Long life, prospects keep and reread magazines.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Magazines
▪ Disadvantage
▪Wide geographic area- usually cannot be used to
limit recruiting to the specific area.
▪Long lead time for ad placement.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Magazines
▪ When to use
▪When job is specialized.
▪When time and geographical limitations are not of
utmost importance.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Radio and TV
▪ Advantage
▪ Can reach prospects that are not actively looking for a job
better than printed ads.
▪ Can be limited to specific geographic areas.
▪ Creatively flexible.
▪ Can dramatize employment story more effectively than printed
ads.
▪ Little competitive recruitment clutter.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Radio and TV
▪ Disadvantage
▪Lack of permanence; prospects cannot refer back to
the ad
▪Creation and production of commercials-
particularly TV- can be time consuming and costly.
External Method
▪ Type of Media for Job Advertisement
▪ Radio and TV
▪When to use
▪In competitive situations when not enough
prospects are reading printed ads.
▪When there are multiple job openings.
▪Useful to call attention to printed ads.
External Method
▪ College Recruiting:
▪ It involves recruitment from educational institutions that offer
opportunities to recruit recent graduates.
▪ Educational institutions are particularly excellent sources of
potential employees for entry-level positions.
▪ It could be also important sources of professional and technical
employees.
▪ This method includes campus interviews and keeping a live
register of job seekers.
▪ Under this method, information about jobs and profile of
persons available for jobs exchanged and preliminary screening
is done.
External Method
▪ Employment Agencies
▪ are used by many organizations for identifying potential
workers.
▪ There could be public or private employment agencies.
▪ Those agencies have information on job seekers in terms of
qualifications, skills, interests, etc and can be good sources
of employment by organizations.
▪ The major functions of these agencies are to increase the
pool of possible applicants and to do preliminary screening.
External Method
▪ Employment Agencies
▪ To utilize these agencies effectively and efficiently,
organizations are advised to:
▪ Give the agency an accurate and complete job description
and specification.
▪ Specify the devices or tools that the agency should use in
screening potential applicants.
▪ If possible, create a long-term relationship with one or more
agencies.
External Method
▪ Employment Agencies
▪ Organizations specifically use employment agencies when;
▪ They do not have their own human resource department,
▪ They want to fill a particular position openings quickly,
▪ They need to attract a greater number of minority and
female job candidates, or
▪ They attempting to recruit individuals who are not actively
seeking employment.
External Method
▪ Types of employment agencies:
▪ Public agencies operated by federal, state, or local
governments
▪ Agencies associated with nonprofit organizations
▪ Privately owned agencies
External Method
▪ Reasons for using a private employment agency:
▪ When a firm doesn’t have an HR department and is not geared to doing
recruiting and screening.
▪ The firm has found it difficult in the past to generate a pool of qualified
applicants.
▪ The firm must fill a particular opening quickly.
▪ There is a perceived need to attract a greater number of minority or female
applicants.
▪ The firm wants to reach currently employed individuals, who might feel
more comfortable dealing with agencies than with competing companies.
▪ The firm wants to cut down on the time it’s devoting to recruiting.
External Method
▪ Avoiding problems with employment agencies:
▪ Give the agency an accurate and complete job description.
▪ Make sure tests, application blanks, and interviews are part of the agency’s
selection process.
▪ Periodically review data on candidates accepted or rejected by your firm, and by
the agency.
▪ Check on the effectiveness and fairness of the agency’s screening process.
▪ Screen the agency.
▪ Check with other managers or HR people to find out which agencies have been the most
effective at filling the sorts of positions needed to be filled.
▪ Review the Internet and a few back issues of the Sunday classified ads to
discover the agencies that handle the positions to be filled.
Temp Agencies and Alternative Staffing