TB Design
TB Design
17-D-202
NORTH AMERICAN WOOD POLE COUNCIL
TECHNICAL
BULLETIN
Wood Pole
Design
Considerations
Prepared by:
W. Richard Lovelace
Executive Consultant
Hi-Line Engineering
a GDS Company
About NAWPC
The North American Wood Pole Council (NAWPC) is a federation of three organizations representing the wood
preserving industry in the U.S. and Canada. These organizations provide a variety of services to support the use of
preservative-treated wood poles to carry power and communications to consumers.
The three organization are:
Table 1
Physical loads affecting wood poles
Type Load Direction of Force Caused By
Vertical In line with the axis of the Weight of the attached equipment and ice loaded conductors plus
pole or column the vertical component of guy tension
Longitudinal Parallel to the direction or Tension in the wire dependent on the sag and tension values used
run of the line during installation
Transverse Perpendicular to the Wind blowing on the bare or ice laden conductors and pole plus the
direction or run of the line tension produced by line angles
4 lb (Medium
Table 2 12”
& Heavy)
NESC loading districts, conditions
Radial Horizontal 9 lb (Light)
Loading Temperature thickness of ice wind pressure
District (ºF) (in.) (lb/ft.2)
Heavy 0 0.50 4
Conductor
Medium 15 0.25 4
Light 30 0.00 9
Ice (Ir) 0.25” (Medium)
Based on Table 250-1 of the 2017 Edition of the National
Electrical Safety Code 0.50” (Heavy)
Using the equation in Figure 1, transverse wind point of maximum stress. The 2017 NESC refers to
loads can be calculated for any series of conductors. the 2015 edition of ANSI O5.1 for resolution of the
Values for four typical distribution conductors are point of maxium stress along the pole column above
shown in Table 3. grade.
To choose a tangent pole to adequately support In the 2017 NESC, Rule 261A2a, EXCEPTION 1
a set of conductors, the designer must determine allows for non-guyed naturally grown wood poles
the resisting moment of a selected length and class 55-ft. or less in length for the point of maximum
pole. The resisting moment is the amount of force a stress to be evaluated at the ground-line. This
pole can withstand at the point of maximum stress bulletin will address distribution poles 55-ft. and less
before it breaks. in length only.
The resisting moment is calculated based on The fiber strength is dependent upon the tree
the fiber strength of the wood species and the species from which the pole is produced. Table 4
circumference of the pole at the ground-line and shows various tree species and the fiber strength of
the pole top. The pole classes in ANSI O5.1 are each.
determined from the circumference of the pole at the Table 4
ANSI classification point (6-ft. from the butt) and at
the pole top. Wood fiber strength
Species Fiber Strength
Figure 2 Top Southern Pine 8,000 psi
Circumference
Douglas fir 8,000 psi
Red (Norway) Pine 6,600 psi
Ponderosa Pine 6,000 psi
Western Red Cedar 6,000 psi
Northern White Cedar 4,000 psi
Ground-line
Ground-line The resisting moment of a wood pole is calculated
Circumference using the following equations. To fully understand
the process, an example problem will be worked
to develop the natural resisting moment for a 45-ft.
Class 4 Southern Pine pole.
The natural resisting moment (Mrn) is the resisting
moment of the wood pole as it comes from the pole
manufacturing company.
The 2017 NESC requires that wood structures be To develop the allowable construction resisting
designed to withstand the specified loads in Rule moment, the designer must apply strength factors
252 multiplied by the load factors in Table 253-1
without exceeding the permitted stress level at the
Example 3:
Wind span calculation
Calculate the wind span supported by Pole #2 below:
Example 2:
Calculate the natural bending moment due to Figure 4
wind on the pole
Pole 1 Pole 2 Pole 3
Using the following equation, calculate the natural
Span A Span B
bending moment due to wind (Mbn).
Like the natural resisting moment, the natural
bending moment is for the pole as it arrives from
300’ 200’
the pole manufacturer. To develop the allowable
construction bending moment due to wind on the Span A + Span B 300+200 500
pole, the designer must apply load factors from Sw = = = = 250 ft.
NESC Table 253-1 to the natural bending moment. 2 2 2
This will be shown later in Example 4.
To determine the maximum transverse wind
Mbn = Wd
[ (2Ct + Cg)
Kc ] Hp2
span for a given pole length and class with a set
of specified conductors attached to a pole top
assembly, the designer must calculate and sum
Mbn = Natural bending moment due to wind the forces acting on the pole and wire with applied
blowing on the pole (ft-lbs.) NESC strength and load factors.
Wd = NESC loading district horizontal wind per Example 4 will work through the steps needed to
unit area of pole surface (lbs/ft.²) calculate the total transverse load on the pole and
Ct = Circumference of pole at top (in.) wire and from those values, the maximum transverse
Cg = Pole circumference at ground-line (in.) wind span.
Kc = Calculation constant = 72TT Table 6 lists the NESC load factors from NESC
Hp = Height of pole above ground (ft.) Table 253-1 and the strength factors from NESC
Table 261-1. These values will be used to determine
the maximum wind span for the 45’-4 Southern Pine.
Wd = 4 lbs/ft.² (Table 2, Heavy loading,
horizontal wind)
Ct = 21” (ANSI O5.1) Table 6
Cg = 34.8205” (calculated in Example 1) NESC load and strength factors for
Kc = 72TT = 226.19 non-guyed wood poles
Hp = 38.5’ (45’ pole - 6.5’ setting depth) Load Factors Grade B Grade C
Transverse wind at crossing 2.50 2.20
Mbn = 4
[ (2 • 21) + 34.8205
226.19 ] 38.52 = 2,014 ft-lbs. Transverse wind elsewhere
Transverse wire tension
2.50
1.65
1.75
1.30
Longitudinal at dead-ends 1.65 1.30
Strength Factors
Wood poles 0.65 0.85
Tension
Mb = Moment due to wind blowing on the pole
with applied NESC load factor
Mbn = Natural bending moment due to wind =
3,772 ft-lbs.
Fw = NESC load factor, transverse wind
Wind elsewhere, Grade C = 1.75 (Table 6)
Mb = (3,772)(1.75) = 6,601 ft-lbs.
The bending moment due to wind with applied
load factor on the 40’-3 SP pole is 6,601 ft-lbs.
Ground line Step 3:
moment Calculate the moment due to wind blowing on the
conductors.
Wood pole = 40’-3 Southern Pine (SP) set 6-ft. deep Mc = ∑ Wc(Hc)(Fw) = Conductor wind moment
Conductors = (3) 1/0 ACSR 6/1 (Raven) primary with with applied NESC load factor (ft-lbs/ft.)
(1) 1/0 ACSR 6/1 (Raven) neutral Wc = Transverse wind load for 1/0 ACSR,
light loading = 0.2985 lbs/ft. (Table 3)
Wind span = 200-ft.
Hc = Height of conductors above grade.
Line Angle = 4° (see RUS specification C2.21)
Pole top assembly = RUS C2.21 Assume 9-in. or 0.75-ft. for the
NESC construction grade = C height of the pin and insulator assembly
NESC loading district = Light RUS C2.21 framed on a 40-ft. pole set
6-ft. deep.
The problem is to determine if the 40’-3 Southern AØ & CØ = 33.25-ft., BØ = 34.75-ft.,
Pine pole will adequately support the 200’ wind Neutral = 30.5-ft.
span of the above conductors and the 4º line angle Fw = NESC load factor for transverse wind
at NESC Grade C construction with the applied ice elsewhere, Grade C (Table 6) = 1.75
and wind conditions of the light loading district.
The line is not crossing over another utility.
Figure 8
From ANSI 05.1, the 40’-3 Southern Pine pole top
RUS C2.21
circumference equals 23 in. and the circumference
6-ft. from butt equals 36 in. Using the equations
in Example 1 and 2, the natural resisting moment
(Mrn) equals 98,537 ft-lbs. and the natural bending
moment due to wind on the pole (Mbn) for light
loading equals 3,772 ft-lbs.
Step 1:
Calculate the wood pole resisting moment.
Mr = Mrn(Fs)
Mr = Resisting moment with applied NESC
strength factor
Mrn = Natural ultimate resisting moment of a
40’-3 SP pole = 98,537 ft-lbs.
Fs = Strength factor for wood poles at
Grade C (Table 6) = 0.85
Mr = 98,537 (0.85) = 83,756 ft-lbs.
Wood Pole Design Considerations Page 10
Wire Wc (lbs/ft.) Hc (ft.) Fw Mc (ft-lbs/ft.) Step 5:
0.2985 x 33.25 x 1.75 = 17.37 Calculate the ground-line moment.
Aø
Mg = (Mc • Sw) + Mb + Mt
Bø 0.2985 x 34.75 x 1.75 = 18.15
Mg = Ground-line moment
Cø 0.2985 x 33.25 x 1.75 = 17.37 Mc = 68.82 ft-lbs/ft. (Step 3)
Sw = 200’ (Given)
N 0.2985 x 30.50 x 1.75 = 15.93
Mb = 6,601 ft-lbs. (Step 2)
Mc (ft-lbs/ft.) = 68.82 Mt = 26,181 ft-lbs. (Step 4)
The moment due to wind blowing on the Mg = (68.82 • 200) + 6,601 + 26,181 = 46,546 ft-lbs.
conductors is 68.82 ft-lbs/ft. for 1-ft. of each Mg = 46,546 ft-lbs.
conductor tied to the pole top assembly.
Step 6:
Step 4: Compensate for deflection.
Determine the moment due to tension in the A non-guyed line angle pole will deflect under the
conductors Mt. strain of the applied moments. To compensate for
The tension value used in this example is 50% of this deflection, it is recommended that the ground-
the rated tensile strength of 1/0 ACSR 6/1 conductor. line moment (Mg) be increased by a deflection factor
Tensile strength of 1/0 = 4,380 lbs. (Table 3). before evaluating the pole class.
50% = 0.5(4,380) = 2,190 lbs. The deflection factor is chosen by the designer
The designer can choose to use the initial loaded based on his or her experience. Twenty percent
tension value found in the company’s sag and tension will be used for this example. Some designers may
tables such as Sag10. This value may be significantly choose a higher value based on local conditions.
lower than the 50% of rated tensile strength Mg’ = Mg (1.20)
depending on the loading district. Mg’ = 46,546 (1.20) = 55,855 lbs.
Caution: The designer must be confident that the
construction crew is correctly tensioning the wire to Step 7:
the value shown in the sag and tension tables. Evaluate the strength of the 40-ft. Class 3 pole.
Sm =
( ) 1.20
- Mb - Mt than 300 kV can produce lightning flashovers when
lightning strikes near the electric distribution line.
Mc A BIL equal to or greater than 300 kV (dry
flashover) can be achieved on wood poles using
Sm = Maximum wind span standard pole-top assemblies rated for the operating
Mr = Resisting moment = 83,756 ft-lbs. (Step 1) voltage. The wood provides the additional insulation
Mb = Bending moment due to wind on pole = needed to achieve the required BIL.
6,601 ft-lbs. (Step 2) On metal or concrete poles, fiberglass links or
Mc = Moment due to wind on the conductors = higher voltage insulators must be added to standard
68.82 ft-lbs./ft. (Step 3) pole-top assembly hardware to achieve the same
Mt = Moment due to transverse wire tension = BIL as wood poles. The phase conductors, insulators
26,181.44 ft-lbs. (Step 4) and neutral conductor in a three-phase steel or
1.20 = Deflection factor concrete pole distribution line are all connected by a
conductor. In a wood pole distribution line, they are
83,756
Sm =
( 1.20 ) - 6,601 - 26,181
= 538 ft.
connected by a wood insulator.
For areas of high lightning incidence, lightning
arrestors should be installed approximately every
68.82 1,200-ft. along the line and at dead-ends. This will
The 40’-3 non-guyed line angle pole will augment the natural insulation of the wood and
adequately support a 538-ft. maximum wind span for minimize nuisance recloser operations and fuse
the specified design conditions. blowing. This is more important for steel or concrete
poles because of their essentially zero BIL.
Foundation
Raptor Protection
Proper embedment of the non-guyed pole is
extremely important for good construction. Backfill In many areas of the U.S., utilities must provide
the pole hole with good soil and tamp extra hard. raptor protection to comply with federal regulations.
The old rule of two men tamping and one man Wood pole and crossarm construction offers a
shoveling holds true. In poor soils, it may be distinct advantage because of the natural insulating
necessary to backfill the hole with gravel and set the properties of wood.
pole deeper at 10% of its length plus 4-ft. For most raptors, including eagles, electrocution
Deeper setting depths will change the ground-line can be effectively prevented using a 10-ft. wood
circumference and the height above grade of the crossarm mounted 12 to 18 in. below the pole top.
conductors. The ground-line moment must be This will provide the recommended 60-in. spacing
re-calculated and height of the conductors above required for raptor protection.
grade adjusted in the equations for the new values if Steel or concrete poles can act as a grounding
the pole is set deeper in the ground. conductor, thus decreasing the phase to ground
clearance for raptors.
It is recommended that 24-in. fiberglass pole-
top pins, vinyl pole wraps, perch guards and
wood or fiberglass crossarms be installed on steel
or concrete poles to achieve adequate raptor
protection.
As can be seen, standard wood pole crossarm
construction can reduce raptor electrocution without
addition of special assemblies or perch guards.
Wood provides a humane and economic advantage
in protecting raptors.
Disclaimer - The North American Wood Pole Council and its member organizations believe the information contained in this
document to be based on up-to-date scientific and economic information and is intended for general informational purposes. In
furnishing this information, NAWPC and GDS Associates DBA Hi-Line Engineering make no warranty or representation, either
expressed or implied, as to the reliability or accuracy of such information; nor does NAWPC and GDS Associates DBA Hi-Line
Engineering assume any liability resulting from use of or reliance upon the information by any party. This document should not
be construed as a specific endorsement or warranty, direct or implied, of treated wood products or preservatives, in terms of
performance, environmental impact or safety. The information contained herein should not be construed as a recommendation to
violate any federal, provincial, state or municipal law, rule or regulation, and any party using or producing pressure treated wood
products should review all such laws, rules or regulations prior to using or producing preservative treated wood products.
NAWPC 17-D-202
© 2017 North American Wood Pole Council 07-2019