Learning Guide#1
Learning Guide#1
Name of Institution
November/2013
Addis Ababa
LEARNING GUIDE # 2
Learning Instructions:
1. Read the specific This learning guide is developed to provide you the
necessary information regarding the following content coverage and topics:
2.1. Knowledge of national regulations and structure of CRVS system
2.2. Method of formulating organizational structures and delivery
system principles
2.3. Techniques of designing service development programs
2.4. Concept of millennium development goals
2.5. Concept of equity issues in civil registration
INTRODUCTION
The organization of the civil registration administration may be centralized or
decentralized. A centralized system is one where the network of local registration
offices is directly controlled and administered by a central authority or an agency
in the national government. A decentralized registration system is one in which the
local registration offices are supervised or administered by some authority at a sub
national level such as a district, region, state or province. In these instances, there
is no national office to oversee the local registration operations. However, there
may be a national agency for the coordination of the registration system and/or for
establishing national standards such as uniform registration laws, definitions of
vital events, registration practices, etc. In this region, there is at least one country,
Malawi, with a national registration office which coordinates but does not
supervise or direct the District Commissioners responsible for civil registration.
This office also maintains a file of individual birth and death records. In addition to
Malawi, there are 3 countries, Central African Republic, Somalia, and Swaziland
with no civil registration authority in the central government. The Central African
Republic was anticipating, at the time of the survey, the creation of a national
center for civil registration. In some countries, there appears to be a dual system of
registration. For example, in Ethiopia the Ministry of Interior is responsible for the
registration of births and deaths in the rural areas, whereas the Ministry of Housing
and Urban Development registers the vital events occurring in the urban areas in
the past regime.
Hence the above highlight lies a backdrop for this learning guide to give detail on.
Knowledge of national regulations and structure of CRVS system, Method of
formulating organizational structures and delivery system principles, Techniques
of designing service development programs, of millennium development goals,
Concept of equity issues in civil registration.
2.1 Knowledge of national regulations and structure of
CRVS system
The first conference of African Ministers responsible for Civil Registration was
held in Addis Ababa in August 2010. During the meeting, one of the
recommendations that the ministers reached into consensus was that countries
should develop comprehensive legal frameworks for civil registration system, with
associated strategies to derive vital statistics from the registers.
Ethiopian civil code of 1960 contains more than 100 Articles that have not been
enforced over the past 52 years. The government of the Federal Democratic
Republic of Ethiopia by giving due consideration to the concern has incorporated a
plan to set up a framework for Civil Registration and National ID implementation
across the country under the five years Growth and Transformation Plan (2010/11-
2014/15). Accordingly, the initiative has been started to setup a Civil Registration
legal framework. However, the enactment of the Civil Registration law delayed
with a view to consolidate it with the National ID legislation, which was presented
to the government separately. To maximize the implementation and interfacing of
the two systems, the new concept of National ID could be cited as the main
challenge for the delay of the legislation due to lack of experience how to merge
the two systems. Finally, after a thorough discussion with stakeholders at various
levels, the House of People’s Representatives enacted the Proclamation on the
Registration of Vital Events and National Identity Card on the 7th of July 2012.
This proclamation enables the country to establish two separate institutions
(Federal Civil Registration organ which is responsible for the ministry of
Justice and the National Identity Card Issuing Organ which responsible for
the ministry of Interior) for the purpose of implementing the vital events
registration and the national identity card. These two institutions that sought to be
established are obliged under the law to work closely in particular with exchange
of data which are relevant to them.
Civil Registration is to be established with the objectives of among others serving,
ensuring and safeguarding the basic human rights of the people, improving the
efficiency and fairness of the justice system, facilitating the health, education and
other social services to the public. Provision7 of Vital Statistics could be
implemented based on the UN recommendations and guidelines. Vital
Statistics, using Vital Registration as a source, is a prerequisite to socioeconomic
planning. It is essential to estimate the yearly changes in population size and
structure, to understand the dynamics of population, to get population projection
inputs, to monitor and assess the health status of a population, and to conduct in
depth epidemiological studies.
Based on these objectives, the new “Civil Registration and National Identity” law
contains the following important contents:
It has given clear definitions of “Vital Events”
Identified organs (at the national and regional level) and periods for the
registration of vital events (including late registration)
Identified the particulars of the registration of Births (including abandoned
births),
Marriage, Divorce, Death (including cause of death)
Identified the mechanisms which the transfer of copies of the records of vital
events to the Statistical Agency of the country and the length of time required to
transfer
Certification of the registration of vital events to concerned individuals
Registration for National Identity Card and the information needed for the
registration
The validity times and renewal of the national ID
Obligations of the holder of the national ID
Henceforth, Regulations are being drafted for the full implementation of the law
and establishment of the two institutions.
Centralized System
In a centralized system, there are two options which may relate to the
administration of a civil registration program and vital statistics system. One is
where the responsibilities for both activities rests within a single organization such
as the National Statistics Office, or in the Ministry of Health, Interior, or Home
Affairs. The other is where the two functions are separate, with civil registration
under the responsibility of one agency and the vital statistics system under another
agency. Given these different administrative structures, the registration
system will have varying responsibilities and functions
MINSTRY A
CR OFFICE CV OFFICE
Municipality
District
Region
Figure 1. Single Agency for Civil Registration and Vital Statistics
Figure 1 represents a civil registration system where the registration and vital
statistics responsibilities are placed in a single administrative organization. This
system integrates the two functions, CR and VS, which are closely linked together
since vital statistics are developed from the item content of the civil registration
forms - birth, death, fetal death and, where applicable, marriage and divorce events
Data collection and processing mechanisms performed for registration activities
and subsequently for the preparation of vital statistics can be effectively
maintained within a single organization. The capability here is that required
modifications throughout the registration system which can affect vital statistics
can be conducted within the organizational unit. This eliminates the
need to resolve potential inter-agency differences regarding the program, and
allows close intra-agency collaboration with appropriate registration unit activities.
This can also improve timing for incorporating effective changes in both systems,
and effectively maintains an interactive role for both aspects of the systems.
Record flow from the local registration offices may be directed through district and
regional sites prior to receipt at the national office. Copies of the documents
completed for each vital event for legal registration purposes may be retained at
each level in order to provide appropriate services to the population.
The vital statistics derived from these forms are prepared at the national office and
generally distributed to the various levels of government and other sources. As
district and regional offices develop capacity to prepare vital statistics data locally,
these units can then abstract data from the registration forms as the forms pass
through their offices on to the national office. The transmission of the registration
forms through the local units allows them to access the data for local use.
In the centralized system all administrative and technical direction comes from the
central office It is essential that strong lines of communication are in place in both
directions - to and from the central office and local units This assures that
knowledge from both sources are utilized in effectively managing and operating
the system. Committees may be established with representation from both local
and national programs and organizations. These may include maternal and
child health programs, family planning, and social services. In this way, the
various needs and issues in these areas can be considered as part of the
administration and operation of the registration program.. Although a centralized
system has many merits, one demerit of centralization is the inherent delays in
field operations as authorization is awaited from the head office. Such delays may
not only result in delayed action but occasionally may mean no action at all with
various negatively impacting consequences.
CENTRALIZED CIVIL REGISTRATION AND
VITAL STATISTICS SYSTEMS -- NATIONAL LEVEL,
MULTIPLE AGENCY SYSTEMS
MINISTRY Y
MINISTRY X VS OFFICEs
CR OFFICE
VS OFFICE
Local CR office
Figure 2.Separate Agencies for Civil Registration and Vital Statistics
Decentralized System
Several organizational options exist for civil registration and vital statistics
programs within a decentralized administrative structure This may include a
structure where the national government has oversight as to the legal requirements
for registration activities and for the preparation and distribution of national vital
statistics information. Sub-national administrative units such as State or Provincial
governments have the primary responsibilities for data collection, operation and
maintenance of the systems, Another configuration is where the state or provincial
government has total responsibility for civil registration and vital statistics,
independent of the national government In this type of organizational structure,
arrangements are made by the individual states or provinces with the national
government to provide appropriate data and information. DECENTRALIZED
CIVIL
REGISTRATION AND
VITAL STATISTICS SYSTEMS -- SINGLE AGENCY
AT THE STATE OR PROVINCE LEVEL
PROFESSIONAL
CR -- vs +O-------...jORGANIZATION4
PROFESSIONAL
NATIONAL VS OFFICE
CV—VS
ORGANIZATION
STATE/PROVINCE
STATE/PROVICE STATE/PROVINCE
MINSTRY A
MINSTRY A MINSTRY A
Municipality Municipality Municipality
District
Region
Figure 3
Sub national Single-Level Administration
In the decentralized structure where the national government has general oversight
and specified legal requirements, and the conduct of operations and maintenance
activities for civil registration and vital statistics rests with the state or provincial
government, the registration of vital events is directed and administered by the
state/province office Subsidiary units me established at various locations and
within various agencies across the geographic area of the state/province. Generally,
however, all of the legal registration functions and record processing activities are
conducted at the state/province level. A head civil registration office within each
directs and administers the system.
Within this type of decentralized structure, the national office should initiate a
program such as a national/state committee or, affiliation with a national
professional association related to registration and vital statistics activities to
coordinate the various state or province government programs. This would serve to
assure standards are met and consistency in data and information designed for
national vital statistics and civil registration use is maintained, The committee
should meet periodically, perhaps annually, to address any issues which arise
at the local levels, to obtain updated information as to changes or developments at
the national level, and to maintain an interactive relationship with the other
state/province programs.
A decentralized program within a country has certain advantages and
disadvantages as was noted under the centralized systems described above From an
individual state or province perspective, one advantage is that decentralization 1)
permits the inclusion of data into their registration data collection system
that is relevant to their area; 2) addresses legal issues which may be unique to their
particular population; and, 3) allows management and operational control
appropriate to their own governmental structure The legal aspects of the
system, if consistent with national requirements. may provide certain benefits in
meeting national government needs, Such support can serve both the local and
national programs, while the local government still maintains the system necessary
to meet their own needs. There can be disadvantages to this structure as well As
noted above, the lack of coordination and cooperation of the various decentralized
single sub national programs within a country can lead to inconsistent patterns of
1) data collection, 2) registration processes including recording of nonresident
events and, 3) the distribution of such records to other states' programs. The
inclusion of events in the national vital statistics program also requires that each
state/province must maintain acceptable levels of completeness, accuracy and
reliability of their data, implying that some degree of standards must be
implemented. This may be difficult to assess given a large number of independent
programs within a decentralized system.
DECENTRALIZED CIVIL REGISTRATION AND VITAL STATISTICS
SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE LEVEL ADMINISTRATION
(STATE OR PROVINCE = S/P)
PROFESSIONAL
CR—VS
NATIONAL VS
ORGANIZATION
OFFICE
Municipali
ty
Municipality
District
District
Region Region
Program resources
Here you’ll identify the resources you will need to run your program. Resources
here are broadly defined and may include things like finances, staff, settings,
volunteers, equipment, supplies and contracted services. You also may need to
consider any constraints that may limit or circumscribe your program such as
ethical issues, laws, regulations and funding requirements.
Program activities
You’ll then want to describe program activities. These are the things you do, the
services you offer or the links you make to services for students and their families.
For example, you may conduct tutoring sessions, provide recreation opportunities,
conduct home visits, provide in-service training about educational enrichment to
teachers, etc. It is important to understand the above four steps and components are
the ingredients of your program – they form the basis of your daily actions and
activities. The next four components help you define your program account
abilities. They will help you know if you did what you intended to do and if you
reached your intended results:
Program outputs
Outputs are the direct products of service activities and are usually measured as
volumes. These measures are sometimes referred to as process measures and might
include things like the number of tutoring sessions you provided, the number of
recreation opportunities provided, the number of home
visits conducted, the number of in-service training sessions to teachers provided,
etc.
Program outcomes
Immediate outcomes are those produced closest to the service. They may include
student or parent gains in knowledge, changes in attitude, acquisition of skills,
revised values or modified intentions that are directly linked to the your program
strategy. Intermediate outcomes are the sustained behavioral impacts of your
program effort. Sustained behavioral change is crucial to producing good long-
term outcomes. Once again, developing a program logic model has many benefits.
It helps to structure your critical thinking about program assumptions, intent,
structure and accountabilities. It helps to communicate about your program with
staff and stakeholders, and helps to keep you focused.
The MDGs originated from the United Nations Millennium Declaration. The
Declaration asserted that every individual has the right to dignity, freedom,
equality, a basic standard of living that includes freedom from hunger and violence
and encourages tolerance and solidarity. The MDGs set concrete targets and
indicators for poverty reduction in order to achieve the rights set forth in the
Declaration.
The MDG emphasized three areas: human capital, infrastructure and human rights
(social, economic and political), with the intent of increasing living standards.
Human capital objectives include nutrition, healthcare (including child mortality,
HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria, and reproductive health) and education.
Infrastructure objectives include access to safe drinking water, energy and modern
information/communication technology; increased farm outputs using sustainable
practices; transportation; and environment. Human rights objectives include
empowering women, reducing violence, increasing political voice, ensuring equal
access to public services and increasing security of property rights. The goals were
intended to increase an individual’s human capabilities and "advance the means to
a productive life.
Goals
The MDGs were developed out of several commitments set forth in the
Millennium Declaration, signed in September 2000. There are eight goals with 21
targets, and a series of measurable health indicators and economic indicators for
each target.
Target 1C: Halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people who
suffer from hunger
Target 6C: Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse the incidence of
malaria and other major diseases
Target 8B: Address the Special Needs of the Least Developed Countries
(LDCs)
Target 8F: In co-operation with the private sector, make available the
benefits of new technologies, especially information and communications.
With just four years to the target date of 2015, progress on the health-
related Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) has been slow.
Measuring progress has been hampered by the lack of
quality and timely data; this is especially true when
measuring progress toward goals that rely on civil
registration for their information, such as Goal 4 on reducing
child mortality. Civil registration is the conventional data source for
measuring and monitoring the majority of the MDG indicators. With
complete vital statistics, data required as inputs for measuring the
indicators for achieving universal primary education, reduction in child
mortality, improvements in maternal health and reductions in prevalence
of HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases would be made more accessible
for a continuous and over varying period of time. Unfortunately, most
African countries are far from compiling such comprehensive data,
therefore putting them at a disadvantage limiting their ability to track
progress or lack of in the achievement of the MDG targets at national as
well as sub-national levels. Having comprehensive civil registration data
help to provide measures for the below millennium development goals:
G4 Reduce Mortality
Under-five mortality rate (UMR)
Infant mortality rate (IMR)
G5 Improve Maternal Health
Maternal mortality ratio (MMR)
Proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel (%SHP)
Goal 6. Combat malaria and other diseases
Death rates associated with malaria (CSDRM)
Death rates associated with tuberculosis (CSDRT)
Self-check Written test
Answer Sheet.
Name__________________________________________ Date___/___/___.
1. ___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
_________________________
2. ___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
3. ___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
________________________________
4. ___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
__________________________
5. ___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
___________________________________________________
__________________________________________________