Arch Heat Flow Basics
Arch Heat Flow Basics
1. DEFINITIONS
Temperature – a measure of thermal energy, units of Kelvin (K) or Celsius (C)
Conductivity – a material property, heat flow per unit area per unit thickness per unit
temperature, symbol k (W/m K)
Conductance – a property of a material layer, heat flow per unit area and temperature, symbol
C (W/m2 K) = conductivity k / thickness l (in meters)
Resistance – a property of a material layer or wall measured from surface to surface, equals
1/C , symbol RSI (m2 K /W)
Imperial value R (ft2•F•hr/Btu) = 5.678 RSI
Overall heat transfer coefficient – a property of an enclosure assembly, basically the thermal
conductance of an assembly, heat flow per unit area and temperature, symbol U, U =
1/Rtotal , units W/m2 K.
2. BASIC EQUATIONS
The conductance of a layer, if made of a single material, can be calculated from:
C=k/l
where
k is the thermal conductivity of the material, and
l is the length of the heat flow path, that is, the thickness of the layer.
For layers that have complex shapes, such as hollow concrete block, or composites of several
materials, the conductance is often derived from physical tests or detailed computer models
and reported in tables.
R = 1 / C which therefore is l / k.
The thermal resistance of a multi-layer assembly of flat materials (most building enclosures),
can be calculated from
RT = R1 + R2 +… + Rn
where
RT is total thermal resistance of the assembly, and
R1 to Rn is the resistance of each of the building assembly’s layers, including
air films, air gaps, and solid materials.
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
The U-value is commonly used to describe the heat transmittance of an assembly, especially
windows and non-standard enclosures, and is defined simply as:
U = 1 / RT
Example: Given that the thermal conductivity of Type 4 extruded polystyrene (for example,
Styrofoam SM) is 0.029 W/mK, find the conductance and resistance of a layer 50 mm
thick in both imperial and metric units.
Answer:
Conductance = conductivity k / thickness l (in meters). 50 mm = 0.050 meters so …
C = 0.029 / 0.050 = 0.58 W / m2•K
this means, for example, that a one square meter panel of 50 mm thick Styrofoam
SM will allow 0.58 watts of energy to pass through it under a one degree Kelvin (or
Celsius) temperature change.
Resistance, RSI = 1 / conductance, so
C = 1 / 0.58 = 1.724 m2•K / W
Hence, a layer of SM would have a thermal resistance of RSI 1.724. If one were to
look in a building supply store, a sheet of 2” SM would be stamped with RSI1.76 or
R-10, since 2” sheets are slightly thicker than 50 mm (they are 50.8 mm). By the
way, a layer of 100 mm would have a thermal resistance of RSI3.45, eg twice the
thickness, twice the resistance (this does not work with conductance).
The thermal resistance in imperial R-value would be:
Imperial value R (ft2•F•r/Btu) = 5.678 RSI
Rimp = 5.678 * 1.724 = Rimp-9.8
Again, a full 2” thick sheet would have a slightly higher R-value of R10. Thus, one
often speaks of an “insulation value” of R5 per inch. Four inches, R20 for this layer,
1.5”, R7.5 for the layer.
Most building enclosures include more than just materials – they also include air spaces,
which are insulating. The heat transfer from the air next to the enclosure to the surface of the
enclosure is also not perfect. Hence, one needs to calculate the impact of this effect. These
complications are discussed next.
3. SURFACE FILMS
To account for both the radiation and convection heat transfer modes at the exterior and
interior surfaces of building components, radiative and convective heat transfer coefficients
are used in the form of an equivalent conductance or, alternatively, equivalent resistances.
These equivalent coefficients are termed surface film coefficients. It is important to recognize
that a surface film does not exist in reality. The term film is used simply so that a layer (of
indefinite thickness) can be added to a typical conductive heat flow analysis.
2
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
The resistance to heat flow at a surface is small relative to the heat flow resistance of most
modern wall assemblies and therefore need not be accurately estimated for most purposes.
Poorly insulated walls and windows have a lower overall thermal resistance and thus surface
effects are more important. Hence, a more precise calculation of surface films is justified for
these types of enclosures. The overall equivalent surface conductances, ho, or resistances in
Table 1 can be used to find heat flow without further modification.
Surface Position Flow Direction Resistance Conductance
2
Still Air (e.g. indoors) RSI [m K/W] R (imperial) [W/m2K]
Horizontal Upward 0.11 0.61 9.3
(i.e. ceilings
and floors) Downward 0.16 0.93 6.1
Vertical (i.e. walls) Horizontal 0.12 0.68 8.3
Moving Air (e.g. outdoors)
Stormy 6.7 m/s any 0.03 0.17 34
(winter)
Breeze 3.4 m/s any 0.04 0.25 23
(summer)
Average conditions any 0.06 0.33 17
Table 1: Equivelant Total Surface Film Conductances (ho)
widths, blocked cavities, etc.) and the relatively small influence that the airspace has on the
thermal resistance of modern enclosure assemblies. Simplified values for most practically
encountered situations are presented in Table 2. The values in Table 2 are also given in terms
of resistances so that they can be directly used in the heat flow equation.
Table 2: Thermal Resistance for non-reflective Enclosed Airspaces (RSI and R-value)
In many practical situations an air space is either intentionally or accidentally vented. Air
flow through an air space can change the heat flow characteristics, although significant flows
are required to modify the equivalent conductances listed above. In most cases, the effect of
venting enclosure assemblies can be ignored, and only in extreme cases does in need to be
accounted for. Extreme cases would includes highly ventilated attics (at least 1% venting
area) and cladding panels with both at least 2% vent area and cavities over 50 mm in size.
4
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
Answer:
Layer Material Conductivity Thickness Conductance Resistance
Interior film note 1 N.A. N.A. 8.3 0.120
Concrete 1.8 0.150 12 0.083
Type 4 XPS 0.029 0.075 0.39 2.56
Air space note 2 N.A. 25 N.A. 0.17
Brick 1.3 0.090 14.4 0.069
note 1
Exterior film N.A. N.A. 34 0.029
RSI total 3.04
Overall Heat Transfer, U 0.33
Note 1: Table 1. Since the interior and exterior films are fictitious, they do not have a thickness, and so no
conductivity. Hence, tables typically contain only conductances or resistances for the layer. These
values can be quite variable, but as can be seen, the effect of the value of the film resistance on the total
resistance of a wall is small if the wall is a modern insulated assembly.
5
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
Note 2: Table 2. The flow of heat through an air space is complicated by convection (air flows) and radiation
and so tabulated values of conductance are used instead. Like surface films, the values are variable but
not important to accuracy in the calculation in most modern walls.
The total resistance is RSI3.04 (or imperial R 17.2), 84%of it provided by the insulation, and
heat flow will be 0.33 W/m2 K.
This method can be used to predict heat flow through walls, roofs, or foundations with
uninterrupted or “continuous insulation”. If insulation is installed between studs (wood or
steel), is penetrated by floor slabs, or extensive steel structure, thermal bridging must be
accounted for (see later in this document).
Heat flow across an assembly is simply the temperature difference divided by the true R-value
times the area. The temperature difference is usually just (tinside – toutside).
1. Find the total thermal resistance of the enclosure as described earlier.
2. Find the overall heat transfer coefficient U, using U = 1/Rtotal
3. Multiply the temperature difference across the assembly by U, i.e., U*(tinside – toutside)
Of course if the sun is shining on the wall, the outdoor air temperature is not the correct one
to use, (the actual solar heated surface temperature is more accurate, but difficult to find
sometimes – use the table provided later for guidance).
The effect of heat storage, or thermal mass, can be important for some walls since heavy
mineral-based materials can store a lot of heat: see the section on thermal mass later.
Example: Calculate the amount of heat flow through the wall of the previous example when it
-10 C outside with no sun and 20 C inside.
Heat flow = U *( tinside – toutside)
= 0.33 (20 -10) = 0.33 (30)
= 10 W/m2
Ans. Heat flow outward would be 10 W/m2.
6
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
7
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
This energy will offset the losses of 123 kW, but a heating system of some type would be
needed to make up the remaining need (123-61) = 62 kW. In normal practice, engineers
assume all the energy inside a building is not available to provide heating. This was
acceptable in the days of poorly insulated enclosures, with modest interior heat gains, but
becomes a questionable assumption in highly insulated buildings.
Building Volume
=32x64x8
=16384
8
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
9
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
10
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
12
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
Figure 1: Effective layer Clear-wall R-value for light gauge steel framing
Almost all continuous insulations are, in practice, penetrated by screws, discrete ties, and
other point fasteners. Typical use of wire ties for masonry or sheet metal clips degrade
performance by perhaps 2 to 5%. However, continuous cold-formed steel Z-girts reduce the
performance by 50% or more and should be avoided.
13
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
14
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
15
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
16
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
17
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
12.THERMAL MASS
Thermal mass acts to store and release thermal energy (heat). Thermal mass is almost always
beneficial for buildings with near constant interior temperature. For buildings with aggressive
setback temperatures or long periods of unoccupied hours, thermal mass can cause control
difficulties and may even increase energy consumption.
For high performance buildings, the overall heat loss coefficient is low enough that the
thermal mass of typical construction is quite substantial: if heating is removed it can take
hours for the temperature to drop by one degree. In many high-performance buildings setback
schedules will not work because the building does not cool down to the setback temperature
before the temperature is set up again. This has the major advantage that a super insulated
building can survive many times longer than normal buildings in the event of a power outage.
Thermal mass is often desirable to store solar heat gains and internal heat generation from
occupancy during the day, and release it during the evening. This is one of the basic tenents
of passive solar design. The limit to this strategy in all types of buildings is the rate at which
heat gain can be transferred to the thermal mass during sunny period (without overheating)
not the amount of thermal mass. Because the heat loss of high performance buildings is so
small, increasing thermal mass is often not useful unless the rate of heat transfer to the
thermal mass is increased. This latter goal can be achieved by increasing the surface area of
mass (e.g mass more than 2 to 4” thick take too long to charge), by ensuring that the mass is
not covered by insulating or thermally lightweight finishes, and by encouraging airflow from
the heated zone to remote thermal mass in other zones.
For ultra-low energy use buildings, thermal mass can be a powerful and often necessary
strategy. However, it is a design strategy that is difficult to use because of the complexity of
assessing actual dynamic building use, heat transfer to and from mass, the temperature swing
acceptable to the occupants and other poorly characterized variables.
18
Heat Flow Basics www.LearnBuildingScience.com
20