Thanks to visit codestin.com
Credit goes to www.scribd.com

Scribd
Upload
28 views3 pages

BS Assignment 1

This document provides statistics on case volumes and outcomes for judges in Hamilton County, Ohio across several courts from 2011-2015. It shows the total number of cases, numbers not appealed and appealed, numbers of cases reversed or affirmed on appeal for each judge. The statistics allow comparison of individual judges' rates of cases appealed, reversed, and affirmed for analysis of decision quality. Overall appeal rates were low, between 2-5% of total cases, with most appeals being affirmed rather than reversed.

Uploaded by

045005
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
28 views3 pages

BS Assignment 1

This document provides statistics on case volumes and outcomes for judges in Hamilton County, Ohio across several courts from 2011-2015. It shows the total number of cases, numbers not appealed and appealed, numbers of cases reversed or affirmed on appeal for each judge. The statistics allow comparison of individual judges' rates of cases appealed, reversed, and affirmed for analysis of decision quality. Overall appeal rates were low, between 2-5% of total cases, with most appeals being affirmed rather than reversed.

Uploaded by

045005
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

CASE: HAMILTON COUNTY JUDGES

Not
Total appeale Appeale Reverse Affirme
Cases d Cases d Cases d Cases d Cases P ( C' ) P(C) P(A) P(R) P(R/C)
Common
Pleas 0.96184 0.03815 0.03379 0.00435 0.11416
Court 43850 42177 1673 191 1482 7 3 7 6 6
Domestic
Relations 0.99652 0.00347 0.00291 0.00055 0.16037
Court 30499 30393 106 17 89 4 6 8 7 7
Municipa 10918 0.99530 0.00469 0.00375 0.00094
l Court 8 108675 513 103 410 2 8 5 3 0.20078

Total
Not
Cases Appealed Reversed Affirmed
Judge appealed
Dispose Cases Cases Cases
Cases P ( C' ) P(C) P(A) P(R) P(R/C)
d

Fred
3037 2900 137 12 0.954 0.04115 0.00395 0.08759
Cartolano
125 9 0.04511 9 1 1
Thomas 0.964 0.03529 0.03232 0.00296 0.08403
3372 3253 119 10
Crush 109 7 1 5 6 4

Patrick
1258 1214 44 8 0.03497 0.02861 0.00635 0.18181
Dinkelacker
36 0.965 6 7 9 8
Timothy 0.969 0.03070 0.02712 0.00358 0.11666
1954 1894 60 7
Hogan 53 3 6 4 2 7
0.959 0.04047 0.03824 0.00223 0.05511
Robert Kraft 3138 3011 127 7
120 5 2 1 1 8
William 0.959 0.04019 0.03224 0.00795 0.19780
2264 2173 91 18
Mathews 73 8 4 4 1 2

William
3032 2911 121 22 0.960 0.03990 0.03265 0.00725 0.18181
Morrissey
99 1 8 2 6 8
Norbert 0.955 0.04427 0.03751 0.00675 0.15267
2959 2828 131 20
Nadel 111 7 2 3 9 2
Arthur Ney 0.961 0.03883 0.03448 0.00434
3219 3094 125 14
Jr. 111 2 2 3 9 0.112
Richard 0.959 0.04085 0.03608 0.00477 0.11678
3353 3216 137 16
Niehaus 121 1 9 7 2 8
Thomas 0.977 0.02266 0.02133 0.00133 0.05882
3000 2932 68 4
Nurre 64 3 7 3 3 4

John
2969 2840 129 12 0.956 0.04344 0.03940 0.00404 0.09302
O'Connor
117 6 9 7 2 3

Robert
3205 3060 145 18 0.954 0.04524 0.03962 0.00561 0.12413
Ruehlman
127 8 2 6 6 8

J. Howard
860 836 24 4
Sundermann 0.972 0.02790 0.02325 0.00465 0.16666
20 1 7 6 1 7
Ann Marie
3141 3014 127 13 0.959 0.04043 0.03629 0.00413 0.10236
Tracey
114 6 3 4 9 2
Ralph 0.971 0.02848 0.02654 0.00194 0.06818
3089 3001 88 6
Winkler 82 5 8 6 2 2

Total
Not
Cases Appealed Reversed Affirmed
Judge appealed
Dispose Cases Cases Cases
Cases P ( C' ) P(C) P(A) P(R) P(R/C)
d
Penelope
Cunningha 2729 2722 7 1 0.997 0.00256 0.00219 0.00036 0.14285
m 6 4 5 9 6 7

Patrick
6001 5982 19 4 0.996 0.00316 0.00066 0.21052
Dinkelacker
15 8 6 0.0025 7 6
Deborah 0.994 0.00545 0.00443 0.00102
8799 8751 48 9
Gaines 39 5 5 2 3 0.1875
Ronald 0.997 0.00246 0.00223 0.00023
12970 12938 32 3
Panioto 29 5 7 6 1 0.09375

Total
Not
Cases Appealed Reversed Affirmed
Judge appealed
Dispose Cases Cases Cases
Cases P ( C' ) P(C) P(A) P(R) P(R/C)
d
0.00699 0.00634 0.00065 0.09302
Mike Allen 6149 6106 43 4
39 0.993 3 2 1 3
Nadine 0.995 0.00435 0.00358 0.00076 0.17647
7812 7778 34 6
Allen 28 6 2 4 8 1
Timothy 0.994 0.00515 0.00075 0.14634
7954 7913 41 6
Black 35 8 5 0.0044 4 1
0.994 0.00555 0.00491 0.00064 0.11627
David Davis 7736 7693 43 5
38 4 8 2 6 9

Leslie Isaiah
5282 5247 35 13 0.993 0.00662 0.00416 0.00246 0.37142
Gaines
22 4 6 5 1 9
0.998 0.00152 0.00152
Karla Grady 5253 5245 8 0
8 5 3 3 0 0
0.994
Deidra Hair 2797 2781 16 0
16 3 0.00572 0.00572 0 0
Dennis 0.996 0.00367 0.00303 0.00063 0.17241
7900 7871 29 5
Helmick 24 3 1 8 3 4
Timothy 0.994 0.00563 0.00476 0.00086 0.15384
2308 2295 13 2
Hogan 11 4 3 6 7 6
James
Patrick 2798 2792 6 1 0.997 0.00214 0.00178 0.00035 0.16666
Kenney 5 9 4 7 7 7
Joseph 0.994 0.00532 0.00383
4698 4673 25 7
Luebbers 18 7 1 1 0.00149 0.28
William 0.995 0.00459 0.00350 0.00108 0.23684
8277 8239 38 9
Mallory 29 4 1 4 7 2
Melba 0.995 0.00413 0.00328 0.00085 0.20588
8219 8185 34 7
Marsh 27 9 7 5 2 2
Beth 0.995 0.00437 0.00403 0.00033 0.07692
2971 2958 13 1
Mattingly 12 6 6 9 7 3
Albert
4975 4947 28 9 0.994 0.00562 0.00381 0.00180 0.32142
Mestemaker
19 4 8 9 9 9
Mark 0.996 0.00312 0.00178 0.42857
2239 2232 7 3
Painter 4 9 6 7 0.00134 1
0.994 0.00526 0.00359 0.00166 0.31707
Jack Rosen 7790 7749 41 13
28 7 3 4 9 3

Mark
5403 5370 33 6 0.993 0.00610 0.00499 0.18181
Schweikert
27 9 8 7 0.00111 8

David
5371 5349 22 4 0.995 0.00409 0.00335 0.00074 0.18181
Stockdale
18 9 6 1 5 8
John A. 0.998 0.00122 0.00061 0.00061
3256 3252 4 2
West 2 8 9 4 4 0.5

Patrick
7259 7196 63 12 0.991
Dinkelacker
51 3 0.00868 0.00703 0.00165 0.19048
Timothy 0.982
4262 4189 73 9
Hogan 64 9 0.01713 0.01502 0.00211 0.12329

You might also like