Case 7
Case 7
Abstract
Purpose- The purpose of this study is to examine the supply chain practices – Supplier strategic partnership,
customer relationship, information sharing, information quality, postponement, agreed vision and goals as
well as risk and reward sharing towards the supply chain performance.
Design/ Methodology/ Approach- The study utilizes survey data. The results are based on regression
analysis and equation modelling by using SPSS software.
Findings-The study finds that all supply chain practices namely supplier strategic partnership, customer
relationship, information sharing, information quality, postponement, agreed vision and goals and risk and
reward sharing have a positive relationship towards the supply chain performance.
Practical Implications- For supply chain practitioners, the results indicate that the practices of supply
chain practices that will improve the supply chain performance
Originality/ Value- The paper theoretically develops determinants shows that all off the supply chain
practices will influences the supply chain performance. Considered at a higher level of abstraction, these
relationships indicate a contribution to theory that explains how supply chain practices can result in supply
chain performance.
Keywords- Keywords Malaysia, Operational performance, Supply chain management, Supply chain
management practices, Supply Chain Performance
Paper type- Research Paper
Introduction
Research Background
This research focused on the supply chain practices (SCMP) that effect the supply chain performance
(SCP). Supply chain management (SCM) is an integration of various business process such as planning and
forecasting, procurement, manufacturing and assembly, distribution, management of resources and
customer-focused process management (Lummus, 1999). SCM is part of integration that link to firm
performance which will affects the capabilities in manufacturing firms especially in developing country.
Supply chain management also includes the total connectivity between the upstream (supply and
manufacturing) and downstream (distribution) value chain entities in order to achieve competitiveness. Not
only that, SCM also referred as a set of approaches that used to integrate suppliers, manufacturers, logistics
and customers to improve long time performance of the individual companies and the supply chain as a
whole.
Electroniccopy
Electronic copyavailable
available at:
at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2988725
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2988725
Role of SCM is to meet customer requirement in term of providing customer with the right product of right
quality and quantity from the right source at the right price. This will enhance the performance of an
organization to improve supply chain as it link with suppliers, customers, and other channel members.
Supply chain management practices (SCMP) is a set of activities in organization to promote effective
management of its supply chain. (Donlon, 1996) describe that SCMP include supplier partnership,
outsourcing, cycle time compression, continuous process flow and IT sharing. There are six other
dimensions of SCMP through factor analysis that are supply chain integration, information sharing (IS),
supply chain characteristics, customer services management, geographical proximity and just-in-time
capability identified by Tan et al. (2002). In order to measure SCMP, cross-functional teams, supplier base
reduction, long-term relationship, supplier involvement and communication can be use. Furthermore, it will
cover important dimensions such as upstream (SSP) and downstream (CR) of the supply chain, information
flow (IS and IQ), internal supply chain process (POS) that include agreed vision and goals, risk and award
sharing.
To be highly competitive and achieving sustainable profitability growth, supply chain management can
integrate with internal function within firm and external linkage with suppliers, customer and other channel
members. It can be achieved through effective construction of various SCMP’s (Kim, 2006). (Kim, 2006)
also stated that the efficiency of supply chain can be realized through various interaction of SCMP. It
provides evidences how SCMP could enhance organization competitive capabilities such as customer
service, cost leadership and product differentiation. The overall of this study will allow managers to
effectively utilize different components of SCMP and SCI and performance.
Research gap
SCM practices have a significant impact on firm operational performance throughout the practices along
the entire supply chain that cover upstream, internal process and downstream activities. However, it has not
been yet sufficiently studied in the literature. Additionally, previous studies are mainly focused on the direct
relationships, and thus there is a lack of examining interactions among SCM practices (Ahire, 1998).
According to Kaynak (2008), it is not comprehensive if a research model does not show the relationship
among practices. In other words, further studies need to identify the direct and indirect impact of SCM
practices on firm performance at multiple levels.
In sum, there are some research gaps that reduce the value of previous studies in the literature.
Those are:
• the inconsistency in results of previous studies;
• the role of top management support;
• the mutual interaction among practices has not been examined; and
• data analysis approach.
This study aim at filling the above voids by proposing a new framework based on structural
equation modeling (SEM) technique and validating this model by the data collected from the Malaysia
garment industry. This is a sector playing an important role in the Malaysia socio-economic development
in terms of creating huge employment, especially jobs for females, contributing as a major source of foreign
exchange accumulation for the nation and creating a tremendous integration opportunity for Malaysia in
the global economy.
Electroniccopy
Electronic copyavailable
available at:
at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2988725
https://ssrn.com/abstract=2988725
is literature review and research hypotheses. Thereafter, the second section presents the research
methodology. The third section describes the results of the research. The fourth section presents the
implications for theory and management. The final section is the conclusion of the paper.
Literature review and hypothesis
Supply Chain Performance
Performance measurement is defined as a systematic process of effectively and efficiently quantifying a
concept or an action (Neely, 1997). There are two types of objectives which are short-term objectives and
long-term objectives. Short-term objectives enhance productivity, reduce inventory and lead time while
long-term objectives increase market share and integration (Li S. R.-N.-N., 2006b) (Lyons, 2004).
According to (Chia, 2009), for any company that has strategic implications, identifying the required
performance measures on most of the criteria is essential and it should be an integral part of any business
strategy. Not only that, SCP has been defined as a systematic process of measuring the effectiveness and
efficiency of supply chain operations (Anand, 2015). According to (Miliken, 2001) an effective SCP
measurement process is critical to ensure continuous improvement in the supply chain processes.
Customer Relationship
(Tan, 1998) defined CR as the practice to manage customer complaints, build long-term relationships with
customers, and improve customer satisfaction. It helps organization to differentiate its product from
competitors and dramatically extend the value it provides to its customers and sustain customer loyalty
through customer satisfaction (Cox, 2004) and (Dadzie, 2007).
H2. Customer relationship influences supply chain performance positively.
Information Sharing
Concept of information sharing as an area of cognitive science. Information sharing is defined here as the
process by which speakers depend on ‘given’ information (i.e., information already shared with the hearer
from previous communication) when they convey ‘new’ information (i.e., information assumed to be new
to the hearer). Information sharing is a key concept in linguistics and philosophy, where it is related to
notions like presupposition, anaphora, focus, and indexicality. It is also perceived as crucial in various areas
of language engineering because computer-based processing of language and speech relies heavily on the
computer's ability to distinguish between given and new information (Kees Van Deemter., 2002).
H3. Information sharing supply chain performance positively.
Information Quality
Information quality plays an important role in supply chain performance. In order to make smarter use of
global resources, the companies should pay attention to the quality of information to provide better services
to their customers. This will examines the factors influencing information quality and investigates the
influences of information quality on supply chain performance. The information quality is classified into
four types: accuracy, completeness, consistency, and timeliness. The influencing factors include
technological, organizational, and environmental characteristics. Supply chain performance is measured
based on financial and nonfinancial indices. It can be found that the extent of information quality will
increase supply chain performance and the extent of information quality is influenced by technological,
organizational, and environmental characteristics (Zailani S. &., 2007).
Sampling
The intended population of this study is the industry players of supply chain industry in Malaysia. Given
the true characteristic of the intended population was unknown; convenience sampling was performed
(Sekaran U. B., 2010). Furthermore, I am also used convenience sampling because this research aims to
test the relationships of variables. According to Sekaran (2013), convenience sampling can be performed
in a research intended to test the relationships of variables.
Dimensions Cronbach’s a
Strategic supplier partnership 0.554
Customer relationship 0.730
Information sharing 0.516
Information quality 0.906
Risk and reward sharing 0.620
Supply Chain Performance 0.941
Table 2: The results of reliability testing
The data collection was performed using survey. The sample of this research is 150 industry players
in supply chain industry in Malaysia. The sample size exceeds the requirement of multiple regression
analysis, the statistical analysis tool that we used (Bhatti & Sundram, 2015). To ensure the completion of
the survey, phone calls and e-mail reminders were sent exactly a week after the first attempt to contact
them. At the end of the data collection period, a total of 150 questionnaires were collected. However, only
100 fully completed questionnaires were used for data analysis. Therefore the size use in this study is 100.
The entire respondents selected are experts in the supply and distribution industry. In addition, participants
were assured of confidentiality and anonymity of their returned questionnaires. The selection of appropriate
respondent is done at the time of data collection (fieldwork) process. More completely, Table 3 shows the
respondents’ demographic profile.
Respondent’s Profile
Frequency Percentage
Gender
Male 60 60%
Female 40 40%
Age
20-29 years 20 20%
30-39 years 25 25%
40-49 years 35 35%
50 years and above 20 20%
Job Title
Head of Department 3 3%
Managers 23 23%
Executives 15 15%
Non-executives 34 34%
Others 25 25%
Department
Marketing 15 15%
Purchasing/Procurement 25 25%
Manufacturing 25 25%
Distribution 10 10%
Transportation 20 20%
Others 5 5%
Industry Category
Manufacturing 40 40%
Process industry 20 20%
The second finding of this research showed that the unstandardized B coefficient of customer relationship
is positive (B= 0.294) and the p-value is lower than 0.05 (p-value =0.000). This means the customer
relationship support supply chain performance positively and significantly. Thus, the second hypothesis
was accepted. Furthermore, this finding supports the finding of Dow (1999), (Rahman, 2005) and (Sila,
2005).
The third finding of this research showed that the unstandardized B coefficient of information sharing
is positive (B= 0.566) and the p-value is lower than 0.05 (p-value =0.000). This means information sharing
influence supply chain performance positively and significantly. Thus, the third hypothesis was accepted.
The fourth finding of this research showed that information quality influence supply chain performance
significantly (B=0.347, p-value=0. 000). Hence, the fourth hypothesis was accepted. This finding supports
the previous basic assumption that information quality do influence supply chain performance.
The fifth finding of this research showed that risk and reward sharing influence supply chain
performance positively (B=.560, p-value=0.000). hence, the fifth hypothesis is accepted which the risk and
reward sharing influence the supply chain performance.
Theoretical implication
Supply chain management practices are the important elements in and improving the firms’ operational
performance so that the supply chain performance objectives can be achieves at the highest level. Most of
the respondents agreed that the determinant that affecting supply chain performance is information system.
Based on the finding, the recommended solution should well address to improve information system and a
bit in risk and reward sharing, information quality, customer relationship and strategic supplier partnership.
In existing literature, there is no study that specifically investigated the simultaneous determinant of
information system, risk and reward sharing, information quality, customer relationship and strategic
supplier partnership on supply chain performance. Given this, the paper have fulfilled the gap in the
literature by developing and testing a firms’ supply chain performance model that included by information
system, risk and reward sharing, information quality, customer relationship and strategic supplier
partnership on supply chain performance. The results of this research showed that firms’ supply chain
performance is influenced by strategic supplier partnership, customer relationship, information system,
information quality and risk and reward sharing.
Managerial implication
The theoretical literature on supply chain management suggest direct causal link between SCMPs and
performance . In this study, a number of theoretical contributions have been made. The theoretically
integrated perspective provides a better framework for understanding the complex relationship between
SCMPs and SCP. The roles of SCMPs are revealed to understand the possible means to appropriate SCP.
This information is very crucial especially in the age of globalization where increasingly firms intensify
SCMPs processes both internally and externally of SCP. Managerial implications are twofold. The findings
suggest that managers can take advantage their existing SCMPs to stimulate and consequently influence
their firm performance level. In addition, managers, now, are able to identify which SCMPs will likely to
benefit more in enhancing SCP. Greater benefits are likely to be more if managers improve practices in
areas such as information quality, customer relationship, information sharing while risk and reward sharing
practices. If managers are considering investment in supply chain management, obviously managers should
invest in SCMPs to extract the most benefit for SCP. Such investment decision should not be an independent
activity considering only practices because It’s imperative that managers highlight this to the top
management for any budget allocation for the purpose of investment in supply chain management activities.
Supply chain managers in the manufacturing firm could use these key supply chain practices and transform
them into industrial critical success factors. As such, these critical success factors will be identified as the
key result area to formulate key performance indicator to measure the effectiveness and efficiency of the
organizational resources and supply chain as a whole. Further, managers will also have several options in
Conclusion
In this research or study, there are five factors that had been identified that will lead to the increases the
buyer’s dependence on its suppliers at various company of supply chain in Malaysia which are independent
variable such as strategic supplier partnership, customer relationship, information sharing, information
quality and risk and reward sharing. This research was been done due to researcher observation from the
extracted data and the issues that researcher heard to increase supply chain performance and requirement
in certain practices that implemented by the organization.
Based on the hypothesis result in Chapter 4, five variables are significant. The significant variable
is supply chain practices which consist of strategic supplier partnership, customer relationship, information
sharing, information quality, and risk and reward sharing. The variable significant means there is a
relationship between supply chain practices with supply chain performance. The alternate hypothesis is
accepted because the hypothesis is significant.
Strategic supplier partnership, customer relationship, information sharing, information quality and,
risk and reward sharing are the factors that affecting supply chain performance at supply chain and logistics
industry. This is because these kinds of supply chain practices should be connected to suppliers who meet
the requirements and have significant role in industry' value creation. The organization needs to focus on
information sharing and knowledge transfer as most effective preconditions affecting learning in supply
chain relationships, hence professional experience and tacit knowledge is shared in tight buyer-supplier
collaboration. The organization needs to focus on information sharing and knowledge transfer as most
effective preconditions affecting learning in supply chain relationships, hence professional experience and
tacit knowledge is shared in tight buyer-supplier collaboration (Sundram et al., 2016). The power and
dependence strongly influence the nature of the buyer – supplier relationship (Batt, 2004; van Weele, 1999)
Besides that, according to (Nyaga, 2013) the quality of the relationship enhances firms’ willingness to
engage in collaborative activities with their supply chain partners.
As a conclusion, early supplier involvement, inter-firm learning and supplier orientation are
influence increases the buyer’s dependence on its suppliers. This is because the organization will refer to
the all that variable. Moreover, the organization has to up to date information system that are integrated
within the organization to inform each and all of them.