Drawing Processes
Drawing Processes
When the metal is forced through the die by a tensile force applied to the metal at exist of die it is
called drawing.
Creating shallow cylindrical and rectangular bodies in sheet metal involves several key principles and
techniques to ensure the shapes are accurate, functional, and maintain structural integrity. Here's an
overview of the process:
1. Material Selection:
- Choose a sheet metal material suitable for forming. Common choices include aluminum, steel, and
stainless steel due to their ductility and strength.
2. Design Considerations:
- Ensure the design includes allowances for material thickness and bending.
3. Cutting:
- Use a laser cutter, plasma cutter, or shears to cut the flat blank from the sheet metal.
4. Forming:
- Roll Forming: The flat blank is passed through a series of rollers that gradually shape it into a
cylinder.
- Deep Drawing: For shallow cylinders, deep drawing can be used where a punch draws the flat
blank into a die to form the cylindrical shape.
- Bending: A press brake can be used to bend the sheet into a cylindrical form, particularly for larger
radii.
5. Joining:
- If the cylinder is formed from a flat sheet, the edges need to be joined. Common methods include
welding (TIG or MIG), riveting, or using adhesives.
6. Finishing:
- Deburring, surface treatment (like anodizing or powder coating), and any additional machining
(holes, cutouts) are performed to finish the part.
1. Material Selection:
- As with cylindrical bodies, select a ductile and strong sheet metal such as aluminum, steel, or
stainless steel.
2. Design Considerations:
- Determine the dimensions (length, width, height) and ensure allowances for bends and material
thickness.
3. Cutting:
- Use a laser cutter, plasma cutter, or shears to cut the flat blank from the sheet metal according to
the required dimensions.
4. Forming:
- Bending: Use a press brake to bend the edges of the rectangular blank to form the sides. Typically,
the bends are made in sequence, starting with the shorter sides and then the longer ones.
- Corner Treatments: Depending on the design, corners can be mitered and welded or bent with
relief cuts to allow for smooth corners.
5. Joining:
- Weld the corners if they are mitered. If the corners are bent, ensure they are adequately supported
and joined as needed using spot welding, riveting, or adhesives.
6. Finishing:
- Similar to cylindrical bodies, deburring, surface treatments, and any additional machining are done
to complete the rectangular body.
General Tips
- Tolerance and Allowances: Always factor in tolerances for the material's Spring-back after bending.
- Tooling: Ensure the tools and machines are suitable for the thickness and type of sheet metal being
used.
- Prototype and Test: Create prototypes to test the design and forming process before mass
production.
By following these steps, you can successfully create shallow cylindrical and rectangular bodies from
sheet metal with precision and efficiency.
Advantages
The shallow drawing process in sheet metal manufacturing offers several advantages, making it a
preferred method for producing various parts. Here are some key benefits:
1. Cost-Effectiveness:
- Material Efficiency: Shallow drawing typically results in less material waste compared to other
processes like machining.
- Reduced Tooling Costs: The dies used in shallow drawing are generally simpler and less
expensive to produce and maintain.
- Speed: The process is relatively quick, allowing for high-volume production runs.
- Work Hardening: The deformation process can improve the strength and hardness of the material
through work hardening.
- Grain Structure: The process can refine the grain structure of the material, enhancing its
mechanical properties.
4. Design Flexibility:
- Complex Shapes: Shallow drawing allows for the creation of complex and precise shapes that
might be difficult or impossible to achieve with other methods.
- Variety of Materials: The process can be used with a wide range of metals, including steel,
aluminum, copper, and their alloys.
5. Surface Finish and Accuracy:
- High-Quality Surface Finish: The smooth surface of the dies ensures that the drawn parts have a
high-quality finish, reducing the need for additional finishing processes.
- Dimensional Accuracy: Shallow drawing provides good control over the dimensions of the final
product, ensuring consistency and precision.
- Seamless Parts: Parts produced through shallow drawing are seamless, which enhances their
structural integrity and reduces the risk of failure points.
- Uniform Thickness: The process helps maintain uniform material thickness, which is crucial for
the strength and performance of the final product.
7. Reduction in Post-Processing:
- Minimal Secondary Operations: Parts often require little to no secondary operations such as
welding, assembly, or finishing, reducing overall production time and cost.
8. Versatility in Applications:
- Wide Range of Applications: Shallow drawing is used in various industries, including automotive,
aerospace, consumer electronics, and appliance manufacturing, due to its versatility in producing
components like housings, enclosures, and panels.
Disadvantages
The shallow drawing process, a technique used in sheet metal forming, involves the deformation of
metal sheets into hollow shapes with relatively small depth compared to their diameter. While this
process is beneficial for producing shallow components, it has several disadvantages:
- Constraint: Shallow drawing is restricted to creating components with limited depth. It is not
suitable for parts requiring significant depth, as excessive drawing can lead to material failure.
- Impact: Limits the range of products that can be manufactured using this process.
2. Thickness Variation:
- Issue: During the drawing process, the thickness of the sheet metal can become uneven, with
thinning occurring in some areas and thickening in others.
- Consequence: This can affect the structural integrity and uniformity of the final product, requiring
additional processes to correct.
3. Risk of Wrinkling:
- Problem: The edges of the metal sheet may wrinkle due to compressive forces acting during the
drawing process.
- Outcome: Wrinkling can compromise the appearance and function of the final product, often
necessitating further processing to remove these imperfections.
4. Material Limitations:
- Constraint: Not all materials are suitable for shallow drawing. Materials must have sufficient
ductility to withstand the drawing process without cracking or tearing.
- Limitation: Limits the choice of materials, potentially increasing costs or limiting the application
of the process to specific materials.
- Expense: The initial setup for shallow drawing, including dies and presses, can be costly.
- Consideration: High initial costs can be a disadvantage, particularly for small production runs or
prototyping, where the cost may not be justifiable.
- Quality: The drawing process can sometimes result in surface defects such as scratches, galling, or
tool marks.
- Implication: Additional surface finishing processes may be required, adding to the overall
production time and cost.
7. Stress Concentration:
- Concern: The process can introduce residual stresses into the material, particularly around the
edges and corners of the drawn part.
- Effect: These stresses can lead to issues such as cracking or reduced fatigue life of the component,
necessitating stress relief processes.
- Limitation: Shallow drawing is more suited to simple geometries and may struggle with complex
shapes or designs with intricate details.
- Result: Complex parts may require more advanced or additional forming techniques, complicating
the manufacturing process.
Applications
Shallow drawing, a specific type of sheet metal forming process, involves the creation of shallow,
cup-like shapes from a flat sheet of metal. This process is integral in various industries due to its
efficiency and precision in producing parts with specific geometries. Here are some applications of
the shallow drawing process in the sheet metal industry:
1. Automotive Industry
- Body Panels: Shallow drawing is used to form body panels, such as doors, hoods, and trunk lids,
which require smooth surfaces and precise shapes.
- Fuel Tanks: It is also used for manufacturing shallow fuel tanks and other container-like structures
that require a uniform depth.
2. Consumer Goods
- Kitchenware: Items such as baking trays, frying pans, and other kitchen utensils are often produced
using shallow drawing due to its ability to create smooth and uniform surfaces.
- Appliance Components: Components for appliances, such as the outer casings of washing machines
and dryers, are manufactured using shallow drawing.
3. Electronics Industry
- Enclosures: Shallow drawing is used to produce enclosures and casings for various electronic
devices, ensuring they have precise dimensions and smooth finishes.
- Battery Housings: It is used to create housings for batteries and other components that require
precise and uniform dimensions.
4. Aerospace Industry
- Aircraft Skin Panels: Shallow drawing is employed to manufacture skin panels for aircraft, where
uniform thickness and precise dimensions are crucial for aerodynamic efficiency.
- Interior Components: Various interior components, such as seat frames and paneling, are produced
using this process.
5. Medical Devices
- Surgical Instruments: Certain surgical instruments and components, such as trays and containers, are
made using shallow drawing to ensure they meet strict hygiene and precision standards.
- Medical Device Housings: The process is used to create housings and covers for medical devices
that require precise dimensions and smooth finishes.
6. Packaging Industry
- Containers and Cans: Shallow drawing is used extensively to manufacture containers and cans for
food, beverages, and other products, ensuring they are lightweight and have uniform thickness.
- Aerosol Cans: The production of aerosol cans also relies on shallow drawing to achieve the required
shapes and sizes.
7. Industrial Components
- Machine Parts: Various machine parts and components, such as shallow caps and flanges, are
produced using shallow drawing to meet specific dimensional requirements.
- Brackets and Mounts: Shallow drawing is used to create brackets and mounts that require precise
shapes and structural integrity.
Benefits of Shallow Drawing
- Material Efficiency: It minimizes waste by using the exact amount of material needed to form the
part.
- Versatility: Can be used with a wide range of metals, including steel, aluminum, copper, and their
alloys.
Deep Drawing
Deep drawing processes are divided into three types:
In the automotive industry, deep drawing is usually carried out using rigid tools.
The figure illustrates the deep drawing process. The rigid tools consist of a punch, die and binder. In
deep drawing, the plate holder closes after the metal sheet blank has been inserted.
Next the sheet is clamped between the die and the binder. This process slows down the flow of the
sheet while it is being drawn and thereby prevents wrinkles from forming under the binder. The punch
stretches the sheet over the die radius and forms it in the die. The amount of punch force necessary for
forming is thereby continually increased up to the lower dead center of the punch.
Whereas in pure deep drawing there is no reduction of sheet metal thickness, forming is achieved in
stretch forming purely as a result of a decrease in sheet metal thickness. Stretch forming is extensively
used for the forming of only slightly curved parts with low depth of draw (e.g. roofs, doors).
When drawing complex car body parts in practice, there is usually a combination of stretch and deep
drawing involved. It is necessary that the sheet metal is stretched as well as possible without reaching
the material’s limits (e.g. splits, wrinkles).
There are approximately 300 to 400 sheet metal parts which fit together to form the body of a car. In
order to manufacture high quality sheet metal parts optimally for their particular use, specialized
software simulates the complete deep drawing process.
Deep drawing is a widely used sheet metal forming process that offers several advantages and
disadvantages. Here’s an overview:
- Automation: Deep drawing can be highly automated, making it suitable for mass production.
- Economies of Scale: Once the tooling is created, the cost per unit decreases significantly with high
volume production.
- Minimal Waste: Efficient material usage reduces waste, making it cost-effective and
environmentally friendly.
- Work Hardening: The process can enhance the strength and rigidity of the formed parts through
work hardening.
- Seamless Parts: Produces seamless components, which have better structural integrity compared to
welded parts.
5. Design Flexibility:
- High Accuracy: Ensures uniformity and precision in the produced parts, crucial for high-tolerance
applications.
- Expensive Tooling: Designing and manufacturing the dies can be expensive, making it less cost-
effective for small production runs.
2. Material Limitations:
- Ductility Requirements: Only materials with sufficient ductility and malleability are suitable for
deep drawing, limiting material choices.
3. Risk of Defects:
- Wrinkling: If the blank holder pressure is not properly controlled, wrinkling can occur.
- Tearing and Cracking: High deformation can cause tearing or cracking, especially in less ductile
materials.
4. Thickness Variation:
- Non-Uniform Thickness: Parts may have variations in wall thickness, which can affect the strength
and functionality of the final product.
- Complicated Tooling: The design of dies and punches can be complex and time-consuming,
requiring skilled labor and precision engineering.
- Scrap During Setup: Initial setup and adjustments can result in material waste until the process
parameters are optimized.
1. Car Body Panels: Deep drawing is extensively used to manufacture car body panels, including
doors, hoods, and fenders. These components require precise dimensions and smooth surfaces, which
deep drawing can achieve.
2. Fuel Tanks: Fuel tanks are often produced using deep drawing due to the need for a seamless and
leak-proof design.
3. Engine Components: Various engine components, such as oil pans and valve covers, are made
through deep drawing because of the process's ability to produce parts with uniform thickness and
strength.
Aerospace Industry
1. Aircraft Panels: The aerospace industry utilizes deep drawing to fabricate lightweight and durable
panels for aircraft, ensuring they can withstand high pressures and temperatures.
2. Engine Housings: Deep drawing is used to produce complex engine housings that require high
precision and reliability.
Consumer Goods
1. Kitchenware: Items like pots, pans, and sinks are commonly made using deep drawing due to the
process's ability to create seamless and aesthetically pleasing products.
2. Appliances: Parts for household appliances, such as washing machine drums and refrigerator
components, are often produced through deep drawing.
Electrical Industry
1. Enclosures and Housings: Deep drawing is used to create protective enclosures and housings for
electrical components, ensuring they are both strong and lightweight.
2. Battery Cases: The process is ideal for producing battery cases that need to be durable and precisely
shaped.
Medical Equipment
1. Surgical Instruments: Many surgical instruments and medical devices are made using deep drawing
due to the need for precise and sterile manufacturing.
2. Implants: Deep drawing is used to manufacture certain types of medical implants, which require
biocompatibility and precision.
Packaging Industry
1. Cans and Containers: The production of beverage cans and food containers often involves deep
drawing, as it allows for high-speed manufacturing of lightweight and strong containers.
2. Aerosol Cans: Aerosol cans are another common application, benefiting from the seamless and
strong structure that deep drawing provides.
Industrial Applications
1. Machinery Parts: Various parts for industrial machinery, including gears and housings, are made
using deep drawing to ensure durability and precision.
2. HVAC Components: Deep drawing is used to manufacture components for heating, ventilation, and
air conditioning systems, such as ducts and enclosures.
1. Bending
- Description: Bending involves deforming a metal sheet by applying force along a straight axis,
resulting in an angular change.
2. Deep Drawing
- Description: A process where a metal sheet is radially drawn into a forming die by the mechanical
action of a punch.
- Applications: Used to make complex hollow shapes like cans, automotive panels, and kitchen
sinks.
- Description: Involves cutting and forming a metal sheet using a series of dies to create complex
shapes and patterns.
- Applications: Production of metal parts in large quantities such as automotive parts, electronics
housings.
4. Roll Forming
- Description: A continuous bending operation in which a long strip of sheet metal is passed through
sets of rolls to form desired profiles.
- Applications: Making long products like roofing panels, door frames, and gutters.
5. Hydroforming
- Description: Uses a high-pressure hydraulic fluid to press room-temperature working material into
a die.
1. Material Properties:
- Yield strength
- Hardness
2. Bending Radius:
3. Sheet Thickness:
4. Forming Method:
- The specific method and tool geometry can affect the degree of spring back.
1. Over-bending:
- Intentionally bending the sheet metal beyond the desired angle to compensate for the anticipated
spring back. This requires precise calculation based on material properties and the specific bend.
2. Bottoming/ Coining:
- Applying additional force at the end of the bending process to plastically deform the material at
the bend, reducing the elastic recovery. This method can also improve bend accuracy.
3. Material Selection:
- Choosing materials with lower elastic recovery characteristics for critical applications.
4. Adjusting Tooling:
- Designing tools that account for spring back by incorporating compensation angles or contours.
- Using computer simulations to predict spring back and adjust the process parameters accordingly.
FEA can model the material behavior during and after forming, allowing for more precise control
over the final part shape.
6. Heat Treatment:
In some cases, heat treatment can be used to alter the material properties and reduce spring back.
However, this is typically more applicable to thicker or more complex parts.
Understanding and controlling spring back is crucial in sheet metal forming to ensure that the final
product meets the required specifications. By combining proper material selection, tool design, and
advanced simulation techniques, manufacturers can effectively mitigate the effects of spring back and
achieve high-precision metal parts.
Advantages and Disadvantages spring back of
forming process including
Spring-back is a common phenomenon in metal forming processes where the metal attempts to return
to its original shape after the forming force is removed. This can affect the final dimensions and
geometry of the formed part. Understanding the advantages and disadvantages of spring-back is
crucial for designing and controlling forming processes. Here are some points to consider:
1. Energy Absorption:
- Spring-back indicates that the material has a degree of elasticity, which can be beneficial in
applications where energy absorption is desired, such as in automotive crash components.
- Properly managed spring-back can help in distributing residual stresses more evenly across the
part, potentially improving fatigue life and performance under dynamic loading.
3. Shape Recovery:
- In some cases, the elasticity indicated by Spring-back can be used advantageously in processes
where a slight return to a pre-deformed shape is beneficial for the final application.
4. Material Utilization:
- Understanding Spring-back can lead to optimized material usage by anticipating and compensating
for it in the design phase, potentially reducing waste and cost.
1. Dimensional Inaccuracy:
- Spring-back often results in parts that do not match the intended design dimensions, necessitating
additional processes or adjustments to achieve the required accuracy.
- Compensating for Spring-back requires complex and precise tool designs. This increases the
design time and cost, as the tools need to account for the elastic recovery of the material.
- Spring-back is influenced by material properties, which can vary between batches. This variability
can lead to inconsistent part quality and requires stringent quality control measures.
- Sheet Metal Forming: In the automotive industry, precise sheet metal parts are crucial for vehicle
body construction. Spring-back must be accurately predicted and compensated for to ensure parts fit
together correctly, maintaining the structural integrity and aesthetic quality of the vehicle.
- Tool and Die Design: Tools and dies are designed with compensations for spring-back. Adjustments
are made based on simulations and previous experience to ensure the final part has the desired shape.
2. Aerospace Industry
- Precision Components: Aerospace components often require high precision. Materials like
aluminum and titanium are commonly used, and their spring-back behavior needs careful
consideration during the forming process to ensure dimensional accuracy and performance under
operational conditions.
- Composite Materials: The aerospace industry also deals with composite materials, which exhibit
different spring-back characteristics compared to metals. Understanding and controlling spring-back
is crucial for the reliable production of composite parts.
3. Consumer Electronics
- Thin Sheet Forming: The production of thin metal enclosures for consumer electronics, such as
smartphones and laptops, requires tight dimensional tolerances. Spring-back must be accounted for to
ensure the final product has the correct fit and finish.
- Miniaturization: As devices become smaller, the precision of formed parts becomes even more
critical, making the control of spring-back essential.
4. Construction Industry
5. Medical Devices
- Implants and Instruments: Medical devices, especially implants and surgical instruments, require
high precision. Materials like stainless steel and titanium, commonly used in medical devices, exhibit
spring-back that needs to be managed to achieve the required tolerances and functionality.
Bending process including Spring Back
The bending process in sheet metal fabrication is a common and essential technique used to shape
metal sheets into various forms. This process is widely used in the automotive, aerospace, and
construction industries, among others. Here's a detailed overview of the bending process, including
the concept of spring back:
- Definition: Bending is a manufacturing process that involves the plastic deformation of a material
to change its shape. It produces V-shapes, U-shapes, and channel shapes along a straight axis.
- Tools: The primary tools used in the bending process are the punch and die. The punch applies
force to the sheet metal, pressing it into the die, which shapes the metal.
- Types of Bending:
- Air Bending: The punch does not force the material all the way to the bottom of the die,
resulting in less force needed and more flexibility in the angles achieved.
- Bottoming (Coining): The punch presses the material all the way to the bottom of the die,
resulting in more precise angles but requiring more force.
- Folding: The sheet metal is clamped and a beam is lifted to fold the material around a certain
axis.
- Wiping: A punch presses the sheet against a die, causing the material to bend around the edge
of the die.
2. Material Considerations
- Material Type: Different metals have varying properties that affect their bendability. Commonly
bent materials include aluminum, steel, stainless steel, and brass.
- Thickness: The thickness of the sheet metal influences the bending process, with thicker materials
requiring more force to bend.
- Grain Direction: Bending along the grain direction can lead to cracks and fractures, so bending
perpendicular to the grain is often preferred.
- Bend Allowance: The bend allowance accounts for the stretch of the material in the bend region.
It is the arc length of the neutral axis of the bend.
- Bend Radius: The inside radius of the bend. A larger bend radius reduces the risk of cracking and
requires less force.
Spring Back in Sheet Metal Bending
1. Definition
- Spring Back: Spring back is the tendency of metal to partially return to its original shape after
being bent. It occurs because the material undergoes elastic deformation during bending, which
partially recovers when the bending force is removed.
- Material Properties: Materials with higher yield strength and lower modulus of elasticity exhibit
more spring back.
- Bend Angle and Radius: Larger bend angles and smaller bend radii typically result in more spring
back.
- Sheet Thickness: Thicker sheets exhibit less spring back compared to thinner sheets.
- Over-Bending: Bending the material slightly beyond the desired angle to compensate for spring
back.
- Bottoming: Applying additional force at the end of the bending process to plastically deform the
material, reducing spring back.
- Using Correct Tooling: Selecting appropriate punch and die angles to minimize spring back.
- Finite Element Analysis (FEA): Using FEA simulations to predict and adjust for spring back in
complex bending operations.
- Empirical formulas and simulation software can be used to calculate the amount of spring back
and adjust the bending process accordingly.
Practical Example
Suppose you want to bend a 1 mm thick aluminum sheet at a 90-degree angle. After performing the
bend, you observe that the sheet springs back to 87 degrees. To achieve the desired 90 degrees, you
would:
1. Calculate the Spring Back Angle: The difference between the intended angle and the achieved
angle (90 - 87 = 3 degrees).
2. Adjust for Spring Back: Over-bend the sheet to 93 degrees to compensate for the 3 degrees of
spring back.
3. Perform the Bend: Bend the sheet to 93 degrees, resulting in a final angle close to 90 degrees after
spring back occurs.
Bending is a widely used process in sheet metal fabrication that involves deforming the metal
around a straight axis to create a desired shape. Like any manufacturing process, it has its
advantages and disadvantages, including considerations of springback, a common
phenomenon in bending.
1. Cost-Effective:
2. High Precision:
- Modern bending machines, such as CNC press brakes, offer high precision and
repeatability, ensuring consistent quality in production runs.
3. Versatility:
- The bending process can accommodate a wide variety of materials and thicknesses, from
thin sheets to thicker plates.
4. Strength Enhancement:
- Bending can increase the rigidity and strength of sheet metal parts without adding weight,
which is beneficial for structural applications.
- Bending can eliminate the need for additional welding or joining, reducing assembly time
and potential weak points in the product.
- Definition: Spring back is the tendency of metal to return partially to its original shape
after being bent, due to its elastic properties.
- Challenges: It can complicate the bending process by making it difficult to achieve the
exact desired angle. Engineers must account for and compensate for springback, which
requires precise calculations and sometimes trial-and-error adjustments.
2. Tooling Costs:
- While bending itself is cost-effective, the initial cost of specialized tooling (dies and
punches) can be high, particularly for custom shapes.
3. Material Limitations:
- Not all materials are equally suited for bending. Brittle materials or those with low
ductility may crack or break during the process.
4. Thickness Limitations:
- Very thick sheets or plates may be difficult to bend without specialized equipment, which
can increase costs and complexity.
5. Residual Stresses:
- Bending induces residual stresses in the material, which can affect the part's dimensional
stability and performance, particularly under dynamic or thermal loads.
- While bending is versatile, it may not be suitable for creating very complex 3D shapes
without additional processes like welding or machining.
Addressing Springback:
1. Overbending:
- Bending the metal slightly beyond the desired angle to counteract the elastic recovery that
occurs during springback.
2. Material Selection:
- Choosing materials with lower elastic modulus or higher yield strength can reduce the
extent of springback.
3. Heat Treatment:
- Applying heat to the metal before bending can reduce springback by altering the material's
mechanical properties.
4. Tooling Design:
- Using specialized dies and punches designed to minimize springback by controlling the
flow of material during bending.
- Utilizing computer simulations to predict and compensate for springback, allowing for
more precise tooling adjustments.
In conclusion, while the bending process in sheet metal fabrication offers numerous benefits
such as cost-effectiveness, high precision, and versatility, it also presents challenges,
particularly related to springback. Proper planning, material selection, and tooling design are
crucial to effectively manage these disadvantages and achieve desired results.
Applications
The bending process, including spring back compensation, is used in various industries: