Working at Heights Guide
Working at Heights Guide
www.safestart.com
4000+
Manufacturing
Retail
Transportation/Warehousing
1000+
Agriculture/Forestry
Wholesale Trade
Leisure/Hospitality
1
National Safety Council Injury Facts® 2017 Edition
www.safestart.com
THE COST OF
3
FALLING FROM Falls may not be the most common workplace incident, but
when they occur they often result in a serious injury or fatality.
HEIGHTS The hospitalization rate for falls from ladders alone is roughly
three times higher than the average injury.2
2
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR), “Occupational
Ladder Fall Injuries—United States, 2011”, 2014
3
National Safety Council Injury Facts® 2017 Edition
www.safestart.com
PLAN,
PROVIDE
4
AND The standard advice from OSHA4 on preventing falls from heights is to
plan, provide and train.
It’s good practice to follow OSHA’s plan for working at heights. But
planning, providing and training is only the start—you also need to account
for a few more crucial elements.
For a more detailed look at the standard Plan, Provide and Train approach,
visit safestar t.com/plan-provide-train
4
OSHA, “Fall Prevention Campaign”, 2017
5
PLAN PROBLEMS
WITH
Before any work is done, a thorough risk assessment should
PLANNING
be conducted for each task, and decisions have to be made
regarding the right tools and the safety equipment required.
It’s important to discuss: Planning happens ahead of time—which means that
• how to remove or minimize known it happens in a bubble. Some real-time hazards only
dangers in the work environment appear when work is underway.
• how to keep work areas clean and
Unless people are trained to recognize risk fluctuations
free of trip or slip hazards
associated with changing conditions and human factors,
• how to provide rails or boards around
elevated floors and platforms a traditional risk matrix completed ahead of time can
• which PPE should be used quickly become inaccurate.
• which tools will be needed and how to It’s also easy to fall back on plans for previous jobs if
ensure their safe and proper use you always seem to need the same type of equipment,
which can cause small but important differences to
be overlooked.
In the planning phase, avoid taking shortcuts, rushing or
only considering best-case scenarios.
Ideally, everyone involved in the planning process will
have a solid understanding of how to account for human
factors that could cause issues once work begins.
www.safestart.com
PROVIDE
Learn more about
6 influencing PPE use
in a free guide at
safestar t.com/ppe
Workers need the right equipment for the job. When working PROVIDING ISN’T
ENOUGH
at heights, this includes fall restraints and other relevant PPE,
as well as the right kinds of ladders, scaffolds and tethers.
Each worker must be provided with their own harness (in the
Having a personal fall arrest system
right size) that needs to be kept in good condition. Equipment
and using it are two different things. In
has to be in full working order and PPE should be regularly
addition to providing PPE, employers
inspected for defects and wear and tear.
need to give workers the safety
Obviously, ladders, platforms, toeboards and other structural awareness, decision-making skills and
elements must also be provided by an employer. It’s also up to habits necessary to use fall protection
supervisors to confirm that everything is set up and deployed every time their feet leave the ground.
properly.
www.safestart.com
7
TRAIN TRAINING TROUBLE
Providing training is just as important as providing the right Training can be an amazing safety tool—when it
tools and safety equipment. Workers need to know how to set works. But all too often, employees forget or forgo
up and use their equipment and understand the importance of what they learned in training and/or trainers don’t have
doing so correctly. the knowledge, time or supporting resources to teach
workers about compromising factors like human error.
This is especially true for fall protection—employees need to
It’s not just about providing training on working
know how to adjust and secure it arrest systems, in case all
at heights, but about delivering relevant training
other precautions fail.
that sticks.
Workers also need training in hazard recognition and safe Safety personnel and trainers must rely on supervisors
practices and should be given the responsibility and the right and workers after the training has concluded to ensure
to make safety their primary concern. safe practices are communicated and followed to
avoid the dangerous intersection of the complacency
curve and forgetting curve that naturally follows
any training.
www.safestart.com
EXECUTE
In the past seven years, the number of non-fatal workplace falls
has remained relatively static while the number of fatalities
8
has risen.5
FOUR
PROVIDE TRAIN THREE STEPS to Preventing Falls From Heights
EXECUTE
15
National Safety Council Injury Facts® 2017 Edition
www.safestart.com
9
EXECUTE
Planning, providing and training all happen ahead of
time. Once someone starts working at heights, it’s up to
them to put their training and equipment to good use.
COMPLACENCY
AND THE
10
NORMALIZATION Workers don’t have to work at great heights to risk injury or
death because more than 40% of fatal falls occur from 15 feet
OF RISK or lower.6 The most common height to fall from? Only 6-10 feet.
It’s such a common height to fall from because even though fall
protection is required, it doesn’t seem far off the ground and
workers are less likely to treat it with respect. But the stats don’t
lie—plenty of people fall less than 10 feet and falls from that
height cause over 25% of all fall-related deaths.7
One industry where falls are the biggest concern: Workers may wear their harnesses at heights where the danger
construction. Falls from roofs, ladders and scaffolds is more glaring, but 6 feet can seem like a non-issue for someone
account for nearly 40% of fatalities in the private who regularly works at 30 feet or more.
construction industry. 6
When people work above ground level all day, every day, they
can become complacent with heights. Risk is the norm and even
huge elevations can quickly become familiar, even comfortable.
6
Bureau of Labor Statistics, Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries Summary, 2015
7
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR), “Occupational
Ladder Fall Injuries—United States, 2011”, 2014
RECOGNIZING
AND
OFFSETTING
11
COMPOUNDING
RISK
The higher you work, the greater the risk. Most workers
generally understand this. But fewer people realize how
COMMON RISK
other factors increase the risk exponentially with each new ELEMENTS WHEN
risk factor. WORKING AT HEIGHTS
This means each missing safeguard and each human factor
that is present will increase the likelihood of a fall.
Safeguards not in place
Risk compounds in a way that is too complex to compute in
real time. But it’s possible to offset compounding risk elements Bad working conditions
without complicated calculations. In reality, only three things
are required: Rushing
Knowledge that risk expands as more elements Frustration
are present.
Do workers understand that the likelihood and potential
Fatigue
severity of injury increases as risk grows?
12
HUMAN STATES Fatigue alone
is one of the
RUSHING
ERROR FRUSTRATION most overlooked
FATIGUE
escalators of risk.
COMPLACENCY
Physical protection is vital to safety, but so is human action.
And people are much more likely to make mistakes or make 40% of workers
the wrong decision when they’re frustrated, rushing, fatigued regularly operate
or complacent.
at three times the
These states can lead workers to stop watching or thinking ERRORS risk due to fatigue.
about what they’re doing, lose their footing or drop an object.
EYES NOT ON TASK
MIND NOT ON TASK Learn more in a
Any of the four states can turn a perfectly safe situation into a
LINE OF FIRE free webinar at
dangerous one.
BALANCE/TRACTION/GRIP
safestart.com/
webinars
OUTCOMES
INJURY
NEAR-MISS
EQUIPMENT DAMAGE/LOSS
PRODUCTION SLOWDOWN
www.safestart.com
ADDRESSING
THE CAUSES
OF
There are two big instigators of human error: structural/production issues and personal
13
HUMAN issues. When physical or organizational work factors cause the four states, it’s time to address
ERROR
the cause. This can mean providing more breaks to avoid fatigue or renegotiating deadlines to
reduce rushing. Here are two examples of what this problem could look like in the workplace.
ERRORS
EYES NOT ON TASK
ERRORS
EYES NOT ON TASK
MIND NOT ON TASK MIND NOT ON TASK
LINE OF FIRE LINE OF FIRE
BALANCE/TRACTION/GRIP BALANCE/TRACTION/GRIP
www.safestart.com
14
SUPERVISORY It’s clear that risk can be normalized—and
it’s up to safety professionals to change
they’re used properly and tied to a larger
human error program.
HABITS are an
effective safety
tool. They function
15
EXECUTION Once workers have the training and experience to safely work at heights,
companies need to help them keep their skills and attention sharp. Many
as an execution aid
by guiding workers
AIDS employers make use of passive execution aids like safety posters or
reminders about PPE requirements. to act safely even
But don’t overlook more active execution aids. They take a bit more effort when they’re
but they can engage workers in ways that banners and slogans can’t. affected by adverse
mental states.
16
REDUCING
COMPLACENCY
Complacency is a complicated and stubborn issue. When it KNOWLEDGE
comes to working at heights, it’s also the most common state. Classroom training to understand complacency
Share stories to drive home the importance
That’s why addressing it takes a multi-pronged approach. of safety when working at heights
Toolbox talks are great on a day-to-day basis but the problem Introduce cards or other materials to help
also requires periodic and focused attention. workers track levels of complacency
ORGANIZATIONAL SUPPORT
Supervisors dedicated to fighting complacency
One-on-one conversations and reminders
Steady rotation of toolbox talks and safety posters
www.safestart.com
KNOWLEDGE
Complacency can’t be controlled until everyone
understands what it is and how it works.
17
PREVENTING
HUMAN
ERROR
WITH
REAL-TIME
18
AWARENESS STATES
RUSHING
FRUSTRATION
It’s not always possible to avoid states like rushing, frustration, FATIGUE
fatigue and complacency. Sometimes rushing or working long COMPLACENCY
hours to stay on schedule is unavoidable.
OUTCOMES
INJURY
NEAR-MISS
EQUIPMENT DAMAGE/LOSS
PRODUCTION SLOWDOWN
www.safestart.com
HARNESSING IT
19
ALL
TOGETHER
The most effective way to provide knowledge, real-time skills SAFESTART
and organizational support is to bundle it all into a single Knowing that human error increases risk is only the very
program. It takes a lot of expertise, practice and support to first step in preventing negative outcomes. SafeStart
conquer human error and build the engagement needed for a provides training to educate workers on human error
strong culture of safety. and then give them practical skills and awareness to
stay safe every single day.
To truly keep workers safe at heights, you need to address
human error—and that requires a comprehensive solution SafeStart checks all the boxes to deal with human error
that helps everyone to do their part to keep themselves and in your working at height safety program, including:
others safe. human error training
better risk awareness
complacency reduction
habit-building support
supervisory component
SafeStart also makes it efficient for companies and
people by solving not only falls from heights, but an
endless list of other serious challenges from slips and
trips to back injuries and distracted driving. Because
SafeStart knowledge and skills are transferable,
workers will be safer no matter where they are or what
they’re doing.
www.safestart.com
20
LEARN
MORE
We hope that you found this guide
helpful. For more insight into a variety REGISTER
of safety problems—and their potential
solutions—check out our collection of
TODAY About SafeStart
on-demand webinars
SafeStart is a safety company dedicated
safestart.com/webinars to reducing preventable deaths and
injuries both on and off the job by making
human factors more understandable,
safety training more personable, and
giving organizations around the world a
more engaging and useful approach to
keeping people safe.