Benchling Ebook Primer Design
Benchling Ebook Primer Design
benchling.com
Table of Contents
Primer Design 2 What to Avoid When Designing Primers for PCR 16
• Repeats/Runs 16
1. The Science Behind Primers 3
• Cross homology 16
What are primers? 3
• Primer Secondary Structure and Gibbs Free Energy 16
• W
hat types of primers are there?
• Template secondary structure 19
RNA primers vs. DNA primers 3
Primers in DNA replication 4
3. In Silico Primer Design Tools 19
• Forward and Reverse Primers 5
Desktop vs. Cloud-Based Primer Design Tools 19
Primers in DNA Amplification and Scientific Applications 6
• Primer3 and Primer3Plus 20
• Primer Design for Cloning 7
• NCBI Blast 20
- Primer Design for Digest and Ligate Cloning Method 8
- Primer Design for the Golden Gate Cloning Method 9 4. Benchling’s Molecular Biology Tools 21
- Primer Design for the Gibson Cloning Method 10 Design Primers with Benchling 22
• Manual Primer Design 23
2. Primer Design for PCR 11
• Wizard Primer Design 26
Best Practices for PCR Primer Design 13
• Search, Import, and Attach Existing Primers Easily 27
• Primer Length 13
• Send Primers to NCBI Blast 30
• Primer Melting Temperature (Tm) 13
• Build Custom Primer Libraries 30
• Primer Annealing temperature (Ta) 14
• In silico PCR within Benchling 31
• Primer GC Content and GC Clamp 15
• Free Primer Design Tools for Academics 32
• Set Restriction Enzyme Cut Sites 15
• Request a Demo of Benchling 33
• End Stability 15
Benchling Primer Design and Molecular Biology Resources 34
benchling.com 1
Primer Design
Primers are key ingredients in DNA synthesis, a process that occurs
in sequencing, cloning, PCR, and other molecular biology methods
in the lab. With Benchling, teams can easily access shared primer
libraries, upload new primer sequences, or design brand new primers.
Link primer information directly in the Benchling Notebook and
Benchling Registry providing full traceability for every experiment
where a primer was used. Be able to easily attribute results from
experiments with the exact set of primers used, or see which
sequences a primer is associated with. Once primers are designed,
run in silico PCR, or use them to plan critical tasks such as restriction
cloning, Golden Gate assembly, and Gibson cloning.
benchling.com 2
Section 1 The Science Behind Primers
benchling.com 3
The binding of DNA or RNA primers to the template strand initiates the enzyme responsible for DNA
synthesis, DNA polymerase, to begin adding nucleotides to the reactive 3’-hydroxyl end (called the
“3 prime end”) of a existing nucleic acid on the primer, elongating and replicating the parent strand.
DNA replication begins at an origin of replication, which is identified by proteins called initiators
that latch and make small openings in the double-stranded DNA double (dsDNA) helix. At these
breaks, helicase enzymes break the bonds between the double strands, exposing single-stranded
DNA (ssDNA) in a Y-shaped end called the DNA replication fork. The replication fork is where DNA
replication will actually occur, providing two strands of parent DNA now exposed to act as the DNA
template (gray strands below).
benchling.com 4
Next, RNA primase lays down the RNA primer on each of the parent template strands, providing
the 3’ end for a new polynucleotide strand to begin forming. DNA polymerase binds and synthesis
is initiated, with daughter strands being formed (purple strands). In this diagram, the top daughter
strand is called the leading strand and is exposed in the 5 prime (5’) → 3’ prime (3’) direction right to
left, allowing DNA synthesis to occur continuously as the helix unwinds.
Lagging strand synthesis of the bottom daughter strand occurs in the 5’ → 3’ direction left to right,
where DNA synthesis must continually start over as the helix unwinds. This creates many short
fragments of synthesized products, known as Okazaki fragments which average ~150-200 nucleotides
long. Each Okazaki fragment contains an RNA-DNA joint as a consequence of RNA priming, a
discovery that was important evidence for determining the role of RNA primers in DNA replication.
Okazaki fragments must be joined together by the enzyme ligase, which catalyzes the formation of
covalent phosphodiester bonds between two strands of DNA, ligating them together.
benchling.com 5
A pair of primers must be used, one for the top strand and one for the bottom. The primer pair binds
on opposite ends of the sequence being amplified, with their 3’ ends pointing toward each other.
The oligonucleotide primers being designed do not actually have to hybridize completely to the
template strand; it is essential, however, that the 3’ end corresponds completely to the template
DNA for elongation to occur. The forward primer anneals to the bottom strand that runs 3’ to 5’, and
the reverse primer anneals to the complementary bottom strand of DNA that runs 5’ to 3’. After
elongation, this results in two new strands of double-stranded DNA: one made from the forward
primer; and the other made from the reverse primer.
In order for the primers to bind to the template strand, it’s important they are not complementary to
each other. Primers complementary to each other can result in the creation of primer dimers, which
are two primers binding to each other instead of the template strand. Primer dimers are discussed in
detail in the section on what to avoid when designing primers for PCR.
benchling.com 6
Primer Design for Cloning
Molecular cloning is an important technique that allows scientists to replicate specific target
segments of DNA in host cells. The target gene or fragment of interest can be inserted into a cloning
vector, generally a circular prokaryotic plasmid genome (sometimes simply called a plasmid vector),
which can then be transformed and taken up by a specific recipient cell line, usually a bacterial cell.
The vector will then be incorporated into the host genome via DNA recombination, and as the cell line
naturally undergoes DNA replication as outlined above, the target gene of interest will also replicate,
or begin being cloned.
benchling.com 7
Primer Design for Digest and Ligate Cloning Method
Common restriction enzymes (also called restriction endonucleases) such as EcoR1 recognize
and cut at specific palindromic restriction sites in the plasmid. EcoR1 cuts in a zig-zag across the
double-stranded DNA creating sticky ends, or single-stranded DNA overhangs of a few base pairs
long. Other enzymes like Alu1 are blunt end restriction enzymes that create blunt ends without
overhangs. Generally, the same restriction enzymes that cut the plasmid are also used to digest the
gene of interest out of its parent DNA, creating complementary sticky ends in the plasmid and target
sequence. Once the two are combined in solution, the target fragment can ligate into the plasmid
through hydrogen bonding. Gaps are again filled by DNA ligase and the plasmid is ready to be used in
further experiments, such as transformation.
This is considered the traditional digest and ligate method that will ultimately create recombinant
DNA. Recombinant DNA is formed in the laboratory by combining genetic material from multiple
sources, including DNA material from two different species.
EcoR1
recognition
sequence
GA
AT T
Ligate
A AG
C
T T
Gene of
Plasmid with interest Create Recombinant
restriction site sticky ends plasmid DNA
Figure 3. The process of digestion and ligation cleaves a plasmid at a specific site
and adds a gene of interest into the plasmid.
benchling.com 8
Another common alternative is to design primers with restriction sites at their 5’ ends. After PCR, this
creates a copy of the target DNA region with restriction sites needed at the end of the fragment. This
method is used when there may not be restriction sites for the same enzymes in the correct place in
both the vector and insert.
Traditional digest and ligate methods limit scientists to a single insert per cloning cycle. Advances in
cloning technologies have focused more on the assembly of multiple DNA fragments, which is made
much more efficient with assembly techniques such as Golden Gate cloning and Gibson cloning.
Designing primers for Golden Gate cloning is automatic with Benchling’s primer design and DNA
assembly tools. For Golden Gate, the PCR primers should overlap adjacent DNA fragments to include
restriction sites and be designed in a way that when digested with a Type IIS enzyme, directional
assembly of the fragments is possible with DNA ligase.
Benchling’s Golden Gate Assembly wizard tool was built in conjunction with scientists from New
England Biolabs. The assembly wizard helps to automate the time-consuming and error-prone
benchling.com 9
process of selecting appropriate sticky ends, while also supporting more complex techniques like site-
directed mutagenesis and the integration of spacers between fragments.
benchling.com 10
Section 2 Primer Design for PCR
The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is one of the most important methods in molecular biology.
Millions or billions of copies of a selected gene or specific DNA fragment can be created in a few
hours from a small sample and simple ingredients. The is known as PCR amplification, or gene
amplification. These millions or billions of DNA fragments are called PCR products and can be used
in various ways post-amplification. If you need an in-depth reminder on how PCR works, please see
this video review.
The main components of PCR are dsDNA, free nucleotides, a custom designed PCR primer pair,
a heat stable Taq polymerase, and a thermocycler. A typical PCR reaction involves mixing these
ingredients in a test tube with buffers and putting them through repeated cycles of heating and
cooling with a thermocycler.
Heating separates, or denatures, Cooling allows primers to bind to Raising the temperature slightly allows
dsDNA into ssDNA. the complementary sequence on Taq polymerase to bind to the 3’ primer
the single-stranded DNA template, end and begin synthesizing new strands of
known as primer annealing. DNA, known as primer extension.
These steps are repeated for 25-35 cycles. Every new DNA that is synthesized from the round before
can serve as a template for the next round, creating exponential growth of the target DNA. If a high
quality, purified DNA template was used and there were no issues with PCR reaction, the target region
can go from a single template to several copies to upwards of billions.
benchling.com 11
Figure 5. Designing primers for PCR requires DNA primer pairs, free nucleotides, and target DNA. Step 1.
Denaturation separates the two strands of DNA Step 2. Primers join, or anneal, to the individual strands of
the target DNA Step 3. Primer DNA is extended at the primer’s 3’ end. Steps 1-3 are then repeated.
Designing primers for PCR is essential for successful PCR reactions and initiating DNA amplification.
PCR primers must be custom designed to be complementary to the template region of DNA and
must code for only the specific upstream and downstream DNA sites of the sequence being
amplified. Therefore, it’s key that sufficient sequence information is known of the template DNA
before undertaking primer design. Using in silico molecular biology tools, as discussed below, is a
great way to understand the target sequence you are working with.
benchling.com 12
2.1 Best Practices for PCR Primer Design
In order to achieve successful DNA amplification, it’s imperative to understand how to design a primer
and start off with the right primer pair. Here are some primer tips and characteristics you should
consider when designing primers.
Primer Length
The optimal primer length is 18-25 bp. The primer should be short enough to bind easily during
the annealing step, but not too short as short primeres can result in nonspecific binding and thus
inaccurate PCR products. The primer should be long enough for adequate specificity, but not longer
than >30 bp as that may slow down the hybridization rate. Primer length and composition also
directly affects primer melting and annealing temperatures.
Optimal primer pair melting temperatures are between 50° to 60°, and within 5° of each other.
Primer pairs should have similar melting temperatures since annealing during PCR occurs for both
strands simultaneously. Mishybridization may occur if the melting temperature of each primer
benchling.com 13
is too high or low relative to the annealing temperature for the reaction. If too low, the formation
of undesired, non-specific duplexes or intramolecular hairpins will occur, or the primers may not
anneal to the template strand at all. If too high, there may be secondary annealing. A primer melting
temperature calculator is found inside of Benchling using your choice of either two algorithms: Saint
Lucia of Modified Breslauer.
Primers with higher G/C content will exhibit higher melting temperatures because G-C hydrogen
bonds are harder to break than A-T hydrogen bonds, thus requiring more energy (a higher
temperature) to melt. If the melting temperature of your primer is very low, try to use a G-C heavy
primer or extend the length of the primer slightly.
Tm(primer) Tm(product)
Melting temperature of the least stable Melting temperature of the PCR product
primer-template pair
Optimal annealing temperature is discovered empirically, but generally it is less than the primer
melting temperature (Tm) by about 5° - 10°. If primer annealing temperature is too high it’s likely the
primers will not sufficiently bind, resulting in little to zero amplicons. If primer annealing temperature
is too low, primers may begin forming hairpins (discussed more below) or binding to regions outside of
the target sequence, leading to nonspecific, inaccurate PCR products.
benchling.com 14
One common way to find the initial optimal annealing temperature is to perform a temperature
gradient PCR, or thermal gradient PCR, starting at about 5° below the lowest melting temperature of
the primer pair.
End Stability
Primer end stability is the maximum ΔG value of the five bases from the 3’ end of the primer, or the
maximum ΔG value of where the primer should bind. A stable 3’ end (a more negative ΔG) will help
reduce false priming. Read more about Gibbs Free Energy (ΔG) below.
benchling.com 15
2.2 What to Avoid When Designing Primers for PCR
In order to achieve successful DNA amplification, it’s imperative to understand how to design a primer
and start off with the right primer pair. Here are some primer tips and characteristics you should
consider when designing primers.
Repeats/Runs
Avoid runs of four or more of a single base (e.g., ACCCCC), or four or more dinucleotide repeats (e.g.,
ATATATATAT) as they will cause mispriming.
Cross homology
Cross homology is seen when the primer designed is homologous to other regions of the template
strand, and the outcome is amplification of other genes outside the region of interest. Cross homology is
generally avoided by sending the sequence of your designed primers to test its specificity against genetic
databases. By sending primers through the NCBI BLAST software, as you easily can on Benchling, you
can identify regions of significant cross homologies, helping you avoid them in primer design.
benchling.com 16
Primer Secondary Structure and Gibbs Free Energy
Secondary structures are created when primers fold in on themselves or bind to each other. Often
called primer dimers, these “bad” primers interfere with primer annealing to the template strand and/
or reduce the availability of “good” primers in the PCR reaction, and ultimately will affect the yield of
high quality PCR products. These are usually caused by intra- or inter-primer homology:
A region of 3 or more bases that are Forward and reverse primers that have
complementary to another region within the complementary sequences, causing intermolecular
same primer, causing intramolecular bonding. bonding.
Primer dimer analysis should be performed before using primers in the lab, which includes visualizing
secondary structures and determining the Gibbs free energy (ΔG) for each possible primer dimer. Both
of these primer dimer checks can easily be performed in Benchling. In general, a dimer formed closer
to the 3’ end is much more detrimental than a dimer formed near the 5’ end.
Gibbs free energy ΔG in primer design is the amount of energy needed for a primer to form a particular
secondary structure with itself. In general, ΔG represents the spontaneity of a reaction when held
at a constant temperature and pressure. Structures with a higher ΔG (greater than 0, or positive ΔG)
require an input of energy (heat) to form, so there is a lower likelihood they will form spontaneously
without extra energy. Secondary structures with a lower ΔG (negative ΔG) will happen easily and
spontaneously without additional energy. Very negative ΔG numbers indicate there’s an affinity to
form that structure and it will likely require a lot of heat to reverse the dimer back to linear form, thus
more stable secondary structures (larger negative ΔG values) should be avoided.
benchling.com 17
Commonly observed primer dimer secondary structures and their ΔG values in kcal/mol include:
Having a balance of GC-rich and AT-rich domains help avoid secondary structures. Primer design tools
like Benchling can also help detect secondary structures. Do not design primers that allow secondary
structures to remain stable above the annealing temperatures; they will be unable to bind to the
template strand and initiate DNA synthesis, and PCR product yield will be lowered. In other words, if
the ΔG for a secondary structure is so negative (-9 kcal/mol for example), then even the heat of the
annealing temperature will not be able to break the structure back into its original linear form, and it
will not bind to the template strand during the annealing phase.
benchling.com 18
Section 3 In Silico Primer Design Tools
In silico modeling and design is a crucial step used both to prepare for and to document a variety of
protocols and experiments done in the lab. Software tools used for modeling range from desktop
applications, to online cloud-based systems, like Benchling. These tools are important for modern
labs as they help maintain institutional knowledge, manage experimental traceability and data, and
automate result capture.
Benchling’s Molecular Biology Suite is a comprehensive set of in silico tools that can model a variety
of protocols beyond primer design, including plasmid design, cloning, sequencing, assembly methods,
CRISPR, DNA alignments, codon optimizations, CRISPR gRNA design, and more. After primer design,
performing an in silico PCR allows scientists to use their amplified gene of interest to model
downstream procedures also, such as cloning or assembly methods.
Despite the fact that molecular biology has evolved tremendously over the last decade, most
molecular biology software tools are point solutions that were not built for modern, complex
scientific workflows. With point solutions, R&D organizations may struggle to tie downstream assay
data back to the primers used, or figure out which primers and vectors were already designed and
benchling.com 19
stored in their inventory system. Simply, they lack automated traceability of what was performed
after primer design. Many companies are left managing processes using pen and paper, spreadsheets,
and wasting precious lab hours on manual work. This slows down research and introduces risks
into process development and scale up. Desktop point solutions can also be difficult to maintain,
and ultimately do not allow organizations to fully leverage their data and maintain institutional
knowledge long-term.
NCBI Blast
NCBI Blast is a suite of programs started in 1991 by the U.S.
National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI). Basic
Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) can identify regions of
local similarity between experimental/query sequences and a database of reference sequences. By
comparing nucleotide sequences to different sequence databases, the tool is able to provide detailed
statistical significance reports of any matches. There are various BLAST algorithms, including those
to help identify genomes (RNA or DNA nucleotide sequences), targeted sections like SNPs, and even
proteins. Every query a scientist makes using BLAST is stored forever, creating an ever-growing library
of referenceable sequences that adds to the tools’ accuracy.
benchling.com 20
Section 4 Benchling’s Molecular Biology Tools
Primer design may seem straightforward; afterall, primers are less than 30 base pairs long! But
with so many sensitive primer characteristics to consider, along with the sheer volume of primers a
researcher might need to create, it can be daunting to keep the process organized and traceable.
Benchling’s Molecular Biology application enables intelligent primer design, either manually
or automatically with the wizard. With intelligent permission systems, you can set up which
teams have access to which projects. Teams then can save primers in custom or shared
libraries for future reference or further collaboration and design. In the primer tool, Benchling
scans and detects binding sites on sequences, allowing you to accurately attach primers, run
in silico PCR, and use PCR products to plan critical tasks such as digest and ligate methods,
Gibson Cloning, and Golden Gate Assembly.
The application is a powerful tool that’s used for more than just designing primers. With 10+
tools in one unified platform, you can also create sequence annotations, perform alignments,
and design CRISPR guide RNAs (gRNAs). You can easily share and store designs as well, since
the tool is integrated with Benchling’s cloud-based Notebook and Registry.
benchling.com 21
Sequence Alignment AA / Protein Analysis Sequence Visualization
benchling.com 22
You can design primers in Benchling either manually or with the Primer Wizard. If your primer is
already designed, you can also easily find any existing primers to attach to your sequence, or import
oligos into Benchling. Let’s see what Benchling’s primer design tool can do.
benchling.com 23
Manual Primer Design
You may want to create primers manually in the Benchling platform from sequences that your
organization already uses. To design primers manually, highlight a region of template DNA on the
sequence map by selecting the desired range, right clicking, and choosing to create either the forward
or reverse primer.
benchling.com 24
Next, in the Design tab, you can focus on the bases of the selected sequence, designate an overhang,
and incorporate restriction enzyme cut sites.
After designing, quickly verify your primers automatically in the Verify tab. The following are all
accessible within the interface:
benchling.com 25
You can even adjust thermodynamic parameters to modify how melting temperature is computed
by clicking the wrench icon. Once design is complete, assign a name to the primer and save it in the
primer library.
benchling.com 26
Figure 8a. Primer design in Benchling with wizard
benchling.com 27
Search existing primers that bind to your sequence based on specific primer parameters, such as
length, melting temperature and number of allowed mismatches, and Benchling will show their
stored locations. Select the desired primers and view them bound to the sequence map.
Alternatively, import primers via the Import Oligios feature in Benchling and quickly add any of your
organizations pre-existing primers.
This is especially useful if you are migrating any primers to Benchling from a different tool, such as
Vector NTI, Snapgene, or Geneious. Benchling supports a variety of sequence file types, and carries
over any annotations and tags associated with the sequences.
benchling.com 28
Figure 8c. Primer design in Benchling with wizard
Finally, once designed or saved, you can attach primers to your selected sequence. All saved primers
are listed in the primer tool menu for whatever sequence file you are working on.
Attaching existing primers in Benchling allows you to automatically find existing primers that bind to
your sequence, quickly visualize primer binding sites, and view all of the sequence files which any oligo
file (the primer) has been attached to.
benchling.com 29
Send Primers to NCBI Blast
With Benchling, a user can easily verify primers’ specificity by sending the oligonucleotides through
the NCBI Blast primer tool. Once inside Benchling, simply click and drag the sequence map to
highlight the primer (or any other sequence of interest), right-click, and send to NCBI Blast. The
sequence is sent to the BLASTN program, which searches against nucleotides.
NCBI provides the NCBI Primer Blast tool for primer creation, but it requires you to type in or copy/
paste your oligo sequence every time for primer creation. And once created, you must continually
import the designed primer into Benchling or your molecular biology tool. Simply using Benchling will
give you one central location for the entire workflow, while still allowing you to easily send your oligos
to NCBI’s primer blasting tool.
benchling.com 30
In silico PCR within Benchling
With Benchling, a user can easily verify primers’ specificity by sending the oligonucleotides through
After designing the primers, you can run PCR in silico with Benchling. Simply select the forward and
reverse primers, link them as a pair and create PCR products with two clicks.
benchling.com 31
Once functional primers are designed and PCR products (amplicons) are amplified, the Benchling
platform can continue to model downstream procedures such as digestions and ligations, plasmid
design, transfection, and cloning methods such as Gibson and Golden Gate Assembly.
A user can “@” mention any of the PCR products, digests, plasmids, or primer files directly in a
Notebook entry and register them automatically inside the Benchling Registry. Link any of these
in silico procedures to the actual sample used in the lab with the Benchling Inventory. By linking
these designs to physical products in the lab, Benchling gives you a central location to access all
experimental data and share it with different scientists and teams.
benchling.com 32
With more than 180,000 academics using Benchling around the world, we are invested in building the
next generation of biologists. Having access to free, modern, user-friendly tools allows the academic
community to make ground-breaking discoveries faster and spend less time taking notes in paper
notebooks, digging for data across disconnected tools, and completing error-prone manual data entry.
Here are some helpful tips for academics from Benchling for Academics users on how they use the tool
to elevate their research.
Benchling for Academics is also useful to Professors and science teachers. Instructors may now be
faced with the added challenge of teaching courses remotely due to the coronavirus pandemic. Without
access to wet lab courses, it can be tough for students to grasp the concepts behind molecular biology
techniques. But with the right approach, professors and teachers can use Benchling to adapt lab courses
for virtual learning.
Primer design is just the beginning of what Benchling offers our customers.
Benchling is a fully integrated life sciences R&D platform that supports
scientist productivity, sample tracking, process management, and analytics.
Used by over 230,000 scientists globally across multinational pharmaceutical
corporations, leading biotech companies, and major research institutions,
Benchling is the leader in cloud informatics for life science R&D.
benchling.com 33
Benchling Primer Design and Molecular Biology Resources
• Benchling’s Molecular Biology Tool
• Primers FAQ
benchling.com