Judgment Sheet
Name of Judge ( Reg no)
Causte Title
Petitioner/Appellant ( Reg No)
Respondent (Reg no)
Sl.N Marking Criteria Petitioner Appellant Remarks
o
1 Issues were clearly stated (10)
2 Clarity on Facts (10)
3 Understanding of applicable
laws (10)
4 Validity of contentions (10)
5 Ability to use legal reasoning for
arguments
6 Ability to LAW to facts(10)
7 Use of precedents (10)
8 Eloquence (10) (use of
language)
9 Ability to raise counter
arguments
10 Dress Code & Body language
(5) and courtroom etiquette (05)
Structure of Judgment
Sl.No Points to be considered Judgment
1 Major issue between the parties
(10)
2 Laws involved in the case (10)
3 Identification of correct precedents
(10)
4 Core arguments of P/R (10)
5 Application of law to facts (10)
7 Legal reasoning by petitioner (10)
8 Legal reasoning by Respondent
9 Prayer by P?R (10)
10 Dress code & Courtroom etiquette
(for judge)