Unit 2
Unit 2
2.1 INTRODUCTION
The creative artist seeks to capture the inchoate world in a certain form, so that it
could make some sense. Thus, there has to be a formal structure to the short
story you wish to write⎯an arrangement of characters interacting with incidents/
situations ⎯ for greater effectiveness. However, your skill lies in making it
appear that it is no conscious arrangement, no contrivance, no ‘plot’ to deceive
the reader, and that it could well have happened that way.
69
Modes of Creative Writing It is not possible to devise a plot which would interest everybody. There are
some readers who hate to think, while there are others who want their stories to
be no more than escape sessions, in between the serious business of their daily
life. There is also a small minority who would go to the other extreme and insist
on their money’s worth of nutrition, such as philosophy, morality, knowledge
and what-have-you, with each story. So the best you can do is to attempt enticing
an adult of more-than-average intelligence who has a zest for life as well as for
learning. This implies that you are a serious writer, but not a philosopher or
saint. All you can do is to try to make your stories acquire the status of serious
literature, and yet hope that they will sell. Discussed below are some factors that
give form to your story and make it interesting, plausible and meaningful.
2.3 ATMOSPHERE
Atmosphere is an integral part of fiction. It enables a writer to establish life
likeness and win the reader’s willingness to accept the world created by the
storyteller. Atmosphere is as necessary for fiction as it is for our planet. Life-
forms and characters would not be able to survive without it. Atmosphere is,
therefore, one of the basic elements in a short story. It creates the mood as well
as the psychological and physical effects appropriate to the theme of the story.
By setting a story in an appropriate time and place, you lend it verisimilitude and
authenticity.
Atmosphere binds the story together; sets the time-frame⎯past, present or future;
creates the psychological mood in the reader; and establishes the locale. Thus,
atmosphere helps the writer in creating the texture of his imagined world, with
its characters, locale and environment.
Hopelessly, he even turned a few knobs, waiting for a picture, any picture, to
appear. He rotated the antenna and pushed the set at a new angle. Now he
had missed the opening of the Festival of Russia.
Do you need to be told that it is the very recent past that’s being talked about?
Again, read this:
The spaceship had taken off just a minute ago. The bushes were still shaking
and the dust hadn’t settled down. Now he was stuck, for good, on this
unfamiliar red planet since the next space-shuttle would land there long after
his energy tablets were finished.
Clearly, this deals with the future when interplanetary travel will become a reality.
Historical fiction, of course, requires its ‘period setting’, costumery and the use
of language current in that period. The prejudices, modes of thought and beliefs
of the time would also have to be given due consideration.
There are two men sitting in a train compartment. After some time the first
man asks the second, “Do you believe in ghosts?” “No”, he replies, and
vanishes.
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
........................................................................................................................
(Check your answer with the hints given at the end of the unit.)
73
Modes of Creative Writing
2.4 CHARACTER
When planning a story at what stage does one start thinking about its characters?
The question resolves into a consideration of what comes first at the conceptual
stage⎯the plot, i.e. the total framework, or the characters, who are but a
component of the plot. This is largely a matter of strategy. In a conventional
short story it would be useful to lay down the structure first, as it is the turn of
events that provides the result, and then summon the characters. But if the result
consists in the surprise provided by the twists or turnabouts of the characters, or
in an essentially intellectual or psychological revelation, it would be better to
choose the characters carefully before setting out the plot. This is because the
mental equipment and conditioning of the characters is relatively more important
than the situations they are required to handle. In choosing your characters you
have to bear in mind that there is hardly any place in a short story, as distinguished
from a novel, where a character is not called upon to make a substantial
contribution to the story.
Thus you should exercise utmost economy in the number of characters you choose
for a story; and you should choose only such characters as you can visualize in
fairly clear dimensions right at the start; or are confident of making whole and
full-bodied during the course of the story.
2.5.1 Anti-Hero
The anti-hero story is a marked feature of the twentieth century. It is closely
connected with changes in traditional values and life styles. The term ‘hero’
normally brings to mind a person somewhat larger than life (the heroes of Greek
tragedies or the heroes on the screens of our Hindi films). He is usually someone
of a commanding presence, as great in life as in death⎯noble, proud and almost
overwhelming. Such nobility of human beings has become increasingly dubious,
if not outright comic in our age, where wars can be triggered off by someone
pressing a button, and computers are made responsible for planning our lives,
our careers, our industry, and even our marriages.
Human nature is seldom, if at all, uni-dimensional. Stories with what we call an
anti-hero offer greater opportunity to the writer to depict human nature in all its
complexity. R.K. Narayan’s characters in his Malgudi stories belong to this
category. The anti-hero is complex, variable and ambiguous, in contrast to the
traditional hero of romances who is handsome, fundamentally decent and good-
hearted, even when he defies law and order.
The anti-hero story is mainly a twentieth century development and is the product
of a people’s awareness against the forces of oppression and injustice. He is the
despised and the disinherited: a peasant, a farmer, a coolie or an untouchable:
the ‘scum’ of society, one who challenges the concept of ‘noble descent’, of
racial, feudal and class superiority. He struggles to assert his identity as a human
being. He wishes to be treated on par with others. The protagonists of Premchand,
Gorky and Anand are anti-heroes of this kind.
Late twentieth century fiction is significant, because it presents before us a society
that has endured unforeseen technological and material innovations. Ironically,
as this society has become richer, the human soul has become poorer. The hero
as spy, in the works of some of the best writers of murder mysteries today, is not
the traditional hero like the ever-optimistic James Bond who is loyal to the crown
and to the traditional values. In the hands of authors like John Le Carre, he
becomes both a political analyst and a sad and lonely individual in the decadent
field of international espionage. He reveals to us the basic futility of his
supposedly noble trade, and his yearning for the common, daily world of family
affection and traditions, friendship and love, which are almost outdated. The
very title of the novel, A Perfect Spy, is bristling with irony, as is the hero narrator,
76 who unfolds its complex world.
2.5.2 Anti-Plot Short Story Writing
The earliest storytellers were not bothered by considerations of form. They simply
spun a tale⎯ ‘Once upon a time….’, and narrated the story in a straight line, the
chronology and the plot progressing together. In the course of storytelling they
would often put in their own ideas and comments and close the tale with a moral.
Form, or the shape in which a story was presented, became a serious consideration
when stories began to be recorded in print.
In the traditional story, a major element is the plot which, as we all know, refers
to the sequence of related incidents which make up a narrative. Plot is the easiest
element in a story to understand, and beginners often tend to think that the plot is
the story. For a mature writer, however, this is not so. He or she writes a short
story, not to demonstrate how b follows a, and c follows b, but because the whole
story ultimately presents a deep insight into human life or character. The writer
may begin——‘Let’s suppose that a shy, timid, but romantically imaginative
young man is invited to a party, at which he receives an eager kiss in the dark
from an unknown young woman, who has mistaken him for her lover.’ (‘The
Kiss’ by Chekhov). Here the author of the story challenges the conventions of
the traditional story-form by allowing his narrator-writer to make the statement
that the plot of the story he is writing is imaginary. The reader is warned against
implicit belief in the story as a form that relates events as they actually happen.
The traditional plot having a beginning, middle and an end, with a chronological
progression of events was too patterned and artificial to reflect the complex nature
of modern reality. The revolutionary impact of science and technology on life,
breakdown of faith in Providence and the Divine scheme of things, researches in
depth psychology, and man’s continuing struggle against different forms of
oppression, gave rise to several new insights. The traditional plot thus became
an insufficient and imperfect medium to express the many-sided realities of
contemporary life.
A writer of a modern short story is more self-conscious. We now realize that
there are many ways of telling a short story. The writer, for instance, may choose
a method, and even set up his or her own rules. The plot of the story and whether
it is the author, the characters or one special character who spins it, becomes less
important, than how it is spun. The viewpoint presented by the story is here the
single most important factor, and not the moral of the tale: messages are rarely, if
ever, clearly stated.
The ultimate purpose of every short story writer is to communicate an aspect of
the truth of life as seen and experienced by himself, and personal truth rarely has
a beginning, middle or an end.
Thus authors naturally find a creative outlet in stories which challenge the
commonly held concept of a plot as a sequence of happenings, with a beginning,
a middle and an end. Their aim is basically interpretative, and not the recounting
of the factual details of our daily lives, or a narration of complicated happenings,
all unraveled at the end (as in a detective or a romantic adventure story).
Frequently, the ultimate appeal of the anti-plot stories to the reader’s sense of
truth, is made through symbolism or allegory. Consider, for instance, Kafka’s
well-known story, ‘The Metamorphosis’ where a man finds that he has changed 77
Modes of Creative Writing suddenly into a hideous insect. Do we disbelieve the story because this does not,
and cannot happen in real life? The writer, by depicting an impossible chain of
events, is however able to present an imaginative study of human behaviour
which is undeniably truthful and absorbing. By breaking up the traditional
structure of the plot he is able to transform seen reality into a felt experience.
The dominant mode of nineteenth and twentieth century fiction was realism. As
life, both individual and social, became increasingly more complicated, realism
or the mere portrayal of surface events did not seem an adequate mode to represent
it in all its facets. Writers interested in probing the inner recesses of their
characters’ minds rather than external events per se (Dostoevsky for instance),
took the first step away from realism. Hence the turn inward, with characters not
only responding to the external world, but also turning inward to look at their
own thought processes. Yet other experimenting writers turned to earlier forms
of fiction, such as fable or romance, to recreate fantasy worlds that bore no
resemblance to the ‘real’ world. The types of fiction they wrote laid no claim to
plausibility. Instead, they indulged in the free play of the mind, coming up with
farfetched tales that seemed to have their own inner coherence in a limited world,
circumscribed only by the artist’s imaginative power.
Numerous examples may be cited here. Take the Malayalam story, ‘The Bear’,
by C. Radhakrishnan. In it there are some events, but they are only sketchily
developed and they seem to bear no direct relation to each other. The image of a
bear is first confused with the image of a man in the narrator’s mind, then with
the image of his father. The reader can guess what those associations mean, but
he is not told. The story, somewhat terrifying in its imagery, defies both chronology
and normal credibility of plot. The author seems merely to mock at ‘what happens
next’. Yet the fiction has a certain coherence, deriving its strength neither from
events nor from credible characters or plot.
To study contemporary manifestations of short stories techniques, you can read
John Barth and Donald Barthelme, (Americans, ), Borges (Argentinian), Gunter
Grass or Peter Handke (Germans), Italo Calvino (Italian), the bilingual Samuel
Beckett, Salman Rushdie (Indian), and a host of others.
If some experimenting writers tend to develop analysis and interpretation to their
tedious end, others mock at the concept of ‘developing’ a story. They write
pieces that are so brief that the stories end before the reader has a chance to
ponder where they might lead. The following short story is one such example. 79
Modes of Creative Writing Taboo
Enrique Anderson Imbert
His guardian angel whispered to Fabian, behind his shoulder:
‘Careful, Fabian! It is decreed that you will die the minute you pronounce
the word Doyen.’
‘Doyen?’ asks Fabian, intrigued.
And he dies.
2.6 SUMMING UP
In this Unit we have dealt with the basic elements of a short story like plot,
atmosphere, character and so on. We’ve also spoken about experimental stories
and how these are changing the basic perspective of looking at this genre.
80