EFM Examples
EFM Examples
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
1
ABOUT THIS GUIDE
THIS CONTENT IS ISSUED BY PRATT & WHITNEY, EAST HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, U.S.A., A DIVISION OF
RAYTHEON TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION.
UNLESS FAIR USE OR SOME STATUTORY EXEMPTION APPLIES, YOU MAY NOT REPRODUCE OR DISTRIBUTE
COPIES OF ANY PORTIONS OF THIS CONTENT WITHOUT THE PRIOR EXPRESS WRITTEN PERMISSION OF
RAYTHEON TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION.
THE INFORMATION AND INSTRUCTIONS IN THIS CONTENT ARE FOR GENERAL TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY.
THIS CONTENT DOES NOT REPLACE OR SUPERSEDE THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THE APPROPRIATE
MAINTENANCE OR ENGINE MANUALS OR OTHER OFFICIAL PUBLICATIONS.
Proprietary Statement:
This document is the property of Pratt & Whitney, a division of Raytheon Technologies Corporation (RTC), and contains
confidential and / or proprietary information. You may not possess, use, copy or disclose this document or any information in
it, for any purpose, including without limitation to design, manufacture, or repair parts, or obtain FAA or other government
approval to do so, without RTC's express written permission. Neither receipt nor possession of this document alone, from
any source, constitutes such permission. Possession, use, copying or disclosure by anyone without RTC's express written
permission is not authorized and may result in criminal and/or civil liability.
Note that due to engine production schedules, some discrepancies may exist between actual production components and
course content.
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
2
TASK 1-1:
WORKSHEET
GIVEN: EXCLUDE:
1. FLEET SIZE = 40 ENGINES 1. COST OF OIL
2. AVG COST PER D&C = $25,000 2. COST OF FUEL
3. AVG COST PER OD = $150,000 3. COST OF MONEY
4. AC ANNUAL UTILIZATION = 4,000 HOURS 4. COST OF L&B MAINTENANCE
5. AVG SHOP VISIT COST = $1,200,000
ESTIMATE THE FOLLOWING ENGINE VARIABLE COSTS FOR THE SPECIFIED THRESHOLD
(RATE) LEVEL.
$ per EFH $ per Yr-Fleet
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
3
TASK 1-2 : Calculate EMC/Hour for XYZ if the average SVC is $750,000.
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
4
HvC EFM Class 217c 219 SVR.pptx
TASK 1-2 : What can be said about the length of XYZ’s flight legs?
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
5
Task 2-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
6
Task 2-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
7
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
8
Task 2-2
Given the information below, estimate the following:
• The required 1- and 5-year Maintenance Cost budget for the fleet.
• The impact on the Engine Maintenance Budget due to improper engine stagger plan.
Worksheet
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
9
Task 2-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
10
Task 2-3 : POWERPLANT SPARE REQUIREMENT
HOW MANY ENGINE HOURS ARE FLOWN PER YEAR FOR THE FLEET?
HOW MANY FLYING HOURS DOES AN ENGINE HAVE BEFORE IT HAS A SHOP VISIT?
HOW MANY ENGINE SHOP VISITS ARE REQUIRED FOR THIS FLEET IN AN AVERAGE YEAR?
HOW MANY SPARE ENGINES DOES THE FLEET REQUIRE? IS IT THE SAME EVERY YEAR?
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
11
Task 2-4 : ENGINE STAGGERING EXERCISE
1. What is the spacing (in engine cycles) required between engine changes so that only one engine is away at
overhaul at any time?
2. Will there be any problems with the proposed engine changes? Which engines are the most troublesome?
3. During which aircraft’s next C check do you want to make the first swap, and with which spare engine?
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
13
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
14
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
15
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
16
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
17
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
18
Task 3-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
19
TASK 3-2: PW4056 Phase 3 Engine’s Performance Assessment
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
20
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
21
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
22
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
23
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
24
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
25
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
26
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
27
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
28
Task 3-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
29
Task 4-1
• In this exercise you will compute the maintenance cost per engine flight hour for three different
workscope plans.
• Assumptions:
• The hot section is capable of approximately 6,000 to 8,000 cycles since overhaul.
– The cost for hot section refurbishment is $300,000 USD -- the cost includes the price to replace any
LLPs that has expired.
– The cost for a shop visit to just replace the LLPs in a module is $200,000 USD.
• Compute the average engine maintenance cost per engine flight hour (MC/EFH) based on the product
of shop visit rate (SVR) and shop visit cost (SVC).
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
30
TASK 4-1: ENGINE’S REMAINING DISK LIVES
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
31
Task 4-1
Hot Section costs $300K (includes its LLP replacement), LLP replacement costs $200K
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
32
Task 4-1
C4 C3 C6 T2 T4
limit C13 T3
Base cyc
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000
C4 C3 C6 T2 T4
limit C13 T3
a). XX
cyc
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000
C4 C3 C6 T2 T4
limit C13 T3
b). X XX
cyc
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000
C4 C3 C6 T2 T4
limit C13 T3
c). X X XX X
cyc
0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
33
Task 4-2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
34
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
35
Task 5-1
PW4462-3 SB Business Case for Operator PWX:
Assumptions:
Ignore cost of money (IRR or hurdle rate)
Ignore labor cost (blades are replaced when engine is in the shop)
Task: Result
Estimate average loss in MC/EFH due to Blade 2 Stage problem (delta MC/EFH).
Estimate the break-even point in hour per engine after 100% implementation of SB 716.
Estimate Maintenance Cost savings at year two (2) after 100% SB 716 implementation.
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
36
Task 5-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
37
Task 5-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
38
Task 5-2 : PW4000-3 SB72-763 Business Case for Operator ABC
Average cost per engine shop visit ..……. $1,200,000
Tasks: Ignore labor cost (blades are replaced when engine is in the shop)
Results
1) Determine the current shop visit rate of Airline ABC from SVR chart 3. __________
2) Estimate impact of the T2B problem on SVR in %, from the Top Problems chart 1. __________
3) Estimate average loss in MC/EFH due to T2B problem (delta MC/EFH). __________
5) Estimate the break-even point in hours per engine after 100% implementation. __________
6) Estimate Maintenance Cost savings at year two (2) after 100% SB 763 implementation. __________
7) Estimate the increase in MTBSV (in hours) as a result of the SB implementation. __________
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
39
Task 5-2 : Top Causes of Engine Shop Visits for Airline ABC
Chart 1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
P&W Proprietary 456WB FEB 2015
Chart 2
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
41
Task 5-2 : Shop Visit Rates of ABC and of the entire Fleet
Chart 3
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
42
Task 6-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
43
Task 6-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
50
Task 6-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
51
Task 6-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
52
Task 7-1
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
53
Task 7-2 : Single Engine Taxi Fuel Savings Exercise
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
54
Task 8-1
Line ”h” above represents savings in MC at 10% derated takeoff. (Other benefits include labor, OSR, lower SVR, LLP time
and more.)
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
60
YOUR ANSWERS TO THE REVIEW QUESTIONS
SECTION 1: SECTION 3: SECTION 6: SECTION 9:
FOR TRAINING PURPOSES ONLY Subject to export and disclosure limitations on the page “About This Guide” PRATT & WHITNEY PROPRIETARY INFORMATION
456WB FEB 2015
61