FM CH9
FM CH9
CHAPTER9
, INTRODUC I ION
~ . . / ' . .
A lack or effec_ti~e long-range planiiing _i_s a common Ir ~ited re~so~n for fi~an~ial
distress and faill,!re. 1:£!!&:"W!'gtr:.l!.{~ is a means . • , _st~mat~cally thn~lun_g
about the future and-anticipating· poss1ble·problems·b~fore-tH ~c~r. Plann1n~ 1s •
said to be a process, that at best helps the firm avoid stu~bl11Jg ,1nto the future
·...;--.-- ,
backward.·
. , . . . . ....
fifJ!JlJ~iaJ_p/.~r,ni~g forrri~lates th~ way in which financiid go@ls_ are .to be achie~_ed.
A financial plan is thus, a statement o( what is to be. done- in the future._ Many
decis.ions have a long lead time which mea~s they take a lo_ng.time to implement.
In an uncertain world; this requires that' decisions inade far .:in advailce· of--their
1
As -discu~~ in t~e ~arlier. chapters, the app.ropri~te ·goal is for th~ fin~cial
m~ag~r IS l.~~r~~•!l~ t~~J.!!!!~~a!ue ofthe·ow.ners~ ~uity and JlQtjust 0~
.b~ tt§elf. I~ the firm 1s su_cc~ssful i.n doing this,_ then gr:owtJ:I )Yi11 us~al!~ ~~s~lt.
sr
_• Growth may thus be a ~es1rable consequence of good-decision making but 1t 1s not
-~ end ~nto itself. How~ver, while growth rate is u~d -in the planiling proc'ess:.ft
ts '?.On~•~ered_ a convenient means of summarizing various--aspects of a ti~ s_
fmanc1al and •n~e~tment policies. Likewise,_ if we think ·of growth as growth _in the
~arket-value _of the eq~i~ i~ the firin, then g~als of growth ~d increasing the
market value ~f the :equity 1n the firm are not all that different"
.
'
~inane/al Forecpstingfor Strategic Growth 195
After the-pl~ning ho~zon and l~v~l ofaggre~tion are· establ~~h~d, a financial plan
~equi,;es :inputs iri th~ form. of altemative sets· of _ass~mption5: '-about important
I
Due to the ~ou~t ~pen~ in exa~in~ng _the .·di¢erent ~en~~ios and variables that.
·wilt ev_entually become the basis. for a comp~ny's; :t1nar1ci~I plan, ,.it seems
- reasonable to ask-what the .p.lanning. pr:ocess .w_ill .accomplish'. • •. -
• • • t . ' .."' ~--:.. ' -
. .
Among the more ~$!!,!_f!~~ ben~flts, ~!
derived from :fina~~i~I. plann_ing are -~e
I- -fol_lowing. , -· '_ • _ ,. \ . - • · - ,·
. ~
• I
~
196 Chapter 9 ,
2. Jnteractiol:'$ •or Linl!ages. b~twe~n •fnvfftment prop
. \
. . osals ~ ci,,e ful!y
examined. • . '
• •
~
.
The financial plan enables the e~oeonents to show explicitly .
the Un ~s
between investment pro~ sals _for the different operating activ
ities of the· -
finn and. its ayailable financing choices. For example, if
. the firm -is
.• planning on expanding· or undertaking ·.n_~W inv~ ~eP ,ts and
·projects, an
other relevant variables.such as-source, te~ s ~d timing of
thoroughly examined. •. . fin~ cing &re- -
•• • • •
.
·3. Possible problems related to the proposal projects are '
identi~t!-aciions
to address them are studied.
·.,
..
.
\ . .,'
• I
I • ,. . • .,
✓
' • <
Financ ial Forecast ingfor Strategic_ Growth 197
fin~n~ial planni ng proces s will differ·-from firm ·19 firm, just as companies differ
1n size. and· produc ts. Howev er, a basic financia_l planning model will have the
follow1n~ comm on elem~n ts; (a) econom ic environmenf_assumptions~.(b) salej
_ for~as t, (c) pro forma statem en~1 (d). asset requirements,· (e) financiaJ
requirement; and (f) additio nal funds needed.
-.
r
' . I. Economic Environment Assumption. The plan·: will ·have to state
. explicitly_ the ~non u~~o nm~n t i~ which the firm expects· to reside
I
l
I over the hfe <;>f the·pla n. Among the 1nore important-economic mump tiQn
that will have to be. made are the inflation rates, level of interest rates and
the firm's tax rate.. - - . ,-.
2. Snl.es Forect isL An. ·externally supplied .sal~s forecast _considered the_
"~rive r'' shall be the "It~" of all financial plans. The ~r of-tbe planning
model wiJI _supply this value and most other yalu~ will b~ ~lcula ted ~ .
on it. ·Planni ng will focus on projected future sales ·and the assets ~
_•financ ing needed to suppo~ those sales. •· • -· • •
. . .
Oftent imes, the sales forecast ·will be given as the growth rate in s¢es
rather than as an explicit.. sales figure. ·Perfect sales forecast are·_·-not.
possib le, of·cou ~e, becaus e sales depend .on the. . uncertai_n future ·state of·
the econom y. To come up with itc,_ projections, firms co~ld- ~nsult with
t.
some busine sses which specialize in macroe co~o~i c ~d •i~dustry
project ions. Also, evalua ting alternative scen~ os ~oes no! ~uire sales-
foreca st to be very accura te because the financial planner~s goal is to
examin e the interpl ay betweell investment and t;inancing needs.a t different
possible- sales level, not to pinpoint what we. exJ:)Cct ~o ~appen ..
7
. .
• • Total Ass-et Turnov~r~ An increase·in the_firm~s total ~set turnover
-i.ncre"ases~thi.- -;~ties'. generated for each.· pes~ •. in ~~- This ..
aecieises ihe firm;s need for new·assets as sales grow and thereby
i~creases the sustaina6·1e growth rate. .Notic~ th~!-. total. asset:
. _·turnover _is the same thing as decreasing capital intensity: •
The· sustainable growth @te is a very useful plan~i'ng -number.
. What it illu$trates is the explicit relationship betwee·n. the firm's
four major areas. of ·concern: (a) its operat_ing e~ciency as
measured by profit margin, (b) its asset use effici~~cy as measured
by total asset tu.rnover, (c) its dividend ·policy as measured by ~e
· . retention ratio, anq (~) _its financial policy as measured by the
d~bt-equity ratio..
. .
-5; Financial Requir~ments. The financial. p1an wHI include a se.ction about
~e_necess31)_ ftna.n~in £atr.r~~ .m~ :f~is part:ot~e ~Ian sltould_di~cUSS
d1v1d ~nd pohcy and d~bt po u~y-somet1.mes firms w.tll expect to raise ~h
by se, Iing new shares of stock or by borrowing. In this case, ~he ·plan will
have to consider
.
what kinds of securities have to be
.
sold and what methods
. .
of issuance are mo~t appropriate.,
l
_J
Financial Foreccutingfor-Strategic Growth 199
6. AddWl!n~I Funds Needed (AFN).· After the firm. has a sale~ (Q~~d
.~ e~!!!!l..!1.e of the required spending on assets, some amount of new
financing wi II often be necessary because projected total assets will exceed
projected total liabilities· and_ equity. In other words, the statement of
." financial ~osition will n9 longer. balance. ,
Because ·new financing may be· necessary to· cover all. of the proj_ected
capital spending, a financial "pl~g" varia~le must be· sel~ed. The plug is
the designat~ source(s) of external financing oeeded to deal with any -
·shortfa~l (or surplus) in financing afld thereby bring the statement of
financial position into balance.
. .
WeH nm OOIRpanies ••neaslly bat .d.teir· operaang,~s 0'.11. a ~ fil l1_lta I ta_• • - -
•• •ftnincial _statements. 11le planning p,ecess begim,witll •---'fONCait.9 •n '.f•_~-- •• -
five or SO years. TheR the, ~ts required to m11t1heales.tafgets an, i•itati_ll ~ ...
and deci$i<>n is made concerning how io:~~ance theffquirecf assets.·Af Cl 1£ ~- 1.&.
income. statements wt sta~,ts of financial :position can be l"cje ~ aid
earnings per share, as wel I-as _the l{ey ratios can be. f~ted~ .
Once_ the "base-case"· forecasted statements and •ratio~ have ~n prq,ared, top
managers wi 11 ~k questio·ns such as: •
•• Are the forecasted results as good as we can realistically .ex~~ and i'rnoi
how might we chan_ge our_operating plans to produ~~ _better e811lings· and
a higher stock price? : •
• How sure are we th~t we wi.H b~ able to :achieve ·the projected results? For
•, exainp_le, j~ o.~r bas~-case forecast assumes ~ reaso~ably strong economy
but a recession occurs, would we be better off under an alternative
.operating plan? •
J-
_:_ _-- --- --- --- ~-- --- -=- --- --
~-2~00~~Ci!_'h~ap'f!_li~-er~9_ _
Apply the iteration process using the available financing mix until the
•AFN •w~uld become so small· that t}le forecast •can ·be considered
complete.
r .
Income· Statement • '
Sales ft2,000,00Q:
Cost of sates 1,200,000
Gross profit . 80Q,OOO
Operating expenses • . . 380,000
Earnings before interest and taxes 420.000
Interest expense . 70,000
Earnings before taxes 350,000
Taxes (35%) • 122,500
Eamings-after·taxes e 227,50Q
Dividends r! l3§,5QO
0~2~ 9Ch~ aierp t~er~ 9~~- ----:- === :,;,:; ;;;;-~ -~--- ---
_!2 . c:· • ·a1 position
Statement of ,!na~c, •
•• Assets- • ~ 50.000
,I
- 400,000
·cash 750,000
.Accounts receiy~ble
Inventory • t-1.200.000
, current assets 800,000
Fixed assets (ne.t) • t-2,000,00Q
Total assets
Liabilities and Equity • ,a 250.000 _
Accounts p~yable _ 10,000 ·
Accrued wages · 20,000
Accrued taxes flt 280.000
· Current liabilities · 70.000
Notes payable·- bank • . • 150.000
- Long-term debt •. 1,200,000 -
Ordinary shares· • 300,000 -
Retained earnings.
Total liabilities and equity •. 192.Q00,000 \
The firm is.expecting a20 percent increase in sales next year,·and management is
concerned a~ut the compariy,s need for external fu~ds. The increase i~ sales~
e ~ to be _carried put without any ~xpaas~ 9f fixed assets> but rathetdlrollgh
~ etr1e~ asset utilizat~on i~ the ex~stirg • • · AmQlll liabilities, only _,.
liabilities vary directly with sales. •
Solution: -
f •
. . .
l
The projected income stat~me ·• ••..
nt wili• show t.he c.10II owing ....
. . .
Sales ,.
Cost of sales '2,400.000 •
Gross ·profit 1,440.000
Operating expenses 960.000 -
Earnings before interest and laxes. :•:
Interest expense • • -•.
Earning$ before taxes .. . 70,000
• Taxes {35%) _ • 434.000
• Earnings after taxes _ 151,900 _.
.. · • - P:282.100
_ D1vadends (36% paYfflent) _ 19 101.§00
r
j
I,
I
I
•. J
'
,
, - - - \
.2,rt tI
•
..J
J
(1) Cash = 2~5% x P2.4M sales , . ·: •.. _
(2) Acco.unts receivable = 20% of P2.4M ~· · ·.' - _-iii 1-/b.'O -- Io J~ ~ ~
(3) Inventory =· 37.5% x P2.4M •
(4) No percentages are computed f.or.\fixed ass~ts, -note~- payable,. long~
. terin debt, ordinary shares .and. retaine~ e~mings because they are
not assumed to maintain a direct r~lationship with sales-volume. For- •
simplicity, depreciation is not explicitly. consi~ered.·
1
•
• (5) Accounts payable = 12.So/o of.P2.4M
(6) Accrued expenses = 0.5% of P2.~M "\
I . •
(7) ·Accrued-taxes.=.1%_ofP2.4M ._ . . .
·(8) ~e~inedeamings .= P.300,000 + P282,lp0 - -Pl0l,600
_ -------~--:--:--:-----~
~04~J..,C~h~ap~ter~9_ _;__,__.;-_~
1
Ii Method • • •
FortnU O • • ·FN) may also be computec;l as f~Uows:·.
• needed (A. . •
. • Additional financing .• . - . • •
. ·red Spontaneous . Increase in
Additional ~eq~~se _ increase _- - retained
• . tunds = ;~~ssets in liabilities earnings
needed
wbere:
I
Reqtj~red · Change in
CurtentAssets(pr8Sen~
.x · · Sales (present) .
increase · = sales
ina~ts
I
~. Increase
·ta· ed .• .•
·~~i~;s = •
_am,·ng~s • .•
r:
~ taxes ~
Oividehd
. . payment'
..
:· . · - ··
. •• .. I
•• • •.. ! .
• I
APJ)lied ·to Millen~iu~ Co., AFN is: computed 8$_ fo.llQ\Ys: •• :.. :-
_, o ~ • '\. I •' • • " • -., • • ' • .. - • o • •
\
Financial Forecasting/or Strategic Growth
- ' •
Sales . . . P6,000
0paating oosts (~usive ~ nx, ~atton)
5432
_Earnings before interest and taxes 568
• Less interest~ :- - . . -17§ : .
Eanlngs before taxes •. 392
... -
I
Taxes(~) • . . •. . 157' .
Net inoome before preference dividend· .. ·. 235 ~·,
Dividends to preference . _._-a.· .·
I •~ .inoome available to on:linary .--.ew.~e 1_1:1 . _.: •
Oividends to ordinary
• •'
- -
Adcltlon to ~ earnings. .... .. . ..
. \ .
• .• ··r-amarind Company' . .
Statement'of· Rnancial Position ·:
. December 31· 20x4· •-
-· •~-- ~ (Thousands of ~ l ,' .· •~ - .
.
-~ I ,,,. . \ .
. . ,
,
_Cash.
, Aa:ounts receivable . . . .
Inventories .
• . Total cunent .assets
. .
Net . . . . ~ . . •
T~ Assem·: •• " . · •. •
. • • l.i8blllties and Equity • '-,
. .
. . · · . .,. ·120 -·.. ~ .
~~~. ·-· • I
..
. -payable .
.. . ...
220 '
Accnas • • •
....,. .. .. .
·. ,
~~
• •
Solution:
B~ on the data~and ~µmptio~~~giv~ri,.the·foHo·wing -projecti9ns·are· mac1e and the. -
.additional financing needed ·determined. · •• _· · • · · •. ·,•' .• ,.'...•• •, • .• . ~ ·· • - · . •
. • ' 'i
. .. . . . . . .
'
Figure-,_l~ · . , .
. . . Proj~ed. Income Statement (First Pass) •
... •·..- ... ~ • _ : (T~ _o f Pesos )'- . . • - ..
- ., . , ..,.
.
! .
, .
· ,._ . PS,000: ·: -: · . • x. 110% ~ . · · - . . ·P6,60(l ,
Sales
0perattng CX>Sls ranc:1• oi•. P200 I . •. ; . i
.• 5,975
•. depreaalim) .. , 5432 . , • X'-110%. . . • '.
•
•
em
.• 116
_,em-
12s
Addition to· ~- e~fngs ,. 136
I
Financial -Forec~tingfor Stral~gic Growth. • 207
. I
Figare . 9-2._ .-
Projected Statemeflt of.Financial Po$ition (First P.s)
• (Thousands of Pesos) . . .•
20X4 ·20XSFOl8C8Sf
Actual Basis First Pass
. ·.Assets . . .
. 'cash ... 20 X 110% ·p 22
J- · • 750
. • Aooounts ~ble 1100,4 825
I
. I. . •inventories 1,230
X
X 11(}% , 1,353
Total current assets . ~.000. P2,200
.· x 110% •. · • 2,200.
I - Net plant and equipment-
Total Assets • •
2,QQQ·
•t◄~oqo • N,199
~
.
.. ;
. \ . . . .
.• •Figure. 15.;] QOntainS ~tlUllari~d~S .20X4 -actual. ·and: i~ j>roj~ 20:Xs
. · ·statements offmancjal-po$ition. Total-~ -~~projected-•t P4,400,~_\vliile. ·
. the forecastell ti~lity and ~uity·_accounts t~~lto· oµly ·p4,.176~000. SiriCC the
. . res(?urces •or~ assets requi~d. to_ suppo~). the high~r· sales :1evel exceed the
.-1 ~vailable_.~~s,._~-?1eal1S·,at addi~ion~l· f?nd~ ~i!.~ h~ve tQ bQ o~tained._' The
- Aa; of¥224,()00 wt~I :be by bo~w•ng frotn the· bank as·notes payable r a i s e d
' I
., . . .. . -
208 Chapter 9
• ume that after Considerin~ all th~ relevant factors, Taman~d ~ec1ded on the .
, -·.=
.."· !f.owi ng funds financing mix to nuse the AFN of P224,000. . . •·
Percent Amou nt· Interest rate -..
• 25% P 56,0QO 8%
Notes payable • 25 56,000 10%
Long-tenn debt
Ordinal)' shares~ 50 112,000.
Total • · 100% I n24,000 >
•
..
• 2,400 shares · -
.,
-·
·solution: • . -!
Off,lnary ·l!m -~ ~
Dividends 'k) ordnary 116 • · 125 .• •~ 6 131
• ~ to retained earnings ' -~ \. . ~
,-
Cash
Assets
,. 20 •. p· 22 p 22 .
825
AocoUnts receivable 750 -825
' ' 1nventorieS . 1,230 1,353 .. ·1,353·
I I
' Tota1 current assets
. •
P2,000 192.200 P2.200
• Net plant and equipment 2,QQQ 2.~ 2,200
1 . , T0181 Assets • 194,000 P4,400 '4,100
I
In Figure 15-4 the _second pass 20XS -Sta~enieilt of Financial Positjon shows
. that .a shortfall of Pl2,00() will s~ill exist.as ~esult of financing f~back. a1
effects due to the additional. in~~resJ (net- ~f taxes) and· dividend p&yments, that
. reduced th~ projected re~ined· earnings: Jnis amount raises the cumulative
AFN from P224,000 to _P23~,000.
•
.
' \
. : • .
- ,
_Ne xt yea r's for eca st as dev elo ped ·ab ove
ces s. For eca stin g is an iter ativ e pro ¢ess," both· 1n the w_ay the ~nancial
•pro
s are gen era ted and in the _·~ ay th~ fin~cial pl~n is devefoped. For
statement develops a preliminary forecast-'
pos es, the con sul tan t _or_ fin anc ial sta ff
planning pur ds. This ·will serve_,as -a starting
bin atio n of pas t pol icie s a~d tren
•based on a com n m9 dified to. see· wh ~ effects .
for eca st. Th e mo del · is the
point or "baseline"
e on the •firm's _earnings and financial
•_ alternative .operating·. plans woul~- hav
ndi~ ion Lik ew ise, alte m~ tiye o·p era tiilg plans· are examined_ °'1d¢r different~sales- ·
, _co
n ~ s<Jividend j,olicy .and· capital ·structure
7
• gro wth . rate sce nar ios and link ~~ to the fin
ns. Th e rev ised foreca ~t or ~o del can also be ·u$ed· to an aly ~ alternative
• decisio -
- •
_.- workin
.
g.capi
.
tal policies. • \
1
·- -· •
.
4
\ . .
-.
-..
'•
I ,
' '