Schmitt 1985
Schmitt 1985
North-Holland
Job satisfaction has been shown to be related to a number of individual and organizational
effectiveness variables. Consequently, it is suggested that attempts to select individuals with
inclinations towards satisfaction would be of theoretical and practical importance. For five
samples of individuals representing a wide variety of occupations, regression analyses were used to
assess the usefulness of life satisfaction in the prediction of subsequent job satisfaction, while
statistically controlling various demographic variables, pay, tenure, and perceptions of task
characteristics. In a sixth sample of workers eligible for retirement, the hypothesis that life
satisfaction can be predicted from job satisfaction was also examined. The results showed that in
three of the first five samples, life satisfaction was a significant predictor of job satisfaction. In the
sample of retirees, significant results were also obtained using job satisfaction to predict subse-
quent life satisfaction. It is suggested that satisfaction may be a relatively stable and general aspect
of certain individuals which is a function of particular personality characteristics and/or an
inclination towards interpreting various situations in a favorable manner.
The authors would We to thank David E Bowen, Arnon E. Reichers, and Mary D. Zalesny for
their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this paper.
Mailing address: N. Schmitt, Dept. of Psychology, Michigan State University, Snyder Hall. East
Lansing, MI 48823, USA.
Barrett 1972; Weitz 1952), and longevity (Palmore 1969). In sum, the
importance of job satisfaction as a criterion of practical importance
seems well supported. In addition, many organizational researchers and
theorists would maintain that job satisfaction should be an important
criterion in its own right. That is, organizations should strive to
promote the satisfaction of their employees irrespective of its relation-
ship to organizationally relevant outcomes.
Given the large volume of research devoted to questions of worker
satisfaction, it is very surprising that few studies have attempted to
predict job satisfaction. Schmitt and Schneider (1983) have recently
noted this neglect and have suggested that research attempting to select
individuals with inclinations toward being satisfied should prove of
theoretical and practical importance. In support of this notion, Pulakos
and Schmitt (1983) have shown that job satisfaction can, in fact, be
predicted using individuals’ preemployment expectations concerning
the degree to which they believe favorable outcomes will be obtainable
from work. This particular approach to predicting job satisfaction is
unique, in that it assumes that satisfaction is partly dependent upon
individual characteristics rather than the more commonly accepted
proposition that satisfaction is due. to certain conditions such as met
versus unmet expectations regarding- work (Wanous 1980), enriched
design of jobs (Hackman and Oldham 1975), and the ability of work to
fulfill employee needs (Alderfer 1972; Porter 1964). Staw (1984) has
also echoed similar sentiments in his suggestion that researchers begin
examining various individual difference determinants of job attitudes
such as satisfaction.
Consistent with the idea that job satisfaction can, at least in part, be
individually determined, the present research is based on the proposi-
tion that individuals have generalized predispositions towards satisfac-
tion or dissatisfaction. Development of and support for this hypothesis
has obvious implications for selection, as well as for job design,
organizational development, and quality of life programs, the objective
of which usually includes a positive employee affect. If some people
are, in fact, predisposed to be satisfied or dissatisfied across situations,
reports of life satisfaction, for example, may be useful in predicting job
satisfaction and could thus be of potential value in a personnel selec-
tion mode. Positive correlations between life and job satisfaction could,
of course, be interpreted as consistent with the spillover hypothesis.
However, the spillover hypothesis does not explicate the underlying
N. Schmin. E.D. Pulakos / Job and life satis/acrion 157
Method
Sample
The data used in the present study were obtained as part of a larger project on job
change in the State of Michigan. Specifically, six different samples of respondents
Table 1
Means and standard deviations of the sample on demographic variables and pay.
Variable Sample
LCC CETA LOS RET HEMP WOMEN
Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD
Sex 1.45 0.50 1.62 0.49 1.62 0.49 1.20 0.40 1.39 0.49 2.00 - h
Ethnic status 1.94 0.25 1.98 0.16 0.94 0.25 1.99 0.11 1.10 0.30 1.93 0.25 P
Marital status 1.70 0.46 1.19 0.39 1.44 0.50 1.84 0.37 1.13 0.34 1.48 0.50
Socioeconomic
status 48.30 19.69 29.17 18.47 5.30 2.67 10.70 4.03 23.20 12.49 60.87 16.76
Education 3.61 1.05 2.00 1.00 3.19 1.35 3.54 1.56 1.95 0.gl 4.91 1.31 \
Age 32.90 9.06 1.98 1.55 2.78 1.60 2.49 0.67 2.33 1.30 36.13 12.60
Tenure 4.19 2.85 - - - - 5.58 1.07 - - 5.53 2.45
Pay 4.85 1.64 2.70 0.87 3.92 1.26 6.30 1.71 4.14 1.55 5.43 1.98
Note:
LCC = community college group; CETA = those employed under the Comprehensive Employment Training Act; LOS = persons who lost or left a
Civil Service job in the previous year; RET = Civil Service retirement eligible persons; HEMP = persons identified as hard-to-employ who were
participating in job skills training; and WOMEN = participants in International Women’s Year Conference.
Sex was coded as 1 for male and 2 for female; ethnic group was coded 1 for minority and 2 for white; marital status was coded 1 for single and 2 for
married; socioeconomic status was coded on a Civil Service pay grade scale ranging from 1-20 for the LOS and RET groups; all other groups were
coded on the Duncan scale (Reiss et al. 1961). Education, age, and tenure codes were unique to the sample and are described in the text.
N . Schmitt, E. D. Puiakos / Job and IiJe satisfacrion 159
completed measures at two points in time approximately one year apart. The basic
demographics of the respondents from each sample are presented in table 1.
Because this larger project focused on j o b change, all samples were chosen so as to
maximize the likelihood that the respondents would be making, or had very recently
made, some decision about employment. The first sample consisted of a group of
community college students (LCC, N = 298) who were enrolled in practically oriented
job skills programs. These individuals completed two questionnaires with one year
between administrations. People engaged in work through the Comprehensive Employ-
ment Training Act (CETA, N=129) comprised a second sample. Two samples were
drawn from State of Michigan Civil Service files. The first of these was comprised of
individuals who had lost or left their jobs (LOS. N = 82) within the year prior to the
data collection. At the second questionnaire administration, they had obtained new
employment. The second Civil Service sample consisted of all those persons who were
eligible for retirement (RET, N =162). Employees were eligible for retirement if they
were 55 and had worked for the State 30 years. Individuals who were participating in a
large corporation’s job training program for the hard-to-employ (HEMP, N = 36)
comprised a fifth sample. Finally, women (WOMEN, N = 117) participating in an
International Womens’s Year conference concerned partly with employment opportun-
ities for women comprised the sixth sample. Excluding the RET group, all those
included in the analyses were employed at the time of completion of the second
questionnaire.
All six samples were convenience samples in that they were not chosen randomly
from some population. Rather, they were chosen to represent groups of people
undergoing some change in their work role: Representativeness of the respondent group
as a whole was also a concern. Response rates to the first questionnaire ranged from
23% in the HEMP group to 43% in the RET group. Because of assurances of
confidentiality, no follow-up of nonrespondents was possible. Further, S attrition took
place when the second questionnaires were administered. Of those reponding to the
first questionnaire, between 58 and 70% responded to the second set of instruments.
However demographic information (e.g., sex, race, age) on potential respondents was
compared to demographic characteristics of the respondent group, and no significant
differences were found.
Instruments
In all samples, j o b satisfaction was measured with the Minnesota Satisfaction Question-
naire (Weiss et al. 1967). The life satisfaction measure consisted of three items of the
G U M et al. (1961) scale and two additional items were written concerning satisfaction
with familiy and leisure activities. Responses to all five items were made o n five-point
scales ranging from ‘Strongly Disagree’ to ‘Strongly Agree’. Perceptions of j o b design
factors were measured with the Skill Variety, Autonomy, Task Significance, Task
Identity, and Feedback subscales of the Job Diagnostic Survey (Hackman and Oldham
1975).
Demographic statistics which were used as controls included those shown in table 1.
Sex, ethnic status, and marital status were coded similarly across all samples. For the
Civil Service samples (LOS and RET), data were available concerning their pay grade
160 N. Schmitt, E. D. Pulakos / Job and life satisfaction
(range of grades from 1 to 20), and these were used as the socioeconomic status
variable. For other groups, their occupation was coded using the Duncan index (Reiss
et al. 1961).
For all, education was coded on a six-point scale using the following options:
1 = Did not finish high school, 2 = Graduated from high school (or GED equivalent),
3 = Some college or other post high school education, 4 = Associate degree or comple-
tion of other post high school educational program, 5 =Four year college, and
6 = Graduate study.
Age was uncoded for the LCC and WOMEN samples. For the RET sample, age was
coded in the following manner: 1 =Under 55, 2 = 55-59, 3 = 60-64, 4 = 65-70,
5 = Over 70. Options on the age scale for the remaining samples were categorized as
follows: 1= Less than 20, 2 = 20-24, 3 = 25-29, 4 = 30-34, 5 = 35-39, 6 = 40-49,
7 = 50-59, 8 = 60-65, 9 = Over 65.
The tenure variable for the RET group had the following response options: 1 = Less
than 12 months, 2 = 1-3 years, 3 = 4-6 years, 4 = 7-10 years, 5 = 10-20 years, 6 = More
than 20 years. The WOMEN and LCC samples responded on a scale with the following
options: 1 = I do not currently have a job, 2 = Less than 6 months, 3 = 6 months-1
year, 4 =1-2 years, 5 = 2-3 years, 6 = 3-4 years, 7 = 4-5 years, 8 = 5-10 years, and
9 = More than 10 years. For the other samples, tenure data were unavailable. Pay was
the final potential correlate of job satisfaction that was assessed. In all groups, pay
response options ranged from ‘Less than $3.00/hour’ to ‘More than $13.00/hour’.
Procedure
All data were collected by mailed questionnaire at two different times approximately
one year apart. Life satisfaction measures were collected at the first questionnaire
administration, while job satisfaction and job design variables were assessed at the
second data collection. Various demographic variables were collected at both times.
Data analyses
Coefficient alpha was computed for all multi-item scales as a means of assessing the
internal consistency of each measure. The primary analyses consisted of hierarchical
regressions for each sample. Specifically,job satisfaction was regressed on demographic
variables, job design measures, and life satisfaction. In all cases, the demographics, pay,
and job design measures were entered first in order to assess the unique contribution of
life satisfaction to job satisfaction. This provided a particularly strong test of the
hypothesis concerning the prediction of job satisfaction for three reasons. First, the
demographics represent the usual correlates of job satisfaction (Locke 1976; Weaver
1977). Second, job design variables are also usually significant correlates of job
satisfaction (Hackman and Oldham 1975; Schmitt et al. 1978; Schmitt and Bedeian
1982). Third, the job design and job satisfaction measures were collected at the same
point in time, increasing the likelihood of an inflated relationship due to common
method bias. Hence, the predictability of job satisfaction from life satisfaction data
obtained the previous year should be maximally conservative.
N. Schrnrrr. E.D. Pulakos / Job and /ye sarisjacrion 161
Since the respondents from the RET sample were moving from life-long employ-
ment to retirement, hierarchical regression for this sample consisted of the prediction of
life satisfaction from job satisfaction. Specifically, the demographic variables and
income were entered first followed by j o b satisfaction in predicting satisfaction with
life. Job design factors were obviously not relevant for this analysis.
Results
The results of the internal consistency analyses and the means and standard deviations
of the scale scores are presented in table 2. Although the Minnesota Satisfaction
Questionnaire contains subscales for intrinsic and extrinsic satisfaction, their corrected
intercorrelation in each sample was above 0.80. Because of t h s high degree of
redundancy, the two subscales were combined into one satisfaction index. Coefficient
alphas were relatively satisfactory for all scales in each group with the exception of the
HEMP group’s responses to the job design variables. It is likely that the items in the
Job Diagnostic Survey were not interpretable for some respondents in this sample.
The results of the regression analyses are presented in table 3. Support for the
hypothesis that life satisfaction is a significant predictor of job satisfaction, even when
major demographic variables, pay, and j o b design factors are statistically controlled,
was obtained in three out of five samples. One exception occurred in the H E M P group
whose sample size was very small. It should be noted, however, that even in this
sample, the results were consistent with our hypothesis as evidenced by the fact that life
satisfaction increased the Multiple R from 0.73 to 0.77. In the CETA sample, not only
did life satisfaction fail to contribute to the prediction of job satisfaction, but the
zero-order correlation between the two variables was nonsignificant.
In the RET sample, we investigated an hypothesis exactly opposite to that evaluated
in the other samples; namely that satisfaction with life upon retirement can be
predicted by job satisfaction. While it may seem reasonable to suppose that a person
with high j o b satisfaction would experience decreased life satisfaction upon retirement,
recall that the central thesis of this paper is that certain people are predisposed to be
satisfied more so than others. Hence, it would follow that those individuals who report
satisfaction with their jobs would also report satisfaction with retirement. In fact,
although the demographic variables proved to be unrelated to life satisfaction, job
satisfaction was significantly related to subsequent satisfaction with life.
With respect to the zero-order correlations, the job design variables were the best
correlates of job satisfaction in all samples. This was not unexpected because of results
from previous research relating job satisfaction and job design variables and because of
the likelihood of common method bias. I t is noteworthy, however, that the zero-order
correlations between job and life satisfaction measures collected one year apart were
relatively substantial and statistically significant in all but two instances. Finally,
although the incremental R ‘s associated with life satisfaction were small, consideration
must be given to the extremely conservative procedure used here as well as the number
of previously entered predictors. As such, their significance represents strong support
for the idea that there is a unique ‘general satisfaction component’ to the life and job
satisfaction constructs.
Table 2
Means, standard deviations, and internal consistencies (IC) for life and job satisfaction and job design variables for each sample.
Variable Samole
LCC CETA LOS RET HEMP WOMEN
Mean SD IC Mean SD IC Mean SD IC Mean SD IC Mean SD IC Mean SD 1C
Job h
satisfaction 72.81 11.64 0.90 73.15 12.25 0.91 71.37 11.94 0.90 77.28 12.33 0.91 69.92 11.65 0.88 75.19 12.54 0.90 P
Life
satisfaction 20.78 3.49 0.86 20.62 3.39 0.80 20.84 3.22 0.82 22.27 2.88 0.82 19.46 3.66 0.73 21.39 3.03 0.83
Skill
variety 15.09 4.83 0.82 11.44 4.43 0.63 12.54 5.06 0.80 - - - 10.46 3.57 0.22 16.55 4.29 0.81 \
Autonomy 15.37 4.21 0.76 14.14 4.06 0.66 14.16 4.94 0.84 - - - 13.42 3.18 0.48 16.90 3.55 0.67
Feedback
fromjob 15.75 3.53 0.72 14.86 3.91 0.66 14.14 3.78 0.68 - - - 14.10 3.83 0.46 16.20 3.36 0.46
Task
identity 15.09 4.29 0.70 14.14 4.54 0.62 14.20 5.04 0.78 - - - 13.40 4.32 0.60 15.98 4.24 0.77
Task
significance 16.23 3.96 0.66 15.13 4.05 0.60 16.04 3.84 0.63 - - - 14.73 4.47 0.61 16.84 3.80 0.66
Nore: LCC = community college group; CETA = those employed under the Comprehensive Employment Training Act; LOS = persons who lost or
left a Civil Service job in the previous year; RET = Civil Service retirement eligible persons; HEMP = persons identified as hard-to-employ who
were participating in job skills training; and WOMEN = participants in International Women's Year Conference.
m
2
..
L1 I 9E 891 28 62 I 867.
.
6I'Ot
98'11
10'11
. 6I"i
OP'Z
E I'Z
EP'Z
ZS'S I
ZL'O
.
II 80's
P8'S
.69'P ..
100
Z8'L
SS'8
w ES'8
,I9'LI
-8L'Ll
6L'O LL.0 SE'O OL'O 69'0 6L'O
9L'O E L'O 61'0 L9'0 69.0 89'0
IZ'O 62'0 62'0 62'0 IE'O 62'0 PZ'O W'O too ZI'O EI'O 61'0
EI'O 6P'O 9P'O OE'O - - EI'O- ZZ'O EI'O SP'O EOO 8E'O
\ ZOO ' EE'O 10'0- 00'0 ZO'O- IP'O EO'O 8E'O ZOO- 9E'O
60'0 LP'O ro- PI'O OZ'O .IS'O 81'0 WO ZZ'O OS'O
EP'O Z9'0 ES'O OS'O LE'O 8S'O 61'0 SS'O 9E'O 85'0
91'0 ES'O 91'0 WO EZ'O 9t'O LZ'O SV'O EZ'O PS'O
Q PO'O 9E.O 80'0 IE'O LOO- 80'0 81'0 EZ'O 50'0- 01.0 00'0 LOO
-..-
rij
'1
SO0 -
PZ'O-
LI'O
IP'O
-
OS'O-
-
PI'O
91'0
I00
9I'O
PO0
-
PI'O-
-
10'0 EI'O- OI'O-
SO0 -
I00
LOO -
ZOO
-c 0 1'0 - LO'O 00'0 90'0- PO'O 90'0- O"0- EI'O CO'O- 60'0- COO- SO0
4 90.0- 02'0 6I'O- EOO- EOO- SO0 EI'O- 01'0 90'0- EOO 500- PI.0
COO SI'O PI'O 62'0 LO'O 800 ZOO- 91'0 60'0 00'0 900- 00'0
00'0 EOO- LZ'O 61'0 90'0- EO'O- 90'0 LOO 00'0 20'0- 100- ZOO-
- - 92'0- 00'0 ZOO 900- COO 80'0- SI'O PZ'O II'O 60'0
8 J 8 1 8 1 B 1 8 J 8 1
N3NOM dN3H m n SO? VL33 337
aldlues P A
164 N . Schmitt. E.D. Pulakos / Job and life satisfaction
Discussion
References
Alderfer, C.P., 1972. Existence, relatedness, and growth: human needs in organizational settings.
New York: The Free Press.
166 N. Schmitt, E. D.Pulakos / Job and li/e satisfaction
Blood, M.R., 1969.Work values and job satisfaction. Journal of Applied Psychology 53, 456-459.
Burke, R.J., 1969/1970. Occupational and life strains, satisfaction, and mental health. Journal of
Business Administration 1, 35-41.
Gurin, G., J. Veroff and S. Feld, 1961.Americans view their mental health. New York: The Free
Press of Glencoe.
Hackman, R.J. and G. Oldham, 1975. Development of the job diagnostic survey. Journal of
Applied Psychology 60,159-170.
Hammer, T.H. and M. Berman, 1981. The role of noneconomic factors in faculty union voting.
Journal of Applied Psychology 66,415-421.
Hamner, W.C. and F.J. Smith, 1978.Work attitudes as predictors of unionization activity. Journal
of Applied Psychology 63,415-421.
Iris, B. and G.V. Barrett, 1972. Some relations between job and life satisfaction and job
importance. Journal of Applied Psychology 56, 301-304.
Kornhauser. A.W., 1965. Mental health of the industrial worker: a Detroit study. New York:
Wiley.
Locke, E.A., 1969.What is job satisfaction? Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 4,
309-336.
Locke, E.A., 1976.‘The nature and causes of j o b satisfaction’. In: M.D. Dunnette (ed.), Handbook
of industrial and organizational psychology. Chicago. IL: Rand-McNally.
McGuire, W.J., 1968. ‘The nature of attitudes and attitude change’. In: G. Lindzey and E.
Aronson (eds.), The handbook of social psychology. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Mobley, W.H.. S.O. Homer and A.T. Hollingsworth, 1978.An evaluation of precursors of hospital
employee turnover. Journal of Applied Psychology 63,408-414.
Palmore, E., 1969. Predicting longevity: a follow-up controlling for age. The Gerontologist 9,
247-250.
Porter, L.W., 1964. Organizational patterns of managerial job attitudes. New York: American
Foundation for Management Research.
Porter, L.W. and R.M. Steers, 1973. Organizational, work, and personal factors in employee
turnover and absenteeism. Psychological Bulletin 80,151-176.
Pulakos, E.D.and N. Schmitt, 1983. A longitudinal study of valence model predictions of j o b
satisfaction of new employees. Journal of Applied Psychology 68,307-312.
Reiss, A., 0.Duncan, P. Hatt and C. North, 1961.Occupations and social status. New York: The
Free Press of Glencoe.
Schmitt, N. and A.G. Bedeian, 1982. A comparison of LISREL and two stage least squares
analysis of an hypothesized life-job satisfaction reciprocal relationship. Journal of Applied
Psychology 67. 806-817.
Schmitt, N. and B. Schneider. 1983.‘Current issues in personnel selection’. In: K.M. Rowland and
J. Ferris (eds.), Research in personnel and human resources management, Vol. 1. Greenwich,
CT:JAI. Press.
Schmitt, N., B.W. Coyle, J.K. White and J. Rauschenberger, 1978. Background, needs, job
perceptions, and j o b satisfaction: a causal model. Personnel Psychology 31, 889-901.
Schneider, B., 1976.Staffing organizations. Santa Monica, CA: Goodyear Publishing Co.
Staw, B.M., 1984. Organizational behavior. Annual Review of Psychology 35, 627-666.
Steers, R.M. and S.R. Modes, 1978.Major influences on employee attendance: a process model.
Journal of Applied Psychology 63,391 -407.
Wanous, J.P., 1980.Organizational entry: recruitment, selection, and retention of new employees.
Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Weaver, C.N., 1977.Occupational prestige as a factor in the net relationship between occupation
and job satisfaction. Personnel Psychology 30. 607-612.
Weaver, C.N., 1978. Job satisfaction as a component of happiness among males and females.
Personnel Psychology 31, 831-840.
N . Schmirr, E.D. Pulakos / fob and life saris/action 167
Weiss, R.V., G. Dawis. G.W.England and L.H.Lofquist, 1967. Minnesota studies in vocation
rehabilitation: manual for the Minnesota satisfaction questionnaire. Minneapolis, MN: Univer-
sity of Minnesota.
Weitz, J.A., 1952. Neglected concept in the study of job satisfaction. Personnel Psychology 5 ,
201-205.