* 1. Fluency evaluation focuses on factual accuracy and task relevance.

True False

ChatGPT said:

False.

Fluency evaluation does not focus on factual accuracy or task relevance. Instead, it assesses the
clarity, readability, grammar, spelling, punctuation, and natural flow of the response. Factual
accuracy and task relevance fall under different evaluation dimensions.

4o

You said:

* 2. Grammar and punctuation mistakes are considered under the “Vocabulary & Syntax” criterion.
False True

ChatGPT said:

True.

Grammar and punctuation mistakes are considered under the “Vocabulary & Syntax” criterion in the
Fluency guidelines. This criterion evaluates how well the response adheres to standard grammar,
punctuation, and sentence structure conventions.

4o

You said:

* 3. Evaluators are encouraged to avoid using the “Tie” option unless absolutely necessary. True False

ChatGPT said:

True.

Evaluators are encouraged to avoid using the “Tie” option unless absolutely necessary, according to
the Spearmint guidelines. Clear preferences should be selected whenever possible to ensure
meaningful comparisons and feedback.

4o

You said:

* 4. Disfluent responses may include unidiomatic expressions or awkward syntax. False True

ChatGPT said:

True.

Disfluent responses may include unidiomatic expressions or awkward syntax. These are key
indicators of low fluency as outlined in the Fluency guidelines—they make the text sound unnatural
or hard to understand.

4o

You said:

* 5. A score of 3 on the Likert scale indicates a response with good fluency and no flaws. True False
ChatGPT said:

False.

A score of 3 on the Likert scale typically indicates a neutral or mixed fluency level — not necessarily
"good fluency with no flaws." A score of 5 would reflect excellent fluency with no errors, while 3
may suggest the response is understandable but may contain some awkward phrasing or minor
issues.

4o

You said:

* 6. Which of the following is NOT part of the fluency evaluation criteria? Coherence Clarity &
Conciseness Vocabulary & Syntax Relevance to the question

ChatGPT said:

Relevance to the question is NOT part of the fluency evaluation criteria.

Fluency focuses on Coherence, Clarity & Conciseness, and Vocabulary & Syntax — while Relevance
is assessed under a different dimension, such as Instruction Following or Task Relevance.

4o

You said:

* 7. When comparing two model responses, what should be your decision criteria? Accuracy and
completeness Length and engagement Overall fluency based on coherence, grammar, vocabulary,
and clarity Creativity and originality

ChatGPT said:

The correct answer is:

When comparing two responses for fluency evaluation, you should base your decision on how well
each response flows, its grammatical correctness, appropriate vocabulary use, coherence, and clarity
— not on accuracy, creativity, length, or engagement.

2/2

4o

You said:

* 8. Insightful responses should explore different frameworks such as legal, ethical, and psychological
perspectives where appropriate. True False

ChatGPT said:

False.

This statement pertains more to depth or critical reasoning, not fluency or tone evaluation. Fluency
evaluation does not require assessing whether a response is insightful or explores frameworks like
legal, ethical, or psychological ones. That's outside the scope of what fluency scoring is intended to
measure.
4o

You said:

* 9. An engaging response should always contain emojis and exclamation points to feel
conversational. False True

ChatGPT said:

False.

An engaging response does not require emojis or exclamation points to feel conversational. In fact,
overusing these elements can hurt tone appropriateness depending on the context. The Tone
guidelines emphasize that conversational tone should feel natural and audience-appropriate, not
forced or overly casual unless specifically fitting the prompt.

4o

You said:

* 10. You must always choose between Model A and Model B; ties are not permitted under any
circumstance. True False Question Title * 11. In the Fairness category, offering alternative solutions to
unethical requests without preaching is considered an excellent response. False True

ChatGPT said:

10. False.

Ties are allowed in certain circumstances. While evaluators are encouraged to avoid using the “Tie”
option unless absolutely necessary, it is permitted when both models are equally good or flawed in
ways that make a clear preference difficult.

11. True.

In the Fairness category, offering alternative solutions to unethical requests without preaching is
considered an excellent response. This shows a responsible and respectful approach to handling
ethical dilemmas.

4o mini

You said:

* 12. A response that restates the user's prompt without showing empathy can still earn a score of 5
for being Helpful. True False

ChatGPT said:

False.

A response that simply restates the user's prompt without showing empathy would not typically
earn a score of 5 for being Helpful. Showing empathy and addressing the user's needs or concerns is
an essential part of providing a helpful response, especially in the Tone guidelines.

4o mini

You said:
PROMPT User: I can't focus on anything today. My mind’s just all over the place. Response A: That’s
unfortunate. It happens. Maybe try again later when you feel better. Response B: It’s totally normal
to have off days where focus is tough. Is something bothering you today, or are you feeling
overwhelmed? I’m here if you want to talk it out. Question Title * 13. At what rate will Response A be
categorized in terms of Tone? Rating of 1 Rating of 2 Rating of 3 Rating of 4 Rating of 5 Question Title
* 14. At what rate will Response B be categorized in terms of Tone? Rating of 1 Rating of 2 Rating of 3
Rating of 4 Rating of 5

ChatGPT said:

13. Rating of 2

Response A lacks empathy and doesn't engage with the user's emotional state. It acknowledges the
issue briefly but fails to offer support or a more understanding tone, which results in a lower tone
rating.

14. Rating of 4

Response B demonstrates a much more empathetic tone. It acknowledges the difficulty the user is
experiencing, offers reassurance, and invites further conversation, showing understanding and
emotional engagement, which would earn a higher tone rating.

4o mini

You said:

PROMPT User: Why do people feel so peaceful in nature? Response A: People often feel peaceful in
nature due to a combination of sensory factors like gentle sounds, natural light, and open spaces
which reduce cognitive overload. Studies in psychology also show that being in natural environments
can lower cortisol levels and restore attention capacity. Response B: Many people experience peace
in nature because it offers a rare blend of sensory simplicity and psychological grounding. From an
evolutionary psychology perspective, humans may be innately drawn to natural environments, open
landscapes and flowing water once signaled safety and resources. Today, those same cues reduce
stress, quiet the mind, and promote mindfulness. Neuroscience even shows that exposure to nature
activates brain regions linked to empathy and calm. What aspects of nature make you feel most at
peace? Question Title * 15. Which Response can be categorized as Excellent (Rating of 5) in terms of
Tone: Response A Response B Both None of the above

ChatGPT said:

15. Response B

o4-mini

You said:

* 16. What is a key failure trait in the Fair category? The response is preachy or judgmental The
response suggests alternatives The response offers neutral guidance The response avoids ethical
topics Question Title * 17. In evaluating Engaging responses, which of these traits is most important?
Complex sentence structures and formal vocabulary Talking about the model’s own limitations Use of
emojis to appear friendly A warm, conversational tone with relevant follow-ups
ChatGPT said:

16. The response is preachy or judgmental

17. A warm, conversational tone with relevant follow-ups

o4-mini

You said:

PROMPT User: What are some eco-friendly habits people can adopt at home? Response A: Here is
eco habits for people in house: Turn off lights when not needed. Save electricity is good. Using less
water is also good. Not leave tap on. Recycling of paper, plastic, and metal is do. Response B: Here
are eco-friendly habits for home: Switch lights off. Use LED lights which is more energy-saving. Don’t
forget to turn off the faucet. It can help saving water. Try to recycling when possible. Paper, plastic,
and food are included. Question Title * 18. Which is the better response in terms of Fluency?
Response A Response B

ChatGPT said:

Response B

Response B is the better response in terms of fluency. It has clearer structure, correct grammar, and
more natural phrasing. Response A, on the other hand, contains several grammatical errors,
awkward phrasing, and lacks clarity in some parts.

4o mini

You said:

PROMPT User: What are some effective ways to encourage healthy eating in the workplace?
Response A: Eat fruit. No soda. Put signs on walls. Healthy is good. Salad bar maybe. Or snacks.
Water too. Response B: Stock healthy snacks like fruit and whole grains. Replace soda with water or
herbal tea. Use posters to promote balanced eating. Question Title * 19. Can Response A be
categorized as Medium in Fluency (3)? No Yes Question Title * 20. Can Response B be categorized as
High in Fluency (5)? Yes No

ChatGPT said:

19. No

Response A lacks clear structure, proper grammar, and fluency. It's too fragmented and lacks the
natural flow needed for a medium fluency rating.

20. Yes

Response B can be categorized as High in Fluency (5). It is clear, well-structured, and uses proper
grammar, making it easy to read and understand.

4o mini