Author Tutorial
Author Tutorial
This document is the confidential and proprietary information of Aries Systems Corporation, and may not be disseminated or
copied without the express written permission of Aries Systems Corporation. The information contained in this document is
tentative, and is provided solely for planning purposes of the recipient. The features described for this software release are likely to
change before the release design and content are finalized. Aries Systems Corporation assumes no liability or responsibility for
decisions made by third parties based upon the contents of this document, and shall in no way be bound to performance therefore.
Editorial Manager is a registered trademark and the property of Aries Systems Corporation.
AUTHOR TUTORIAL ........................................................................................................ 4
Author Software Requirements ..................................................................................................................................... 4
Logging In ...................................................................................................................................................................... 10
Multi-Language Toggle................................................................................................................................................. 11
eXtyles ............................................................................................................................................................................ 48
http://get.adobe.com/reader/
Users should contact their IT department if they experience difficulty installing or utilizing this software. Adobe also
offers a help database for the free Reader at this address:
http://www.adobe.com/support/reader/
For general Software and Hardware requirements when using EM, please use the following link:
http://www.editorialmanager.com/homepage/homefaq10.html
A pop-up alert box is displayed if the system is accessed with an unsupported browser.
Fill in the Required Pre-Registration information and click ‘Continue >>’ when done. There will then be a ‘Duplicate
Registration Check’.
Note: It is important that users enter their name exactly as they are known. It is not unusual for variations in spelling
to cause duplicate entries in the database.
Users should click on ‘Yes’ if they could already be registered. If the user is certain that he or she is not already
registered, he or she should click on ‘No’. The system will then present the ‘Registration’ page, which provides an
option to change First Name, Last Name, E-Mail Address or all three fields.
If no matches are found (i.e. no duplicates), then proceed to the second step, the Registration process.
Registration Process
The following screens will be displayed:
A user may indicate to the Publication that he or she is available as a Reviewer, by selecting “Yes” in response to the
question, ‘Are you available as a Reviewer?’
If the Publication is using classifications, users may also select Personal Classifications from a predefined list.
Note: If the Editorial Office has set up Classifications as a required field, users must select one or more areas of
expertise from this predefined list.
If the publication has Classification Ranking enabled, users may be asked to specify levels of personal expertise for
their selected Personal Classifications.
Clicking the ‘Rank Personal Classifications’ button will direct you to a pop-up window where users have the option to
rank their experience level for each Classification as ‘Low’, ‘Medium’ or ‘High’.
Note: If the Editorial Office has set up Personal Keywords as a requirement, users must enter the minimum
number of Keywords indicated.
Click on ‘Edit Personal Keywords’ to access the screen to enter free-form areas of expertise. To add a new Keyword,
simply type the Keyword(s) into the ‘New Keyword’ field and click on ‘Add’. Click on ‘Close’ after all Personal
Keywords have been entered.
At the bottom of the form, a preferred username must be selected. Failure to enter a username or any other required
information for registration will result in the following warning:
When satisfied with the information that has been provided, click the ‘Continue >>’ button at the bottom to proceed.
A ‘Registration Confirmation’ page will appear. Please ensure that everything is spelled correctly, and that the e-mail
address is correct.
If all fields are correct, click on ‘Continue >>’. The registration process is now complete, and the user may check
their e-mail for the password sent by Editorial Manager.
Once all necessary information has been provided, click on the ‘Continue >>’ button to proceed.
When the ‘Read more’ link is selected, this warning will be displayed:
Logging In
Users can begin to use the system once they have received a notification e-mail from the Editorial Office containing
the username and password.
Go to the Publication’s EM website. At the top of the navigation main menu a set of menu options is available. Click
on ‘LOGIN’- as shown below:
The Editorial Manager Log-In screen will be displayed. Enter the username and password in the appropriate fields.
Click on the ‘Author Login’ button. This will display the ‘Author Main Menu’ which will contain a list of functions
that may be performed in the system.
Note: If users have multiple roles with the Publication, it is possible to set up a default login role. The option to do
this can be found by clicking on the ‘Update My Information’ link on the main navigation menu.
Multi-Language Toggle
If your publication provides access to secondary languages, you will see the ‘language drop-down’ in the top right
corner of your screen as part of the main menu bar area. Here you may choose to display the site in a language other
than the Publication’s default language by selecting from the list of available languages.
If you switch to an alternate language, your preference will be saved by the system and the site will display in that
language at each subsequent login. Your preferred language is recorded as the one most recently displayed.
The user will then be redirected to the Registration screen, where all of the personal information currently available to
the Publication is displayed, and may be updated as needed.
Once changes have been made, click on the ‘Submit’ button. EM will check to see if all of the required fields have
been entered – if not, the following warning will be displayed:
Users may return to the information pages (click on the ‘<< Previous Page’ button) or can simply click on the button
labeled ‘Continue’.
Submitting a Manuscript
Once an author has logged into the system, the Author Main Menu will be displayed:
Click on the on the ‘Submit New Manuscript’ link. This will display the Submit New Manuscript menu. Authors will
be asked to enter data that is associated with the manuscript – this can include text, images and descriptions. Some of
o Full Title
o Short Title
o Abstract
o Comments
o Authors
o Keywords
o Classifications
The word or character count is made available at the time of submission if this feature has been enabled:
If the word or character count limitations imposed by the Publication have been exceeded, the user may not continue
on to the next step. If this is the case, a warning box will appear if the user clicks ‘Next’.
Add/Edit/Remove Authors
The Author submitting the manuscript will be listed as the Corresponding Author by default. Only the Corresponding
Author will receive any e-mail notifications from the system. The designated Corresponding Author may be changed,
but this person must be a registered Editorial Manager user, because he or she will need to be contacted throughout the
submission process. Other Authors do not need to be registered in the system, but may be included for the purpose of
appearing in the list of all Authors. A first name and last name are required.
The Author can designate the order in which Other Authors, including the Corresponding Author, should be listed.
After the Additional Author information has been entered, the list of Authors can be reordered by entering the desired
display rank in the ‘Order’ column and clicking the ‘Update Author Order’ button. The Author with “1” in the ‘Order’
Note: The user who begins the manuscript submission process is, by default, the Corresponding Author.
To change the Corresponding Author, first enter the name of the new Corresponding Author in the textboxes and click
the checkbox next to 'Please select if this is the Corresponding Author'. If the person entered is not registered with
Editorial Manager, the user will be unable to designate him/her as the Corresponding Author until that user has been
registered. If this person is registered with Editorial Manager, his or her username must be entered. However, please
note that if the Corresponding Author is changed, once the manuscript has been submitted, the user who has entered
the submission will no longer be considered the Corresponding Author and will not be able to access the manuscript.
The new Corresponding Author will receive an e-mail when the PDF is built, asking him or her to log into EM to view
and approve the submission before it can be sent to the Editorial Office.
Be aware that the journal may require or make optional secondary fields for the Co-Authors’ name and address
information. These fields are intended to store the information kept in the primary fields in a secondary language or
format. If you have any questions about what should be provided for these fields, consult the publication’s submission
policies.
Select Section/Category
The Section/Category list is used by the Author to indicate that his/her submission belongs to a particular ‘Section’ of
the Publication or belongs to a particular ‘Category’ within the contents of the Publication. This step may be optional,
required or hidden by the Editorial Office so the Author may not see it.
Submit Abstract
The ‘Submit Abstract’ step allows the Author to type or copy and paste the manuscript’s Abstract into a textbox. This
also may be an optional, required or hidden step.
Enter Keywords
Enter the keywords for the manuscript, with each keyword separated by a semicolon (for example: active vitamin D;
parathyroid hormone-related peptide; hypercalcemia; bone resorption). This may be an optional, required or hidden
step.
Select Classifications
Click the checkbox next to any classification to be selected. Authors may select as many classifications as
appropriate. Click 'Submit' when finished. This may be an optional, required, or hidden step.
Suggest Reviewers
If this function is enabled by the Editorial Office, Authors will be asked or required to provide names and contact
information for as many review candidates as the Publication requires for a submission. Please fill in the necessary
information:
Oppose Reviewers
If the site is configured to include this step, Authors are provided with the opportunity to inform the Editorial Office of
Reviewers that should not review the submission. Provide all of the necessary contact information:
Note: Publications may disregard any request for specific Reviewers to be either invited or excluded. The Suggest
and Oppose Reviewers steps simply provide information for the Publication to use when selecting appropriate
Reviewers.
Request Editor
Depending upon how the Editorial Office has configured the EM site, Authors may be asked to request a particular
Editor to be assigned to a submission. The request will be taken under advisement by the Editorial Office. Select an
Editor by using the drop-down menu and click ‘Next’ to proceed. This may be an optional step for a Publication. If
an Author is not directed to request an Editor, the submission will be assigned to an Editor selected by the Editorial
Staff.
Attach Files
Next, the Author will be asked to attach all of the files associated with the submission.
Some Publications accept information offline or outside of their EM websites (e.g.., e-mail, postal mail, or fax). If
offered the option of selecting either ‘Online Web System’ or ‘Offline,’ the Author may click the appropriate button.
Note: EM supports Open Document Files in the following formats: OpenDocument spreadsheet (.ods),
OpenDocument Word Processor (.odt) or OpenDocument presentation (.odp)
o Choose the Item from a drop-down box. Manuscript, figures or tables may all be separate Items in the drop-
down box, as the Items listed may vary with each Publication. Make sure to choose the correct one.
o The option of online or offline may not always be available since the Publication may require the Item to be
submitted online only.
o Locate the file on the hard drive using the ‘Browse’ button.
o Authors may attach files to their submission that have been ‘compressed’ (i.e. zip files). This allows Authors
to upload several files at once, rather than having to upload one file at a time. It also enables a faster upload
of a large single file. The system will automatically ‘unpack’ or ‘un-zip’ the file, so that the individual file(s)
can be attached to the submission. There is more information regarding the upload of compressed files at the
end of this section.
o Click ‘Attach This File’ to upload the file (uploading may take several minutes for larger files), and the
following window should appear:
For Items to be sent offline, please select the Item from the drop-down menu, click the ‘Offline’ Delivery Method, and
then click ‘Attach This File’. The Item will be added to the list of submission files with the ‘Offline’ designation so
that the Editorial Office can anticipate the Item’s arrival through an alternate delivery method.
Repeat this process until all Items in the submission have been specified. All attached files are visible in the list at the
bottom.
When all Items have been attached, click ‘Next’ at the bottom of the page.
Click ‘Build PDF for my Approval’. A thank you message will appear on the screen, and the manuscript will now be
located in the ‘Submissions Waiting for Author’s Approval’ folder on the ‘Author Main Menu’. To complete the
submission process and send the submission to the Editorial Office, the Author must view and approve the PDF. (See
‘Author PDF Approval’ in the following section).
Even if an Author is unable to complete the submission process, no data will be lost. The submission can be accessed
by clicking on the ‘Incomplete Submissions’ folder on the ‘Author Main Menu’.
File order can be changed by entering numbers in the text box next to each Submission Item. The files are numbered
in the sequence in which they were uploaded. For example, if four files are uploaded, the default value for each Item
is 1, 2, 3 and 4, respectively. The user can then change the order of the files by typing in a new order and clicking the
‘Update File Order’ button.
If the Publication has elected to impose a particular file order that differs from the order used, that imposed order will
supersede the order used. If the files are uploaded in an incorrect order the system will alert the Author and update the
order according to the publication’s settings.
The Submission Item Label Can Be Changed after the File Is Uploaded
The ‘Item’ column in the list of attached files contains drop-down boxes for each file, so the Submission Item
Description can easily be changed after the file has been uploaded. For example, if an Author uploads a Figure, but
did not select the ‘Figure’ Item from the Item drop-down box, the Item label would be incorrect. The Author can
change the description by typing the correct information in the box.
Example: File ‘Order’ and ‘Item’ designation, and ‘Description’ can all be changed after file upload
Removing Files
Once files have been attached, you can remove them from the submission individually or in groups. To remove an
attached file, simply select the file’s check box in the select column of the attached file grid and then click the Remove
button. Check All/Clear All links are available for selecting/deselecting all files. Once one or more files are selected,
a ‘Remove’ button is enabled, allowing the user to remove the selected files. You may select any number of attached
files for removal using these steps.
Compressed files are any files created by a “packing” utility, such as PKZip or WinZip. A compressed file may
consist of a single file, or multiple files. The primary purpose of ‘zipping’ or ‘compressing’ files is to reduce the
overall file size, thus facilitating faster transmittal. Compressed file formats supported include .zip and tar.gz. When
uploaded, EM unpacks the zip file into the individual files, at which point the author must select the Item Type for
each individual file.
The first drop-down contains an alphabetical list of the file extensions of all files successfully uploaded in the zip
file(s). If another zip file is uploaded, any new file extensions are added to the drop-down, and the list is re-sorted. If
any zip file contains files that have no extension (i.e. Mac files), the word “Other” displays as a choice at the end of
the list and applies to all files without an extension.
The second drop-down lists all Item Types configured for the selected Article Type.
A button labeled “Change Now” appears to the right of the dropdowns, but is disabled until both a file type and Item
Type have been selected.
Once the author has selected both a file type and an Item Type, the ‘Change Now’ button is enabled. The author then
clicks the button, and the selected Item Type is applied to all files with the selected file type.
Authors may use this feature to change the Item Type for a given file format as many times as necessary, as well as to
change any individual item manually.
If the Article Type is configured to ‘Allow file uploads from Los Alamos arXiv server’, the ‘Attach Files’ page
displays special instructions and a text box for entry of the arXiv file identifier. Authors can also upload additional
‘regular’ files on the same page, in addition to the arXiv file.
Select a Submission Item from the drop-down list and enter the arXiv code, which consists of a string of letters and
numbers identifying the particular Los Alamos database (i.e. hep-th or physics.acc-ph) followed by a forward slash
and a 7-digit number unique to Los Alamos (e.g., hep-ex/0401001, physics/0401001, math.AG/0401002).
Next click ‘Attach this File’. When the arXiv code is recognized by the Los Alamos server and the corresponding file
is found, the compressed file (.tar.gz format) containing the source files is downloaded from the Los Alamos server.
The .tar.gz file is unpacked by the system, and all of the individual files are uploaded to EM. Each file is listed
individually so Authors can associate each file with an appropriate Submission Item, edit the Description, and re-order
the list of files for PDF creation.
Note: Most documents on the Los Alamos arXiv server are in LaTex format. To assist Authors who may not be sure
which Submission Items to select for various arXiv file components (such as .bbl, .cls, .sty, etc.), the Publication can
create Submission Items in the drop-down menu, which describe these components (Bibliography file, Style File, etc).
If an Author is unclear about which Item to choose, select the Item that most closely describes the file and the system
will proceed without a problem.
Once the PDF version of a manuscript has been created by the system, the Author will see a set of links in the Action
column of the table (far left).
Note: The actual process of building the PDF may take several minutes, depending on the size of files and
outstanding PDF building activity.
‘View Submission’ allows an Author to view the PDF version of a submission. Authors may choose to make
alterations to a submission such as spelling corrections, description changes, extra graphics, etc. – this can be
done by selecting ‘Edit Submission’. If there is a problem creating the PDF, there will be a message in the
PDF explaining what may have caused the problem. The Author must view the PDF before it can be
approved.
‘Edit Submission’ will bring the Author to the same interface that was used when initially submitting a
manuscript. Authors can remove or add files at the Attach Files portion of the submission if anything needs
to be changed. If any changes are made, a new PDF file will be built. Once the Author has viewed the
submission, he or she will click ‘Approve Submission’ to send it to the Editorial Office.
‘Remove Submission’ allows Authors to remove a manuscript from the system (the Manuscript will never be
received by the Editorial Office). Authors can always remove a submission and start over if desired
When a submission has been approved, it will be filed in the ‘Submissions Being Processed’ list in the ‘Author Main
Menu’.
Authors may access the Fees and Payments page in the following ways:
2) At any point after a Fee has been levied on a submission, a new ‘Fees and Payments’ link will display in
Author folders. Authors may click this link at any point to take action on Fees or view the payment status.
3) An Author Payment deep link merge field may be included in letters. This link will log the Author into the
system and navigate them directly to the Fees and Payments page.
The Submissions Waiting for Author’s Approval folder is the first opportunity the Author has to see the ‘Fees and
Payments’ page. The submission step for an Author is to approve the submission by clicking the ‘OK’ button on the
‘Are you sure you want to approve the submission?’ alert. Upon clicking the ‘OK’ button for the ‘Are you sure…’
alert, the Author is taken directly to the new ‘Fees and Payments’ page.
The ‘Fees and Payments’ page displays the settings configured for the appropriate submission.
In the example below, the Submission Fee has two options – Society Member is levied one submission rate (75.00
USD), and Non-Society Members are levied another submission rate (100.00 USD). This Submission Fee has two
possible Payment Method options – ‘Bill Me’ or ‘Request Waiver’. To complete the submission, the Author would
select which pricing option applies, and which payment method he would like to use. There is also space for the
Author to enter comments to the publication.
When the Author clicks the ‘Proceed’ button on the Fees and Payments page, he proceeds to the ‘Author’s Decision’
page which confirms that he approved the submission (now it will be sent to the Editorial Office) and indicates his
selected method of payment for the Submission Fee.
If the Author selected ‘Credit Card’ for the payment method on the ‘Fees and Payments’ page, he or she can then click
the ‘Pay Now’ button and proceed directly to PayPal where he or she can pay by credit card or personal PayPal
account.
Note: The author is NOT required to have a personal PayPal account in order to pay any fees by credit card.
Once an Author has completed the credit card transaction, they are returned to EM.
When the Submission Fee payment is completed by either the ‘Credit Card’, ‘Request Waiver’ or ‘Bill Me’ option, the
‘Fees and Payments’ Action Link is displayed in relevant Author folders.
Clicking the ‘Fees and Payments’ link takes the Author to the same ‘Fees and Payments’ page, except now the Author
will see the current payment status, along with any notes the publication may have entered for the Author.
Other Fees
Clicking the Author Payment deep link takes the Author directly to the ‘Fees and Payments’ page, so he or she can
pay the fee (or request a waiver, or request a bill) immediately without having to login to the system. This is just like
paying a Submission Fee, as described previously.
Note: If the submission has more than one fee, the Author must select which fee he or she wants to view on a new
‘Select a Fee’ page. After making a selection, he or she will proceed to the ‘Fees and Payments’ page as shown
above.
The basic layout of the page is the same, including customized instructions, fee-specific instructions, payment
information and any notes to the Author that may be entered for this Fee. Below are some example layouts of what the
Author may see.
Note: It may not be possible to view the status date of a submission, depending on the system configuration chosen by
the publication.
Authors will be notified when the Publication has made a decision. If the Publication has provided access, the Author
will see a ‘Send E-mail’ link within the list of available actions. This will allow the Author to send an e-mail to the
publication at any time. The publication will have set up either one or multiple Ad Hoc e-mails that can be modified
for use by an Author. In some cases, using an Ad Hoc letter will allow users to attach files to the letter by choosing
from personal files.
When an Ad Hoc letter is configured to allow attachments, then the sender of the letter will see a new ‘Add/Change
Attachments’ button on the ‘Customize Letter’ page.
Clicking the ‘Add/Change Attachments’ button will open a window where files can be uploaded as an attachment from
a user’s local computer by clicking the ‘Browse’ button and choosing the file to be added.
The attached files now display above the ‘Add/Change Attachments’ button. If the user clicks the ‘Add/Change
Attachments’ button again, any files already attached are listed in the file table in the order they were attached. If the
user deselects or removes any previously attached files and clicks ‘Proceed’ on the ‘E-mail Attachment Upload’ page,
they are removed from the letter
Submissions for which the logged-in Author served as an Other Author are now included in their Submissions Being
Processed, Revisions Being Processed, and Submissions with a Decision folders (where the submission’s Article Type
requires Other Authors to register and the logged-in Author has successfully done so).
A new permission called “View Other Author Status” is added to the ‘Author RoleManager’ page. When this
permission is enabled, Authors see a new View Other Author Status Action Link (when applicable) that leads to the
Author version of the ‘Other Author Status’ page. This Action Link displays for Authors when this permission is
enabled for the Author Role and:
2) There are Other Authors on the submission, and at least one of them has been notified that verification of
their contribution is required.
3) The submission’s current Article Type is configured to either require co-author verification or co-author
registration.
From this folder the following options are listed: View Submission, File Inventory, Revise Submission, Decline to
Revise and View Decision.
View Submission
The ‘View Submission’ link allows the Author to see the PDF of the most recent version of the submission.
File Inventory
The File Inventory link allows the Author to download any of the source files that make up the submission. Authors
can access submission files and work on them before clicking the ‘Revise Submission’ link.
Submit Revision
The ‘Revise Submission’ link provides access to the ‘Submit Revised Manuscript’ interface that leads the Author
through the submission process.
This interface is similar to the ‘Submit New Manuscript’ interface. When the Author arrives at the ‘Attach Files’ step
in the process, he or she is presented with the list of source files from the previous version. The Author may choose
whether or not to carry over files from the previous version to the new Revision.
When presented with the list of source files, there is a checkbox displayed to the right of each file. The checkbox must
be checked to carry the file over to the new version of the submission. Read the instructions the publication will
provide on screen to see what they prefer. See below:
Click ‘Next’ to proceed to the next page, where there will be an option to upload revised files to be attached to the
Revised Submission. Again, it is possible to reorder the source files with the arrows, and upload new files (see
below). Click ‘Next’ to build the PDF.
Respond to Reviewers
A ‘Respond to Reviewers’ submission step can be displayed on the ‘Submit Revision’ page. Authors can click the
‘View Decision Letter’ link to view the decision letter, which includes the blinded comments from each Reviewer. If
If the ‘Respond to Reviewers’ step is ‘Required’, it will not be possible to build the revision PDF until text has been
entered in the ‘Respond to Reviewers’ text box.
The Author may have access to the submitted responses to Reviewer Comments in the ‘Revisions Being Processed’
and ‘Submissions with Decision’ folders.
Decline to Revise
This link is used when an Author decides not to submit a Revision. The submission record then moves to the Author’s
Decline Revisions folder. If this is done in error, the Author will be able to reinstate a Declined Revision.
View Decision
An Author can view the Decision Letter by clicking on the link in the ‘View Decision’ column.
1) Commentaries: A Publication may solicit commentaries on a submitted article (that may or may not have
yet been accepted for publication). This feature provides a way to invite an Author to submit a paper and link
the existing (‘parent’) submission to the associated commentaries.
2) Proposals: A Publication invites a leading expert (or experts) to submit a manuscript about a particular
topic; or a Publication devotes an entire issue (special issue) to invited manuscripts for a particular topic(s).
This feature provides a way to invite Authors to submit papers and link the submissions for the purpose of
tracking.
My New Invitations: This folder holds Proposals and Commentary Solicitations for which the Author has
not yet ‘Agreed’ or ‘Declined’ to submit a related article. A link appears for the Author to View the
submission for which an opinion/commentary is being invited. The Author is also given a link to the
invitation letter sent by the Editorial Office. There an Author is able to either Agree to Submit or Decline.
My Accepted Invitations: This folder holds Proposals and Commentary solicitations for which an Author
has ‘Agreed’ to submit a related article. A link appears for the Author to View the ‘parent’ submission for
which an opinion/commentary is requested. Authors are also given a link to the invitation letter sent by the
Editorial Office. Submissions move out of this folder once the ‘Submit Invited Manuscript’ link is clicked.
The Author can then submit the manuscript when ready. Once an Author begins to submit an invited
manuscript, it will move into the regular folders for Submitting and Incomplete – just like a regular
manuscript.
If enabled, all Authors are given access to a ‘Correspondence History’ page. The Author’s ‘Correspondence History’
page lists only those letters sent to or from the Author via the system, or those sent outside the system but added
manually by an Editor. Such letters include:
Authors will see a ‘Correspondence’Action Link in most of the folders displayed on their Main Menu:
When this link is clicked, a pop-up window will display all letters sent to or from the Author regarding this
submission. Letters are displayed in date order (newest on top), but can be sorted using the standard sort arrows.
External correspondence will display for the Author on the ‘History’ page. The item will be marked with (External) to
denote this message as having been added manually by an Editor.
When the Artwork Quality Results are viewed, a ‘Proflight Detail Report’ will provide analysis of the file.
The Artwork Quality Results will also display specific information regarding any problems with the file as well as
possible solutions. This means that an Author can make any necessary changes to the artwork files and upload new
files, better suited for production.
Reference Checking will attempt to find each publication citation in PubMed and/or CrossRef. However, Reference
Checking will not search for books or in press articles, as these texts are not listed in PubMed or CrossRef. If the
Reference Checking tool is able to find the citation in PubMed and/or CrossRef, a link to that citation is created.
If the Publication has Reference Checking enabled, Authors will see a link that says ‘View Reference Checking
Results’:
Clicking on the ‘View Reference Checking Results’ link will allow the Author to see the results of the reference
check:
Publication citations that cannot be matched with an entry in either PubMed or Cross Ref will be listed as either ‘Not
Validated’ (see #6 in the figure above), meaning the tool views the citation as a Journal reference but cannot locate it
on PubMed or CrossRef OR as Not Checked (see #3 above), meaning the citation does not appear to be from a
Journal.
Authors should view the Reference Checking Results and attempt to resolve any problems with the references prior to
submitting.