Theory construction
1. Role of Theory in Research
• Provides a Framework: Helps organize and interpret data.
Example: Agenda-Setting Theory helps analyze media's effect on public
opinion.
• Explains Phenomena: Clarifies why and how behaviors/patterns occur.
Example: Cultivation Theory explains how media shapes perceptions.
• Predicts Outcomes: Enables forecasting of future behaviors/events.
Example: Emotional Resonance Theory predicts which campaigns might go
viral.
• Informs Practice: Offers practical insights for real-world application.
Example: Agenda-setting helps in designing media campaigns.
• Refines Knowledge: Theories evolve over time, improving understanding.
Example: Media effect theories now include social/digital media impacts.
A. Key Differences:
Aspect Quantitative Research Qualitative Research
Purpose Test/validate theories Develop/explore new theories
Role of Theory Pre-existing theory used Theory emerges from data
Data Collection Structured (e.g., surveys) Unstructured (e.g., interviews)
Data Analysis Statistical Thematic
Theory Development Confirm/refine theory Generate new theory
B. Examples:
• Quantitative Research Example:
o Problem: Why do people share unverified info from untrusted
sources?
o Theory: Uses & Gratifications + Media Literacy
o Method: Survey (500 participants), Statistical tests
o Outcome: Confirms/refines theory
• Qualitative Research Example:
o Problem: How do people experience social media addiction?
o Theory: Emerges from data
o Method: In-depth interviews (20 participants), Thematic analysis
o Outcome: Development of new "Social Media Addiction Framework"
3. Strengths and Limitations
• Quantitative: Best for testing, measurement, generalization
• Qualitative: Best for exploring depth, context, and complexity
4. When to Use Each Approach
• Choose based on research question, nature of the topic, and goals.
5. Contemporary Challenges in Theory Construction
• Lack of Conceptual Frameworks: Difficulty defining new terms (e.g.,
"digital intimacy")
• Technological Obsolescence: Rapid platform changes (e.g., TikTok vs.
Facebook)
• Data Overload & Method Uncertainty: Massive unstructured data with no
clear analytical guidelines
• Ethical Gray Areas: Issues like privacy, consent in digital research
• Measurement Validity: Challenges in defining/measuring new variables
(e.g., engagement)
• Interdisciplinary Tensions: Clashes in methods/theories across fields (e.g.,
communication vs. computer science)
• Cultural Norms & Misinterpretation: Risk of misunderstanding digital
subcultures (e.g., memes, crypto)
• Publishing Hurdles: Pressure to fit into traditional frameworks despite
emerging topics
6. Key Takeaway
• Research in digital/social media needs flexibility, interdisciplinarity, and
creativity.
• Absence of existing theory is not a weakness—it’s a chance to create new
frameworks.