Approach To Learning Disability
Approach To Learning Disability
Division of Neurology, Dept. of Pediatrics, Lokmanya Tilak Municipal GeneralHospital and Lokmanya
Tilak Municipal Medical College, Sion, Mumbai, Maharastra, India
Abstract. Learning disabilities (LD) is one of the important causes of poor academic performance in school going
children. Learning disabilities are developmental disorders that usually manifest during the period of normal
education. These disabilities create a significant gap between the true potential and day to day performance of an
individual. Dyslexia, dysgraphia and dyscalculia denote the problem related to reading, writing and mathematics.
Perinatal problems are certain neurological conditions, known to be associated with LD; however, genetic
predisposition seems to be the most probable etiological factors. Evaluation of a child suspected to be having LD
consists of medical examination, vision and hearing test analysis of school performance. The psycho-behaviour
assessment and education testing are essential in the process of diagnosis. The experienced persons in the field
of LD should interpret the results of such tests. With Individualized Remedial Education Plan (IEP) most children
leam to cope up with disability and may get integrated in a regular steam. [Indian J Pediatr 2001; 68 (6) : 539-546]
teachers and educators are confronted with the Also, factors such as previous head trauma,
problem of understanding how best to educate these plumbism, otitis media, meningities, seizures and its
children, who fail to learn despite an average or above treatment have been shown to be associated with
average intellectual capacity. The learning disabled learning disability. Chronic medical conditions like
individual possesses a unique set of characteristics asthma may interfere with learning through
which needs to be recognized for an effective absenteeism and or concomitant emotional concerns.
educational intervention. Rutter et al (1970)s documented an increase incidence
There are three types of learning disabilities that are of learning and behavioural problems in children with
commonly described.3 They are as follows : epilepsy. Farwell et al (1990) 6 suggested that
phenobarbital may affect the cognitive function in 2-3
1. Dyslexia : The word Dyslexia is derived from the years old children given the medication to prevent
Greek word "dys" meaning difficult and "lexia" febrile seizures and may lead to learning problems.
meaning words or vocabulary. Commonly The exact aetiology of learning disability is difficult
interpreted as difficulty in reading, dyslexia to prove, nevertheless past medical problems do
denotes a language disorders affecting reading, contribute to the development of learning disability
spelling, speaking and listening. and may even compound the disability by frequent
2. Dysgraphia : The term refers to an unexpected school absenteeism. The exact cause and effect
difficulty in learning to write. relationship would be difficult to prove.
The neurologic disorders like Neurofibromatosis 1,
3. Dyscalculia : The term refers to a disorder
Tuberous sclerosis and children treated with cranial
affecting mathematical reasoning and
irradation have a higher frequency of learning
calculations.
disability and the ratio of nonverbal to verbal L.D. is
reversed, compared with the general population. 7
CLINICAL EVALUATION PROCEDURE
A. Birth History
An accurate diagnosis with a complete description of a
Information regarding pregnancy and birth is
child's learning problem is not possible without a
important to note as factors like prematurity, low birth
thorough evaluation. The evaluation must identify the
weight history of perinatal asphyxia may lead to
academic areas that present problems, the factors that
sequelae of learning disability. Lilenfield and Pasama-
contribute to the problems, the available strengths for
nick (1960)8proposed a range of factors like prolonged
compensation and the extent of non-academic
labour, malpresentation, cord around neck leading to
difficulties.
hypoxic ischemic injury to the brain responsible for
The clinical evaluation consists of the following : learning disability in children.
In a series conducted by Davie et al (1972),9Dunn et
9 Medical assessment including history with spedal
a/(1971)1~it was consistently reported that Appropriate
emphasis on events at birth, developmental
milestones, educational performance and socio- for Gestational Age (AGA) children faired better
cultural background of family. The detailed academically than Small for Gestational Age (SGA)
physical and neurological examination should be babies. Thus, prematurity and LBW may be considered
performed. The vision and hearing test should be as important contributing factors for the development
of learning disability.
undertaken to detect the sensory defidts if present.
9 Analysis of school performance : school reports, B. Development History
history of failures/condonement and assessment
of the child's behavior in school. The milestones in d e v e l o p m e n t of speech and
9 Assessment of General Cognitive Functioning as language are very important for evaluation of a child
measured on standardized tests for intelligence. with a suspected learning disability.
9 Assessment of Achievement Level - as measured Language Delay
on educational tests.
9 Assessment of associated behavioral and social Many children with learning disabilities have history
problem if any. suggestive of delay in language development. They fail
to use words, sentences or phrases at an appropriate
MEDICAL HISTORY age or continue to speak in single words. Many of these
children also have articulation problems which may
Events around the perinatal period are extremely persist for a long period through the school age. This
important in children with developmental disabilities? delay or imprecision of language use is often carried
over to learning letters of the alphabet and to reading. (1959)13and Bakwin (1973)14showed that concordance
Language deficits of reading, writing and spelling have rates for monozygotic versus dizygotic twins was
been described as developmental disturbances, higher.
reflecting an immature nervous system, u It was also
observed that learning disabled children had slow SOCIAL HISTORY
maturation of language skills, especially reading.
Socioeconomic status as well as education of parents
Therefore, delayed onset of speech may be a symptom
should be recorded. It has been reported that factor like
of a language disorder in the presence of otherwise
inferior intellectual level, lack of motivation, lack of
normal developmental milestones. environmental stimulation and parental indifference
Motor Co-ordination to the child's scholastic attainments interfere with the
school achievements. A child belonging to an
Children with learning disability may be slow to sit,
unpriviledge class may show lower performance due
walk or run and may have a general clumsiness.
to these environmental factors. Also, understanding of
Activities such as walking, jumping, catching are often
socioeconomic status of the family is of great help in
delayed. Children with LD tend to be clumsy and planning the interventional program for a child having
awkward on the playground and are unable to
learning disability.
perform simple physical exercises like toe touching or
balancing. PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
However, it may be noted that in most learning
disabled children, the motor milestone may be normal Primary learning disability itself has no specific signs
but and they often demonstrate motor clumsiness and found on physical examination. However, physical
awkward finger movements which are related to the examination including detailed neurologic
difficulties in motor co-ordination. examination is important to detect neurological defidts
or other handicapping condition in such a child.
Bladder Control
Neurocutaneous markers like hypopegmented-
Generally, bladder control is not delayed in learning macules (ash leaf macules), periungle filromas or
disabled children, but a few may have associated shagreen patches, multiple cafe-au-lait spots may be
enuresis. It was observed that children with enuresis seen in children with learning disability.
were found to have developmental delays twice as The presence of dysmorphic features like epicanthal
oftenJ2The aforementioned link between enuresis and folds, slanting palpebral fissures, microcephaly and
developmental delay, would suggest that there is a polydactly may be an indication of chromosomal
common underlying maturational factor that makes defects or associated M.R.
learning disabled children, more vulnerable to develop
enuresis as well as behavioural disturbances. NEUROLOGICAL EXAMINATION
TABLE5. Characteristics in Adults with L.D. noted that soft signs do not provide useful diagnostic
criteria for indication of brain dysfunction in learning
9 Hide reading problems, many subterfuge. disabled children and their absence does not rule out
9 Spell poorly; rely on others. the possibility of L.D.
9 Avoid writing, may not be able to write.
* Often competent in oral language. Dexterity
9 Rely on memory; may have excellent memories.
9 May have good spacial talents. It has been found that the incidence of left handedness,
9 Often very good at "reading" people. ambidexiterity and crossed laterality is comparatively
9 Have difficulty with planning and organization. h i g h in children w i t h LD. The dexterity s h o u l d be
9 Have difficulty with time; often too early, late, or forget tested in hand, leg, eye and ear.
appointments. Rely on digital watches; cannot tell time. A n u m b e r of behavioural characteristics, academic
abilities, perceptual and developmental difference may
termed these signs as neuromaturational signs. These be present to a greater or lesser extent. The signs and
signs are minor, m a y often occur in n o r m a l y o u n g s y m p t o m s as per the age of the child or grade level
c h i l d r e n a n d are n o t n e c e s s a r i l y r e l a t e d to a n y may be useful for suspecting the diagnosis of learning
structural lesion in the brain. Therefore it should be disability. They are summarized in the Tables 1 to 5.
ASSOCIATED BEHAVIOURAL PROBLEMS AND child's strengths and weaknesses in such areas.
FAMILY DISTURBANCES Individualized supportive education by the remedial
teacher to learning disabled children in regular school
helps the students to catch up with education in
The u n d e r l y i n g basis of learning disability is a
regular class. It is important that the remedial teacher
neurophysiological defect in cognitive processing but
and the regular class-teacher work closely to plan the
the overall effect is a cascade of reactions that seriously
duration of remedial instruction and activities to teach
affects many other functions. Psychological problems
students in the regular and remedial class to improve
are commonly observed in children with learning
their performance.
disability. 21
These children tend to be easily influenced by
CONCLUSION
others. Some of them may get involved in antisocial
activity and risk taking behaviour. Serious emotional
Learning disability forms an important cause of failure
disturbances such as low self esteem, temper tantrums
in school in otherwise capable children. The learning
may be observed in children with LD. Many children
disabilities are often accompanied by problems of at-
lack self confidence. Some demonstrate difficulties in
tention and concentration, organization, mood and
a p p r o p r i a t e l y m a n a g i n g t h e m s e l v e s in social
emotions and feelings and social interaction. A
situations. multidisciplinary approach is essential for early recog-
All these issues place a great stress on the family.
nition of this disability. The appropriate curriculum
Parents of learning disabled children are often
adjustment, help the child attain his / her maximum
frustrated by problems they face in trying to get help
educational potential and become a productive and
for their child's problem. Many of them deny it. Most
contributing adult member of the society.
parents are deeply concerned about future educational
possibilities and economic limitations that their child
REFERENCES
may face.
1. Hornsby B. Overcoming Dyslexia : A straight forward
ADHD AND LEARNING DISABILITY guide for families and teachers. Singapore : PG
Publishers Pvt. Ltd. 1994.
A reciprocal relationship exists between learning and 2. Hammil DD. On defining learning disabilities An
attention. Some children have difficulty in paying emerging consensus. J Learn Disabil 1990; 23 : 73-84.
3. Rutter M. Prevalence and types of Dyslexia. In Benton
attention secondary to their inability to understand AL, Pearl D, eds. Dyslexia, An Appraisal of Current
what is being taught or may have a primary attention Knowledge. New York: Oxford University Press, 1978;3-
deficit, is Distinction between learning disability and 28.
ADHD is often difficult because most of these 4. Erenberg G. Learning Disabilities; An overwiew.
childhood disorders have overlapping features. Seminars in Neurology 1991; 11 : 1-6.
However learning Disability and ADHD often coexists. 5. Rutter M, Tizard J, Whitemore K. Education, health,
The shared symptoms include distractibility, and behaviour. London: Longman, 1970.
disorganization, impulsiveness, poor social skills, poor 6. Farwell J, Lee YJ, Hirtz DG. Phenobarbital for febrile
self control and lack of self esteem. These children seizures-effects on intelligence and on seizure
recurrence. N Engl J Med 1990; 322 : 364-369.
show higher rates of anxiety than children diagnosed 7. Cohen BH. Neurologic causes of learning disabilities.
with isolated ADHD and have clear symptoms of this Seminars in Neurology 1991; 11 : 7-13.
disorder, but may have equally serious deficits in 8. Lilienfeld AM, Pasamanick B. The associationof mental
communication. Children with learning disability only and factors. With the Development of mental delivery.
by contrast characteristically demonstrate phonologic Am J Mental Deficiency 1960; 60 : 557.
and logic problems. 9. Davie R, Butler N, Goldstein H. From birth to seven: a
report of the national child developmentstudy. Br Med
REMEDIAL EDUCATION J 1972; 3 : 4.
10. Dunn H, Cricton JU, Robertson AM et al. Late
prognosis in children of low birth weight: Proceedings
Remedial or special education includes specific of the XIIIInternational Congress of Pediatrics; Vienna.
teaching strategies and teaching materials. It is a Academy of Medicine 1971; 33-38.
planned intervention designed to reduce, eliminate or 11. Zuckerman B, Chase C. Specific Learning Disability and
preclude deficiencies in specific learning areas. 15An Dyslexia: A language based model. 1984 year book
Individual Education Program (IEP) is formulated by medical publishers; 249-276.
the remedial teacher taking into consideration the 12. Lewis Melwin: Enuresis in children. In Child and
Adolescent Psychiatry-A Comprehensive Text Book. 2"dedn, EEG Brain Mapping in Dyslexia. Child Health
594-595. Development 1987; 5 : 9-21.
13. Hermann K. Reading disability: a medical study of 18. Shaywitz S. Shaywitz B. Dyslexia. In Swaiman KF, ed.
word blindness and related handicaps. Copenhagen: Pediatric Neurology Principles and Practice. 3rd edn, 1999;
Munksgaard 1959. 576-584.
14. Bakwin H. Reading disability in twins. Dev Med Child 19. Dakin DE. Educational Assessment and Remediation
Neurol 1973; 15 : 184-187. of Learning Disabilities. Seminars on Neurology 1991;
15. Shaywitz B, Shaywitz S. Learning Disabilities and 11 : 42-49.
Attention Disorders. In Swaiman KF, edr. Pediatric 20. Shapiro BK, Gallico RP: Learning Disabilities: The child
Neurology Principles and Practice. 2nd edn. 1989; 1119- with developmental disabilities. Pediatric Clinics of
1151. North America 1933; 40 (3) : 491-505.
16. Kulkami MV, Chad G, Shanbag P. Learning Disability 21. Pratt H. Donell D. Orfuse M. Disorders of cognition,
: Recent Advances in Pediatrics 1995; 5 : 314-333. attention and Learning. Ind J of Pediatr 1999; 66 9404-
17. Connors CK. Event related potentials and Quantitative 414.