Major Project
Major Project
Highway engineering is an engineering discipline branching from civil engineering that involves
the planning, design, construction, operation, and maintenance of roads, bridges, and tunnels to
ensure safe and effective transportation of people and goods. There are a lot of highways and
roads in India and the total length of those devices is more than 3.31 million km. India's road
transport is getting more and more in the last 20 years. The Indian highway has vehicles of many
different lengths which is different from many other countries, in India about 98% of the
equipment is flexible so bitumen are used as it is an important part of how well the mixer works.
Asphalt pay is waiting not only because of more traffic, but also because of extreme weather
conditions in the country in some parts of the country, pay temperature can be very high.
Weather conditions are a big part of deciding what kind of ingredients to use for built roads to
pay for bitumen, the quality of bitumen needs improvement. Aphalt pavements provides low
cost , high durability, waterproofing abilities, and rabbit construction. Before laying down the
actual payment a series of tests are performed to make sure the small can meet the requirements.
Bitumen aging is one of the major factors in the deterioration of asphalt pavement. As bitumen
aging causes the asphalt pavement to lose its ability to withstand stress during the cooling
number of environmental variables that affect it, including surface temperature, ultraviolet
Short-term ageing is deemed to represent the ageing a bituminous binder undergoes during
handling, storage, mixing, and laying of asphalt mixtures.The most commonly used test is
RTFOT test. The RTFOT method ensures that the bitumen flows continuously and that all
bitumen is exposed to air. Several modifications of RTFOT are used for high viscosity bitumen.
This research study consider the use of VG30 and aggregate in the construction of a bituminous
concrete layer. In the propsed study has tested the properties of normal bitumen and aged
bitumen . After testing it has been found that tha aged bitumen is better than the normal bitumen,
and aged bitumen imparts more strength as compared to the normal bitumen and comes up with
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1 General
1.1 Appearance
1.2 Composition
2.3 Summary
2.8 Aggregates
General
General
General
5.1 Analysis
5.2 Results
6.1 Conclusion
6.2 References
INTRODUCTION
1. GENREAL
Bitumen is the oldest known engineering material and has been used from the earliest times as an
adhesive, sealant and waterproofing agent. As long ago as 6000BC the thriving ship-building
industry in Sumeria used naturally occurring bitumen, found in surface seepage in the area.
The primary function of a pavement is to transmit loads to the sub-base and underlying soil.
Modern flexible pavements contain sand and gravel or crushed stone compacted with a binder of
bituminous material, such as asphalt, tar, or asphaltic oil. Such a pavement has enough plasticity
to absorb shock, there are two types of pavements based on design considerations i.e. flexible
pavement and rigid pavement. Difference between flexible and rigid pavements is based on the
manner in which the loads are distributed to the subgrade.
The most significant role of the pavement is to sustain the weight applied by a vehicle, such as a
truck or an airplane, without undue deformation. The layered construction of the pavement is
intended to disperse the weight under the wheel so that the resulting stress at the lowest layer of
the pavement, the sub-grade, is low enough to avoid damage. A vehicle wheel or airplane tire
applies the greatest significant load to a paved surface. In an elastomeric pavement, the strategy
is to distribute the load such that the stress at the sub-grade soil level is minimal enough that it
can withstand the stress without severe deformation. Soil should be enhanced when the present
soil is not stiff enough to withstand the relatively minor stress. If the soil is vulnerable to
dampness, it must also be improved. An issue like this may be rectified by the addition of lime
and Portland cement to the soil.
Generally, the layers in a pavement improve in quality as one goes up from the bottom to the
surface layer. The surface layer, which can be asphalt or concrete, is the most expensive and
stiffest/most durable layer in the entire pavement structure. Components of this layer are mostly
naturally occurring materials. For example, asphalt binder is a by-product of the petroleum
distillation process, and aggregates are obtained from rock quarries or riverbeds.
Generally, the layers in a pavement improve in quality as one goes up from the bottom to the
surface layer. The surface layer, which can be asphalt or concrete, is the most expensive and
stiffest/most durable layer in the entire pavement structure. Components of this layer are mostly
For the most part, as one moves up from the bottom layer to the surface layer, each layer of the
pavement gets better. The most costly and stiffest/durable layer in the overall pavement system is
the surface layer, which may be asphalt or concrete. The elements that make up this stratum are
largely found in nature. Asphalt binder, for example, is a by-product of petroleum distillation,
while aggregates come from rock quarries or riverbeds.
The largest stress occurs near the surface of flexible pavement, and as the depth of the pavement
increases, the stress reduces. As a result, the best material for the surface should be utilized, but
lower-quality materials may be used as the pavement depth grows. Because of the asphalt's
capacity to bend and deform somewhat, then return to its original place when each traffic load is
applied and released, the word "flexible" is employed. There is a chance that these small changes
could become permanent and cause ruts in the wheel path over time.
Quantity
Other Uses
5%
Roofing
10%
Paving
85%
Table 1.1: Distinction drawn between petroleum bitumen and coal tar
Bitumen Applications
Bitumen is widely used in the construction of asphalt roads and bituminous membrane
products. Bitumen is commonly used to build highways, motorways and rail networks.
1.4 Types of Bitumen:- Flexible pavements with bituminous surfacing are widely used in India.
The high traffic intensity in terms of commercial vehicles, overloading of trucks and significant
variations in daily and seasonal temperature of the pavement have been responsible for early
development of distress like rutting, cracking, bleeding, shoving and potholing of bituminous
surfacing. A factor, which causes concern in India, is very high and very low pavement
temperature conditions in some parts of the country. Under these conditions the bituminous
surfacing tends to become soft in summer and brittle in winter.
An ideal bitumen modifier used in pavement construction should fulfill the following primary
objectives:
To study the difference between the properties of the normal bitumen and RTFOT
bitumen.
To analysis the provided specimen's Marshall Stability and Marshall Flow value.
According to transportation engineers and bitumen technologists, the current standard tests
provide the "engineer responsible for the service performance of a bituminous concrete" with
too little or no information. One of the most important qualities of asphalt is its ability to flow.
Bituminous binder rheology refers to the flow characteristics of the material at different
temperatures in the field and during processing. To address these problems, a thorough
theological investigation of bitumen is necessary. As part of this planned research, the
structural and functional performance of RTFOT-modified bituminous concrete will be
evaluated. Physical features of several types of regular bitumen and RTFOT-modified
bitumen will be studied in the proposed research. Also, figure out how far the specimen can
move before it loses its strength the most.
1.8 Organization of Thesis: - This report of the dissertation has been organized into six chapters
which are briefed below:
Chapter 3 shows the methodology used for dissertation work which is done to evaluate
the strength characteristics of bituminous concrete using short Term Aging of Bitumen.
The flow chart of the proposed methodology covers the framework of the present study.
Chapter 4 covers the experimental program which has been done in the work. Various
tests that have been carried out during work and their standard test methods are
mentioned here.
Chapter 5 presents the analysis and results of various experiments which were
performed on the raw material and different grades of bitumen used in this study, such as
VG30. Find the optimal bitumen content of the bituminous mixes and also stability and
flow values obtained by the Marshall Test and compare the results of the bitumen and the
RTFOT Bitumen And show the results of RTFOT.
At the end of this thesis, all the studies which have been referred to are mentioned under the
title of references.
LITREATURE REVIEW
2.1.1 Shubham Bansal et al (2017)- Disposal of huge amount of discarded waste materials like
plastic, polythene bags, bottles, rubber tires etc, which are generated in huge quantity and causes
environmental hazards after their disposal. Present study attempts to utilize these waste materials
as partial replacement of bitumen to develop a modified binder, for making bituminous concrete
mix. To simulate with the field conditions, ‘Marshall Stability Analysis’ was performed on the
samples prepared by partially replacing ‘Optimum Bitumen Content’ with waste plastic (4%,
6%, 8% and 10%) and crumb rubber (5%, 10% and 15%). Experimental results demonstrate that
partial substitution of bitumen with waste plastic results up to 16% increment in strength whereas
with rubber material, about 50% increment in strength was observed as compared to the
conventional mix (CM). Laboratory testing results indicate that by using waste materials,
bituminous concrete of required strength and density can be obtained and an environment
friendly green pavement can be prepared with less material cost.
2.1.2 Goliya et al. (2017) studied the rutting behavior of polymer Modified bituminous mixes by
using waste plastic. In their study, they use waste plastic as an additive in bituminous concrete to
reduce the rutting defect in flexible pavement. They performed an experimental investigation on
BC. Samples of the bituminous concrete mix were prepared with or without waste plastic and
were tested for mechanical properties along with properties like rutting and fatigue. Their study
was done on BC mixes using VG30 grade bitumen having maximum stability was 14.20 KN at
OBC 5.49% by weight of the total mix. The waste plastic was added in BC mixes in various
proportion i.e. 4%, 7%, and 10% by weight of bitumen for both 15 processes (Dry and Wet
process). They perform wheel rutting Test on Bituminous concrete slab of specified dimension
and measure the resistance of BC mixes against permanent deformation at critical temperatures
(40℃, 50℃, and 60℃) under loading similar to that surface is applied. They concluded the
following results through their study. The stability in case of the dry process increased to14.70%
on addition of plastic up to 7% and further addition of plastic waste leads decrease in Marshall
stability values, similarly, in case of the wet process, it was 22.01% on addition of plastic up to
10% then further addition plastic waste Marshall Stability Value decreases. Thus, they concluded
that wet process of polymer modification gives improved bituminous mix (grading I) as
compared to the dry process. ii
2.1.3 Goel et al. (2004) study based on emerging road materials and innovative concepts that are
recognized for future development. They observed the various waste products such as fly ash,
2.2 Bituminous Paving Mixes: - Bituminous paving mixtures are used as surface or base layers
in a pavement structure to distribute stresses caused by loading and to protect the underlying
unbound layers from the effects of water. To adequately perform both of these functions over the
pavement design life, the mixture must also withstand the effects of air and water, resist
permanent deformation, and resist cracking caused by loading and the environment. Although
great strides have been made in understanding the behavior of bituminous mixtures and the
factors that affect their performance, much work remains. The following sections provide a
summary of some of the principal issues and challenges associated with the design and
production of bituminous mixtures that can meet the ever-increasing structural needs of modern
pavements
2.3 Properties of Bituminous Mixes :- Bituminous mixes should be stable, durable, flexible,
workable and should offer sufficient skid resistance. The mix consists of coarse and fine
aggregates, filler and binder. It may be well graded, open graded, gap graded or unbounded as
per the requirements. As far as possible, it should be economical also.
2.4 Summary
Bituminous mixes should be stable, durable, flexible, workable and should offer sufficient skid
resistance. The mix consists of coarse and fine aggregates, filler and binder. It may be well
graded, open graded, gap graded or unbounded as per the requirements. As far as possible, it
should be economical also.
Coating Of aggregate
Particles 95% Minimum IS:6241
The minimum percentages of voids in mineral aggregates of BC are shown in Table no.2.1 as
per the MORTH, 2013
Nominal Maximum Minimum VMA Percentage Related to design Percentage Air Voids
Particle Size (mm)
3.0 4.0 5.0
26.5 11.0 12.0 13.0
37.5 10.0 11.0 12.0
2.8 Aggregates : -
2.8.1 Coarse aggregates - Coarse Aggregates consist of crushed rock retained on the 2.36
mm sieve. They shall be clean, hard, durable of the cubical shape, free from dust and soft or
friable matter, organic or other deleterious substances. Aggregate meeting all the physical
requirements specified in table 500-18 of MORTH for Bituminous Concrete construction
2.8.2 Fine aggregates - Fine Aggregates consist of crushed stone passing on a 2.36 mm sieve
and retained on a 75-micron sieve. They shall be clean, hard, durable, dry and free from
dust and soft or friable matter, organic and other deleterious matter. Fine Aggregates
shall have a sand equivalent value of not less than 50 when tested according to IS 2720
part – 37, and the Plasticity Index of the fraction passing the 0.425 mm sieve shall not
exceeding 4 when tested in accordance with IS 2720 part – 5
2.8.3 Fillers - The filler should consist of finely divided mineral matter such as rock dust,
hydrated lime, or cement. The filler material should be graded within the limits. The filler
material should be free from organic impurities and have a plasticity index not more than
4. It is also possible to replace the conventional filler material of BC mixes with marginal
filler material to improve their properties. We have used cement as a filler in the design
of BC mixes.
2.8.4 Binder - An appropriate type of bituminous material is commonly used for Asphalt
Concrete mix as a binder complying with the relevant standard specifications or
otherwise specified. Bitumen shall be viscosity graded bitumen or Polymer modified
bitumen complying with IRC & MORTH specification, obtained from an approved
source
2.9.1 Abstract- The study investigated the aging properties of modified bitumen penetration
grade PG 76-22 (binder). The aging was simulated using the rolling film oven (RTFOT) and
pressure aging vessel (PAV) for short-term and long-term aging during production and lying of
asphalt mixtures, though the actual time of long-term aging in the field varies depending on
paving times and usage
The empirical tests, which include penetration and softening points, were conducted to ascertain
the binder consistency and also the viscosity of the binder was investigated before and after
aging. The RTFOT was conducted at 1630C for 85min, and PAV for 20hrs. Results from the
study indicated that aging resulted in oxidation of the bitumen with increase in the stiffness of
the binder. It was observed that aging increased the viscosity, decreased the binder penetration
and increased the softening point of the modified bitumen. It could be concluded that aging
increases hardness, thereby decreasing the penetration and increasing the binder softening point
and viscosity.
2.9.2 Introduction- Aging in bitumen normally resulted from the weathering of the binder due
to oxidation. The aging of bitumen is one of the principal factors causing the deterioration of
asphalt concrete pavements. The aging modes of failures includes fatigue, thermal induce cracks,
and raveling. In practice the actual time for short-term and long-term aging in construction sites
varies and depends on hauling distances and period of pavement usage John, R., and W. David
(2003). There are two basic mechanisms involved in binder aging, these include an irreversible
process like chemical changes of the bitumen, consisting of oxidation of bitumen molecules, and
loss of volatile components which subsequently has an impact on the rheological properties of
the binders. The reversible process is the second mechanism termed as physical hardening; this
involves the reorganization of the binder molecular structure, under specific conditions. Xiaohu,
L. and U. Issacsson (2002)
Bitumen aging can be attributed to some factors these include the binder characteristics and it
content in the mix, nature of aggregates and particle size distribution, air void content in the mix.
Other factors include production related parameters such as temperature and time Edwards, Y.
and U. Issacsson (2005). In this study the rolling thin film oven test (RTFOT) was used to
simulate short-term aging and the pressure aging vessel (PAV). The RTFOT measures the effect
of heat and air on a moving film of semi-solid asphaltic binder. The test temperature of 1630C
and time for the RTFO test is 85 min expected to produce aging effects comparable to average
site conditions Annual Book of ASTM Standards (2006)
Short-Term Aging- The different binder samples A and B were simulated and artificially aged
at 163 degree C for 85 mins using the rolling thin film oven test (RTFOT) in accordance with
ASTM D 2872 (2006). For variability test, the same standard temperature for RTFOT was
conducted at different additional time lags of 70 min and 100 min.
Long-Term Aging- Using Paved RTFOT residue were collected and placed in the PAV sample
rack in accordance with ASTM D 6521 (2000). The PAV is preheated to the 100°C test
temperature. When the PAV reaches within 2°C of the desired temperature, a pressure of 2070
kPa is applied using the valve on the air cylinder. After 20 hours, the air pressure is released
slowly (over a period 8 – 10 min) using the bleed valve.
2.9.4 Aging Concepts- The amphoteric are the most reactive in terms of reactivity are capable of
forming interlinked structures because they have more than one reactive site.
2.10 Conclusion- Effect of aging on bitumen performance was studied. The conclusion drawn
from the study are
For storage, penetration decreases 90% for 26 days and viscosity increased 77% for 26 days
For different sources of aging For UV aging 30% penetration for 9 hours and 17% in thermal
aging. ductility varies 14% for UV and 44% for thermal aging.
The aging can be prevented by rejuvenation methods like, emulsion treatment and addition of
fille, thus rejuvenating the bitumen ensures longer life to pavement;
METHODOLOGY
General: The main objective of the study is to find out the difference between the properties of
normal bitumen and RTFO bitumen in respect of same grade of bitumen. Bituminous Mixes are
of the most commonly used all over the world in pavement construction. Review of the literature
indicated that currently, construction of pavements is largely based on conventional materials
while flexible pavements. This chapter presents the framework of the proposed methodology to
assess the strength characteristics of bituminous concrete using VG30, which is presented in the
following section. An attempt has been made to explain the principle and methodology of testing
the ageing properties and strength characteristic by using different apparatus like RTFOT &
Marshall apparatus. Various empirical tests have been conducted to describe the physical
properties of the bitumen binders before and after ageing. The purpose of this research is to
investigate how bitumen properties change as a result of ageing.
3.1 Methods of Laboratory Aging: The aging of bituminous binders is one of the key factors
determining the lifetime of an asphalt pavement. The process of aging involves chemical and/or
physical property changes that usually make bituminous materials harder and more brittle, thus
increasing risk of pavement failure. The aging-related pavement failure modes include cracking
(thermal or traffic induced) and raveling. Cracks on pavement surface may increase aging of the
binder because of increased exposure area to atmospheric oxygen.
To simulate field aging in laboratory, different types of test may be used, including conduction
of accelerated aging on bituminous binders, loose asphalt mixture, or on compacted asphalt
specimen. For bituminous binders, there are three European standardized tests for short-term
aging at high temperatures, namely Rolling Thin-Film Oven Test (RTFOT, EN 12607-1), Thin
Film Oven Test (TFOT, EN 12607-2), and Rotating Flask Test (RFT, EN 12607-3). These tests
reasonably simulate aging particularly during mixing process in an asphalt mixing plant.
3.2 Rolling Thin Film Oven Test: The Rolling Thin-Film Oven (RTFO) procedure provides
simulated short term aged asphalt binder for physical property testing. Asphalt binder is exposed
to elevated temperatures to simulate manufacturing and placement aging. The RTFO also
provides a quantitative measure of the volatiles lost during the aging process.
The basic RTFO procedure takes unaged asphalt binder samples in cylindrical glass bottles and
places these bottles in a rotating carriage within an oven. The carriage rotates within the oven
3.3 Tests on Bitumen: - There are a number of tests to assess the properties of bituminous
materials. The following tests are usually conducted to evaluate different properties of
bituminous materials.
3.3.1 Penetration Test: - It measures the hardness or softness of bitumen by measuring the
depth in tenths of a millimeter to which a standard loaded needle will penetrate vertically in 5
seconds. BIS had standardized the equipment and test procedure. The penetrometer consists of a
needle assembly with a total weight of 100g and a device for releasing and locking in any
position. The bitumen is softened to a pouring consistency, stirred thoroughly and poured into
containers at a depth at least 15 mm in excess of the expected penetration. The test should be
conducted at a specified temperature of 25o C. It may be noted that penetration value is largely
influenced by any inaccuracy with regards to pouring temperature, size of the needle, weight
placed on the needle and the test temperature. A grade of 40/50 bitumen means the penetration
value is in the range 40 to 50 at standard test conditions. In hot climates, a lower penetration
grade is preferred.
3.3.2 Ductility test: - Ductility is the property of bitumen that permits it to undergo great
deformation or elongation. Ductility is defined as the distance in cm, to which a standard sample
or briquette of the material will be elongated without breaking. Dimension of the briquette thus
formed is exactly 1 cm square. The bitumen sample is heated and poured in the mould assembly
placed on a plate. These samples with moulds are cooled in the air and then in water bath at 27o
C temperature. The excess bitumen is cut and the surface is leveled using a hot knife. Then the
mould with assembly containing sample is kept in water bath of the ductility machine for about
90 minutes. The sides of the moulds are removed, the clips are hooked on the machine and the
machine is operated. The distance up to the point of breaking of thread is the ductility value
which is reported in cm. The ductility value gets affected by factors such as pouring temperature,
3.3.3 Softening point: - Softening point denotes the temperature at which the bitumen attains a
particular degree of softening under the specifications of test. The test is conducted by using
Ring and Ball apparatus. A brass ring containing test sample of bitumen is suspended in liquid
like water or glycerin at a given temperature. A steel ball is placed upon the bitumen sample and
the liquid medium is heated at a rate of 5o Page | 26 C per minute. Temperature is noted when
the softened bitumen touches the metal plate which is at a specified distance below. Generally,
higher softening point indicates lower temperature susceptibility and is preferred in hot climates.
3.3.4 Flash and fire point: - Test At high temperatures depending upon the grades of bitumen
materials leave out volatiles. And these volatiles catch fire which is very hazardous and therefore
it is essential to qualify this temperature for each bitumen grade. BIS defined the ash point as the
temperature at which the vapor of bitumen momentarily catches fire in the form of ash under
specified test conditions. The fire point is defined as the lowest temperature under specified test
conditions at which the bituminous material gets ignited and burns.
3.3.5 Viscosity: - Viscosity denotes the fluid property of bituminous material and it is a measure
of resistance. At the application temperature, this characteristic greatly increases the strength of
resulting paving mixes. Low or high viscosity during compaction or mixing has been observed to
result in lower stability values. At high viscosity, it resist the comp active effort and thereby
resulting mix is heterogeneous, hence low stability values and at low viscosity instead of
providing a uniform film over aggregates, it will lubricate the aggregate particles. Cannon
Manning Viscometer are designed for the determination of the absolute viscosity of bitumen and
cut back by a vacuum capillary method at specific temperature.
Cannon Penske viscometer is designed for the determinations of the kinematic viscosity by a
vacuum capillary method. Various type of glasses capillary viscometer are used to measure the
viscosities because no signal capillary is suitable for the measurement of materials of all
viscosities.
Calculate and report the absolute viscosity to three significant figures by following
equation
Viscosity Poise = Kt
where,
Abrasion test is carried out to test the hardness property of aggregates and to decide whether they
are suitable for different pavement construction works. Los Angeles abrasion test is a preferred
one for carrying out the hardness property and has been standardized in India (IS: 2386 part-
IV). The principle of Los Angeles abrasion test is to find the percentage wear due to relative
rubbing action between the aggregate and steel balls used as abrasive charge. Los Angeles
machine consists of circular drum of internal diameter 700 mm and length 520 mm mounted on
horizontal axis enabling it to be rotated (see Fig-2). An abrasive charge consisting of cast iron
spherical balls of 48 mm diameters and weight 340-445 g is placed in the cylinder along with the
aggregates. The number of the abrasive spheres varies according to the grading of the sample.
The quantity of aggregates to be used depends upon the gradation and usually ranges from 5-10
kg. The cylinder is then locked and rotated at the speed of 30-33 rpm for a total of 500 -1000
revolutions depending upon the gradation of aggregates. After specified revolutions, the material
is sieved through 1.7 mm sieve and passed fraction is expressed as percentage total weight of the
sample. This value is called Los Angeles abrasion value.
The aggregate impact test is carried out to evaluate the resistance to impact of aggregates.
Aggregates passing 12.5 mm sieve and retained on 10 mm sieve is filled in a cylindrical steel cup
of internal diameter 10.2 mm and depth 5 cm which is attached to a metal base of impact testing
machine. The material is filled in 3 layers where each layer is tamped for 25 numbers of blows
Page | PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2
(see Fig-3). Metal hammer of weight 13.5 to 14 Kg is arranged to drop with a free fall of 38.0 cm
by vertical guides and the test specimen is subjected to 15 numbers of blows. The crushed
aggregate is allowed to pass through 2.36 mm IS sieve. And the impact value is measured as
percentage of aggregates passing sieve (W2) to the total weight of the sample (W1).
Aggregate impact value = (The total weight of the sample (W1)) / (Percentage of
aggregates passing sieve (W2)) x 100
Aggregates to be used for wearing course, the impact value shouldn’t exceed 30 percent.
For bituminous macadam the maximum permissible value is 35 percent. For Water bound
macadam base courses the maximum permissible value defined by IRC is 40 percent.
Marshall Method Theory and Scope: Bituminous mixes are used in the surface course of road
and airfield pavements. The desirable bituminous mix properties include stability, density,
durability, flexibility, resistance to skidding and workability during construction. Stability is
defined as resistance of the paving mix to deformation under load and is thus a stress level which
causes strain depending upon anticipated field conditions. Stability is function of friction and
cohesion. Durability is defined as the resistance of the mix against weathering which causes
hardening and this depends upon loss of volatiles and oxidation.
2.4.1 AIM- To determine optimum binder content of given bituminous mix by Marshall Method
of Mix Design.
2.4.2 Apparatus: Mould Assembly, Sample Extractor, Compaction Pedestal and Hammer,
Breaking Head, Loading Machine, flow meter, thermometers, water bath and oven. hot courtesy
of WA M
2.4.3 Procedure:
The corrected Marshall Stability value of each specimen is determined by applying the
appropriate correction factor, if the average height of the specimen is not exactly 63.5 mm.
Table No. 2.2: Required Correction Factor for Marshall Stability Value
1000
Gt = W 1 W 2 W 3 W 4
+ + +
G1 G2 G3 G4
G −G m
V v= t x100
Gm
W
V b= 4 xGm
G4
VMA = V v +V b
Vb
VFB = x100
VMA
W 1=¿Percentage by weight of course aggregate in the total mix
W 2 = Percentage by weight of Fine aggregate in the total mix
W 3 = Percentage by weight of filler in the total mix
W 4 = Percentage by weight of bitumen in the total mix
G 1 = Apparent specific gravity of course aggregate
G2 = Apparent specific gravity of fine aggregate
G3 = Apparent specific gravity of filler
G4 = Specific gravity of bitumen
Gm = Bulk density or mass density of the specimen
Gt = Theoretical maximum specific gravity of the mixture
3.5 Proposed Methodology :- In this study , the methodology have been developed related to
the characteristics of the bituminous concrete based on the literature review of the natural
aggregates and one unmodified bitumen binder used as a pavement construction material. The
proposed methodology of the present study is shown in the below flow chart. We have developed
this methodology for conducting the experimental work on the bituminous concrete mixes. The
proposed methodology provides an idea of how we can incorporate the ageing properties of
bitumen in the construction of bituminous concrete pavements.
3.6 Procurement of Material and Characterization :- Firstly we have procured the raw
material that required for the study. Procured mainly three types of raw material i.e. aggregates,
fillers, and binders and then Characterized them Natural Aggregates of 19 mm nominal size,. and
VG30 as the binder for mixes.
3.8 Gradation of aggregates :- Based on the nominal size of aggregates, we have selected the
Grading-I for the BC mix design according to MoRTH (2013) guidelines. Then matching the
obtained grading of Natural Aggregates with a range of Grading-I.
3.9 Mix design by using Aggregate and Binders :- After the grading of aggregates, have
selected the proportions of aggregates and prepare the mix of BC with the trial value of bitumen
with 4.3%. For each sample of the trial value of bitumen three specimens were prepared. The
compaction of the specimens through the Marshall hammers and kept in a water bath at 60℃
maintained temperature for 30 minutes. Analysis and Comparison of Results Preparation of
Marshall Samples for unmodified BC mixes Marshall Stability Value, Marshall Flow Value,
Marshall’s Test on all unmodified BC mixes & determine the Optimum bitumen content of the
bitumen specimens same process for the RTFOT modified bitumen.
3.10 Analysis and Results- The results obtained through the natural BC mix and one modified
BC mix have to tabulate and compare with each other at OBC. By drawing the bar graph of each
mix the analysis of results will be done.
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
General: This research work has been carried out on bituminous mixes for performance
assessment of BC using natural aggregates & Unmodified bitumen (VG-30). First of all, find out
the physical properties of all the raw material used in this study. Aggregate, cement as a filler &
in binder VG30. Performance evaluation can be carried out by conducting Marshall Stability,
skid resistance test and indirect tensile strength. Aggregate and cement was obtained from
nearly spotted crusher and shops behind the College. An attempt is made in the present
investigation to study the performance and properties of BC mix with partial replacement of
different grade and different percentage of binders to compare their strength characteristics with
conventional BC mixtures. Bitumen had obtained from different batch of bitumen.
4.1 Properties of Bitumen:-The bitumen used in this study was VG30. The Requirement of
bitumen as a binding material and its different forms were discussed. Various tests are conducted
on bitumen to assess its consistency, gradation, viscosity, temperature susceptibility, and safety.
Standard test procedures are followed according to codebooks specified in the table below. The
requirements of the physical properties of binders are tabulated in Table.
MoRTH
Test
S. No. Properties specification
Method
(2013)
Penetration (100 gram,
1 5second at 25ºC) (1/10th of IS 1203 30 to50
mm)
Softening Point ºC (Ring and
2 IS 1205 60
Ball Apparatus),
Ductility at 27 ºC (5cm/ minute
3 IS 1208 +50
pull),cm
4 Specific Gravity IS 1202 1.01
IS 1206
5 Viscosity at 150 ºC, Poise 5-9
(Part 2)
In the proposed study the entire basic laboratory test have been performed on VG30 as per the
test methods mention in Table 10. In figure shows the ductility test performed on VG30 by using
the ductility testing machine. In the study have taken total 6 samples of two specimens for each
binder conducting the ductility test. The test results of the binder are tabulated in Table 16.
Similarly, Figure 9 shows that the penetration test performed on specimens.
Thus, continuing the laboratory test on every binder and performed the next ring and ball test for
measuring the softening point of every binder. Figure 11 shows that how the ring and ball test for
measuring the softening temperature of VG30 have been conducted. 2 specimens of each VG30
with ring and ball have been taken to find out the softening point of VG30. The next test on
VG30 is to determine the viscosity of bitumen by using canon manning viscometer tube. The
viscosity at a standard temperature of 150℃ in poise have been measured as per the test method
in IS 1206 (Part2). Figure 11 shows that the viscometer bath containing a viscosity measuring
tube.
The flash and fire point tests are also conducted by using the Penske-Martin open cup by
following the test procedure given in IS1209.
In the proposed studies, the aggregates were collected for the testing of their physical
properties in the laboratory. Followed the standard test methods for testing of
aggregates used in BC mixes. Figure 14 (a) shows the aggregates used in BC mixes.
First of all, the abrasion test was performed on aggregate by using the Los Angeles
Abrasion Testing Machine. The equipment used to measure the abrasion resistance of
aggregates shown in Figure 14(C),
The impact test on the aggregates also to be conducted to know the toughness of the
aggregate used in BC mixes. The Impact Testing Machine used for measuring the toughness
The remaining aggregate tests were also conducted in the same manner by following the standard
test methods are mentioned in Table and water absorption test and specific gravity test on
aggregates were conducted by using the pycno-meter and the test results are presented in Table.
4.3 Aggregate Gradation: - In the proposed study, collected the Aggregate used in the
construction of BC mixes. Then the sieves were arranged according to the MORTH (2013)
for Grading -I for bituminous concrete. Grading of NA has been done manually without
using sieve shaker. Aggregate grading that satisfies the requirement of the Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways (MoRTH, 2013) specifications for midpoint gradation for Grading-I
of Bituminous Mix were selected and are tabulated in Table 4.3
4.5 Design of Bituminous Concrete Mix:- The bituminous mix design aims to determine the
proportion of bitumen, filler, fine aggregates, and coarse aggregates to produce a mix that is
workable, strong, functional, durable, and economical. The requirement of material and their
proportions by weight and by volume shown in the phase diagram of the bituminous mix.
Stage 1: The first stage of this mix design divided into three steps first of all selection of
aggregates as per the type of mix mentioned in Table 4.8. Then the selection of grading of
aggregates according to MORTH (2013), here we have select Grading - I for 19 mm nominal
size of aggregates. Then we have determined the specific gravity of aggregates through Pycno-
meter Method.
Stage 2: We have divided this stage into further two steps by measuring the proportion of
aggregates according to blend made in Table 4.3 and make the proportion of mixes. Then the
Stage 3: In this stage measurement of weight of compacted specimen taken in air and water both
separately and calculate the specific gravity of compacted specimens. After that compacted
specimen put in the Marshall Machine to determine the stability and flow value of the specimen.
Similarly, the specimens which were prepared at different bitumen content were put into the
Marshall machine. After that note down the maximum stability value and minimum flow value
of specimens and select the optimum bitumen content
Stage 4: Before testing the specimen, their dimensions are measured to note the volume and their
weight of specimen in air, weight of specimen in water, and weight of specimen saturated and
dry conditions are taken. The following quantities are worked out for analysis i.e., Bulk specific
gravity of Compacted Mixture, Theoretical maximum specific Gravity, Percent of air voids,
Percent of air voids in mineral aggregates (VMA), Percent of voids filled with bitumen (VFB)
and further the results are plotted as shown in Figure 3. After that the specimens are kept in
water bath maintained at 60°C for 60 minutes. The specimens are tested 3 to 4 minutes after
taken out from water bath. The specimen is put in Marshall Apparatus and Marshall Stability and
flow dial gauge readings are observed according to ASTM D6927-15 standards. Repeat the same
process for remaining specimens.
4.6.1 Marshall Sampling Mould:- The Marshall Sampling mould is a standard unit which used
to make the compacted specimens of BC mixes. It has standard dimensions that produce most
likely equal volumes of BC specimens. The specification of the Marshall sampling mould and
hammer are tabulated in Table 4.6.
Mould
4.6.2 Mixing Procedure:- The mixing of ingredients was done as per the following procedure.
• Required quantities of coarse aggregate and fine aggregate & mineral fillers
were taken in an iron pan
• This was kept in an oven at a temperature of 160℃ for 2 hours. This is because
the aggregate and bitumen are to be mixed in the heated state so preheating is
required.
• The VG30 was also heated up to its melting point before the mixing in
different apparatus in different utensils.
• The aggregates in the pan were heated on a controlled electric heater for a few
minutes maintaining the above temperature.
• Now bitumen (54 gm), i.e., 4.5 % was added to this mix and the whole mix was
stirred uniformly and homogenous in Asphalt Mixer. This was continued for
15-20 minutes till they were properly mixed which was evident from the
uniform color throughout the mix.
• The total 75 no. of blows were given per each side of the sample so subtotal of
150 no. of blows was given per sample.
• Then these specimens with moulds were kept separately and marked them.
Fig 15.
Figure shows that the compacted specimens of the BC mix. We have prepared specimens for
each Percentage and different grade mentioned in previously of bitumen content. The specimens
The following equation are involved in the calculation of the volumetric part and void analysis
part of the study. The various terms involved in this portion are evaluated after the gradation of
material and measuring the specific gravity of raw material. These formulas were put into the
Microsoft Excel sheet and the values of all the parameters were found.
In this study, a total of seven different compositions of mixes were prepared and the samples
were named. The weight of bitumen and aggregate for each sample was calculated. The
specimens mixed consisting of only natural aggregates were prepared by adding the different
percentages of bitumen content. The Marshall Test specimens were made by adding 4.8 percent
bitumen by total weight of aggregates according to Asphalt Institute Manual Series No.2 (MS-2).
The ratio of Marshall Stability to Flow Value, known as Marshall Quotient, was also calculated
and it was found to be within limits (2-5 KN/mm) for all samples. All the specimens were
conditioned by keeping them in a water bath maintained at 60 °C for 30 min and then tested in
the Marshall Testing Machine. The bitumen content corresponding to maximum stability,
maximum density, and 4% voids were determined, and averages of these values were taken as
OBC for each mix. It can be observed that all the properties fulfill the requirements of MoRTH
(2013).
General: -
This chapter shows that the results obtained after performing tests on both the types of BC mix
through the Marshall Testing Machine. The chapter has two parts ,first part contains calculations
and analysis and the second part covers the results obtained in the present study. We have done
successfully the test for Marshall Properties, volumetric measurement of specimens of BC mixes,
and void calculations. After conducting these tests over the BC mixes we analyze the physical
properties of ingredients used in the preparation of BC mixes. And the results obtained through
the experimental work in this study.
5.1 Analysis:-
5.1.1 Analysis of the Physical Properties of ingredient used in BC mixes :- First of all
the basic test has been performed the basic on VG30 based on the previous literature
review 1 unmodified binder has been selected in this study. It can be observe from
below Table all the basic properties of VG30 is under the safe limit. The limits of
these properties in MoRTH incorporate from the IRC SP: 53 Is: 73 & IRC SP:55
guidelines on the use of modified bitumen in road construction.. Results in this table
the shared results of RTFO abstract Bitumen and after that comparison of the
properties in the result sections. After the RTFOT method analysis the results has
been shown. This works on the short term ageing properties of bitumen.
RTFOT MoRTH
S. Test VG-30
Properties PMB-40 specification
No. Method Results
Results (2013)
Penetration (100 gram,
1 5second at 25ºC) (1/10th IS 1203 66 70 50-70
of mm
Softening Point ºC (Ring
2 and Ball Apparatus), IS 1203 50 54 45-52
Minimum
Ductility at 27 ºC (5cm/
3 IS 1208 53 60 +40
minute pull),cm
4 Specific Gravity IS 1203 1.01 1.02 0.97-1.02
After conducting the test on bitumen, test on aggregates has been conducted which is used in the
construction of BC mixes. Table 18 shows the results obtained through the basic laboratory test
on aggregates.
MoRTH
Natural
S. No. Properties Test Method specification
Aggregate
(2013)
Aggregate Impact
01 IS:2386 (IV) 15% Max 24%
Value
Los Angeles
02 IS:2386 (IV) 21.78% Max 30%
Abrasion Test
Water Absorption
03 IS:2386 (III) Max 2%
Value
2.67For 10mm,
2.69 For 6mm,
04 Specific Gravity IS:2386 (III) 2.83 For Stone 2.5-3.0
Dust
Combined
05 Flakiness and IS:2386 (I) 26.23% Max 35%
Elongation Index
Now some results related to the RTFOT apparatus which has been used for the short term aging
properties of bitumen. After rotating it up to 5 hrs it has been seen some changes in the weight of
bitumen and some others properties of bitumen which are mentioned previously in this chapter.
5.2 Results:-
Table shows the results of BC mixes with natural aggregate, with some trial percentages of
bitumen, i.e., 4.5, 5.3, 5.5, and 6.5. The weight of bitumen is divided by the total weight of
aggregate and the total weight of the aggregate is 1200 gms.
The mean values of different parameters of mix calculated and tabulated in Table 20. Graphs are
plotted between the percentage of bitumen content and the following parameters.
8.4
8.2 8.25
8 8
7.8
7.6 7.62
7.53
7.4
7.2
7
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
4 3.53
3.5 3.2
2.81 2.94
Fig. 24 shows the relationship between the Marshall Flow Value and Bitumen Content. It is
observed that with an increase in bitumen content, the flow value of natural BC mixes is
increasing.
2.71
Unit Weight(g/cc^3)
2.7 2.7
2.69 2.69
2.68
2.67 2.67
2.66
2.65 2.65
2.64
2.63
2.62
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
Fig. 25 shows the relationship between the bitumen content and the unit weight of BC mixes. It
is observed that with an increase in bitumen content, the unit weight increases up to a certain
extent and then decreases on a further increase in bitumen content. The maximum unit weight
was obtained at 5.3% of the bitumen content.
VMA(%)
10
0
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
Fig. 26 shows the relationship between the percentage of void mineral aggregates and bitumen
content. It is clear from the graph that there is an increase in bitumen content and the increase in
%VMA.
74
73.55
73
72 72
71 71
VFB(%)
70
69 69
68
67
66
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
Fig, 27 shows the relationship between bitumen content and the percentage of the void filled
with bitumen. The graph shows the parabolic relation between these two parameters. As the
bitumen content in the mix increases, there is a increase in %VFB in bitumen content.
Now the results which is getting from the RTFOT Bitumen After the decreasing the weight of
short term ageing properties , stability and flow value etc. Here tabulated in the results of VG30
ans RTFOT bitumen
Chart Title
9 8.96
8.79
8.6 8.62
8.2 8.23
7.8
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% RTFOT Bitumen Content
Fig 28 shows the relationship between the Marshall Stability Value and the RTFOT bitumen
content of BC mixes. The result observed that with an increase in bitumen content, there is a
increase in Marshall Stability.
Marshall FlowValue
3.6 3.53
3.4 3.4
3.2 3.24
(mm)
3 3.01
2.8
2.6
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% RTFOT Bitumen Content
Fig. 29 shows the relationship between the Marshall Flow Value and RTFOT Bitumen Content.
It is observed that with an increase in bitumen content, the flow value of RTFOT BC mixes is
increasing.
Chart Title
4.4
4.26
Unit Weight(g/cc^3)
4.2
4.11
4 4.04
3.8
3.67
3.6
3.4
3.2
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% RTFOT Bitumen Content
Fig 30 shows the relationship between the bitumen content and the unit weight of RTFOT BC
mixes. It is observed that with an increase in bitumen content, the unit weight increases up to a
certain extent and then decreases on a further increase in bitumen content. The maximum unit
weight is obtained at 5.3% of the bitumen content.
VMA(%)
27.35
25 24.1
20
15
10
5
0
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
Fig 31 shows the relationship between the percentage of void mineral aggregates and bitumen
content. One can see clearly through the graph that with an increase in bitumen content and an
increase in %VMA
Chart Title
75
74.65
74 73.78 74.05
73
VFB(%)
72
71.32
71
70
69
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
Figure 32 shows the relationship between the percentages of voids filled with bitumen and the
content of RTFO bitumen. The graph shows the relationship between these two parameters. As
the increase in bitumen content in the mix, the increase in %VFB increases in bitumen content.
5.3 Comparisons between the different grades of bitumen:- For the assessment of the
different Marshall properties of mixes at different percentages of bitumen, has made a
9.5
Marshall Stability(KN)
8.96
9 8.79
8.65
8.5 8.23 8.25
8
8
7.53 7.62
Normal VG30
7.5
RTFOT VG30
7
6.5
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
Fig 33. Comparisons between Normal VG30 & RTFOT VG30 Bitumen
Fig. 33 shows that after short-term aging, bitumen provides more strength compared to normal
bitumen. It can bear more and provide great strength against normal bitumen. Now comparing
the Marshall Flow value of bitumen.
Table 5.7 Results of Comparison of Marshall Flow Value for VG30 &
RTFOT VG30
4
3.4 3.533.53
3.5 3.24 3.2
3.01 2.94
3 2.81
2.5
2
1.5 Normal VG30
1 RTFOT VG30
0.5
0
4.5 5.3 5.5 6.5
% Bitumen Content
Fig 34. Comparisons between Normal VG30 & RTFOT VG30 Bitumen
Fig. 34 shows that after a short period of aging, bitumen provides more flow value to the load
applied to its surface than normal bitumen. It can bear more and provide great strength against
normal bitumen.
The results that the RTFOT bitumen produces more strength compared to the normal bitumen.
The short term properties has been changed in bitumen then it gives us strength against the load
apply on the road and flow value of the load to easily bear the load and not to attempt the crack
easily on the surface of the bitumen.
Discussion: - The proposed research demonstrates that pavement temperature has a significant
impact on the rate of aging. It has been shown that the viscosity of various bitumen’s increases at
varying rates as time passes. Aging causes chemical or physical property changes in bituminous
materials, making them harder and more brittle and reducing the chance of pavement failure.
This Marshall Stability test is used in the hot-mix design of bitumen with particles up to 25 mm
Page | PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2
in size. The Marshall technique is often used in India to create BC mixes. This test method is
utilized in the development and evaluation of bituminous pavement mixtures. This exam is often
utilized in paving work and regular testing programs. In comparison to regular bitumen, RTFOT
bitumen generates higher strength. The bitumen's short-term qualities have been altered, giving
us strength against the load applied to the road and a flow value of the load that allows us to
quickly wear the load and avoid cracking on the bitumen's surface. One of the most important
things that affect how the long asphalt pavement lasts and how old the bituminous binders get.
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSION
The main objective of this study is to investigate the short term aging of bitumen and to
study how this aging affects the properties of bitumen. The results obtained from single
bitumen tested in the aged state where compared with the results obtained after short
aging treatments.
From this study it has been observed that the RTFOT modified bitumen BC mix
possesses the improved Marshall characteristics. It is observed that the Marshall Stability
value increases with bitumen 5.2% and further increasing after increasing the bitumen
content increases.
Viscosity values of RTFOT modified bitumen is found to increase by 1.5 times in case of
un modified binder after short term aging test.
The results suggest that bitumen aging is more severe for the top portion of the pavement
because it is exposed to atmospheric air and the pavement temperature is higher so a
hardness gradient develops with the depth of the pavement which may play a major role
in the top surface break phenomenon.
REFERENCES
IRC: 37, 2018. Guidelines for the design of flexible pavements. Indian Road Congress:
New Delhi
IS: 73, 2013. Paving bitumen–specification Indian Standard Code for unmodified
bitumen.
MoRTH (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways), 2013. Specifications for road and
bridge works. In Indian Road Congress. New Delhi, India: Author
SP 53. (2010). Guidelines on use of modified bitumen in road construction.
Jing, R., Varveri, A., Liu, X., Scarpas, A. and Erkens, S., 2019. Laboratory and field
aging effect on bitumen chemistry and rheology in porous asphalt
mixture. Transportation Research Record, 2673(3), pp.365-374.
IS: 2386, 1963. Methods of test for aggregates for concrete–Part 1: Particle size and
shape.