BJT VS Fet
BJT VS Fet
Electronics (NPN) and Holes (PNP) for (either electrons in an N-channel FET or
Charge Carries current flow (Majority and minority holes in a P-channel FET).
carriers)
A type of transistor in which electric
field is used to control the flow of
current in a semiconductor.
Polarity Bipolar Unipolar
FETs have three terminals:
the source, the drain, and the
gate. The gate terminal
controls the conductivity of
the channel between the
source and the drain.
Depending on the type of
FET, the channel can be
Emitter (Highly dopes): is the formed by either majority
terminals through which the electrons (N-channel FET) or
majority carriers (electrons majority holes (P-channel
for NPN and holes for PNP) FET).
enter the transistor. Source (S): The source
Base (Light Doped) – middle terminal is the terminal from
region of transistor. Control which the majority charge
Terminals the flow of charge carries carriers (electrons for n-
from the emitter to the channel JFET or holes for p-
collector. channel JFET) enter the
Collector (Slightly doped) – channel.
collects the majority charges Drain (D): The drain terminal
emitted from emitter. is the terminal through which
the majority charge carriers
exit the channel.
Gate (G): The gate terminal
controls the conductivity of
the channel by modulating
the depletion region width. It
determines the output
current based on the voltage
applied to it.
Connections Common Base: Common source (CS), common gate
(CG), and common drain (CD)
Common Emitter
Page 1 of 13
Common Collector
Page 2 of 13
High-frequency circuits: In RF and
microwave applications, like satellite
communication systems.
The choice between BJT and FET depends on the specific requirements of the application, taking into consideration factors
such as current handling capabilities, voltage gain, power consumption, and cost-effectiveness. By understanding the
differences between BJT and FET, engineers can make informed decisions to optimize the performance of their electronic
designs and pave the way for technological advancements in various fields.
Page 3 of 13
Feature BJT (Bipolar Junction Transistor) FET (Field Effect Transistor)
Current-controlled device → small base
Control Voltage-controlled device → gate voltage (VGS) controls
current controls large collector-emitter
Mechanism current between drain & source.
current.
Bipolar: Both majority & minority carriers Unipolar: Current flow due to only majority carriers
Charge Carriers
(Electrons in NPN, Holes in PNP). (electrons in N-FET, holes in P-FET).
Polarity Bipolar Unipolar
- Emitter (E): Heavily doped, injects carriers. -
- Source (S): Entry of majority carriers. - Drain (D): Exit of
Base (B): Thin, lightly doped, controls carriers.
Terminals carriers. - Gate (G): Controls channel conductivity (via field
- Collector (C): Moderately doped, collects
effect).
carriers.
Basic Common Base (CB), Common Emitter (CE), Common Source (CS), Common Gate (CG), Common Drain
Configurations Common Collector (CC). (CD).
- Cut-off (VGS < Vth): No conduction. - Ohmic region: Acts
Modes of - Active: Amplifier mode. - Saturation: Fully
like variable resistor. - Saturation (VDS > VGS − Vth):
Operation ON (switching). - Cutoff: Fully OFF.
Amplifier mode.
Input Impedance Low (kΩ range, due to base current). Very high (MΩ–GΩ, due to insulated/reverse-biased gate).
Output Resistance High (esp. in CE config). Low (CS config).
Temperature
Positive → risk of thermal runaway. Negative → self-stabilizing.
Coefficient
Switching Speed Slower (limited by charge storage). Faster (no charge storage, voltage-controlled).
Sensitivity Highly sensitive to base current changes. Less sensitive to minor gate voltage changes.
Noise
Higher noise (minority carrier recombination). Very low noise (no recombination, only majority carriers).
Performance
Size & IC Use Larger, less compact. Smaller, ideal for ICs (CMOS, VLSI).
Power
Higher (requires continuous base current). Lower (only gate charging current).
Consumption
Gain-Bandwidth
Higher (better linearity, better for analog). Lower.
Product
Radiation
More susceptible. Less susceptible.
Sensitivity
Relationship
Linear (better analog amplification). Non-linear.
(Input vs Output)
Cost Cheaper. More expensive.
Installation No special handling needed. Requires careful handling (gate oxide fragile).
Types NPN & PNP JFET, MOSFET (Enhancement/Depletion), IGBT
- CMOS digital ICs (microprocessors, memory). - Power
- Amplifiers (audio, RF). - Oscillators. - Voltage
Applications MOSFETs in SMPS & motor drives. - Low-noise amplifiers
Regulators. - Switching in TTL circuits.
(receivers, sensors). - Analog switches, multiplexers.
Advantages
Page 4 of 13
Faster switching (high-speed digital).
Low noise → perfect for biomedical signal amplifiers (ECG, EEG).
More thermally stable (no thermal runaway).
Compact size → ICs, CMOS logic.
1. Control Mechanism
o JFET → channel controlled by reverse-biased junction.
Page 5 of 13
o MOSFET → channel controlled by electric field through oxide (capacitor effect).
2. Modes of Operation
o JFET → always depletion-type.
o MOSFET → both depletion and enhancement available (enhancement is dominant in ICs).
3. Suitability
o JFET → low-noise, precision analog.
o MOSFET → fast switching, digital + power electronics.
JFETs → used in front-end of biomedical sensors (ECG/EEG amplifiers) due to low noise.
MOSFETs → used in medical ICs (digital processors inside imaging devices, pacemakers, infusion pumps)
BJT
UJT FET SCR
Parameter (Bipolar Junction
(Unijunction Transistor) (Field Effect Transistor) (Silicon Controlled Rectifier)
Transistor)
Single PN junction, 3 terminals Two PN junctions, 3 Voltage-controlled, 3
Four-layer PNPN, 3 terminals
Structure (Emitter E, Base-1 B1, Base-2 terminals (Emitter, terminals (Source, Drain,
(Anode, Cathode, Gate)
B2) Base, Collector) Gate)
Current-controlled
Voltage-controlled (emitter Voltage-controlled (gate Current-triggered (gate
Control Type (base current controls
voltage controls conduction) voltage controls channel) current turns it ON)
conduction)
Active, Cutoff,
Ohmic, Cutoff, Saturation, OFF, ON (Latching behavior,
Modes of Normally used as relaxation Saturation modes for
Pinch-off (depending on once ON stays ON until
Operation oscillator or triggering device amplification &
FET type) current < holding current)
switching
Cannot amplify (not an
Can amplify (high gain Can amplify (voltage- Cannot amplify, only acts as
Amplification amplifier, only
device) controlled gain) switch/controlled rectifier
oscillator/trigger)
Low (requires
Input Moderate (lower than FET, Low (needs gate current to
significant base Very high (10⁶–10⁹ Ω)
Resistance higher than BJT) trigger, then latches)
current)
Large (10s to 100s Moderate (mA to 100s
Output Very high (tens to 100s of
Small (mA range) mA, up to Amps in mA, Power MOSFETs →
Current Amps in power SCRs)
power BJTs) Amps)
Moderate (not as fast as
Switching Moderate to fast Very fast (especially
Moderate (used in oscillators) MOSFETs, used in AC power
Speed (depends on BJT type) MOSFETs)
control)
Relaxation oscillator, Power control (AC/DC motor
Amplifiers, digital Amplifiers, analog
triggering SCRs/triacs, drives, lamp dimmers,
Applications logic, switching, signal switches, digital logic,
sawtooth wave generators, inverters, controlled
processing power electronics
timing circuits rectifiers)
Symbol Simple (one emitter arrow, More complex (two Channel + gate Thyristor symbol (anode,
Simplicity two bases) junctions) representation cathode, gate)
Main Very cheap, simple High current handling High input resistance, low High power handling with
Advantage oscillator/trigger device & amplification power consumption control capability
Requires continuous Sensitive to static charges Latches ON, needs forced
Main Cannot amplify, limited power
base current → power (MOSFETs), lower power commutation (hard to turn
Limitation handling
loss than BJT for small devices OFF)
Key Takeaways
Page 6 of 13
UJT is neither a true amplifier like BJT/FET nor a power switch like SCR; it is a special-purpose device mainly for
oscillators, pulse generation, and triggering.
Compared to BJT/FET, UJT is much simpler but limited in function.
Compared to SCR, UJT is often used as a trigger source for firing SCRs in power electronics.
IGBT:
The Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor also called an IGBT for short, is something of a cross between a conventional Bipolar
Junction Transistor, (BJT) and a Field Effect Transistor, (MOSFET) making it ideal as a semiconductor switching device.
The IGBT Transistor takes the best parts of these two types of common transistors, the high input impedance and high
switching speeds of a MOSFET with the low saturation voltage of a bipolar transistor, and combines them together to produce
another type of transistor switching device that is capable of handling large collector-emitter currents with virtually zero gate
current drive.
The Insulated Gate Bipolar Transistor, (IGBT) combines the insulated gate (hence the first part of its name) technology of the
MOSFET with the output performance characteristics of a conventional bipolar transistor, (hence the second part of its name).
The result of this hybrid combination is that the “IGBT Transistor” has the output switching and conduction characteristics of a
bipolar transistor but is voltage-controlled like a MOSFET.
IGBTs are mainly used in power electronics applications, such as inverters, converters and power supplies, were the demands of
the solid-state switching device are not fully met by power bipolar and power MOSFETs. High-current and high-voltage bipolar
are available, but their switching speeds are slow, while power MOSFETs may have higher switching speeds, but high-voltage
and high-current devices are expensive and hard to achieve.
The advantage gained by the insulated gate bipolar transistor device over a BJT or MOSFET is that it offers greater power gain
than the standard bipolar type transistor combined with the higher voltage operation and lower input losses of the MOSFET. In
effect it is an FET integrated with a bipolar transistor in a form of Darlington type configuration as shown.
Page 7 of 13
Parameter Small Signal Transistor Power Transistor
watt). sinks required.
Large size, often TO-220, TO-247, TO-3 with metal tab
Physical Size Small size, usually in TO-92, SOT-23 packages.
for heat dissipation.
Lower current gain (20 – 50) because of high current
Gain (β or hFE) High current gain (100 – 1000).
handling.
Frequency Wide bandwidth; suitable for high frequency Limited frequency response; mainly used in low to
Response applications (RF, audio, signal amplification). medium frequency power switching.
Slower compared to small signal transistors due to
Switching Speed Very fast due to low capacitance.
higher capacitance and large junction area.
Requires heat sinks or cooling systems due to high
Heat Management No heat sink required (natural cooling is enough).
power dissipation.
Examples BC547, 2N2222, 2N3904. TIP41, 2N3055, MJ2955, IGBT modules.
Used in X-ray machines, MRI gradient power supplies,
Biomedical Used in ECG, EEG, EMG amplifiers, hearing aids,
hospital UPS, surgical laser drivers, ventilator
Applications sensor interfacing, medical imaging pre-amps.
compressors.
Small Signal Transistors → Amplification of weak signals (low voltage, low current).
Power Transistors → Switching and amplification of large loads (motors, power supplies, converters).
Size & Packaging differs significantly because of heat dissipation needs.
Current Gain is high in small signal, but intentionally lower in power transistors for stability at high currents.
(BJT, FET/JFET, MOSFET, IGBT, Small-Signal vs Power, “Which to prefer & why”, plus Biomedical applications)
Q1. At room temperature, which device’s transconductance increases linearly with its quiescent current?
A) JFET B) Enhancement MOSFET C) BJT D) IGBT
✅ Ans: C — gmBJT=IC/VTg_m^{BJT} = I_C/V_TgmBJT=IC/VT; linear in ICI_CIC (with VT≈26 mVV_T\approx 26\,\text{mV}VT
≈26mV).
Q2. Which device naturally includes a body diode between its main terminals?
A) BJT B) JFET C) MOSFET D) IGBT (die-level)
✅ Ans: C — Power MOSFET structure creates an intrinsic body diode; IGBT modules often add an external freewheel diode.
Q3. For very high source impedance sensors (≥1 MΩ), which front-end input device minimizes input bias error?
A) BJT B) JFET/MOSFET C) IGBT D) Small-signal BJT Darlington
✅ Ans: B — FET gates have ultra-high input impedance → negligible bias current.
Page 8 of 13
Q4. Which device is most prone to thermal runaway in linear operation without emitter/source balancing?
A) BJT B) JFET C) MOSFET D) IGBT
✅ Ans: A — BJT has negative temp-co of VBEV_{BE}VBE → current hogging risk.
Q5. In a switching converter, dynamic losses scale approximately as 12CissV2f\tfrac12 C_{iss} V^2 f21CissV2f. Which parameter
is not part of that expression?
A) Input capacitance B) Bus voltage C) Switching frequency D) On-resistance
✅ Ans: D — RDS(on)R_{DS(on)}RDS(on) impacts conduction loss, not the ½CV2f½CV^2f½CV2f switching loss.
B) BJT Focus
Q6. A CE amplifier with constant ICI_CIC is moved from 25 °C to 75 °C. Which parameter rises significantly?
A) VBEV_{BE}VBE B) gmg_mgm C) rπr_\pirπ D) Early voltage
✅ Ans: B — gm=IC/VTg_m = I_C/V_Tgm=IC/VT; VTV_TVT increases with T → gmg_mgm increases slightly for fixed ICI_CIC.
Q9. For lowest voltage noise with a 50 Ω source, the best input device is:
A) JFET B) MOSFET C) Low-noise BJT D) IGBT
✅ Ans: C — BJTs excel with low source impedance (voltage noise advantage).
Q13. JFETs are preferred over MOSFETs when the priority is:
A) Lowest gate leakage (DC) B) Highest input impedance
C) Lowest 1/f noise with mega-ohm sources D) Highest f_T
✅ Ans: C — JFETs often have excellent low-freq noise for high-R sources.
Page 9 of 13
C) Avalanche breakdown D) Thermal shutdown
✅ Ans: B — Saturation region for JFET.
D) MOSFET Focus
E) IGBT Focus
Q22. Compared to MOSFETs, IGBTs usually show higher turn-off loss due to:
A) Body diode B) Tail current from stored charge
C) Gate leakage D) Miller effect only
✅ Ans: B — Minority carrier tail current.
Q24. In IGBT modules, the freewheel path for inductive loads is usually provided by:
A) Intrinsic body diode B) External/Co-pack diode
Page 10 of 13
C) Emitter-collector diode D) Snubber capacitor only
✅ Ans: B — Co-pack (anti-parallel) diode is standard.
Q34. When you need very low dropout linear pass element at low voltage/high current, which is often best?
A) BJT Darlington B) Logic-level MOSFET in linear region (careful SOA) C) IGBT
D) JFET
✅ Ans: B — MOSFET can give milliohm-level drop; must respect SOA.
Page 11 of 13
H) Biomedical Applications (Device Choice & Rationale)
Q38. Ventilator blower motor inverter (24–48 V, 10–20 kHz) generally favors:
A) IGBT B) MOSFET C) BJT D) Triac
✅ Ans: B — Low-to-mid voltage + high switching freq → MOSFET.
Q40. Photoplethysmography (PPG) / pulse oximeter TIA (photodiode readout) front-end favors:
A) BJT input B) FET input (very low bias current) C) IGBT D) Power MOSFET
✅ Ans: B — Photodiode leakage is tiny; FET input minimizes bias current error.
Q41. Electrosurgical unit (ESU) RF power stage at a few hundred kHz generally uses:
A) SCRs B) IGBTs only C) RF-rated MOSFETs D) UJTs
✅ Ans: C — RF MOSFETs handle the frequency and switching efficiently.
Q42. In biopotential amplifiers, the dominant noise mechanism the device choice tries to minimize is:
A) Shot noise of body diode B) 1/f and bias current noise at high source impedance
C) Tail current of IGBT D) Avalanche noise
✅ Ans: B — Hence FET-input architectures are common.
Q44. To isolate & drive a small infusion pump motor from a microcontroller:
A) Small-signal BJT in linear region B) Logic-level MOSFET with flyback diode
C) UJT D) JFET
✅ Ans: B — Efficient low-side switching + diode for inductive kick.
Page 12 of 13
Small-signal vs Power: speed/noise vs current/thermal; package & SOA matter.
Biomedical: FET inputs for microvolt signals; MOSFETs for low-V fast switching; IGBTs for high-energy pulses/drives.
Page 13 of 13