Unit 9
Unit 9
9.0 Objectives
9.1 Introduction
9.2 Definition Importance and Uses of Sensory Evaluation
9.3 Sensory Receptors and their Roles in Sensory Evaluation
l Taste Receptors
l Odour/Smell Receptors
9.0 OBJECTIVES
After reading unit we should be able to:
l Control the different factors for proper conduct of sensory evaluation; and
9.1 INTRODUCTION
We, as consumers, eat only that food which is palatable and enjoyable. Palatability
means the quality of food should be appealing and appetizing and we crave for
more. The primary consideration for selecting and eating a food commodity is
thus the palatability or eating quality, and other quality parameters, such as nutrition
and wholesomeness are secondary. For the consumers the eating quality attributes
– aroma, taste, aftertaste, tactual properties and appearance are the deciding
factors in food acceptance. Thus quality is that “which the consumer likes best”
and the grades of quality are understood more by the degree of desirable attributes
and absence of undesirable characteristics. All these attributes are detected by
5
Sensory Evaluation our sensory organs, hence this method of deciding quality of a food is called as
sensory evaluation.
In our country, the dairy industry so far considers the chemical and microbiological
quality as the sole criteria of deciding food quality. With the availability of more
milk, increased competition and consumers’ awareness about quality, the
significance of sensory evaluation is being realized and it is emerging as an important
analytical tool in fast growing dairy industry.
ii. Importance
iii) These important quality attributes are measured in a fast and quantifiable manner
employing sensory techniques. The use of chemical and instrumental methods
for examining sensory characteristics are time consuming, complicated and
expensive,
v) Sensory evaluation techniques help in ensuring that the consumers get a non
defective and enjoyable product.
i) Inspection of Raw Materials: The main raw material for dairy industry is
milk. Any defect in quality of milk related to colour, appearance, aroma and
taste can be quickly detected on the reception dock by the senses of smell, taste
and sight. This will help producing final product of good quality. The other raw
materials, such as, sugar, stabilizer, emulsifiers, flavouring and colouring substances
6 and other additives are also examined for colour and flavour.
ii) New Product Development or Improvement of Existing Product: Definition, Application of
Sensory Quality Parameters
According to a survey more than 90% of the new products developed result and Sensory Lab
into failure mainly because of poor sensory attributes and rejection by the Requirements
consumers. The adoption of appropriate sensory methods during new product
development is thus inevitable.
iii) Cost Reduction: In addition to eating quality of a dairy product, the cost is
also an important consideration for selection of the product by consumers. Hence,
dairy product manufacturers always try to reduce the cost by either using low
cost ingredients or adopting good management skills. The use of low cost or
alterative ingredients may adversely influence the sensory characteristics of the
product and may not find good acceptability. The sensory evaluation of product
during these modifications is, therefore, highly advantageous.
vi) Shelf Life Studies: Dairy products during storage undergo many types of
changes, for example, chemical, bacterial, enzymatic, physical, etc. All these
alter the sensory properties, such as taste, colour, flavour, texture and
appearance. Application of sensory evaluation not only monitors these changes
but also determine the nature and extent of the defects in dairy product during
storage so that corrective measures can be adopted. As per the existing rules,
the mention of ‘manufacture date’ and “expiry date or use before date” on
the label are mandatory. The expiry date has to be determined by using
chemical and sensory techniques together.
1) What are the important parameters for deciding eating quality of a food?
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
In human beings at least three different senses respond to specific chemical stimuli:
taste, smell and common chemical or pain sense. The sense organs consist of
sensory cells or group of cells, which respond to stimuli and transmit an impulse
via the nervous system to the brain. Human nervous system constitute of chemical
senses, somatic senses and auditory. The type of stimulus, corresponding receptors
and human experience exhibited by these senses is shown in Table 9.1.
8
Table 9.1 Definition, Application of
Sensory Quality Parameters
and Sensory Lab
Type of Senses Stimulus Type/ Receptor Human Experience
Requirements
Reaction
1. Chemical
Gustatory Chemicals (water Taste buds Tastes
soluble)
Olfactory Chemicals (gas Olfactory cells Odours
soluble/ volatile)
2. Somesthetic (Body)
Cutaneous Temperature change Cells in skin Warmth/ coldness
Mechanical pressure Cells in skin Pain
Intense energy/ heat Free nerve endings Pain
Kinesthetic Mechanical pressure Cells in tendons, Deep pressure
muscles
Vestibular Heat movement Cells in semi- Balance
(static) cellular canals
and vestibule
Organic Chemical or Cells in viscera Pressure, Hunger,
mechanical action Nausea
3. Distance
Visual Light waves Rods and cones Colour
of retina
Auditory Sound waves Hair cells of corti Sound/ pitch
i. Taste Receptors
The tongue serves as the major organ of taste. The raised portions on the tongue,
known as papillae, are considered to be sites of taste buds, the receptors of taste.
The tongue is insensitive to taste in the regions where there are no papillae.
Gustatory (taste) sensibility is mainly confined to the tip and edges of the tongue
and absent in middle of the tongue.
Four kinds of papillae are found on the human tongue as shown in Fig. 9.1 These
are Foliate, Circumvallate, Fungi form, and Filli form.
Fig. 9.1: Front View of Tongue Showing Differert Papillae and The Regions Where 9
BasicTastes are Perceived
Sensory Evaluation Filli form papillae, evenly distributed on the anterior 2/3 of the tongue are most
numerous but have no taste buds. Fungi form papillae, large and round and
mushroom-like in appearance are large in number at the tip and sides of the
tongue. Foliate papillae are found on the posterior one third of the tongue, usually
in folds on the sides. These are also not well developed in man and have little
function. The circumvallate papillae present in form of “V-shape” on the back of
the tongue are large and easily visible.
Human taste buds are located on moist surfaces within the oral cavity and pharynx.
A few non-papillae associated taste buds may also be found in such locations as
the Soft palate, Pharynx and Larynx. These taste buds are simply embedded
within the epithelium of the mucous membrane. The group of epithelium cells,
some of which are supporting cells and other taste cells are innervated (stimulated)
by sensory nerve endings. When a taste bud is exposed to the taste stimulus,
strong taste signals are transmitted by taste nerves into the central nervous system
and finally taste reflexes are integrated into the brain stem directly into superior
and inferior nuclei. Based on transmission of these impulses to the sub maxillary,
sublingual and parotid glands, excretion of saliva is controlled during ingestion of
food.
Taste perception: Taste buds differ somewhat in their response to stimuli. The
four basic taste solutions are perceived by different regions of the tongue (Fig.9.1).
l Sour taste may be noted chiefly along the sides of the tongue
The sense of smell is far more sensitive than the sense of taste. An average person
requires relatively concentrated solution to perceive taste sensation. In contrast an
odoriferous substance, e.g. mercaptan may be diluted to the extent of 0.43 x 10-15
mg/litre of air and yet be recognized as such by the sense of smell.
The nose equipped with olfactory nerves, is the special organ of smell. The
olfactory receptors are located mainly in the uppermost region (roof) of the nasal
cavity and are lined with so-called olfactory epithelium, which is yellowish in
colour with pink respiratory epitherial cells around it. The surface of the olfactory
epithelium is coated with a layer of mucous. Embedded in the mucous layer is a
mat of fine hair-like appendages of the olfactory cells called cilica. The cilia are
excited by molecules of odorous substances. The olfactory area, about 2.5 cm
size, is reached chiefly by eddy currents rather than the direct passage of air
during inhalation. The odorous substance must, therefore, be sniffed or whiffed
rather slowly but strongly. The molecules of odorous substances also reach the
olfactory area from the mouth during mastication of the food. Therefore, during
the tasting of dairy products the judge/ evaluator actually is sensing the odour and
taste of the product at the same time. The overall physiological concept of odour
perception is schematically shown in Fig. 9.2.
10
Definition, Application of
Sensory Quality Parameters
and Sensory Lab
Requirements
Olfactory receptor Brain
Olfactory receptor
Olfactory receptor
ii) The odour-laden air must reach the olfactory receptors. The substance must,
therefore, be strongly sniffed.
iv) The evaluator should have normal smelling capacity. People with obstructed
nasal passage, brain lesions or injured olfactory nerve are unable to smell,
either partially or of have a particular substance or group of substances. The
situation is called as “anosmia”.
11
Sensory Evaluation
Smell
Food Flavour
Taste
Trigeminal
Touch Pressure
Kinaesthesis Texture
Hearing
Fig. 9.3 Relationship of the Five Primary Senses with Sensory Attributes of a Food Product
d) Touch: Tactual and mouth feel play an important role in examining the body
and texture characteristics. The tongue and palate evaluate feeling of meatiness
and grittiness in butter and sandy defect in ice cream and sweetened condensed
milk. The pressure between the teeth and jaws determine the hardness, chewiness
and gumminess. The fingertips and ball of the thump help in determining other
textural attributes, notably stickiness, elasticity/ sponginess and brittleness.
e) Sound: The evaluator can detect the presence of ice crystals while drawing
a ice cream sample with spoon. The relative size and distribution of holes in
Swiss cheese can be felt by the gentle tapping of the outside of the cheese.
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
2) List the different receptors that detect the quality parameters in a food.
12
……………………………..…………………………………………...... Definition, Application of
Sensory Quality Parameters
……………………………..…………………………………………...... and Sensory Lab
Requirements
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
The first requirement, that is, proper laboratory facilities is discussed in this unit,
and the other two will be dealt in unit 2.
Many designs of the sensory evaluation laboratory are available. One such designs
has been shown in Fig. 9.4. Generally sensory laboratory should include a briefing
room, an office, testing booths and sample preparation room. Irrespective of the
design, the most important considerations for a sensory laboratory are location,
ventilation, lighting, traffic pattern, sample preparation and presentation, evaluators
communications and experimental comfort.
b) Testing Booths/Area: This is the area where panel members carry out actual
sensory evaluation of dairy products. Testing area shall be located separately
but in the immediate vicinity of the preparation area. This area is normally divided
in to small booths (number of booths between 5 to 10) so that each panel
member can independently evaluate the product. Following conditions have to
be maintained in testing area for obtaining best results:
- Noise level shall be kept to a minimum during the tests. The movement of
persons shall also be restricted in the area.
- The testing area shall keep free from odours. A slight positive pressure may
be created in the testing area to reduce inflow of odorous air from other
area.
ii) Age: Evaluators should preferably be in the age group of 18-50 years. Persons
of younger age are unable to properly interpret and communicate the sensory
results, whereas at older age the memory decreases. Sharp memory of evaluator
is considered highly useful in judging of dairy products, particularly for quality
control applications.
iii) Interest and Motivation: Sensory evaluation work is very time consuming
and sometimes fatigue also. The evaluator should, therefore, have interest and
be motivated.
v) Sampling: The sample should be representative of the lot. Care shall be taken
that no loss of flavour occurs and no foreign tastes or odours are imparted
during the sample presentation. The sample should be drawn from a bulk lot in
such a way that body and texture characteristics are not changed.
vi) Sample Numbers and Quantity: For economic efficiency of sensory testing,
larger the number of samples per session, the better it will be. However, the
size and quantity of sample for each judging session vary from product to
product. Normally 5-8 samples with average intensity of flavour for each
sitting are optimum. Number of samples may be increased in case of odorous
material of low intensity. The amount of each sample should be about 25-50
ml or gm, which is sufficient for one full sip or bite.
vii) Score Card: The evaluation card should be simple, brief, easy to follow and
all important sensory attributes included in it. It should be clearly printed and
the matter should be arranged in logical sequence. Terminology used shall be
clear and understandable.
1) Name the most important area of a sensory evaluation laboratory and write the
conditions to be required in this area.
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
2) What facilities in a testing booth can be provided to mask colour effect while
judging dairy products?
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
4) Write important Do’s and Don’ts for proper judging of dairy products.
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
……………………………..…………………………………………......
Sensory evaluation laboratory should be properly designed and equipped with all
the basic facilities needed for smooth conduct of sensory evaluation. Briefing
room shall be adjacent to the testing area and have an environment of comfortable
sitting to the evaluators. Sensory booths located in the testing area are important
parts of a sensory laboratory where evaluators do actual testing of products
independently. It should have sufficient ventilation, working space and lighting
facilities and should be free from odours and outside noise. All facilities related
to sample preparation, presentation and storage of dairy products should be
provided in preparation room.
Kinesthesis : The sense whose end organs lie in the muscles, tendons
and joints and are stimulated by bodily tensions.
Sensory Receptors : These are detectors, which inform us about the physical
and chemical change in our environment.
Bodyfelt, F.W., Bobias, J. and Trout, G.M. (1988). The Sensory Evaluation of
Dairy Products, AVI Publ. Co., New York.
Nelson, J.A. and Troat, G.M. (1964). Judging of Dairy Products, AVI Publ. Co.,
New York.
Stone, H. and Sidel, J. (1993). Sensory Evaluation Practices, Academic Press, Inc.
London.
You may mention the more important applications of sensory evaluation, e.g.
inspection of raw materials and finished product, new product development, quality
control, determination of self life, selection of packaging materials, cost reduction
etc.
1) Primary senses in human beings are smell, taste, sight, touch and hearing.
c) Cells in skin and free nerve endings – warmth, coldness, pain and textural
characteristics.
1) The most important area of a sensory evaluation lab is testing area. The necessary
conditions is testing are: a) humidity about 60%; b) temperature about 20oC; c)
lighting – sufficient (correlated colour temp. 6500 K), uniform and shadow free;
d) sensory booths – facilities of sink, writing space, colour masking device,
comfortable sitting facilities etc.; and e) sufficient space (0.9 m wide x 0.6 m
deep)
4) Do’s: For proper judging of dairy products, the laboratory conditions should
be favourable, size of sample should be sufficient, sample should be
representative and at proper temperature, numbers of samples at each session
should be 5-6.
20