IPR Notes Unit 1
IPR Notes Unit 1
UNIT 1 Notes
Copyright is a bundle of exclusive rights given by the law to the creators of original works. It is a form of intellectual property
protection granted by law. The rights provided under Copyright law include the rights of reproduction of the work,
communication of the work to the public, adaptation of the work and translation of the work.
Copyright laws serve to create property rights for certain kinds of intellectual property, generally called works of authorship.
Copyright laws protect the legal rights of the creator of an ‘original work’ by preventing others from reproducing the work in any
other way.
Indian copyright law is at parity with the international standards as contained in TRIPS. The (Indian) Copyright Act, 1957,
pursuant to the amendments in 1999, 2002, and 2012, fully reflects the Berne Convention for Protection of Literary and Artistic
Works, 1886, and the Universal Copyrights Convention, to which India is a party. India is also a party to the Geneva Convention
for the Protection of Rights of Producers of Phonograms and is an active member of the World Intellectual Property Organization
(WIPO) and the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).
Several international treaties encourage reasonably coherent protection of copyright from country to country. They set minimum
standards of protection which each signatory country then implements within the bounds of its own copyright law.
1. Berne Convention, 1886
Berne convention was the first and oldest multilateral convention on copyright that was for the protection of literary and artistic
work which was adopted in 1886.
Initially, 10 nations were part of this convention and today 152 nations out of 190 are part of it. This convention made a union for
the protection of the rights of the authors in their literary and artistic work.
The Berne Convention provides that, at a minimum, copyright protection in all signatory countries should extend to “literary and
artistic works”, including “every production in the literary, scientific and artistic domain, whatever may be the mode or form of its
expression.”
The Berne Convention contributed some major concerns to the copyright laws: -
The work originating in one signatory nation of the Berne Convention to be protected in the same manner in other nations
too.
The automatic protection was granted to the author’s work and was not subjected to any registration deposition fees or any
formal notice in connection with the publication. This means that the copyright exists as soon as the work is “FIXED” i.e.
recorded in any form.
If any dispute arises in the nation of origin, then the dispute can be filed in either of both nations.
It described the types of works protected, duration of protection, scope of exceptions and Limitations of copyright.
Principles such as “national treatment” (works originating in one signatory country are given the same protection in the
other signatory countries as each grant to works of its own nationals)
Principles such as “automatic protection” (copyright inheres automatically in a qualifying work upon its fixation in a
tangible medium and without any required prior formality).
1
2. WIPO Copyright Treaty [PDF]
The WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) is a special agreement under the Berne Convention that deals with the protection of works
and the rights of their authors in the digital environment. In addition to the rights recognized by the Berne Convention, they are
granted certain economic rights. The Treaty also deals with two subject matters to be protected by copyright:
The treaty was signed in 1996 and also recognizes that the transmission of works over the Internet and similar networks is an
exclusive right within the scope of copyright, originally held by the creator.
It categorizes as copyright infringement both: -
The circumvention of technological protection measures attached to works
The removal from a work of embedded rights management information.
The Agreement on Trade-Related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs) is comprehensive in giving cover to all areas of
technology, property, patents, trademarks, copyrights and so on.
The TRIPs encourageS upon the member country’s sovereign right to frame its own legislation on intellectual property matters.
This clause has been included on account of persistent demand from developed and industrialized countries.
The TRIPs Agreement covers seven categories of intellectual property rights:
Copyright
Trademarks
Geographical Indications
Industrial Designs
Patents
Integrated Circuits
Trade Secrets
It was signed in 1996 and administered by the World Trade Organization. This agreement includes a number of provisions related
to the enforcement of Intellectual Property rights. It says that national laws have to make the effective enforcement of
Intellectual Property rights possible, and describes in detail how enforcement should be addressed.
Copyright law protects expressions of ideas rather than the ideas themselves. It protects original works of ownership. It gives an
exclusive right to do or authorize others to do certain acts in relation to literary, dramatic, musical, and artistic works,
cinematography, and sound recordings. Computer programs are also included in literary works. Authors of Computer programs,
and broadcasting organizations are to be given the right to authorize or prohibit the commercial rental of their works to the public.
These similar exclusive rights also apply to the films.
The Copyright Act, 1957, along with the Copyright Rules, 2013, is the governing law for copyright protection in India. After
independence, the Indian Copyright Act was the first law which was enacted from the provisions of the Berne Convention.
Objectives:
The Indian Copyright Act, 1957 is enacted with the following two main objectives:
The main objective of the Copyright Act is to encourage authors, composers, artists, and designers to create original works by
rewarding them with the exclusive right for a limited period (usually for the life of the originator plus 50 years) to exploit the
work for monetary gain.
The economic exploitation is done by licensing such exclusive rights to entrepreneurs like publishers, film producers and record
manufacturers for monetary consideration. In reality, people who economically exploit the copyright are the greater beneficiaries
of the copyright law than the creators of works of copyright. The publishers and authors of books are such examples.
The objective of copyright law is also, in essence, to protect the author or the creator of the original work from the unauthorized
reproduction or exploitation of his/her materials. The right also extends to prevent others from exercising without authority any
2
other form of right attached to copyright, for example, in the case of literary work, the right of translation, adaptation or
abridgement.
In recent times, with the rapid advance of technology, copyright infringement in the form of ‘piracy’ has become a serious
problem of an international character. This is because technological progress has made the reproduction of copyrighted material
easy and cheap.
Accordingly, Indian copyright owners can protect their copyright in almost any country in the world. The appropriate actions
taken under the Copyright Act 1957 can stop the infringement of copyright. Infringement of copyright is also an offense
punishable with imprisonment and fine.
Modern Phase: - The copyright Act of 1911 was again amended in 1914 and it was also called modern copyright legislation. For
the very first time criminal sanction was introduced in act for infringement of copyright. The term of the copyright was fixed for
10 years from the date of its first publication. This act remained applicable until replaced by the Copyright Act, 1957.
1957 Phase: - The Act was enacted after the independence of the nation from British rule. It was the first enactment of intellectual
property laws. It came into force on 21 st January 1958. Major provisions of the Act were adopted by the Berne Convention of the
protection of Literary and Artistic Work, 1886.
This Act is amended 6 times till now to align with rapid changes in society and provisions of international treaties i.e. Berne
Convention, UCC, TRIPs Agreement.
1. Primary Works
Original Literary Work,
Original Dramatic work,
Original Musical work,
Original Artistic Work,
1. Secondary Works
Cinematography films, and
Sound recordings.
Cinematographic Films
Section 2(f) of the Copyright Act, 1957 defines cinematographic films which include any work of visual recording and a sound
recording accompanying such visual recording and the expression cinematograph shall be construed as including any work
produced by any process analogous to cinematographic including video films. It is classified into secondary works as suggested in
clause (b) of section 13 of the act.
Level of Originality:
A television report or documentary may be based upon a live incident or a newspaper report, thus the act does not prescribe any
specified level of originality in the cinematographic film.
Sound Recordings:
4
According to section 2(xx) of The Copyright Act, 1957, sound recording suggests that a recording of sounds from which that
sound may be produced regardless of the medium on which such recording is made or the method by which the sounds are
produced. Clause (c) of section 13 of the act states sound recordings as a by-product works.
Case: Gramophone Co. India v. Super Cassette Industries
Facts: ‘G.co’, Plaintiff, produced audio records titled ‘Hum Aapke Hain Kaun’ by Rajashree production ltd, who were the owners
of cinematographic work. They had already sold 55 lakhs of audio cassettes and 40,000 compact discs titled ‘Hum Aapke Hain
Kaun’. The defendants too launched an audio cassette by adopting the same title with its design, color scheme, get up and layout
deceptively similar. A permanent Injunction was sought.
Held: Injunction varied by stipulating not to use the same title, design colour scheme etc with bold letters the record is a version
of different artists.
Economic rights
This right is also known as the Exclusive Rights of the copyright holder provided under Section 14 of the Act. In this Act different
types of work come with different types of rights. Such as:
Right to reproduce;
Right to issue copies;
Right to perform at public;
Right to make cinematography and sound recording;
Right to make any translation;
Right to adaptation; and
Right to do any other activities related to the translation or adaptation.
Right to reproduce;
Right to communicate;
Right to issue copies;
Right to make any cinematography and sound recording;
Right to make an adaptation; and
Right to do any other activities related to the translation or adaptation.
Right to sell, rent, offer for sale of the copyrighted work; and
Right to communicate.
Right to communicate;
Right to issue copies; and
Right to sell, rent, offer for sale of the copyrighted work.
Moral rights
In addition to the protection of economic rights, the Copyright Act, 1957 conjointly protects ethical rights, that is due to the actual
fact that a literary or inventive work reflects the temperament of the creator, just as much as the economic rights reflect the
author’s need to keep the body and the soul of his work out from commercial exploitation and infringement. These rights are
5
supported by Article 6 of the Berne Convention of 1886, formally referred to as a world convention for the protection of literary
and inventive works, whose core provision relies on the principle of national treatment, i.e. treats the opposite good as one’s own.
Section 57 of The Copyright Act, of 1957 recognizes two types of moral rights which are:
Right to paternity– which incorporates the right to assert the authorship of the work, and the right to forestall others from
claiming authorship of his work; and
Right to integrity- which incorporates the right to restrain, or claim damages in respect of any distortion, modification,
mutilation, or any other act relating to the said work if such distortion, multiplication, or alternative act would be prejudiced to
claimant honour or name.
ASSIGNMENT OF COPYRIGHT
The owner of the copyright can generate wealth not only by exploiting it but also by sharing it with others for mutual benefit. This
can be done by way of assignment and licensing of copyright.
Only the owner of the copyright has the right to assign his existing or future copyrighted work either wholly or partly and as a
result of such assignment the assignee becomes entitled to all the rights related to copyright to the assigned work, and he shall be
treated as the owner of the copyright in respect of those rights.
Civil remedies
These remedies are given under Section 55 of the Copyright Act, 1957 which are:
6
Interlocutory injunction
This is the most important remedy against the copyright infringement, it means a judicial process by which one who is threatening
to invade or has invaded the legal or equitable rights of another is restrained from commencing or continuing such act, or is
commanded to restore matters to the position in which they stood previous to the relation. Thus for granting the interlocutory
injunction, the following three factors are considered as necessary:
Prima facie case, an assumption of the court that the plaintiff can succeed in the case and become eligible for relief.
Balance of convenience, in it the court will determine which parties suffer the greater harm, this determination can vary with the
facts of each case.
Irreparable injury, it is difficult to decide and determine on a case by case basis. Some examples of it include- loss of goodwill
or irrevocable damages to reputation, loss of market share.
Mareva injunction
This is a particular form of the interlocutory injunction which restrains the defendant from disposing of assets that may be
required to satisfy the plaintiff’s claim or for removing them from the jurisdiction of the Court.
Pecuniary remedies
There are three types of pecuniary remedies provided:
An account of profit, which lets the owner seek the sum of money made, equal to the profit made through unlawful conduct.
Compensatory damages, which let the copyright owner seek the damages he suffered.
Criminal remedies
For infringement of copyright, the criminal remedies provided under Section 63:
In the case of repeat offenders, the minimum punishment terms of 1 year and a fine of 1 lakh however, the highest punishment
will be the same as the first-time offender.
EXCEPTIONS
This act shall not constitute copyright infringement in cases of:
Fair Dealing
Fair dealing is the statutory limitation on the exclusive right of the copyright owner which permits the reproduction or use of
copyrighted work in a manner that otherwise would have constituted infringement. This law is given under Section 52 of the
Copyright Act, 1957 according to which the free uses can be made for any work except computer programs for the purposes:
For private and personal use including research,
For criticism and review,
For reporting of current events or issues including lectures in public,
For broadcasting in cinematographic films or by posting photographs,
For reproduction and reporting of any judicial proceeding,
For reproduction, or publication of any kind of work prepared by the secretariat of a legislature,
For reproduction of any kind of work in a certified copy made or supplied accordance with any law,
For reading and recitation of any literary or dramatic work in the public domain,
7
For publication of any non-copyright matter bona fide intended for the use of educational institutes, and
For recording any sound by the owner of the right in the work.
The Central Government may, by order published in the Official Gazette, direct that all or any provisions of this Act shall apply.
(a) To publish work first within the territory of India and then outside
(b) To unpublished works, the authors whereof were at the time of the making of the work, subjects or citizens of a foreign
country to which the order relates, in like manner as if the authors were citizens of India.
(c) In respect of domicile in any territory outside India to which the order relates in like manner as if such domicile were in India
(d) To any work of which the author was at the date of the first publication thereof, or, in the case where the author was dead at
the date, was at the time of his death, a subject or citizens of a foreign country to which the order relates in like manner as if the
author was a citizen of India at that date or time.
According to section 42 of the act, power to restrict rights in works of foreign authors first published in India – If it appears to the
Central Government that a foreign country does not give or has not undertaken to give adequate protection to the works of Indian
authors, the Central Government may, by order published in the Official Gazette, direct that such of the provisions of this Act as
confer copyright on works first published after the date specified in the order, the authors whereof are subjects or citizens of such
foreign country and are not domiciled in India, and thereupon those provisions shall not apply to such works.
8
The protection of technological measures and rights management information were introduced in WCT and WPPT as effective
measures to prevent copyright infringement in digital environments. The introduction of Sections 65A and 65B is expected to help
the film, music and publishing industry in fighting piracy.