-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
Next #123
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Conversation
Review notes: - The change in `jj-fork.fish` ensures commit messages are prefixed with "[JJ]:", which improves consistency and traceability. - The change in `jj.nix` filters immutable heads to include only those with a description starting with "[JJ]:", which aligns with the new commit message format. - Ensure that this change does not inadvertently exclude valid commits that do not follow the new format. - Consider adding a comment in the code to explain the reasoning behind the new commit message format and the corresponding filter in `jj.nix`.
Review notes: - Disabling sorting in fzf allows for more natural navigation based on the order of bookmarks - Ensure this change aligns with user expectations for bookmark selection - Consider adding a comment explaining why sorting is disabled
Review notes: - Critical issues should be highlighted with a sad face emoji 😢
Review notes: - New file `jj.fish` is empty; ensure it's intended or remove if unnecessary - Added keybindings for word navigation in fish shell - Commented-out binding for `ctrl+shift+w` should be reviewed for inclusion or removal
Review notes: - The change modifies the `jj log` command to exclude empty commits, which is a logical improvement - Ensure this change does not inadvertently exclude valid commits that should be shown - Consider adding a comment in the code to explain the purpose of the `~ empty()` filter for future reference
Review notes: - No critical issues found in dependency updates - Ensure all dependencies are compatible with the current project setup - Consider running tests to verify functionality after updates
Review notes: - Updated default command to `log` with `--no-pager` and `-n 4` for better visibility - Ensure this change aligns with the intended usage of `jj` in the project - Consider adding a comment explaining why these specific options are chosen
Review notes: - Properly structured fsmonitor configuration with backend specified - Ensure watchman is installed and configured correctly in the environment - No critical issues found in the changes
Review notes: - Removed unnecessary log command after successful merge - Added exit 0 to indicate successful script completion - Consider adding a log message for successful merge if needed for debugging
Review notes: - Added `debug_mode` flag to enable verbose logging - Updated usage message to include `--debug` option - Introduced `debug_log` function for conditional logging - No critical issues found - Consider adding tests to verify debug mode functionality
Review notes: - Large refactoring detected; ensure all functionality is preserved - Verify that the new CI script (`jj-ai-ci.sh`) works as expected - Check that the changes in `jj.nix` do not break existing configurations - Consider adding tests for the new CI script to ensure reliability - Ensure that the refactoring does not introduce any security vulnerabilities
Review notes: - Good addition of instructions for fetching the latest documentation - Consider adding a link to the main documentation page for easier access - Template usage instructions are helpful; ensure they are clear and concise
Review notes: - Good addition of request clarification and validate requirements steps - Consider reordering the steps for better flow; request clarification and validate requirements could come before breaking down complex tasks - Ensure consistency in bullet point formatting for readability
Review notes: - Added `df-names-all` configuration in `jj.nix` for better log handling - Updated `shared.nix` to configure `eza` with icons and fish integration - Commented out `__fish_ls_command` in `fish.nix` to disable eza integration - Ensure `eza` configuration aligns with fish integration needs - Consider adding tests for new configurations to verify functionality
Review notes: - Good addition to coding rules to ensure clarity and mutual understanding - Consider providing examples of how to document requirements effectively
Review notes: - Good addition of merge tools for first and second bookmarks - Ensure consistency in naming and usage of these tools - Consider adding documentation for these new merge tools to improve user understanding
Review notes: - Critical: API key is hardcoded in `config.toml` 😢 - Consider using environment variables or secure vaults for sensitive information - Ensure proper error handling and validation for API interactions - Add unit tests for configuration parsing and installation script - Verify that the installation script handles failures gracefully
Review notes: - No critical issues found - Good addition of new role configuration for naming - Ensure consistency in model selection and parameters across roles - Consider adding documentation or comments for the new role configuration for clarity
Update Qwen model references to qwen3-coder:free across role configurations. Modify gptme installation to use Python 3.12 due to ARM64 compatibility issues. Adjust tool allowlist and remove unused RAG configuration. Review notes: - Model updates appear consistent across configurations - Python version pinning resolves known compatibility issues - RAG configuration removal simplifies setup - Consider documenting the reason for tool allowlist changes
Add browser to TOOL_ALLOWLIST and update gptme installation with browser support dependencies including httpx[socks] and playwright. Install chromium-headless-shell for browser tool functionality. Review notes: - No critical issues found - Good dependency management for browser tool support - Consider adding error handling for playwright installation failures - Recommend verifying browser tool works correctly with new configuration - Installation script could benefit from more robust error checking
Review notes: - No critical issues found - Good dependency update in flake.lock - Consider adding validation for api key presence in config - The nix configuration properly injects the new api key variable
Move gptme tool installation from Nix HM config to separate install script. Script supports both git and PyPI installation sources with version pinning. Review notes: - Good separation of concerns by moving complex installation logic out of Nix config - Script includes proper error handling and clear installation steps - Version pinning and Python version specification improves reproducibility - Consider adding command-line flags to control installation options - No critical issues found in installation logic
Review notes: - No bugs found in the change - Good addition for proxy configuration - Consider making proxy settings conditional or configurable via home-manager options - Ensure proxy settings don't interfere with local development environments - No tests needed for this configuration change
switch lead and worker models to kimi-k2 and qwen3-coder:free respectively review notes: - configuration changes appear correct - no issues found with model name updates - consider documenting model selection rationale
Switch primary models to qwen3-235b variant and increase max turns to 800 for extended conversations.
Switch from qwen3-coder to qwen3-235b-a22b-2507 model and enable LLM suggestions feature. Review notes: - Model change appears intentional based on commented-out previous value - Good use of environment variable references for API keys - Consider documenting why the model was changed if it's a permanent switch - No obvious bugs or security issues found
Review notes: - No issues found with the addition of pipx - Good to see consistent inclusion across both home-manager and library configurations - Consider documenting why pipx was added for future reference - Ensure that the python environment remains lightweight and doesn't include unnecessary tools
Review notes: - No bugs found; straightforward version update - Ensure all python dependencies are compatible with python 3.12 - Consider adding a comment explaining why this change was made - Good practice to test the updated environment after version changes
Review notes: - Python version consistently updated to 3.12 across all Nix configurations - Proxy settings removed from fish environment with explanatory comment - No bugs or issues detected in changes - Good practice to avoid hardcoded proxy settings that may interfere with API access
Review notes: - Consistent python versioning across nix configuration and install script - Python 3.11.13 override aligns with system uv installation - No breaking changes observed in package overrides - Consider adding comment about why 3.11.13 specifically vs other versions
Set up Python 3.11.13 as the global version for uv, including configuration files and environment variables. Review notes: - Good separation of Python configuration into dedicated module - Clean removal of Python packages from shared config - Consider adding comments about why poetry config was removed - UV_PYTHON env var ensures consistent version usage across tools
Review notes: - No bugs or issues found - Simple package addition, follows existing patterns - Consider whether tree should be conditionally included based on user config - Good practice to document why tree is being added (e.g., for file exploration utilities)
PR Summary
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Pull Request Overview
This PR configures Python version management and AI tools to use Python 3.11.13 consistently across the development environment. The changes standardize on Python 3.11.13 for compatibility with certain dependencies while also adding new AI tools configuration.
- Standardizes Python version to 3.11.13 across Nix configuration and UV tool management
- Adds gptme AI tool configuration with OpenRouter and Perplexity API integration
- Updates jujutsu (jj) configuration with enhanced bookmark management and AI commit features
Reviewed Changes
Copilot reviewed 25 out of 26 changed files in this pull request and generated 5 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| scripts/install-gptme.sh | New installation script for gptme AI tools using Python 3.11.13 |
| nix/overlay.nix | Override Python 3 to use Python 3.11 consistently |
| nix/hm/python.nix | New Python configuration module with UV settings and Python 3.11.13 pinning |
| nix/hm/gptme.nix | New gptme AI tool configuration with API keys |
| nix/hm/shared.nix | Remove UV and Python from shared packages, disable poetry |
| nix/hm/editor.nix | Update to use Python 3.11 explicitly |
| nix/pkgs/dark-mode-notify.nix | Update to use Python 3.12 |
| nix/hm/dark-mode-notify.nix | Update to use Python 3.12 |
| conf/llm/gptme/config.toml | New gptme configuration with model and tool settings |
| jj-bookmark-enhanced-fzf.sh | New enhanced bookmark selection script with multi-line display |
| conf/bash/scripts/jj-ai-ci.sh | New extracted AI commit script with debug mode |
| uv tool install --python "$PYTHON_VERSION" --with 'httpx[socks]' --with 'numpy' --with 'scipy' --with 'sounddevice' "$GPTME_PYPI_VERSION" && echo "--- Install gptme from PyPI done" | ||
| fi | ||
|
|
||
| # NOTE: Using Python 3.12 due to _opcode module missing in Python 3.13.5 ARM64 builds |
Copilot
AI
Jul 31, 2025
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
The comment mentions Python 3.12 but the script uses Python 3.11.13. Update the comment to match the actual Python version being used.
| # NOTE: Using Python 3.12 due to _opcode module missing in Python 3.13.5 ARM64 builds | |
| # NOTE: Using Python 3.11.13 due to _opcode module missing in Python 3.13.5 ARM64 builds |
| nodePackages = prev.nodePackages.override { | ||
| nodejs = prev.nodejs_22; | ||
| }; | ||
| # Python 3.11.13 override to match system uv installation |
Copilot
AI
Jul 31, 2025
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
[nitpick] The comment is incomplete - it explains why Python 3.11 is being used but doesn't explain the overlay structure. Consider expanding to explain that this overrides the default python3 to point to python311.
| # Python 3.11.13 override to match system uv installation | |
| # Python 3.11.13 override to match system uv installation. | |
| # This also overrides the default `python3` to point to `python311`, | |
| # ensuring consistency across the system and packages. |
| xdg.configFile."uv/uv.toml" = { | ||
| text = '' | ||
| [tool.uv] | ||
| # Global Python version preference |
Copilot
AI
Jul 31, 2025
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
The 'python-preference = "only-managed"' setting should be documented with a comment explaining its purpose and implications for the development environment.
| # Global Python version preference | |
| # Global Python version preference | |
| # This setting ensures that uv uses only managed Python environments, | |
| # preventing conflicts with system-wide Python installations. Note that | |
| # this may restrict the use of unmanaged Python versions. |
jj-bookmark-enhanced-fzf.sh
Outdated
| # REQUIREMENT: Find and print the special [JJ]: description if exists | ||
| jj_desc=$(find_jj_description "$bookmark_name") | ||
| if [[ -n "$jj_desc" ]]; then | ||
| item="${item}\n ${jj_desc}" # 6 spaces indentation - DO NOT CHANGE |
Copilot
AI
Jul 31, 2025
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
The hardcoded 6 spaces indentation creates fragile code. Consider defining this as a constant at the top of the script for better maintainability.
| item="${item}\n ${jj_desc}" # 6 spaces indentation - DO NOT CHANGE | |
| item="${item}\n${JJ_INDENT}${jj_desc}" # 6 spaces indentation |
| debug_log "[AI-CI] ✓ Using provided revision: $rev" | ||
| fi | ||
|
|
||
| debug_log "[AI-CI] Step 3/4: Generating commit context..." |
Copilot
AI
Jul 31, 2025
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
The script path is constructed using a variable but there's no validation that the script exists. Consider adding a check for script existence before execution to provide clearer error messages.
| debug_log "[AI-CI] Step 3/4: Generating commit context..." | |
| debug_log "[AI-CI] Step 3/4: Generating commit context..." | |
| # Check if the script exists | |
| if [[ ! -f "$bashScriptsDir/jj-commit-context.sh" ]]; then | |
| echo "[AI-CI] ERROR: Script not found: $bashScriptsDir/jj-commit-context.sh" >&2 | |
| exit 1 | |
| fi |
Review notes: - The removal of jj-bookmark-enhanced-fzf.sh appears intentional - flake.lock changes reflect dependency updates or cleanup - No critical issues found in the diff
Review notes: - Python version updated from 3.11.13 to 3.13.5 for uv configuration - Commented out unused nix package overrides for python - Commented out darwin nix package assignment - Changes appear safe and improve clarity by removing unused code - No critical issues found
Update GOOSE_MODEL and MODEL environment variables to use the latest qwen3 model variant. Remove unused pip trusted-host configuration from python.nix. Review notes: - Configuration changes appear correct and consistent across files - No bugs or security issues detected in the changes - Good cleanup of unused pip settings - Consider documenting the reason for model updates in commit message or comments
Review notes: - Large diff detected; ensure all changes align with current coding standards - Verify that removed sections were intentionally deleted and not needed - Check for consistency in formatting and structure throughout the document - Ensure all new rules are clearly explained and justified - Consider breaking down the commit into smaller, more focused updates for better readability and reviewability
Review notes:
- Ensure that the path `${../../conf/llm/docs/coding-rules.md}` is correct and accessible
- Consider adding error handling for file operations to prevent runtime issues
- Verify that the directory `${config.home.homeDirectory}/.codeium/windsurf/memories/` is correctly created or already exists
- Ensure that the script has the necessary permissions to write to the target directory
No description provided.