Evaluation of Mineralogical Composition and Reliable Petrophysical Parameters by Neutron Induced

Gamma Ray Spectroscopy in Mineralogical Complex Reservoir of Lower Goru Formation, Middle Indus
Basin A Case Study*
Kamran Aziz1, Aamir Rasheed2, Arshad Hussain Palekar3, Rehan Hanif3, S. Sohaib Zulfiqar3, and M. Zeeshan Baig3

Search and Discovery Article #40887 (2012)

Posted February 29, 2012

*Adapted from oral presentation at PAPG/SPE Annual Technical Conference 2011, Islamabad, Pakistan, November 22-23, 2011

1
OMV (Pakistan) Exploration Gesellschaft m.b.H. /OMV Maurice Energy Limited {formerly Petronas Carigali (Pakistan) Limited} ([email protected])
2
OMV, Gmbh Pakistan
3
Schlumberger, Pakistan

Abstract

Lower Goru Formation reservoirs sands (Lower Cretaceous) characterization in the Middle Indus Basin is challenging due to complex
mineralogy of the rocks. The varying mineralogy characteristically makes the Petrophysical Evaluation difficult and cannot be
resolved by using basic conventional log suites. To resolve this ambiguity in Lower Goru Formation evaluation, proper additional data
sets are required.

Reservoir quality is defined by two main factors, porosity and permeability of a rock. The reservoir quality index or rock type is
known to be an important input for field static and dynamic models. Core data analysis in Lower Goru Sands across the Middle Indus
Basin reveals the presence of heavy minerals, calcareous cement, conductive mineral i.e. chlorite, chamosite etc. that effect the
conventional wireline logs response i.e. reservoir porosity (storage capacity) and permeability (flow capacity). Hence, the
quantification of the mineral contents becomes important in classifying the rock type.

However, estimation of complex mineralogy from conventional logs (density, neutron, and sonic) is also complicated by several
factors such as barite mud effects, oil base mud filtrate invasion, sensitivity of the tools measurements, as well as differences in the
tools vertical resolution and depth of investigation.

Developments in the neutron capture spectroscopy logs make it possible to estimate all matrix parameters which are significant for
accurate formation evaluation. The number of parameters is dramatically reduced. Using the measured spectroscopy data as input to
multi-mineral solver software, provides more accurate mineralogy output, consequently yielding better porosity and water saturation
calculation.

This paper describes the application of neutron capture spectroscopy data to formation evaluation and characterization of Middle
Indus Lower Goru Sands. The formation evaluation result in the studied well is found to be validated with core data.
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE
2011
Evaluation of Mineralogical Composition and Reliable Petrophysical Parameters by
Neutron Induced Gamma Ray Spectroscopy in Mineralogical Complex Reservoir of
Lower Goru Formation, Middle Indus Basin A Case Study

Coauthors: Aamir Rasheed (OMV)

Arshad H. Palekar (Schlumberger)
Kamran Aziz Rehan Hanif (Schlumberger)
Chief Geologist Sohaib Zulfiqar (Schlumberger)
OMV, Islamabad. Zeeshan Baig (Schlumberger)
ENERGY SECURITY THROUGH INDIGENOUS RESOURECES
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Outline

Overview of area
Problems faced in Lower Goru Sands a complex and heterogeneous
reservoir
Elemental Capture Spectroscopy A method to resolve mineralogical
complex reservoirs
Core to spectroscopy log integration
Accurate petrophysical evaluation using spectroscopy data in multi-
mineral model
Results
Conclusions
Acknowledgement

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 1
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Regional Structural Framework

Study Area

C.I: 3 ms
NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 2
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Stratigraphic Framework

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 3
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Field Description

A Studied Well A

Studied Well

GR
GR

Top A Sand

Acoustic Impedance draped on the TWT Structure Map of the prospective reservoir

A
Top Chiltan

C.I: 3 ms A

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 4
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Well Results
Well X-1 Studied Well
TOP A DEPTH STRUCTURE MAP

P-10

Studied Well

P-90
Well X-1

P-10 P-90

Petrophysical Evaluation
Perforated together using
Properties X-1 Studied Well
TCP guns
Gross Interval 81 m 83 m
Produced Gas @ 3.71
MMscfd Net Sand 26.1 m 28 m
X-1 tested 3.7 MMscfd Net Pay 8.8 m 9m
Avg. Porosity 9.00% 9.00%
Average Core Permeability < 1mD Avg. Sw 26% 24%
NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 5
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Problems faced in Lower Goru Sands - Middle Indus

Studied Well
Mismatch between calculated & core porosities

Actual grain density unknown

Fixed Density of matrix, ma, used in porosity
equation ;
= (ma b) / (ma f),
Limestone 2.71 g/cc
Sandstone 2.65 g/cc
Dolomite 2.83 g/cc

Core gives stationary measurement of grain
density & permeability not entire spectrum

Accurate porosity & permeability essential for
reservoir volumetric and reservoir flow potential

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 6
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Problems faced in Lower Goru Sands of Middle Indus

Need of Accurate Mineralogy for Studied Well

Reservoir Volumetric

High GR due to radioactive
minerals or Clay?

Neutron-Density are effected by
heavy minerals? Heavy Mineral effect. What percentage?

Difficult to predict accurate

mineral volumes from
conventional logs
N-D showing crossover. Sand clean?

Mud logs only provides basic Volume of Clay? Any other mineral?
information
High GR, Showing high Clay?

SCAL / Core Sedimentology
Results are time consuming

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 7
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Problems faced in Lower Goru Sands of Middle Indus

Using GR Not Using GR

Conventional Petrophysical
Evaluation - Basic Assumptions

Porosity (fixed grain density)

Vclay (GR, Neutron, Density)

Matrix/Mineral (Cross-plots)

Ambiguities in Conventional
Petrophysical Interpretation

Do not estimate accurate
mineralogy

Over/under estimate porosity

Over/Under estimate fluid
saturations

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 8
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Elemental Capture Spectroscopy - Methodology

A single advance tool to resolve all petrophysical issues in one go

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 9
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Elemental Capture Spectroscopy - Applications

Identify carbonate (CaCO3), gypsum (CaSO4.2H2O) and anhydrite

(CaSO4); quartz (SiO2), feldspar (Ca-Mg-K-Silicates) and mica; pyrite
(FeS2), siderite (FeCO3), coal, and salt (NaCl) fractions for complex
reservoir analysis
Estimate exact amount of clay using aluminum
Estimate most realistic total porosity using bulk density
Estimate mineralogy-based permeability
Determine well-to-well correlation from geochemical stratigraphy
Determine sigma matrix for cased hole and openhole sigma saturation
analysis
Obligatory requirement for Shale Gas evaluation
Estimate producibility and in situ reserves

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 10
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Continuous Grain Density for Measuring Accurate

Porosity

Core grain density varies from ~2.66 to 2.69

Very good match between porosity from core and

porosity using grain density from spectroscopy data

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 11
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Estimation of Continuous Permeability

Permeability from spectroscopy data is called K-Lambda

permeability as is derived using following equation:

Whereas:

k is the absolute permeability (mD)

Z is proportionality constant with a default value of 200000.0
(dimensionless)

t is the total porosity using spectroscopy grain density (v/v)

m is the cementation factor

g is the grain density from spectroscopy (g/m)

Wi is the weight fraction of mineral i (w/w)

Soi is the specific surface area of mineral i (m2/g)

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 12
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Estimation of Continuous Permeability

Mineral Group S0 (g/cm3)

Clay 6.0

Quartz-Feldspar-Mica 0.22

Carbon 2.0

Anhydrite 0.1

Pyrite 0.22

Siderite 0.22

Halite 0.22

Coal 0.22

If the initial estimate of k is less than 100 mD, the calculated

permeability is modified using the following expression:

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 13
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Core Results Vs Spectroscopy Log - Perfect Match

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 14
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Accurate Petrophysical Evaluation using

Spectroscopy Data in Multi-mineral Model

MODEL-3 USING SPECTROSCOPY DATA AND CONVENTIONAL LOGS

Reservoir Model Shale Model
Equations Volumes Equations Volumes
Rt (DWA) Quartz Bulk density Quartz
Rxo (DWA) Calcite Neutron porosity Calcite
Bulk density Illite DWAL Illite
Neutron porosity Kaolinite DWSI Kaolinite
DWAL Chlorite DWCA Chlorite
DWSI Siderite DWFE Siderite
DWCA Pyrite DWSU Pyrite
DWFE Water WWTH
DWSU Gas U
WWTH
U

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 15
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Accurate Petrophysical Evaluation using

Spectroscopy Data in Multi-mineral Model

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 16
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Comparison between Conventional Interpretation

and Interpretation using Spectroscopy Data

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 17
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Reliable Results with High Confidence Level

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 18
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Conclusions & Recommendations

Conclusions

Reliable amount of clay/types and other minerals

Estimation of accurate porosity due to variable grain density measurements
Estimation of reliable continuous permeability for understanding reservoir
potential and making well testing decision
Resolution of complex lithology/mineralogy throughout reservoir interval

Recommendations

Elemental Spectroscopy provides reliable information in making timely/right

decision for well testing
Elemental Spectroscopy can replace expensive coring program in exploration as
well as in development wells

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 19
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank:

Valued JV Partners

Schlumberger Pakistan

Schlumberger Internal Paper Reviewing Process Team (MyPaper2)

ATC-2011 Technical Committee & Reviewers

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 20
 ANNUAL TECHNICAL CONFERENCE 2011

NEUTRON INDUCED GAMMA RAY SPECTROSCOPY A MEASUREMENT TO RESOLVE COMPLEX RESERVOIRS AUTHORS: Aziz, Kamran, et al. Slide 21