Observational
cosmology:
Inflation
Filipe B. Abdalla
Kathleen Lonsdale Building G.22
http://zuserver2.star.ucl.ac.uk/~hiranya/PHAS3136/PHAS3136
Big Bang and Inflation
After these lectures, you should be able to:
• Describe the three key problems with the Big
Bang model
– The flatness problem
– The horizon problem
– The monopole problem
• Describe the key aspects of the theory of
inflation
• Explain how inflation solves the key problems
with the Big Bang
• Discuss primordial perturbations arising from
inflation
Successes and failures of the Big Bang model
Successes:
• Explains expansion of the Universe
• Predicts the CMB
• Explains abundance of light elements
Failures:
• The flatness problem
• The horizon problem
• The monopole problem
The Flatness Problem
• Consider = rtot / rc
tot
– The total physical density relative to critical at any given redshift
– rtot = rm + rR + rDE
• Re
Re--arrange the Friedmann equation:
Sign is irrelevant here so take modulus
• Today: tot (t0) = m + R + L
• Observations (CMB anisotropies) give
– | tot -1| < 0.1
• How does | tot - 1| vary with time?
• Remember how the
derivative of a changes as a
function of time
• So tot – 1 goes as t to the
power of 1 or 2/3 depending
on matter domination or
radiation domination. Either
way it should increase with
time
• This means that the solution
omega total =1 is unstable
http://www.astro.ucla.e
edu/~wright/cosmo_03.htm
The Horizon Problem
• “Horizon size”: distance light
could have travelled since the
Big Bang
• Consider CMB photons from
opposite sides of the Universe:
– Light has not yet travelled
between those points
– Yet CMB properties are the
same
• Why?
– Would like a theory in which
this arises naturally…
http://physics.gmu.edu/~rms/astro113/myimages/horizon1.jpg
The Monopole Problem
• Magnetic monopole = type of particle
• Believed to be an inevitable consequence of Grand
Unification Theories (GUTs)
– Expect enormous numbers of them
– Mass ~ 1016 mH = huge
• Not observed
• Numbers predicted would easily close the Universe (not
observed)
• Particle physics also predicts similar problems for other
massive particles e.g. gravitinos
Inflation
• º Phase of rapid acceleration
– Proposed as an add
add--on to the Big Bang model (Big Bang Inflation
model)
• Could be caused by something like a cosmological constant
– Often called the “inflaton
“inflaton
inflaton””
– Leads to exponential expansion
• Inflation must have ended
– e.g. to allow gravity to form galaxies
• Thought to happen very early
– t ~ 10-34 s
Þ Negligible changes to calculations we already did
Implications of Inflation
• Flatness problem:
– Rapid accel -> adot grows rapidly
– | tot -1| reduces dramatically
– Analogy:
• Blow up surface of balloon
• Looks flatter
• Horizon problem:
– Small thermalised patch of Universe is inflated beyond the current
horizon
– We see homogeneity
• Monopole problem:
– Number density of monopoles is dramatically reduced
http://physics.gmu.edu/~rms/astro113/myimages/flatness1.jpg
http://rst.gsfc.nasa.gov/Sect20/inflationX.jpg
I don’t want to see
this box ever again
because it is not
correct
Inflation needs
scalar fields:
• For a field phi that exists in space
where
h L iis th
the lagrangian
l
lagrangian.
i .
• Comparing to a fluid as before we have:
• Equivalent of Friedman eq
eq::
• If V(F
V(F) bigger than the kinetic term slow roll (see later):
Derive the Friedman equation
for fields.
• We start with the fluid
equation
• We
W replace
l th
the
density and pressure
for scalar fields in.
• The gives:
• Dividing by the
derivative of phi:
Slow roll and ending inflation:
• Slow roll parameters:
• Inflation
I fl i ends
d when
h the
h field
fi ld is
i near the
h bbottom and
d
slow roll is no longer satisfied.
• The Universe reheats
• The filed can oscillate being damped by 3H term
• Number of ee--foldings is:
– Need about 60 e
e--folds…
Show that this is equivalent to
lambda expansion, i.e. exponential
• Starting from:
• The friedman equation is
equivalent to:
• Assume slow roll.
roll This is equivalent
to the first term in the first
equation to be negligible and the
derivative of the filed in the second
equation.
• Replacing one of the H into the
first equation:
• Rearranging and removing the time
dependence:
http://www.astro.uccla.edu/~wright/CMB-MN-03/11Oct03/
Inflation produces density perturbations
• Pointed out 1 year after inflation was proposed.
• Tiny quantum fluctuations are blown up to large scales
• Tiny quantum fluctuations continue to be produced during
inflation
– All scales have a similar amplitude of fluctuations just
after inflation
• Gravity amplifies these fluctuations into galaxies and
clusters of galaxies…
• Seems to fit observations well, possibly the most
convincing success of inflation.
http://www.astro.uccla.edu/~wright/CMB-MN-03/11Oct03/
Inhomogeneities in the Universe
Relevant comments on inhomogeneities:
inhomogeneities:
• Quantum fluctuations during inflation
produce inhomogeneities
• CMB fluctuations ~ 1 in 100,000
• Galaxies today are clumped
Current thinking:
• Gravity amplifies fluctuations
• Before recombination
– Competing effects of gravity and
pressure
• Next lecture more in detail…
• Laws of physics predict what we see
– Mainly gravity and electromagnetism
Power Spectrum of density fluctuations
CMB experiments
SDSS
Galaxy Surveys
Physical understanding of the
theoretical prediction
Ingredients
• Assumption about post-
post-inflation
P(k) log P(k)
P(k) / kn
• Growth due to gravitational
collapse
• Plasma oscillations large log k small
• We will see this in the next scales scales
lectures…
• Inflation predicts P(k) / kn
– where n~1
• Gravitational collapse amplifies
fluctuations Wayne Hu
http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/beginners/introduction.html
Perturbations from Inflation:
• Quantum Fluctuations arise for this field with r.m.s. (not on
syllabus, if interrested see QFT: Peacock) this is not an obvious
result arising from the equations for a scalar filed
• Parts of the Universe with different f exit inflation at different times,
differing by
• Hence there is a fractional variation in energy densities on the
Hubble radius scale of
• While V » constant, H » constant, so horizon-scale perturbations
are roughly constant. This gives scale invariant fluctuations
• Fluctuations of a certain wave number k cross the Hubble radius
when k-1 = 1/(aH
1/(aH).
).
• Power spectrum of density fluctuations
(this is on the syllabus)
END for now!!!
