Harvard Lawsuit & Asian Identity
Harvard Lawsuit & Asian Identity
✦ e cineribus et ad astra ✦
april • Vol. 38, spriNg issue aCtoN-BoXBorough regioNal high sChool www.thespectrumabrhs.com
Headlines
Reflections on New Zealand
A message from the Mus-
lim Student Association.
Intro–Page 2
News–Page 3
The New Watergate
What the Cohen hearing
revealed.
History–Page 4
The Role of Identity in the Harvard Lawsuitmissions (SFA) organization. white America. It erases the strug- munity. Hasan Minhaj, acclaimed
History–Page 4 By aNJali ramaN ’20
News Editor Julie Yao (AB ’16), contributor gles of those who immigrated to Indian-American comedian, dedi-
to the Columbia Spectator, says that America and had to build their lives cated the entire first episode of his
The History of Stand-Up Les Goodson was one of the some Asian Americans joined SFA from scratch. The idea of a “model Netflix series to attacking Asian
fifty black people who started at- and Blum due to “selfish indigna- minority” in some way connotes entitlement in the Harvard case.
Why did Washington tending Columbia University in the tion and frustrations from feeling a population both successful and While his arguments questioning
cross the Deleware? To get fall of 1969, after tensions from the voiceless in an often black-and- completely integrated into the fabric the lawsuit are completely valid, it
to the other side! Vietnam War, the death of Martin white racial binary.” of American society, which seems is disheartening to see the rift cre-
Luther King, and the Civil Rights The connection Asians feel to largely an attempt to suppress the ated by the lawsuit. Instead, the
Movement prompted the university Blum’s mission stems from the voice of Asian-Americans and deny anger in this lawsuit would be bet-
History–Page 5 to recruit a more diverse student “model minority” stereotype, which their history. ter directed towards those who have
body. Goodson was asked to leave claims that systemic discrimination The “model minority” label also been able to manipulate the system
Columbia after earning poor grades no longer exists—instead, “good” creates a societal expectation for and truly steal seats in universities.
Trader Joe’s Snack Review his freshman year, uncharacteris- minorities such as Asians have Asian-American success. America The recent college admissions scan-
Great - er Joe or Traitor tic of a graduate of his elite high worked for their own success while expects Asians to excel, and as dal involving wealthy parents brib-
school. Goodson couldn’t thrive at others have not. such, Asians feel pressured to con- ing coaches and admissions officers
Joe? Columbia because he didn’t feel at As Yao explains, “By promot- form to this stereotype, often by at- to get their kids into top schools is a
home there—he felt “phony” for ing Asians as the ‘model minority’ tending prestigious universities like perfect example of how the college
even interviewing and he felt un- [to] seemingly uplift the status of Harvard. In truth, people like Blum admissions system itself, and not
Forum–Page 6 represented by the “Eurocentric” Asian Americans, white suprema- have exaggerated the influence of affirmative action, is taking away
coursework. This cultural landscape cists label black Americans, who are race in college admissions, playing seats from deserving student.
can still be seen today on college fighting…for liberation for all mar- upon the fears of Asian-Americans The Les Goodson story shows
Girl Heroes campuses. However, new holistic ginalized people, including Asians, who feel the need to conform to why we need diversity in colleges:
Meet Mrs. McDonald: approaches to college admissions as the opposites of a ‘model minor- expectations. The personality rat- we are the culture we create. Di-
have the potential to create a fair ad- ity.’” Asian Americans are doing ing feared by many “does not ex- versity brings different stories and
the “ruler of the Writing missions process and to normalize a the same by opposing affirmative ist,” Yao explains. Harvard uses cultures to campuses, and because
Center.” multiracial experience in American action. a “whole person review” of their college is a formative period, it is
colleges. Although it’s very easy to dis- candidates, taking account of high important that appreciation for di-
The recent lawsuit against Har- miss this lawsuit as an outlet for school information and parental versity is integrated into the experi-
Forum–Page 7 vard University claims that the ad- Asian-Americans to justify why elite employment to get a sense for can- ence. The rift in Asian Americans
missions committee discriminates institutions may not accept their didates beyond their grades and test surrounding this issue really shows
against Asian-Americans through a children, it’s also important to look scores. Additionally, Yao points out how the legacy of white superior-
Love Nest: Spring Edition personality rating system. Edward into how Asian-American identity that “Asian Americans comprise ity and wealth continues to dictate
Fly like a mother bird into Blum, the prosecutor, has been may have helped build support for only 6 percent of the U.S. popula- American discourse on race despite
fighting against affirmative action this lawsuit. The classification of tion, [but] 23 percent of Harvard’s attempts by minorities to have a
the Love Nest. for a decade because he believes that Asian-Americans as a successful student body are Asian Americans. voice. Affirmative action should not
white students are denied admission race can be reductive to individuals’ Clearly, Asians haven’t been hurt by be the issue that fractures the Asian
in favor of underrepresented mi- experiences—it comes back to the the current policy regarding race.” community. It should be the issue
Off-Topic–Page 8 norities. Only recently did he merge “model minority,” and dismisses Perhaps the most harmful part that allows us to realize the real in-
his agenda with Asian-Americans the experiences of individuals who of the affirmative action case is its justices of the admissions process
through the Students for Fair Ad- have fought to secure their place in divisiveness within the Asian com- and seek to rectify them together.
Intro
Page 2 The Spectrum April 2019
Letter From the EICs unexpectedly. Before we knew The Spectrum David Brusie
By Nithiyani Anandakugan it, we went from writing for the Genevieve Hammond
’19 and Jasmine Mangat ’19 paper to leading it. And in our Faculty Advisors
Co-Editors-In-Chief Founded 1982
new role as Co-Editors-in-Chief,
we found that The Spectrum had e cineribus et ad astra Contact Us
In this issue, we began hand-
ing off the torch to our next Co- taken on a whole new meaning 36 Charter Road
Editors-in-Chief. In fact, this for us. On Monday afternoons Nithyani Anandakugan Acton, MA 01720
paper is the last one that the became a place to be mostly un- Jasmine Mangat www.thespectrumabrhs.com
two of us will lead together. We productive. On Thursday after- Editors-in-Chief [email protected]
spent a lot of time over the past noons, it became a place to have
Facebook and Instagram @theabspectrum
few months selecting next year’s fun with our writers. During lay- Somya Prabhakar
Chief Staff. During this process, out weeks, it became a place to Chief Copy Editor
we’ve begun to transition our devour Ms. Hammond’s snacks.
new members into their roles. But above all that, it became a Copy Editors
As such, we’ve had quite a bit of place where we each met many Kaitlyn Chen Olivia Comolli, Michelle Gong, Katherine Gu,
Elizabeth Howard, Ellen Liu, Justin Shan, Eddie
time to reflect on The Spectrum new friends, and a place where Grace Du Wang
and the role it has played in our we figured out what leadership Chief Layout Editors
lives over the past two years. actually means. We cannot ex-
Staff
When we joined The Spectrum plain how grateful we are for the Madigan Anderson, Anna Charisse, Annabella
our sophomore year, we thought experiences The Spectrum has of- Teagan Smith
Chen, Kelsey Chen, Michael Cheng, Natalie
of it as an opportunity to write fered us. Mainspread Editor Dawn, Ananya Gade, Paolina Garro, Pratik Gazu-
outside the classroom and to Here’s to the past two years at la, Joyce Gong, Michelle Gong, Swetha Hariharan,
express ourselves in the way the The Spectrum and everything Anjali Raman Emily Hiltunen, Alisa Khomiakova, Ritika Koi-
we wanted to be heard. With- we’ve learned along the way! News Editor rala, Divyasri Krishnan, Iris Li, Rohan Muralidar,
in the following year, we rose Cheers, Srija Nagireddy, Emmie Ohnuki, Julia Olney, Ben
through the ranks quickly and Nithyani and Jasmine Orr, Anna Paradiso, Sonali Rai, Mila Rushkin,
Grace Gong Neha Saravanan, Francesca Servello, Supria Shroff,
Forum Editor David Tsitrin, Charu Tyagi, Aadhiti Vallatharasu,
Anushka Wani, Brandon Wu, Sophie Zhang
Prisha Dayal Columnists
Off Topic Editor Katherine Chen, Lizette Sta. Maria, Balwant-
Amrit Singh, Vera Tsang
Serena Han Layout Editors: Peter Bi, Sarah Jin, Eileen Kou,
Kirtana Krishnakumar Isaiah Lee, Amber Li, Jessica Zhang, Emily Zhao,
Publicity and Finance Milena Zhu
Relections on New Zealand mosque, from going as well. He re- ward manner. Some thought that,
By Miriam Bounar ’20
fused. He came back that afternoon because people did not identify as
Guest Correspondant-MSA Muslim they felt it was not as neces-
and informed us that our mosque’s
On March 15th, 2019, the Mus- principal had given multiple an- sary to speak about the attacks. This
lims in Christchurch, New Zealand nouncements regarding possible mere thought prompted great con-
attended the weekly Friday prayer escape plans in the case of an at- cern and a sense of isolation. How-
known as “Jummah.” None of them tack. Children, five-year-olds, were ever, a spark was ignited in all of
were aware of what was to come, being told how to run for their lives the members, each concluding that
and none of them deserved any of it. if someone came with the intention we must do something to inform the
A man decided to visit the mosque to do harm. The following week, I public about the truths of our reli-
that day, and he was greeted with re- attended my class and met up with a gion. The only way to combat this
spect and kindness. The first victim third grader with whom I had bond- act of violence is by teaching. So
of the shooting welcomed the indi- ed over the past years. She ran to me teach we will.
vidual by greeting him with peace and gave me a hug, but this time lon- “Ignorance leads to fear, fear
and acceptance: “Salam, Brother.” ger than usual; she was shaking and leads to hatred, and hatred leads to
The rest of the story has been broad- I asked her what was wrong. Crying, violence. This is the equation.” - Ibn
cast internationally for the past cou- she told me she thought “they had Rushd
ple of weeks. A week later, smaller hurt me too.” If anyone has any questions or
attacks occurred at various mosques Attacks like these do not just would just like to learn more, please
in England, and the Saturday after damage those involved; they also come by Wednesdays after school
the attacks in New Zealand. 150 hurt those who identify with the in room 204E or email us! We are
lives were lost in Mali. victims. At the MSA meeting, in the works of planning an event
The news headlines will soon members— both Muslim and non- at the moment and will release fur-
fade away, but the horrors will never Muslim— were overwhelmed with ther information soon! Mosques
leave our minds. Personally, I chose emotions, the strongest being de- around New England will also be
to skip attending Sunday School at termination. They noticed that few participating in the annual Open
my mosque that weekend in fear people in the community were talk- Mosque Day. At the Islamic Society
of a possible attack. I attempted to ing about the incident, and instead of Greater Lowell (ISGL), it will be
convince my father, a teacher at the just sending condolences in an awk- on April 28th, from 2-5 PM.
News
April 2019 The Spectrum Page 3
Inherited Privilege
spite our detailed record of history, scandal, especially when consider- However, there are still some
it seems that mistakes are often re- ing that Nixon hired five men to parallels between the aftermaths of
peated anyways. For example, just break into the headquarters of the Dean and Cohen’s testimony. Al-
immediately makes him or her as John Dean was Nixon’s partner- Democratic National Committee though both testimonies damaged
By akshitha maQtedar ’21 seem more reliable. By obtaining a in-crime, Michael Cohen describes in hopes of finding information to the President’s credibility, neither
Spectrum Staff higher education, one acquires both himself as Trump’s “fix-it guy.” But defeat the other Democratic candi- of them had immediate drastic im-
implicit and explicit advantages in according to Vox, he’s a lot more dates. Nixon’s articles of impeach- pacts in the realm of politics. Even
At a school like ABRHS, the life. than that. For nearly a decade, he ment accused him of “approving, after Dean’s confession, the pub-
heater starts working as soon as the Recently, society became out- worked as a high-level executive in condoning, acquiescing in, and lic did not turn against Nixon or
October chill settles in. Supplies raged upon discovering that many Trump’s businesses, coordinating a counselling witnesses with respect hold him accountable right away. It
ranging from whiteboard markers affluent families had used their variety of contentious operations. to...false or misleading testimony was only after incriminating tapes
to science textbooks are updated wealth to get their children into In statements to prosecutors, Co- in duly instituted judicial and con- were exposed did people believe
and repurchased whenever neces- elite colleges in the “Operation Var- hen alleged that Trump had direct- gressional proceedings,” which is that Nixon committed an uncon-
sary. Students looking to finish up sity Blues” scandal. Many of these ed him to these operations with the exactly what Cohen accuses Trump stitutional act. Similarly, Cohen’s
some homework have a quiet place students lacked the merit to get into understanding that it was illegal. of. Nixon urging Dean to cover trial has little effect on the views of
waiting for them in the library and the school on their own but were Last month, Cohen testified up the White House’s connection the public, mainly because people
the counseling center. They have admitted after their parents bribed that Trump knew in advance to the Watergate break-in directly weren’t surprised by the allegations
access to a stable WiFi network the school or paid people to forge that WikiLeaks planned to pub- parallels Trump ordering Cohen to and many did not believe Cohen.
here, too. They enjoy these luxuries extracurriculars. Though this is an lish hacked Democratic National lie about his involvement with the Because of society’s rapid pro-
as a result of their privilege. extreme example of privilege, it Committee emails. The testimony hacked emails. If the testimony is gression, we believe we won’t re-
Inherited privilege is defined as also symbolizes the wide difference spurred controversy, and people true, both Trump and Nixon broke peat our mistakes from the past.
any unearned benefit or advantage between affluent and working class have divided opinions on Cohen’s the law, specifically by committing Yet, the Nixon scandals have come
one receives due to his or her iden- families; wealthier families already credibility. But one thing is for sure: perjury, the act of swearing a false back as the Cohen trials, leading
tity. For example, individuals might provide their children with an ad- this incident is not new. oath. us to ask the following questions:
enjoy privilege because of their race, vantage simply by having the mon- Cohen and Dean are strikingly Despite the similarities, the Co- why does history repeat itself, and
religion, gender identity, sexual ori- ey to send them to an expensive similar, not only for their role in hen trials have not impacted peo- more importantly, when will we fi-
entation, class, or wealth. Privilege university. Students without such covering up white-collar crimes, ple’s opinions as much as Dean’s nally begin to learn from our past
then becomes a tool that propels financial benefits cannot afford to but also in their relationship with testimony did. With torrents of mistakes?
people forward, even though they study at these schools, regardless
themselves may not have fought for
or chosen it. Though it can be diffi-
cult to understand one’s own privi-
of their hard work. Scenarios like
these demonstrate the inequality
created by privilege. Although dis-
How Our Heritage Affects Us
lege, many people possess it. mantling society’s unequal distribu- By Neha ViJay ’21 cultural background earlier. Know- a particular interest in a group of
Privilege has always been pres- tion of privilege is no simple task, Spectrum Staff ing that many students at AB have people, less than a personal heri-
ent in our society. In fact, many working to recognize privilege is had similar experiences, I decided tage.” -Michael Cheng (’20)
prominent figures have accom- a step towards understanding and The meaning of the word “cul- to interview some to gain different “I cook a lot for my family be-
plished great things due to their equalizing disparity. ture” changes based on the context perspectives on how they hold on cause I’m usually home alone, and
privilege. Malcolm Gladwell, while Indeed, many people in our in which it is used. A cultural back- to their native language and heri- I try to follow my mother’s La-
interviewing Bill Gates, describes school community have clear inher- ground usually refers to the shared tage and how that affects them in tino dishes because I think food is
the advantages granted to many ited privilege. However, not all of practices of people with the same daily life. one of the easiest ways to connect
multi-billionaires as they were us have the same amount of privi- ethnicity or racial background. “I was taught at a religious back to one’s culture. Just being in
growing up. For example, in a time lege. During an advisory activity, However, in a diverse country like school to read Hebrew, but I never an aroma of spices makes me feel
when many did not have access to students answered different ques- America, a person’s ethnic heritage learned how to understand what I like I’m actively being part of my
computers, Gates did, allowing him tions on a survey about our lives. and customs could be influenced was saying. But, whenever I meet culture and heritage. I wish I knew
to jumpstart his success. Gladwell The questions were as simple as by other distinctly “American” someone from Israel, I ask them to more about my Indian culture. We
predicts that without access to a “Are you right-handed or left-hand- traits. The part of people’s culture teach me a little bit [of Hebrew] so used to be followers of Sikhism
computer, Bill Gates would not ed?” while others were questions that stays with them while they live I can learn some. While in Ameri- from my dad’s side but after his
have achieved his level of fortune. like “Have you ever had nothing to in another country may also differ ca, I still use the one or two words passing, we’ve mostly focused on
Furthermore, Gates’s mother was eat for dinner?” Surprisingly, even based on specific circumstances: I know to connect to my heritage.” my mother’s Catholicism since we
on IBM’s board of directors, which being right-handed over left-handed which generation of immigrants -Alexa Kushner (’21) were never introduced to that be-
gave him connections to many is a privilege; many school supplies they are, how much their parents “The philosophies taught in fore. Unfortunately, we haven’t re-
influential people. Although Bill are designed for right-handed stu- educated them about their heritage, Hinduism have been ingrained in ally focused on any Punjabi culture
Gates’ talent did, of course, play a dents, leaving our left-handed peers or whether they are a mix of two or me since I was a child; they affect in a really long time and it would
large part in his success, he also had with a disadvantage. We have all more ethnicities. my perspective on life. Eastern phi- be nice to be able to know more
access to resources—like comput- seen or experienced the challenges With its diverse student body, losophies sharply contrast those of about it.” -Balwant Singh (’19)
ers and other successful individu- left-handed people face with scis- AB is filled with distinct perspec- the Western kind. Thus, the way I Regardless of an individual’s
als—that others did not. Many of sors, left-opening desks, and the tives on how their heritage affects feel about certain issues is differ- race or ethnicity, his or her heritage
the elite reap benefits of privileges smudging of pens! Although this is students in their daily lives. As a ent from the way some of my other will always have an effect on his or
like these. a very small example of privilege, it second generation Indian-Amer- friends feel. Ultimately, I think her life. In a community like AB,
Moreover, privilege is present in shows how privilege can affect our ican myself, my culture is a com- both the American and Indian cul- some may have similar ethnic back-
education. As AB students, we are everyday lives. bination of what my immigrant tural upbringings I’ve experienced grounds that help them connect
Acknowledging that our com- parents have taught me and what have helped me become the way I with each other while others have
privileged to receive such a strong
I have experienced as an Ameri- am today.” -Apurva Joshi (’21) different perspectives and stories of
education. However, many children munity contains diverse individu-
can citizen outside my family. For “I wish that I understood my their heritage. How we perceive our
do not receive the same opportuni- als with varying advantages is vital.
example, while I was a toddler, I culture a bit more than I do, but not culture and how we incorporate it
ties, leaving them at a disadvantage. After coming to this realization, we
had a slight Indian accent. It was that I would necessarily practice into our lives is eventually what
According to Global Partnership for can work to manage this privilege.
something my friends would point those traditions on a daily basis; helps us define who we are as hu-
Education, sixty-one million chil- Unfortunately, unequal access to
out whenever I would say words I would approximate it to taking mans in this world.
dren—many of whom are girls—do opportunity propels some forward such as “tree” or “comfortable.”
not have access to schooling. Indi- while impeding the progress of oth- As I grew older and spent more
viduals who lack the opportunity ers. Recognizing privilege allows time speaking English with my
to obtain a higher education, pos- individuals of every background friends and teachers, I lost that ac-
sibly due to familial and financial to access the same opportunities. cent, along with my ability to speak
restrictions, face a disadvantage in However, we all have many iden- my native language fluently. For a
society. The Bureau of Labor Sta- tities, based on race, sexuality, young child, the idea of growing
tistics quantifies that in 2017, those gender, nationality, and education up and being perceived as differ-
with the highest level of educa- level, among other factors. Each ent can be terrifying. It is a feeling
tion earned three times as much as identity secures a different set of that anyone of any background
those with less than a high school privileges and disadvantages. By can go through, and it is one I tried
diploma. Further, society values the observing and understanding these to avoid as a child. Today, I regret
opinions of individuals with higher differences, community can strive not trying to speak my native lan-
education more, regardless of the to provide equal opportunity for guage more when I was younger
subject. For example, simply add- all and help everyone achieve their because I realize how much I lost
ing the prefix “Dr.” to one’s name goals. by not trying to connect with my
History
April 2019 The Spectrum Page 5
The Importance of History in China nese achievements and overlook Morning Post claims Beijing offi- Weiwei, who investigated govern-
By Sophie Zhang ’22
mistakes. According to the New cials argued that separatist ideals in ment corruption during the 2008
Spectrum Staff York Times, one textbook altogether Hong Kong stemmed from a lack Sichuan earthquake, I wondered
In eighth grade, my social stud- ignores the United States’ involve- of appreciation for Chinese history, if there were more protesters like
ies teacher showed us a documen- ment in World War II. The text- demonstrating the government’s him. My own mother, who grew up
tary about Chinese culture. The book states that, in Japan’s defeat, belief that political dissent would in China, often mocks the govern-
students in the movie lined up in “the fundamental reason for the run rampant if censorship ceased. ment and its propaganda. While
rows every morning to sing the na- Chinese victory is that the Chinese Indeed, the University of Hong watching the Chinese New Year
tional anthem with smiles across Communist Party became the core Kong states that around 47.7% of special, she commented on how of-
their faces. I watched the video power that united the nation.’’ In people in Hong Kong distrust the ten the hosts mentioned President
with skepticism, doubting their pa- reality, both the Communists and government. But in 2018, Hong Xi Jinping. My mother grew up
triotic fervor. Nationalists united against the Jap- Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam with Communist parents, but she tend to reform only when people
When I met a friend who im- anese before splitting over a bitter announced “that all Hong Kong has seemingly embraced Ameri- begin questioning their morals and
migrated from China, I asked her civil war. Further, textbooks inten- secondary schools would teach can ideals of free speech. However, reviewing their rights. Without
about it. She said that it was true. tionally leave out controversial top- Chinese history as an independent do the people in China notice this noticeable threats to Chinese eco-
Incredulous, I browsed through ics such as the Tiananmen Square compulsory subject at the junior propaganda? Do they even care? nomics and success, the ignition for
Youtube for more clips. In one vid- massacre and the Hong Kong pro- levels… to equip pupils with a Focusing on censorship, The Inde- change quickly flickers out.
eo, children walk around in a field, tests, both of which demonstrate sense of national identity.” pendent states that Chinese youth A few weeks ago, my mother
filing into neat rows. When the mu- rebellion against the government. In this period of globalization, have no interest in illegal Western showed me a video from her home-
sic blasts, they sing with joy, never Accompanied by Chinese censor- one might think China would begin sites such as Facebook or Google town. It depicts adults happily
missing a note. In another clip, stu- ship, the twisting of textbook nar- opening its curriculum to Western because China has many replace- clapping along to a song about Xi
dents wander into school and sud- ratives has blurred the youth’s view influences. The Ministry of Edu- ments for them, like Baidu and Jinping and his wife Peng Liyuan.
denly freeze. They hear the anthem of their own country. The govern- cation’s 2017 work report, how- WeChat. Even if some dislike the They repeat two simple phrases
start to play, so they stop to belt out ment regularly checks their text- ever, reveals no major overturns in government’s influence, according over and over again, singing “Xi
their sacred song. books to make sure it aligns with textbook propaganda. Instead, the to the Washington Post, the Chinese dada, Peng mama.” Without
Over the years, China has cre- their socialist ideology. list focuses on increasing school government remains extremely knowing the language, one can
ated a strong sense of patriotism by According to Reuters, after attendance and socialist ideals. To popular today. Few citizens are detect the adoration towards the
subtly brainwashing its people. To discovering that publishers were cultivate “first-class talent,” the re- overly political, and most use the singers’ leader and “parent.” Chi-
maintain this influence, the govern- altering textbooks without their port pushes for “correct political internet to shop, play games, and nese propaganda has turned aging
ment closely monitors Chinese his- consent, China’s Ministry of orientation” and “socialism with check emails, not to rebel. Wide- adults into trusting, naive children.
tory textbooks, ensuring patriotism Education “launched a ‘com- Chinese Characteristics,” which spread support for the Chinese gov- As a whole, censorship creates a
and removing any criticism. prehensive’ inspection of school includes supporting Communist ernment stems from its nationalism childlike dependency on the gov-
The Chinese history curriculum textbooks to remove unapproved Party supremacy, sustaining Chi- and historical censorship. China ernment. Comparing the power
tends to focus on the positive notes alterations or foreign content… na’s global rise, and revering the lives in a perfect bubble separated of a father and son, the father will
of the past, highlighting honor and to combat Western influence in president. from Western influence and citi- always dominate, and the son will
pride. Teachers often glorify Chi- China’s schools.” The South China Seeing political activists like Ai zen dissent. However, governments continue to clap along.
Location & History History of Stand-Up Comedy with relevant material for his audi- Stand-up comedy was eventu-
By Srija Nagireddy ’19 There is no doubt that students By Iris Li ’21
in different places are not taught ences based on daily news or gos- ally picked up by the television
Spectrum Staff Spectrum Staff
the same material despite being sip. Hope also utilized several writ- industry in the mid- to late-1900s,
When asked about causes for enrolled in the same course. Even Although stand-up comedy, a ers to come up with his act. with shows like the Ed Sullivan
the American Civil War, students textbooks—works viewed as ac- form of entertainment that often Modern stand-up comedy really Show (1948-71), the Cosby Show
living in New England would curate authorities on the subject— satirizes politics, stereotypes, news, took off with a man named Char- (1984-92), and Seinfeld (1989-98).
likely answer slavery. To many, have their problems. The textbook or even the oddities of everyday ley Case who performed his mono- Late-night television with Da-
that may even seem like a foregone used by an AB student in U.S. His- life, has been around for a few de- logues without any props or cos- vid Letterman and Jay Leno also
conclusion. However, this is not tory I is not necessarily the same cades, it has only recently gained tumes. Mort Stahl, a comedian with gained popularity, and it became
the case everywhere. This year, de- one used by a student taking the mainstream popularity with a rise a similar style to Case, appeared in many Americans’ chosen form of
viating from their original stance, equivalent course in Texas. Text- 1950; he would sit on stage with a newscasting as daily events were
in Netflix’s production of comedy
the Texas State Education Board book manufacturers modify dif- rolled up newspaper in one hand made more palatable by comedic
specials.
published a different approach to ferent versions of the same text and talk to the audience as if he levity. Soon, late-night TV became
teaching the cause of the Civil War for different locations by using Beginning in the early 1900s,
stand-up comedy took place in were having a conversation with another way for Americans to com-
in their Social Studies Texas Essen- the states’ individual guidelines
tial Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) that are tailored to what educators vaudeville or variety shows. A them rather than acting out scenes. ment on prominent social issues or
history curriculum. In the updated and parents want to see. Altering comedy set was often included in He often talked about politics, so- events.
TEKS, teachers are instructed to textbooks to fit certain regulations, a combination of specialty acts like ciety, and pop culture. From these In the 21st century, people now
explain the “central role of the ex- however, leads to texts reflecting acrobats, magicians, singers, and comedians’ work grew a prominent have the luxury of being able to
pansion of slavery in causing the the partisan and potentially inac- dancers. These routines were often feature of stand-up: most modern watch stand-up comedy on TV and
Civil War and other contributing curate views supported by states’ fast-paced, scripted, and character- comedians use this form to point online platforms such as Netflix in
factors including sectionalism and standards. In addition, book man- ized by one-liners or punchlines. out the faults in our society or gov- the comfort of their homes. Ulti-
states’ rights.” The change was due ufacturers often gloss over issues Rather than engage with the audi- ernment. For instance, during the mately, stand-up comedy has come
to increasing debate over the extent that could cause conflict for school ence, actors would usually interact Civil Rights Movement, African a long way from its roots in vaude-
of slavery’s role in the war. This administrators, something particu- American Dick Gregory used com- ville and has captured the hearts of
with each other.
debate has extended to the way his- larly prevalent in southern states edy as a way to bring attention to Americans all over the country in
over events such as the Civil War. In the 1930s and 1940s, comedi-
tory is taught in American class- racial issues. laughter and understanding.
rooms, and, more specifically, the As a result, students receive dif- ans from the Catskill Mountains in
biases inherent in the education of ferent accounts of history based on New York emerged with a variation
students from certain regions of where they live. For example, the on a classic comedy routine that
the country. U.S. History curriculum here at had pre-planned, interchangeable,
The US lacks a set of Federal AB emphasizes slavery as the main and easily repeatable comedic skits.
guidelines for its history curricu- cause behind the Civil War, staying These comics gained popularity
lum. Instead, each state creates its consistent with the curriculum set due to the different style of comedy
own cirriculum. A state’s standards forth by the Massachusetts Depart- that focused on actions rather than
are determined by its board of edu- ment of Education. In contrast, words. Some common routines at
cation, a group of elected officials. Texas’ curriculum used to list slav- the time included throwing a pie in
The boards can often be intensely ery as one of many contributing the face of a fellow actor or satiri-
partisan, leading them to phrase factors to the war, placing more
cal skits about gold-digging wives.
historical events a certain way to of an emphasis on state rights is-
sues. While these distinctions may Comedians tried to find topics
minimize or overstate the role of
these events to fit their political seem minor, they carry the heavy that could be understood by both
ideologies. This seemed to be the history of slavery with them and Americans and immigrants living
case in Texas, where many people the conflicts over its recognition in urban areas given that stand-up
felt concerned that board mem- today. Just last year, Americans in was mainly centered in New York
bers’ conservative bent influenced the North and South were divided City. They continued to use mul-
what they did and did not include. over whether Confederate stat- tiple punchlines in their routines to
For example, research by the Edu- ues should be displayed in public. keep the audience laughing. For ex-
cation Fund of the Texas Freedom Once again, the debate surround- ample, one popular one-liner from
Network, an organization created ing the causes of the Civil War had well-known comedian Groucho
to defend the freedom of religion reignited. Marx was, “Behind every success-
in education, reported that a sig- The past, while undeniably im- ful man is a woman. Behind her is
nificant number of proposed text- mutable, can be interpreted and
his wife.”
books in 2014 exhibited partiality analyzed in a multitude of ways,
towards Christianity, in some cases all of which depend on the per- Soon, however, comedians start-
overstating the influence religious sonal biases of those examining its ed to shift from timeless skits about
figures such as Moses had on piv- events. Conscientious issues can be the human experience to current
otal documents such as the Con- looked at in a variety of different events. Bob Hope, a radio host in
stitution. Therefore, concern is ways. The importance of recogniz- 1938, started the shift from script-
increasing over the wildly varying ing this concept and its effect on ed routines to on-the-spot comedy
standard of education for students students as well as partisanship is by improvising jokes based on the
across the nation. more pertinent than ever. news. On his show, he came up
Forum
Page 6 The Spectrum April 2019