Tutorial #8, due in class on Nov.
4, 2011
1. A thin plate of steel contains a central through-thickness aw of length 16 mm, which is subjected to
a stress of 350 MPa applied perpendicularly to the aw plane. The 0.2% ow stress of the material
is 1400 MPa.
Calculate the plastic zone size and the eective stress intensity level at the crack tip, making rea-
sonable assumptions about the state of stress.
• Solution: Since the plate is thin, we will assume a state of plane stress and we will verify this
assumption afterwards. The plastic zone size under plane stress is given
2
1 KI
ry =
2π σy
√
• The√case at hand is that of a√ panel with a central crack of length 2a; KI = σ πa =
350 3.14 × 0.008m = 55.5MPa m. With this value, we get ry = 0.25mm. Since we can reason-
ably expect a sheet to be a few mm thick, we see that the plane stress assumption is not correct
in this case. Instead, if we assume plane strain conditions to prevail, we get ry = 0.08mm,which
will be less than one-tenth of the sheet thickness, thus justifying our assumption of plane strain.
• Note also that here the crack length is 200 times the plastic zone size, which means that LEFM
can be safely applied.
• Due to the presence of the plastically deformed region ahead of the crack tip, the sheet is more
compliant, just as it would be if the crack were longer. Irwin argued that the eective crack
length is 2(a + ry ) (the tip is centered in the plastic zone of size rp = 2ry ). Thus, the eective
crack length here is 16.16 mm.
If, after heat treatment, the ow stress of the steel dropped to 385 MPa, what would the plastic
zone size be under the applied stress of 350 MPa, and what conclusions would you draw about the
use of LEFM?
• Solution: Now, for plane stress, ry = 3.3mmand for plane strain, ry = 1.1mm. The former is
now a valid assumption since the plastic zone size is now likely greater than the thickness of
the sheet. But, now the plastic zone size is comparable to the crack size, and the use of LEFM
is not justi ed.
2. Suppose that an ASTM compact tension specimen is used to measure the fracture toughness of a
steel. The specimen has dimensions W = 40mm and B = 20mm. The crack length was 18.5 mm,
and the fracture load was 15kN. For a compact tension specimen, the stress intensity factor is given
by
r
P π a (1/2) a (3/2) a (5/2) a (7/2) a (9/2)
K= 16.7 − 104.7 + 369.9 − 573.8 + 360.5
B W W W W W W
(a) Calculate Kc of the steel.
√
• Solution: From the numbers given, Kc = 32.2MPa m.
(b) If the steel has yield stress 800MPa, was this a valid fracture toughness measurement?
• Solution: The fracture test is valid if both
2 2
KIC 32.2
B and a > 2.5 = 2.5 × = 0.004m = 4mm
σY 800
• Since this is satis ed, this is a valid fracture toughness test.
3. A sharp penny-shaped crack with a diameter of 2.5 cm is completely embedded in a solid. Catas-
trophic fracture occurs when a stress of 700 MPa is applied.
1
(a) What is the fracture toughness of the material? (Assume that this value is for plane-strain
conditions)
2 √ √
• Solution: KIC = π σ πa = 88.3MPa m
(b) If a sheet (0.75 cm thick) of this material is prepared for fracture-toughness testing (t = 0.75
cm, a = 3.75 cm), would the Kc value be a valid fracture toughness number (the yield strength
of the material is given to be 1100 MPa)
• Solution:
2 2
KIC 88.3
2.5 = 2.5 = 1.6cm
σY 1100
• Since this value is greater than the thickness of the sheet, this will not be a valid fracture
toughness test.
(c) What would be a su cient thickness for valid KIC determination?
• 1.6cm
