Forming Processes
Forming Processes
Forming
INTRODUCTION
Formed or shaped plastics provide a great variety of marketable products,
in a wide size range from drinking cups to large products (Figs 10.1 and
10.2). Different techniques are used, but thermoforming is the most pro-
ductive and the most diversified. Other techniques are similar to
thermoforming but normally use less heat and are more limited in their
choice of plastic; these processes include cold forming, stamping or com-
pression forming, flow molding, rubber pad molding, diaphragm form-
ing, coining, and forging. Formed parts are used in many different
applications and production lines (form, fill and seal, etc.). Food, elec-
tronic devices, medical products, and other parts use continuous
thermoforming operations at the end of high-speed production lines to
reduce the handling of products, provide hermetically sealed contents,
reduce costs, and so forth.
Thermoforming has many advantages over other methods of thermo-
plastic fabrication:
1. Parts with a large surface area can be formed with relatively low mold
and equipment cost, because of the low pressures required.
2. Very thin-walled parts can be readily formed, which is not feasible by
any other method.
3. High-volume thin-walled products, such as drinking cups, can be pro-
duced at the lowest cost per capital investment, at production rates of
50 000 to over 200 000 units per hour.
4. Low-volume heavy-gauge products, such as computer housings, are
competing favorably with injection molding in price, through lower
tooling costs, and in product detail with 69OkPa (lOOpsi) forming
pressures.
Figure 10.1 Precise-timed cooling for ABS thermoformed hull for a 15ft (4l/2 m)
runabout.
Figure 10.2 Two thermoformed parts, made from coextruded sheets, are bonded
together to create a fuel tank. The tank's inside has a nylon surface to resist
gasoline; the outside uses PP to provide the required support strength while
keeping the cost low.
THERMOFORMING
Thermoforming usually begins with plastic sheet or film: sheet thickness
tends to be 10 mil (250 |im) and greater; film thicknesses are normally less
than 10 mil (250 |um). Extrusion is the most common method of producing
sheet and film for thermoforming (Chapter 3); very small amounts are cast
or calendered (Chapter 5).
Thermoforming usually consists of heating extruded thermoplastic (TP)
sheet, film, and profile to its softening heat and forcing the hot and flexible
material against the contours of a mold by pneumatic means (differentials
in air pressure are created by pulling a vacuum between the plastic and
the mold, or the pressure of compressed air is used to force the material
against the mold), mechanical means (plug, matched mold, etc.), or com-
binations of pneumatic and mechanical means.
The process involves (1) heating the sheet (film, etc.) in a separate oven
then transferring the hot sheet to a forming press, (2) using automatic
machinery to combine heating and forming in a single unit, or (3) a
continuous operation feeding off a roll of plastic or directly from the exit
of an extruder die (postforming). Almost all the materials are TPs. To date
very few thermosets (TSs) have been used, as markets have not devel-
oped. These TSs can be reinforced or unreinforced (Chapter 12). Almost
any TP can be used, but certain types make it easier to achieve deep draws
without tearing or excessive thinning in areas such as corners. Ease of
forming depends on material characteristics; it is influenced by minimum
and maximum thickness, pinholes, the ability of the material to retain heat
gradients across the surface and the thickness, the controllability of ap-
plied stress, the rate and depth of draw, the mold geometry, the stabiliz-
ing of uniaxial or biaxial deformation, and most important, minimizing
the thickness variation of the sheet.
Bending, one of the oldest thermoforming techniques, is relatively easy
to handle. It is often accompanied by joining (adhesive or welding) or
mechanical operations (milling, drilling, polishing). If the sheet is heated
only locally in the bending operation, no special forming tools are needed.
The width of the heating zone and the thickness of the sheet determine the
bending radius. Limitations are related to the softening point of the sheet
and the intrinsic rigidity of the heated sheet (sag should be minimized).
Transparent plastics (such as PMMA and PC) with thicknesses up to
3Y2 in. (90mm) are frequently bent for use in store displays, staircases,
partitions in banks, aircraft windows, and so on. With this type of plastic,
if restrictions in the bending area are minimized, the thickness at the bend
can remain unchanged.
PROCESSING
All thermoforming systems include a means of receiving sheets cut to size,
from rolls, or directly from an extrusion line. Sheet thicknesses over
1.5mm are generally cut to size, and thinner sheets are supplied on rolls.
There are no gauge limitations on extrusion lines. The thermoformer
contains the mold, may or may not include the trimming means, and
provides the pin chain or gripping system that indexes the sheet through
the heating, forming, and sometimes the trimming operations. Trimming
is not necessarily an integral part of the forming cycle, but few applica-
tions can use the formed web without some kind of trimming. Specific
variations of basic thermoforming include processing sheets cut to size, or
from rolls, or directly from an extrusion line.
The most elementary thermoforming techniques include basic vacuum
forming, drape forming, pressure forming, and matched-mold forming.
These terms describe the single operation of clamping the heated sheet
against the male or female mold and removing air between sheet and
mold surface by vacuum, external air pressure, or both. All thermo-
forming molds contain fine holes for air evacuation. A secondary opera-
tion within the forming cycle prestretches the hot sheet in order to control
thickness in the final product. Prestretching may be accomplished with a
plug or ring in plug-assist or ring-assist forming, or by air in pressure-
VACUUMON
VENT HOLES
Figure 10.4 Straight forming: pressure.
bubble plug-assist forming, vacuum snapback forming, pressure-bubble
vacuum snapback, and air-slip forming. Another popular technique is
trapped-sheet contact-heat pressure forming.
The various thermoforming techniques are generally described in terms
of the means used to form the sheet, such as bending, vacuum forming,
pressure forming, plug-assist forming, and matched-mold forming. The
different methods enable the processor to form different product shapes
to meet various performance requirements. Most of these techniques are
reviewed in Figs 10.3 to 10.12. The range of formable shapes runs from the
Heated
sheet Vacuum
Male
mold
Sheet
Vacuum
box
Vacuum
Figure 10.5 Snapback forming.
Clamp
VACUUM ON
PRESTRFTCH FORM
PRESTRETCH FORM
VACUUM ON
PRESTRETCH FORM
AIRSLIP-PLUG-ASSIST COMBINATION
VACUUM
BLEED FULL
VACUUM ON
PRESTRETCH FORM
Press
Female Die
Heater
Plastic Sheet Sheet Clamp
Press
Sheet
Clamp
FORMING Male Die
Press
Female Die
Forming definitions
Air-assist
Methods in which airflow or air pressure is employed to preform the sheet
partially before the final pulldown onto the mold using vacuum.
Air-slip
A variation of snapback thermoforming in which the male mold is en-
closed in a box so that, when the mold moves forward toward the hot
plastic, air is trapped between the mold and the plastic sheet, creating a
cushion. As the mold advances, the plastic is kept away from it by the air
cushion until the full travel of the mold is reached. A vacuum is then
applied to remove the air cushion and form the part against the plug.
Billow
Heated sheet is clamped over a billow chamber. Air pressure in the
chamber is increased, causing the sheet to billow upward against a de-
scending male mold.
Bubble
Sheet is clamped into a frame suspended above a mold, heated, blown
into a blister shape by air, then molded to shape by a descending plug
applied to the blister, forcing it downward into the mold.
Clamshell
A variation of blow molding and thermoforming in which two preheated
sheets are clamped between halves of a split mold (like the two-part mold
used to form the final blow-molded part). The two sheets are drawn into
the mold cavity by a vacuum and kept separate by injecting air between
them. An end contact surface could include an integral hinge.
Cold
A process of changing the shape, primarily TP sheet or billet in the solid
phase, through plastic (permanent) deformation with the use of pressure
dies (Fig. 10.13). The term implies that deformation occurs with the plastic
at room temperature. However, its range has been widened to include
forming at higher temperatures, or warm forming, but much below the
plastic melt temperature and lower than those for thermoforming. Within
this process there are special methods, such as solid-phase pressure form-
ing (SPPF), which use cold and warm forming as well as thermoforming.
Cold plastic forming is very similar to cold metal forming. The main
differences are the time dependence of TP deformation and springback, or
recovery. Formed TPs exhibit molecular orientation along the principal
strain directions, thus increasing performance (Chapters 1 and 3).
Plastic
billet
Formed
part
Drape
Sheet is clamped into a frame, heated, and draped over the mold. A
vacuum can be used to pull the sheet into conformity with the mold.
Forging
A production method whereby TP stock, usually heated, is shaped to a
desired form by compression forces (impression molding) or by sharp
hammer-like blows. Virtually all ductile materials may be forged and
preheating may not always be required. When a material is forged below
the melt temperature, it is cold forged. Cold forging of plastic is generally
called cold forming or solid-phase pressure forming. When a material is
forged above the melt temperature, it is hot forged.
Gusset
Contoured
Mandrel formed
Figure 10.14 Form, fill, and seal processes: (a) vertically formed, (b) horizontally
formed, and (c) shape formed.
Plug
Also called plug-assist, a process in which a plug, male mold, or male
stretching device is used to partially preform the part before forming is
completed using vacuum and/or pressure.
Plug-and-ring
A plug functioning as a male mold is forced into a heated plastic sheet
held in place by a clamping ring.
Prebillow
Prestretching of the heated plastic sheet by differential air pressure prior
to thermoforming.
Preprinting
Printing of a distorted pattern on a plastic sheet which is then
thermoformed to the desired shape, bringing the printed pattern into the
proper undistorted shape.
Pressure
Application of air pressure onto the sheet to force it into the cavity to form
the part rather than using vacuum to draw the sheet against the mold
cavity.
Prestretched
Stretching of heated sheet either by mechanical means or by differential
air pressure prior to the final shaping by differential air pressure.
Sandwich heating
The usual method of heating the sheet, prior to forming, which consists of
heating both sides of the sheet simultaneously.
Snapback
A variation of vacuum forming. Heated sheet is pulled to a concave form
by the vacuum box underneath; it is then snapped upward against a male
plug by vacuum through the plug. The process can extend deep drawing.
Stretch
Heated sheet is stretched over a male mold then drawn into shape by
vacuum and/or pressure.
Twin-sheet
The twin-sheet process produces hollow parts from cut-sheet or roll-feed
machinery. With a typical web-fed, twin-sheet system, two rolls of plastic
materials are simultaneously fed, one above the other. The webs are
transported through the oven on separate sheet-conveyor chains and
heated to a formable temperature. At the forming station, a specially
designed blow pin enters the space between the two sheets before the
mold closes. Air pressure is introduced between the sheets through the
blow pin and a vacuum is simultaneously applied to each mold half.
Twin-sheet forming is done by a slightly different method on specially
designed rotary thermoformers.
MATERIALS
The following TPs are thermoformed in large volumes: high-impact and
high-heat PS, HOPE, PP, PVC, ABS, CPET, and PMMA. Other polymers
of lesser usage are transparent styrene-butadiene block copolymers,
acrylic multipolymer, polycarbonate, cellulosics, and ethylene-propylene
thermoplastic vulcanizates (TPE). Coextruded structures of up to seven
layers include barriers of EVAL, Saran, or nylon, with polyolefins, and/or
styreneics for functional properties and decorative aesthetics at reason-
able costs.
All TPs that can be processed into films or sheets can be thermoformed,
provided the heated area to be formed does not exceed the hot-strength
capabilities of the material to support itself. Among them is foam sheet
such as PS foam sheet (Chapter 9).
Some plastic sheets stretch as much as 600%, others as little as 15%. This
behavior directly influences what shapes can be formed and their quality.
Those with a putty-like appearance respond to very small pressures;
others, which tend to be stiff, require heavier operating equipment. The
pressure response is somewhat related to the ability to be stretched while
hot, but the correspondence is not exact.
The most useful formable TPs do not have sharp melting points (Chap-
ter 1). Their softening with increasing heat is gradual. Each material has its
own range of heat, wide or narrow, within which it can be effectively
formed. Thus, one plastic may have a forming heat of 275-40O0F (135-
2040C), whereas another may become soft enough for forming at 35O0F
(1770C) but melt at 40O0F (2040C). And a plastic may stretch well at a
given heat but tear easily if heated a few degrees higher or cooled a few
degrees. This single property is one of the most important of all the factors
involved in forming.
Films (<10mil, <250jiim) of formable resins exhibit different behavior
depending on the plastic: PS is unstable with heat and requires extra
cooling; PVC and PVDC are excellent, with no restrictions; nylon is diffi-
cult; PCTFE is sensitive to heat and pressure fluctuations; HDPE is diffi-
cult without a support film; and PP has a very narrow heat range. In fact,
PP is extremely unstable within the conventional range of forming heat, so
it is processed by other techniques. Conventional PP has the major defi-
ciency of lacking a rubbery plateau at the forming heat; it just sags and
falls apart. A process was developed to form PP just below its softening
point, avoiding any sag. Known as solid-phase pressure forming (SPPF),
it forces PP into the desired shape by mechanical plugs and pressure. In
turn researchers changed PP to overcome its deficiencies. They developed
a proprietary catalyst and reactor technology to extrude thermoformable
sheet and film. Their material has a rubbery plateau region and a high
dynamic modulus, so it is processable in conventional thermoforming
machines.
Similar changes have also been made to plastics that were difficult or
impossible to form but which had properties desirable in a formed prod-
uct. PET is an example involving large production quantities. To make it
formable, researchers produced crystallized PET (CPET).
Other important materials are coextruded sheets and films (Chapter 3).
These multilayer extruded materials provide synergism between physical
properties and chemical resistance. They include barrier layers of
ethylene-vinyl alcohol (EVOH) copolymers and others, including those
required for aseptically packaged food products with a long shelf life at
room temperature. Crystallized polyethylene terephthalate (CPET) has
been used in dual-ovenable thermoformed trays for packaging frozen
foods. These trays can be heated in microwave and conventional ovens;
the formed parts are not affected.
Recycling
With most forming (not including bending) there can be up to 50% scrap
trim. This material could be wasted, but it is actually recycled and blended
with virgin materials. Individual sheet or film stock formed into round
shapes could have 50% or more scrap. With square forms, there could be
up to 25% scrap.
Quality products
The wall-thickness distribution is a decisive quality criterion for
thermoformed products. Online registration and control of the wall thick-
ness occurs during thermoforming. Pertinent measuring systems, the con-
trol strategy, and practical testing procedures are used.
The different shapes and forming techniques mean that different re-
quirements need to be set up. Fastness, rigidity, surface properties (gloss,
structure, etc.), diffusion properties, shaping precision, and thermo-
forming stability are largely material-specific demands. However, they
are considerably affected by the choice of process parameters.
Some component properties are directly influenced by the quality of
wall thickness and its distribution, i.e., for most processes, poor control
of thickness tolerances will lead to poor repeatability of formed shapes.
The wall thickness indirectly affects the shaping precision and the
thermoforming stability. Thus, the cooling behavior and the local relaxa-
tion of molecular orientation as well as the shrinkage of the material
differ, depending on the thickness of the product. This is why the wall
thickness and its distribution are important quality characteristics that
have to be set. Important considerations are the defined tolerances and the
limits on distribution variation of sheet and film to be processed, espe-
cially if the formed product must meet performance requirements and/or
cut costs by using the minimum wall thickness to reduce material
consumption.
In plug-assist forming of small parts, the wall thickness depends prima-
rily on the molding plug and partly on the temperature. But when the
parts have large surface areas, the surface-temperature distribution has a
considerable influence on the wall-thickness distribution. This behavior is
very important since it provides a parameter that can be drastically modi-
fied from one forming cycle to the next [53].
Postforming
A popular forming process that has provided both performance and cost
savings, principally for long production runs, is applied as the plastic
sheet, film, tape, and different profiles (tube, rod, etc.) exit the die of an
extruder, Upon leaving the die, and retaining heat, the plastic is continu-
ously postformed. With this type of inline system, the hot plastic has only
to be reduced to the desired heat of forming. All it may require is a fixed
distance from the die opening. Cooling can be accelerated with blown air,
a water spray, a water bath, or combinations thereof. Examples of post-
forming products are given in Chapter 3 (Figs 3.46 to 3.49 on pages 285-6).
This equipment requires precision tooling with very good registration.
EQUIPMENT
Thermoforming machines usually have sheet feeders or web feeders.
Sheet-fed machines operate from sheet cut into definite lengths and
widths for specific applications (Fig. 10.1, page 462). Web-fed machines
use either coil stock or a web which is fed directly from an extruder. The
machines range from simple, perhaps homemade, single-stage outfits to
multistage operations with computerized process control. With single-
stage machines, precut sheets are loaded individually into a clamping
frame, moved into a heating chamber, and moved back to their original
position, where the forming takes place. Figure 10.15 shows a single-stage,
shuttle-type, plug-assist former. A two-stage unit consists of two forming
stations with one heating chamber.
Another type of machine uses three or more stages. These rotary or
carousel types are usually built on a horizontal circular frame that rotates
(Fig. 10.16). The rotary table operates like a merry-go-round, indexing
through the various stations. A three-stage machine would have stations
for loading and unloading, heating, forming, and cooling; stations would
be indexed 120° apart.
To speed up output, inline sheet-fed machines are used. Two parallel
continually moving tracks hold and move a clamped sheet through the
required stations of heat and forming. All movements are indexed so all
I. HEAT 2. LOAD,FORM, a UNLOAD
PLUG TABLE
HEAT[R
CLAMP
TRACK
PRAME
HEATER
MOLD TABLE
LOAD
a
UNLOAD
FORM
HEAT
PLUG TABLE
HEATER
CLAMP FRAME CLAMP FRAME
HCATEf)
MOLD TABLE
Pneumatic controls
Vacuum thermoforming can be related to most of the other forming
processes. A vacuum system may use heaters to bring the sheet to its
processing temperature and forcing techniques to impart the shape of a
mold. The hot, pliable material is moved rapidly to the mold (perhaps by
gear drives) and/or moved by an air pressure differential, which holds it
in place as it cools. When the proper set temperature is reached, the
formed part can be removed without losing its shape.
Two important requirements in this cycle are to sustain the pressure
and to maintain uniform heating of the plastic. Faster evacuation
generally produces higher-quality parts. It is important to have the correct
mold heating so the fast vacuum will produce a part with no internal
stress (or very little). While the part is formed, the vacuum gauge should
never fall below 20in. Hg (6SkPa). As a TP cools, this pressure cannot
provide sufficient force to form the part and will not hold the plastic tight
against the mold (Table 10.1).
A vacuum under 20 in. Hg (68kPa) is not satisfactory; at least 25 in. Hg
(8SkPa) is required. For proper pressure regulation, a vacuum storage or
surge tank is necessary to retain a minimal even vacuum. For long form-
ing cycles, a surge tank will permit the use of a smaller vacuum pump
than would otherwise be required. To determine the vacuum surge tank
size in cubic feet, use the following formula (229):
V0XP0 + V1nXP1n=V1XP1
Pressure (psi)
Temperature controls
Even though TPs have specific processing heats, forming requires thor-
ough, fast, and uniform radiant heat from the surface to the core to the
surface. To achieve these sheets, plastics over 0.040 in. (1.02mm) should
use sandwich-type (bottom and top) heater banks. To ensure sufficient
heat is used, heaters should have capacities of at least 4-6kWft~2 (43-
65kWm~2). Various types of radiant heating elements and their perform-
ances are shown in Table 10.2. Figure 10.18 shows ABS sheets, 76 in. x
230 in. (193cm x 584cm), being conveyed to an IR oven in the back of the
console, where the sheets are individually heated and formed into 15ft
(4.6m) outboard-powered runabouts. The complete automatic process of
conveying the sheet, heating, forming, and cooling takes lOmin.
Efficiency (%)
The cycle time is controlled by the heating and cooling rates, which in
turn depend on the following factors: the temperature of heaters and the
cooling medium, the initial temperature of the sheet, the effective heat-
transfer coefficient (Table 1.28, page 86), the sheet thickness, and thermal
properties of the sheet material. Different materials absorb radiant heat
most efficiently at various wavelengths, which in turn are affected by the
temperature of the emitting heater. The most appropriate wavelengths for
TPs fall within the infra-red spectrum of 6jLim (40O0F, 2040C) to 3.2 ^Lm
(120O0F, 6490C). For example, ABS, PE, and HIPS absorb radiant heat
most efficiently when the heating elements emit 3.5-3.3 jum, whereas PC
requires 3.4 jam.
Typical material and process heats for a variety of plastics are given in
Table 10.3. The normal forming heat should be attained throughout the
sheet, and should be measured just before the mold and sheet come
together. Shallow-draw projects with fast vacuum and/or pressure form-
ing allow somewhat lower sheet heats and thus a faster cycle. Slightly
Table 10.3 Guide to thermoforming processing temperatures (0F)
Lower Normal
Mold processing forming Upper
Plastic heat* limitb heatc limitd Set heate
higher heats may be required for deep draws, prestretching, and highly
detailed molds.
When extrusion and thermoforming are separate operations, the heat
energy supplied for extrusion is completely lost by chilling the sheet.
Reheating for thermoforming requires additional heat energy. The inline
process offers the advantage of using a high percentage of the energy
contained in the sheet to condition it to the forming heat. Savings of about
30-40% can actually be obtained. The inline process provides a more even
heat distribution, and weight distributions can be reduced without chang-
ing physical properties. At equal output rates, an inline process needs
only half the floor space of separate operations.
The time required to cool the heat-softened plastic below its heat-
deflection temperature while it is in contact with the mold is often the key
to determining the overall forming cycles. Cooling is accomplished by
conductive heat loss to the mold and convective heat loss to the surround-
ing air [3]. The cooling rate depends upon the tooling because, in all
methods except matched mold, the plastic is in contact with the mold on
one side only. The opposite side is cooled convectively by forced air and
ambient air. Water sprays are sometimes used but often pose as many
problems, e.g., water spotting. Pressure forming helps to minimize cool-
ing time because the higher air pressure keeps the sheet in more intimate
contact with the mold surface.
Molds
Molds can range from hardwood for short runs to filled and unfilled high-
temperature polyester (TS) and epoxy resins, cast solid urethane, sprayed
metal, cast aluminum, cast porous aluminum, and machined steels. The
most common material is cast aluminum, which provides a good combi-
nation of durability, light weight, thermal conductivity, ease of manufac-
ture, and cost.
In tooling design, a male primary mold will allow a deeper draw than
a female mold because the plastic can be draped or prestretched over the
male mold. However, when a male plug-assist is used to prestretch the
sheet for a primary female mold, the advantage is nullified. In general,
female molds provide easier release, are less likely to get scratched or
damaged, produce thicker and stronger rims in containers, can use
smaller sheet blanks, and provide the sharpest definition on the outside of
the part. Female molds usually have the disadvantage of producing parts
with thin bottoms; however, good plug-assist design and operation can
largely eliminate this problem. Male molds are generally lower in cost.
Molds used with vacuum or pressure techniques require holes, chan-
nels, slits, ducts, and so on, to evacuate the air or to build up the pressure.
To avoid visible marks on the surface of thermoformed parts, holes
should be kept as small as possible, such as 10-25 mil (250-635 |iim). Care-
ful placement of the holes will be helpful in providing fast, efficient
airflow during forming. Logic and experience provide guidelines for the
placement of openings.
In cast-resin molds, vacuum holes can be provided by including
greased wires in the casting for later removal. Cast porous aluminum
molds (also used in blow molding) should be considered for greater
detail, such as graining, stitching, and relief work.
Undercuts can be included by the use of split molds. Some molds use a
removable section that pulls out of the mold after forming (or can be left
inside to provide a threaded insert, etc.). In the design of all molds one
should consider a draft angle of at least 2-3° per side for the female molds
and 5-7° for the male molds (the larger the better). A straight-sided angle
in the direction of the draw makes the parts difficult to release. This is
Table 10.4 Shrinkage guide for thermoformed plastics
LDPE 1.6-3.0
HOPE 3.0-3.5
ABS 0.3-0.8
PMMA 0.2-0.8
SAN 0.5-0.6
PC 0.5-0.8
PS 0.3-0.5
PP 1.5-2.2
PVC, rigid 0.4-0.5
PVC, flexible 0.8-2.5
especially true with male molds, where the natural shrink is toward the
mold. With advanced forming techniques, such as collapsible molds,
parts with zero degrees of draft or even negative drafts can be successfully
formed.
Various sheet materials have different mold shrinkage factors, ranging
from almost no shrinkage up to as much as 3V2%. Typical basic shrinkage
values are given in Table 10.4. Shrinkage can be changed significantly
when additives or fillers are used in the resin blends; it can go from zero
to practically any preengineered value. However, the percentage of
shrinkage is not as important as the consistency of the factor. Molds can be
designed to allow for the shrinkage. Careful pretesting is required for
precision parts.
Cooling conditions also affect the rate of shrinkage. Restraining the
part, either before or after release, will tend to limit the total shrinkage.
The mold heat, cooling speed, and cooling fixtures should remain con-
stant to ensure the uniformity of final part shapes. About 70-80% of the
dimensional change due to shrinkage occurs as the sheet cools from its
forming heat to its set heat. Stabilization to the final dimension can take
several hours, or even longer. Most of the change may be due to plastic
relaxation once forming stresses are removed.
DESIGNS
Designers should consider the nature of thermoforming [3] which uses
flat panels instead of the solid, enclosed, boxlike, cylindrical, rodlike, or
structural shapes of other processes. They should be aware of and observe
the material's depth-of-draw limitations, which can vary depending on
the type of TP, the thickness tolerance of the sheet, and the degree of
pinhole freedom it enjoys. For straight vacuum forming into a female
mold, the depth/width ratio should generally be ^0.5. For drape forming
over a male mold, this ratio should be ^L For parts to be used with the
plug-assist, slip-ring, or one of the reverse-draw methods, the ratio can
exceed 1 and may even reach 2 under normal circumstances. However,
shallow drafts are generally formed more readily than deep drafts and
they produce more uniform wall thicknesses.
Undercuts and reentrant shapes are possible in many designs. They
require movable or collapsible mold members, but with small undercuts
they can often be sprung from a female mold while the formed part is still
warm. This type of action works best when the plastic has some flexibility,
as do the TPEs, or is very thin. Guidelines for the maximum amounts of
undercutting that can be stripped from a mold are as follows: 0.04 in.
(1.02mm) for acrylics, PCs, and other rigid plastics; 0.060 in. (1.52mm) for
PEs, ABSs, and PAs; and 0.100 in. (2.54mm) for flexible plastics such as the
PVCs.
As reviewed on p. 253, coextruded films and sheets are used to gain
product performances. The coextrusion can also be sectionalized to gain
product advantages (Figs 10.19 and 10.20).
When female tooling is split to permit the removal of parts with under-
cuts, a parting line of the split halves becomes visible on the formed part.
If this is objectionable, the designer can sometimes incorporate the parting
line in the decoration of the part or at some natural line on the part.
CLEAR WHITE
COLOR
Figure 10.19 A coextruded sheet for producing a three-color thermoformed
container with an integrally hinged lid.
CLAMPSTRIP CLAMPSTRIP
(RECLAIMABLE) (RECLAIMABLE)
COLOR OR CLEAR
COLORORCLEAR
Figure 10.20 Addition of a single-plastic clamping strip at each side of a
coextruded sheet permits scrap reclaim of the thermoformed trim waste.
Sharp corners should never be specified, since they hamper the flow of
material into the mold's corners. This results in excessive thinning of the
materials and causes concentrations of stress. A minimum radius of twice
the stock thickness is recommended. It is also more desirable from several
standpoints to have large, flowing curves in a thermoformed part than to
have squared corners or rectangular shapes. The best parts have smooth,
natural curves and drawn sections that are spherical or nearly spherical.
Their walls will be more uniform, they will be more rigid, their surfaces
will have a lower tendency to show tool marks, and their tooling and
molds will be lower in cost. Notches or square holes should be avoided
when punching formed parts. Round holes are preferred to oval ones for
minimizing stress buildup.
Some draft is required in sidewalls to facilitate the easy removal of the
part from the mold. Female molds require less draft since parts tend to
pull away from mold walls as they shrink during cooling. With female
tooling, for most plastics the draft on each sidewall should be at least 1^ °.
For male tooling, it should be 1° (Fig. 10.21).
Metal inserts are usually not feasible, because thin walls are not suffi-
ciently strong to hold inserts, particularly if thermal expansion and con-
traction take place. Figure 10.22 shows a method of holding metal fittings.
It may be desirable to increase the stiffness of thermoformed parts. Many
- Sharp
corners R - 2 T or greater
such parts are panel shaped and made of thin walls, so they may lack
rigidity. It corrugations are used it is preferable to have them in two
directions, or an embossed pattern can add to their rigidity [3]. With short-
run production it may be more economical just to use thicker sheet plastic
to gain stiffness. If the function of the part permits, use curved, dished, or
domed surfaces to gain stiffness (Fig. 10.23).
When thermoformed parts are stacked, without controlled spacing,
they will jam together, which could create sufficient stress to cause them
to split. To avoid jamming and control the space between parts, a stacking
boss or shoulder system can be used (Fig. 10.23). Within this stacking area
the plastic must be sufficiently rigid to prevent the deflection of bosses
that would cause jamming. The height of the bosses is generally greater
than their vertical cross sections at the point of least taper; otherwise the
tapered walls will interfere before the stacking sections can engage. Other
designs can also be used to eliminate jamming.
Tolerances
Thermoformed parts lack the dimensional accuracy of injection- and
compression-molded parts. With its low pressure, thermoforming re-
duces the degree to which the sheet being formed is forced to conform to
the mold. Sheet variations, mainly in their thickness and degree of exist-
ing pinholes, affect the final accuracy of the part. This is particularly true
because tooling is generally one-sided. The objective should be to use a
sheet with tight thickness controls which is pinhole-free, rather than just
to determine its weight (some fabricators 'buy' by the lower-cost method,
where weight is the controlling factor).
Parts are dimensionally affected by the difference between their form-
ing temperature and their product-use temperature. Thus, a plastic's
coefficient of thermal expansion and contraction has a significant effect.
The chosen tooling is generally inexpensive. High-precision tooling is
usually not produced.
The pressure, time, and temperature variations that can exist will affect
the final part dimensions. Of these factors, evenness in heating the sheet
before forming is usually the most important. An allowance must also be
made for postforming shrinkage (Chapter 12). Molds should be designed
oversize so that, when shrinkage is complete, the part dimensions will be
correct to within the design tolerances.
Accuracy is much more prevalent with really precise tooling, especially
with matched male and female molds and careful control of temperature,
time, and pressure. The dimensional tolerances with the more conven-
tional single-mold system are generally ±0.6% (±0.35% for close toler-
ances) with female molds, ±0.5% (±0.3% close) with male molds under 3ft
(0.9m), ±0.8% (±0.4% close) with male molds over 3ft (0.9m), and ±30%
(±10% close) for wall thicknesses.
COSTING
The central element of any thermoforming system is the tooling, compris-
ing the mold and trimming means. The design of the product will deter-
mine the thermof orming technique to be used. Cost and volume will
influence the size of the forming machinery, the number of mold cavities,
and the rate of production.
The selection of a thermoplastic material for a thermoformed product
first requires that it be extrudable into sheet form. Then its cost, availabil-
ity, and manufacturing continuity are considered. The performance re-
quirements of the product dictate the selection of the lowest-cost plastic
that offers adequate formability; tensile, elongation, and impact strength;
chemical resistance, low or high temperature resistance, and other proper-
ties that may apply; clarity; dielectric strength; moisture, vapor, and oxy-
gen permeability; and recyclability.
If the properties of expensive engineering plastics are required, they
may be achievable through multilayer extrusion or lamination or by alloy-
ing to achieve such properties at lower cost with a structure composed
mainly of commodity plastics. Other alternatives to lower the cost of the
product material include density reduction by introducing foaming
agents, and incorporating inexpensive fillers to extend the primary resin.
TROUBLESHOOTING
This chapter has presented different problems and solutions along with
some guidelines. Like other processes, forming is subject to many vari-
ables that influence appearance, performance, and cost. All the variables
Table 10.5 Troubleshooting guide for thermoforming
are controllable, and logical steps can be taken to manage them, as re-
viewed in Chapters 2 through 4.
Major influences are sheet thickness, plastic viscosity, and melt index
(Chapter 1), regrind (Chapter 16), sheet orientation (Chapter 1), draw
ratio, forming temperature and pressure, and surface blemishes, blisters,
blushing, scratch marks, and so on. A guide to troubleshooting the
thermoforming process is given in Table 10.5.