Chapter 2
Chapter 2
Machinery
1
Course Content
O2 Introduction
Equipment Cost
Ownership Cost
2
2.1 Introduction
The Plant, equipment and tools used in construction operations are
priced in the following three categories;
1. Small tools and consumables
2. Equipment usually shared by a number of work activities
3. Equipment used for specific tasks
Depreciation
Investment Cost
4
A. Initial cost
On an average, initial cost makes up about 25% of the total cost invested
Cost of shipping
Useful life
Salvage value
6
B. Depreciation
How ever, there is always some uncertainty about the exact length of the
useful life of the asset and about the precise amount of salvage value,
which will be realized when the asset is disposed. The Depreciation
methods are
Straight line method
7
B. 1 Straight line method
equipment will lose the same amount of value in every year of its useful
life until it reaches its salvage value. The depreciation in a given year can
be expressed by the following equation
Dn = (C – S) / N
Where Dn = Depreciation in year n
C = The initial cost
S = The salvage value
12
Solution
13
Solution (Cont…)
14
Solution (Cont…)
15
C. Investment (Interest) cost
value of the equipment during its useful life. The average value of
equipment may be determined from the following equation:
where
IC is the total initial cost,
P the average value, and
n the useful life (years).
17
Example 2.2
Solution
Using the above equation, the average value is;
18
D Insurance tax and storage
costs
Insurance cost represents the cost incurred due to fire, theft, accident
and liability insurance for the equipment.
Tax cost represents the cost of property tax and licenses for the
equipment.
Storage cost includes the cost of rent and maintenance for equipment
storage yards, the wages of guards and employees involved in moving
equipment in and out of storage, and associated direct overhead.
The average rates for interest, insurance, tax, and storage found in the
literature are listed in the following Table. These rates will vary
according to related factors such as the type of equipment and location
19 of the job site.
D Insurance tax and storage
costs
20
Summary of ownership cost
The total equipment ownership cost is calculated as the sum of
21
Example 2.3
Calculate the hourly ownership cost for the second year of operation of a 465
hp twin-engine scraper. This equipment will be operated 8 h/day and 250
days/year in average conditions. Use the sum-of-years’-digits method of
depreciation and the following information:
Initial cost: $186,000
23
2.3 COST OF OPERATING CONSTRUCTION
EQUIPMENT
Ownership costs are also called “variable” cost. Because they depend
on several factors such as the number of operating hours, the types of
equipment used, and the location and working condition of the
operation.
Maintenance & Repair cost
Tire cost
Consumable cost
Equipment Operator cost
Special Items cost
24
Mobilization & Demobilization cost
2.3.1 Maintenance and Repair Cost
The cost of maintenance and repairs usually constitutes the largest
25
2.3.1 Maintenance and Repair Cost (Cont…)
The lifetime repair cost is usually estimated as a percentage of the
equipment‟s initial cost deducting the cost of tires. It is adjusted by
the operating condition factor obtained from the following Table
26
Example 2.4
Estimate the hourly repair cost of the scraper in Example 2.3 for the
second year of operation. The initial cost of the scraper is $186,000,
tire cost $14,000, and its useful life is 5 years. Assume average
operating condition and 2000 h of operation per year.
Solution
27
2.3.2 Tire Cost
The tire cost represents the cost of tire repair and replacement. Because
the life expectancy of rubber tires is generally far less than the life of the
equipment on which they are used on, the depreciation rate of tires will
be quite different from the depreciation rate of the rest of the vehicle.
Table 2.4 lists the typical ranges of tire life found in the most
recent literature on the subject for various types of equipment.
Tire repair cost can add about 15% to tire replacement cost. So,
the following equation may be used to estimate tire repair and
replacement cost:
28
2.3.2 Tire Cost
29
2.3.3 CONSUMABLE COSTS
30
2.3.3.1 Fuel
Fuel consumption is incurred when the equipment is
31
2.3.3.1 Fuel
32
Example 2.5
Calculate the average hourly fuel consumption and hourly
fuel cost for a twin- engine scraper in Example 2.3. It has a
diesel engine rated at 465 hp and fuel cost $2.00/gal. During
a cycle of 20 s, the engine may be operated at full power,
while filling the bowl in tough ground requires 5 s. During
the balance of the cycle, the engine will use no more than
50% of its rated power. Also, the scraper will operate about
45 min/h on average.
33
Solution
For this condition, the approximate amount of fuel consummated
during 1 h is determined as follows:
Rated power: 465 hp
Engine factor: 0.5
Filling the bowl, 5 s/20 s cycle =0.250
Rest of cycle, 15/20 0.5 =0.375
Total cycle =0.625
Time factor, 45 min/60 min =0.75
Operating factor, 0.625* 0.75 =0.47
From Table 2.5: use „„unfavorable‟‟ fuel consumption factor =0.040
Fuel consumed per hour: 0.47(465)(0.040) =8.74 gal
Hourly fuel cost: 8.74 gal/h ($2.00/gal) =$17.48/h.
34
2.3.3.2 Lubricating Oil Cost
The quantity of oil required by an engine per change will include the amount added
during the change plus the make-up oil between changes. It will vary with the engine
size, the capacity of crankcase, the condition of the piston rings, and the number of
hours between oil changes. It is a common practice to change oil every 100 to 200 h
[6]. The quantity of oil required can be estimated by using the following formula:
where q is the quantity consumed (gal/h), hp the rated horsepower of engine, c the
capacity of crankcase (gal), f the operating factor, t the number of hours between
changes, the consumption rate 0.006 lbs/hp-h, and the conversion factor 7.4 lbs/gal.
The consumption data or the average cost factors for oil, lubricants, and filters for
their equipment under average conditions are available from the equipment
35 manufacturers.
2.3.4 MOBILIZATION AND DEMOBILIZATION COST
This is the cost of moving the equipment from one job site to
another. It is often overlooked because of the assumption that the
previous job would have already paid for it.
These costs include freight charges (other than the initial
purchase), unloading cost, assembly or erection cost (if required),
highway permits, duties, and special freight costs (remote or
emergency).
The hourly cost can be obtained from the total cost divided by the
operating hours.
36
2.3.5 EQUIPMENT OPERATOR COST
Operator‟s wages are usually added as a separate item and added
37
2.3.6 SPECIAL ITEMS COST
and scraper blade cutting and end bits, as well as ripper tips,
shanks, and shank protectors, should be calculated as a
separate item of the operating cost.
per hour.
38
2.4 METHODS OF CALCULATING OWNERSHIP AND
OPERATING COST
39
EXAMPLE 1
40
SOLUTION
41
SOLUTION
42
SOLUTION
43
SOLUTION
44
Example 2
45
Solution
46
47
Summary
48
Example 3
49
Solution
50
Example 4
51
52
Summary
53
Over all Summary
54
Further Reading
Read the basic principles behind each methods from the following books
For better understanding about the calculation read Appendix of the first book
55
56
Examples 5
Example 5.1 Example 5.2
Assume a contractor has purchased The same contractor has purchased
a new Caterpillar D8R Bulldozer a new Caterpillar 950G Wheel
with a delivered duty paid price of loader with a delivered price of
birr 9,750,000 ETB Calculate the birr 4,500,000ETB. Moreover, the
hourly cost of the specified
price of tires is birr 15,000 per
Bulldozer.
tire, which is birr 60,000 for 4
tires.
D. Assume the Bulldozer will be engaged partly in works such as borrow material
production and common excavation with medium impact as well as in heavy rock
ripping and dozing hard rock with high impact conditions
Estimated economic life = Assume 10 Years
A2 = S * I / [(1+I)n – 1]
A2 = 67303.75 Birr/Year
J. Dozer Depreciation Cost per hour (DDC)
DDC = (A1 – A2) / E
DDC = (1453068.857 – 67303.7)/2000 = 692.88 Birr/Hr
59
1-B) Insurance charges:
equipment book value for heavy duty equipments and between 1 to 1.5%
for light duty equipments such as small vehicles.
A. Delivered price……..……………………….…….Birr 9,750,000
B. Annual insurance charges…………..………1% of delivered price
60
1-C) Property Tax
Different countries have different tax regulations whereby equipment owners pay
DPT = 2000/(2*2000)
61
1-D) Erection and Installation costs:
63
2- EQUIPMENT OPERATING COSTS
These costs include mainly the costs of fuel, lube oils, filters, grease,
64
2-A) Fuel
Performance Hand Book the fuel cost of the given dozer can be
computed as follows
Assumed Load factor ……………….Medium
Estimated fuel consumption………….33 Ltr/Hr
Fuel cost ……………………….… 11.90 Birr/Ltr
Dozer Fuel Cost per hour (DFC) = B*C
DFC = 392.70 Birr/Hr
65
2-B) Cost of lube oils, filters and grease:
The cost of lubricants (lube oils), filters and grease will mainly depend on the
maintenance practice of the equipment owner and conditions of the work
location.
Some equipment owners follow the equipment manufacturers‟ guideline
concerning time periods between lube oils, filters and grease changes while
others establish their own preventive maintenance guidelines.
Therefore, depending on the equipment owner‟s preventive maintenance
schedule or the equipment manufacturer‟s service guideline, the cost of lube
oils, filters and grease will be calculated based on the number of changes over
the economic life of the equipment.
66
1-B-1) Cost of lube oils
Lube oils include lubricants required for Crankcase/Engine, Transmission, Final
drives and Hydraulic control systems.
A. Estimated consumption of Engine oil………………...……0.129 Ltr/Hr
I. Dozer Lube Oils Cost per hour (DLOC) = A*B + C*D + E*F + G*H
69
1-C) Cost of tires:
Cost of tires is one of the major operating costs for wheel mounted equipments. Tire costs
include the cost of tire replacement and its repair. It is actually difficult to estimate tire
economic life because of the tire wear variability depending on the site surface conditions,
speed, wheel position, working load, maintenance conditions, road grades and curves as well
as operator‟s skill. The best way to estimate tire economic life is to use the equipment owner‟s
tire utilization records for each type of equipment. In the absence of such accurate records, it
is better to use tire economic life guide lines prepared both by the equipment and tire
manufacturers. As provided in the Caterpillar Performance Hand Book , the economic life of
tires is categorized into three zones (A- based on the working applications.
A. Dozer Tire Cost per hour (DTC) = 0.00 Birr/Hr (Crawler Mounted)
70
1-D) Cost of normal repair
Normal repairs are all the repair cost during the life time of the equipment excluding
undercarriage as well as major repair and overall. Accurate estimated cost of normal
repairs can be obtained from previous records of the equipment owner. However, in
the absence of such accurate data, the equipment manufacturers‟ guideline can be used
to estimate the hourly equipment cost of normal repairs. In the Caterpillar
Performance Hand Book, the hourly normal repair costs are calculated using the basic
repair factor from charts provided based on the work application of the equipment
which are rated as Zone A (moderate), Zone B (average) and Zone C (Severe).
Moreover, extended-life multipliers will be used if the estimated economic life of the
equipment is greater than 10,000 Hrs and these extended-life multipliers are given for
each equipment depending on their economic life.
71
The cost of normal repair cost provided in the caterpillar Hand book includes costs
of parts and labors.
A. Work application……..………………………Zone B (Average)
B. Basic repair factor…………………………….7.5 USD/Hr
C. Estimated economic life……………………….20,000 Hrs
D. Extended life multiplier…………………………1.3 (since economic life is
greater than 10,000)
E. Hourly normal repair cost of parts = 0.7*B*D
F. Hourly normal repair cost of labor = 0.25*0.3*B*D
G. Dozer Normal Repair Cost per hour (DNRC) = E + F
DNRC = 7.55 USD/Hr
Using the selling rate of the commercial bank of Ethiopia
1 USD =16.74 Birr
DNRC = 16.74*7.55 = 126.387 Birr/Hr
72
1-E) Cost of high wear items:
High wear items are these items having very short economic life as
73
Summary of Operating Costs
As discussed earlier, the equipment operating cost includes the cost of fuel,
lubricants, filters, grease, tires, undercarriage, normal repairs and high wear
items and all these costs will be summed to get the operating cost of the
equipment. Accordingly, the operating cost of the dozer can be summarized as
follows
Hourly operating costs
Based on the principles of direct labor hourly cost estimation, the annual
operator‟s salary and benefits shall be summed up and divided by the annual
utilization of the equipment to get the hourly cost of operators.
In determining the annual operator‟s salary and benefits, the following costs,
but not limited to, shall be assessed properly. Once, the annual salary and
benefits are calculated for the equipment operators, the hourly cost of
operators can be computed as follows:
A. Total annual salary and benefits………………. 62,310.44 Birr
B. Annual equipment utilization………………………2000 Hrs
C. Hourly operator‟s cost = A/B = 31.16 Birr/Hr
75
Table – Operator’s annual salary and benefits cost breakdown
77
Additional
There are also cases where contractors may lease their equipments to
79
Hourly overhead costs = 193.482 Birr
5) EQUIPMENT BREAKEVEN COST
costs, operator‟s costs and overhead costs. Accordingly, the hourly breakeven
costs for the dozer is;
A. Hourly owning costs…………………….………. 698.13 Birr
B. Hourly operating costs…………………….……560.59 Birr
C. Hourly operator‟s costs…………………………….31.16 Birr
D. Hourly overhead costs ………………………….193.482Birr
E. Hourly breakeven costs = A + B + C + D
Hourly breakeven costs = 1483.36 Birr
80
6) PROFIT AND INCOME TAX
business in Ethiopia shall pay 30% of its gross profit as income tax as
per the Income tax proclamation No. 286/2002.
81
For completeness of the exercise in establishing the equipment rental cost of
the equipments in this example , assume the net profit margin to be 10% of
the equipment breakeven cost. Accordingly, gross profit has to be calculated
and added to the equipment breakeven cost to establish the rental rate of
equipments.
Let C be the equipment breakeven cost
Gross Profit = X% * C
Net Profit = 10% * C
Income tax = 0.3 * Gross profit
Gross Profit = Net Profit + Income tax
X% * C = 10% * C + 0.3 * X% * C
X% = 10% + 0.3 * X%
X% = 14.29%
A. Hourly breakeven costs = 1483.36 Birr
83
As an illustration, let‟s demonstrate to calculate the equipment idle
rental rate and the equipment running rental rate the dozer;
Dozer Idle Rental Rate per hour
84
Assignment-1 (to be submitted on January 5,2020
No Description Values No Description Values
1 Purchasing price 5 000 000,00 23 Scheduled Transmission oil filter changes every 500 Hrs
10% of purchasing Price of Transmission oil filter
2 Salivage value price 24 1529.63 Birr/Pc
3 Cost of tire 15,000.00 birr each 25 Scheduled Hydraulic oil filter changes every 500 Hrs
4 Estimated economic life of tire 2500 hrs 26 Price of Hydraulic oil filter 1822.00 Birr/Pc
Estimated economic life of the Scheduled Primary fuel filter change
5 equipment 10years 27 every 2000 Hrs
6 Estimated annual utilization 1500 hrs 28 Price of Primary fuel filter 665.58 Birr/Pc
7 Estimated cost of capital 10% 29 Scheduled Final fuel filter change every 500 Hrs
8 Insurnace charge 1% of purchasing price 30 Price of Final fuel filter 1209.16 Birr/Pc
9 Property tax (registration fee) 2000 Birr/2 years 31 Scheduled Primary air filter change every 2000 Hrs
10 Assumed load factor Medium 32 Price of Primary air filter 3055.16 Birr/Pc
11 Estimated fuel consumption 20lit/hr 33 Scheduled Secondary air filter change every 1000 Hrs
12 Fuel cost 19 birr/lit 34 Price of Secondary air filter 3050.00 Birr/Pc
13 Estimated consumption of Engine oil 0.120 Ltr/Hr 35 Estimated grease consumption 0.004 Kg/Hr
14 Price of Engine oil 68.79 Birr/Ltr 36 Price of grease 131Birr/Kg
Estimated consumption of Basic repair factor
15 Transmission oil 0.034 Ltr/Hr 37 4.5 USD/Hr
16 Price of Transmission oil 74.61 Birr/Ltr 38 Extended life multiplier 1,25
Estimated consumption of Final Total annual cost of operator’s wage and
17 drives oil 0.036 Ltr/Hr 39 benefits 55,500 birr/year
18 Price of Final drives oil 70.36 Birr/Ltr
Estimated consumption of Hydraulic
19 oil 0.076 Ltr/Hr
20 Price of Hydraulic oil 70.36 Birr/Ltr
21 Scheduled Engine oil filter changes every 250 Hrs
85 22 Price of Engine oil filter 807.93Birr /Pc
Thank you
86