Unit 7
Unit 7
Introduction
Objectives
Cooperative Learning
7.3.1 Nature and Concept
7.3.2 What is a Group?
7.3.3 Underlying Assumptions
Cooperative Learning Strategies
7.4.1 Teacher Presentation Students Revision (TPSR)
7.4.2 Student Teams Achievement Divisions (STAD)
7.4.3 Team Games Tournaments
7.4.4 Group Investigation
7.4.5 Jigsaw
7.4.6 Group Project Work
Advantages of Cooperative Learning
Formation of Groups
Teacher's Role in Cooperative Learning
Let Us Sum Up
Unit-end Exercises
Answers to Check Your Progress
Suggested Readings
7.1 INTRODUCTION
To maximize students' learning and attainments, innovative and reflective
teachers are always in search of methods of teaching and learning other than
the conventional methods which in popular parlance are often labeled as chalk
and talk or lecture methods.
The educational researchers and teacher educators have developed a variety of
strategies which are stated to be free from the weaknesses of conventional
methods. Besides enhancing the level of students' performance, cooperative
learning methods and strategies have the potential to bring about desirable
changes in students' behaviour. In this unit, you will study the concept, need,
types and advantages of cooperative learning. The role that you can play in the
use of cooperative learning has also been discussed in the unit. We hope that
you will use this method of teaching in your school.
7.2 OBJECTIVES
After studying through this unit, you should be able to:
explain the concept of cooperative learning,
describe the need and importance of cooperative learning,
describe the different strategies of cooperative learning,
state the advantages of cooperative learning,
explain different types of groups,
illustrate formation of groups by teachers,
explain the teacher's role in cooperative learning.
Teaching Learning
Strategies
7.3 COOPERATIVE LEARNING
7.3.1 ~ a t u r and
e Concept
In our schools, the students are organized in grades or classes on the basis of
their level of achievement in the prescribed curriculum. The students placed in
a class, by and large, belong to the same age group. A teacher is called upon to
transact the prescribed c ~ c u l u m to the whole class treating it as one unit in
spite of the fact that each class comprises students of varying levels of abilities
and interests. It is quite natural that in a mixed ability class, different students
shall have different perceptions and experiences about the same curriculum.
On the other hand, in an individualized learning situation, a teacher gets an
opportunity to reorient hisher teaching to the specific needs of an individual
student who proceeds at hislher own pace. However, it is not possible for a
teacher to attend to the needs of all students individually. Researchers have
developed the cooperative learning strategies as an alternative to both whole
class teaching and learning strategies and the individualized learning strategies.
The cooperative strategies make an attempt to overcome the weaknesses of
both whole class and individualized learning strategies. Based on this
explanation let us understand cooperative learning.
"Cooperative learning is a set of teaching strategies used to help learners meet Cooperative Learning
specific learning and interpersonal goals in structured groups (Slavin, 1995)".
This definition of cooperative learning includes the following three ideas:
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the unit.
.........................................................................
.........................................................................
.........................................................................
.........................................................................
3. In the context of cooperative learning, indicate whether the
following statements are true or false.
Group goals
Individual accountability
Equal opportunity for success
Equal opportunity for success: In groups, all students, reeardless of their past
achievement, have equal chance of contributing to the realization of group
goals. Students compete with their own performance, not with each other.
Improvement in the performance of a low achiever or average achiever or high
achiever leads to improvement in the overall performance of the group as a
whole. Thus, each member, irrespective of hisher level of past achievement,
gets a similar opportunity to contribute to the accomplishment of the group.
A few cooperative learning strategies which you can use in your school are
described in the sub-sections 7.4.1 to 7.4.6.
This strategy is very simple as it is used along with the conventional whole
class teaching. It can be used for the teaching of all subjects in any class. Its
main purpose is to strengthen learning resulting from whole class strategy. The
underlying assumption is that the subject matter presented by the teacher is
better grasped by the students if it is revised by them in small groups. The use
of this method will provide opportunities to the students to verbalize their
learning which helps in the clarification of concept which in turn lays the
foundation for making the learning stable and lasting. The group may appoint
one of the bright students as the group leader or chairperson. The group leader
may ask one of the students to summarize the content of the lesson taught by
the teacher and encourage other students to ask questions relating to the points
not understood by them. The students who have understood the content shall
provide answers to the question in their own ways. The group leader may
moderate and regulate the discussion on the probable answers to the question
in hand. The questions, which are not answered or resolved in the group, may
be brought to the whole class for resolution with the help of students of other
groups or by the teacher. For example, after teaching the lesson on the great.
uprising of 1857 in social sciences, you c~ divide the class into groups for
revision and discussion. During group work, some of the students may provide
details or offer explanations which might have been missed by you. In case one
of the groups fails to resolve the question relating to the difference between-the
Teaching Learning
Strategies immediate and the long term causes, it may be brought back to the whole class
for further discussion.
Teach the content of the lesson in hand in your own usual way which may
be a blend of exposition, discussion, illustration, etc.
Divide the class into groups and ask the members of each group to
nominate their group leader. Give instructions for the organization of group
work before asking them to work separately.
Monitor the proceedings of all the groups and provide on the spot
guidance, if required.
Organize plenary session to attend to the issues which could not be
resolved in groups. This could be accomplished with the help of students of
other groups.
Reteach those portions of the content which all the students have failed to
comprehend. This can be done by using different examples, illustrations,
etc. or by using :appropriate instructional aids.
Activity 1
1. Plan and execute TPSR strategy to teach any topic in your class.
Student Team Achievement Divisions (STAD) is one of the most well known
strategizs of cooperative learning which uses four or five member teams to
master topics dealing with basic skills. Like the teacher presentation student
revision strategy (TPSR), teachers using STAD initially present the content or
skill as they normally would. After the initial presentation you ask the students
to work on the concept or skill in the setting of a structured group. When they
understand the content, you administer a test and assign a score to each student
and then derive improvement score by comparing the present score of the
student with hisker base score. On the basis of improvement scores of
individual members, average improvement score of each group is calculated
which serves as the criterion for giving awards to the groups.
Cooperative Learning
the students. They may be helped to form realistic targets or goals of
achievements. The experiment may comprise three stages. In the first stage, the
teacher may read the module aloud and give brief explanations wherever
necessary. In the second stage, the groups may be asked to go through the
materials as well as the textual lesson using different learning strategies under
the guidance of the teacher. In the third stage, the groups may meet the teacher
and discuss the difficult as well as interesting points. The teacher may also
arrange a quiz session. Assessment of the work can take place in the last stage.
You may find that lot of self-learning takes place through self-direction,
struggle and efforts on the part of the learners.
STAD can be used for a range of topics in all subjects. For example, the
I strategy can be used for topics like solar system, water cycle, etc in science,
climate regions, longitude and latitude problems in social studies, parts of body
and characteristics of drugs in health education.
Team study or group work: Slavin (1995) recommends the following steps
for team study:
Evaluation and grading: When base scores are used, teachers should ensure
that improvement in scares is reflected in the individual student's term grades.
A specified number of improvement scores may lead to upward revision in
their grade. This puts them in the position of competing only with their past
performance, and it gives every student in the class a chance for success.
Activity 2
1. Plan and execute a STAD strategy to teach ahy topic in your class.
This strategy is based on the principle of cooperation within the team (group)
and competition between teams (groups). You might have observed that in
games like hockey, fobtball, basketball, etc, all the individual players play as a
team to win the game against another team. The individual members in a team
'lq thee best to help each other, particularly the senior and experienced players
he;$ and guide the youngsters to hone their playing skills.
You can use this strategy by devising a game"in your subject and then by
dividing the class into teams of four or five members. For example, as a
language teacher you can devise a spelling or vocabulary game. ,You can make
different teams to sit at different places in the class and then ask each member
of a team to give antonym or synonym of a given word. The score for a correct
response should be decided before hand. At the end of the round, a team shall
have a score on the basis of correct responses given by its members. The
procedure is repeated with the other teams. At the end of the first round, you
can announce the total score of each team.
The strategy can be used in all school subjects. For example, in Social
Sciences, team tournaments can be organized around mountains, rivers,
.rainfall, historical personalities, political personalities, events, etc. In Science,
team tournaments can be organized on themes like physical ailments, solar
sybtem, applicationeofscience and technology in agriculture, industry, etc.
Divide the class into teams and assign the same theme or different themes
to all the teams.
a Ailnounce date and time of the tournament. Team members may meet in Cooperative Learning
the classroom, in the school library or at some other convenient place for
making the plan.
Frame rules and make the same known to the team before the
commencement of the tournament.
Conduct the competition and giv'e rewards to the winning team.
Organize tournaments periodically and ensure participation of all the
students in the tournaments.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the unit.
This strategy entails division of the class into a few small groups with four or
-
five students in each group. These groups are either assigned different ,
Teaching Learning
Strategies problems or different aspects of the same problem for investigation. Focus of
group investigation is relatively less on content goals and more on inquiry
skills. You can introduce the problem to the whole class if its various aspects
are to be investigated by different groups. In case, each group is assigned a
separate problem, you will have to introduce the problem to the group
concerned. Students are likely to get fully involved in the investigation if the
problem selected is a real life problem. For example, problems like LLmonsoon
failure", "delayed monsoon", can be selected for investigation after detailed
consultation and discussion between you and the students.
(ii) Plan of action: After selection of the problem, help the students to identify
various aspects of the problem for detailed investigation. Divide the class
into a few groups and allow each group to choose an aspect of its choice.
Help each group to discuss and finalize its plan for investigation. For
example, the following may be identified as aspects of the problem of
monsoon failure:
'
The investigation plan prepared by the students shall include proposed
strategies for carrying out various tasks like gathering information, analysis
and synthesis of collected information, preparation of report, etc.
7.4.5 Jigsaw
Jigsaw, developed by Slavin (1995), assigns students to groups and asks each
student to become an expert on one aspect or part of an organized body of
knowledge. These experts then teach the portion of the content to other
members of their group. Thus, each student gets an opportunity to teach one
aspect or component and is taught other aspects by different members of
hisher group. For example, for the topic on the achievements and policies of
the Mughal Emperor Akbar, a teacher of History can implement the strategy as
under:
i) Identify the major components of the broad topic. In the present case, the
components could be:
ii) Divide the class into groups with five members in each group. Assign
common names to different membei-s in each group like A, B, C, D or E.
iii) Assign the first component to the students with the name A in all the
groups. Likewise, the second, third, fourth, fifth components may be
assigned to the students with the names B, C, D and E respectively.
iv) Allow sufficient time to the students to master the component assigned to
them. Tell them the references and other sources, which they could tap.
Monitor and supervise the progress of different groups.
v) Provide opportunities to the experts to meet to exchange their notes and to
further refine, improve and strengthen their learning. For example, the
students with the name "A" in all the groups shall meet and discuss their
work and understanding of the topic on the life and achievements of
Akbar. The "experts" on the other components shall meet separately to
further enrich their knowledge on concerned components.
vi) Ask the experts (students) to return to their original group and teach the
component of their specialization. Each member of the group shall teach
the component of hisher specialization to the other students.
vii) Monitor students as they teach their topics to the other members of the
group.
viii)Adrninister a test covering all components of the topic.
Teaching Learning
Strategies ix) Score the test and determine the improvement points in respect of each
student.
x) Provide feedback to the groups about their performance and reward team
achievements.
Activity 3
1. Plan and execute a Jigsaw session for a group of students of your class.
Write how it was different from your teaching.
In many respects group project work resembles group investigation but there
are some dissimilarities also. In the group investigation the focus is less on
content goals and more on enquiry skills, whereas in the group project work,
students work in groups to accomplish some task or perform an activity. The
underlying assumptian is that students will understand each other and pick up
interpersonal skills when they are provided opportunities to work together in
small groups for some time. The implementation of this strategy involves the
following phases:
i. Selection of'the project: To begin with, you discuss with the students the
possibility of undertaking some project. After discussing various
alternatives, one major project or few small projects for execution may be
selected. For example, organization of science exhibition, celebration of
some day (human rights day, teachers' day, friendship day, annual day,
etc), organization of youth parliament, organization of poetical symposium,
publication of class or school magazines, may be considered for selection
as group projects.
ii. Organizational In case a major project has been selected, it may
be split into subprojects and a group may be assigned the responsibility to
take care of one aspect of the major project within each group, ask
individual members to accept the responsibility for specific tasks. In
addition ensure that each group decides the phasing, time budgeting and
resources required in respect of the specific task assigned to it.
iii. Execution: After the completion of detailed planning, students get engaged
in the execution of the project. Make yourself readily available to all the
students for consultation and solving their problems, if any. Keep a watch
on the participation and contribution of each student and monitor progress
of each group. Impress upon the group leaders to see that all the students
participate enthusiastically to complete the project on time. - .
iv. Evaluation: After completion of the project, make all the grotips to meet in
the plenary session to take stock of their achievements, weaknesses or
failures. They may point out the flaws, if any, in the selection, planning or
execution of the project. They may also discuss the lessons they might have
learnt and the points they would like to keep in mind at the time of
execution of some other similar project in future (Arora, 2002). You may
also ask them to think how they would execute the project if they were
called upon to attempt it again.
Cooperative Learning
Check Your Progress 3
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the unit.
.........................................................................
.........................................................................
You are further expected to ensure that all groups function in a democratic
manner. Students should be encouraged to elect their own group leader and to
decide the procedure for conducting group work to complete the assigned
learning task.
Cooperative Learning
Check Your Progress 4
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the unit.
i. To begin with, you have to identifj learning tasks and fix learning goals for
cooperative learning. The nature of learning tasks should be in tune with
the scope of cooperative learning strategies. For example, in group
investigation, a suitable problem needs to be identified, in team games
tournaments, a game or a quiz shall have to be devised and in-group project
work, some activity to be performed shall have to be decided. The major
problem or project should be split into specific tasks to be assigned to
different groups.
ii. After identification of the problem, you have to divide the class into
groups. The size and composition of the groups should be decided keeping
in view the learning goals.
iii. You are expected to take all the steps necessary to facilitate the work of
groups. Besides making suitable seating arrangement you should make
available necessary material like maps, charts, magazines, newspapers, etc
to the students. The sources of information gathering should also be made
I known to the students.
iv. You should continuously monitor and supervise the functioning of different
groups. When the groups are working separately, you should move from
I
group to group to provide on the spot guidance to the groups, if required.
The groups facing some problem should be helped to overcome the same.
i
I
v. After completion of the group work, organize the plenary session where
different groups shall share their experience and present the report of the
work done by them. You shall provide feedback to the groups for fbrther
improvement in the quality of their work.
Teaching Learning
Strategies vi. An important task of the teacher is to evaluate the performance of each
student to ascertain the extent of improvement in their learning and to
decide improvement points, rewards, etc.
b) Compare your answers with those given at the end of the unit.
...........................................................................
...........................................................................
2. What should determine composition of groups?
...........................................................................
...........................................................................
1. Identify a problem for group investigation by the students of class 10, and
prepare a detailed plan for its implementation.
2. Differentiate between teacher presentation student revision (TPSR) and
student teams achievement divisions (STAD) strategies of cooperative
learning.
3. Devise five games in your subject for the organization of team games
tournaments for the students of class9-10.
4. Differentiate between the roles of a teacher in the cooperative learning
strategies and other methods of teaching.
2. Cooperative learning
a) enhances motivation
b) provides opportunity of active participation to every one
c) enhances individual learning achievement
3. a) True
b) False
c) False
1. a) inquiry/communicative interpersonal
b) attitudinal change
c) democratic
d) Same ability level