Chapter 15
Chapter 15
Exercise Questions
Monetary Economics
Muhammad Sannan
ANSWER: 1
b. You deposit $400 into your checking account at the local bank.
For You (Depositor): Neither (Your deposit is an asset for you, but it's not a liability).
For the Bank: Liability (They owe you $400, which is a deposit).
For the Federal Reserve: Asset (They hold the bank's promise to repay the loan).
For the Bank: Liability (They owe the Federal Reserve $1,000,000).
For the Borrowing Bank: Liability (They owe the other bank $500,000).
For the Lending Bank: Asset (They hold the other bank's promise to repay $500,000).
e. You use your debit card to purchase a meal at a restaurant for $100.
For You (Depositor): Neither (Your checking account balance decreases, but there is no
direct creation of assets or liabilities in this transaction).
For the Bank: Neither (The bank's liabilities (your deposit) are reduced, but there's no
direct impact on their assets or liabilities in this specific transaction).
ANSWER: 2
The process of deposit creation in the banking system is determined by the money
multiplier, which is a function of the reserve requirement set by the central bank. The
formula for the money multiplier is:
If the First National Bank receives an extra $100 in reserves and decides not to lend out
any of these reserves, the money multiplier will not come into play because the reserves
are not being used to create new loans and deposits.
In this scenario, the deposit creation for the entire banking system is zero since the
reserves are not multiplied through the lending process. The money multiplier only
affects deposit creation when banks use excess reserves to make new loans, leading to a
multiplication of the initial reserve injection.
ANSWER: 3
When the Federal Reserve buys $1 million worth of bonds from the First National Bank,
it injects $1 million in reserves into the banking system. If the First National Bank and
other banks use the resulting increase in reserves to purchase securities (such as more
bonds) and not to make loans, the impact on checkable deposits will be limited.
ANSWER: 4
1. Reserves:
Reserves are the deposits that banks hold at the central bank (Federal Reserve in
the U.S.) plus vault cash.
When the depositor withdraws $1,000 in currency, the bank's reserves decrease
by $1,000 because the currency is no longer part of the bank's reserves.
2. Checkable Deposits:
Checkable deposits represent the money that depositors have in their accounts,
which they can access through checks or electronic transactions.
When the depositor withdraws $1,000 in currency, the checkable deposits
decrease by $1,000.
3. Monetary Base:
The monetary base is the sum of currency in circulation (outside the banking
system) and reserves held by banks.
The withdrawal of $1,000 in currency reduces the reserves (part of the monetary
base) by $1,000.
However, the currency in circulation increases by $1,000 since the withdrawn
money is now in the hands of the depositor.
ANSWER: 5
When a bank sells $10 million of bonds to the Federal Reserve to pay back a $10 million
loan, it involves several steps that have implications for the level of checkable deposits.
Let's break down the process:
ANSWER: 6
When you decide to hold $100 less cash and deposit that $100 in the bank, the effect on
checkable deposits in the banking system will be a net increase. Here's how it works:
ANSWER: 7
The statement "The Fed can perfectly control the amount of reserves in the system" is
generally false. While the Federal Reserve has tools and mechanisms to influence the
level of reserves in the banking system, achieving perfect control is challenging due to
several factors:
1. Autonomous Factors: The Fed does not have control over all factors influencing
reserves. Autonomous factors, such as changes in currency holdings by the public or
fluctuations in the Treasury's account with the Fed, can impact reserves independently
of the Fed's actions.
2. Open Market Operations: The Fed primarily uses open market operations (buying or
selling government securities) to influence the level of reserves. However, the impact is
not always perfectly predictable due to various market dynamics and participants'
reactions.
3. Interest Rate Movements: The Fed's target interest rates (like the federal funds rate)
also influence the demand for reserves. However, the relationship between interest rates
and reserve demand is complex and subject to changes in economic conditions.
4. Bank Behavior: Banks' decisions regarding lending, borrowing, and holding reserves
are influenced by various factors, including economic conditions, regulations, and risk
considerations. The Fed can provide incentives or disincentives, but it cannot perfectly
control individual bank behavior.
5. Market Dynamics: The financial markets and global economic conditions can introduce
uncertainties that impact the effectiveness of the Fed's actions in controlling reserves.
ANSWER: 8
The statement "The Fed can perfectly control the amount of the monetary base, but has
less control over the composition of the monetary base" is generally true. Let's break
down the statement:
ANSWER: 9
When the Federal Reserve buys $100 million worth of bonds from the public and lowers
the required reserve ratio, it is likely to have an expansionary effect on the money
supply. Let's break down the process:
ANSWER: 10
a) Central Bank (e.g., Federal Reserve):
Open Market Operations: The central bank can buy or sell government securities in the
open market. When the central bank buys securities, it injects money into the banking
system, increasing reserves and potentially leading to more lending and money creation.
Conversely, selling securities absorbs money, reducing reserves and potentially limiting
lending.
Discount Rate: The central bank can influence the money supply by changing the
discount rate, the interest rate at which banks borrow from the central bank. Lowering
the discount rate encourages borrowing, leading to more lending and increased money
supply.
Reserve Requirements: Adjusting the required reserve ratio can directly impact the
money supply. Lowering the reserve requirements allows banks to lend a higher
proportion of their deposits, leading to an increase in the money supply.
(b) Banks:
Lending Behavior: Banks play a crucial role in money creation through the lending
process. When banks make loans, they create new deposits, contributing to the
expansion of the money supply. Conversely, if banks reduce lending, the money supply
can contract.
Reserve Management: Banks' decisions on how much to hold in reserves versus lending
out affect the overall money supply. If banks choose to hold excess reserves, the money
supply may not expand as much. Conversely, if they lend out more of their reserves, the
money supply can increase.
Currency Holding: If depositors decide to hold more currency and less in deposit
accounts, the money supply may decrease as currency is not part of the bank's reserves.
Deposit Behavior: Depositors can influence the money supply by their deposit and
withdrawal decisions. When depositors deposit money into banks, it contributes to the
money supply. Conversely, withdrawing funds reduces the money supply.
Use of Credit: Depositors using credit (taking out loans) contribute to the money supply
by creating new deposits. This is because the borrowed funds are deposited in the
banking system, leading to an increase in the money supply.
ANSWER: 11
The statement "The money multiplier is necessarily greater than 1" is generally true. The
money multiplier is a measure of the potential increase in the money supply resulting
from an initial change in the quantity of reserves in the banking system. The formula for
the money multiplier is:
The required reserve ratio represents the fraction of deposits that banks are required to
hold as reserves. Since the denominator in the money multiplier formula is the required
reserve ratio, the money multiplier will be greater than 1 if the required reserve ratio is
less than 1.
Here's why:
1. If the required reserve ratio is 0.1 (10%), the money multiplier would be 1/0.1=10.
2. If the required reserve ratio is 0.05 (5%), the money multiplier would be 1/0.05=20.
In both cases, the money multiplier is greater than 1. This implies that an initial injection
of reserves into the banking system can lead to a multiple expansion of the money
supply through the lending and deposit creation process.
It's important to note that the money multiplier is a theoretical concept, and in practice,
various factors can influence the actual multiplier, including the behavior of banks and
the public, changes in the velocity of money, and other economic conditions.
ANSWER: 12
A financial panic can have a significant impact on the money multiplier and the money
supply, often leading to a contraction in the broader monetary system. Here's how a
financial panic may affect these factors:
ANSWER: 13
The money multiplier is influenced by two main factors: the currency ratio (c) and the
excess reserves ratio (e). The formula for the money multiplier is:
The required reserve ratio is determined by subtracting the currency ratio and the
excess reserves ratio from 1:
During the Great Depression years from 1930 to 1933, it's reported that both the
currency ratio (c) and the excess reserves ratio (e) rose dramatically. Let's analyze the
impact of these changes on the money multiplier:
1. Currency Ratio (c):
If the currency ratio (c) increases, it means that a larger proportion of the money
supply is held in the form of currency rather than as demand deposits. An
increase in c decreases the value of (1 - c - e), which, in turn, increases the
required reserve ratio.
2. Excess Reserves Ratio (e):
If the excess reserves ratio (e) rises, it means that banks are holding a larger
proportion of their reserves in excess rather than lending them out. An increase
in e also increases the required reserve ratio.
Given that both c and e increased dramatically during the Great Depression, the
combined effect would likely be a significant increase in the required reserve ratio. As a
result, the money multiplier, which is the reciprocal of the required reserve ratio, would
decrease.
ANSWER: 14
Paying interest on excess reserves is a monetary policy tool that the Federal Reserve can
use to influence the behavior of banks. By doing so, the Fed aims to impact the money
supply and control inflation. The introduction of interest on excess reserves can affect
the multiplier process and the money supply in several ways:
ANSWER: 15
The decline in the money multiplier during the periods 1930–1933 and 2008–2010,
despite different outcomes in M1 money supply, can be attributed to changes in various
factors influencing the money creation process and the behavior of banks and the
public. Several key factors help explain the difference in outcomes between the two
periods:
1. Interest on Reserves:
During the recent financial crisis (2008–2010), the Federal Reserve introduced the
payment of interest on reserves. This policy aimed to encourage banks to hold
excess reserves at the Fed rather than lending them out. This had the effect of
reducing the money multiplier by limiting the deposit creation process.
In contrast, during the 1930s, interest on reserves was not paid. The difference in
the treatment of reserves played a role in shaping the behavior of banks and their
lending activities.
2. Banking System Stability:
The stability of the banking system also matters. In the 1930s, the banking system
faced widespread failures and a lack of confidence, leading to a contraction in
lending and a decrease in the money supply.
During the 2008 financial crisis, there were significant interventions by central
banks and governments to stabilize the financial system. Policymakers took steps
to prevent widespread bank failures and restore confidence, which helped
prevent a severe contraction in the money supply.
3. Velocity of Money:
The velocity of money, representing the speed at which money circulates in the
economy, can impact the effectiveness of changes in the money supply. A change
in the velocity of money can offset the impact of changes in the money supply on
nominal GDP.
In the recent financial crisis, despite the decline in the money multiplier, increased
spending velocity and demand for money contributed to an overall increase in
the M1 money supply.
4. Quantitative Easing and Asset Purchases:
During the 2008–2010 period, central banks, including the Federal Reserve,
implemented unconventional monetary policies such as quantitative easing. This
involved large-scale purchases of financial assets to increase bank reserves and
stimulate economic activity.
The asset purchases had an impact on the broader financial markets and
contributed to an expansion of certain components of the money supply, even as
the money multiplier declined.
5. Policy Responses:
The responses of central banks and governments to economic crises play a
crucial role. The policy responses during the recent financial crisis were more
proactive, with measures taken to stabilize financial institutions and provide
liquidity support to prevent a severe contraction in the money supply.
ANSWER: 16
Explanation:
When the Federal Reserve sells $2 million of bonds to the First National Bank, it receives
$2 million in reserves in exchange. This transaction increases the reserves held by the
Fed while decreasing its holdings of bonds. Conversely, the First National Bank
experiences a decrease in reserves by $2 million and an increase in its bond holdings by
the same amount. Overall, the transaction results in a $2 million reduction in reserves
within the banking system. However, since the sale of bonds offsets the increase in
reserves, there is no change in the monetary base.
ANSWER: 17
Central Bank
Assets Liabilities
Commercial Bank
Assets Liabilities
Explanation:
The central bank provides a $10 million loan to the commercial bank, increasing its
loans asset. Simultaneously, the commercial bank's reserves increase by $10 million,
corresponding to the loan received. Both the central bank's and commercial bank's
reserves and assets increase by $10 million each, leading to no change in the monetary
base.
Assets Liabilities
Commercial Bank
Assets Liabilities
Explanation:
The central bank sells $10 million in securities to the commercial bank, decreasing its
securities asset. As a result, the commercial bank's reserves decrease by $10 million,
representing the payment for the securities. Both the central bank's and commercial
bank's reserves and assets remain unchanged, resulting in no change in the monetary
base.
(c) The commercial bank repays the loan to the central bank.
Central Bank
Assets Liabilities
Commercial Bank
Assets Liabilities
Explanation:
The commercial bank repays the $10 million loan to the central bank, reducing its loans
asset. Consequently, the commercial bank's reserves decrease by $10 million, reflecting
the repayment of the loan. Both the central bank's and commercial bank's reserves and
assets decrease by $10 million each, resulting in no change in the monetary base.
ANSWER: 18
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
Depositor
Assets Liabilities
No change No change
Assets Liabilities
Currency +$50
million
Assets Liabilities
Depositor
Assets Liabilities
Explanation:
Initially, the Federal Reserve lends $100 million to five banks, increasing reserves and
loans by $100 million each. When depositors withdraw $50 million and hold it as
currency, deposits decrease by $50 million, leading to a decrease in reserves held by
banks by the same amount. Overall, reserves remain unchanged, but the monetary base
decreases by $50 million due to the withdrawal of currency by depositors.
ANSWER: 19
The initial impact of the loans extended by the Fed is shown in the T-accounts below:
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
Upon receiving the reserves, banks proceed to lend out the excess reserves. This leads
to multiple deposit creation, where the increase in reserves within the banking system
supports $10 million in new loans and checkable deposits, resulting in a $10 million
expansion of the money supply. The culmination of this multiple deposit creation
process is depicted in the following T-accounts:
Assets Liabilities
Explanation:
Before the transaction, the First National Bank has checkable deposits in its account.
After the Fed lends $1 million to the First National Bank, the bank's reserves and
checkable deposits increase by $1 million each, as it receives the loan amount. This
increase in checkable deposits contributes to the overall checkable deposits in the
banking system.
ANSWER: 20
The Federal Reserve's sale of bonds to the First National Bank decreases reserves by $2
million. Consequently, checkable deposits in the banking system decrease by $20
million. The initial impact on both the Federal Reserve and the banking system is
illustrated below:
Federal Reserve System
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
Following the reduction in bank reserves, the process of multiple deposit creation
operates in reverse. As a result, the ultimate impact on the balance sheets of both the
Federal Reserve and the banking system is depicted below:
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
ANSWER: 21
The total increase in checkable deposits is only $5 million, substantially less than the $10
million that occurs when no excess reserves are held. The reason is that banks now end
up holding 20% of deposits as reserves and only lend out 80%, so that the increase in
deposits found in the T-accounts is $1,000,000 + $800,000 + $640,000 + $512,000 +
$409,600 + . . = $5 million. The T-accounts below show the effect of the securities
purchase:
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
After the increase in reserves and the multiple deposit creation process, the Fed and
Banking system balance sheets are as follows:
Assets Liabilities
Assets Liabilities
ANSWER: 22
The banking system is still not in equilibrium because there continues to be $100 million
of excess reserves (+$1 billion of reserves minus $900 million of required reserves, 10%
of the $9 billion of deposits). The excess reserves will be lent out until equilibrium is
reached with an additional $1 billion of checkable deposits. The T-account for the
banking system when it is in equilibrium is as follows:
Banking System
Assets Liabilities
ANSWER: 23
Checkable deposits will decrease by $50 million when the banking system is in equilibrium (as a
result of the $5 million decrease in reserves supporting the money supply). The T-account is
shown below:
Banking System
Assets Liabilities
ANSWER: 24
When the Fed sells $1 million of bonds and banks reduce their borrowings from the Fed
by $1 million, it leads to a decrease in the money supply. This occurs because the sale of
bonds by the Fed reduces the monetary base by $1 million. Additionally, the reduction
in borrowing from the Federal Reserve further decreases the monetary base by another
$1 million. Therefore, the total decline in the monetary base is $2 million, resulting in a
corresponding decrease in the money supply. This reduction in the money supply occurs
as both actions effectively remove money from circulation in the economy.
ANSWER: 25
a. The money supply (M) is the sum of currency (C) and checkable deposits (D), which is
$600 billion + $900 billion = $1500 billion. The currency deposit ratio (c) is calculated by
dividing currency by checkable deposits, resulting in 0.667. The excess reserve ratio (e) is
excess reserves (ER) divided by checkable deposits (D), yielding 0.017. The money
multiplier (m) is calculated using the formula (1 + c) / (rr + e + c), where rr is the
required reserve ratio. Given the provided excess reserve ratio and the currency deposit
ratio, the money multiplier is 2.13.
b. With the unusually large open market purchase of bonds by the central bank, the
monetary base increases by the amount of the purchase, leading to an increase in the
money supply. Using the calculated money multiplier from part (a), the new money
supply is projected to be $4483.65 billion.
c. If banks choose to hold all of the proceeds from the open market purchase as excess
reserves rather than loan them out, the excess reserves would increase to $1415 billion.
Consequently, the excess reserve ratio would rise to 1.57. However, since currency and
deposits remain the same, the money supply remains at $1500 billion. As a result, the
money multiplier decreases to 0.71.
d. The scenario described in part (c) is similar to the situation during the financial crisis
in 2008, where the Federal Reserve injected liquidity into the banking system, but
lending remained low. This led to a situation where the money multiplier was below 1
for an extended period, reflecting the possibility of large amounts of reserves entering
the banking system but being held as excess reserves, resulting in a decreased money
multiplier.