Nan Su Example
Nan Su Example
ISSN 2229-5518
Abstract— Since there is a scarcity of fine aggregate throughout the country it is essential to find a replacement of fine aggregate. Our
idea is to use copper slag as replacement of fine aggregate.Due to several costs of labours for compaction we can go to self compacting
concrete. Self compacting concrete is one of the high performance concrete which had an enormous growth in the construction industry in
the recent years. Self compacting concrete can be described as a high performance materials that flows under its own self weight, without
requiring vibration, to achieve consolidation by completely filling up formworks even when access is hindered by narrow gaps between
reinforcement bars. In this present works, for M30 grade concrete beam copper slag is replaced for sand at0%, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80% and
silica fume is used as an admixture in concrete. The various concrete workability tests such as slump flow test, T50cm slump flow ,V-funnel test, J-
ring and L-box tests were performed.
Key words— Compressible packing model, Packing factor, Nansu method, Superplasticizers.
—————————— ——————————
1 INTRODUCTION
IJSER
2 MATERIAL PROPERTIES
compaction for such type of concrete requires heavy 2.1 Cement
compaction and labour costs are also high nd it cannot
The cement used in this study was 53 grade Ordinary Port-
be done by mechanical means. This difficulty can be easily
solved by self compacting concrete.The self compacting con- land Cement (OPC).The properties of cement used are given
crete is a newest innovative high performance concrete that it in table 1.
has ability to spread and self consolidates the formwork with-
out any external vibration. The elimination of vibration causes
a reduce of manpower and increase the speed of construction. Table 1: Physical Properties of Cement
Replacement of fine aggregates produces reduction in scarcity
of river sand. S.No Properties Result
Copper slag is one of the waste materials that are obtained
from copper manufacturing industry. This material is suitable 1 Fineness of cement 2%
for fine aggregate. Hence it is a waste materials and is eco 2 Normal Consistency 31.28%
friendly. European Federation of National Associations Repre- 3 Initial setting time of cement 37 minutes
senting for Concrete provides a guidelines for requirements 4 Final setting time of cement 590 minutes
for constituent materials, test methods and check list.The de- 5 Specific gravity 3.15
sign mix of self compacting concrete based on Nansu method
and Compressible packing model for M30 grade concrete is
prepared. 2.2 Coarse aggregate
Locally available 16mm size well graded coarse aggregate
were selected for present work. The various properties of
———————————————— coarse aggregate were determined and tabulated in Table 2.
• Author name is currently pursuing masters degree program in structural
engineering in Paavai Engineering College, Namakkal, PH-9159940713. Table 2: Properties coarse aggregate
E-mail: [email protected]
• Co-Author name is currently pursuing masters degree program in struc-
tural engineering in Paavai Engineering College, Namakkal, PH- S.No Properties Result
8508797749. E-mail: [email protected] 1 Fineness Modulus 3.46
• Our guide is Assistant Professor in Civil Engineering in Paavai Engineer-
ing College, Namakkal, PH-8122625335. E-mail:[email protected]
2 Specific Gravity 2.695
3 Bulk Density 1450 kg/m3
4 Moisture Content 0.25%
5 Water Absorption 0.4%
IJSER
Appearance Black and glassy 3.1 NANSU METHOD
Specific gravity 3.93
Aggregate size = 20 mm size aggregate
Percentage of voids% 34
Water absorption% 0.18 Specific gravity of coarse aggregate = 2.7
Moisture content% 0.13
Fineness Modulus 3.28 Bulk density of loose coarse aggregate = 1500 Kg/
Bulk density 1900 kg/m3 Specific gravity of fine aggregate = 2.6
Table 5: Chemical properties copper slag Bulk density of loose fine aggregate = 1410 Kg/
w/c = 0.46 If the results of the quality control tests mentioned above fail
Water content = 215 kg/m3 to meet the performance required of the fresh concrete, ad-
Cement = 467.39 kg/m3 justments should be made until all properties of SCC satisfy
Step 3: Calculation of silica fume content: the requirements specified in the design. For example, when
SF/SF+C = 0.10 the fresh SCC shows poor flowability, the PF value is reduced
SF = 0.10 (SF + C) to increase the binder volume and to improve the workability.
SF = 45.03 Kg/ .
CA FA Ce- Water Silicafume Super-
(w/c)max = 0.45 Kg/ Kg/ ment lr Kg/ plasticizes
Kg/
Step 4: Calculation of mixing water content required Kg/
IJSER
Step 5: Calculation of super-plasticizer dosages: 3.2 Compressible Packing Model Method
The solid content of SP is 40%. According to engineering expe- Step 1: Calculation of coarse and fine aggregates content:
rience, the dosage of super-plasticizers is 1.8% of content of The content of coarse aggregates in SCC
binders. Wg = PF x ρ gL (1 Vfa/Va)
IJSER
Kg/
690 972. 405.3 186.43 45.03 13.705 S.No Method Unit Typical range
9 Min Max
1.70 2.4 1 0.46 0.111 0.034 1 Slump flow test(Filling mm 650 800
ability)
2 T50cm slump flow (Filling sec 2 5
ability)
3 V-funnel test(Filling sec 8 12
4 EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
ability)
One control and five SCC mixes with various proportions of 4 J-ring (Passing ability) mm 0 10
fine aggregate partially replaced by copper slag were prepared 5 L-box - 0.8 1
according to the limitation stipulated in the EFNARC guide-
lines and checked whether it met the criteria for properties of
4.1.1 Slump flow test and T50 test
SCC. Mix design calculations were based on several character-
istic properties like packing factor, bulk density of loose ag- A slump cone of size 200 mm diameter at the bottom and 100
gregates, specific gravity, etc. Packing factor of 1.15 was taken mm diameter at the top and 300 mm height was filled with the
by trial basis. fresh concrete. Then the slump cone was lifted vertically and
the concrete was allowed to flow freely, and the time taken for
Quantity of cement and water required for cement mixing the concrete to form a circle of 500 mm diameter was noted
was calculated as per ACI method. Quantities of other materi- (this is T50 time). Then the average of the final dimensions of
als were calculated by Nan su tool for mixdesign (Nan Su et al. the concrete in both perpendicular directions was calculated
(this dimension is the slump flow in mm). The results of
2001). Fine aggregate was replaced by copper slag at various
slump flow test and T50 Test show that the workability of the
proportions such as: 20%, 40%, 60% and 80% with the ob- SCC is within the typical range and satisfy the criteria for a
tained optimum mix and checked for its workability and du- SCC up to replacement of Fine aggregate by Copper slag at
rability properties. Table 5 shows the composition of SCC 60%. The variation of slump flow and slump 50 for various
percentage of copper slag replacement for fine aggregate are
mixes for various proportions of Copper slag replaced for fine shown in Figure 1 and Figure 3 respectively.
aggregate.
Slump 50 Test
Table 6: Mix Proportion for M30 Grade Concret 6
4
Slump Flow (sec)
2
IJSER © 2016 0
http://www.ijser.org 0 20 40 60 80
Copper S lag Replacement %
Slump 50 (sec)
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 7, Issue 4, April-2016 95
ISSN 2229-5518
satisfy the criteria for a SCC upto replacement of Fine aggregate by
Copper slag at 60%. The variation of V funnel test and V funnel T5
test for various percentage of copper slag replacement for fine ag-
gregate are shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4 respectively.
700
Slump Value (mm)
650
600
550
0 20 40 60 80
Slump (mm)
4.1.2 V funnel test and T 5minutes test L box is an apparatus to find the flow and passing ability of
IJSER
the fresh concrete. The dimensions of the L box were fabricat-
V funnel is an apparatus used to find the flow ability of the
ed as stipulated in the EFNARC. The vertical part of the L box
fresh concrete. The dimensions of the V funnel are fabricated was completely filled with the fresh concrete and allowed to
as stipulated in the EFNARC. The fresh concrete was filled in settle for one minute. Then the door at the base of the vertical
the V funnel without any compaction with the top of the fun- segment of the L box was opened and the concrete was al-
lowed to flow through the horizontal segment of the L box,
nel is leveled with a trowel. Then the bottom door was opened and the time taken for the concrete to reach the 200 and 400
and the concrete was collected in a bucket placed below. The mm mark was noted. When the flow of the concrete was com-
time taken for concrete for the complete discharge was noted pletely stopped, the height of the concrete from the base at the
face of the vertical portion of the L box was noted as H1 and
(this is the flow time). The whole process had to be completed
the height of concrete at other face was noted as H2. The ratio
within 5 minutes of preparation of the concrete. Then once between H2 and H1was calculated as the Blocking ratio. The
again, the same process is repeated. whole process had to be completed within 5 minutes of prepa-
ration of the concrete.
V Funnel Test
L-box Test
10 1.2
1
V Funnel (sec)
5 0.8
L-box
0.6
0
0.4
0 20 40 60 80 0.2
Copper S lag Replacement % 0
0 20 40 60 80
V Funnel (sec) Copper S lag Replacement %
L-box
8
rang and wait till the flow of the concrete was completely stopped.
6
e Then the average of the final dimensions of the concrete in
4
and
2 both perpendicular directions was calculated. Also measure
0 IJSER © 2016
0 20 40 60 80 http://www.ijser.org
Copper S lag Replacement %
V Funnel T5 (sec)
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 7, Issue 4, April-2016 96
ISSN 2229-5518
the height difference in between the concrete inside the J ring [1] N .Saravana Kumar, “Structural Behavior of Self Compacting Concrete
and at the edge of the concrete at four different locations. Confined with Ferrocement Under Axial Compression”, SSRG Internation-
al Journal of Civil Engineering, volume 1 Issue 1,Feb 2014.
The results for the workability test for SCC are shown in Table 8 [6] Seshadri Sekhar,“Studies on Effect of Mineral Admixtures on Durabil-
ity Properties of High Strength Self Compacting Concrete”, International
Table 8 Workability Test on SCC Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology, pISSN: 2321-7308.
IJSER
[7]K.V.S Gopala Krishna Sastry,“A Comparative Study on Mechanical
mm Ring Box Properties of Normal Vibrated Concrete and Self Compacting Concrete”,
mm 50 sec T5 mm International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering Research, Vol. 2, Issue
mm sec 2, October 2014 - March 2015, pp: (93-100).
0% 700 2 6 8 1.5 0.8 Satisfied
20% 690 3 8 12 2 0.8 Satisfied [8]S.M Naveen Kumar, “Behavior of Blended Self Compacting Concrete
Using Industrial Byproduct”, International Journal of Scientific and Research
40% 670 3 7 10 3 0.9 Satisfied Publications, Volume 5, Issue 7, July 2015, ISSN 2250-3153.
60% 650 4 6 9 4 1 Satisfied
[9] V. Avinash, “Appraisal of Strength of Self Compacting Concrete with
80% 600 5 8 11 8 0.9 Satisfied Variable Size of Steel Fibre”, International Journal of Innovative Research in
Science, Engineering and Technology, Vol. 3, Issue 11, November 2014, ISSN:
5 CONCLUSION 2319-8753.
The SCC mixes having copper slag as fine aggregate and
[10] Zoran, Properties of Self Compacting Concrete Different Types of
containing SF as powder material tested for their fresh proper-
Additives”, Architecture and Civil Engineering, Vol. 6, No 2, 2008, pp. 173 -
ties as per EFNARC. From this it can be concluded that achiev- 177.
ing fresh SCC properties is possible by adopting the Nan Su et
[11] Prashant O. Modani, “Self Compacting Concrete with Recycled Ag-
al. method when these industrial by-products are used.
gregate: A Solution for Sustainable Development”, International Journal of
Civil and Structural Engineering, Volume 4, No 3, 2014, ISSN 0976 – 4399.
IJSER © 2016
http://www.ijser.org
International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research, Volume 7, Issue 4, April-2016 97
ISSN 2229-5518
[16 ]P.S Ambily, C. Umarani, K. Ravisankar, Prabhat Ranjan Prem, B.H.
Bharat Kumar, Nagesh .R. Iyer. “Studies on Ultra High Performance Con-
crete Incorporating Copper Slag as Fine Aggregate”, Construction and
Building Materials,77(2015), pp 233-240.
IJSER
April 2012, ISSN: 2277-3754.
IJSER © 2016
http://www.ijser.org