CHAPTER II
THEORETICAL REVIEW, RELEVANT RESEARCH AND
FRAMEWORK OF THINKING
A. Theoretical Review
1. Theory of Character and Moral Value
a. Definition of Character
Characters are what make stories. Without a character, there is no
story to tell, only a lot of scenery. Many characters in literature, television
series, and movies have a huge impact on people. Some people like to live
their lives through these characters, who appear to have more interesting
lives. Also, these characters may seem so real and inspirational, that
people forget they are fictional.
Characters become so important to the audience, that cities across
the country hold conventions in which people pay a lot of money to dress
and act as their favorite characters from multiple types of shows,
particularly of the comic magazine genre (type of literature).
Characters are the heart and soul of the story, the most important
elements in literature. They are of central importance for the film
experience. Characters are not only people, but also the elements of nature
such as wind, waves, grasses, waves, or even an animal. In fiction a
character may be defined as a verbal representation of a human being.
1
2
Though action, speech, description, and commentary, authors portray
characters that are worth caring about, being empathetic with, and even
loving, although there are also characters you may laugh at, dislike, or
even hate.
The main function of a character in a story is to extend or prolong
the plot, make it readable and interesting. Many stories use multiple
characters, and every story has a main character that affects the plot a great
deal. The main character could be a protagonist, an antagonist, dynamic,
static, flat, or even a round character. Readers feel that the characters given
in the literary pieces exist, and they enjoy reading their real and lifelike
figures and actions.
Character is revealed by how character responds to conflict. Every
story hinges on the actions undertaken by its major character, or
protagonist, a term drawn from ancient Greek tragedy that is more useful
in discussions of fiction than such misleading term as hero or heroine.
Additionally, stories may contain an opposing character, or antagonist,
with whom the protagonist is drawn into conflict. Because of the
importance of character, there are some definitions that are suggested by
some experts.
According to Volger (2007:30), character is a very essential part of
each project. The stories will need strong and intriguing characters, in
order to get through the audience and give them ‘a window to the story’. It
3
means that character should have character’s personality. The personality
mirrored in his behaviors and attitudes and the way he is interacting with
others. The personality would cross someone’s mind first if the person
would have to describe the character of a protagonist.
A set of personalities may be the first thing a writer defines about
his character because it will help him to get a first idea about his
personality. The way he should behave and what distinguishes him from
the other characters in the story. There have to be positive as well as
negative personalities because otherwise the character will most likely feel
very artificial. A combination of both positive and negative personalities
will complexity and credibility to the character and offer interesting
opportunities for conflicts within himself in a way that the character has to
fight against certain aspect of his personality in order succeed.
In line with Volger, Gill (1995: 127), stated that character is
someone in literary work has some short identity which is made up by the
appearance, conversation and possibly thoughts in their head. This
definition can mean that it is essential to evoke empathy, sympathy or
interest for character right from the start and enable audience to connect
with the character. As in the real life, first impressions are not to be
underestimated.
Meanwhile, Card (1990: 98) emphasized that characters, like
people, make good or bad first impression. When characters first show up
4
in the story, we start to like them or dislike them right away. It can be said
that the bad or good impression is showed up by attitude. Attitude is one of
the most effective means to reveal character. It is attitude what
distinguishes them in one and the same situation from one another.
Depending on their attitude they will react different to conflicts, problems,
successes and triumphs. The audience’s sympathy or empathy can be
influenced by the right choice of attitudes. Characters will mostly likely
lose sympathy if they cheat whilst aiming for their goal, if they constantly
whine and complain or blame somebody else for their own mistake. The
best and most obvious way to express attitude in visual media is through
action. We see how a protagonist acts and reacts in certain situations and
get a feeling for common attitudes which distinguish him from other
characters.
The next definition is stated by Stanton (2007: 29). He pointed out
that character affects the plot. If we don’t know the plot of the story, it will
be hard to understand what the story tells us. This definition means that by
following the storyline and understanding the plot, the audience will know
the character from every attitude in each action. Characters guide readers
through their stories, allow them to understand plots and to ponder theme.
Meanwhile, concept of character is also stated by Volger (2007:
31). He emphasized that a character torn by warring allegiances to love
and duty. Some qualities and traits should be in conflict with each other.
For example, a ‘good character’ is in conflict with a ‘bad character’. At the
5
same time a character who has a unique combination of contradictory
impulses, such as trust and suspicion or hope and despair, seems more
realistic and human than one who displays only one character trait. By
letting two opposed characters interact with one another it is much easier
to reveal their characteristics. Along with the invention of some patterns
and habits, tastes and preferences the personal traits of the character will
help to make him appear lifelike and unique at the same time. The
elaboration of the aspects as mentioned is also important for supporting the
ability of the audience to get emotionally with the character.
Indeed many people still get confused about the difference between
character and characterization. Is characterization has similar meaning
with character? Since character and characterization cannot be separated.
A literary device that is used step by step in literature to highlight
and explain the details about a character in a story is called
characterization. It is the act of creating and describing characters in
literature. Characterization is in the initial stage which the writer
introduces the character, giving a description of character’s physical
attributes as well as the character’s personality. Baldick (2001: 7) stated
that characterization is the representation of person in narrative and
dramatic works. This may include direct method like the attribution of
qualities in description or commentary and indirect method, inviting
readers to infer qualities from characters, actions, speeches or appearances.
This definition tells us that there are two kinds of characterization. The
6
first is direct or explicit characterization. This characterization takes a
direct approach towards building the character. It uses another character,
narrator or the protagonist himself to tell the audience about the subject.
The second is indirect or implicit characterization. The audience has to
deduce for themselves the traits of the character by observing his or her
thought process, behavior, speech, act of talking, appearance and manner
of communication with other characters.
Based on the theories and definition above, it can be concluded that
character is the person presented in a dramatic or narrative work, who are
interpreted by the reader as being endowed with moral, dispositional and
emotional qualities that are expressed in what they say in the dialogue and
what they do in action.
b. Definition of Moral
According to Kant (2017: 239), moral is a system of duties, which
fall into two parts, both of which are also systems of duties. Every duty is
either duty of right or a duty of virtue. It means moral therefore consist in
nothing else than the conception of law itself, which certainly is only
possible in a rational being, in so far as this conception, and not the
expected effect, determines the will. This is a good which is already
present in the person who acts accordingly, and we have not to wait for it
to appear first in the result. So that for this there would have been no need
7
of the will of a rational being; whereas it is in this alone that the supreme
and unconditional good can be found by itself which we call moral.
However, pure conception of duty and the moral law generally,
with no admixture of empirical inducements, has an influence on the
human heart so much more powerful than all other incentives which may
be derived from the empirical field that reason, in the consciousness of its
dignity, despises them and gradually becomes master over them without
them realizing by themselves. And morality becomes one of the most
important matters to think about whenever we want to do something to
someone else. Thus, all the process of how morals have a large influence
on the daily life of humans and as the framework of our actions.
Kant (2017: 241), also claimed that morality is different from
physical experience. Moral commands are universal regardless of a
person’s inclinations or physical experience. These universal commands
are a result of individual personal reason, independent of inclination and
individual personal freedom, also independent from inclinations, to choose
to act on the universal commands.
But Allison (2011: 6) stated that morality is to investigate the idea
and principles of a possible pure will, and not the actions and conditions of
human volition in general, which are the most part drawn from
psychology. It has been seen that there is nothing it is possible to think of
anywhere in the world, or indeed anything at all outside it, that can be held
8
to be good without limitation, that human volition can be the apex, un-
except only of a good will or bad will. Understanding with the power of
judgement and like talents of the mind, whatever they might be called, or
courage, resoluteness, persistence in an intention, as qualities of
temperament, are without doubt in some respects good and to be wished
for; but they can also become extremely evil and harmful, and if the will
that is to make use of these gifts of nature, and whose peculiar constitution
is therefore called character, is not good. It is the same with gifts of
fortune. Power, wealth, honor, even health and that entire well-being and
contentment with one’s condition, under the name of happiness, make for
courage and thereby often also for arrogance, where there is not a good
will to correct their influence on the mind, and make them universally
purposive; not to mention that a rational impartial can never take
satisfaction even in the sight of the uninterrupted welfare of a being, if it is
adorned with no trait of a pure and good will; and so the good will appears
to constitute the indispensable condition even of the worthiness to be
happy that is why we need to take a control of what is called moral.
According to Downie (2006: 33) claimed that the first use of
‘moral’ we shall note is that in which it is synonymous with ‘ethic’. It
might also means of the term an ‘ethical judgment’ is the judgment of an
ordinary moral agent about moral right and wrong, or about what someone
morally ought or ought not to do, or about whether or not someone
behaved fairly, or about whether or not someone is a morally good person.
9
In this sense we might say that a certain question is a matter of ethics,
rather than of politics. But if ‘ethic’ and ‘moral’ can be coextensive in their
areas of application there are also, secondly, uses of ‘ethic’ and ‘moral’ in
the first sense. Thus in popular speech the term moral has become
narrowed to matters of sexual behavior, whereas high-minded people who
are aware that there are problems of conduct other than sexual ones have
pre-empted the word ‘ethics’ to refer to them. In terms of this distinction
we find that the politician who tells us lies is deemed ‘unethical’, but now
days in modern era people often separate those correlations between ethics
and moral, people now days prefer to judge people by the moral of
herself/himself not use ethics anymore.
Meanwhile, according to Hare (2009: 11) moral is judgment to say
‘the attitude that it is wrong (or right) to do so and so’. It is mentioned also
in other opinions of Hare, morality as an approval, as opposed to other
sorts of approval. The only safe way of characterizing the attitude which is
expressed by a universal imperative is to state it. It means to maintain an
attitude we need to use of ‘moral approval’ towards a certain practice is to
have a disposition to think, on the appropriate occasions, that it is right; or,
if ‘think’ itself is a dispositional word, it is simply to think that it is right;
and our thinking that it is right may be betrayed or exhibited behaviorists
would say constituted by our acting in certain ways. Above all, doing acts
of the sort in question when the occasion arises; next, saying that they are
10
right; applauding them in other ways, and so on. But there is in this entire
nothing to explain just what one thinks that a certain sort of act is right.
Based on the theories and opinions above, it can be concluded that
morality is concerned with the principles of right and wrong behavior, the
goodness and badness of human character to understand both the
storyteller’s intentions and the underlying moral lesson.
c. Definition of Value
Values are what matter to us. They are what motivate our behavior.
They ground our judgments about what is good or bad, desirable or
undesirable. Any form of activity that involves making judgments about
what is better or worse, good or bad, high quality or low quality, right or
wrong, successful or unsuccessful, desirable or undesirable. All of these
judgments involve values in one form or another.
There are values in sports, values in art, values in social and
cultural practices, values in science, values in relationships, values in
economic transactions, religious values. Our everyday experience is
saturated with values and value judgments.
There are some definitions about value according to some experts.
Venkataiyah and Sandhya (2002: 1) stated that values are the guiding
principle of life which are conducive to all round development, they give
direction and firmness to life and bring joy, satisfaction and peace to life.
This definition makes it clear that values are type of belief that is within
11
the scope of the belief system, in which one must act and avoid an action,
or about something that is inappropriate or inappropriate to be done,
owned or trusted. Appropriate here means something fit, suitable and
applicable. This statement means that value is a kind of guide line in
society, which determines a course of action. The society must follow the
appropriate action and avoid the inappropriate action to be done.
The next definition of value is emphasized by Bertens (2011: 139).
He emphasized that value is something that interest for us, something that
we look for, something that pleases, something that loves, and in short
value is something good connotation. This statement means that value
brings everything in a good sense and can give something pleasure. There
is no negative thing in value. Value is sometimes used as an abstract noun
in a narrower sense which such terms as good, desirable, or worthwhile are
properly applied. In a wider sense to cover, in addition, all kinds of
rightness, obligation, virtue, beauty, truth and holiness. Value is also used
like temperature to cover the whole range of a scale; plus, minus or
indifferent. What is on the plus side is then called positive value and what
is on the minus side is negative value.
Meanwhile Aspim and Chapman (2007: 14) stated that value is
batch of ideas, conventions, principles, rules, objectives, products,
activities, practices, procedures, or judgment that people accept, agree to,
prefer, incline towards, see as important, and indeed act upon. Value refers
to what is valued or judged to have value, thought to be good, or desired.
12
Such phrases are also used to refer to what people think is right or
obligatory, even to whatever they believe to be true. Behind this
widespread usage lies to convert assumption that nothing really has
objective value, that value means being valued and good means being
though good. But the term value is also to mean distinguishes two senses
of value. It can be meant either to prize, like, esteem, cherish, or hold dear.
Or to apprize, estimates, evaluates, or valuate. The terms value and
valuation are used in our contemporary culture, not only in economics and
philosophy but also in other social science and humanities, that value is a
relative worth, utility, or importance, liking or regard for person or thing.
Value may sometime suggest an evaluation made from an individual or
specific point of view or in individual or social situation.
d. Definition of Moral Value
Many people have tried to give the limitation of what moral value
is and they had different opinion about the moral value itself depending of
their point of view. Some people say that moral values are as set of
principles which help us evaluate what is good and bad and it help us in
becoming a good human being. They can come from the self, family,
community, religion, government or any other entity that influence the
thoughts of the individual. These values involve lot of actors like morality,
respecting others, helping others, etc. The standard of the moral value is
different between one community to others. Here are some opinions of
what morality is according to experts.
13
Sheng (2008: 11) emphasized that moral value is a kind of non-
material value, because the object itself has its own moral value, such as
moral action, moral principles and feeling of moral satisfaction, is an
abstract object instead of a physical object. Broadly speaking, human
values can be categories as either material values or spiritual values.
Material values focus totally on things like food, shelter and money. This
definition can be meant that moral value here is spiritual values, which
refer values of trueness, goodness, and beauty arising from intellect
emotion and will.
Hatman (2009: xxi) stated that moral value is first and foremost a
detailed and profound phenomenological description of values, and moral
in particular. It means that moral value is a primary value and if we want
to make description about if we have provide a very specific, detailed,
profound and extraordinary explanation, especially when we want to give
and explain and describe of the moral values. This statement means that
every value will get quality if it has relation with other values. For
example, honesty is an example of moral value, this value has no meaning
if it does not be applied with other values. Loyalty is moral value, but it
must be applied with other values. Humanity, for example, can be found in
the love of husband and wife. When moral value is related with
responsibility, it is related to human personality, but beside moral value we
also automatically can say other values. Moral value makes people wrong
or not only because of his or her responsibility.
14
Moral values which are related with pure heart, have persuasive
power, and it should be practiced. For example, aesthetic value could be
practiced by playing a music composition. After that the result of it, if it is
a painting it needs to be showed, and if it is music, it need to be listened to.
To make moral value a reality, it can be appealed to from a pure heart. One
of the special characteristics of moral values is that this value will effect
voice of pure heart. Moral value should not stand alone without other
value. Although moral value is the main value that we must appreciate, but
it is aligned with other values. Moral values are not separate with other
values. For example, a seller applies moral values all at once with apply
economic values. Moral values are nothing without other values. It is form
of formality.
Another concept of moral value is stated by George and Uyanga
(2014: 41) emphasized that moral values are essential values that
determine individual’s perception of morality and moral consciousness in
society. Moral values can be learned by all people, everyone can get the
moral value from his environment, when they interact with their friends in
society. This is universal values. Universal values include peace, freedom,
social progress, equal rights, human dignity. In fact there are many values
fond in people that can be learnt actually, such as: love and affection,
honesty, responsibility, perseverance, integrity, harmony, patience,
bravery, justice, simplicity, peaceful etc. These moral values are the values
that are related to an individual’s character to confirm what is right and
15
wrong. This individual character can bring the societies to the universal
values.
Based on the theories and definitions above it can be concluded
that moral values are the standards of good and evil, which govern an
individual’s behaviour and choices.
e. Kinds of Moral Value
Kinner et.al (2009: 9) stated that there are some basic moral values.
They are: (1) Commitment to something greater than one self. It means
that as human beings we have to recognize the existence and be commited
to a supreme being, a higher principle and transcendent purpose or
meaning to one’s existence. (2) Self-respect but with humility, self-
discipline, and acceptance of personal responsibility. It explains that every
individual has to care for and respect oneself, to not exit oneself or
overindulge, to act in accordance with one’ conscience or to accept
responsibility for one’s behavior. (3) Respect and caring for others. It
means that we have to recognize the connectedness among all people and
to serve human kinds and to be helpful to individuals. (4) Caring for other
living things and environment. It means that every individual has to care
for other creatures such as animals, plants, and etc. and much concerned
with environment where the individual lives.
According to Kaludevoric, there are four kinds of moral value.
They are: (1) Justice. It is connected to an idea that every athlete has equal
intrinsic value and the same dignity. (2) Honesty. It means that every
16
athlete can be trustworthy and be honest in his or her dealing with others
including competitors during the play. (3) Responsibility. It refers to an
idea that every athlete is responsible for his or her acting. (4) Beneficence.
It is a state of not doing harm, preventing harm, and removing harm.
2. Theory of Film
a. Definition of Literature
Etymologically, the Latin word-literatural is derived from-litera‖
(letter), which is the smallest element of alphabetical writing. Mario Klarer
(2004) stated that it is more enlightening to look at literature or text as
cultural and historical phenomena and to investigate the conditions of their
production and reception. In most cases literature is referred to as the
entirely of written expression. With the restriction that every written
document can be categorized as literature in the more exact sense of the
world. It is a fact that literature is a creation of humankind that has
aesthetics and artistic sides. In the past, the form of literature was usually
conveyed orally, such as epic stories. In further progress, literature was
made in written form and then it was visualized as in drama. Later, epic
stories, written literature and drama are known as genre of literature.
Further, there are three major literary genres; they are fiction that consists
of novel and short story. Drama that consists of comedy and tragedy and
the last is poetry. These three genres literature are applicable until now.
17
Furthermore, Boulton (in Ade and Okuneye, 2008: 2) emphasized
literature from a functional perspective as the imaginative work that gave
the R’s: recreation, recognition, revelation, and redemption. This statement
allows people to take literature as their way to have recreation by enjoying
as much literature as they like. Or they can write literature to have some
kind of recognition. People also allow to reveal as well as to redeem
themselves by writing literature.
Meanwhile, Robson (2001: 1) stated that literature means the entire
written document of a community. This theory says that the entire written
documents which are created, such as novel, short story or poetry is
regarded as literature.
Another definition of literature is stated by Rees (in Ade and
Okuneye 2008: 2). He stated that literature is a permanent expression in
words of some thoughts or feelings and ideas in the form of prose,
poetries, dramas, short stories or novels. This thoughts, feelings, and ideas
are expressed by its author sometimes based on what had happened to his
life, or to his family. This kind of writing is in contrast to newspaper, or
science books, or politic report.
Based on the definitions and theories above it can be concluded
that literature is a social institution which society aspiration expressed by
the author their literary works.
18
b. Definition of Fiction
Fiction is one of the two branches of literature. People in general
enjoy watching film in television or in theatre, read novel or poem. Human
beings need entertainment to refresh their mind from all day work.
Fiction is a general term used to describe an imaginative work of
prose, either a novel, short story or novella being untrue. Fiction is based
on made-up and fabricated stories and characters. It is also can be said that
fiction is a belief or statement that is false, but it is often held to be true
because it is expedient to do so. Fiction is not real. For example, a fiction
film might take place on a made-up planet, big wars among planets and
stars, or it has fantasy elements that don’t exist in the real world, like
happened in the film Star Wars and Avengers. The story narrates various
incredible experiences of the main character. Another good example of
fiction is Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carol. The story narrates various
adventure of the main character Alice, in a fictitious land full of incredible
creatures and events, Alice has go through certain magical experiences in
the wonderland, in the world that has never existed.
These explanations and examples are in line with what Dong Gu
(2006: 46) stated that “fiction as literature genre is a kind of prose
narrative about actions and events that may not necessarily have prior
temporal existence but are nevertheless true to be the low of probability in
life. It is intentionally created not primarily for the transmission of
information but for the sake of entertainment and aesthetic appreciation”.
19
Meanwhile, Mazzeo (2012: 7) emphasized that fiction is a written
work based on the writer’s imagination. It brings the meaning that
everything which is written based on a writer’s imagination, not real, and
cannot be found in the real world can be classified as a fictional work. This
means that fiction refers to literature created from the human imagination.
Mysteries, science fiction, romance, fantasy, chick lit, crime thrillers are
all fiction genres.
From the definition above it can be concluded that fiction is a
made-up and fabricated story based on the human imagination, and it does
not happen in the real world.
c. Definition of Nonfiction
What about nonfiction? What is the difference between fiction and
nonfiction? Some people may define that nonfiction has something to do
with the real life. Nonfiction is the opposite of fiction. When fiction talks
about something unreal, only human imagination, something that we
cannot find in the real daily activities, the nonfiction talks about something
real, happened in the real life. It is not human imagination. The fictional
literature is imagined, fabricated, and not real. Nonfiction refers to
literature based in fact. Nonfiction comprises books and videos in many
categories including biography, business, cooking, health and fitness, craft,
home decorating, language, travel, religion, art, music, and many others. In
short, something real and can be proven in reality. Something that human
beings do in their daily activities. To avoid misunderstanding about fiction
20
and nonfiction, it is better for us to know the definitions of nonfiction
according to some experts.
Perl and Schwarts (2006: 2) stated that nonfiction means
journalism, business writing, academic scholarship and car manuals.
Nonfiction is a kind of work writing that has something to do with the
journalistic works, business letters, academic writing, scientific books,
manuals and many others related to the real world.
Meanwhile Mazzeo stated that nonfiction is writing that is true to
facts and history. This statement means that nonfiction is something
happened in the real daily life. It concerns with news, email, weather
forecast, student report and many others.
Schagen (2009: 3) stated that as all art forms, nonfiction is merely
as representation of reality, and not reality itself. It means that nonfiction
only tries to represent or depict that reality of live not that reality itself.
Nonfiction refers to literature based on fact. It is the broadest category of
literature.
Based on the definition above, it can be concluded that nonfiction
is part of literature that is representation of reality and true to the fact.
d. Definition of Film
Movie/film is one kind of the most popular entertainment media. It
is a mirror, which reflects all the respect of human society, including the
material world and the spiritual world as well. Movie or film is so
important that it has become the first arts of the human world.
21
According to Marcel Danesi (2010) film is a text that contains a
series of photographic images which results in the illusion of motion and
action in real life. A film, also called a movie, is the motion picture that
tells a story, like in television or cinema. It is produced by recording
photographic images with cameras, or by creating images using animation
techniques or visual effects.
Movie offers a special language of projected moving image with
sound a language which incorporates the characteristics of the graphic,
plastic, spatial and narrative arts. It is finally becoming accepted in
educational circles an established art from suitable for study analysis,
research in institution of higher learning. Movie or film study encompasses
the examination of the motion picture as a medium of communication,
entertainment and artistic expression.
Michael Rabiger (2009: 24) also stated that every film is
interesting and entertaining, and makes the audience think. Every existing
work is unique and interesting so that there are many ways that can be
used in a documentary to convey ideas about the real world. Film is
considered to be an important art form a source of popular entertainment
and powerful method for educating or indoctrinating and also a tool of
communication among citizens. The visual elements of cinema give
motion picture a universal power of communication.
Mario Klarer (2010: 38) emphasized that film is predetermined by
literary techniques; conversely, literary practice developed particular
22
features under the impact of film. Many of the dramatic forms in the
twentieth century.
Films are mostly adapted from real story in the world and others
are adapted from books or novels. Most people use movies in
entertainment, critics, advertisement, and education. Films will give us a
message such as moral, motivation, faith, science, etc. In the developing
era for example, moral degradation happened because of the influences of
bad culture like free sex, alcohol, crime, marriage by accident, suicide,
abortion and so on. These matters also can be seen through a film.
Based on the theories above it can be concluded that film is a mass
media entertainment and by its audio-visual power it can give an effect to
the emotion or feeling of the viewer who watch it.
3. Relevant Research
The relevant researches are used to be outwarding and knowledge
for the writer. The first example of relevant research was done by Ely Nur
Rohyani, student of State Institute for Islamic Studies (STAIN) Salatiga.
The research entitle is The analysis of moral values of Danny Boyle’s
movie entitled “Slumdog Millionaire”. The result of her research is that
there are some moral values in this movie. The moral values are: believe in
God, love and belonging, feeling sorry and apologizing, never giving up,
humanity and hard-work. In this thesis the writer used film as her object
research.
23
The similarity of Ely Nur Rohyani’s thesis and this thesis is that
both are concerned with moral values conveyed in the story of the film and
the need to analyze them. The method used in this two thesis is qualitative
method. The aim of both thesis are almost the same, to find out and to
analyze moral values in the film.
The difference of Ely’s thesis and this thesis is that the writer of
this thesis analyzes the characters in the film but Ely’s thesis is not
concerned with the character in the film she analyzed.
The second relevant research is conducted by Faisal from State
Islamic University Syarif Hidayatullah entitled Analysis of Main
Character on Bruce Almighty movie viewed from Personality Traits
Theory by Costa and McCrae. The method he used when he conducted the
research was descriptive qualitative one. The purpose of his research is to
establish the character and characterization of Bruce Nolan as main
character by analyzing the evidence from the dialogues and his actions in
the film. The result of his research is the character, Bruce Nolan, has a
dynamic and round character. He has much bad characterization than
positive ones.
The similarity between this thesis and Faisal’s is that both of these
thesis are try to reveal and much concerned with aspect of character
conveyed and delivered in the film. The method used in both thesis are
also the same. Both of the writer used descriptive qualitative method.
24
The difference of Faisal’s thesis and this thesis is the purpose of his
thesis is to only analyze Bruce Nolan character and characterization while
this thesis aims to analyze some characters in the film. Beside that Faisal’s
thesis doesn’t analyze moral value of character as in this thesis.
The third relevant research is conducted by Ahmad Hadil Amin
from State Islamic Studies Institute, entitled The Analysis of Moral Values
on the “War Horse” Movie. The method he used when he conducted the
research was the qualitative one. The purpose of the research is to find out
the moral values in the film and to find the use of watching movies
towards English teaching. The result of the research is there are moral
values in the film, they are: love and affection, loyalty, peace-loving,
perseverance, bravery, enthusiasm, honesty, kind-hearted, self-confidence
and strong-belief.
The similarity of Ahmad Hadil Amin’s thesis and this thesis is both
of these thesis try to reveal and are much concerned with aspect of moral
values in the story of both of the art work. The method used in the thesis
are also the same, they used descriptive qualitative method. The aim of his
thesis and this thesis is almost the same, to find out and analyze moral
values aspect in both of art work. The writer of this thesis and Hadil’s
thesis used film as their object of the research.
The difference of Ahmad Amin’s thesis and this thesis is that this
thesis presented the analysis of character while Hadil’s thesis doesn’t
present character in his thesis.
25
4. Framework of Thinking
Based on the theories above, the purposes of this research are to find
out the character and moral value in the film entitle “A League of Their
Own” film by Penny Marshall.
1. Characters
Character is a very important part and has a role that cannot be
considered trivial in a literary work such as movies, novels, short stories or
poem. Character is a central concern, the idea, or the artist’s point of view
on the subject matter which often deals with the possibility of change in
human existence and what accounts for that change if it occurs and it is
also the element of film that it structured and gives a film unity. It is
impossible if there is no character in the work of art. It does not matter
whether the literary work is categorized as a good literary work or a bad
one. But in essence, every literary work must have character.
The character found in the film A League of Their Own is a focus
on how the main character tries to be truly shown and conveyed through
the film in accordance with the contents of the film and also associated
with other elements such as setting, theme, plot and so forth.
2. Moral Values
26
Morality is conformity to the moral code of the social group. To
act in a moral way means, thus, to act in conformity to group standards of
conduct.
Value means the worth of the thing. Value in the singular is sometimes
used as an abstract noun. In a narrower sense to cover that to which such
terms as “good” or “worthwhile” are properly applied and in the wider
sense to cover, in addition all kinds of rightness, obligation, virtue, beauty,
truth, and holiness.
Moral value in literature work is usually meant as a suggestion relating
to certain moral teachings of a practical nature, which can be taken (and
interpreted), through the story in question. It is an indication that had been
given by the author about the various things associated with life issues
such as attitude, behavior, and manners in intercommunication.
Moral value is a term in logic that a principle or action or character of
human is true or false, right or wrong and good or bad. Moral values
concern with the view of the goodness or badness of human action and
character. Moral value in literature work can be seen as mandate message.
Even, actually message unsure is constituted as an idea that underlies the
creation of literature work as a supporting message. It based on the
consideration that the moral value which was delivered by fiction has
different effects than by nonfiction.
27
Film is a work of art as well as audio visual media, means of
communication to the audiences which has its own power created by
combining all elements or aspects in it to build a story created within
different social, historical and cultural context.
“A League of Their Own” movie is based on the true story of the All-
American Girls Professional Baseball League, “League” moves briskly
through the introduction of rival sisters Dottie (Geena Davis) and Kit (Lori
Petty) to tryouts for the first-ever women’s professional baseball league. A
League of Their Own is a good movie, with a great cast and a
heartwarming. It is also has strong messages of teamwork and compassion.