0LNw7VQCT4K1I4uVHFSF PAP 054
0LNw7VQCT4K1I4uVHFSF PAP 054
Ecuadorian Case
Fernando Salinas-Herrera, Diego Salinas-Herrera, Geovanny Pardo-Salazar
Department of Electrical and Energy Studies
Agency of Regulation and Control of Electricity
Quito, Ecuador
[email protected]
Abstract— This paper proposes a coordinated strategy for Several control strategies for SVC devices have been
SVC operation in terms of SVC optimal reactive power proposed in the literature such as PI control, Model
reserve, dispatching of uneconomical forced thermal Predictive Control (MPC), Fuzzy Logic, Artificial Neural
generation, and transmission system voltage quality. First, an Networks (ANN), Genetic Algorithms (GA), Fryze-
operation strategy is developed at steady state operation to Buchholz-Dpenbrock (FBD), among others [3]–[11]. The
then find the dynamic response at N-1 contingencies. A integral square error criterion is used to tune PI damping
coordinated strategy is performed by evaluating the impact of controller parameters to increase dynamic stability. MPC in
the SVC operation at not only the controlled bus but the entire turn, can balance the reactive power in the system by
transmission system. This work constitutes a relevant base for
controlling the firing angle to improve transient response.
analysing operation strategies for FACTS devices with an
integral view (that is the impact on the wide area of the power
ANN and GA are proposed to improve the transient stability
system) and not just considering the local effects. The by optimizing the SVC parameters, but they can be difficult
proposed operation strategy is validated on Ecuador realistic to implement in practice.
data with the aim to get the most benefits of such devices in On the other hand, and beyond control strategies, SVC
coordination with other power system apparatus. operation strategies have been also of interest for the
research community. To get the most benefits from the SVC
Keywords— SVC, FACTS, reactive compensation, power
operation in a real-world power system, a comprehensive
flow control, voltage quality, Ecuadorian power system
analysis needs to be carried out not only in terms of control
I. INTRODUCTION strategy but in terms of active power reserve, operation
limitations, system constraints, wide area impact, etc. Zhao
Electrical networks play a fundamental role within et al. in [12] study the operation of the SVC for flicker
power systems. The operation of such complex systems is mitigation of electric arc furnaces. Ceaki et al. in [13]
restricted by physical laws as each network element has analyse the SVC operation impact on power quality for grid-
finite bounds, limiting the amount of energy that can be connected PV plants. In [14], Mansour et al. proposes a
transported and supplied to the end-user. The increasing SVC operation strategy in coordination with under-load tap
demand for electricity and the evolution of the energy changer (ULTC) to compensate the reactive power
markets have led to very saturated power systems which in requirements from the upstream network. Huang et al. in
turn, have pushed network operation closer to stability [15] design a control strategy for the 900 MVA SVC in
limits. The operation of transmission networks is frequently Holeta Substation in Ethiopia, to control the 400 kV
affected by stability problems due to the unpredictable transmission level and to provide dynamic response during
system behaviour. Ideally, the active power transmission and following system contingencies. In [16], Yang et al.
capability of lines should be until thermal limits. However, study the reactive power control on an isolated wind-diesel
voltage and stability limits denote earlier restrictions. In this hybrid power system using SVC sliding mode control. In
regard, voltage and stability limits should be displaced to [17], Palmer et al. present a wide area control of SVCs for
improve the active power transmission. Furthermore, as the first swing and damping control in longitudinal systems.
length of transmission lines increases, the active power Subhra et al. in [18], propose a control strategy for an SVC
transfer is limited even more. Historically, several cost to improve the overall power quality in a distribution
efficient solutions have been preferred over the installation network. However, the most of such analysis have focused
of new transmission lines [1]. mainly on the SVC control strategy rather than on an
In a complex interconnected AC transmission network, integral operation strategy considering the impacts on the
the power flow between generation and load is transferred wider power system.
through multiple paths. With multiples sources and loads, Nonetheless and despite the extensive literature, there is
the power flow analysis should determine the different still a need to analyse SVC operation strategies considering
active and reactive power flow levels in all lines, which in a wider area impact. Moreover, system requirements and the
turn is defined by voltages and impedances at their operation of other system assets, which to our knowledge,
terminals. In this context, there is a need to control power has not been previously considered in the literature. This is
flow through transmission lines in order to improve mainly particularly true in Ecuador since there has been installed a
the transmission capacity and to manage power flows under first SVC device in the power system. This paper aims to
dynamic conditions (load changes, line trips, generation address these gaps by providing a more integral analysis of
outages, etc.) for securing system stability and reliability the SVC operation for maintaining power quality and, in
[2]. coordination with the operation of other system assets such
The Static Var Compensator (SVC) as a member of as thermal generation units.
Flexible AC Transmission System (FACTS) devices can This work is organized in 7 sections. Section 1 presents
dynamically inject inductive or capacitive power into the the introduction. Section 2 briefly reviews the power flow
system to rapidly control voltage fluctuations and to control strategies. Section 3 describes the SVC to be studied.
increase transmission capacity. Section 4 designs the optimization problem, objective
function, and constraints. Section 5 introduces the case
here:
is the voltage at controlled bus,
is the SVC current,
is the SVC total reactance,
is the SVC total susceptance,
Fig. 2. SVC working point coordination. It coordinates the operation of
is the voltage reference. filters, TCR and TSC according to the system needs. TCR and TSC
coordinates when SVC’s output is less than 60 MVAr, TCR and FC are
on and TSC is off.
The Chorrillos SVC was designed following the IV. OPTIMIZATION PROBLEM
Standards IEEE 1031, IEC 60871 and IEC 61000-3-6. It A. Forced Thermal Generation at Guayaquil Side
operates at a voltage level of 30 kV and is connected to the
230 kV network through a coupling transformer. The rated In order to maximise the utilization of renewable energy
capacity goes from -30 MVAr (inductive) to +120 MVAr at high hydrology scenarios in Ecuador, without affecting
(capacitive) [25]. power quality, forced thermal generation (FTG) is required
at Guayaquil area. Guayaquil represents a heavy load region
The nominal and in-site measured parameters of the of the power system and is relatively far from the major
Chorrillos SVC, and the working point coordination, are hydro-generation units. In this regard, due to voltage quality
shown in TABLE I and Fig. 2, respectively. By design, requirements in this area, two thermal units need to be
when the TSC and FC are enabled, and the TCR is dispatched: Trinitaria supplying 65 MW, and Gonzalo
disconnected, the voltage increases to 32.88 kV, and the Zevallos supplying 50 MW [27].
compensation reaches 135.6 MVAr. Likewise, when the
TSC is disconnected, the FC are enabled, and the TCR is As Chorrillos SVC is located at Guayaquil area, its
supplying maximum power, the voltage drops to 29.28 kV, operation may relief some forced thermal generation turning
and the total compensation is -41.2 MVAr [25]. the power dispatch more economic.
0.900
Scenario 3: SVC (free voltage control) without FTG Severino_138 EAR1_Esclusas_230
Scenario 4: FTG and SVC (free voltage control) 0.850
Scenario 5: FTG and SVC (slow susceptance regulation, Santa_Elena_138 0.800 Electroquil_138
10 MW at dead-band)
Scenario 6: SVC (slow susceptance regulation, 10 MW San_Gregorio_230 Esclusas_230
TABLE II
In Scenario 6, 16 buses present low voltages.
Characteristics of the Ecuadorian power system for this analysis. At this point, we draw some conclusions:
Voltage (kV) 500 230 138 69 46 23 13.8 Other
Bus number 12 77 149 137 35 30 186 70 From Scenario 3, it is clear that the SVC itself, operating
Substations number 5 31 54 49 2 2 at maximum capacity, cannot solve all voltage problems at
number 4 16 5
Fixed capacitors
MVAr 177 198 39
Guayaquil area.
number 7
Fixed reactors Additionally, from Scenario 6, it is seen that although
MVAr 360
Lines number 279 the SVC (operating at slow susceptance regulation) can
Km 8795 maintain the voltage at Chorrillos_230 bus within the limits,
Trafo (2-windings) number 198 this is not enough for the rest of buses.
Trafo (3-windings) number 96
number 185 Finally, from Scenario 4, it is observed that operating at
Loads MW 3785
free voltage control, the SVC contributes to lower voltages
MVAr 820
Synchronous at buses Chone_138 and Severino_138, due to its injection
number 104
machines of inductive reactive power to maintain voltage at 1 per unit
Installed capacity MW 5568 at Chorrillos_230 bus.
Spinning reserve MW 1661
Taking these results into account, FTG is reduced to the
operation of Trinitaria central due to its lower operation
costs [27] (compared to Gonzalo Zevallos), supplying 65 operation, the proposed SVC and FTG operation strategy is
MW. At this stage, we apply the proposed optimization not determinant for stabilizing the power system. Further
algorithm (Fig. 4). It provides the SVC and FTG optimal work is needed to improve system stability when N-1
operation condition which consists of the SVC operating at contingency scenarios.
slow susceptance regulation, supplying 70 MVAr
(capacitive) within dead-band and Trinitaria central
supplying maximum capacity. The results are presented in
Scenario 7 in TABLE III and Fig. 5.
B. Contingency Operation
Once the optimal operation at steady state is obtained,
we perform a N-1 contingency analysis to find the system
dynamic response and to exploit the SVC fast response
when disturbances. The N-1 cases are adopted from the
analysis done in [27] as follows: Fig. 6. Impacts of C-1 in SVC and controlled bus. SVC reactive power
injection swings from about 69.60 MVAr to 79.40 MVAr until Chorrillos
C-1: Transmission line Chorrillos – Pascuales 230 kV (2 voltage totally stabilizes after 9 seconds.
of 4 circuits are tripped),
C-2: Transmission line El Inga – Tisaleo 500 kV (1 of 1
circuit is tripped),
C-3: Transmission line Tisaleo – Chorrillos 500 kV (1
of 1 circuit is tripped),
C-4: Transmission line El Inga – San Rafael 500 kV (1
of 2 circuits is tripped).
Trip time is set at 5 seconds. The SVC response time is
set at 100 milliseconds. Contingencies are first simulated for
Scenario 7 (optimal operation) and voltage profiles are
verified. If voltages are out of limits, full FTG is Fig. 7. Impacts of C-1 in voltages profiles. All voltages are within 0.95
implemented at Scenario 7. and 1.017 per unit. No overshoots greater than 20%. There are no voltage
limit violations.
In C-1, no major impacts are evidenced. Bus voltages
are within limits without dispatching full FTG. Fig. 6 shows
the impact of C-1 in the SVC reactive power injection and
controlled bus voltage, and Fig. 7 shows the voltage
profiles. In addition, the results show that the SVC response
time is less than 40 ms and the maximum overshoot is less
than 1% which meet the SVC control requirements.
In C-2, C-3, and C-4, despite Scenario 7 can maintain
the voltage at Chorrillos_230 bus within the limits, not all
the buses satisfy this condition, even after dispatching full
FTG. For instance, Fig. 9 and Fig. 10 show the impact of Fig. 8. Impacts of C-4 in SVC and controlled bus with full FTG. Overshoot
C-4 when full FTG is dispatched. is less than 2% and response time less than 40 ms.
This study was supported by the Agency of Regulation [19] P. Kundur, N. J. Balu, and M. G. Lauby, Power system stability and
and Control of Electricity (ARCONEL). control, vol. 7. McGraw-hill New York, 1994.
[20] R. M. Mathur and R. K. Varma, Thyristor-based FACTS controllers
REFERENCES for electrical transmission systems. John Wiley & Sons, 2002.
[1] X.-P. Zhang, C. Rehtanz, and B. Pal, Flexible AC transmission
[21] H. Bevrani, G. Ledwich, and J. J. Ford, “On the use of df/dt in power
systems: modelling and control. Springer Science & Business
system emergency control,” in Power Systems Conference and
Media, 2006.
Exposition, 2009. PSCE’09. IEEE/PES, 2009, pp. 1–6.
[2] K. R. Padiyar, “FACTS controllers in power transmission and
[22] N. G. Hingorani, L. Gyugyi, and M. El-Hawary, Understanding
distribution,” 2007.
FACTS: concepts and technology of flexible AC transmission
[3] R. C. Bansal, “Automatic reactive-power control of isolated wind– systems, vol. 1. Wiley Online Library, 2000.
diesel hybrid power systems,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 53,
[23] A. Sode-Yome, N. Mithulananthan, and K. Y. Lee, “A
no. 4, pp. 1116–1126, 2006.
comprehensive comparison of FACTS devices for enhancing static
[4] R. C. Bansal, T. S. Bhatti, and D. R. Kothari, “A novel mathematical voltage stability,” in Power Engineering Society General Meeting,
modelling of induction generator for reactive power control of 2007. IEEE, 2007, pp. 1–8.
isolated hybrid power systems,” Int. J. Model. Simul., vol. 24, no. 1,
[24] MEER, “Plan Maestro de Electricidad 2016 - 2025,” Quito, 2017.
pp. 1–7, 2004.
[5] A. M. Kassem and A. Y. Abdelaziz, “Reactive power control for [25] Y. Hai and Z. Zhengxuan, “Basic Design Report For Ecuador
Chorrillos SVC Project,” Rongxin Power Electronic Co.,Ltd., 2015.
voltage stability of standalone hybrid wind–diesel power system
based on functional model predictive control,” IET Renew. Power [26] Y. Hai and W. Shaobo, “Ecuador Chorrillos SVC Project Control
Gener., vol. 8, no. 8, pp. 887–899, 2014. Strategy Study Report,” Rongxin Power Electronic Co.,Ltd., 2015.
[6] A. Banerjee, V. Mukherjee, and S. P. Ghoshal, “Intelligent fuzzy- [27] CENACE, “Plan Bianual de Operación del Sistema Nacional
based reactive power compensation of an isolated hybrid power Interconectado Enero 2018 - Diciembre 2019,” Quito, 2017.
system,” Int. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst., vol. 57, pp. 164–177,
2014. [28] W. Shaobo and Y. Hai, “Ecuador Reactive Power Compensation
Project Simulation Study Report,” Rongxin Power Electronic Co.,
[7] A. Banerjee, V. Mukherjee, and S. P. Ghoshal, “Modeling and Ltd., 2015.
seeker optimization based simulation for intelligent reactive power
control of an isolated hybrid power system,” Swarm Evol. Comput.,
vol. 13, pp. 85–100, 2013.
[8] R. C. Bansal, “Modelling and automatic reactive power control of
isolated wind-diesel hybrid power systems using ANN,” Energy
Convers. Manag., vol. 49, no. 2, pp. 357–364, 2008.
[9] S. Vachirasricirikul, I. Ngamroo, and S. Kaitwanidvilai,
“Coordinated SVC and AVR for robust voltage control in a hybrid
wind-diesel system,” Energy Convers. Manag., vol. 51, no. 12, pp.
2383–2393, 2010.
[10] M. Gong, F. Cai, P. Chen, M. Li, and R. Zheng, “SVC control
strategy based on FBD and LMS algorithm,” in 2017 Chinese
Automation Congress (CAC), 2017, pp. 3450–3454.
[11] L.-F. Li, K.-P. Liu, and L. Ma, “Intelligent control strategy of SVC,”
in 2005 IEEE/PES Transmission & Distribution Conference &
Exposition: Asia and Pacific, 2005, pp. 1–4.
[12] Z. Zhao, C. Chen, X. Wang, and S. Bao, “Operation test and
industrial application of SVC for mitigation flicker from electric arc
furnaces,” in 2008 China International Conference on Electricity
Distribution, 2008, pp. 1–3.
[13] O. Ceaki, R. Vatu, N. Golovanov, R. Porumb, and G. Seritan,
“Analysis of SVC influence on the power quality for grid-connected
PV plants,” in 2014 International Symposium on Fundamentals of
Electrical Engineering (ISFEE), 2014, pp. 1–5.
[14] M. H. Abdel-Rahman, F. M. H. Youssef, and A. A. Saber, “New
static var compensator control strategy and coordination with under-
load tap changer,” IEEE Trans. power Deliv., vol. 21, no. 3, pp.
1630–1635, 2006.
[15] X. Huang, L. Zhang, Y. Ding, and X. Li, “The design of control and
protection system of 900 MVAr SVC in Holeta substation in
Ethiopia,” in 2016 IEEE PES PowerAfrica, 2016, pp. 223–227.
[16] Y. Mi, C. Ma, S. Wang, C. Bi, Y. Zhu, and H. Zhang, “Reactive
power control of an isolated wind-diesel hybrid power system based
on SVC by using sliding mode control,” in 2016 35th Chinese
Control Conference (CCC), 2016, pp. 9882–9887.
[17] E. Palmer, A. Vahidnia, and G. Ledwich, “Wide area control of
SVCs for first swing stabilisation and damping in longitudinal
systems,” in 2014 Australasian Universities Power Engineering
Conference (AUPEC), 2014, pp. 1–5.
[18] S. De and S. Debnath, “Optimal switching strategy of an SVC to
improve the power quality in a distribution network,” IET Sci. Meas.