VAC – Constitutional Values and Fundamental Duties
Secularism in India: Challenges and Opportunities
- Introduction
Secularism is a fundamental principle of modern democracies, ensuring the
separation of religion from the state and guaranteeing equal treatment to
all citizens, regardless of their religious beliefs. In India, secularism is
enshrined in the Constitution and is a cornerstone of the country’s
democratic framework. This assignment explores the concept of secularism
in India, its significance, and the challenges it faces.
- What is Secularism?
Secularism is often understood as the separation of church and state.
However, the Indian concept of secularism is more nuanced, emphasizing
the coexistence and equal respect for all religions. This approach is centered
around the concept of ‘tolerance’ and recognizes the diversity of Indian
society . Through this ,it seeks to promote harmony and understanding
among different religious communities.
The Western concept of secularism, on the other hand, is based on the idea
of separating the church from the state. For example the laïcite policy in
France which focuses on essentially keeping religious practices strictly
private and not allowing religious influence in government or public life. This
approach is rooted in the Enlightenment values of reason, individualism, and
democracy.
In contrast, the Indian concept of secularism is more nuanced and integral
to the values of the nation. It mainly focuses on tolerance as it's principle
giving equal space to every religion to thrive and enrich the fabric of Unity in
Diversity.
- Value of Secularism in the Indian Constitution
Secularism is a part of the basic structure doctrine of the Indian
Constitution(upheld by the Supreme Court in Keshavananda Bharti Case)
which means that it cannot be amended or altered by Parliament. The
Constitution guarantees freedom of religion, equality before the law, and
protection from discrimination on the grounds of religion. These provisions
ensure that all citizens, regardless of their religious beliefs, are treated
equally and have the same opportunities.
The importance of Secularism can be caused from the fact that it promotes
national integration by recognizing the diversity of Indian society and
promoting harmony and understanding among different religious
communities.
- Preserving the Spirit of ‘Sarva Dharma Sama Bhava’
The concept of ‘Sarva Dharma Sama Bhava’ (equal respect for all religions) is
deeply ingrained in Indian culture. To preserve this spirit, it is essential to
promote mutual respect and understanding among different religious
communities. ( What I believe is that mutual respect can only be ensured by
2
the very value of fraternity which in turn incomplete without acknowledging
Equality and Liberty as principles of our daily lives) .Education, media, and
civil society indeed play a crucial role in promoting secular values and
fostering a culture of tolerance and acceptance.(Though that’s another thing
that today’s media is completely going in another direction)
- Challenges to Indian Secularism
“Only Struggles and Challenges which are inevitable, can compel any
concept to prove it timeless relevance “
Indian secularism faces numerous challenges, including threats from
fundamentalism and extremism. The rise of Hindu nationalism and Islamic
fundamentalism has posed a significant challenge to Indian secularism.
“The Moment any Religious person get intoxicated with extremism, thst
person is no longer religious “
These ideologies seek to promote a narrow and exclusivist interpretation of
religion, which undermines the principles of secularism.
The impact of partition on Indian secularism has also been significant. The
partition of India and Pakistan in 1947 ( which was obviously the result of
two-nation theory) led to one of the largest mass migrations in history,
resulting in widespread violence and communal riots. This traumatic event
has had a lasting impact on Indian secularism, with many Indians continuing
to harbor communal prejudices and biases.
- Case Studies: Partition and its Aftermath
The partition of India and Pakistan is a stark reminder of the challenges
faced by Indian secularism. The violence and communal riots that
accompanied partition resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of
people and the displacement of millions.
3
Despite this traumatic event, India has made significant progress in
promoting secular values and fostering a culture of tolerance and
acceptance. The Indian Constitution, which was adopted in 1950, enshrines
the principles of secularism and guarantees freedom of religion, equality
before the law, and protection from discrimination on the grounds of
religion.
- Conclusion
In conclusion, secularism is a cornerstone of Indian democracy, and its
preservation is essential for maintaining the unity and integrity of the
nation. By promoting mutual respect and understanding among different
religious communities and addressing the challenges posed by
fundamentalism, communalism, and extremism, India can continue to thrive
as a secular and democratic nation.
4
Uniform Civil Code : In context of Secular and Progressive India
“I measure the progress of a community by the degree of progress which
women have achieved,”
- Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
Uniform Civil Code which has been legally mentioned in the DPSPs as Article
44 , supported by the vision of the framers of our Constitution is still a
contentious topic or issues not because of the procedure it entails but the
failure of the government to convey its message appropriately.
Introduction
Uniform Civil Code, in simple terms , talks about having a uniformity across
the country in terms of laws and rules. It’s in context of doing away with the
discriminatory and derogatory practices in every personal laws of religions
especially against the women. Hence it got so much support from the
feminists also.
It's not the first time that we are bringing uniformity. The first and foremost
example standing as a testament is Our Indian constitution which itself
emphasizes upon Rule of Law i.e. Rule is above all , everyone is equal and
bound to abide by the rules equally. Another examples of Uniform codes are
Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (erstwhile Indian Penal Code) ,
5
6
