Advisory Circular 91 28 Crew Safety During Turbulence
Advisory Circular 91 28 Crew Safety During Turbulence
AC 91-28 v1.1
Advisory circulars are intended to provide advice and guidance to illustrate a means, but not necessarily the only
means, of complying with the Regulations, or to explain certain regulatory requirements by providing informative,
interpretative and explanatory material.
Advisory circulars should always be read in conjunction with the relevant regulations.
Audience
This advisory circular (AC) applies to:
• aircraft operators
• crew members.
Purpose
This AC provides guidance to operators and their crew members regarding regulation 91.535 of
the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (CASR). The purpose of the AC is to assist with
establishing procedures regarding turbulence management as it relates to crew coordination and
communication, as well as the performance of safety and service-related duties by crew during
turbulence or when turbulence is expected.
Status
This version of the AC is approved by the Branch Manager, Flight Standards.
Note: Changes made in the current version are annotated with change bars.
Unless specified otherwise, all subregulations, regulations, Divisions, Subparts and Parts
referenced in this AC are references to the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (CASR).
Contents
1 Reference material 3
1.1 Acronyms 3
1.2 Definitions 3
1.3 References 5
2 Introduction 7
2.1 Safety during turbulence 7
3 Categorising turbulence 8
3.1 Turbulence types 8
3.2 Turbulence intensity 8
4 Turbulence threat and error management 10
5 Education and training 11
5.1 General 11
5.2 Crew coordination and communication 11
5.3 Crew are not invincible 12
5.4 Recognition of denial reflex 12
5.5 Increasing crew and passenger safety 12
6 Turbulence prevention and management procedures 13
6.1 General 13
6.2 Crew coordination and communication 13
6.3 Crew safety and service-related duties 14
6.4 Managing the descent phase 15
6.5 Passenger safety and promoting voluntary seatbelt use and compliance 15
7 Monitoring and improvement 17
7.1 Reporting 17
7.2 Safety management system (SMS) 17
1 Reference material
1.1 Acronyms
The acronyms and abbreviations used in this AC are listed in the table below.
Acronym Description
AC Advisory Circular
ATSB Australian Transport Safety Bureau
1.2 Definitions
Terms that have specific meaning within this AC are defined in the table below. Where
definitions from the civil aviation legislation have been reproduced for ease of reference, these
are identified by 'grey shading'. Should there be a discrepancy between a definition given in this
AC and the civil aviation legislation, the definition in the legislation prevails.
Term Definition
cabin crew member A crew member who performs, in the interests of the safety of an aircraft’s
passengers, duties assigned by the operator or the pilot-in-command of the
aircraft but is not a flight crew member
Crew member A person is a crew member of an aircraft if the person is carried on the
aircraft and is:
(a) a person:
(i) who is authorised by the operator of the aircraft to carry out a
specified function during flight time relating to the operation,
maintenance, use or safety of the aircraft, the safety of the aircraft’s
passengers or the care or security of any cargo which may affect
the safety of the aircraft or its occupants; and
(ii) who has been trained to carry out that function;
or
(b) a person who is on board the aircraft for the purpose of:
(i) giving or receiving instruction in a function mentioned in
subparagraph (a)(i); or
(ii) being tested for a qualification associated with a function mentioned
in subparagraph (a)(i); or (c) a person authorised by CASA under
these Regulations, or by the operator, to carry out an audit, check,
Term Definition
crew station For a crew member of an aircraft, means a position on the aircraft that is
designed and equipped to enable the crew member to carry out the crew
member’s assigned duties on the aircraft.
critical phases of flight The period of high workload on the flight deck; normally the periods between
the beginning of taxiing until the aircraft is on the route climb phase, and
between the final part of descent to aircraft parking.
exposition (a) for an Australian air transport operator, means:
(i) the set of documents approved by CASA under regulation
119.075 in relation to the operator, and
(ii) if the set of documents is changed under regulation 119.085,
119.095 or 119.105, or in accordance with the process mentioned
in regulation 119.100—the set of documents as changed, or
(b) for an ASAO, means:
(i) the set of documents approved by CASA under regulation
149.080 in relation to the ASAO, or
(ii) if the set of documents is changed under regulation 149.115 or
149.120, or in accordance with the process mentioned in
paragraph 149.340(i)—the set of documents as changed.
operator of an aircraft, means:
(a) if the operation of the aircraft is authorised by an AOC, a Part 141
certificate or an aerial work certificate—the holder of the AOC or
certificate; or
(b) otherwise—the person, organisation or enterprise engaged in aircraft
operations involving the aircraft.
shoulder harness Any device that is used to restrain the upper torso of a person and consists of
a single diagonal upper torso strap or dual upper torso straps.
threat and error The process of detecting and responding to threats and errors to ensure that
management the ensuing outcome is inconsequential, i.e. the outcome is not an error,
further error or undesired state.
1.3 References
Legislation
Legislation is available on the Federal Register of Legislation website https://www.legislation.gov.au/
Document Title
91.535 of CASR Crew safety during turbulence
Document Title
ICAO Doc 10086 Cabin Crew Safety Training Manual (second edition)
Advisory material
CASA's advisory materials are available at https://www.casa.gov.au/publications-and-resources/guidance-materials
Document Title
Other
Document Title
ATSB Aviation Safety Staying Safe Against Inflight Turbulence, 30 June 2008
Bulletin AR-2008-034
ATSB Educational Fact Staying Safe Against Inflight Turbulence, 2nd edition, March 2014
Sheet AR-2008-034
ATSB Transport Safety NW of Noumea La Tontouta International Airport, New Turbulence event
Report AO-2013-181 involving a Boeing 777-3ZGER, VH-VPE, 472km Caledonia, 23 September
2013
TC Advisory Circular Use of safety belts and shoulder harnesses on board aircraft, Issue No. 2, 28
AC No. 605-004 November 2014
TSB Aviation Severe Turbulence Encounter, Air Canada Boeing 777-333ER, C-FRAM
Investigation Report Anchorage, Alaska, 85 nm ENE, 30 December 2015
A15F0165
TSB Aviation Loss of control ExpressJet Airlines Embraer EMB-145LR, N16954 London,
Investigation Report Ontario, 53 NM W, 5 September 2014
Document Title
A14O0165
2 Introduction
3 Categorising turbulence
Occupants feel definite strain against seatbelts; unsecured objects are dislodged; and
cabin service and walking are difficult.
3.2.5 Severe - Large, abrupt changes in aircraft altitude and/or attitude. Usually causes large
variations in indicated airspeed. Aircraft may be momentarily out of control. Occupants
are forced violently against seatbelts; unsecured objects are tossed about; and cabin
service and walking are impossible.
3.2.6 Extreme - Aircraft is violently tossed about and is practically impossible to control. May
cause structural damage.
5.1 General
5.1.1 Crew safety during turbulence2 can be enhanced by providing comprehensive training
in turbulence prevention and management.
5.1.2 Effective training will incorporate a variety of methods, such as simulated scenarios,
lessons learned from investigative bodies, and interviews with crew members who have
experienced turbulence events, to highlight the potential adverse consequences.
5.1.3 It is recommended that the information contained in sections 5.2 to 5.5 of this chapter
be highlighted in the education and training crew receive.
2 Regulation 91.535.
3 Refer to chapter 3.2 of this AC.
− actions the pilot-in-command (PIC) wants other crew members to undertake any
time turbulence is expected
− methodology for communicating to the cabin the onset or worsening of turbulence
e.g. cabin interphone or PA system
− phraseology for other crew members to communicate the severity of turbulence
− commitment to using standard operating procedures and phraseology during a
turbulence encounter.
5.2.7 If flight into forecast turbulence is unavoidable, prompt notification to other crew
members is crucial to their safety.
6.1 General
6.1.1 The following considerations are relevant when developing procedures for the
management of turbulence to ensure crew safety4:
− the definition of turbulence types and intensity
− anticipated and unanticipated turbulence
− crew communication and coordination
− stages of flight e.g. take-off, cruise, descent and final approach
− turbulence duration and conditions inside the aircraft
− PED use during turbulence
− management of assistance animals during turbulence
− post turbulence management
− human factors and prevention strategies
− managing complacency
− turbulence reporting.
4 Regulation 91.535.
− If at any time the crew experience uncomfortable turbulence without notice from the
flight crew, they immediately take their seats and inform the flight crew.
− Crew advise the flight crew of turbulence being encountered in the cabin. This may
be particularly significant on large aircraft types.
− The flight crew proactively communicate turbulence advisories to the crew and
passengers using the interphone, PA system and seatbelt signs.
Note: Reliance solely on the seatbelt sign is not appropriate.
− Flight crew utilise a positive signal for when crew may commence their duties after
take-off, and when they should be seated and secured prior to landing.
− If the seatbelt sign needs to be illuminated prior to the descent and landing phases
(e.g. during light turbulence) and if it is still safe and acceptable to perform duties,
crew members are given clear instructions when the descent phase will commence.
5 Regulation 91.555.
− When the seatbelt sign is extinguished during flight as part of normal operations or
when the threat of turbulence has expired, an announcement is made by flight crew
or the senior cabin crew member explaining the hazards associated with turbulence
and that keeping their seatbelts fastened will help prevent injuries from
unanticipated turbulence.
− Encouraging the use of an approved child restraint system (CRS) that is
appropriate for the occupant’s size and weight to secure an infant or small child and
ensuring the infant/child is secured in the CRS any time the seatbelt sign is
illuminated.
− Advising passengers responsible for an infant/child using a CRS that they should
ensure that the infant/child is properly secured in their CRS, and then ensuring that
his or her own seatbelt is properly fastened.
− Advising passengers what they should and should not do if the seatbelt sign is
illuminated e.g. not to get out of their seat to open overhead lockers when the
seatbelt sign is illuminated, to remain seated and ensure their seatbelt is fastened.
− Use of visual aids, such as briefing cards and/or pointing to seatbelt signs, in
addition to verbal announcements, when relaying information to special needs
passengers about actions that need to be taken when managing turbulence events.
− For flights where it is expected that passengers will sleep, instructing passengers to
fasten their seatbelt over blankets to assist crew in verifying that a sleeping
passenger is secure if turbulence is encountered during the flight.
6.5.4 Practices that may assist with improving passenger compliance with seating and
seatbelt instructions from crew members include:
− Safety demonstrations, briefings and reminders illustrating the benefits of using
effective turbulence practices.
− Educating passengers that the illumination of the seatbelt sign is not routine and is
a warning function.
− Implementing verbal and written advice to passengers that CASA regulations
require them as individuals to comply with crew member instructions regarding the
seatbelt sign.
− Articles in airline publications and/or information on safety information cards
encouraging passengers to engage in effective practices, such as keeping
seatbelts fastened at all times.
− Prior to descent or early into descent, depending on conditions, flight or other crew
members announcing to passengers that the seatbelt sign will be illuminated in 10-
15 minutes and that any personal needs requiring movement in the cabin should be
met before that time. This practice underscores the requirement to comply with the
seatbelt sign.
7.1 Reporting
7.1.1 Incident reports provide operators with an opportunity to more accurately predict areas
that encounter turbulence which can then be conveyed to crew, personnel responsible
for developing crew procedures, and passengers.
7.1.2 It is recommended that incidents of moderate and severe turbulence are reported by
crew so that post-incident investigations can be conducted, and continuous safety
improvements realised. Incidents relating to light turbulence can also be useful in
identifying routes that are more likely to encounter turbulence.